Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
The “bankable feasibility study” is not a guarantee that a mining project will produce a
planned outcome. Further independent review is advisable, if not necessary, to test
and validate strategic targets, directions and goals. Quantitative risk analysis can not
only play a key role in the making of quality decisions for project approval, but will
also provide grounded measures for project execution risk management.
403-233-7994, dave@cscproject.com
CSC
Excellence In Risk Management
There are more risks to mining than just commodity price fluctuations….
Limitation Statements define some uncertainties, but not all of them…..
-OR-
CSC
Excellence In Risk Management
Mining is a risky business and each stage is impacted by uncertainties
Political
Political
Uncertainty
Uncertainty
Financial &
Economic
Investor Science & Uncertainty
Investor
Uncertainty Technology
Uncertainty
Uncertainty Mining
Complexity
Geological
Uncertainty Market &
Construction Mining Metallurgical Commodity
Uncertainty Uncertainty Uncertainty Pricing
Location Uncertainty
Uncertainty
Social & Social & Social & Social & Social & Social &
Environmental Environmental Environmental Environmental Environmental Environmental
Uncertainty Uncertainty Uncertainty Uncertainty Uncertainty Uncertainty
CSC
Excellence In Risk Management
So what does +/- 15% really mean?
CSC
Excellence In Risk Management
The bankable feasibility study as a comprehensive engineering
study, cost estimate and mining development plan
CSC
Excellence In Risk Management
The hierarchy of Capital Cost estimates
CSC
Excellence In Risk Management
Precision and accuracy are separate variables in the Cost Estimate
“Precision” “Accuracy”
CSC
Excellence In Risk Management
The definition of estimate classes describes the expected range of
uncertainty around an estimate (in assessment and simulation this is
the slope of the probability distribution)
90% 90%
80% 80%
P90 =220 $MM
P90 =237 $MM
70% +10% 70%
+19%
Probability
60% 60%
Probability
P50 = 200 $MM P50 = 200 $MM
50% 50%
P90-P10 = 80%
40% 40% P67.7 crosses at 10% over estimate
30% 30%
0% 0%
$MM $MM
CSC
Excellence In Risk Management
Quantitative risk analysis calculates the probability distribution of a cost outcome
70% Slope of
Probability
40 $MM
Class V Estimate
60% Contingency Slope of
Required for
P50 Confidence Class 2 Estimate
50%
40% P50 = 200 $MM
30%
20% P10 =178 $MM
-9%
10%
0%
120 160 200 240 280
$MM
CSC
Excellence In Risk Management
A example of risk analysis applied
to a mining capital cost estimate
CSC
Excellence In Risk Management
The CAPEX Influence Diagram for a UG Mining Construction Project
Bid $ 3,799k
Rate
Shaft
Excavation $ 53,635k
Competing Mine
Materials/ $ 38,215k
Projects Estimate
Variance Level
Excavation
Labour $ 11,621k
Rate
Subsurface
Equipment
Scope
Variance $58,387k $ 171,682k
Mill Total
Used
Equipment Project
Labour CAPEX
Productivity $ 1,270k
Roads $ 17,570k
Organization
Performance Infrastructure Exchange
Rate
Local
Benefits Water Miscellaneous
Cost
Variance $5,179k $ 11,121k
$22,088k
($ 1,602k/yr) $ 2,592k
Engineering Contingency
Sustaining @ 15%
Cost Capital Administration
Variance $ 17,409k $ 20,001k
EPCM Indirects
CSC
Excellence In Risk Management
From the probabilistic simulation conducted during the quantitative risk
analysis, the Expected Value output of Total CAPEX is $ 181 MM, which
is $ 9 MM above the Base with contingency.
CSC
Excellence In Risk Management
The Base Capital Cost estimate is $ 172 MM. The expected Total Capital Cost
is $ 181 MM. In this case there is only a 39% chance that the project will
achieve the CAPEX Base Case estimate with contingency
Base with
Total CAPEX contingency
( 172 $MM)
100
90 Mine Base
54 $MM
80
Mill Base
70 58 $MM
Probability
EV = 181 $MM
60
50
40
30
20 Mill CAPEX EV = 61 $MM
Mine CAPEX EV = 67 $MM
10 Total CAPEX EV = 181 $MM
181 $MM
CSC
Excellence In Risk Management
Expected increases to Construction Costs add $ 23 MM to the
Base CAPEX Estimate. Schedule Impacts add $ 7 MM.
160
+7
140
Indirect Costs
Mill Costs
Labour Costs
Schedule
Infrastructure
Mine Costs
Costs
CSC
Excellence In Risk Management
A planned outcome requires a sound strategy and a sound execution plan
Strategy
Flawed Sound
Doomed A
Flawed from the Botched In absolute terms, there
Beginning Job is about a one in four
chance of getting the
“right” strategy paired
with the “right”
Flirting A Pretty execution plan for the
with Good “planned outcome”…
Sound
Disaster Chance
• Accuracy and precision are different. Accurate estimates are precise, but
precise estimates are not necessarily accurate.
• Beware of the Halo Effect: the tendency to believe and place faith that
your strategy and execution plan are sound, grounded, etc.;
• The Delusion of Absolute Performance: any given formula cannot ensure
high organizational performance, etc.;
• The Delusion of Lasting Success: enduring success is not sustainable;
• Recognize the Role of Uncertainty: adjust your thinking to accommodate
uncertainty (risk & opportunity!) and make better decisions;
• See your Project through Probabilities: approach problems as
interlocking internal and external probabilities;
• Separate Inputs from Outcomes: actions and outcomes are imperfectly
linked. It is easy to infer that bad outcomes must mean somebody made
mistakes, or a good outcome must mean somebody made good decisions
(or got lucky!);
• There are more things that can go wrong rather than right in execution:
determine the project drivers, assess & quantify risk and develop a risk
management plan to build better valued projects;
CSC
Excellence In Risk Management
A Final Note….
• We often hear the phrase “We have to get cost certainty or
else……) We are rarely told what the “or else” is, but it sounds
pretty awful. In these circumstances, CSC takes the position
that owners, their consultants and contractors to look for the
value proposition in their development and construction
projects. Should your project go over budget, or goes long,
make sure that the project achieves value in the completed
cost. When the project delivers value that respects or justifies
the cost, then it is a good project.
CSC
Excellence In Risk Management
Specifics:
Specialties: