Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Develop an Approach for integrating Ispat’s business objectives with individual objectives
of all executives in order to provide the Company a platform for profitable growth in the
next 3-5 years time-frame
Develop a plan for extending the Approach developed for Dolvi to cover Kalmeshwar also.
2
The Nature of Change
The success of any change journey depends primarily on how well individuals
embrace the change
6
Rewards Integration
Business & 5
Measurement
Operations
Strategy Structure 4
Processes 5
3
1 2 Comprehension &
Mastery
Organisational Business
Processes 4
Acceptance
3
Awareness 2 Trial
1
Knowledge
Individual
3
Why
Change
Globalization Cost-effective
Partnerships Innovation producer Supply chain
Integrated Logistics
New competitors Integrated Supply Chain
New products/process technology
Technology
Products
Process Knowledge capital
Systems Information Capital
Consolidati World class Skills up gradation Training
on quality
of steel
industry
6
Why Issues of Importance for Defining PMS in Ispa
Change
Company must move quickly; those who lag will survive at best
8
Why
Change
The implications Q
Focus on Customer
Empower People Use Enabling Technology
Reduce Costs
X
X
Eliminate Non-Value Emphasise Continuous
Added Activities Improvement
Compress Time
Eliminate Waste
Develop End-to-End Solutions
Increase Productivity
9
Need for an Operational
Vision
The Operational Vision is the first step in our change journey towards achieving our objectives
Develop
implementatio
Identify gap
n plan setting
between Develop
Define our Assess current out time
Operational solutions to
goals situation frames,
Vision and As bridge the gap
resources,
Is Status
responsibilities
, and costs
10
Need for an Operational
Vision
Provides a
vivid picture
of focus areas
Provides Provides
criteria for direction and
decision drives the
making organisation
Operational
Vision
Empowers
employees
with Encourages
motivation, continuous
authority and improvement
enablement
11
Need for an Operational
Vision
12
Operational Vision Definition
Identification of key
performance indicators
(KPIs)
Identification of milestones
to guide us on the change
journey (Timelines)
13
Definiti
Operational Vision Definition
on
A framework defining
how we wish to
OPERATE
Encompasses the
entire organization People Technology
Does not take into
account current level • Structure Business Integration
of performance on • Roles • Accuracy and timeliness
each parameter • Responsibilities of information
• Skills Process • Degree of integration
• Motivation
Forms the basis for
review of current
processes to identify
gaps vis-a-vis vision • Decision making
• Planning
• Operational flow
• Monitoring and control
Areas to be
targeted for
Change 14
Approa
Operational Vision ch
Analysis of
the Business
Performance
Organizing
Inputs from
Business
Management
Plans
Operational
Vision
Experience of Best
other Steel Practices and
Companies Benchmarks
15
The Extended Supply Chain
Supply Chain
Plan
Suppliers Design
Customers
Source Make Deliver Service Sell
Information Technology
Finance
The supply chain is the business process combining the material and
information flow required to source, make, and deliver goods and services
to the end customer.
16
Alignment of Business
The Operational Vision Framework
Components
The operational vision should guide our efforts in aligning the process, people and
technology components of the business with our strategy to bridge the gap
between current and target performance levels
•Organization structure
•Technology applied to
is process driven
Strategy enable dramatic
•There is complete improvements in
clarity on roles and business operations
responsibilities
•Improved
People Business Technology
•Employees are Integration communication across
empowered organisational
boundaries both
•Job requirements are
internal and external
matched with necessary Process
skills /tools •Instantaneous sharing
of information
•There is clear linkage
between strategic •Processes are aligned to meet •Supports new ways of
objectives, success strategic objectives doing business
factors and KPIs
•Processes ensure that each
•The HR policies support activity undertaken adds
reward based on value to the products as
achievement against perceived by our customers
KPIs
•Process orientation facilitates
quick response at lower costs
and improved17 quality
Moving from Functional to Process
The Operational Vision Framework
Orientation
M M
A
E A
GENERATE DEMAND
M E
N N M N
F A N
U G F A U
I R F I R F
G
I I FULFILL DEMAND
N K A N K A
N N
A E C A E C
T
E N T T
E
N T E
U E C I U
C I R DEVELOP PRODUCTS & PROCESSES
R R E N R
E N I G I
I
I N
G N N
N G
G G
G MANAGE ENTERPRISE
18
Supportive organization
Product
Marketing Sales Service Development
Customer Customer Customer
Needs
Customer
Customer Management
Segment 1
Product B
Product B
Product C
Product A
Product B
Product C
Product B
Product C
Product C
Product A
Product A
Product A
Needs
Customer
Segment 2
Customer
Needs
Segment 3
21
Moving from Functional to Process
The Operational Vision Framework
Orientation
22
Approa
Operational Vision ch
Prepared a “Process Map” for Ispat’s operations; classified operations into 4 “Core
Processes”
M1 : Develop Products and Processes
M2 : Generate Demand
M3 : Fulfill Demand
M4 : Plan and Manage the Enterprise
