You are on page 1of 30

Advantages of mathematicians

learning history of math


• better communication with non-mathematicians

• enables them to see themselves as part of the


general cultural and social processes and not to
feel “out of the world”

• additional understanding of problems pupils and


students have in comprehending some mathematical
notions and facts

• if mathematicians have fun with their discipline


it will be felt by others; history of math provides
lots of fun examples and interesting facts
History of math for school teachers
• plenty of interesting and fun examples to enliven
the classroom math presentation
• use of historic versions of problems can make
them more appealing and understandable
• additional insights in already known topics
• no-nonsense examples – historical are perfect
because they are real!
• serious themes presented from the historical
perspective are usually more appealing and often
easier to explain
• connections to other scientific disciplines
• better understanding of problems pupils have and
thus better response to errors
• making problems more interesting
• visually stimulating
• proofs without words
• giving some side-comments can enliven the class
even when (or exactly because) it’s not
requested to learn... e.g. when a math symbol
was introduced
• making pupils understand that mathematics is
not a closed subject and not a finished set of
knowledge, it is cummulative (everything that
was once proven is still valid)
• creativity – ideas for leading pupils to ask
questions (e.g. we know how to double a sqare,
but can we double a cube -> Greeks)
• showing there are things that cannot be done
• history of mathematics can improve the
understanding of learning difficulties; e.g. the use
of negative numbers and the rules for doing
arithmetic with negative numbers were far from
easy in their introducing (first appearance in India,
but Arabs don’t use them; even A. De Morgan in the
19th century considers them inconceavable; though
begginings of their use in Europe date from
rennaisance – Cardano – full use starts as late as
the 19th century)
• math is not dry and mathematicians are human
beeings with emotions  anecdotes, quotes and
biographies
• improving teaching  following the natural process
of creation (the basic idea, then the proof)
•for smaller children: using the development of
notions
•for older pupils: approach by specific historical
topics
•in any case, teaching history helps learning how
to develop ideas and improves the understanding
of the subject
•it is good for giving a broad outline or overview
of the topic, either when introducing it or when
reviewing it
Example 1: Completing a square / solving
a quadratic equation

al-Khwarizmi (ca. 780-850)


x2 + 10 x = 39

x2 + 10 x + 4·25/4 = 39+25

(x+5)2 = 64

x + 5 = 8

x = 3
Example 2: The Bridges of Königsberg
The problem as such is a problem in recreational math.
Depending on the age of the pupils it can be presented just as
a problem or given as an example of a class of problems
leading to simple concepts of graph theory (and even
introduction to more complicated concepts for gifted
students).
The Bridges of Koenigsberg can also be a good
introduction to applications of mathematics, in this
case graph theory (and group theory) in chemistry:
Pólya – enumeration of isomers (molecules which differ only in the
way the atoms are connected); a benzene molecule consists of 12
atoms: 6 C atoms arranged as vertices of a hexagon, whose edges are
the bonds between the C atoms; the remaining atoms are either H or
Cl atoms, each of which is connected to precisely one of the carbon
atoms. If the vertices of the carbon ring are numbered 1,...,6, then a
benzine molecule may be viewed as a function from the set {1,...,6} to
the set {H, Cl}.
Clearly benzene isomers are invariant under
rotations of the carbon ring, and reflections of
the carbon ring through the axis connecting two
oppposite vertices, or two opposite edges, i.e.,
they are invariant under the group of symmetries
of the hexagon. This group is the dihedral group
Di(6). Therefore two functions from {1,..,6} to {H,
Cl} correspond to the same isomer if and only if
they are Di(6)-equivalent. Polya enumeration
theorem gives there are 13 benzene isomers.
Example 3: Homework problems (possible: group work)

 possible explorations of old books or specific topics, e.g.

Fibonacci numbers
and nature
Fibonacci’s biography
rabbits, bees, sunflowers,pinecones,...
reasons for seed-arrangement
(mathematical!)
connections to the Golden number,
regular polyhedra, tilings, quasicrystals
Flatland
Flatland. A Romance of Many Dimensions. (1884) by
Edwin A. Abbott (1838-1926).

ideas for introducing higher dimensions


also interesting social implications (connections to
history and literature)
Example 4: Proofs without words

