Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Rules to remember:
1. Contradictory: opposite truth value
2. Contrary: at least one is false (not both true)
3. Subcontrary: at least one is true (not both false)
4. Subalternation: truth flows downward, falsity flows upwards
Inferences from the Traditional Square
of Opposition
A number of very useful immediate inferences may be readily drawn
from the information embedded in the traditional square of opposition.
Given the truth or falsehood of anyone of the four standard-from
categorical propositions, it will be seen that the truth or falsehood of
some or all of the others can be inferred immediately.
If A is true: E is false; I is true; O is false
If E is true: A is false; I is false; O is true
If I is true: E is false; A and O are undetermined
If O is true: A is false; E and I are undetermined
If A is false: O is true; E and I are undetermined
If E is false: I is true; A and O are undetermined
If I is false: A is false; E is true; O is true
If O is false: A is true; E is false; I is true
5.6 Immediate Inferences
Conversion
Obversion
Contraposition
5.6. Further Immediate Inferences
There are three other immediate inferences that are not
directly associated with the square of opposition that have to
be considered.
These are:
1. conversion,
2. obversion, and
3. contraposition.
Conversion
“In general, we say that the converse of a given proposition
is obtained by exchanging the S-term and the P-term” (Hall, 2012:
78).
Convertend Converse
A: All S is P I: Some P is S. (by limitation)
E: No S is P E: No P is S
I: Some S is P I: Some P is S
O: Some S is not P Conversion not valid
Complement
Obvertend Obverse
A: All S is P E: No S is non-P
E: No S is P A: All S is non-P
I: Some S is P O: Some S is not non-P
O: Some S is not P I: Some S is non-P
Contraposition
There are two steps in order to derive the contrapositive of a
given standard-form proposition
(1) switching the subject and predicate terms and
(2) replacing the subject and predicate terms with their term
complements
Obvertend Obverse
A: All S is P A: All non-P is non-S
E: No S is P O: Some non-P is not non-S
(by limitation)
I: Some S is P Contraposition not valid
O: Some S is not P O: Some non-P is not non-S
Memory Aid
To help remember when conversion and contraposition yield
logically equivalent results, note the second and third vowels
of the words.
C O NV E R S I O N
-conversion works for E and I
C O NT R A P O S IT I O N
-contraposition works for A and O
5.7 Existential Import and the Interpretation
of Categorical Propositions
Existential Import
Boolean Point of View
5.7 Existential Import and the Interpretation
of Categorical Propositions
A proposition is said to have existential import if it asserts the
existence of objects of some kind.
The problem with existential import presents some problems
for the relationships suggested by the traditional square of
opposition.
Particular propositions, the I and O propositions, surely do have
existential import.
The I proposition “Some flowers are roses” asserts that there exists at least one
flower which is a rose.
The O proposition “Some dogs are not companions” says that there exists at
least one dog that is not a companion.
Existential Import and the Interpretation of
Categorical Propositions