Identified Sub-Processes upto the 2nd level for each of the above core processes;
for example, “Generate Demand” was broken down further as:
M2 : Generate Demand
M-2.01 : Manage Customer Relationship
M-2.02 : Create Market
23
Business Process
The Operational Vision Framework
Model
M-1 Develop Products / Processes M-2 Generate Demand M-3 Fulfill Demand
Manage
Conduct Manage Supply
M-1.01 M-2.01 Customer M-3.01
Research Sourcing
Relationship
Design Products
M-1.03 M-2.03 Capture Orders M-3.03 Fulfill Orders
/ Processes
Deliver Service
M-3.04 and Support
Manage
M-3.05 Logistics
Network
24
M1 : Develop Products and
The Operational Vision Framework
Processes
Potential for
Characteristics of World Improvement in
Class Companies Ispat
25
M2 : Generate
The Operational Vision Framework
Demand
Generate Demand
Potential for
Improvement in
Characteristics of World Ispat
Class Companies
Sales management tools track product mix margin and contributions High
High
Tightly integrated marketing, business, research and operations plans
Iterative plan development tools perform “what if” analysis on market strategies High
26
M3 : Fulfill
The Operational Vision Framework
Demand
Fulfill
DemandDeliver Service and Support
Produce
Potential for
Improvement in
Characteristics of World Ispat
Class Companies
Customer specific performance goals and automatic tracking with exception reporting High
Advanced bar-coding and EDI for cross-docking /flow through distribution High
Target inventory levels based on total supply chain variability at the SKU level High
27
M4 : Plan and Manage the
The Operational Vision Framework
Enterprise
Potential for
Improvement in
Characteristics of World Ispat
Class Companies
28
Business Processes -
The Ispat Operational Vision Level 2
M-1.01 : Conduct
Research
Integrate
Define Research
M-1 M-2
Develop Products / Processes Generate Demand M-3 Fulfill Demand M-1.0103 M-1.0104 Strategic
Scope
M-1.01
Conduct
Research
M-2.01
Manage
Customer M-3.01
Manage Supply
Sourcing
Partners
Relationship
Conduct Basic
M-1.0105 M-1.0106 Advanced
Design
M-1.03 Products / M-2.03 Capture Orders M-3.03 Fulfill Orders
Processes
Research
M-3.04
Deliver Service Research
and Support
Manage Logistics
M-3.05
Network
M-4 Plan and Manage the Enterprise M-1.0107 Integrate Results M-1.0108 Apply Results
Manage
M-4.01 Manage M-4.02 Plan Enterprise M-4.03 Financial
Information Operations
29
Business Processes -
The Ispat Operational Vision Level 2
M-1.02 : Define
Product
Identify
Identify Channel
M-1 M-2
Develop Products / Processes Generate Demand M-3 Fulfill Demand M-1.0203 Manufacturing M-1.0204
Strategies
M-1.01
Conduct
Research
M-2.01
Manage
Customer M-3.01
Manage Supply
Sourcing
Strategies
Relationship
Manage Logistics
M-3.05
Network
Manage
M-4.04 Manage Human M-4.05 Implement M-4.06 Relations with
Resources Capital Projects
Stakeholders
Establish Project Track
M-1.0209 M-1.0210
Schedule Performance
30
Business Processes - Level 2
The Ispat Operational Vision M-1.03 : Design Products and
Processes
M-3.04
Deliver Service Support
and Support
Manage Logistics
M-3.05
Network
Trial Heat
M-1.0307 M-1.0308 Test Customers
M-4 Plan and Manage the Enterprise
Manage
Manage Production
M-4.01 M-4.02 Plan Enterprise M-4.03 Financial
Information Operations
Manage
M-4.04 Manage Human M-4.05 Implement M-4.06 Relations with
Resources Capital Projects
Stakeholders
Manage Product Track
M-1.0309 M-1.0310
traits Performance
31
Business Processes - Level 2
The Ispat Operational Vision M-2.01 : Manage Customer
Relations
Manage
Capture
M-1 M-2
Develop Products / Processes Generate Demand M-3 Fulfill Demand M-2.0103 Customer M-2.0104
Feedback
M-1.01
Conduct
Research
M-2.01
Manage
Customer M-3.01
Manage Supply
Sourcing
Inquiries
Relationship
Design
M-1.03 Products / M-2.03 Capture Orders M-3.03 Fulfill Orders
Processes
Deliver Service
M-3.04
and Support
Manage Logistics
M-3.05
Network
Manage
M-4.04 Manage Human M-4.05 Implement M-4.06 Relations with
Resources Capital Projects
Stakeholders
32
Business Processes -
The Ispat Operational Vision Level 2
M-2.02 : Create
Market
Execute
Introduce New
M-1 M-2
Develop Products / Processes Generate Demand M-3 Fulfill Demand M-2.0203 Marketing M-2.0204
Products
M-1.01
Conduct
Research
M-2.01
Manage
Customer M-3.01
Manage Supply
Sourcing
Campaign
Relationship
Educate Sales
M-2.0205
Design
M-1.03 Products / M-2.03 Capture Orders M-3.03 Fulfill Orders
Processes
/Customers
Deliver Service
M-3.04
and Support
Manage Logistics
M-3.05
Network
Manage
M-4.04 Manage Human M-4.05 Implement M-4.06 Relations with
Resources Capital Projects
Stakeholders
33
Business Process -
The Ispat Operational Vision Level 2
M-2.03 : Capture
Orders
Prepare Negotiate
M-2.0301 M-2.0302
Proposal/Quote Terms
Take/Close
M-1 M-2
Develop Products / Processes Generate Demand M-3 Fulfill Demand M-2.0303
Manage
Manage Supply
Order/Contract
Conduct
M-1.01 M-2.01 Customer M-3.01
Research Sourcing
Relationship
Design
M-1.03 Products / M-2.03 Capture Orders M-3.03 Fulfill Orders
Processes
Deliver Service
M-3.04
and Support
Manage Logistics
M-3.05
Network
Manage
M-4.04 Manage Human M-4.05 Implement M-4.06 Relations with
Resources Capital Projects
Stakeholders
34
Business Processes -
The Ispat Operational Vision Level 2
M-3.01 : Manage Supply
Sourcing
Establish
M-3.0101 Approve Supplier M-3.0102
Contract
Manage
M-1 M-2
Develop Products / Processes Generate Demand M-3 Fulfill Demand M-3.0103 M-3.0104 Purchase
