Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Religious language
Astronomy vs Astrology
Rationality:
Scientific:
Non-scientific:
I see a cake.
Rationality:
Scientific:
Non-scientific:
Might is right .
I am strong.
I am right.
Wittgenstein on language
games:
Meaning through usage
Action
Particularised to a given context
Fuzzy relations between games
Applies to all uses of language
Wittgenstein on language
games:
Wittgenstein on religious
language:
Take two people, one of whom talks of his behaviour
and of what happens to him in terms of retribution,
the other one does not. These people think entirely
differently. Yet, so far, you cant say they believe
different things you can call it believing the
opposite, but it is entirely different from what we
would normally call believing the opposite.
I think differently, in a different way. I say different
things to myself. I have different pictures.
(Wittgenstein, 1966, p. 58)
Different games?
Astrology
Terrestrial
causation
Different games?
Theocentric
Hubristic
Terrestrial
causation
A case study:
II Kings 6:
The attendant of the man of God got up early to go
outside,
there
surrounding
the city
was
the army,
and
Woe, my lord! What can we do?. He replied, Do not
with
fear:
the multitude
that is
with us
exceeds
all those
them.
So Elisha
Yahweh,
saying,
Yahweh,
prayed
to
the mountains were full of horses, and chariots of fire
And
toward
surrounded
Elisha.
as they
came down
him,
Elisha prayed
to Yahweh,
saying, Strike
this people
with
Religious/scientific parallelism:
Veldhuiss model:
IV.13
7
IV.13
8
V.55
(Talon, 2005)
(Foster, 1997)
Religious/scientific parallelism:
Diviners Manual:
39
40
a-he-en-na-a ul BAR.ME AN U
KI it-hu-zu
(Oppenheim, 1974)
Ritual healing:
10
Parallel systems:
Theocentric
Hubristic
Terrestrial
causation
Parallel systems:
Pseudoscienc
Theocentric
e
Hubristic
Terrestrial
causation
Beyond omens?
Religious prognoses: