Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Contracts
CONTENTS
Basic hedging practices with Forwards
Futures contracts specifications & details,
terminology
Differences: Forwards vs. Futures
Pricing principles for forwards & futures for
various types of assets
Arbitrage opportunities
Hedging with futures contracts Optimal
hedge ratio
Stock futures & Stock index futures
Arbitrage with stock futures
2
Example 1
Two parties enter into a forward contract
on an agricultural commodity. The forward
price is Rs. 101.51 per unit and maturity
period is 3 months. What are the payoffs
for the long hedge & short hedge aspects
of the transaction? Assume that the
transaction is cash settled. Calculate the
total proceeds with break-up for the long
hedger & short hedger, if the spot price at
maturity ranges from Rs. 97 to 106.
(Source: Adapted from N.R. Parasuraman,
Fundamentals of Financial derivatives)
6
Gain (Loss) in
Forwards = Spot
price after 3 months
Forward price
97
(4.51)
101.51
98
(3.51)
101.51
99
(2.51)
101.51
100
(1.51)
101.51
101
(0.51)
101.51
102
0.49
101.51
103
1.49
101.51
104
2.49
101.51
105
3.49
101.51
106
4.49
101.51
7
Gain (Loss) in
Forwards = Forward
price Spot price
after 3 months
95
6.51
101.51
96
5.51
101.51
97
4.51
101.51
98
3.51
101.51
99
2.51
101.51
100
1.51
101.51
101
0.51
101.51
102
(0.49)
101.51
103
(1.49)
101.51
104
(2.49)
101.51
105
(3.49)
101.51
106
(4.49)
101.51 8
Example 1: Conclusion
Total proceeds is the total cost incurred
by the long hedger or the total
revenues earned by the short hedger
At each price level total proceeds for
the long & short hedger are of equal
monetary amount
For long hedger it is an outflow while
for short hedger it is an inflow
Total proceeds will always be equal to
the forward price
9
Profit
Price of Underlying
at Maturity, ST
10
(K=
Profit
Price of
Underlying
at Maturity,
ST
11
(K=
Futures Contracts
Futures contract is a standardised forward
contract
It is standardised in terms of asset type,
quantity, quality, delivery, time period
A forward contract is OTC in nature; hence there
is NO performance guarantee default risk
A futures contract is traded in an exchange;
hence guaranteed by it
The exchange ensures this by a practice of
margins & levies marking-to-market & daily
settlement
Settlement is mostly done by closing out & not
13
by physical delivery
32
33
34
Collaterisation
A practice followed in OTC segment
of forwards to reduce credit risk
Similar in nature to the marking-tomarket & margining system
followed in futures market
Interest is paid on the outstanding
cash balances of the parties
involved
39
1. No Income Asset
Basic Model:
Forward Price = Spot Price + Cost of
Carry
F =
S
+
C
C is the cost of carrying the asset in
stock for future delivery
Generally C includes: cost of
financing the purchase & storage
cost of asset
44
1. No Income Asset
Forward Price = Spot Price + Cost of
Carry
F =
S
+
C
As long as forward price is as per this
equation an investor will be
indifferent between buying the asset
spot or forward (or selling the asset
spot or forward)
Note: Because borrowing & lending
45
1. No Income Asset
If forward price differs from the
above equation there will be
arbitrage 2 cases:
A. F > S + C : It is cheaper in spot
market & dearer in forward
market
B. F < S + C : It is cheaper in
forward market & dearer in spot
market
46
1. No Income Asset
Arbitrage Strategy: Case A: F > S
+C
Buy Spot & Sell Forward Borrow
an amount equal to S at risk-free
rate for a period equal to
maturity of forward, use S to buy
asset spot, sell asset forward at
F, service the debt at maturity
using proceeds of forward sale
47
1. No Income Asset
Arbitrage Strategy: Case B: F < S
+C
(Short) Sell Spot & Buy Forward
Short Sell asset spot at S, Invest
proceeds of spot sale (S) at riskfree rate for a period equal to
maturity of forward contract, Buy
asset forward at F, at maturity
Close out short position by
48
1. No Income Asset
Arbitrage can be precluded when
there is no arbitrage profit
Case A: F not > S +CF S C
Case B: F not < S +CF S C
In equilibrium both types of arbitrage
will be precluded
This can only happen if: F = S + C
Thus forward price = spot price +
cost of carry
49
1. No Income Asset
How to calculate S + C ?
