You are on page 1of 60

ASSESSING

SPEAKING
BASIC TYPES OF SPEAKING
1. IMITATIVE
2. INTENSIVE
3. RESPONSIVE
4. INTERACTIVE
5. EXTENSIVE ( MONOLOGUE)
BASIC TYPES OF SPEAKING-
INTERACTIVE- INTERACTION
INTERACTION DIVIDES INTO 2 TYPES

1. TRANSACTIONAL LANGUAGE

2. INTERPERSONAL EXCHANGES
BASIC TYPES OF SPEAKING-
INTERACTIVE - INTERACTION:
TRANSACTIONAL:

1. MARY: EXCUSE ME , DO YOU HAVE THE TIME?

DOUG: YEAH, NINE-FIFTEEN

2. TONY : WHAT IS THE MOST URGENT ENVIRONMENTAL


PROBLEM TODAY?

SUSAN : I WOULD SAY MASSIVE DEFORESTATION


BASIC TYPES OF SPEAKING-
INTERACTIVE - >INTERACTION:
INTERPERSONAL:
JEFF: HEY STEF , HOW S IT GOING?

STEF: NOT BAD, AND YOURSELF?

JEFF: IM GOOD

STEF: COOL , OKAY GOTTA GO


MACRO MICRO SKILLS OF
ORAL PRODUCTION
MICRO SKILL - PRODUCING THE SMALLER CHUNKS OF LANGUAGE
SUCH AS PHONEMES MORPHEMES , WORDS, COLLOCATIONS AND
PHRASAL UNITS

MACRO SKILL - EXPRESSES THE LARGER ELEMENTS SUCH AS


FLUENCY , DISCOURSE , FUNCTION, STYLE, COHESION , NON-VERBAL
COMMUNICATION AND STRATEGIC OPTIONS
MICRO SKILLS

a) Produce differences among English phonemes and allophonic


variants.
b) Produce chunks of language of different lengths.
c) Produce English stress patterns, words in stressed and unstressed
positions, rhythmic structure, and intonation contours.
d) Produce reduced forms of words and phrases.
e) Use an adequate number of lexical units words to accomplish
pragmatic purposes.
f) Produce fluent speech at different rates of delivery.
MICRO SKILLS
g) Monitor one's own oral production and use various strategic
devices pauses, fillers, self-corrections, backtrackingto
enhance the clarity of the message.
h) Use grammatical word classes systems tense, agreement,
pluralization), word order, patterns, rules, and elliptical forms.
I ) Produce speech in natural constituents: in appropriate
phrases, pause groups, breath groups, and sentence
constituents.
j) Express particular meaning in different grammatical forms.
k) Use cohesive devices in spoken discourse.
MACRO SKILLS
a)Appropriately accomplish communicative functions
according to situations, participants, and goals.
b)Use appropriate styles, registers, implicature,
redundancies, pragmatic conventions, conversation rules,
floor-keeping and yielding, interrupting, and other
sociolinguistic features in face-to-face conversations.
c) Convey links and connections between events and
communicate such relations as focal and peripheral ideas,
events and feelings, new information and given
information, generalization and exemplification.
MACRO SKILLS
d) Convey facial features, kinesics, body language, and other
nonverbal cues along with verbal language.
e) Develop and use a battery of speaking strategies, such as
emphasizing key words, rephrasing, providing a context for
interpreting the meaning of words, appealing for help, and
accurately assessing how well your interlocutor is understanding
you.
DESIGNING ASSESSMENT TASKS
IMITATIVE SPEAKING
Word and sentence repetition task
Test-takers hear: Repeat after me:
1 ) beat [pause] bit [pause]
2) bat [pause] vat [pause]
3)1 bought a boat yesterday.
4)The glow of the candle is growing.
5)When did they go on vacation?
6)Do you like coffee?
Test-lakers repeat the stimulus.
SCORING SCALE FOR REPETITION
TASKS

2 acceptable pronunciation
1 comprehensible, partially correct pronunciation
0 silence, seriously incorrect pronunciation
VERSANT=PHONEPASS
FORMERLY CALLED PHONEPASS
Scores for the versant test are calculated by a
computerized scoring template _ reported back to
the test-taker within minutes.
DESIGNING ASSESSMENT
TASKS: INTENSIVE SPEAKING
At the intensive level, test-takers are prompted to produce short
stretches of discourse (no more than a sentence) through which they
demonstrate linguistic ability at a specified level of language.

,

.
DESIGNING ASSESSMENT
TASKS: INTENSIVE SPEAKING
Intensive tasks may also be described as limited response tasks
(Madsen, 1983), or mechanical tasks (Underhill, 1987), or what
classroom pedagogy would label as controlled responses.


(Madsen, 1983),
(Underhill, 1987),
.
Directed Response Tasks-

In this type of task, the test administrator elicits a particular
grammatical form or a transformation of a sentence.


,
.
Directed Response Tasks-

Test-takers see:
Interviewer: What did you do last weekend?
_______________________________________________________
Test-taker:

Interviewer: What will you do after you graduate from this program?
_______________________________________________________
Test-taker:

Test-taker: _______________________________________________________ ?
I was in Japan for two weeks.
Interviewer:

Test-taker: _______________________________________________________ ?
It's ten-thirty.
Interviewer:
Read-Aloud Tasks-

Intensive reading-aloud tasks include reading beyond the sentence
level up to a paragraph or two.

.
(,
, , , , )-
.
Read-Aloud Tasks-

, 4
.
Pronunciation-:
Points:
0.0-0.4 Frequent phonemic errors and foreign stress and intonation patterns that cause the speaker to be unintelligible. -
, , ,
0.5-1.4 Frequent phonemic errors and foreign stress and intonation patterns that cause the speaker to be occasionally unintelligible.
- , , ,

1.5-2.4 Some consistent phonemic errors and foreign stress and intonation patterns, but the speaker is intelligible. -
, ,

2.5-3.0 Occasional non-native pronunciation errors, but the speaker is always intelligible. -

Sentence/Dialogue Completion Tasks and Oral
Questionnaires-
/

Another technique lor targeting intensive aspects of language requires test-takers to read
dialogue in which one speaker s lines have been omitted. Test-takers are first given time to read
through the dialogue to get its gist and to think about appropriate lines to fill in.


.
. ,
.
Sentence/Dialogue Completion Tasks and Oral
Questionnaires-
/

Dialogue completion task
Test-takers read (and then hear):
In a department store:
Salesperson: May I help you?
Customer: ______________________________________________________________
Salesperson: Okay, what size do you wear?
Customer: ______________________________________________________________
Salesperson: Hmmm. How about this green sweater here?
Customer: ______________________________________________________________
Salesperson: Oh. Well, if you don't like green, what color would you like?
Customer: ______________________________________________________________
Salesperson: How about this one?
Customer: ______________________________________________________________
Salesperson: Great!
Customer: ______________________________________________________________
Salesperson: It's on sale today for $39.95.
Customer: ______________________________________________________________
Salesperson: Sure, we take Visa, MasterCard, and American Express.
Customer: ______________________________________________________________
Test-takers respond with appropriate lines.
Picture-Cued Tasks-

One of the more popular ways to elicit oral language performance
at both intensive and extensive levels is a picture-cued stimulus that
requires a description from die test- taker.

(intensive)
(extensive)
.
Picture-Cued Tasks-

Pictures may be very simple, designed to elicit a word or a plirase;
somewhat more elaborate and "busy"; or composed of a series that
tells a story or incident.