 Pythagorean number theory

2(1+2+...+n)=n(n+1) 1+3+5+...+(2n-1)=n2
Connections with other sciences – Example: Chemistry
Polyhedra – Plato and Aristotle - Molecules
What is a football? A polyhedron made up of regular pentagons and
hexagons (made of leather, sewn together and then blouwn up tu a
ball shape). It is one of the Archimedean solids – the solids whose
sides are all regular polygons. There are 18 Archimedean solids, 5 of
which are the Platonic or regular ones (all sides are equal polygons).
There are 12 pentagons and 20 hexagons on the
football so the number of faces is F=32. If we count
the vertices, we’ll obtain the number V=60. And
there are E=90 edges. If we check the number V-
E+F we obtain
V-E+F=60-90+32=2.
This doesn’t seem interesting until connected to the
Euler polyhedron formula which states taht V-E+F=2
for all convex polyhedrons. This implies that if we
know two of the data V,E,F the third can be
calculated from the formula i.e. is uniquely
determined!
In 1985. the football, or officially: truncated icosahedron, came
to a new fame – and application: the chemists H.W.Kroto and
R.E.Smalley discovered a new way how pure carbon appeared. It
was the molecule C60 with 60 carbon atoms, each connected to 3
others. It is the third known appearance of carbon (the first two
beeing graphite and diamond). This molecule belongs to the class
of fullerenes which have molecules shaped like polyhedrons
bounded by regular pentagons and hexagons. They are named
after the architect Buckminster Fuller who is famous for his
domes of thesame shape. The C60 is the only possible fullerene
which has no adjoining pentagons (this has even a chemical
implication: it is the reason of the stability of the molecule!)
Anecdotes
 enliven the class
 show that math is not a dry subject and
mathematicians are normal human beeings with
emotions, but also some specific ways of thinking
 can serve as a good introduction to a topic
Norbert Wiener was walking through a Campus when
he was stopped by a student who wanted to know an
answer to his mathematical question. After
explaining him the answer, Wiener asked: When you
stopped me, did I come from this or from the other
direction? The student told him and Wiener sadi:
Oh, that means I didn’t have my meal yet. So he
walked in the direction to the restaurant...
Georg Pólya told about his famous english colleague Hardy the follow-ing
story: Hardy believed in God, but also thought that God tries to make
his life as hard as possible. When he was once forced to travel from
Norway to England on a small shaky boat during a storm, he wrote a
postcard to a Norwegian colleague saying: “I have proven the Riemann
conjecture”. This was not true, of course, but Hardy reasoned this way:
If the boat sinks, everyone will believe he proved it and that the proof
sank with him. In this way he would become enourmosly famous. But
because he was positive that God wouldn’t allow him to reach this fame
and thus he concluded his boat will safely reach England!

In 1964 B.L. van der Waerden was visiting professor in Göttingen. When
the semester ended he invited his colleagues to a party. One of them,
Carl Ludwig Siegel, a number theorist, was not in the mood to come and,
to avoid lenghty explanations, wrote a short note to van der Waerden
kurz, saying he couldn’t come because he just died. Van der Waerden
replyed sending a telegram expressing his deep sympathy to Siegel
about this stroke of the fate...
It is reported that Hermann Amandus
Schwarz would start an oral examination
as follows:
Schwarz: “Tell me the general equation
of the fifth degree.”
Student: “ax5+bx4+cx3+dx2+ex+f=0”.
Schwarz: “Wrong!”
Student: “...where e is not the base of
natural logarithms.”
Schwarz: “Wrong!”
Student: ““...where e is not necessarily
the base of natural logarithms.”
Quotes from great mathematicians
 ideas for discussions or simply for enlivening the class

•Albert Einstein (1879-1955)


Imagination is more important than knowledge.
•René Descartes (1596-1650)
Each problem that I solved became a rule which served
afterwards to solve other problems.
•Georg Cantor (1845-1918)
In mathematics the art of proposing a question must be held
of higher value than solving it.
•Augustus De Morgan (1806-1871)
The imaginary expression (-a) and the negative expression
-b, have this resemblance, that either of them occurring as
the solution of a problem indicates some inconsistency or
absurdity. As far as real meaning is concerned, both are
imaginary, since 0 - a is as inconceivable as (-a).
Conclusion
There is a huge ammount of topics from history which can
completely or partially be adopted for classroom presentation.
The main groups of adaptable materials are
anecdotes quotes
biographies historical books and papers
overviews of development  historical problems
The main advantages are (depending on the topic and
presentation)
imparting a sense of continuity of mathematics
supplying historical insights and connections of mathematics
with real life (“math is not something out of the world”)
plain fun
General popularization
There is another aspect of popularization of
mathematics: the approach to the general public.
Although this is a more heterogeneous object of
popularization, there are possibilities for bringing
math nearer even to the established math-haters.
Besides talking about applications of mathematics,
there are two closely connected approaches: usage of
recreational mathematics and history of mathematics.
The topics which are at least partly connected to his-
tory of mathematics are usually more easy to be ad-
apted for public presentation. It is usually more easy
to simplify the explanations using historical approaches
and even when it is not, history provides the frame-
work for pre-senting math topics as interesting
stories.
 important for all public presentation
since the patience-level for reading math
texts is generally very low.

history of mathematics gives also various


ideas for interactive presentations,
especially suitable for science fairs and
museum exhibitions
Actions in Croatia
• University fairs – informational posters (e.g. women
mathematicians, Croatian mathematicians); game
of connecting mathematicians with their biographies;
the back side of our informational leaflet has
quotes from famous mathematicians

• Some books in popular mathematics published in


Croatia: Z. Šikić: “How the modern mathematics was
made”, “Mathematics and music”, “A book about
calendars”