Manage
Manage Supply
Partnership
Conduct
M-1.01 M-2.01 Customer M-3.01
Research Sourcing
Relationship
Track
M-3.0105 Accounts M-3.0106
Design
M-1.03 Products / M-2.03 Capture Orders M-3.03 Fulfill Orders
Processes
Performance
M-3.04
Deliver Service Payable
and Support
Manage Logistics
M-3.05
Network
Manage
M-4.04 Manage Human M-4.05 Implement M-4.06 Relations with
Resources Capital Projects
Stakeholders
35
Business Processes -
The Ispat Operational Vision Level 2
M-3.02 : Produce
M-3.02 Produce
Develop
M-3.0201 M-3.0202 Model Resources
Demand Plan
Develop Schedule
M-1 M-2
Develop Products / Processes Generate Demand M-3 Fulfill Demand M-3.0203 M-3.0204
Manage
Manage Supply
Production Plan Production
Conduct
M-1.01 M-2.01 Customer M-3.01
Research Sourcing
Relationship
Prepare for
M-3.0205 Reserve M-3.0206
Design
M-1.03 Products / M-2.03 Capture Orders M-3.03 Fulfill Orders
Processes
Production
M-3.04
Deliver Service Resource
and Support
Manage Logistics
M-3.05
Network
Manage
M-4.04 Manage Human M-4.05 Implement M-4.06 Relations with
Resources Capital Projects
Stakeholders
Maintain Track
M-3.0209 M-3.0210
Equipment Performance
36
Business Processes -
The Ispat Operational Vision Level 2
M-3.03 : Fulfill Orders
Manage Stock
M-3.0301 Creating Stock M-3.0302
Manage Despatch
M-1 M-2
Develop Products / Processes Generate Demand M-3 Fulfill Demand M-3.0303 M-3.0304
Manage
Manage Supply
Order Products
Conduct
M-1.01 M-2.01 Customer M-3.01
Research Sourcing
Relationship
Prepare
M-3.0305 M-3.0306 Bill Customers
Design
M-1.03 Products / M-2.03 Capture Orders M-3.03 Fulfill Orders
Processes
Invoices
Deliver Service
M-3.04
and Support
Manage Logistics
M-3.05
Network Manage Manage
M-4 Plan and Manage the Enterprise M-3.0307 Claims & M-3.0308 Accounts
Returns Receivable
Manage
M-4.01 Manage M-4.02 Plan Enterprise M-4.03 Financial
Information Operations
Manage
M-4.04 Manage Human M-4.05 Implement M-4.06 Relations with
Resources Capital Projects
Stakeholders
Track
M-3.0309
Performance
37
Business Processes -
The Ispat Operational Vision Level 2
M-3.04 : After Sales
Support
Manage Provide
M-1 M-2
Develop Products / Processes Generate Demand M-3 Fulfill Demand M-3.0403 Complaint M-3.0404 Services &
M-1.01
Conduct
Research
M-2.01
Manage
Customer M-3.01
Manage Supply
Sourcing
redressal Support
Centre
Relationship
Design
Track
M-1.03 Products / M-2.03 Capture Orders M-3.03 Fulfill Orders
M-3.0405
Processes
M-3.04
Deliver Service
and Support
Performance
Manage Logistics
M-3.05
Network
Manage
M-4.04 Manage Human M-4.05 Implement M-4.06 Relations with
Resources Capital Projects
Stakeholders
38
Business Processes - Level
The Ispat Operational Vision 2
M-3.05 : Manage Logistics
Network
Schedule
M-1 M-2
Develop Products / Processes Generate Demand M-3 Fulfill Demand
M-3.0503 M-3.0504 Receive Material
M-1.01
Conduct
Research
M-2.01
Manage
Customer M-3.01
Manage Supply
Sourcing
Receipts
Relationship
Design Maintain
M-1.03 Products /
Processes
M-2.03 Capture Orders M-3.03 Fulfill Orders
M-3.0505 Inventory M-3.0506 Schedule
M-3.04
Deliver Service
and Support Accuracy Dispatches
Manage Logistics
M-3.05
Network
Track
M-4 Plan and Manage the Enterprise
M-3.0507
M-4.01 Manage
Information
M-4.02 Plan Enterprise M-4.03
Manage
Financial
Operations
Performance
Manage
M-4.04 Manage Human M-4.05 Implement M-4.06 Relations with
Resources Capital Projects
Stakeholders
39
Business Processes -
The Ispat Operational Vision Level 2
M-4.01 : Manage
Information
Maintain Existing
M-4.0105
Design
M-1.03 Products / M-2.03 Capture Orders M-3.03 Fulfill Orders
Processes
Applications
Deliver Service
M-3.04
and Support
Manage Logistics
M-3.05
Network
Manage
M-4.04 Manage Human M-4.05 Implement M-4.06 Relations with
Resources Capital Projects
Stakeholders
40
Business Processes -
The Ispat Operational Vision Level 2
M-4.02 : Plan
Enterprise
Design Design
M-1 M-2
Develop Products / Processes Generate Demand M-3 Fulfill Demand M-4.0203 organisation M-4.0204 Relationships
M-1.01
Conduct
Research
M-2.01
Manage
Customer M-3.01
Manage Supply
Sourcing
structure Between Units
Relationship
Develop
M-4.0205 Organisational M-4.0206
Design
M-1.03 Products / M-2.03 Capture Orders M-3.03 Fulfill Orders
Processes
Strategic Plans
M-3.04
Deliver Service Goals
and Support
Manage Logistics
M-3.05
Network Develop Develop
M-4 Plan and Manage the Enterprise M-4.0207 Operational M-4.0208 Contingency
Plans Plans
Manage
M-4.01 Manage M-4.02 Plan Enterprise M-4.03 Financial
Information Operations
Manage
M-4.04 Manage Human M-4.05 Implement M-4.06 Relations with
Resources Capital Projects
Stakeholders
41
Business Processes - Level 2
The Ispat Operational Vision M-4.03 : Manage Financial
Operations
Manage Logistics
M-3.05
Network
Manage
M-4.0307 Support Costing M-4.0308
M-4 Plan and Manage the Enterprise
Manage
Manage Investments
M-4.01 M-4.02 Plan Enterprise M-4.03 Financial
Information Operations
Manage
M-4.04 Manage Human M-4.05 Implement M-4.06 Relations with
Resources Capital Projects
Stakeholders
42
Business Processes - Level
The Ispat Operational Vision 2
M-4.04 : Manage Human
Resources
M-1.02 Define Product M-2.02 Create Market M-3.02 Produce Manage Ensure
Employee Employee Well-
M-4.0405 M-4.0406
Design
M-1.03 Products / M-2.03 Capture Orders M-3.03 Fulfill Orders
Processes
Reward and Being and
M-3.04
Deliver Service
and Support Recognition Satisfaction