, ,
, ,
.
Picture-Cued Tasks-

Picture-Cued Tasks-

.
Picture-Cued Tasks-

Test-takers hear:
This family is at an airport going on their
vacation.
Where are they going for their vacation?
1. What will he do in Hawaii?
2. What will she do there?
3. What Is she going to do there?
4. What is he going to do in Hawaii?
Picture-Cued Tasks-


2 ,
1 ,
0 ,
Translation
DESIGNING ASSESSMENT TASKS:
RESPONSIVE SPEAKING

Assessment of responsive tasks involves brief interactions


with an interlocutor, differing from intensive tasks in the
increased creativity given to the test-taker and from
interactive tasks by the somewhat limited length of
utterances.
Question and Answer
Question-and-answer tasks can consist of one or two questions
from an interviewer, or they can make up a portion of a whole
battery of questions and prompts in an oral interview.
They can vary from simple questions like "What is this called in
English?" to complex questions like "What arc the steps
governments should take, if any, to stem the rate of
deforestation in tropical countries?
Questions eliciting open-ended
responses
1. What do you think about the weather today?
2.What do you like about the English language?
3.Why did you choose your academic major?
4.What kind of strategies have you used to help you learn English?
a. Have you ever been to the United States before?
b. What other countries have you visited?
c. Why did you go there? What did you like best about it?
d. If you could go back, what would you like to do or see?
e. What country would you like to visit next, and why?
respond with a few sentences at most.
Elicitation of questions from the
test-taker
Do you have any questions for me?
Ask me about my family or job or interests.
If you could interview the president or prime
minister of your country, what woulc you ask that
person?
Test-takers respond with questions.
Eliciting instructions or directions
Describe how to make a typical dish from your country.
What's a good recipe for making ______?
How do you access email on a PC computer?
How would I make a typical costume for a___celebration in your
country?
How do you program telephone numbers into a cell (mobile) phone?
How do I get from___to_______ in your city?
Test-takers respond with appropriate instructions/directions
Paraphrasing

Paraphrase the following little story in your own words.

My weekend in the mountains was fabulous. The first day we backpacked into the mountains
and climbed about 2,000 feet. The hike was strenuous but exhilarating. By sunset we found
these beautiful alpine lakes and made camp there. The sunset was amazingly beautiful. The next
two days we just kicked back and did little day hikes, some rock climbing, bird watching,
swimming, and fishing. The hike out on the next day was really easyall downhilland the
scenery was incredible.

Test-takers respond with two or three sentences.


Paraphrasing a phone message

Please tell Jeff that I'm tied up in traffic so I'm going to be about a
half hour late lor the nine o'clock meeting. And ask him to bring up
our question about the employee benefits plan. If he wants to check
in with me on my cell phone, have him call 415- 338-3095. Thanks.

Test-takers respond with two or three sentences


Paraphrasing a story

My weekend in the mountains was fabulous. The first day we backpacked into the mountains

and climbed about 2,000 feet. The hike was strenuous but exhilarating. By sunset we found

these beautiful alpine lakes and made camp there. The sunset was amazingly beautiful. The next

two days we just kicked back and did little day hikes, some rock climbing, bird watching,

swimming, and fishing. The hike out on the next day was really easyall downhilland the

scenery was incredible.

Test-takers respond with two or three sentences.


Paraphrasing a phone message

Please tell Jeff that I'm tied up in traffic so I'm going to be about a
half hour late lor the nine o'clock meeting. And ask him to bring up
our question about the employee benefits plan. If he wants to check
in with me on my cell phone, have him call 415- 338-3095. Thanks.

Test-takers respond with two or three sentences.


