Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Where will
we play?
How will
we win?
What capabilities
must we have?
..which, taken together, are choices
What
that uniquely positions a brand
management
systems do we
need?
in its market place with
comparative advantage
Most Crucial ?s for Winning in the Market Place
What is our
Marketing
aspiration?
Where will
we play?
How will
we win?
What capabilities
must we have?
What
management
systems do we
need?
To Win
What is our
winning
aspiration?
Where will
we play?
Key Idea #I
How will
We must CHOOSE
we win?
Marketing Strategy is about
making choices. To win,
What capabilities
must we have?
you must choose to do some
things and not do others.
What
management
systems do we
need?
Playing to Win
What is our
winning
aspiration?
Where will
we play?
Key Idea #2
How will
Strategy is
we win?
about
What capabilities
increasing
must we have?
the odds
What
of
success.
management
systems do we
need?
Where will
we play?
Key Idea #3
How will
Successful
we win?
strategy-making
What capabilities
combines logic
must we have?
and creativity.
Strategy should be
What
management
systems do we
creative and
need?
scientific
Source: Playing to Win, A.G. Lafley, Roger L. Martin – it involves generating and testing
hypotheses.
Playing to Win
What is our
winning Future-oriented statement that clearly spells out what it means to win —
aspiration? concretely, specifically, ambitiously. Do NOT be modest. Do NOT play to
play.
Where will
we play?
How will
we win?
What capabilities
must we have?
What
management
systems do we
need?
How will
we win?
What capabilities
must we have?
What
management
systems do we
need?
How will Competitive advantage on the chosen playing field. STP/ 4Ps/ Brand
we win? Equity/ Market Orientation/ Market Segmentation/ Relationship/ Low
cost /differentiation
What capabilities
must we have?
What
management
systems do we
need?
How will Competitive advantage on the chosen playing field. STP/ 4Ps/ Brand
we win?
Equity/ Market Orientation/ Market Segmentation/ Relationship/ Low
cost /differentiation
What capabilities
must we have?
Current AND future marketing activities that enable the organization
to bring the where-to-play and how-to-win choices to life.
What
management
systems do we
need?
What must be What must be What must be What must be What must be What must be
true about the true about true about true about our true about our true about
size and what our what our end- capabilities costs and how how our
attractiveness channels and users truly and how they they compare competitors
of our chosen partners truly value? compare to to those of our will react?
segments? value? those of our competitors?
competitors?
Playing to Win
What is our
winning Future-oriented statement that clearly spells out what it means to win —
aspiration?
concretely, specifically, ambitiously. Do NOT be modest. Do NOT play to
play.
Where will
we play?
Specific spaces where you will and will NOT compete: customer segments,
distribution channels, product/service, geography, PLC, etc.
How will Competitive advantage on the chosen playing field. STP/ 4Ps/ Brand
we win?
Equity/ Market Orientation/ Market Segmentation/ Relationship/ Low
cost /differentiation
What capabilities
must we have?
Current AND future marketing activities that enable the organization
to bring the where-to-play and how-to-win choices to life.
What
management
systems do we
Processes, structures, and rules that build your capabilities,
need? reinforce and measure your organization's strategic choices.
Measures of market share, in-store, presence, in-stock
positions, Product R&D systems
Oil of Olay
Copyright 2014 A.G. Lafley, Roger L. Martin, and Jennifer Riel. Copying or posting is an infringement of copyright.