Manage Logistics
M-3.05
Network Ensure Manage Labour
M-4 Plan and Manage the Enterprise M-4.0407 Employee M-4.0408 Management
Involvement Relationships
Manage
M-4.01 Manage M-4.02 Plan Enterprise M-4.03 Financial
Information Operations
43
Business Processes - Level 2
The Ispat Operational Vision M-4.05 : Implement Capital
Projects
M-1.03
Design
Products /
Processes
M-2.03 Capture Orders M-3.03 Fulfill Orders Report Status 60
Deliver Service
M-4.0505 against action
M-3.04
and Support
plan
Manage Logistics
M-3.05
Network
Manage
M-4.04 Manage Human M-4.05 Implement M-4.06 Relations with
Resources Capital Projects
Stakeholders
44
Business Processes - Level 2
The Ispat Operational Vision M-4.05 : Manage Relations with
Stakeholders
Develop Public
Build Lender
M-1 M-2
Develop Products / Processes Generate Demand M-3 Fulfill Demand M-4.0603 M-4.0604 Relationship
Relationships
M-1.01
Conduct
Research
M-2.01
Manage
Customer M-3.01
Manage Supply
Sourcing
Programmes
Relationship
M-3.04
Deliver Service Directors Relations
and Support
Manage Logistics
M-3.05
Network Manage Legal
M-4 Plan and Manage the Enterprise M-4.0607 and Ethical
Issues
Manage
M-4.01 Manage M-4.02 Plan Enterprise M-4.03 Financial
Information Operations
Manage
M-4.04 Manage Human M-4.05 Implement M-4.06 Relations with
Resources Capital Projects
Stakeholders
45
Operational Vision
The Ispat Operational Vision M-1.01: Conduct
Research
46
Operational
Vision
The Ispat Operational Vision
M-1.02: Define
Product
Operational Potential approaches to
Vision getting there
Use 8-Gate Approach for developing products and Co-engineer the product with the customer
achieve : Use product line plans developed by only cross-
A 25% reduction in definition/design lead time functional teams
100% increase in customer satisfaction
Assign responsibility for customer satisfaction and
Improve product profitability by a minimum of product cost to the same cross-functional team
25%
Set up market aligned product development
Launch at least 2 new products every year teams where one person from each team is
Ensure 100% adherence to schedule and budgets responsible for the performance of that market
segment
Gather inputs from marketing, manufacturing,
Q = Completeness of
intermediaries and suppliers
definition Begin next generation product development
C = Cost to deliver
during current generation product cycle
Objective of this sub-process quality
D = Involvement of Develop cost, contribution and NSR targets up
partners
front
Define products and D = To design product
within specified Plan total product life cycle
processes that meet time limits
47
Operational Vision
The Ispat Operational Vision M-1.03: Design Products and
Processes
Q = % on-time to
specification,
C = Deliver quality at
Objective of this sub- total minimum
cost
process D = Reduced order
processing costs
D = % on time
Efficiently manage the M = Standard
procedures,
complete customer order to Continuous
cash cycle improvement
S = Turnover,
qualification of
staff
54
Operational Vision
The Ispat Operational Vision M-3.04 After Sales
Support
55
Operational Vision
The Ispat Operational Vision M-3.05 Manage Logistics
Network
57
Operational Vision
The Ispat Operational Vision M-4.02: Plan the
Enterprise
59
Operational Vision
The Ispat Operational Vision M-4.04: Manage Human
Resources
Q = Employee turnover
C = Personnel costs
D = Consonance between Attract, retain and develop
employees’ aspirations highly motivated talent both
and Company’s needs
D = Training days per new
Objective of this sub-process at entry level and in
hire specialized/ critical functions
M = Continuous 60
improvement
Operational Vision
The Ispat Operational Vision M-4.05: Implement Capital
Projects
Cos Qualit
t Reduce Costs y Put Quality First
Cost per concept developed per time period
Improvement in quality / reliability on account
Cost savings on account of new concepts incorporated
of new products / processes
Research budget as a percentage of total budget
Ideas researched that are incorporated into
designs per year (yield rate)
Cycle Interface
Time Compress Time
Service Focus on Customer
Percentage of R &D time spent gathering data Number of project failures due to the
Cycle time reduction on account of new implementation of unproven technologies
products / processes Percentage of R&D data gathered from a central
cross-functional enterprise wide repository
Number of new product offerings made possible
by internal R&D efforts
63
Key Performance
Indicators
Representative KPIs M-1.02 Define
Product
Q
Cos Qualit
t Reduce Costs y Put Quality First
Product line sales Customer product satisfaction ratings
Return on investment made in research
% of revenue generated from products
introduced in the last 2 years
Cycle Interface
Time Compress Time Service Focus on Customer
Time from initiation to release to development Number of new product introductions per year
(design/definition lead time) Bill of Material Accuracy
Break Even Time (BET); the time from when the Adherence to schedule and budget
initial product specifications are frozen until the
product shows a profit Average change orders to original Bill of
Material
64
Key Performance Indicators
Representative KPIs M-1.03 Design Products and
Processes
Q
Cos Qualit
t Reduce Costs y Put Quality First
Percent cost of defective design Percent of design completed electronically