TEST OF SPOKEN ENGLISH
Somewhere between responsive, interactive, and extensive speaking tasks lies another popular
commercial oral production assessment, the Test of Spoken (TSE). Described in chapter 5 and
referencedin the appendix at the back of this book. More information is available at
www.toefl.org

The tasks on the TSE are designed to elicit oral production in various discourse categories radier
than in selected phonological, grammatical, or lexical targets. Lazaraton and Wagner examined
15 different specific task in collecting background data from native and nonnative speakers of
English.
CATEGORIES OF ORAL
PROFICIENCY SCORES
Unable to function in the spoken language
Able to satisfy immediate needs using rehearsed utterances
Able to satisfy minimum courtesy requirements and
maintain very simple face to face conversations on familiar
topics
Can initiate and maintain predictable face to face
conversations and satisfy limited social demands
Able to satisfy routine social demands and limited work
Able to satisfy most work requirements with language usage that is often , but not always
acceptable and effective
Able to speak the language with sufficient structural accuracy and vocabulary to participate
effectively in most formal and informal conversations on practical 8 social and professional
topics
Often able to use the language to satisfy professional needs in a wide range of
sophisticated and demanding tasks
Able to use the language fluently and accurately on all levels normally pertinent to
professional needs
Speaking proficiency is regularly superior in all respects , usually equivalent to that of a well
educated , highly articulate native speaker
Speaking proficiency is functionally equivalent to that of a hightly articulate , well educated
native speaker and reflects the cultural standards of the country where the language is
spoken
Test of spoken english scoring guide
TSE -Test Rating scale
Communication almost always effective : task performed very competently :
speech almost never marked by nonnative characteristics

Functions performed clearly and effectively

Appropriate response to audience /situation

Coherent , with effective use of cohesive devices

Almost always accurate pronunciation , grammar , fluency and vocabulary


Test of spoken english scoring guide
TSE -Test Rating scale
Communication generally effective:
Task performed competently , successful use of
compensatory strategies : speech sometimes marked by
nonnative characteristics
-generally appropriate response to audience /situation
Generally accurate 4 skills
Test of spoken english scoring guide
TSE -Test Rating scale
3) some successful use of compensatory strategies, speech regularly marked by
nonnative characteristics

Somewhat appropriate response , coherent, accurate for 4 skills

4)communication generally not effective :task performed poorly , ineffective use of


compensatory strategies

Performed ineffective, generally inappropriate response, incoherent, inaccurate 4


skills
Test of spoken english scoring guide
TSE -Test Rating scale
No effective communication , no evidence of ability to
perform task , no effective use of compensatory strategies,
speech always markey by nonnative characteristics
No evidence, incoherent , no uses of devices
No evidence of ability to respond
Always inaccurate 4 skills
DESIGNING ASSESSMENT TASKS
INTERACTIVE SPEAKING:

ORAL PRODUCTION ASSESSMENT:

1) INTERVIEWS

2) ROLE PLAYS

3) DISCUSSIONS

4) GAMES
ORAL INTERVIEW
DEF: THE FIRST THING THAT COMES TO MIND
FACE TO FACE QUESTION
TAPE RECORDED , RELISTENING
CRITERIA:
ACCURACY PRONUNCIATION, GRAMMAR, VOCABULARY USAGE ,
FLUENCY , SOCIOLINGUISTIC OR PRAGMATIC,TASK
ACCOMPLISHMENT, COMPREHENSION
TIME: 5-45 MINUTES /PURPOSE /CONTEXT /
INTERVIEW
PLACEMENT : 5 MIN
ORAL PROFICIENCY / OPI /:30 MIN
1) WARM UP / NO SCORING /: SMALL TALK ,
INTRODUCTIONS,
WHILE TEST TAKER BECOME COMFORTABLE
2) LEVEL CHECK :PREPLANNED QUESTIONS
ROLE PLAY
POPULAR ACTIVITY IN COMMUNICATIVE LANGUAGE TEACHING
REHEARSAL TIME- MAP OUT WHAT THEY ARE GOING TO SAY
CONTROLLED , GUIDED BY INTERVIEWER
INTENSIVE, RESPONSIVE LEVEL > CREATIVE, COMPLEXITY
APPROACHES OF PRAGMATIC LEVEL
DISCUSSIONS AND CONVERSATIONS