•The pupils in schools make posters about famous


mathematicians or math problems as part of their
homework/projects/group activities
• The Teaching Section of the Croatian Mathematical
Society decided a few years back to initiate
publishing a book on math history for schools; the
book “History of Mathematics for Schools” has just
come out of print
•The authors of math textbooks for schools are
requested (by the Teaching Section of the Croatian
Mathematical Society) to incorporate short historical
notes (biographies, anecdotes, historical problems ...)
in their texts; it’s not a rule though
• “Matka” (a math journal for pupils of about
gymnasium age) has regular articles “Notes from
history” and “Matkas calendar” starting from the first
edition; they write about famous mathematicians and
give historical problems
• “Poučak” (a journal for school math teachers) uses
portraits of great mathematicians on their leading
page and occasionally have texts about them
•“Osječka matematička škola” (a journal for pupils and
teachers in the Slavonia region) has a regular section
giving biographies of famous mathematicians;
occasionally also other articles on history of
mathematics
• The new online math-journal math.e has regular
articles about math history; the first number also has
an article about mathematical stamps
• All students of mathematics (specializing for
becoming teachers) have “History of mathematics” as
an compulsory subject
•4th year students of the Department of
Mathematics in Osijek have to, as part of the
exam for the subject “History of mathematics”,
write and give a short lecture on a subject form
history of math, usually on the borderline to
popular math (e.g. Origami and math, Mathematical
Magic Tricks, ...)
Marin Getaldić (1568-1627)

Dubrovnik aristocratic family


in the period 1595-1601 travels
thorough Europe (Italy, France,
England, Belgium, Holland, Germany)
 contacts with the best scientists of the time (e.g.
Galileo Galilei)
enthusiastic about Viete-s algebra
back to Dubrovnik continues contacts (by mail)
Nonnullae propositiones de parabola  mathematical
analysis of the parabola applied to optics
De resolutione et compositione mathematica 
application of Viete-s algebra to geometry: predecessor
of Descartes and analytic geometry
Ruđer Bošković (1711-1787)

mathematician, physicist,
astronomer, philosopher, interested
in archaeology and poetry
also from Dubrovnik, educated at
jesuit schools in Italy, later
professor in Rome, Pavia and Milano
from 1773 French citizneship, but
last years of his life spent in Italy
 contacts with almost all
contemporary great scientists and
member of several academies of
science
founder of the astronmical opservatorium in Breri.
for a while was an ambassador of the Dubrovnik republic
great achievements in natural philosophy, teoretical
astronomy, mathematics, geophysics, hydrotechnics,
constructions of scientific instruments,...
first to describe how to claculate a planetary orbit from
three observations
main work: Philosophiae naturalis theoria (1758) contains
the theory of natural forces and explanation of the
structure of matter
works in combinatorial analysis, probability theory,
geometry, applied mathematics
mathematical textbook Elementa universae matheseos
(1754) contains complete theory of conics
can be partly considered a predecessor of Dedekinds
axiom of continuity of real numbers and Poncelets
infinitely distant points
Improving the public image
of math using history:
•everything that makes pupils more enthusiastic
about math is good for the public image of
mathematics because most people form their
opinion (not only) about math during their
primary and secondary schooling;

•besides, history of mathematics can give ideas


for approaching the already formed “math-
haters” in a not officially mathematical context
which is easier to achieve then trying to present
pure mathematical themes
Links I
•http://student.math.hr/~bruckler/ostalo.html
•http://archives.math.utk.edu/topics/history.html Math Archives
•http://www.mathforum.org/library/topics/history/ Math Forum
•http://www-history.mcs.st-andrews.ac.uk/history/ MacTutor
History of Mathematics Archive
•http://www.maa.org/news/mathtrek.html Ivars Peterson's
MathTrek
•http://www.cut-the-knot.org/ctk/index.shtml Cut the Knot! An
interactive column using Java applets by Alex Bogomolny
•http://www.mcs.surrey.ac.uk/Personal/R.Knott/Fractions/egyptian
.html Egyptian Fractions
•http://www.mcs.surrey.ac.uk/Personal/R.Knott/Fibonacci/
Fibonacci Numbers and the Golden Section
Links II
• http://www.maths.tcd.ie/pub/HistMath/Links/Cultures.html
History of Mathematics Links: Mathematics in Specific
Cultures, Periods or Places
• http://math.furman.edu/~mwoodard/mqs/mquot.shtml
Mathematical Quotation Server
• http://www.dartmouth.edu/~matc/math5.geometry/unit1/INTR
O.html Math in Art and Architecture
• http://www.georgehart.com/virtual-polyhedra/paper-
models.html Making paper models of polyhedra
• http://www.mathematik.uni-bielefeld.de/~sillke/ A big
collection of links to math puzzles
• http://mathmuse.sci.ibaraki.ac.jp/indexE.html Mathematics
Museum Online (japan)
• http://www.math.de/ Math Museum (Germany)