Cost of defective design as a percent of net Percent of design simulated electronically
revenue/sales Average number of production defects in new
products
Cycle
Time Compress Time
65
Key Performance Indicators
Representative KPIs M-2.01 Manage Customer
Relationship
Q
Cos Qualit
t Reduce Costs y Put Quality First
Cost in identification of potential customer Quality Customer (taking Value added grades
and having long term contract)
Optimization of relationship maintenance cost
Percentage of handling customer inquiry
electronically and through e-sites
Quality of Personnel handling the Customer
inquiry
Cycle
Time Compress Time
66
Key Performance
Representative KPIs Indicators
M-2.02 Create Market
Q
Cos Qualit
t Reduce Costs y Put Quality First
Cost of introduction of new product development Percent of market information collected
Cost of execution of marketing campaign electronically
Percent of education provided to the customer
on application of steel
Average number of production defects in new
product
Cycle
Time Compress Time
67
Key Performance
Indicators
Representative KPIs M-2.03 Capture
Orders
Q
Cos Qualit
t Reduce Costs y Put Quality First
Percent cost of error in negotiating terms Percent of proposals and Quotes on e-sites
Cost of increased cycle time Average number of defects in proposals
/Quote /Negotiate terms
Cycle
Time Compress Time
68
Key Performance
Indicators
Representative KPIs M-3.01 : Manage Supply
Sourcing
Q
Cos Qualit
t Reduce Costs y Put Quality First
Material Cost/Sales Lost production due to material non-availability
% change in material cost annually % of all active suppliers that are approved
Purchasing overhead expense as a % of total % of material not confirming to specifications
purchase value % of Qty returned to supplier
Number of active suppliers (for A/B/C materials)
Cycle Interface
Time Compress Time
Service Focus on Customer
69
Key Performance
Representative KPIs Indicators
M-3.02 : Produce
Q
Cos Qualit
t y
Reduce Costs Put Quality First
% annual change in controllable plant costs % quality runs
Conversion cost / Sales % of process lines using computerised process
Inventory levels of WIP and stock of finished control
material Preventative maintenance hours/total
Maintenance cost/estimated replacement costs maintenance hours
Investment in safety-related facility Preventative maintenance schedule adherence
improvements/total plant operating costs rate
No. of days/hours without accidents Rejection rate %
Lost production due to unscheduled maintenance : Defects per million
lost production due to scheduled maintenance
Total rejection cost /total sales
Cost Per MT/ per employee
% of product wise complaints/ total sales
Maintenance cost/controllable plant costs
Number of plant/line shutdowns due to quality
Quality Claims Cost/ Sales (or COGS)
problems
Supervisory span of control (supervisor : workers)
Mean time between equipment failure
Capacity utilisation
MT of output per unit of labour input
70
Key Performance
Representative KPIs Indicators
M-3.02 : Produce
Cycle Interface
Time Compress Time
Service
Focus on Customer
Manufacturing lead time Adherence to production plans
Qty of Material waiting despatch % of employees cross-trained
Number of changes to production plans % of workforce participating in self-directed
Average lead time to prepare production for teams
new product % variation in production from plans
Set-up time Number of changes to the Master Schedule
Physical distance a product moves through the Backlog
factory % of worker time spent moving materials
% of orders delivered on time as per the Master Carry forward orders as a % of total orders
Schedule
Ratio of delivery time offered to customers to
Work-to-wait ratio actual manufacturing time
Plant performance units of output per hour
71
Key Performance
Indicators
Representative KPIs M-3.03 : Fulfill
Orders
Q
Cos Qualit
t y
Reduce Costs Put Quality First
Average delivery expenses per MT Percentage of electronically accepted /paperless
Average order processing expenses per MT orders
Order processing expenses/total sales
% advanced shipment notices that match order
Late delivery penalties/total shipping expenses
% on-time delivery of rush orders
Average insurance cost per value of shipment
% of bills accurately prepared
Average shipping and handling cost
Rupee value of merchandise shipped with quality
problems/total rupee value shipped
Accounts Receivable (value and days cover)
% of units shipped with quality problems
Value of discounts given
% of claims audited
Account write-offs/total sales
72
Key Performance
Indicators
Representative KPIs M-3.03 : Fulfill
Orders
Cycle Interface
Time Compress Time
Service
Focus on Customer
73
Key Performance
Indicators
Representative KPIs M-3.04 : After Sales
Support
Q
Cos Qualit
t Reduce Costs y Put Quality First
Complaint Claims / Sales Customer suggestion adoption rate
Average complaint claim cost per unit sold % of customer complaints resolved
Average cost per customer inquiry or call % of Quality Complains answered within target
time
Field service expense/total sales
% of customer complaints or inquiries resolved
No of customer complaints/No of customer
compliments
Average system downtime during business
hours
Cycle
% of customers receiving sales follow-up calls
Time Compress Time
% late customer complaint redressal
Time lag from identification of customer
problem to satisfactory action on problem