27
Multiple Cascades
Winning
Corporate
Aspiration
Level Where to
Play
Capabilities
Management
Systems
Strategic Penetrate
Possibility present market
Problem-
Possibility
Old/small Possibility
brand Possibility
Possibility
Possibility
Possibility
The Play-to-Win Process
6. Develop a cascade for each theme & status quo, then reverse engineer each
Winning Where We How We Core Management
Aspiration Play Win Capabilities Systems
Possibility
Possibility
Possibility
CHOICE I Possibility
Possibility
Strategic Possibility
Cascade & reverse engineer
Problem Possibility
Possibility
Possibility
CHOICE 2
Possibility
Possibility
Possibility
The Play-to-Win Canvas
A Visual for Developing Winning Marketing Strategy
Tool
INITIAL
possibility
OIL OF OLAY
Old Strategy: Playing to Play
What is our
winning • To try for an honorable share in the global skin-care category
aspiration? • To turn from a shrinking position to a growing one, improving from
$750 million in sales
What
• Product-based innovation (development of line
capabilities extensions)
must we
have? • Strong retail relationships
• Advertising budget
What
• Measures of market share, in-store
management
presence, in-stock positions
systems do
we need? • Product R&D systems
28
Marketing Goal
INITIAL
possibility
INITIAL
possibility
Why does it matter
INITIAL
possibility
INITIAL
possibility
INITIAL
possibility
INITIAL
possibility
INITIAL
possibility
INITIAL
possibility
INITIAL
possibility
INITIAL
possibility
Seven Questions to answer “Where to play-
How to win”
Segments
INITIAL
possibility
Reverse Engineering
Marketing Strategy's magic question: WHAT MUST BE TRUE?
What must be What must be What must be What must be What must be What must be
true about the true about true about true about our true about our true about
size and what our what our end- capabilities costs and how how our
attractiveness channels and users truly and how they they compare competitors
of our chosen partners truly value? compare to to those of our will react?
segments? value? those of our competitors?
competitors?
INITIAL
possibility
OIL OF OLAY
Where will • Customers: Target younger women just noticing the first signs of aging
we play? • Channel: Sell through mass channels (best customers)
• Product: New products and formulations that fight multiple signs of
• aging
Geography: Consistent global brand
How will
• Move upmarket in product, price, and promotion
we win?
• Establish “masstige” channel presence
What
• Innovation (in product, distribution,
capabilities packaging)
must we •
have? • Consumer understanding
• Go-to-market approaches
Partnering
What
• Partnering systems
management
systems do • Channel and consumer
metrics
we need?
29
Hypothetical Example: AlphaPharma
1. Draft the current strategy cascade
• To extend patients' lives and increase their quality of life
winning
aspiration • To be a global biopharma company delivering safe, effective
medicines
• To be the top player in our chosen therapeutic areas
Where Customers: Patients Channel: Prescribers Geography: Developed world
we play Product: Prescription medicines in three therapeutic areas – oncology, diabetes,
and heart disease
Research leadership: Science-driven primary research that produces innovative and
How effective drugs in our three therapeutic areas. Development excellence: Develop drugs
we win through the pipeline and sell through to doctors. Winning partnerships: Work with
highly influential clinicians to build long-term relationships.
Failure to
innovate
effec9vely
and a weak
pipeline
Hypothetical Example: AlphaPharma
3. Frame the problem as two distinct choices
Broaden focus
Failure to
innovate
effec9vely
and a weak
pipeline
Narrow focus
Hypothetical Example: AlphaPharma
4. Brainstorm initial where-to-play/how-to-win possibilities
Expand beyond three therapeutic areas to a
broad array of acute and chronic conditions
Create comprehensive treatment regimens
rather than drugs
Expand to medical devices
Become a fast follower, move into generics
Expand to over-the-counter
Win on the basis of the best science
Failure to Broaden focus Win on the basis of brand building and
relationships
innovate Refocus on the patient as customer
effec9vely Focus on chronic diseases
and a weak Focus on most pervasive diseases
Focus on early-stage, highly technical
pipeline Narrow focus
