Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 28

Multi V Ⅲ Tropical Copyright 2010 @LG Electronics / AC Company All Rights Reserved 1

Internal Use Only

System Comparison

ALT
ALT 11 :: Air-cooled
Air-cooled Multi
Multi V
V Major
Major Feature
Feature

Multi V Outdoor unit • Individual operating system


• Composed of outdoor unit and indoor unit / AHU
• Effective energy consumption by means of
optimized INV scroll compressor & temp. control
• Supply cooling and heating function, also can
supply simultaneous cooling and heating function.
• Supply fresh air by connecting Air handling unit or
AHU-1
individual heat recovery ventilator or fresh air
indoor unit connection.
• Flexible and less installation, shorter period for
AHU-2 install.
• Precise temperature control by using electronic
expansion valve.
• Water cost and operator cost is saved
AHU-3 • Individual energy billing is possible by use of
power distribution indicator.
• After hours operation is possible.

Available
Space

Multi V Ⅲ Tropical Copyright 2010 @LG Electronics / AC Company All Rights Reserved 2
Internal Use Only

System Comparison

ALT
ALT 22 :: Water-Cooled
Water-Cooled Chiller
Chiller Major
Major Feature
Feature

• Conventional system for whole area's air-


Cooling Tower conditioning on and off.
• Composed of chiller unit, chilled & condensing
water pump, cooling tower, boiler and FCU / AHU.
• Generally use constant compressor and use
AHU-1
2 step capacity control.
• Simultaneous cooling and heating is possible with
4-pipe connection
AHU-2 • Relatively low efficiency under the partial load
condition.
• Fresh air supply by using air handling unit.
• Need expert person to handle the system and
AHU-3 maintenance.
PUMP • If there is a malfunction with the chiller unit,
it can affect whole space's air conditioning.
(generally apply back up unit for emergency)
• More installation period
PUMP

Water-cooled Chiller

Multi V Ⅲ Tropical Copyright 2010 @LG Electronics / AC Company All Rights Reserved 3
Internal Use Only

System Comparison

ALT 1 ALT 2
Classification
Air-Cooled Multi V Water-Cooled Chiller
Owner 91 57
User 90 60
Designer 92 68
Installer 93 47
Cost 89 63

Owner Owner

10 10
8 8
6 6
User Cost User Cost
Value 4 4
Analysis 2 2
Graph

Designer Installer Designer Installer

Multi V Ⅲ Tropical Copyright 2010 @LG Electronics / AC Company All Rights Reserved 4
Internal Use Only

System Comparison
wner)
ALT 1 ALT 2
Classification
Air-Cooled Multi V Water-Cooled Chiller

Schematic Diagram

System Efficiency A B
Machine Room space (heat source) A C
Machine Room space (Indoor unit) B B
Pipe Shaft Size A B
Closed curtain wall design B A
Energy Source (single/multiple) A B
Design / Installation Time A B
Owner Central / Internet Control A B
Easy Maintenance A C
Automatic Back Up A B
Impact of malfunction A B
Easy Retrofit A C
System expansion A B
Corrosion Resistance B A
Maintenance labor Cost A B
Total Points (100) 91 57
VⅢ
Multi*A: Tropical
Good (5 Point), B:Copyright
Not Bad2010 @LG Electronics
(3 Point), / AC Company All Rights Reserved
C: Bad (1 Point) 5
Internal Use Only

System Comparison (User)

ALT 1 ALT 2
Classification
Air-Cooled Multi V Water-Cooled Chiller

Schematic Diagram

Individual use at night or holiday A C


Individual Temp. Control A B
Quick Start (in the morning) A C
Noise Level (outdoor area) B B
Noise Level (Indoor area) A A
Bacteria pollution A C
User
Environmental Friendliness A A
Maintenance water quality, pipe corrosion A C
Possibility of water leakage in the room A B
Possibility of Ref. leakage in the room B A
Operating Cost proportional distribution A B
Stable Capacity B A
Total Points (100) 90 60

VⅢ
Multi*A: Tropical
Good (5 Point), B:Copyright
Not Bad2010 @LG Electronics
(3 Point), / AC Company All Rights Reserved
C: Bad (1 Point) 6
Internal Use Only

System Comparison (Designer & Installer)


ALT 1 ALT 2
Classification
Air-Cooled Multi V Water-Cooled Chiller

Schematic Diagram

Main Equipment B B
Sub Parts A B
Initial Cost
Piping Installation B C
Central Control A B
Total Cost A B
Heat Source Unit Operation B A
Running Cost Pump Operation A B
Cooling Tower Operation A B
Air Side Unit Operation A A
Heat Source Unit A B
Pump A B
Maintenance
Airside Unit B B
Cost
Cooling Tower A B
Water Piping A B
Total Points (100) 89 63
VⅢ
Multi*A: Tropical
Good (5 Point), B:Copyright
Not Bad2010 @LG Electronics
(3 Point), / AC Company All Rights Reserved
C: Bad (1 Point) 7
Internal Use Only

