14 3 2011

1998

14
3
2011

CA&CC Press

 14
3 2011

: 620720-0459

: M-770

CA&CC Press.
: 556699-5964
: 22 339

/: (994 - 12) 497 12 22 E-mail: elis@tdb.baku.az

/: (46) 920 62016 E-mail: m.esenov@gmail.com

/: (994 - 12) 596 11 73 E-mail: jeyvazov@gmail.com
()
/: (+7 - 701) 531 61 46 E-mail: timur-cac@mail.ru
()
.: (+996 - 312) 65-48-33 E-mail: lbondarets@mail.ru
()
.: (992 - 917) 72 81 79 E-mail: madzamila@mail.ru
()
.: (998 - 71) 125 43 22 E-mail: farkhad_tolipov@yahoo.com
()
: (+994 - 50) 3006694 E-mail: ziken12@yahoo.co.uk
()
: (374 - 10) 56 59 65 E-mail: haroutiun@gmail.com
()
.: (+995 - 95) 45 82 88 E-mail: kakha_ae@yahoo.com
()
.: (972) 2 5882332 E-mail: mssamed@olive.mscc.huji.ac.il
()
.: (49 - 89) 3003132 E-mail: GA-infoservice@s.m.isar.de
()
.: (86) 10-64039088 E-mail: sunzhzh@isc.cass.net.cn
()
. (7 - 495) 3163146 E-mail: egorova@mosinfo.ru

(, -)
.: (716) 880-2104 E-mail: robert.g.tian@medaille.edu
()
.: (380-44) 524279 13 E-mail: zhangozha@yahoo.co.uk

14 3 2011

, ,
()
, ()
,
( )
, ,
()
, , -
()
()
,
()
, ,
,
()
, , ,

. .. ,
( )
, ,
()
, ()
, ()
()
,
()
,
()
,
- ( )
,
()
, ,
()
, ,
( )
, ,
()
, , - ,
()
,
. c ()
, ()
, ,

()

, ,

:
CA&CC Press AB
Hubertusstigen 9. 97455 Lule
SWEDEN
: www.ca-c.org

, 2011
CA&CC Press, 2011

 14 3 2011

-
14
3
2011

. ,
. .

:
............................................ 7

. ,
. .

:

................................................... 21

. ,
. ,
. ,
. .
. .

........................................................ 33

-
-
................................................................. 46
4

14 3 2011

. .

.................................................................. 53

. .

:
..................... 73

. .

............................ 90

. .

............................................... 104

. .

:
, , ....................... 120

. .

........................................................................ 132

. .

:

,
................................................... 146

. .

............................................ 159

. .

....................................................................... 171
5

 14 3 2011

. .

( ) ........................................................................ 183

. .

:
.............................. 197

. ,
. .

........................... 207

14 3 2011

-


(, )
-


(, )

.
?

()

. ,

, -

, . ,
,
.

1
Contesting
Danger: A New Agenda for Policy and Scholarship on Central Asia // International Affairs (London), May 2011,
Vol. 87, No. 3. P. 589612. .

 14 3 2011

: - ?
,
,
,

.
,
, ,
,
. ,
, ,
, , ,
.
,
. - .

.
n

, ,
.
.
n

-,
, .

,
.

.

, ;

, . :
,
-.
,
,


,

.

-, , -

, . , .
, , ,
,
2. 2

Agnew J. Geopolitics: Re-Visioning World Politics. London: Routledge, 2003. P. 3.

14 3 2011

, .
. (18611947). , , .
, , 3, ,
4.
, .
, .
,
.
, , , , ,
, .. . O
. , 5.
,
, ,
. : ,
, , .

, ,
, , .
XIX
.

, .
6. - ,
Ibid. P. 5.
Dodds K. Geopolitics in the Foreign Office: British Representations of Argentina 19451961 // Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 1994, Vol. 19, No. 3. P. 276.
5
Tuathail G., Dalby S. Introduction: Rethinking Geopolitics: Towards a Critical Geopolitics. .: Rethinking Geopolitics / Ed. by G. Tuathail, S. Dalby. London: Routledge, 1998. P. 5.
6
Hambly G., Bennigsen A., Bivar D., Carrre dEncausse H., Hajianpur M., Lamb A., Lemercier-Quelquejay Ch.,
Pierce R. Central Asia. London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 1969. P. 241242.
3
4

 14 3 2011

7, 8.
1990- . , . , - . , . ,
, , , , , , 9. , ,
.
Calming the Ferghana Valley ( )10, 1999
. ,
.

. 2000
Calming the Ferghana Valley .
(Center for Preventive Action) 11. 2005 ,
Central Asian
Survey ( ) 12. ,

.
2007
Communist
and Post-Communist Studies ( ) . .
Conflict and Conflict Resolution in Central Asia: Dimensions and Challenges (Soviet Central Asia: The Failed Transformation / Ed. by W. Fierman. Boulder, Westview, 1991.
Bennigsen A., Broxup M. The Islamic Threat to the Soviet State. London: Croom Helm, 1983.
9
Fuller G. Central Asia: The Quest for Identity // Current History, 1994, Vol. 93, No. 582. P. 149.
10
.: Rubin B., Lubin N. Calming the Ferghana Valley: Development and Dialogue in the Heart of Central
Asia. Report of the Ferghana Valley Working Group of the Center for Preventive Action. New York: Century
Foundation, 1999.
11
.: Megoran N. Calming the Ferghana Valley Experts. A Review Essay of Calming the Ferghana Valley: Development and Dialogue in the Heart of Central Asia by Nancy Lubin, Barnett Rubin, and the Center
for Preventive Action. New York: The Century Foundation Press, 1999 // Central Asia Monitor, Vol. 2000, No. 5.
P. 2025.
12
Discourses of Danger in Central Asia / Ed. by J. Heathershaw, S. Torjesen // Central Asian Survey, 2005,
Vol. 24, No. 1. P. 196.
7
8

10

14 3 2011

: ).
. . , ,
, ,
,
13.
. : , , , ; , ,
; .
. , .
, .
,
. , , . , ,
, , , , .

14. , ,
,
. ,
. , ,
,
. . , .
15
16. . , , .
13
Sandole D. Central Asia: Managing the Delicate Balance between the Discourse of Danger, the Great
Game and Regional Problem Solving // Communist and Post-Communist Studies, 2007, Vol. 40, No. 2. P. 260261.
14
.: Megoran N. The Critical Geopolitics of the Uzbekistan-Kyrgyzstan Ferghana Valley Boundary Dispute, 19992000 // Political Geography, 2004, Vol. 23, No. 6. P. 731764.
15
.: Lewis D. The Temptations of Tyranny in Central Asia. London: Hurst and Company, 2008.
16
Collins K., Wohlforth W. Central Asia: Defying Great Game Expectations. .: Strategic Asia 2003
2004: Fragility and Crisis / Ed. by R.J. Ellings, A.L. Friedberg. Seattle, Washington: National Bureau of Asian Research, 2003. P. 291317.

11

 14 3 2011

, .
- , , , .
,
17.
19962006 . (
). 1520 , , , 18. , , , , , 19. , .
, ,
, , 20.
, . ,
,
.
.
: , .
( , 11 , 10 2001 .).
, ( ),
,
( ),
. , ,
:
: , , .
17
.: Brzezinski Z. The Grand Chessboard: American Primacy and its Geostrategic Imperatives. New
York: Basic Books, 1997; Starr S.F. Making Eurasia Stable // Foreign Affairs, 1996, Vol. 75, No. 1. P. 8092 (.
: Edwards M. The New Great Game and the New Great Gamers: Disciples of Kipling and Mackinder // Central Asian Survey, 2003, Vol. 22, No. 1. P. 83102).
18
Elber L. West Wing at Ratings Crossroads // Associated Press, 22 October 2002 [http://
b4a.healthyinterest.net/news/000172.html], 31 July 2009.
19
.: ( ).
20
Philpott S., Mutimer D. Inscribing the American Body Politic: Martin Sheen and Two American Decades //
Geopolitics, 2005, Vol. 10. P. 338.