research
Focus on the development &
commercializaion stage
Hypothetical Example: AlphaPharma
5. Cluster and cull possibilities by theme
Expand beyond three therapeutic areas to a
broad array of acute and chronic conditions
Create comprehensive treatment regimens
rather than drugs
Broaden
Expand to medical devices
Become a fast follower, move into generics
Expand to over-the-counter
Win on the basis of the best science
Failure to Broaden focus Win on the basis of brand building and Maintain current
relationships breadth
innovate Refocus on the patient as customer
effec9vely Focus on chronic diseases and most Narrow
and a weak pervasive diseases, i.e. diabetes therapeutic focus
Narrow focus Focus on early-stage, highly Narrow by stage
pipeline technical research (early)
Focus on the development & Narrow by stage
commercializaion stage (late)
Hypothetical Example: AlphaPharma
5. Cluster and cull possibilities by theme
Expand beyond three therapeutic areas to a
broad array of acute and chronic conditions
Create comprehensive treatment regimens
rather than drugs
Broaden
Expand to medical devices
Become a fast follower, move into generics
Expand to over-the-counter
Win on the basis of the best science
Failure to Broaden focus Win on the basis of brand building and Maintain current
relationships breadth
innovate Refocus on the patient as customer
effec9vely Focus on chronic diseases and most Narrow
pervasive diseases, i.e. diabetes therapeutic focus
and a weak
Focus on early-stage, highly technical Narrow by stage
pipeline Narrow focus (early)
research
Focus on the development & Narrow by stage
commercializaion stage (late)
Hypothetical Example: AlphaPharma
5. Cluster and cull possibilities by theme
Expand beyond three therapeutic areas to a
broad array of acute and chronic conditions
Create comprehensive treatment regimens
rather than drugs
Broaden
Expand to medical devices
Become a fast follower, move into generics
Expand to over-the-counter
Win on the basis of the best science
Failure to Broaden focus Win on the basis of brand building and Maintain current
relationships breadth
innovate Refocus on the patient as customer
effec9vely Focus on chronic diseases and most
pervasive diseases, i.e. diabetes Diabetes experts
and a weak
Focus on early-stage, highly
pipeline Narrow focus technical research Petri dish
Focus on the development & Commercial engine
commercializaion stage
“Diabetes experts”
Global leader Global leader Improve
quality of life Extend lives
in diabetes in diabetes Cure diabetes
of diabetics
“Diabetes experts” research treatment for diabetics
Global leader Global leader Improve
quality of life Extend lives
in diabetes in diabetes Cure diabetes
of diabetics
“Diabetes experts” research treatment for diabetics
diabetics
Endocrin- Primary
care ologists
physicians
Diabetes
educators
P
h
a
r
m
a
-
c
i
s
t
s
Prescript-ion
protocol
Diabetes
devises
Developed
world
china
Third world
Global leader Global leader Improve
quality of life Extend lives
in diabetes in diabetes Cure diabetes
of diabetics
“Diabetes experts” research treatment for diabetics
diabetics
Diabetes
devises Primary care
physicians
china
Pharma-cists
Prescript-ion
protocol
Endocrin-
ologists
Developed
world
Diabetes
educators
Third world
Global leader Global leader Improve
quality of life Extend lives
in diabetes in diabetes Cure diabetes
of diabetics
“Diabetes experts” research treatment for diabetics
Diabetes
educators
Third world
Global leader Global leader Improve
quality of life Extend lives
in diabetes in diabetes Cure diabetes
of diabetics
“Diabetes experts” research treatment for diabetics
Deep under-
Prescript-ion Diabetes Developed china
standing of protocol devises world
diabetes
Excellent
science Deep under-
standing of
patients
Deep under-
standing of
clinicians
Create trust
w/other
diabetes
Sell-thru to experts
patients &
Drug clinicians
develop-
ment
prowess
Nati’l Affiliat-
ions
Global leader Global leader Improve
quality of life Extend lives
in diabetes in diabetes Cure diabetes
of diabetics
“Diabetes experts” research treatment for diabetics
Deep under-
Create w/other
trust
Sell-thru to
patients & standing of
experts
diabetes
clinicians clinicians
Drug
develop-
ment
rebrand prowess
Ads &
market-ing
Hi profile
sponsor-
ships
Nati’l Affiliat-
ions