Customer service lead time
Mean time to repair product
74
Key Performance Indicators
M-3.05 : Manage Logistics
Representative KPIs Network
Q
Cos Qualit
t Reduce Costs y Put Quality First
Logistics costs/total material cost % of variations in schedules given to suppliers
Logistics transaction processing cost/total logistics cost Delivery frequency from suppliers
Material handling costs/total logistics cost % of receipts received on time
Material movement costs/total logistics cost
% of receipts at “point of usage”
% consumption above normative level
% of deliveries bar coded
Inventory carrying cost/total material cost
Storage cost /total inventory carrying costs
Inventory record accuracy by category/item
Inventory insurance cost/total inventory carrying costs Number of material shortages
Obsolete /slow moving /non moving inventory cost (value, % of unplanned material movements
insurance and warehouse space occupied)
Number of transporters used
Number of receipts and issues handled
75
Key Performance
Indicators
The Ispat Operational Vision M-4.01 Manage
Information
Q
Cos Qualit
t Reduce Costs y Put Quality First
IT budget as a % of total budget Accuracy of data
Consistency in data
Number of entities managing the same data
Cycle Interface
Time Compress Time Service Focus on Customer
Time taken by the department to deliver user % of employees having access to on-line
requirements computerised data
% of departments having access to on-line
computerised data
76
Key Performance
Indicators
Representative KPIs M-4.02 Plan the
Enterprise
Q
Cos Qualit
t Reduce Costs y Put Quality First
Performance against budget Number of processes with multiple owners
Number of instances of multiple reporting
relationships
Number of processes without owners
Cycle Interface
Time Compress Time Service Focus on Customer
Time between actual and targetted dates of Percentage variation in plans prepared by
freezing of the Sales plans Sales/Exports and APC
Time between actual and targetted dates of Percentage variation in plans prepared
freezing of the Production plans Number of different entities involved in the
planning process
Number of changes to plans prepared by
Sales/Marketing, Exports, PPIC, Corporate
Strategy etc
77
Key Performance Indicators
Representative KPIs M-4.03 Manage Financial
Operations
Q
Cos Qualit
t Reduce Costs y Put Quality First
Cost of the Finance function as a % of total income
Reporting accuracy
Cost of capital Number of reconciliations required between G/L
Interest expenses
and subsidiary ledgers
Write-offs on company assets
Variation in foreign exchange exposure
compared to policy
Costs of providing management reporting
Return on investments made
Accuracy of cash budgets (ie actual vs budgets)
Man-hours spent on keying / re-keying entries
on account of inadequate system integration
due to Excel spreadsheets usage
Cycle
Time Compress Time Interface
Number of days for year-end, quarterly and Service Focus on Customer
monthly closing
Time taken for budgeting exercise
Number of collections processed per person
Time between collections and posting of
collections
% of real time journal entry postings,
validations, approvals, balancing and error
Time taken to process and despatch payments correction
Duration of the capital planning process Variation between actual and desired values
Man-hours spent on manual account analysis taken by financial ratios
78
Key Performance
Indicators
Representative KPIs M-4.04 Manage Human
Resources
Q
Cos Qualit
t Reduce Costs y Put Quality First
Personnel costs Number of employees with quality certification
Overtime paid Percentage of workforce participating in
Absenteeism problem-solving groups
Man-hours per vehicle
Number of temporary workmen
Replacement costs per employee grade
Employee turnover
Supervisory New recruit turnover
Managerial
Executive
Cycle Interface
Time Compress Time
Service Focus on Customer
Suggestions submitted per employee
Average number of days between receipt of job
requisition and date of new hire Employee suggestion adoption rate
Interviewing time and testing time per new No of benchmarking studies conducted in last n
candidate periods
Training days per new hire % of appraisee feedback incorporated in final
evaluations
% of employees possessing cross-functional
skills
79
Key Performance Indicators
Representative KPIs M-4.05 Implement Capital
Projects
Q
Cos Qualit
t Reduce Costs y Put Quality First
Cost overruns against budgets Incidence of time overruns
Opportunity loss due to delay in implementing Incidence of budget overruns
Cycle Interface
Time Compress Time Service Focus on Customer
Time taken for implementation Accuracy of Status reporting
Delays in reporting information Time taken for generating status report
Acceptance of projects proposals
80
Key Performance Indicators
Representative KPIs M-4.06 Manage Relations with
Stakeholders
Q
Cos Qualit
t Reduce Costs y Put Quality First
Cost of compliance Number of government audits
Number of stakeholder enquiries
Number of compliance problems
Number of compliance inquiries
Cycle Interface
Time Compress Time Service Focus on Customer
Time taken to prepare information needs of Service level for investor satisfaction
stakeholders Dividend paid to investors
Delays in reporting information Service level for government compliance
81
Reasons for
Cascading the Vision Cascading
Why
Cascade?