Spot Price + Cost of
Carry
Notations:
F0 = Forward/Futures price today
S0 = Spot price today
r = Risk-free interest rate with
continuous compounding
e = Exponential constant
50
1. No Income Asset
How to calculate Spot Price + Cost
of Carry?
rT
Mathematically u/ continuous
S0 e
rTPrice + Cost of
compounding:FSpot
0 S0 e
Carry
Therefore:
Cost of Carry is the cost of financing
the spot purchase of the asset &
holding it to the maturity of the
forward contract (this is applicable
51
1. No Income Asset
Note:
In the condition of the forward price
being lower than the cost-of-carry
price, short selling the asset in the
spot market is just one of the
possible forms of arbitrage.
The other form of arbitrage is that
under such conditions sufficient no.
of investors who hold the asset at
present are ready to sell the asset in
52
1. No Income Asset
Example 1: Determine the forward
price of a no income paying asset for
a 3 month maturity. The current price
of the asset is INR 40 and risk-free
interest rate for 3 months is 5% pa.
Analyse the situations if the forward
price is INR 43 and INR 39.
53
Carry
(S0 - I)e
Return + FCost
of
Carry
rT
(S - I)e
0
Therefore:
Note: The present value of carry
return has been reduced from spot
60
Important Note:
The present value of the income
from the asset may be calculated
with a different risk-free rate
than the one applicable to the
maturity period of the forward /
futures contract
It depends on the risk-free rate
applicable to the time period
61
F0 S0 e
(r - q)T
65
Notations:
We are now at a time between inception
& maturity
K = Forward price set at the inception of
the forward / futures contract for specific
maturity
F0 = Price of the forward / futures
contract at the present point of time
(between inception & maturity); S0 = Spot
price at present point of time
T = Remaining time to maturity from
70
F0 S 0 e rT
Forward/Futures price today
= Expected spot price at
the maturity date
At todays forward price Value of a Long
forward contract at maturity = Expected
rT
S 0 e (F
0K
spot price at maturity
) Original
forward price mentioned in contract (K) =
F0 K
Value at Maturity
rT
rT
rT
rT
Value of [the
F0 Long
K ]e contract
[ S 0 e Ktoday
]e S(f)
Ke
0 =
Present Value of Value of the Long
forward contract at Maturity =
71
F0 S 0 e rT
Forward/Futures price today
= Expected spot price at
the maturity date
At todays forward price Value of a Short
forward contract at maturity = Original
rT
K S 0 ein contract (K)
forward price mentioned
Expected spot price at maturity (F0) = K
F0
rT
rT
[ K Short
S 0 e ]econtract
Ke today
S 0 (f) =
Value of the
Present Value of the Value of the Short
forward contract at maturity =
rT
72
F0 ( S 0 I )e
Forward/Futures price today
= Expected spot price at
the maturity date
At todays forward price Value of a Long
forward contract at maturity = Expected
rT
(
S
I
)
e
K
spot price at maturity0 (F0) Original
forward price mentioned in contract (K) =
F0 K
rT
F0 S 0 e ( r q )T
Forward/Futures price today
= Expected spot price at
the maturity date
At todays forward price Value of a Long
forward contract at maturity = Expected
( r q )T
S 0 e (F0) K
spot price at maturity
Original
forward price mentioned in contract (K) =
F0 K
Basis Risk
Basis refers to the difference between the spot
price of the underlying asset & its futures price
Basis risk is said to exist when this difference
tends to change
It is of particular importance in futures contract
because of its standardised nature the
maturity of the futures contract may not match
with the planning horizon of the hedger
Due to this the futures contract has to be
closed out at the prevailing futures price & this
has an impact on the position being hedged
82
Basis Risk
At any point of time:
Basis = Spot price Futures price
When the value of Basis increases from one
point of time to another: Basis is said to
strengthen
When the value of Basis decreases from one
point of time to another Basis is said to weaken
When the Basis remains unchanged from one
point of time to another the hedge is said to be
perfect & the value of the hedgers position at