12

14 3 2011

: , , -
: - !

, , ,
, - , ,
, .
,
. , , ,
- , , .
. ,
,
, , ,
.
, . -
, .
- , , ,
.

2005/2006 . (
) . , ( ,
!) (
). , 150-
, .
- .. ( ) : -
.
: , ,
. , . , .
, :
. , , 2005 : . , 13

 14 3 2011

, .
, . .

, . 21. ,
, , , , 22. , .
,
,
, .
, , , / .
,
23.
. 24, , . , 25.
,
, ,
.
11 2001
- .
- . 21
22

2002.

.: Said E. Orientalism. New York: Vintage, 1979.

.: Myer W. Islam and Colonialism: Western Perspectives on Soviet Asia. London: Routledge/Curzon,

23
.: MacFarlane S.N. The United States and Regionalism in Central Asia // International Affairs, 2004,
Vol. 80, No. 3. P. 447461.
24
Lovelace D. Foreword. .: Strategic Consequences of the Iraq War: US Security Interests in Central
Asia Reassessed / Ed. by E. Wishnick. US Army War College: SSI. P. iii.
25
Giragosian R. The Strategic Central Asian Arena // China and Eurasia Forum Quarterly, 2006, Vol. 4, No. 1.
P. 133.

14

14 3 2011

,
11
, 26. 11
. () -,
.
. , , , ,
, 27.

. 2005 .
(. . 1).
1999 (). , . . , ,
, , , , ,
28.
-
. -
. ( , ,
/, ), 29. ,

, ,
30. , , 31. ,
. , 26
Paraphrasing of Jones Testimony. .: Strategic Consequences of the Iraq War: US Security Interests in
Central Asia Reassessed. P. 4.
27
Hill F. The United States and Russia in Central Asia: Uzbekistan, Tajikistan, Afghanistan, Pakistan, and
Iran, 15 August 2002 // Brookings, 13 July 2001 [http://www.brookings.edu/speeches/2002/0815russia_hill.aspx].
28
.: Plater-Zyberk H. Tajikistan: Waiting for a Storm? // Central Asia Series, Conflict Studies Research
Centre, London, May 2004, Vol. 4, No. 13.
29
Barnett Th. The Pentagons New Map: War and Peace in the Twenty-First Century. New York: Berkeley
Books, 2004. .: . // , 2004,
3 [http://globalaffairs.ru/number/n_3225].
30
Seiple Ch. Uzbekistan: Civil Society in the Heartland // Orbis, Spring 2005. P. 246.
31
.: Rumsfeld D. Annual Report to the President and to Congress. Washington: Department of Defense,
2002 [http://www.nti.org/e_research/official_docs/dod/2002/81502DOD.pdf], July 2009. P. 11.

15

 14 3 2011

1972

: [http://www.state.
gov/p/sca/ci/], 13 2011.

16

14 3 2011

, ,
.
. , , . ,
, . XXI
, , 2010 .

, - 2005
32. ,
, , , .

-
- - , , , . ,
.
1990- , . 33, ,
,
, 34. , - , ,
. -
, - . , ,
.

()35. ,
, ,
32
.: , .
, 2005.
33
Clem R.S. The New Central Asia: Prospects for Development. .: Geography and Transition in the
Post-Soviet Republics / Ed. by M.J. Bradshaw. Chichester: John Wiley and Sons, 1997. P. 171172.
34
Kaiser R. The Geography of Nationalism in Russia and the USSR. Princeton: Princeton University Press,
1994. P. 370371.
35
.: Asankanov A. Ethnic Conflict in the Osh Region in Summer 1990: Reasons and Lessons. .: Ethnicity and Power in the Contemporary World / Ed. by K. Rupesinghe, V. Tishkov. Paris: United Nations University, 1996.

17

 14 3 2011

36. , ,
37,
.
2010 (. ).

1990- 2000- .
.
1998
. - ,
, , . ,
,
, , ,
, . .
38.
.
,
- .
39, 40, 41. , ,
. ,
. 2010 .
, (19912005 .) : ,
.
(20052010 .) ,
, , , . ,
.
,
, ,
, . . , , ,
Haghayeghi M. Islam and Politics in Central Asia. New York: St Martins Press, 1995. P. 186.
Fane D. Ethnicity and Regionalism in Uzbekistan. .: Ethnic Conflict in the Post-Soviet World:
Case Studies and Analysis / Ed. by L. Drobizheva, R. Gottemoeller, C. McArdle Kelleher, L. Walker. London:
M.E. Sharpe, 1996. P. 275.
38
McGlinchey E. Powerless in Kyrgyzstan // RFE/RL Newsline, 13 July 2000.
39
.: Caryl Ch. Declining Democracy // Newsweek Web Exclusive, 21 January 2001 [www.newsweek.com].
40
.: Rubin B., Lubin N. Op. cit.
41
.: Holidays in the Danger Zone: Meet the Stans // BBC, 20022003.
36
37

18

14 3 2011

,
- 42. . ,

, ,
1990- 43. .
, , :

44. .
, , , 45. , , , , -, . , ,
. , .

:

- , -,
. , , , ,
. , , ,
, .

. , 2010
,
; , (
ICG, 2010 .) 46. , , 42
.: Schoeberlein-Engel J. Identity in Central Asia: Construction and Contention in the Conceptions of
Ozbek, Tajik, Muslim, Samarqandi and Other Groups. Ph.D. thesis. Harvard, 1994.
43
Smith G. The Post-Soviet States: Mapping the Politics of Transition. London: ArNo.ld, 1999. P. 227.
44
.: Megoran N. The Critical Geopolitics of the Uzbekistan-Kyrgyzstan Ferghana Valley Boundary
Dispute, 19992000.
45
Polat N. Boundary Issues in Central Asia. Ardsley: Transnational Publishers, 2002. P. 167.
46
Harding L. Kyrgyzstan Killings are Attempted Genocide, Say Ethnic Uzbeks // The Guardian, 17 June
2010. P. 1.

19

 14 3 2011

, ,
.

. , , .
. . .

. .
,
47. . , 48, , ,
, 49
, . . ,

.
, , , ,
,
, , 50. , , ,
. .
, , . ,
.
.
, . . , , (), 51. , , , , , . , , .
47
.: Megoran N., Raballand G., Bouyjou J. Performance, Representation, and the Economics of Border
Control in Uzbekistan // Geopolitics, 2005, Vol. 10, No. 4. P. 712742.
48
.: Bichsel Ch. Conflict Transformation in Central Asia. London: Routledge, 2009.
49
.: Bichsel Ch. In Search of Harmony: Repairing Infrastructure and Social Relations in the Ferghana
Valley // Central Asian Survey, 2005, Vol. 24, No. 1. P. 5366.
50
.: Heathershaw J. Post-Conflict Tajikistan. London: Routledge, 2009.
51
.: Reeves M. Locating Danger: Konfliktologiia and the Search for Fixity in the Ferghana Valley
Borderlands // Central Asian Survey, 2005, Vol. 24, No. 1. P. 6781.

20

14 3 2011

: . ,
.
; ,
. ,
- , 52.
, ,
- , ,
, . - , .
, ,
, , .
52

Myer W. Op. cit. P. 269.

:



,
()
(, )

()
(, )

,
;
-

() :
21

 14 3 2011

10 ,
-

( ).


, , , ,
( ).
20102011 , , ,
.

, . , .
()
,
, ; ,

- .
,
,
,

.
,

,
, . , .
.
, , :
, . ,
.
.
; , .
,
: .
, .
.
.
22

14 3 2011

.
,
.
.
-
(
) 2010 1;
2, 2010 3. ,
,
.
, ,
, - (), .
,
,
.
, .
,
1998- 2009 78% ( 4 346 7 754 ). , , , .
,
.
, 20092010 89% (
2002 . 2,5 ); 14,3% .
, , , . ,
, , , 5%
, 70%
, 25% .
, , , .
,
.
1
.: [http://www.lenta.ru/news/2010/09/
23/claim/].
2
.: C [http://www.rosbalt.ru/
main/2011/05/03/845310.html].
3
.: [http://vz.ru/news/2011/5/22/
493403.html].

