Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
BULK BREAKING
SPATIAL CONVENIENCE
ASSORTMENT/ VARIETY
OTHER SOD(s)
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
INSTRUCTIONS: If quantitative marketing-research data are available to enter numerical ratings in each cell, this should be done. If not, an intuitive ranking can be imposed by noting for each segment whether demand for the given service output is high, medium, or low.
25 16 20
10 6 3 6 10 3 1 100
14
4
10 18
8
32
10 8 1 100
15 29 11
100
12 10 15
100
% Respondents
16%
13%
61%
= Additional Important Attributes
10%
IDEAL CHANNEL SYSTEM FOR B2B SEGMENTS BUYING A NEW HIGH-TECH PRODUCT
Manufacturer (New High Technology Product)
Associations, Events, Awareness Efforts TeleSales/ TeleMktg Internal Support - Install, Training & Service Group ThirdParty Supply Outsource
Full-Service
Responsive Support
References/ Credentials
Source: Reprinted with permission of Rick Wilson, Chicago Strategy Associates, 2000.
Range of Service Outputs Demanded Purchase process easy to find, select & buy Purchases are delivered to home Information on product usage/ needs planning Fast and efficient buying process Information on comparing and choosing Ability to see, touch and inspect products Absolute lowest prices Experience provides social interaction Place sells specific brands desired Percent who are heavy Internet users
Segment's Relative Importance of Service Output "Branded Products "Low "Fast/Efficient Delivered" Price/Comparisons" Purchase Process" HIGH HIGH Moderate VERY HIGH Low HIGH Moderate Low HIGH Low VERY HIGH Low Low VERY HIGH Low HIGH Low Low Moderate 31%
Source: 2000 Chicago Strategy Associates. Used with permission of Rick Wilson.
Low Price and Efficiency Segments Importance of home delivery in creating ideal grocery shopping experience
1.8
7.4
Improvement in having groceries delivered to your home would make shopping more ideal
3.8
6.7
Source: 2000 Chicago Strategy Associates. Used with permission of Rick Wilson.
Ease of initiating transactions and transfers between fund families and consequent transfer costs High
Varies
High
High
Low
Varies
Medium
High
High
High
Unsophisticated Investor
Low
Low
High
High
Source: Carmichael, Trent, Bill Norris, Rob Rozwat, and Emiko Taguchi (1996), "Charles Schwab OneSource: Channel Audit." Used with permission of the authors.
SCHWAB: SERVICE OUTPUTS SUPPLIED BY DIFFERENT CHANNELS FOR THE MUTUAL FUND INDUSTRY
Bulk-Breaking Spatial Convenience Delivery/Wait Time Assortment/ Variety Pre-Sale Service
Ease of initiating transactions and transfers between fund families and consequent transfer costs Low
Initiation/ execution time (including between fund families) High (within family) Low (between families)
Medium/High
Low
Low
Low
Medium/High
High
High
High
High
High
Low
Source: Carmichael, Trent, Bill Norris, Rob Rozwat, and Emiko Taguchi (1996), "Charles Schwab OneSource: Channel Audit." Used with permission of the authors.
Physical Possession Ownership Promotion Negotiation Producers Financing Risking Ordering Payment Wholesalers
Physical Possession Ownership Promotion Negotiation Financing Risking Ordering Payment Retailers
Physical Possession Ownership Promotion Negotiation Financing Risking Ordering Payment Consumers Industrial and Household
The arrows above show flows of activity in the channel (e.g. physical possession flows from producers to wholesalers to retailers to consumers).
Manufacture r
Title Function
Suppliers Manufacturer
Transporter s Warehouse s
Dealers
Transporters
Custome r
Dealers
Suppliers
Payment Function
Custome r Banks
Banks
Manufacture r
Banks
Dealer s
Information Function
Suppliers Transporter s Warehouse s Banks Advertising Agency Manufacture r Transporter s Warehouse s Banks Advertising Agency Dealer s Transporter s Banks
Custome r
Customer
Promotion Function
Suppliers
Manufacture r
Dealer s
Custome r 12
Each flow carries a cost. Some examples of costs of various flows are given below:
Marketing Flow Physical possession Ownership Promotion Cost Represented Storage and delivery costs Inventory carrying costs Personal selling, advertising, sales promotion, publicity, public relations costs, trade show costs
Time and legal costs Credit terms, terms and conditions of sale Price guarantees, returns allowances, warranties, insurance, repair, and after-sale service costs
Ordering Payment
Promotion
Negotiation
(a) CDW-G started a small-business consortium in 2003 to help small firms compete more effectively for federal IT contracts. What CDW-G gives the small biz partner: lower prices on computers than they could otherwise get; business leads; and access to CDWs help desk and product tools; CDW also handles shipping and billing, reducing the small biz partners channel flow burden. What the small biz partner provides: access to contracts CDW could not otherwise get. (a) CDW collects receivables in just 32 days; CDW turns its inventories 2x per month; CDW has no debt. (a) Were a kind of chief technical officer for many smaller firms: (b) In April 2004, CDW was authorized as a Cisco Systems Premier (CSP) partner, in serving the commercial customer market.
Financing
Risking
ACTIVITY:
1. Shopper connects to Peapod system: shops Places order Specifies 90-minute delivery window 2. Peapod server receives order, places in queue to shop 3. Order is transmitted to professional Peapod shoppers in the Jewel food store
FLOW (performer):
ORDERING (shopper)
ORDERING (Peapod)
4. Order is shopped inside Jewel food store* *Out-of-stocks are replaced with second choice if shopper has specified one during the online shopping step.
