Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 36

TELAAH JURNAL

NASIONAL
THE KNOWLEDGE, ATTITUDE AND PRACTICE OF EXCLUSIVE
BREASTFEEDING AMONG MOTHERS IN TWO SEMI-URBAN

AREAS AROUND A BABY FRIENDLY HOSPITAL INITIATIVE


(BFHI) DESIGNATED HOSPITAL IN LAGOS STATE, NIGERIA

Oleh
Cracety Meilina Sitepu
13111101104
Semester VII BM GIZI

Judul Jurnal : The Knowledge, Attitude and Practice


of Exclusive Breastfeeding among
Mothers in Two Semi-Urban Areas
around a
Baby Friendly Hospital
Initiative (BFHI)
designated hospital in
Lagos State, Nigeria
Penulis
: Titilola T. Obilade MBBS, MPH,
FMCPH, MWACP, MILD, Ph.D.
Publikasi
: 2015
Penelaah
: Cracety Meilina Sitepu
Tanggal Telaah : 20 Agustus 2016

Review Jurnal

Deskripsi Jurnal

1.

Menentukan hubungan antara pengetahuan


ibu mengenai ASI Ek slusif dan pelak sanaan
ASI Ek slusif di per tengahan kota Lagos,
Nigeria

2.

Menentukan faktor-faktor sosial demog rafi s


pada ASI Ek slusif

3.

Menentukan efektivitas pada penyebaran ASI


Ek slusif diantara ibu-ibu yang dilayani oleh
Rumah Sakit BFHI

Tujuan Penelitian

1. To determine the relationship between mothers


knowledge on exclusive breastfeeding and the
practice of exclusive breastfeeding in two semiurban areas of Lagos, Nigeria.
2. To determine the socio demographic predictive
factors of Exclusive Breastfeeding.
3. To determine the effectiveness of the propagation
of Exclusive Breastfeeding amongst
mothers in areas served by BFHI designated
hospitals.

Purposes

The knowledge, attitude and practice of exclusive


breastfeeding amongst mothers in the semi urban area
of Lagos, Nigeria. Is statistically significantly affected by
their educational level and by their professional level.
Those with a higher level of education were more likely
to have a correct knowledge (P < 0.05). Religion,
educational level, professional level and number of
children were statistically significant for practicing EBF
for at least three months (P < 0.05).

Hasil Penelitian 1

The belief that colostrum is not good for the baby was
statistically significant for educational level and
profession (P < 0.05). The belief that sperm could get
into the breast milk was statistically significant for age,
religion, ethnic group, education, profession and the
number of children (P < 0.05). Out of all the socio
demographic variables examined, educational level of
the mother and the mothers professional level were the
two variables that were most frequently statistically
significant for knowledge, attitude and practice
questions.

Hasil Penelitian 2

BAHASA INDO

Hasil Penelitian 1

BAHASA INDO

Hasil Penelitian 2

The knowledge, attitude and practice of


breastfeeding are mostly affected by the
education and the profession of the mother.
Certain beliefs about breast milk and sperm
were statistically significant across all the socio
demographic data examined.
Recommendations were made to increase health
education targeted at correcting beliefs about
colostrum and breast milk. Recommendation
was also made for a reevaluation of BFHI.

Kesimpulan Penelitian

BAHASA INDO

Kesimpulan Penelitian

Telaah Jurnal

The aim of the study was to determine the


knowledge, attitude and practice of exclusive
breastfeeding (EBF) amongst mothers living in
areas around a Baby Friendly Hospital
Initiative (BFHI) designated hospital in Lagos,
Nigeria.

Fokus Utama Penelitian

BAHASA INDO

Fokus Utama Penelitian

SISTEMATIKA PENULISAN

Sistematika penulisan yang digunakan pada jur nal


sudah cukup bagus. Sudah mencangkup hal-hal yang
har us ada pada sistem penulisan jurnal.

(Judul, nama penulis, unit kerja dan alamat lengkap,


abstrak, pendahuluan, metode penelitian, hasil dan
pembahasan, kesimpulan dan saran, ser ta yang
terakhir daftar pustaka)

Gaya Penulisan 1

Tata Bahasa

Tata bahasa yang digunakan pada penulisan


jurnal yang berjudul DEFISIENSI BESI DAN
ANEMIA PADA ANAK BAWAH DUA TAHUN
(6-23 BULAN) DI KABUPATEN ACEH BESAR
ini cukup baik, karena pembaca sudah bisa
menangkap isi yan di tulis.