System Comparison (Cost)

ALT 1 ALT 2
Classification
Air-Cooled Multi V Water-Cooled Chiller

Schematic Diagram

Easy Design A B
Design Time A B
Designer Design Flexibility A B
Zoning A B
Long Piping B A
Total Points (100) 92 68
Installing Period A B
Commissioning A B
Easy Installation A B
Installer
Easy Unit Moving A C
Simple components A C
Serviceability B B
Total Points (100) 93 47

VⅢ
Multi*A: Tropical
Good (5 Point), B:Copyright
Not Bad2010 @LG Electronics
(3 Point), / AC Company All Rights Reserved
C: Bad (1 Point) 8
Internal Use Only

Simple Design
Chilled water piping is more complex than VRF system because it has many equipments (pump, cooling tower,
chiller, expansion tank, water chemical treatment, etc.). And also pipe size is bigger and heavier than VRF
system.

Multi V IV System (VRF) Water Cooled Chiller System

Boiler

ODU
Cooling Pump Water-
Tower cooled
chiller Pump

Water
piping
IDU

FCU

DX AHU
AHU

 Less components, Simple composition  More components, Complex composition


 VRF supplier cover to install & maintenance the system  One suppliers cannot cover all units
 Indoors are directly connected to Multi V outdoor units.  Long single piping from chiller, pump, to FCU.
 Easy work with small and flexible pipe.  Big (diameter 300mm) & long pipe.
 Easy expansion of equipment.  Hard to work
 Leakage test with high pressure nitrogen gas (38kgf/sqm)  Leakage test is difficult because of single long pipe
per each system is possible.
 It can guarantee the installation quality
Multi V Ⅲ Tropical Copyright 2010 @LG Electronics / AC Company All Rights Reserved 9
Internal Use Only

Easy Commissioning
One supplier (LG-Shaker) can do commissioning all system.

Multi V IV System (VRF) Water Cooled Chiller System

 VRF supplier can do commissioning all system  Each supplier have to do commissioning many times.

1 step Commissioning 6 steps Commissioning


(4)

Water cooled chiller (3)

Multi V Ⅲ Tropical Copyright 2010 @LG Electronics / AC Company All Rights Reserved 10
Internal Use Only

Shaft & Pipe size

Multi V system can saving a shaft size of building

Multi V IV System (VRF) Water Cooled Chiller System

 Indoors are directly connected to Multi V outdoor units.  Long single piping from chiller, pump, to FCU.
 Easy work with small and flexible pipe.  Big (diameter 300mm) & long pipe.
 Easy expansion of equipment.  Hard to work
 Leakage test with high pressure nitrogen gas (38kgf/sqm)  Leakage test is difficult because of single long pipe.
per each system is possible.
 It can guarantee the installation quality

75mm

Ref.G Ref.L 300mm


D:41.3 D:19
Ins:19 Ins:13
●●●●

water pipe CWS CWR


40 pairs
Ref. pipe size : 0.26sqm(82%) size : 0.32sqm

Multi V Ⅲ Tropical Copyright 2010 @LG Electronics / AC Company All Rights Reserved 11
Internal Use Only

Piping Work

Refrigerant piping system makes simpler, flexible installation & shortens installation time.

Multi V IV System (VRF) Water Cooled Chiller System

Multi V Ⅲ Tropical Copyright 2010 @LG Electronics / AC Company All Rights Reserved 12
Internal Use Only

Easy Maintenance
For Chiller Certified maintenance and operating staff is needed. But Multi V IV is no need
maintenance staff.

Multi V IV System (VRF) Water Cooled Chiller System


 The system requires certified maintenance and
 No need special maintenance staff.
operating staff not only for chillers but also pumps,
 Economic and easy maintenance boilers, cooling towers etc.
→ More expensive maintenance cost.

→ No need Maintenance Staff


→ Maintenance Staff is required

Multi V Ⅲ Tropical Copyright 2010 @LG Electronics / AC Company All Rights Reserved 13
Internal Use Only

Easy Maintenance
For Chiller, maintenance & cleaning periodically by exclusive company

Multi V IV System (VRF) Water Cooled Chiller System


 Need to clean the water pipes
 No water pipes : No scale (use refrigerant)
: System efficiency drop & origin of germs

Unit : %

Unit : mm

thickness of scale

After 2~3year After 5~6year After 7~8year


10% 25~30% 35~40%

Multi V Ⅲ Tropical Copyright 2010 @LG Electronics / AC Company All Rights Reserved 14
Internal Use Only

Easy Maintenance
For Chiller, Water treatment is required for clean water

Multi V IV System (VRF) Water Cooled Chiller System


 No water treatment is needed  Water treatment is required
(deficient service can cause diseases in the system)

[ Polluted Cooling Tower ]

Multi V Ⅲ Tropical Copyright 2010 @LG Electronics / AC Company All Rights Reserved 15
Internal Use Only

Installation Space

By adopting Multi V AHU system, available space is maximized.

