Optimization report for Steel and Concrete

– 6th May 2015

Celestia Spaces, Sewri

Submitted by
Celestia Spaces, Sewri DOCUMENT CONTROL
DOCUMENT NO : NS/14-15/OPTZ-01

References:

Rev. No Document Date Document Description Author Verifier Approver

R0 NS/14-15/OPTZ-01 6th May 15 PLL CS – Concrete and Steel optmization AAS Ritesh AAS

Contact Person

Amol Sathe, Project Manager

Neilsoft Limited
7th Floor, Pride Parmar Galaxy, Near Sadhu Vaswani Chowk, Camp
Pune – 411001, Tel: +91 20 30542200, Fax: +91 20 2613 1755, Mobile: +91 9371014280
Email: amol.sathe@neilsoft.com

DISCLAIMER:
A person using Neilsoft documents or data accepts the risk of:
a) Using the documents or data in electronic form without requesting and checking them for accuracy against the original hard copy version; and
b) Using the documents or data for any purpose not agreed to in writing by Neilsoft.

OPT
Celestia Spaces, Sewri
Overall Summary

Subject : Quantity NS tender submission of 22th Aug 14 -

Summary * R3

Construction Area in
Sq.ft for Budget 1,864,390.00

Construction Area in
Sq.ft GFC by
Neilsoft 1,934,951.06

Concrete Reinforcement
PLL Tender GFC vs PLL
Structure PLL Tender vs NS GFC vs PLL Tender vs NS Tender Tender
Tender (A) NS GFC (C) Tender (A) NS GFC (C)
Tender Variance =A-B Variance =A-C Variance =A- Variance =A-
B C

Tower A 34845 36500.35 -0.58 -1655.35 4862.07 4993.98 119.74 -131.91

Tower B 35799 38481.16 202.10 -2682.16 5350.59 5906.54 104.58 -555.95

Associated Podium 22200 22856.14 649.14 -656.14 2910.42 4001.56 0.01 -1091.14

Government Parking 10517 12450.25 700.22 -1933.25 1648.29 1447.77 0.00 200.52

Club House 665 735.77 -70.77 -70.77 106.02 106.02 0.00 0.00

104,026.00 111,023.66 -70.77 -6997.66 14877.39 16455.87 0.00 -1578.48

-7% -11%

Ratio of
Reinforcment
kg/sq.ft 7.980 8.505

OPT
Celestia Spaces, Sewri Overall Summary..Contd
Analysis of Qty increase due to Area increase For Area comparison we
will need break up of
Construction Area in Sq.ft for Budget 1,864,390.00
PLL tender areas

Construction Area in Sq.ft GFC by Neilsoft 1,934,951.06

sqft Concrete (cu.m3) Steel (MT)

Area difference 70,561.06 4,048.65 600.09

Impact on quantities due to above area+ Concrete (cu.m3) Steel (MT)

GFC vs PLL Tender diff 6997.66 1578.48

To be accounted for NS & Sterling 2,949.01 978.39

Post optimization reduction in Steel in
Podium Columns is approx:- 600
Post optimization reduction in Steel in
Podium Raft is approx:- 200
Post optimization reduction in Steel in
Podium beams is approx:- 100

Net effect 978.39-900 = 78 MT

OPT
Celestia Spaces, Sewri
STEEL QUANTITY - Tender 22 Aug 14 in BLACK
(R4)
QUANTITY - as per GFC in RED
STEEL QUANTITY (kg)
BUILDING
S.No.
COMPONENT Raft Column Slab / Stair Beam Non Structural walls Misc Total

Area (sq.m)
Concrete(m kgs/m Steel
1 Tower A Steel (kg) Concrete(m3) kgs/m3 Steel (kg) Concrete(m3) kgs/m3 Steel (kg) Concrete(m3) kgs/m3 Steel (kg) 3) kgs/m3 Steel (kg) Concrete(m3) 3 (kg) Concrete(m3) kgs/m3