Topic nomination , maintenance , termination


Attention getting , interrupting , floor holding , control
Clarifying questioning , paraphrasing
Comprehension signals
Negotiating meaning intonation patterns for pragmatic effect
Kinesics , eye contact , proxemics, body language
Politeness formality , other sociolinguistic factors
GAMES / L,S,R,W /
Tinkertoy game
Crossword puzzle
DESIGNING ASSESSMENT TASKS: RESPONSIVE SPEAKING

Assessment of responsive tasks involves brief interactions


with an interlocutor, differing from intensive tasks in the
increased creativity given to the test-taker and from
interactive tasks by the somewhat limited length of
utterances.
Question and Answer
Question-and-answer tasks can consist of one or two questions from an
interviewer, or they can make up a portion of a whole battery of questions
and prompts in an oral interview.

They can vary from simple questions like "What is this called in English?" to
complex questions like "What arc the steps governments should take, if
any, to stem the rate of deforestation in tropical countries?
Questions eliciting open-ended responses

1. What do you think about the weather today?


2.What do you like about the English language?
3.Why did you choose your academic major?
4.What kind of strategies have you used to help you learn English?
a. Have you ever been to the United States before?
b. What other countries have you visited?
c. Why did you go there? What did you like best about it?
d. If you could go back, what would you like to do or see?
e. What country would you like to visit next, and why?
respond with a few sentences at most.
Elicitation of questions from the test-taker

Do you have any questions for me?


Ask me about my family or job or interests.
If you could interview the president or prime minister of your
country, what woulc you ask that person?
Test-takers respond with questions.
Eliciting instructions or directions
Describe how to make a typical dish from your country.
What's a good recipe for making ______?
How do you access email on a PC computer?
How would I make a typical costume for a___celebration in your
country?
How do you program telephone numbers into a cell (mobile) phone?
How do I get from___to_______ in your city?
Test-takers respond with appropriate instructions/directions
Paraphrasing

Paraphrase the following little story in your own words.

My weekend in the mountains was fabulous. The first day we backpacked into the mountains
and climbed about 2,000 feet. The hike was strenuous but exhilarating. By sunset we found
these beautiful alpine lakes and made camp there. The sunset was amazingly beautiful. The next
two days we just kicked back and did little day hikes, some rock climbing, bird watching,
swimming, and fishing. The hike out on the next day was really easyall downhilland the
scenery was incredible.

Test-takers respond with two or three sentences.


Paraphrasing a phone message

Please tell Jeff that I'm tied up in traffic so I'm going to be about a
half hour late lor the nine o'clock meeting. And ask him to bring
up our question about the employee benefits plan. If he wants to
check in with me on my cell phone, have him call 415- 338-3095.
Thanks.

Test-takers respond with two or three sentences


Paraphrasing a story

My weekend in the mountains was fabulous. The first day we backpacked into
the mountains and climbed about 2,000 feet. The hike was strenuous but
exhilarating. By sunset we found these beautiful alpine lakes and made camp
there. The sunset was amazingly beautiful. The next two days we just kicked
back and did little day hikes, some rock climbing, bird watching, swimming, and
fishing. The hike out on the next day was really easyall downhilland the
scenery was incredible.

Test-takers respond with two or three sentences.


Paraphrasing a phone message

Please tell Jeff that I'm tied up in traffic so I'm going to be about a
half hour late lor the nine o'clock meeting. And ask him to bring up
our question about the employee benefits plan. If he wants to check
in with me on my cell phone, have him call 415- 338-3095. Thanks.

Test-takers respond with two or three sentences.


TEST OF SPOKEN ENGLISH
Somewhere between responsive, interactive, and extensive speaking tasks lies another popular
commercial oral production assessment, the Test of Spoken (TSE). Described in chapter 5 and
referencedin the appendix at the back of this book. More information is available at
www.toefl.org

The tasks on the TSE are designed to elicit oral production in various discourse categories radier
than in selected phonological, grammatical, or lexical targets. Lazaraton and Wagner examined
15 different specific task in collecting background data from native and nonnative speakers of
English.