23

 14 3 2011

, -
. .

; , .
, .
, 2010
, 5
. 932 ( 200 250 .), 4.
. ,
(..
), , , . 85 ( 7,6 ), , , , ,
, .
95 , , ( 70 , 3,4 ).
,
, 11 : , , 1 ,
5 , 3 . 5,2 : 0,5 ( 2008 .), 1,6 , 1,5 , 1,6 5.
, , , 5,4%, 12%
. , .
.
;
, , .

, .
, ,
-
, .
4
[http://www.newsru.com/world/
29oct2010/fsknafghan.html].
5
World Drug Report 2010, U.N.

24

14 3 2011

, .
,

,
.
,
; 6.
, .

10 ; ,
(, , ), .
2010
. , - ,
. .

, .

.
.

.
.

, .
,
(2009 .) (2010 .) .
. .
;
-

6
, ,
, .

25

 14 3 2011

- ( ,
), , , ().
. (
-) ( )7 .
; .
,
, ,
;
, , , , 8.
, , . -
( 2011 .), , ,
.

. ,
; , , . 10
, . ,
, , .
,
: , , , ,
.
.

, .
, , ,
;
.

. , , ,
- .

7
, (.,
[http://vz.ru/news/2011/5/23/493608.html]).
8
.: . // , 27 2010 [http://i-r-p.ru/page/stream-exchange/index-26913.html].

26

14 3 2011

,
( ).
.
.
n

-, , .

-, , ,
, ; , ,
,
.

- , , , , ,
.

. , , , , . ,
, , , , ; ,
.
,
,
2011 . ,
,
, .

, . ;
- ( ) . , .
20102011
650;
. .
I 2011 , 2002 , , . (1 102) . (
: I 2009 . 1 300 , 2010- 1 790, 2011 . 2 7009.)
-
.
9

[www.antiterror.ru].

27

 14 3 2011

( ).
, ; 1 - 83 115 . ( 30 -);
-- , ,
. , 10.

. ,
. , - ( ) ; , .
,

, -
.

, ;
11.
2011 .
. ; , , .
,
. , - .
, , , , ,
, . -
-.
, , , ,

,
, .

, , , ,
, ,
10
.: . : [http://
www.iimes.ru/rus/stat/2011/14-05-11.htm].
11
.: . . .

28

14 3 2011

, 1, , .
. ,
(, , ), .
, 2009
,
.
, - .
, . ,
.
, . - ,
. , . . ,
, . , .

. , , .


.
,
. ,
, , .
, , ,
c . , .
,
.
,
.
, -
. , , ,
. , , 2011
.
29

 14 3 2011

, ,
. ( )
. , - .
. (16 2011 .), . ,
; - ,

-, . 12.
21 2011 - , ; 16 . 11 .
, ( 75%), 13.
,
. ,
, ( , )
, , .
, -
. ( ) 14.
, ,
;
,
, .

10 :

,
,
.
( , 3,6 . 36,5 . 15).

, .
.: [http://kommersant.ru/doc/1642887/print].
[http://www.rosbalt.ru/main/2011/05/23/851121.html].
14
.: [http://vz.ru/news/2011/5/23/
493429.html].
15
[http://www.lukoil-overseas.ru/upload/iblock/3c7/oil_news_06z77r.pdf].
12

13

30

14 3 2011

; .
, ,
, .
, : , (
), 2011 . -
.
- , , .
16.
,
( , , ),
.
,
.
,
( 2,1 .), .
, - , .
, ,
,
, .
,
,
, . ,
, 17.

, .
, , .
, . ,
, , , , .
16
17

.: . [http://www.afghanistan.ru/doc/19906.html].
.: . [http://www.afghanistan.ru/doc/19737.html].

31

 14 3 2011

. .

, 7 2001 ,
; , 100 .
, ,
18.
, , . ,
. , .
. .
- . ,
, 1020 : ,
, - .
, , , . , , ( ) .
, ,
, .
, .
, ,
. , : ,
.
,
, , ;
, , . , .
: ?

18
.: , [http://www.centrasia.
ru/ news2.php?st=1290759240].

32

14 3 2011

(, )



(, )



(, )




(, )

, .

,
, , , . ,

1.

( , 1
.: Borum R. Psychology of Terrorism // Tampa: USF (University of South Florida), 2004. P. 145.

33

 14 3 2011

. .)
, , , .

. : .

1994
90%

.
- .

, .
(),
, ,
.

,


. , - . :

.

;
, ;

2.

, , ,
: , /
3.

1991
Borum R. Op. cit. P. 148.
.: Perl R. Terrorism, the Future and U.S.
Foreign Policy. Foreign Affairs. Defense and Trade Division. Congressional Research Service. The Library of
Congress, 2003. P. 15.
2
3

, , ( ) ( ).
1747 - , . -
- ,
,
1773 . - .
- -, 34

14 3 2011

. , 1973 4.
,
, , . 1838 - .
1919 ,
- ,
. 13 1919 ,
- .
, , , 5.
,
, .
-
1929 , .
,
-, . . , , , ,
.
, ,
: , , ..6
:

;
;
,
;
,
.

,
, (/),
4
.: Shay Sh. The Endless Jihad. Herzliya, Israel: International Policy Institute for Counter-Terrorism,
2002. P. 27.
5
.: Farhang M.S. Afghanistan in the Last Five Centuries // Ismaeliyan press (Qom), 1992. P. 3032.
6
.: Heller M. The Soviet Invasion of Afghanistan // C.C.S. Memorandum, 1982, No. 2. P. 12.

35

 14 3 2011

, .

. , , -
. , 7.
, , . , .
, ,
, .
.

: , .
. ,
, .
8.
, . , , .
,
9.

-. , , : ,
, - . . , ,
: ,
, , , , 10. ,
,
.
.: Shay Sh. Op. cit. P. 55.
.: Ibid. P. 6567.
9
.: The Middle East, February 1990.
10
An Interview with Borhaneddin Rabbani // Newspaper of Payame Mujahid (Kabul), 8 March 2005.
7
8

36

14 3 2011

. -, . ,
()
, 1990- ,
.

, .
, .
. ,
,
,
11.
,

( ) , . , , ,
, 12.
, , ,
. ,
, ,
, , .
, , .
. 90%
.
, ,
.
,
, ,
, . ,
, ,
.
11
12

.: Dow Jones News, 21 September 1997.

.: Ibidem.

37

 14 3 2011

. 25 000 , 13.

-

53 , , 14.
,
, . , .
1980-
. , .

, , .
, . 1994 15.
,
, , , . ,

16.
,
, .
.
1997 , . 1997
, , .
.
13

P. 212.
P. 44.

.: Pahlavan Ch. Afghanistan: Era of the Mujahidin and the Taliban // Qatreh Press (Tehran), 1998, Vol. 1.

14

.: Pohly M., Dowran Kh. Who is Bin Laden?. Transl. by M. Mirmoezzi. Tehran: Rozaneh Press, 2001.

15

.: Khosravi K. Osama Ibn Mohammed Bin Laden // Simindoxt Press (Tehran), 1996. P. 9095.
.: Ibid. P. 97.

16

38

14 3 2011

. , ,
- . ,
,
-17.
, --
- .
, , ,
18.
(
), . , ,
, .
,
.
-
, , .
. , ,
19.

11

11 - -, 11 2001 20.
19 - . -,
, . , . (), . , ,
,
. 21.
.: Veisi Z. In the Search of Bin Laden // Internet site of Bashgahe Andishe (Tehran), 2003. P. 2021.
.: Bodansky Y. Bin Laden, The Man Who Declared War on America. California: Roseville Forum,
1999. P. 346347.
19
.: Al Hayat, 12 February, 2002.
20
.: Kepple G., Milelli J.-P., Ghazaleh P. Al Qaeda in Its Own Words // Harvard University Press, 2008. P. 48.
21
.: Holmes St. Al Qaeda, 11 September 2001. .: Gambetta D. Making Sense of Suicide Missions.
Oxford University Press, 2006. P. 21.
17
18

39

 14 3 2011

,
, 5
.
.
-
.
, , , ,
22.
; . ,
, . ,
, 23.
, , , , , , , , , -24.
. , , , ,
. , 25.