Multi V IV System (VRF) Water Cooled Chiller System

Multi V Ⅲ Tropical Copyright 2010 @LG Electronics / AC Company All Rights Reserved 16
Internal Use Only

Installation Space (Rooftop)

By adopting Multi V AHU system, available space is maximized.

Multi V IV System (VRF) Water Cooled Chiller System


 Rooftop Outdoor unit installation Area : 291 ㎡ (51%)  Rooftop Cooling Tower installation Area : 567 ㎡

(mm) (mm)

11,700
4,700

4,700
5,120 5,120
21,400

23,400
12,120 12,120

11,700
4,700

4,700
5,120 5,120

13,600
24,240

Multi V Ⅲ Tropical Copyright 2010 @LG Electronics / AC Company All Rights Reserved 17
Internal Use Only

Installation Space (Basement)

By adopting Multi V AHU system, available space is maximized.

Multi V IV System (VRF) Water Cooled Chiller System


 Basement Equipment installation Area : None  Basement Equipment installation Area : 330 ㎡

3,300
3,300
7,500 7,500

3,300
3,300
7,500 7,500

16,500
Available area : 330 ㎡

3,300
3,300

10,000
7,500 7,500

3,300
3,300
7,500 7,500

3,300
3,300
7,500 7,500

15,000 8,000

[Water-cooled Chiller] [Circulation pump]

Multi V Ⅲ Tropical Copyright 2010 @LG Electronics / AC Company All Rights Reserved 18
Internal Use Only

Integration of System
Multi V system can integrate central control easier with lower cost. And internet using remote central control
function is included.

Multi V IV System (VRF) Water Cooled Chiller System

Simple wiring Complicated wiring

BMS BMS

Open Network Open Network

Internet
BMS G/W
ACP
DDC
Function

Interface
Unit

Cooling AHU
Chiller Pump Pump FCU FCU
Tower

All monitoring points included USD $ 200 / point


at no cost 2-6 points / piece of equipment

Multi V Ⅲ Tropical Copyright 2010 @LG Electronics / AC Company All Rights Reserved 19
Internal Use Only

Auto Emergency Back up Function


A stand-by unit is not required in Multi V system. So, Multi V system can reduce initial Cost.

Multi V IV System (VRF) Water Cooled Chiller System

 Automatic emergency back up function operates the  No emergency back up function.


alternate compressor during compressor failure.  Need additional back up unit.
 Multi V system no need back up unit.  In case building cooling load is 1,250 ton
 250 ton x 5 unit For Operating
Malfunction  250 ton x 1 or 2 unit For Stand by
Malfunction OFF OFF ON

Automatic emergency
back up operation

Back-up
Back-up operation Malfunction
ON OFF ON

Standby Unit
Multi V Ⅲ Tropical Copyright 2010 @LG Electronics / AC Company All Rights Reserved 20
Internal Use Only

Easy Operation at Any Time


Multi V system can be operated for the user’s request at any time.

Multi V IV System (VRF) Water Cooled Chiller System

 Multi V system conditions only the necessary areas with  Chiller system generally operates only for the pre-
regard to user’s demands determined schedule for the entire building with no regard
to user demands.

Multi V Ⅲ Tropical Copyright 2010 @LG Electronics / AC Company All Rights Reserved 21
Internal Use Only

Energy Simulation

Multi V Ⅲ Tropical Copyright 2010 @LG Electronics / AC Company All Rights Reserved 22
Internal Use Only

Reference Site

Multi V Ⅲ Tropical Copyright 2010 @LG Electronics / AC Company All Rights Reserved 23
Internal Use Only

Reference Site

Multi V Ⅲ Tropical Copyright 2010 @LG Electronics / AC Company All Rights Reserved 24
Internal Use Only

Reference Site
Boscolo Hotel / Italy
• Product Type : Multi V sync (15 units)
• IDU Type : Cassette, Duct, Wall mounted, Eco-V
• Total Capacity : 150 HP

Multi V Ⅲ Tropical Copyright 2010 @LG Electronics / AC Company All Rights Reserved 25
Internal Use Only

Reference Site

Rixos Hotel / UAE

• Product Type : Multi V III 735 TR (72 units)


• IDU Type : High Static Duct 341 units

Multi V Ⅲ Tropical Copyright 2010 @LG Electronics / AC Company All Rights Reserved 26
Internal Use Only

Reference Site

Intercontinental Hotel / Santiago, Chile

Indoor units
High Static Duct, Low Static
Duct

Outdoor units
Multi V 200HP

Controller
Wired Remote Controller

Intercontinental
Hotel
Multi V Ⅲ Tropical Santiago, Chile
Copyright 2010 @LG Electronics / AC Company All Rights Reserved 27
End of Document

Вам также может понравиться