Gaya Penulisan 2

Kualifi kasi Penulis

Penulis jurnal ini sudah exper t di


bidangnya, terlihat dari latar belakangnya
yang merupakan jurusan gizi politeknik
kesehatan Kemenkes Aceh.

Penulis 1

Kelebihan

Judul yang digunakan berbeda dengan


jurnal lain dan jarang dipakai.

Kekurangan

Judul menggunakan bahasa yang terlalu


ilmiah. Jadi, tidak semua orang bisa
mengerti.

Judul

Kelebihan

Abstrak yang ditulis jelas, karena sudah


menunjukan data dar i hasil penelitian. Selain
itu abstrak mudah dibaca dan dipahami oleh
pembaca.

Kekurangan

Dalam abstrak ini sebab dar i masalah yang


ditulis masih belum dijelaskan secara
mendalam.

Abstrak

Elemen yang
Mempengaruhi
Kekuatan Suatu
Penelitian

Masalah Penelitian

Masalah sesuai dengan


topik bahasan yaitu
defi siensi besi dan
anemia di Aceh Besar.
Masalah dengan jelas
dijabarkan di
pendahuluan

Tujuan Penelitian

Mengetahui prevalensi
anemia dan anemia
defi siensi besi
berdasarkan
pemeriksaan kadar
feritin dan hubungan
kadar serum feritin
dengan anemia pada
anak bawah dua tahun 623 bulan di Kabupaten
Aceh Besar

Masalah dan Tujuan Penelitian

Sistematika penulisan jurnal dapat


dikatakan cukup sistematis, runtun,
dan padu. Tidak ada bagian yang
terputus (saling berhubungan)

Sistematika Penulisan

Desain penelitian : Deskriptif analitik


dengan desain cross
sectional study
Tempat & waktu
penelitian
: Tiga Kecamatan di
Kabupaten Aceh
Besar (Kec.
Lhoknga,
Kec. Leupung dan
Kec. Lhong) pada
bulan
Agustus 2011

Metode Penelitian

Populasi penelitian adalah selur uh anak usia 6-23


bulan ber jumlah 613 anak.

Perhitungan besar sampel menggunakan Slovin dan


dikoreksi dengan desain eff ect jumlah sampel
dikali 3 sehingga besa sampel sebanyak 257 anak
baduta.

Pengambilan sampel dengan metode stratifi ed


random sampling .

Populasi dan Sampel

Peneliti mengambil data dengan


mengunjungi sampel terpilih dan melakukan
wawancara tentang karakteristik sampel, lalu
mengambil specimen darah 2,5 cc setiap
sampel dan melakukan pemeriksaan kadar
serum ferritin dengan metode ELISA dan
kadar Hb dengan Cyanmethaemoglobin.

Instrumen Penelitian

Test of significance was done on categorical variables using


the Chi-Square at a P value of 0.05. The result was
presented in tables. Non responses were not included in
the analysis.

Analisis Statistik

BAHASA INDO

Analisis Statistik

The largest number of respondents were in the age


range of 31-35 years old 103 (28.5%). Almost fifty
percent 192 (49.4%) of the respondents had
completed
their
tertiary education.
Skilled
professions 305 (81.3%) was the most predominant.
Yoruba 230 (58.2%) and Ibo 157 (39.7%) were the
most frequent ethnic groups. Almost all the
respondents were married 382 (98%). Majority of the
respondents practiced Christianity 311(85.9%). Most
of the respondents had four children 107(27.1%)
followed by those who had two children 97(24.6%).

Hasil Penelitian

BAHASA INDO

Hasil Penelitian

The results of this study showed that for questions on


knowledge, attitude and practice of EBF, the educational
level of the mother and the professional level of the
mother were consistently statistically significant (P <
0.05). However, the belief that sperm could get into milk
was statistically significant for age, religion, ethnic
group, education, profession and number of children (P
< 0.05). Education of the mother has consistently been
associated with better outcomes for the child. Mothers
that were educated did not discard colostrum and they
were more likely to have the correct knowledge on
breastmilk.

Pembahasan Hasil Penelitian

BAHASA INDO

Pembahasan Hasil Penelitian

Berdasarkan referensi dalam


jurnal bahwa gaya referensi
yang digunakan adalah
harvard style.

Referensi

BAHASA INDO

Referensi

Kesimpulan dan saran yang ditulis


sesuai dengan hasil penelitian,
kesimpulan dapat mewakili hasil
analisis peneliti dan saran yang
dipaparkan juga cukup implementatif.

Kesimpulan dan Saran

BAHASA INDO

Kesimpulan dan Saran

Terima Kasih