, . , , . , . , ,
.
22
.: Borger J. Blogger Bares Rumsfelds Post 9/11 Orders // Guardian News and Media Limited (London)
[http:// www. Guardian .co.UK /world /2006 /Feb / 24 / freedom of information], 11 September 2006.
23
.: Holmes St. Op. cit. P. 80.
24
.: Ibid. P. 8082.
25
.: Thayil J. 645 Racial Incidents Reported in Week After September 11 // India Abroad [http://www.
Highbeam.com/doc/1p1-79281024-html], 2001.

40

14 3 2011

, ,
26.
- , . , , , .

,
, .
27.
:
1) ;
2)
;
3) :
,
, 28.
:
( -);
, ,
;
, ;
;
,
, . ,
, - , :
, ;
,
26
.: Tiffany P. Islam in Central Asia: The Emergence and Growth of Radicalism in the Post-Communist
Era // Center for Technology and National Security Policy (CTNSP), 2003.
27
.: Omelicheva M.Y. Ethnic Dimension of Religious Extremism and Terrorism in Central Asia. Chicago:
International Studies Association, 2007.
28
.: Ibidem.

41

 14 3 2011

.
, , , 29.

. 1990- . , . , , ,
.
, .
, , : , , , .
: . :
, ; 30.
.
,
.
: , .
. 100 .
1980- . ,

, . , ,

,
.
. , , , 31.
29
.: A Conference on the Islamization of Central Asia: Politics, Economics and Society // Woodrow
Wilson Internal Center for Scholars, 5th floor Conference Room, 11 June, 2003.
30
.: Ibidem.
31
.: Warikoo K. Central Asia Emerging New Order. New Delhi: Haranand Publication, 1996. P. 211.

42

14 3 2011

, , ,
,
32.

( 11 2001 .)
1990- . : -,
, -,
33.
, , . 1990-
2000-
.
19791989 , ,
. , ,
. --
, ,
,

34.

11
, 11 2001
. , .
32
.: Mognus R.H., Eden N. Afghanistan: Mullah, Marx and Mujahid. Pakistan: Pak Book Corporation,
1998. P. 87.
33
.: Cornell S.E. The Narcotics Threat in Greater Central Asia: From Crime-Terror Nexus to State Infiltration // Central Asia-Caucasus Institute, Silk Road Studies Program, China and Eurasia Forum Quarterly, 2006,
Vol. 4, No. 1. P. 3667.
34
.: Cooley J. Unholy Wars: Afghanistan, America and International Terrorism // Pluto Press (London),
2002. P. 58.

43

 14 3 2011

?
, , . : ,
, ; , 35.
, , , .
, -,
[] . ,
, 2001 , .
, ( , ). .
, :
,
, - .
,

. ,
, , -- ( , . .). 2002 , [ ] ,
, , , [ ] 36.
, 11
2001 -,
,
, .
, . 2003 ,
. , ,
35
.: Drug Trade in Eurasia Database // Silk Road Studies Program, Uppsala, 24 August 2005 [http://www.
Silk Road Studies. Org.drug data base. Htm].
36
.: Cornell S.E. Narcotics, Radicalism and Armed Conflict in Central Asia: The Islamic Movement of
Uzbekistan // Terrorism and Political Violence, 2005, Vol. 17, No. 4. P. 619639.

44

14 3 2011

,
, ,
37.
, 11 2001
.
.

, , . , , , , - 38.

1980- , .
, . .
.

.
, ,
.
() .
.
. (). , ,
,
, . , , , , - .
. ,
.
,
, .
37
.: Nichol J. Central Asia: Security, Internal Affairs & U.S. Interests. New York: Nova Science Publishers 2008. P. viii (Soft over).
38
.: Ibid. P. 6.

45

 14 3 2011

: , ,
, , . ,
- .

-
-



(, )

.
.


. ,
,
( ).

-

:
, .
, , -
. , 1990- -

-

-
1990-
,
46

14 3 2011

- . 1992
.
1990- : , .
19961997 1. - ,
2.
2001 .
3.
- -
2001 - (Blackseafor) (
)4. 2003
-
( Blackseafor). 2006 Blackseafor - - , - 5.
-
. 1990-
110 ., 110 (-60/80), - -8 -17, , ,
.6
, 1992
( -17, , , ) 300 .7

, , 8.
1994
- - ,
1
.: . : . , 2007. . 28.
2
.: Torbakov I. Making Sense of the Current Phase of Turkish-Russian Relations // The Jamestown Foundation, October 2007.
3
.: . . . . 3132.
4
1998 ,
2001-. Blackseafor,
- , , , .. [http://www.blackseafor.org/english/operational.php].
5
.: . . . . 5456.
6
.: Weapons Transfers and Violations of Laws of War in Turkey // Human Rights Watch Arms Project.
USA, 1995. P. 3637; Kandaurov S. Russian Arms Exports to Greece, Cyprus and Turkey, Moscow Defense Brief
[http://mdb.cast.ru/mdb/2-2001/at/raegct/].
7
.: : - // [http://
www.itartass.ur.ru/details/rossiya_turtsiya_ot_postavok_gaza_do_voenno_tekhnicheskogo_sotrudnichestva_spravka.
html], 15 2011.
8
.: Litovkin V. The Future of Russian-Turkish Military-Technical Cooperation // RIA Novosti, 26 June 2006.

47

 14 3 2011

.
9.
- , , .
- 2001 -
- . 2002 2003-
10.
2002
.
- . . 11.
- 2004 ( . ) -
- .
- () . 2007 . 2008
. , 2009 ()
, . (
). , 2010
. .
13 2009 . , - - . - - ; ,
12.

,
-
-
2006 .: Litovkin V. Op. cit.
.: .. - // , 26 2008.
11
.: Rusya ile askeri anlama yapld [http://gbulten.ssm.gov.tr/arsiv/2002/01/15/01_2.htm].
12

, 13 2009
[http://www.kremlin.ru/text/docs/2009/02/212886.shtml].
9

10

48

14 3 2011

().
/ ,
(Patriot), (-300 -2 )
- (Arrow-2) 13.
; 2008
.
, CPMIEC: HQ-9
( FD-2000) -300 -2 .
2009 - Eurosam
SAMP-T14.

. ,
, . ,
, , ,
.
2008 . , . - , . 2008 ( , ,
) 200 .
, - 15.
,
-400; . , 2009
(IDEF 2009)
. . . , -400. , 120 16.
, , , ,
/.
2007
, ,
( Lockheed Martin/
Rayteon - Rafael).
13
, , Rapier, Stinger, Atlgan
I-Hawk .
14
.: Trkiyenin fzesi hangisi olacak // Hrriyet, 15 2010; F-35te aslan payi Trk irketlerinin, 2 2010 [http://www.ihlas.net.tr].
15
.: : - //.
16
.: Turkey Hopes to Buy S-400 Air Defense Systems from Russia // RIA Novosti, 27 April 2009.