the time of closing out is same as the value of
his position before entering into the futures
83
contract
Basis Risk
A short hedger expects prices to
decrease & sells futures for protection
If the basis remains same, value of
hedgers position at the time of closing
out is same as the asset value before
entering into the futures contract
If the basis increases the value of short
hedgers position at the time of closing
out increases & vice versa
Hence: a short hedger gains when basis
strengthens & loses when basis weakens
84
Basis Risk
A long hedger expects prices to increase
& buys futures for protection
If the basis remains same, value of
hedgers position at the time of closing
out is same as the asset value before
entering into the futures contract
If the basis increases the value of long
hedgers position at the time of closing
out decreases & vice versa
Hence: a long hedger gains when basis
weakens & loses when basis strengthens
85
Basis Risk
Let the following notations be used:
S1 = Spot price at time 1
S2 = Spot price at time 2
F1 = Futures price at time 1
F2 = Futures price at time 2
B2 = S2 F2 = Basis at time 2
Final payoff (Price paid/recd. for the asset) =
Spot price of asset at time 2 + Cash flow
due to closing out the futures contract = S2
+ F1 F2 = F1 + S2 F2 = F1 + B2
Short hedge: Gain occurs when B2 Increases
86
Basis Risk
Final payoff (Price paid/recd. for the
asset) ,
FPO = S2 + F1 F2
Net Change = FPO S1 = S2 + F1
F2 S1
= (S1
F1) + (S2 F2) = B1 + B2 = B2
B1
Thus: FPO S1 = B2 B1 OR
FPO = S1 + (B2 B1)
Hence Final payoff is the sum of 1.
Spot price at the time of entering the
87
1300
1100
1000
F2
1400
1150
1028
Closing out
Adjust.
1250 1400 =
-150 L
1250 1150 =
100 G
Asset value at
time 2
1300
1100
1000
Net receivable
time 2
1300 150 =
1150
1100 + 100 =
1200
1000 + 222 =
1222
Basis at time 1
-50
-50
-50
Basis at time 2
1300 1400 =
1100 1150 =
1000 1028 = -28
-100
-50
Note: Students should
try out withfrom
more1scenarios
having no change
in basis
Basis
Decreases
Unchanged
90 Increases from 1 to
to 2
2
1300
1100
1000
F2
1400
1150
1028
Closing out
Adjust.
1400 1250 =
150 G
1150 - 1250 =
100 L
Asset value at
time 2
1300
1100
1000
Net payable at
time 2
1300 150 =
1150
1100 + 100 =
1200
Basis at time 1
-50
-50
-50
Basis at time 2
-100
-50
-28
Basis
Decreases from 1 Unchanged
Increases from 1 to
Note: Students should
in basis
to try
2 out with more scenarios having no change
2
93
Following Topics
Cross Hedging Concepts, Steps & Issues,
Hedge Ratio & Optimal Hedge Ratio
Optimal Hedge Ratio Technical aspects
Optimal No. of Futures Contracts Without
& With Tailing Adjustments
Rolling the Hedge
Stock Index Futures
Hedging Equity Portfolios Using Index
Futures Index & Non-Index Portfolios
Changing Beta of a Equity Portfolio
Stock Index Futures Pricing & Arbitrage
98
Cross Hedging
This situation occurs when the asset
underlying the futures contract differs from
the one that is being hedged
This happens because sometimes the
hedger may not find a futures/forward
contract for the asset of interest most
hedges are cross hedges
Observed in case of commodities &
financial futures covering debt securities
Hedger has to identify an underlying asset
that is correlated significantly with the asset
being hedged
99
(page 57)
105
107
in futures price(hF)
*2
2
F
2
S
108
109
QF
VA
VF
h *Q A
QF
110
111
QF
VA
VF
Optimal number of contracts after Tailing adjustment to allow for daily settlement of
futures
h *V A
VF
115
Stock Futures
Also traded in the stock
exchanges
The underlying assets are
individual equity shares
Each futures contract is for a prespecified quantity of the stock
(marketable lot)
120
F
shorted (N*)
Where,
P = Current value of the portfolio
F= Current value of one futures
124
F
contracts to be used (N*)
P = Current value of portfolio, F =
Current value of 1 futures contract
125
to *
index
to *
index
Example 10
A 3-month futures contract on a
popular index has to be priced. The
following info. is available:
Current value of index = 2700
Dividend yield = 1% pa
Risk-free interest rate = 5% pa
Compute the futures price for this
index.