82
Cascading the Vision Approaches to Cascadin
Level 1 ED (M)
target Level 1 ED (M) target
(eg Marketing Dept) (eg Marketing Dept)
Level 2 President Level 2 President Level 2 President Level 2 President Level 2 President Level 2 President
(eg Domestic Mkt.) (eg Mkt. Strategy) (eg Exports) target (eg Domestic Mkt.) (eg Mkt. Strategy) (eg Exports)
target
Level 3 V P Level 3 V P Level 3 G M Level 3 V P Level 3 V P Level 3 G M
eg (Customer Servicing) (eg NPD) (eg Market Research) eg (Customer Servicing) (eg NPD) (eg Market Research)
target
Level 4 Sr. Manager Level 4 Sr. Manager Level 4 Sr. Manager Level 4 Sr. Manager Level 4 Sr. Manager Level 4 Sr. Manager
(eg V AG) (eg Cold Rolling) (eg Break Through) (eg V AG) (eg Cold Rolling) (eg Break Through) target
Each level sets targets for the levels Each level sets its own targets based on
below it, :
keeping in view the overall target Knowledge about its own
capability/processes
Aggregating targets set by levels below
83 it
Approaches to
Cascading the Vision Cascading
Description of Approach
TOP-DOWN APPROACH Set target levels for the vision elements at the
lowest operating levels
Aggregate targets one level up at a time till the
Description of Approach level at which the vision target has been set is
reached
Break up the vision target to relevant and
meaningful targets for one level below Compare the aggregated target with the vision
Repeat the process of splitting targets till targets
target set out
are set at the lowest possible operating level Review and iterate the operating level targets
Agree targets at each level with concerned till the aggregated value matches the vision
people target
Pre-requisites Pre-requisites
Managers need to be willing to set ambitious but Operating personnel need to be willing and
achievable targets for their juniors capable of setting ambitious but achievable
Advantages targets for themselves
Lower number of iterations required Advantages
The focus on the end result is never lost Greater acceptance at the operating levels
Challenges Challenges
Possible difficulty in gaining acceptance for such Iterative process could be time-consuming
targets at the lower levels Level of computational effort is higher
BOTTOM-UP APPROACH
84
Cascading the Vision Top - Down Approach
N
9. Finalise targets,
time frames, Y
information flow and 6. Determine target
responsibilities performance levels one rung
7. Confirm with below the level at which the
8. Determine time operating mangers at target vision is set; continue
frames and each level that targets to set targets one level at a
responsibilities for set are feasible and time for all levels
targets achievable
85
Cascading the Vision Bottom - Up Approach
9. Finalise targets, N
time frames,
information flow and Y
responsibilities 6. Aggregate current and
7. Check if target levels of
8. Determine time aggregated target performance till the
frames and for vision element performance measure for
responsibilities for equals desired the vision element is
targets value obtained
86
Cascading the Vision Issues in Cascading
87
Cascading the Vision Issues in Cascading
ading efforts could vary significantly from one vision element to another..... consequen
ollowing could vary across vision elements
Success in
Cascading
88
Issues in Cascading
Cascading the Vision M1: Develop Products and Processes
Define Product Design lead time 25% Medium High Medium Medium Medium High High
Customer satisfaction levels 100% High High High High High High High
Product profitability 25% Medium High Medium Medium High High High
New products per year 2 Medium Medium Medium Low Medium High High
Adherence to schedule and budgets 100% Low High Low Medium Medium High High
Design Products and Number of Design Modification 0 Low Medium Low Medium High High High
Processes Requests after a launch
Cost of customer claims 100% Low High Medium Medium Medium High High
Manufacturing lead time in the 2 years 25% Medium Medium Medium Medium High High High
following a new product release
1 : Definition Problems
2 : Current Data Availability
3 : Ease of Measurement
4 : Ease of Aggregation
5 : Number of Entities Involved
6 : Determining Responsibility Centres
7 : Level of External Interaction
Likelihood of difficulties in cascading the vision
due to poor data availability, inadequate
measurement mechanisms and dependence on a
large number of external agencies
89
Issues in Cascading
Cascading the Vision M3.2: Produce
Vision Element Vision Target Direction Difficulty Level in Cascading
to be (High/ Medium/ Low)
taken by
vision
element
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Hot metal production >5000 MT/day Low Low Low Medium High Medium Low
Hot Metal Cost $275/MT by FY2010 Medium Low High High High Medium Low
SMS Production >48Heats /Day High Low High Medium High Medium Low
SMS Yield >87% Low Low High Medium Medium Medium Low
Caster 1 speed 6.2 meters/Minute by Low Low High High High High Low
FY 2010
Mill production 2.5 Lacs per month Medium Low High Medium High High Low
MTBC 3.2minutes by FY 2010 Medium Medium High High Medium High Medium
HRC Cost $ 350/ MT by FY 2010 Low High High Medium High High Low
DRI Production 1.8 lacs tonnes by Low High High High High High Medium
Plant Reliability 2009
>95% Low High High High High High Medium
Unplanned downtime <5% Low Low High High Medium High Medium
Maintainence cost $ 100/MT Low Medium High Medium High High Low