49

 14 3 2011

-;
80 800 17.
2009 2009-
40 -. 100 .18
,
72 19.
. , . , , , ( ), , , .
, ,
-80 -90 20. , - .
12
-28 Havoc; 2009
21. ,
Cobra Super Cobra,
.
, , 2013 - -129 - 22.
1997 2 .
( ),
145 - .
Bell Textron, Super Cobra, ; Ka-50-2 Erdogan, , . ,
.
2004 , ,
, - EADS Eurocopter (Tiger)
Ka-50-223.
17
.: srail yerine Ruslardan fze alyoruz // Hrriyet, 11 2008, Trk Silahl Kuvvetlerinde Rus silahlar
dnemi [http://www.nethaber.com], 11 2008. - Merkava Mk4,
M1 Abrams.
18
.: Kornet-E Rus fze kompleksi Trk askerleri tarafndan teslim alnd [http://turkish.ruvr.ru/2009/12/17/
3155702.html].
19
.: Kerimov T. Russia Eyes Turkish Arms Market [http://english.ruvr.ru/2010/07/15/12424622.html], 15 July 2010.
20
.: Cetinkaya O. Russia and Turkey: Military Aspects of a Joint Responsibility for the Region [http://
www.eurasiacritic.com/articles/russia-and-turkey-military-aspects-joint-responsibility-region], July 2009.
21
.: Sariibrahimolu L.Turkey Sends Delegation to Russia for Mi-28 Attack Helicopters // Todays Zaman, 8 June 2009.
22
.: ATAK Projesi nadir [http://www.hurriyet.com.tr/gundem/9263677.asp?gid=233&sz=31569], 24 2008.
23
.: Turkey Shortlists 2 Attack Helicopters [http://www.xairforces.com/newsd.asp?newsid=236&newst=4].

50

14 3 2011

-
,
.
, . , . -, ,
- .
, , , .
,
- . , , .
1920 2010 ,
- 24.
, ,
, , , .
1015 , ,
( ). , ,
, .
100120 F-3525,
,
.

2000- - .
- : .
,
,
.
, . 2010 50% , . , 2010 52,1%26.
24
.: Allied Leaders Agree on NATO Missile Defense System [http://www.nato.int/cps/en/natolive/news_
68439.htm], 20 November 2010.
25
100120 F-35, 1012 .
2014 ,
F-16 - F-4 (.: Turkey to Possibly Buy 20 More F-35 Fighters // Hrriyet Daily News, 7 October 2009).
26
.: Savunma sanayinde hedefler ald, 26 Nisan 2011 [http://ekonomi.milliyet.com.tr/savunma-sanayinde-hedeflerasildi/ekonomi/ekonomidetay/26.04.2011/1382547/default.htm;1http://www.sasad.org.tr/en/turkiye-savunma-sanayiinin-2010yili-verileri-aciklandi.html].

51

 14 3 2011

: .
:
, ,
- .
- , -
.
-
: .

52

14 3 2011

, PhD
. -
(, )

2011 (
,
, ,

) .
20 ()

. : -

.
-
, ,
.
.

,
, - .

, , , ..; 1990-
, , ,
53

 14 3 2011

.

,
,
.

, . ,
; , ,
, .
,

:

, : .
, , , .
. .
, . , (), ,
, .
, . , , .
, , .
, , (), ( ) , .
,
,
. ,
,
, . - . ,
(), , ( , ) , .
.
, . , ; , .
54

14 3 2011

250 , ;
, ,
. , ,
. , ,
( ,
), , , .
, , :
, .
; , , .
: 5001. ,
, 1 000.
, ,
,
. , .
1992 , - ;
.
,
.
1980-
(, , )
, , 1113%.
1930- 50% 1993 ( ). 1998
.
.

, 2.
, 60 70% ; 80% 1
.: . ( ) //
, 1 2003.
2
.: ., ., . . 19891997 [http://www.panorama.ru/works/rk/index.html], 1 2011.

55

 14 3 2011

, 60% .
( , , , ..), 1020% 3.

() .
,
,
, , .
, , ; 4.
- ( ) ( ) ,
.
, . 2010 . ,
:
5. ,
,
.

, .
- :
, . ,
, 6.
,
.
n

-, , ,
.

-, , : , .

3
.: .., .., .. // - . , 2005, 11.
4
.: .
5
.: . // , 3 2010. . 2.
6
.

56

14 3 2011

, , ,
. . 63% , 24,2% , 1,4% 0,2% . .
,
,
( ,
, ).
,
18%; ,
47%, 20% 15%7.
. 47,2% , , , .
, , , 8.
n

-, ,
.
,
. .

1990 . (
) , 40
() - 9. ,
, , .
: ,
.
,
. , ( ) ,
, . : , . - 10.
7
.: .. - : :
. . . . : .. , 2010.
8
.: . // , 2003. . 101106.
9
.: ., ., . . .
10
.: .

57

 14 3 2011

, , , . ,
.
. , 1993 ,
, . - 25 .
, , 11.
, . , , .
, . ,

.
, ,
.
, .
,
; , , , , ,
.
, . , 1997 5 000 ,
1520%,
. ,
12.
2000 . , - .
. ,
: . -
.
13.
, , , .
,
. , -
( 2010 . ).
.: ., ., . . .
.: .
13
.., .. : [http://www.ia-centr.ru/publications/7463/], 1 2011.
11
12

58

14 3 2011

, ,
. , 1991 -,
( --),
, , ,
14.
16 1995 ,
, (), () ,
-. - . .
, . 19891997, , . , . 1994
15.
1999 - .
II. 2003 , 16.
,
( ).
5 2010 - ,
. , 26 2010 -

. .
,
, , , : ,
, 17.
,
- .
.: ., ., . . .
.: .
16
.: . [http://www.religare.ru/article6503], 1 2011.
17
.: .., .., .. . .
14
15

59

 14 3 2011

, . ,
..
- , 18.
.
, ,
,
, .
.. , , ,

. ,
,
.. , .
, ,
,
.
, , - . , , .

,
19. ,
, -
, . , ( , ..),
,
20.
, , , . - , - .
, , , 39%
, () ; 40% 2 . 80% , , , , .
18
[http://www.islamsng.com/
kaz/news/2139], 1 2011.
19
.: . . [quorum.
kz/6123/], 1 2011.
20
.: .

60

14 3 2011

, ,
20 , , ,
.. ,
,
. , 2011 , 10
. , .
,
.
,
, . ,
- .
,
, .
17 2011 25- .
. 3 , . ,
, 21. , , ,
.

, , , ,
.
,
;
. 22. , -
.
, ,
; , .
,
52 , 35- . 23.
,
; 2011
( )
24.
21
. (
) [www.ipwr.com.], 1 2011.
22
.: [www.gazeta.ru/social/2011/06/08/3656953.shtml], 1 2011.
23
.: [tengrinews.
kz/kazakhstan_news/190102/], 1 2011.
24
.: [www.tv7.kz], 1 2011.

61

 14 3 2011

; ( ,
), .

, , 1
1989 , 671 , 46 (2
). (, , , , ); 1 232 25.
2003 1 652 ,
(1 642) 26.
, 2000 5 000 . 2009
2 500 . ,
, 27.
,
. ,
, . , , , , ; ,
28.
, ,
, , ,
, . 29.
. , ,
, -,
,
,
( )30.
,
:
. ,
. , , . 31.
25
.:
[http://www.panorama.ru/works/rk/indexk.html], 1 2011.
26
.: . : // , 16 2003.
27
.: .., .. . .
28
.: . // , 2011, 4.
29
.: .
30
.
31
.: .

62

14 3 2011

, 19 2011 ( )
, .
, , ,
, , - 32.
. 1015
, , ,
, . , , 33.
, 2011 , .
. , ,
,
.

,
. ()
. . , . , -
: . ,
, . , ,
, , 34.
. ,
. : ,
. . , , 35.
, , , , , .
, ,
, .
. , . , , , . ,
32
.: [www.kt.kz], 1 2011.
33
.: ., . , ... [www.rosbalt.ru], 1 2011.
34
[http://www.guljan.org/ru/news/komments/2011/July/
268], 1 2011.
35
. // BNews.kz, 1 2011.

63

 14 3 2011

. , ,
, 36.
, ...
17% 37. , , , 30 . , ; (51,5%) . 3,4% , .
: - ( . .) . ,
. ;
. . , . ,
38.
: 111 , 83 , 7 , 20 1 39. , , ,
, 40.
, . . ; 2010
. .
, , , 41.
,
, , , . ,
, . , - (a ), 42.
,
; , (, , ). , -
- , , , , , , 43.
. .
.: . // , 25 2011.
38
.: . .
39
.: . // , 10 2011.
40
.: . . .
41
.: .
42
.: .
43
.:
[www.nomad.su/?a=3-201107140015], 1 2011.
36
37

64

14 3 2011

,
(,
) . , , :
,
.