135
Index Arbitrage
Arbitrage transactions involving a stock
index for which index futures are traded
Can be carried out when there is a
deviation between the theoretical price
of the index future and the actual price
If the actual price of the index futures is
more than the theoretical price then it
means that the index future is
overvalued so sell it to earn profit
If the actual price of the index futures is
less than the theoretical price then it
136
Index Arbitrage
If the actual price of the index
futures is greater than its
theoretical price then arbitrage can
be done by shorting the index
futures and buying the stocks
underlying the index at the spot
price
If actual price of the index futures is
less than its theoretical price then
arbitrage can be done by buying
137
Index Arbitrage
Index arbitrage requires that a trader is
able to trade swiftly on the portfolio of
stocks underlying the index at their
current prices quoted in the market, as
well as trade on the index futures
contract
Generally this is carried out through
program trading and under normal
market conditions this results in prices of
index futures close to their theoretical
values
Program trading fails to generate correct
138
Underlying Unit(s) of a
currency
Holder of the foreign
currency earns risk free
interest prevailing on that
currency on the balance held
139
F0 S 0 e
Commodity Futures
2 types of Commodities:
Commodities that are
investment assets gold,
silver etc.
Commodities that are
consumption assets crude
oil, base metals
147
Commodity Futures
Commodity Futures
Consumption assets:
Storage costs tend to increase the cost
of carry
Hence a storage cost is akin to a
negative income
So the basic formula for futures pricing
with known income can be modified by
rT
F
(
S
U
)
e
replacing the income
0
0 component with a
ve income term:
149
Commodity Futures
Commodity Futures
Where:
u is the storage costs per annum as a
proportion of the spot price net of any
yield earned on the asset
151
Consumption Assets
F0 S0 e(r+u )T
where u is the storage cost as a proportion of
the asset price
Alternatively,
F0 (S0+U )erT
where U is the present value of the storage
costs
157
S
e
yield y with reference to a 0 0
consumption asset:
cT
For cost of carry
reference to
F0 c
Swith
e
0
an investment asset:
162
Delivery Options
A forward contract specifies a
particular delivery date whereas a
futures contract specifies a delivery
period during which the party with the
short position can choose to make
delivery
Knowing the delivery date is essential
for arriving at the theoretical price of
the futures contract whether at the
beginning, middle or end of delivery
period
163
Delivery Options
Given the generalised model of
forward/ futures pricing, the
forward/futures price may be an
increasing or decreasing function of
time to maturity
If the cost of carry is more than the
convenience yield then it will be
increasing function of time to maturity
If the cost of carry is less than the
convenience yield then it will be
164
Delivery Options
If the futures price is an increasing
function of time to maturity then it is
optimal for the seller of the futures to
deliver at the earliest possible time in
the delivery period because the
interest earned on the cash inflow
from settlement exceeds the benefits
of holding the asset
So in such cases, as a rule, the futures
price should be calculated by the
assumption that delivery will take
165
Delivery Options
If the futures price is a decreasing
function of time to maturity then it is
optimal for the seller of the futures to
deliver at the latest possible time in
the delivery period because the
benefits of holding the asset exceeds
the interest earned on cash inflow
from settlement
So in such cases, as a rule, the futures
price should be calculated by the
assumption that delivery will take
166