1 : Definition Problems
2 : Current Data Availability
3 : Ease of Measurement
4 : Ease of Aggregation
5 : Number of Entities Involved
Cascading the vision could be difficult on account 6 : Determining Responsibility Centres
of the 7 : Level of External Interaction
number of entities involved and identifying
responsibilities for activities
90
Issues in Cascading
Cascading the Vision M3.5: Manage Logistics Network
1 : Definition Problems
2 : Current Data Availability
3 : Ease of Measurement
4 : Ease of Aggregation
5 : Number of Entities Involved
6 : Determining Responsibility Centres
7 : Level of External Interaction
91
Monitoring Mechanisms Monitoring Requirements
92
Monitoring Mechanisms Monitoring Levels
93
Monitoring Mechanisms Monitoring Frequency
Formal periodic monitoring would be necessary at four levels as per the following
schedule :
MD Quarterly
Need to establish
monitoring
schedules for
each vision
element
94
Monitoring Mechanisms Summary of Reporting Mechanisms
What do they
report
Who reports to whom
Performance in the current period against
Various individuals and sections contributing to targets
vision element to the vision element owner
Steps taken towards meeting targets
Vision element owner to sub-process owner
Results of successfully executed steps
Sub-process owner to process owner
Process owner to MD
Issues faced on unsuccessfully executed steps
and means planned/taken to resolve them
Workplan to meet vision element targets (steps
to be undertaken, timeframes and
responsibilities)
Issues requiring attention/intervention
Sub-Process Owner,
Hot Strip Mill
Vision Element
Level Performance
Process Owner
Fulfil Demand
Sub- Process
level Performance
VE VE VE VE VE VE VE VE VE VE VE VE VE VE VE
1 2 n 1 2 n 1 2 n 1 2 n 1 2 n
V Vision element
E
Managing Director
Process
Level Performance
M1 M2 M3 M4
Develop Products Generate Demand Fulfil Demand Plan and Manage
and Processes the Enterprise
M1 M1 M1 M2 M2 M2 M3 M3 M3 M4 M4 M4
.1 .2 .3 .1 .2 .4 VE
.1
VE VE
.2 .5 .1 .2 .5
VE VE VE VE VE VE VE VE VE VE VE VE VE VE VE VE VE VE
VE VE VE VE VE VE VE VE VE 1 2 n VE VE VE
1 1 1 2 n 1 1 2 n 1 2 n 1 2 n 1 2 n VE VE VE
1 2 n 2 n 2 n 2 n 1 2 n
1 2 n
To focus the entire company on achieving the Operational Vision, we must rethink the
way we measure and reward behaviour
• Measure company-wide
bottom line impact
Customer Satisfaction
Return on Assets
Employee
Satisfaction...
Value Servic
e
101
Architecting the Change Integrated Performance Measuremen
Business
Objectives Metrics are linked to business
objectives and critical success
factors
Metrics are process-focused,
Success focusing on business outcomes as
Factors opposed to functional viewpoints
Supply Suite of metrics are balanced,
Chain supporting simultaneous
optimisation of cost, quality and
Dolvi Plant Performance
time
Metrics
Process owner controls
Process
achievement of metrics
Lower levels of metrics are
Sub-process telescoped into higher levels (ie
are consistent with and support the
Group higher levels)
Metrics are integrated into
Individual incentive programs and reward
structures
102
Architecting the Change Integrated Performance Measuremen
- Sponsorship Actions -
Establish performance measurement
approach and improvement goals
Actively sponsor measurement and other
improvement programs
Assign responsibility for measurement to
Program Executive standards
Management Leadership Lead efforts to integrate metrics and targets
into incentive and reward programs
Collaborate with stakeholders to set
Enablement aggressive yet achievable targets
Business
• People Ownership Actively monitor metrics, improvements and
• Process improvement programs
• Technology Recognize successes and challenge and
support areas of shortcoming
Lead organizational behaviour changes that
result in consistently managing to address
critical success factors and better meeting
improvement goals
103
Managing Change
Architecting the Change Our Approach to Change
Management
Sense of• Make sure change support resources are available after implementation
Urgency
• Build consensus and commitment to change; start at the top
104
Architecting the Change Managing Change
Framework for Managing Change
Planning for and managing the move from Sponsorship of change by key executives,
the “as is” organisation to the desired illustrating to the entire organisation
“to be” state management’s commitment to the change
effort
Program Executive
Managemen Leadership
t
Enablemen Business
Critical products developed that t Ownership Ownership and commitment to change
provide individuals and the organisation Projects experienced by all individuals throughout
with knowledge, skills, tools, frameworks the organisation
and support to perform their work successfully
105
Architecting the Change The Recipe for Success
106
Potential
Benefits
From To
Jobs Narrow Multi-dimensional
Organization Hierarchy Team
Orientation Function Process
Customer Inconvenience Reason for existence
Front Line Employee Manual labourer Mission critical
Manager Supervisor resource
Executive Bookkeeper Coach
Priority Activity Leader
Measures Financial Result
Focus Internal Operational
Values Protective Customer
Productive
The end result of an effective business transformation initiative is a business unit
whose people, processes and technology are working together to meet the
organization's strategic objectives
107
Next
Steps
contd...
108
Cascading the Vision Next Steps
109