44.
, .
,
, . ,
. .
. , 2007 -20
( )
. , .
45.
. 2001 16 ,
, . ,
46.
;
.
2011 14 . , 21 85 47. , ,
, 60 .
. , , ,
1990- , ,
48. , . , , ,
, , , , 49.
.: [www.kt.kz], 1 2011.
.: . . .
46
.: [www.newskaz.ru/
incidents/20110711/1681542.html], 1 2011.
47
.: 14 [www.kt.kz], 1 2011.
48
.: . ( ) //
Central Asia Monitor, 8 2011.
49
.: . . .
44
45

65

 14 3 2011

, ,
,
. , , .

, , , ; , , 50.
; , . , , ,
, .
, (
, , ) ;
, , . , , - , .
, - Zakon.kz
. , 51, . , , .
. , , , ,
. , . (, ).
, , , . , 52.
- : , ,
.
, , . 23
.
. - 53.
.: . . .
.: . [inform.kz], 1 2011.
52
.: . : // , 7 2010.
53
.: [www.kazpravda.
kz/c/1308831043], 1 2011.
50
51

66

14 3 2011

10 . . , ,
54.
13 2011
. . , 2011-
;
.

.

. , 20 , , ,
. ,
, ,
55.
,
, .
, ,
, ,
. ,
, ,
.
, , (, ),
, , ,
; , , .
,
, , .
, ,
. 20072009
, - , , .
2009 Al Hilal, , 56,
54
.: // inform.kz, 1 2011.
55
[www.newskaz.ru/society/
20110617/1601787.html], 1 2011.
56
.: . ,
// inform.kz, 1 2011.

67

 14 3 2011

, , ..
,

. , . 2020 57. , , 1/10 58.
, , 2014
59.
, (, .); , - 1 . .

20 ; 3 800
4 300 ( 1990 . 671). 60.
. ,
: , .
, , 35% , . ,
,
. , , , , , (), -
61.

1990- . , , -
,
( ) - .
57
.:
2020 // Nomad.su, 1 2011.
58
.: , 2020 // Zakon.kz, 1 2011.
59
.: . [www.kursiv.kz/1195211350-perspektivnoe-napravlenie.
html], 1 2011.
60
.: . // , 3 2011.
61
.: . // , 9 2006.

68

14 3 2011

1990- 62.
.

, .

1994 ,
, , , , (. 109).


1995 (. 5.5)63.
1994
. ,
.

, ;
, ( )
, , . , , , .
64.
, 80%
, 10% 18 65.
, , . : , , ..
(
) . ,
. : , - , 66. , 62
.: . : . . 2 [http://www.aspect-m.kz/rus/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=
19:-2&catid=4:2010-09-21-05-01-01&Itemid=6], 1 2011.
63
.: ., ., . . .
64
.: . . .
65
.: . [www.westkaz.kz], 1 2011.
66
.: . [http://www.zonakz.net/blogs/user/patriot/
12652.html], 1 2011.

69

 14 3 2011

; .
,
.
: , .
, , ,
67.

. , 2008 840 , 2010 930;
68. , I 2011 , 11 .
, , : , , .
, ,
() . 2000 2009 , . ; , , , 10 69.
, , . , ,
- , .
, . , ,
( , ).
,
. , ,
18 , 70.
, .
. , , 67
.: . : ,
[www.contur.kz/node/1666], 1 2011.
68
.: . . .
69
.: .
70
.: . , 16! // , 20 2011.

70

14 3 2011

, , ,
.
-, , -, , --, -- , , , ,
. ,
,
; ,
, , , .
,
, .
, 71.

2000-
, , , .
,
. . ,
.
70% , , , , 10%.
2000 .
; .
.

. ;
,
(
. ). , , ,
; , , .
71

.: . . .

71

 14 3 2011

, , , .
, ,
, 20102011 ; , .


, , , 72.

,
, .
,
73.
, ,
, , , (
). ,
, , , .
, ,
, , .
( , ), .
,
.
.
;
, .
, , (
),
.
, , .. ,
,
, , . :

.
72
73

.: .., .., .. . .
.: .

72

14 3 2011

, - , ,
, .,
- ( , ,
.).
,
; .
, , -.
.
, , .
,
, .
, .
: , .

:


, ,

,

-
(, )

, , ,

.

73

 14 3 2011

, :

.

,
.
( )
. ,

XXXXI , ,
.
, , . ,
, ; ,
.
, ,
, - , .
, , ,
(, , .). - , , .
, , , ;
.
,
.
, , / ( ) / . 1990- ,
. , , ,
, , ,
,
74

14 3 2011

.
( ) .
, 2/3
, 10%
.
? 1
(. . 1):
1

4%
4,1%
7,6%
10,6%
7,2%
56,2%
10,3%



,
,
,

? 14 , (. . 2):
2

17,8%

8,6%
10,1%

5
25%
37,8%

10

1
, , , - .

75

 14 3 2011

, , , .
(. . 3).
3

34,4%

,

10,7%

,

3%
,

11,9%

,

39,7%

( ) , , (-) ,
,
, ()
,
.
,
.
, ;
( ) .
,
(
). ,

, , .
:
; .
76

14 3 2011

,
.

;
.
(), . , , , . ,
( ,
, , .).
, , / ; , ,
.
, , ( ) , -, , .
. .

: , -, , , . ,
.

; , . ,
, .
, , -; ,
.
,
, , , ,
, .
,
( ).
77

 14 3 2011

, . ,
, , , , , . .

,
, , - .
, , ,
, , , , . (
, , ..), , ,
, . ,
n

-, ,

-, (, , , , , , .),

-, , , -, , .

, .
, 2010 , 12% , , 26% ,
.
, 49,8% , , 4,7% (. . 4).

.
n

, , .

, , , ,
, , , . ,
78

14 3 2011
4

4,7%

25,4%

19,7%

49,8%

, ,

. ,
, . , .

,
, .

( , .).

, (, , ).

, . .

, ,
; .

.
n

, .
79

 14 3 2011

; ,
, ,
. , , .

. ,
(
).

. , .

.
.

:
, ;
,
;

,
, , ,
, , , ..
( ) .
, , ;

, , , ;
, ;
,
, - ;
;
, ( ). -
, -
;
, ;
,
. , ,
.
, . . , ;
80

14 3 2011

,
;
;
-
.
( )
,
; .
,
, :
,
;
, . , , . , ;
, ,
;

;
;
;
,
;
, ;
,
, ;
, ( , , , ..).

,
( ), , , ,
.
, , (. . 5).
, , (
, , .) .
81

 14 3 2011

8,7%

7%

25,7%

20,1%

25,9%

,
, (. . 6):
6

50,1%

5,1%

16,6%

28,2%

82

14 3 2011

, , ,
2010 ( ). 8-800-080-78-68
, , , .
.
. , , , ( ) -
. , , ( ), . ,
, , ..
, ; ,
.
, ; ,
.
.
,
( ).
- , , :
1) ( ) , ;
2) (, );
3)
,
;
4) , - ;
83

 14 3 2011

( )
, ,
.
,
,
,
.

,
, .
, : . ,
, ,
.
,
. , (.. , , , ): , , .
,

.
,
, .
(,
)
.
,
, .
, ,
, :

. , , , , , , , ( ),
. ,
(
).
84

14 3 2011

, . , ,
, ( , )
.
. .
- :
,
, .
;

. , , ( ).

, ;
, . , , .
,
, .

.
, , , ,

.
,

;
, .
,
, (. . 7):
85

 14 3 2011

1,2%

40,5%

58,3%

(. . 8):
8

10,2%

,
,
,
, ..

28,6%

8,2%

14,3%

38,8%

, , ( ), ,
, , ,
( , ) .
, ( , , 86

14 3 2011

, .), , .
:
, , ;
, , , , .
;
, , , , .
, , , .
,
, .
: , . ,
.
,
.
; , .
( ) , ;
- .