Substructure (upto 119740.0

Podium Levels) 565462.50 3973.78 142.30 965100.00 4429.76 217.87 17790.00 789.72 22.53 0 597.36 200.45 0.00 0.00 1353.60 20.62 65.65 1669446.10 2745.31
123260.0
496250.00 3970.00 125.00 656279.40 4191.78 156.56 86530.00 684.27 126.46 0 647.08 190.49 47864.57 736.38 65.00 1236.60 18.66 66.27 1411420.57
Superstructure
(above Podium 706017.0
Levels) 1989850.00 13447.11 147.98 387440.00 5591.45 69.29 0 4311.85 163.74 104308.75 1604.75 65.00 5020.60 79.18 63.41 3192636.35 46806.71
1061860.
1994015.82 13619.86 146.41 406660.00 5831.07 69.74 00 4945.14 214.73 114056.80 1754.72 65.00 5967.00 101.40 58.85 3582559.62
2 Tower B

Substructure (upto 122215.0

Podium Levels) 565397.50 3973.78 142.28 1144030.00 5325.90 214.81 17790.00 563.01 31.60 0 636.76 191.93 0.00 0.00 20.62 0.00 1849432.50 2745.31
137100.0
478236.88 3825.90 125.00 1050294.88 5815.37 180.61 86450.00 676.07 127.87 0 756.18 181.31 47864.57 1236.60 18.66 66.27 1801182.92
Superstructure
(above Podium 822670.0
Levels) 2188830.00 13490.42 162.25 387376.00 5591.99 69.27 0 4310.49 190.85 96285.00 1604.75 5020.60 79.18 63.41 3500181.60 46806.71
1247390.
2351596.58 13767.01 170.81 406660.00 6069.17 67.00 00 5274.82 236.48 95260.62 2201.93 43.26 4446.00 76.05 58.46 4105353.20
3 PPL 315767.50 2526.14 125.00 414005.00 1825.33 226.81 1214295.99 1695.85 716.04 70224.15 5621.87 12.49 573.60 9.56 60.00 2014866.24 20234.42
743509.36 4222.33 176.09 30618.00 1855.50 16.50 629366.63 2664.59 236.20 44279.90 3252.55 13.61 31.28 0.00 424.00 1447773.89
Podium (Associated) 249585.3
4 - PLL 415698.75 3325.59 125.00 584700.50 3506.63 166.74 1957254.95 11048.42 177.15 5 6868.71 36.34 0.00 9.40 3207239.55 57805.27
876913.3
743509.36 3379.59 220.00 638544.80 3741.56 170.66 1742590.93 10576.68 164.76 8 5158.31 170.00 4001558.47
5 Club House 27750.05 129.07 215.00 25268.40 280.76 90.00 52841.00 324.14 163.02 162.00 1.80 90.00 106021.45 2617.61

2143292. 12130.4
TOTAL ( Tender R4 ) 1862326.25 13799.29 134.96 7314265.55 42154.22 173.51 4007215.34 25561.20 50 22671.18 200593.75 3209.50 0 220.36 15539,823.79 179761.34
TOTAL ( current - as per 3543644. 13048.2
GFC ) 2461505.60 15397.82 159.86 6749099.53 43120.14 156.52 3383525.95 26782.61 28 20358.22 305046.56 4724.30 0 640.57 16566,569.59 179761.34

OPT
Celestia Spaces, Sewri

Steel break up - Zone wise

Below & Above Podium Steel breakup (kg)

0.64%
Tower A

Tower B
24.32% 30.35% 47% Tower A & B - Above
PPL podium
53% Club house + podiums

8.80% Podium
(Associated)
Club House

35.89%

OPT
Celestia Spaces, Sewri
Element Concrete consumption

Grade Wise Concrete consumption 14%

23%

Raft

Column

21% Slab / Stair / Ramp

Beam
M40 39%
24%
M50
7%
M60
5% M70
67%

Area break up - Zone wise

1.46%

Tower A

Tower B
27.57%
32.16%
PPL

Podium
(Associated)
Club House
11.26% 27.57%

OPT
Celestia Spaces, Sewri THANK YOU

Submitted by