Global leader Global leader Improve
quality of life Extend lives
in diabetes in diabetes Cure diabetes
of diabetics
“Diabetes experts” research treatment for diabetics
Excellent
Deep under- Deep under- Deep under-
standing of standing of standing of
science
diabetes clinicians patients
rebrand
A
ds &
m
arket-ing
Hi profile
sponsor-
ships
Nati’l Affiliat-
ions
Global leader Global leader Improve
quality of life Extend lives
in diabetes in diabetes Cure diabetes
of diabetics
“Diabetes experts” research treatment for diabetics
China
remains
diabetes wide-spread rates d
China allows
growing iabetes
in
diabetes
Excellent
Deep under- Deep under- Deep under-
standing of standing of standing of
science
diabetes clinicians patients
Excellent
Deep under- Deep under- Deep under-
standing of standing of standing of
science
diabetes clinicians patients
drugs We can
china
for on-
patent
approval in
Patients
value having No all-out
voice in turf war
regimen
Global leader Global leader Improve
quality of life Extend lives
in diabetes in diabetes Cure diabetes
of
“Diabetes experts” research treatment for diabetics
diabetics
diabetics Pharma-cists
physicians ologists
Primary care Endocrin-
china
protocol devises world
Prescript-ion Diabetes Developed
standing
Deep under-of standing
Deep under-of standing
Deep under- of
science
Excellent
Patients
value havin
voice in
regimen
Global leader Global leader Improve
quality of life Extend lives
in diabetes in diabetes Cure diabetes
of
“Diabetes experts” research treatment for
diabetics
diabetics
diabetics Pharma-cists
physicians ologists
Primary care Endocrin-
china
protocol devises world
Prescript-ion Diabetes Developed
standing
Deep under-of standing
Deep under-of standing
Deep under- of
science
Excellent
Patients
value having No all-out
voice in turf war
regimen
Global leader Global leader Improve
quality of life Extend lives
in diabetes in diabetes Cure diabetes
of
“Diabetes experts” research treatment for
diabetics
diabetics
diabetics Pharma-cists
physicians ologists
Primary care Endocrin-
china
protocol devises world
Prescript-ion Diabetes Developed
standing
Deep under-of standing
Deep under-of standing
Deep under- of
science
Excellent
Patients Limited
value having No all-out industry
voice in turf war press
regiment release
Global leader Global leader Improve
quality of life Extend lives
in diabetes in diabetes Cure diabetes
of
“Diabetes experts” research treatment for
diabetics
diabetics
diabetics Pharma-cists
physicians ologists
Primary care Endocrin-
china
protocol devises world
Prescript-ion Diabetes Developed
standing
Deep under-of standing
Deep under-of standing
Deep under- of
science
Excellent
Patients Limited
value having No all-out industry
voice in turf war press
regimen release
Global leader Global leader Improve
quality of life Extend lives
in diabetes in diabetes Cure diabetes
of
“Diabetes experts” research treatment for
diabetics
diabetics
diabetics Pharma-cists
physicians ologists
Primary care Endocrin-
china
protocol devises world
Prescript-ion Diabetes Developed
standing
Deep under-of standing
Deep under-of standing
Deep under- of
science
Excellent
Patients Limited
value having No all-out industry
voice in turf war press
regimen release
Global leader Global leader Improve
quality of life Extend lives
in diabetes in diabetes Cure diabetes
of
“Diabetes experts” research treatment for
diabetics
diabetics
diabetics Pharma-cists
physicians ologists
Primary care Endocrin-
china
protocol devises world
Prescript-ion Diabetes Developed
standing
Deep under-of standing
Deep under-of standing
Deep under- of
science
Excellent
Patients Limited
value having No all-out industry “radio
voice in turf war press
silence”
regimen release
Global leader Global leader Improve
quality of life Extend lives
in diabetes in diabetes Cure diabetes
of diabetics
“Diabetes experts” research treatment for diabetics
Excellent
Deep under- Deep under- Deep under-
standing of standing of standing of
science
diabetes clinicians patients
Patients pay
manage No all-out Compet-itive
drug turf war reaction
drugs We can
approval in
for on-
patent
china Time & effort
value one- economy of won’t
Patients Limited
value having No all-out industry “radio
voice in turf war press
silence”
regiment release
FDA
R&D stage-
process
Thank You