Example 2: PEAPOD SHOPPING AND FULFILLMENT PROCESS: ORIGINAL CHANNEL STRUCTURE ACTIVITY: FLOW (performer):
FINANCING (Jewel Peapod) RISKING (Jewel Peapod) OWNERSHIP (Jewel Peapod) PAYMENT (Peapod Jewel) PHYSICAL POSSESSION (Peapod) OWNERSHIP (Peapod) RISKING (Peapod)
7. Peapod delivery person delivers order to shopper:** unloads bags at shopper's door accepts payment accepts coupons (if any) ** If errors are discovered in the order, Peapod assumes responsibility for correcting them.
PHYSICAL POSSESSION (Peapod Shopper) OWNERSHIP (Peapod Shopper) PAYMENT (Shopper Peapod)
PHYSICAL POSSESSION (Shopper) OWNERSHIP (Shopper) 8. Shopper unloads and puts away groceries
Example 3: SCHWAB: IDENTITIES AND ROLES OF COMPANIES INVOLVED IN PRODUCING MUTUAL FUNDS
Investment Advisor (product design) Fund Administrator (management, administrative services to fund) Mutual Fund Family ("Producer") Fund Distributor (underwriting, manages the marketing and promotion functions)
Flows Performed by Various Entities: Investment Advisor: promotion (through portfolio design) Fund Administrator: negotiation (through management of administrative processes) Fund Distributor: promotion (through performance of selling and marketing tasks) Custodian: physical possession, risking (through responsibility for safekeeping of shares) Transfer Agent: ordering, payment (through responsibility for processing orders and recording share purchases/redemptions)
Transfer Agent (maintain records of fund ownership, process and record share purchases and redemptions)
Intermediaries:
Brokers
Retail Bank
Consumers:
Do-It-Yourself Investor
Consumption
Customer
Retailers
Wholesalers
Manufacturers
Suppliers
PHYSICAL POSSESSION* * OWNERSHIP PROMOTION NEGOTIATION FINANCING RISKING ORDERING PAYMENT TOTAL NORMATIVE PROFIT SHARE*** 100 N/A N/A N/A 100 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
100
* Entries in column must add up to 100 points. ** Entries across row (sum of proportional flow performance of channel members 1 through 4) for each channel member must add up to 100 points. *** Normative profit share of channel member i is calculated as: (final weight, physical possession)*(channel member i's proportional flow performance of physical possession) + + (final weight, payment)*(channel member i's proportional flow performance of payment). Entries across row (sum of normative profit shares for channel members 1 through 4) must add up to 100 points.
TABLE 3.APP3A-1 BUILDING MATERIALS COMPANY EFFICIENCY TEMPLATE FOR CHANNEL SERVING END-USERS THROUGH RETAILERS: (UNDISGUISED DATA)
WEIGHTS FOR FLOWS: COSTS BENEFIT POTENTIAL (High, Medium, or Low) High FINAL WEIGHT PROPORTIONAL FLOW PERFORMANCE OF CHANNEL MEMBER: Mfgr. Retailer End-user (Contractors) TOTAL
PHYSICAL POSSESSI ON OWNERSHIP PROMOTION NEGOTIATION FINANCING RISKING ORDERING PAYMENT TOTAL NORMATIVE PROFIT SHARE
30
35
30
30
40
100
12 10 5 25 5 6 7 100 N/A
15 8 4 29 2 3 4 100 N/A
30 20 20 30 30 20 20 N/A 28%
40 80 60 30 50 60 60 N/A 39%
30 0 20 40 20 20 20 N/A 33%*
TABLE 3.APP3A-2 BUILDING MATERIALS COMPANY EFFICIENCY TEMPLATE FOR CHANNEL SERVING END-USERS THROUGH RETAILERS: RANKORDER DATA (0-3)
WEIGHTS FOR FLOWS: COSTS BENEFIT POTENTIAL (High, Medium, or Low) High Medium Low Low/Medium Medium Low Low Low N/A N/A FINAL WEIGHT PROPORTIONAL FLOW PERFORMANCE OF CHANNEL MEMBER: Mfgr. Retailer End-user (Contractors) TOTAL
PHYSICAL POSSESSION OWNERSHIP PROMOTION NEGOTIATION FINANCING RISKING ORDERING PAYMENT TOTAL NORMATIVE PROFIT SHARE
30 12 10 5 25 5 6 7 100 N/A
35 15 8 4 29 2 3 4 100 N/A
2 2 1 1 2 2 1 1 N/A ?
2 2 3 2 2 2 2 2 N/A ?
2 2 0 1 2 1 1 1 N/A ?
100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 N/A 100
TABLE 3.APP3A-3 BUILDING MATERIALS COMPANY EFFICIENCY TEMPLATE FOR CHANNEL SERVING END-USERS THROUGH RETAILERS : TRANSFORMED RANK-ORDER DATA
WEIGHTS FOR FLOWS: COSTS BENEFIT POTENTIAL (High, Medium, or Low) High Medium Low Low/Medium Medium Low Low Low N/A N/A FINAL WEIGHT PROPORTIONAL FLOW PERFORMANCE OF CHANNEL MEMBER: Mfgr. Retailer End-user TOTAL
PHYSICAL POSSESSION OWNERSHIP PROMOTION NEGOTIATION FINANCING RISKING ORDERING PAYMENT TOTAL NORMATIVE PROFIT SHARE
30 12 10 5 25 5 6 7 100 N/A
35 15 8 4 29 2 3 4 100 N/A
33 33 25 25 33 40 25 25 N/A 32%
33 33 75 50 33 40 50 50 N/A 38%
33 33 0 25 33 20 25 25 N/A 29%
100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 N/A 100