Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 11

Lesson 7

Controversies and Conflicting


Analysis for Selected Primary
Resources: Cavite Mutiny
Learning Objectives
• Recognize historical events using the primary
resources: The Cavite Mutiny
• Interpret and analyze the following primary
resources The Cavite Mutiny
• Discuss the significance of the events
What is the real story behind the
Cavite Mutiny
• In the year 1897 is a
historic year of two
events: the Cavite
Mutiny, martyrdom of
three priests: Mariano
Gomez, Jacinto Zamora
and Jose Burgos later
on immortalized as
GOMBURZA.
What is the real story behind the
Cavite Mutiny
• These events are very
significance milestone
in the Philippines
history and have caused
ripples throughout
time, directly
influencing the decisive
events of the
Philippines Revolution
toward the end of the
century.
What is the real story behind the
Cavite Mutiny
• While the important is
unquestioned, what
made this year
controversial are
different sides to the
story, a battle of
perspectives supported
by the different primary
source.
What is the real story behind the
Cavite Mutiny
• Jose Montero y Vidal, a
Spanish historian who
documented this event
and his work centered
on how the event was
an attempt in
overthrowing the
Spanish Government in
the Philippines.
What is the real story behind the
Cavite Mutiny
• Although regarded as a
historian, his account of
the mutiny was
criticized as woefully
biased and rabit for a
scholar.
What is the real story behind the
Cavite Mutiny
• Two other primary
sources accounts exist
that seem to counter the
accounts of Izquierdo and
Montero. First, the
account of Trinidad
Hermengildo Pardo de
Tavera, Doctor and a
Filipino scholar and
researcher, and wrote a
Filipino version of the
bloody incident in Cavite.
What is the real story behind the
Cavite Mutiny
The GOMBURZA is the
collective name of the
three (3) martyred priests
Jacinto Zamora , Mariano
Gomez, Jose Burgos who
were tagged as the
masterminds of the Cavite
Mutiny.
What is the real story behind the
Cavite Mutiny
• They were prominent
Filipino priest charged
with treason to the
mutiny as part of a
conspiracy to stifle the
movement of secular
priests who desired to
have their own parishes
instead of being merely
assistant to the regular
friars.
What is the real story behind the
Cavite Mutiny
• The GOMBURZA were
executed by garrote in
public, a scene
purportedly witnessed
by a young Jose Rizal.