.
, ,

.
, , ,
,
.
87

 14 3 2011

, 2010 ,
.
;
- - ,
( , .), , .
( ). , ,
, .
: , , ,
, , , , .
, ,
,
.
.
, ;
, , , , , ,
.
, ,
.
,
.
, ; , .
, (), .
, ,
, .

, ,
.
88

14 3 2011

, - - , .
( , , ),
.
, 1315%
, , 1%
, , .
, , , , ,
, , .
, , , ,
. , , : , , ( ), .
, .
, ;
:
;
,
;
, ,
;
, ;
, .
, , , , ,
, .
, ,
, .
,
. ;
.
89

 14 3 2011

. ,
, ,
.
( , ), .
, ,
, , - , :
( );
, ;

;
;
.

(, )

.
. 90

14 3 2011
.
.

-
. ,

,
. 17 2004
.
, ,
1921 ,

.

. ( 16 ),
, 1921 ,
3.
, 18 2004 .
,
, 4.

.


,
.
, ,

.
,

, .
.
. . , , :

. -

1.
,
. .
- 1990- ,

,
, ..
.
, , ,
.
,
. . , 1992- 2003
,
2.
1
elikpala M. From a Failed State to a Weak
One? Georgia and Turkish-Georgian Relations. .:
The Turkish Yearbook, Vol. XXXV. P. 171 [http://www.
politics.ankara.edu.tr/dosyalar/MMTY/36/7_mithat_
celikpala.pdf].
2
.
: . ., 2008. C. 113.

3
.: :
[http:// www.regnum.
ru.17.03.2004].
4
.: . . . C. 113114.

91

 14 3 2011

().
, ,
, -

, .
, 2002
: 240552 ., 115161 ., - 3 162 ., 683 ., 161 ., 16297 .5
, ( ) , XVI
- . , ,
. . ,
... 1820- 6. ,
( )7 ,
8.
- 18771878 - (3 1878 .)
27 1879 ,
.

( , )9, . ,
, 10.
, ,
11. ,
5
.: [http:// www.statistics.ge/ files/ english/census/2002/Religious%20beliefs.pdf]. , , , , .
6
Sanikidze G., Walker E.W. Islam and Islamic Practices in Georgia. Berkeley: University of California,
Institute of Slavic, East European and Eurasian Studies, 2004. P. 6; .:
.. : , , . ., 1998 (. : .
. , . . ., 2005).
7
.: Sanikidze G., Walker E.W. Op. cit. P. 7.
8
Ibidem.
9
: Derluguian G.M. The Tale of Two Resorts: Abkhazia and Ajaria Before and Since the Soviet
Collapse. .: The Myth of Ethnic Conflict: Politics, Economics and Cultural Violence / Ed. by B. Crawford,
R.D. Lipschutz. Berkeley, 1998. P. 276.
10
.: . . 19141917 . ., 1971. C. 160161.
11
.: .. . . C. 242.

92

14 3 2011

, . 6 , 13 1921 ;

(, ).
12.
, - . , ,

. ,
1980- 1990- .
. . , ; 2223 1991

13.
.
. , , - , , , ,
. , .
, , . . ,
. 11 1990 - -
, , , . , ,
(37 .). , , , , , , . 14
2000-
, .. (18881959 .),
. (18731960 .).
12
, 1, . 6 :
, , . 4
, , : 1) ,
, , , , (.:
, , , ,
13 . . 264. .:
. . IV. ., 1960. . 423).
13
.: ,29 1991, 18 (68).
14
. XXI : //
, 2003, 2 (26). . 97.

93

 14 3 2011

, , , ,
(, , ); , ,
, ,
, ..
2000- . , ,
, 15. ,
. 16.


(Diyanet Isleri Baskanligi), , , . , Diyanet , , 17.
, 2006 ( )
29 18. 2008 . 49 19.
,
, . , ,
,
.
. . :
, . , , .
,
20.
,
Diyanet,
; . , , Diyanet...21
, Diyanet . , . 15
.: Balci B. Is There a Place for Islam in Michael Saakashvilis Christian Georgia? [http://www.caucaz.
com/home_eng/breve_content.Php?id=180.25.08.2005].
16
.: Balci B., Motika R. Religion et Politique dans le Caucase post-sovetique. Paris, 2007. P. 243.
17
.: . [http://www.religions.am/index.php?option=com_content&view=
article&id=2999: &catid=1:2009-02-27-03-45-54&Itemid=11] ( . ).
18
C.: [http://www.sngnews.ru. 25.01.2006].
19
.: ? [http://www.golos.am.22.07.2008].
20
. , [http://www.islam.ru/
pressclub/gost/saidaev/)].
21
Balci B. . .

94

14 3 2011

, . ,
.
, , .
,
, ,
.
, .

, 1990- .
- , . :
, . . ,
22. ,
23. , , 2002 102 24, 2005 13725, 2006 15926. , 2008 175 27. , ,
.
(, , , 1866
), ,
.
, , (
) - . - (
) ; , , (, , .).
-
. . ,
2003- 2008 , ,
, . , 95 -, 41, 18, 228.
[http://www.ccrgchouse.ge/gazeti/9/3/.htm].
, , ( .: Sanikidze G., Walker E.W. Op. cit. P. 13).
24
.: [http://www.pravoslavie.ru], 2 2002.
25
.: .
26
.: [http:// www.pravoslavie. Ru], 5 2006.
27
.: ?
28
.: . (- - ). , 2008. . 167 ( . ).
22
23

95

 14 3 2011

, , , - ,
-
.
, . : . ,
. , , . , , .
.
, ... . , , 29.
, , , ,
.
1. .
2. .
3. .
,
, , .
, ,
.

.

1980- , 30.
, 14 2002
( ), 22 2002
31.
, . ,
?, - ;
[http://www.milligazette.com], 4 2006.
: . .
.: : , , . . . 2. : . , 2006.
C. 137.
31
. : [http://www.patriarchate.ge/_en/
?action=eklesia-saxelmcifo].
29
30

96

14 3 2011

. , II : , ,
. - ,
, , ,
32; , , ( ,
I
).
, .
. , . , - , , , :
, , , .
, - .
. , -
. , ,
( . ..). 1991 ; , ... ,
- .
, , (), , - , , , 33.

, .
. ,
34.
1980- ,
35; ( 1989 .)
.
. , 1 1989 5 000 .,
50036. 13 1991 5 000 37.
. 2003
( - ) 300 38.
32
Khalvashi T., Batiashvili N. Can Muslim be a Georgian? Historic Overview of Discourse on Georgian
Essence [http://api.ning.com/files/ CanMuslimbeaGeorgian.doc]. P. 16.
33
. [http://www.newsgeorgia.ru/geo1/20060527/
41734739.html]; [http://www.pravoslavie.ru/cgi-bin/sykon/client/display.pl?sid=364&did=1119]; 1960-
II (.: . . .: : . . 2. .:
, 2002. . 322).
34
Pelkmans M. Baptized Georgian: Religious Conversion to Christianity in Autonomous Ajaria // Max
Plank Institute for Social Antropology, Working Papers, 2005, No. 71. P. 6.
35
.: . . . . 322.
36
.: [http:// www.religio.ru], 10 2005.
37
.: . . .
38
.: [http://www.pravoslavie.ru/cgi-bin/sykon/client/display.pl?sid=363&did=1286].

97

 14 3 2011

,
39.
. . , , , , . , 2004 - . 40.
2004 . , ,
41.
. ()
, (
) . , . ()
() 42.
43, 2004 , 2- , ,
44.

( , ), , , -
. ,
.
, , 5 2004 ( ,
, , , ), , ( , , , ..) , , , .
, , . , 1 2004
39
, , (.: () [http:// www.regnum.ru], 25 2010).
40
.: - 600
[http://www.abkhaziainfo. org], 2 2004.
41
.: . . . . 165.
42
.: Saakashvilis Ajara Success: Repeatable Elsewhere in Georgia? // EUROPE Briefing, Tbilisi/Brussels,
18 August 2004, International Crisis Group. P. 3.
43
.: . . .
44
. . . . 162.

98

14 3 2011

, . . ( )
1 000 .45 17 2004
200 ,
; , , 15- 46. 7 2005 () . 200 .47 27 2006
50 48. 2006 , 300 49. 2008
. , 200 .50
, , ,
, ;
.
. , ( ) , ,
51.
, - .
, .
1. .
2. : , , . : , , .
, , ; , ( ) .
. . : ,
, . , ,
. ...52
45
.: [http://www.pravoslavie.ru/cgi-bin/sykon/client/display.pl?sid=363&did=1286; http://www.georgiaorthodoxy.ru], 3 2004.
46
.: 200 [http://www.sedmitza.ru/news/306842.html]; [http://
www.georgia.orthodoxy.ru/calendar00.htm], 18 2004.
47
.: [http:// www. pravoslavie.ru], 7 2005.
48
.: 50 [http://www.newsgeorgia.ru], 27
2006.
49
.: Landru N. In Georgia Religious Minorities Remain in the Shadow [http://www.caucaz.com], 8 2007.
50
.: [http://www.patriarchia.ru/db/text/468845.html].
51
Pelkmans M. Op. cit. P. 3.
52
., . , // , 2000, 2 (8). . 216.

99

 14 3 2011

- .
. ,
, ; .
. 18 2010 : , 240 (140 ), 8 ( ),
,
53.

, . . , , :
.
, .
. ,
. 1 000, 120. , , 54.
. : ,
, ,
. . , - , ,
. , ,
55.
23 2011 ,
2 000 ( , ), , , . , ,
, : ,
, 90 , .
1. ,
.
2. , . .
3.
56.
53
. [http://www.kavkazoved.info/
news/2011/04/17/novyj-muzej-okkupacii-pod-vidom-druzhby-s-turciej.htm].
54
.
55
.
56
.

100

14 3 2011

,
.

, : 18 2007 . - II .
. ,
,
. ,
.

. . ,
, 57.
, ; , , .
, ,
, .
, , () ,
2009 , 2010
.
. , ,
,
. .
. 58, , ,
, , , , 59.
, 2011 ()
( )
, .

. , 12 2011 . . . , . .
,
. , , , .: [http://www.blagovest-info], 21 2007.
.: [http://www.blagovest-info.ru/index.php?ss=2&s=3&
id=35235%3E] (. : http://religiebi.info/index.php?a=main&pid=17&lang=eng]).
59
, . , . , , ,
(.: Sutidze L. Face towards Mecca, Heart to Homeland [http://www.tabula.ge/en/article-2161.html]).
57
58

101

 14 3 2011

, ( ,
).

,
. , , -, , . ,

. , 2011
. ,
60.
,
, - , ..
, , 6 2005
, TAV & Urban . , .
14 2006 ; 2006
.
95 . 62 .

, 15 . . 18 .
10 .
26
2007 . , ,
, .
8 2006 . ,
.
,
:
.
, BTM ,
: ,
.. 2007 .
26 2007 ,
.
, , 90% .
60
.: Kaar M.Davutolu, Grcistann Acara zerk Cumhuriyetinde Trk iadamlar ile bir arayageldi, 11 2011 [http://www.dha.com.tr/haberdetay.asp?tarih=29.05.2011&Newsid=141602&Categoryd=5].

102

14 3 2011

,
900 ., 300. 61.
, ,
, . , , , , . , (), ,
:
,
18 (! ..). 15 .
18 15 , ? 62. , ,
.
, , , , ,
.
, ( ) .

,
. , , ,
,
, , .
, , , .
, ,
, - ,
, , .

61
- , . : .
- : ,
. .: : .
. . 2. , 2008. . 134148 (. : . :
(19942007). , 2007).
62
. : . . ,
, // , 8 2007 [http://www.newizv.ru/world/
2007-02-08/62906-kavkazskie-riski.html] (. : [http://www.parliament.ge/print.php?gg=1&sec_id=386&info_
id=14749%E2%8C%A9_id=GEO]).

103

 14 3 2011

,

(, , )

()
, ,
.
- , , .
, ,

, - , .

.

, ,
. - ()

, ,


.
,
, ,
, .
, (),
:
, ,
.

;
, .

, , -.

104

14 3 2011

--

, .

.
, - ,
, , .
;
( , , ),
, ,
.

, 2003 -
. ,
(800 ) 1 ,
.
, 97,8% ,
96% , 32,4% , 56,1% , 7,8% , 3,7% . , 1/3 .
, , ,
26,2% , 34,8% , 39%
. - , , . : ,
.
, .
, ;
, , , , ,
.
, , () ,
; ( , . ) . .
1
.: .. : . ,
2003 . .: , 2007. . 4.

105

 14 3 2011

, XVIII
, ;
.
; 1820-
. - ,
;
, .

, .
18801890- ( );
,
.
, . , . , , ,
.
I ,
.
,
,
.
, - (1853
1919). - -
, (, ) - .
, .. : - 10 000 ,
, , , , , , , , , , , , . ,
,
2.
, ( , ) . . ,
, .
,
, XV ; . 1820-
- ,
2
.. . .:
. .: . , 2010. . 167.

106

14 3 2011

.

- . 1850- ,
, -, ,
;
.
-
() ( , ).
, , ,
. -, .
. 18 1864 ; 3. ;
. ( -) ,
.
, ,
. -
-
.
, ,
. ( );
.

, ( ); , - .
32 ,
. , , , .
, ,
,
.
,
- . 6 2008
. .
3
-:
(, 1994), 6070- . I (., 1999)
, .-.. .

107

 14 3 2011

, , , -, . , , , , , 4.
- (
),
.
,
( ). , .
(
);
. ( 1860- .), - (18771878 .), . - ( 1920- .) (1930- .).
.
-
; -
. , , ,
.
- : , ,
, . ,
, , 5.
- , . ; - , , . - ;
.
- 30
1920 . , , 6.
, , 1 ( ), 10 2008.
, 1 1918.
6
.: .. :
(19171991 .). , 2009. . 29.
4
5

108

14 3 2011

. -
.
1923 , ,
. . , -, ;
. ,
1924 .
, , , ,
.
.. , 1 ( ), . 7. , 28 2004 2- .. .. .. , 29370/5908/8.
, . ,
, 12
.
1920- . 300 , . .
. , - 31 1 1937
, , . 14 . 3% 9; . , : ,
10. , .
1980- -
- .
( 1), , 1937 .
, 1937
. (1903 . , . - ),
. 24 1937 ,
16 1989 . .
29 1937
. (1875 . , . ); 14
.: .. : , , ., 2005.
. . 159.
9
.: . (. ). - : . .:
, 1991. . 4647.
10
. . 47.
7
8

109

 14 3 2011

, 25 1937 ,
16 1989 .
.. (1861 . , , . ).
, , -, 1930 , . 16 1989 .
1989 . -, , .
13 1938 . (1900 . , .
), .
13 1938 , 5 ,
( 16 1989 .).
,
.

,
. .
23 1944 ; . ,
. ,
, . ,
.
,
- . , , .
-
, -, , . . ,
11.
, -,
.. :
. . , ,
, , , , 12.

- ;
11
12

, 15 1987.
.. . .: . , 1984. . 193.

110

14 3 2011

, , ( ). ( ),
12 ..
.

: , ,
.
19891990- , ,
. , , .
, ,
, . , (), 1990 . ,
.
1991
, -
. ,
.
:
,
.
, ,
.
1992 . . , .-. , , - .
, .-. . , ,
.
.
.
1992 . 13.
, . ,
13

.: . ? // -, 24 1992.

111

 14 3 2011

.
, .
.-. ;
. ,
, . . , .-. :
,
. , , , , .

1990- . . ; ,
, (,
. , , ).
,
, - ,
1994 .
, (, - -) 14
1998 , - 14.
,
, , .
, , .

, - . , (- , -). ;
, . , ,
.

() , 14
.: .. : . /: -
, 2004. . 159.

112

14 3 2011

. ,
.
.
. - ,
, .
, . , , .

;
. ;
, , , , , .
, ( , ), .
, , .
. ,
, , 15.
. . 16. , .
, : , , , .17; , .
(1) (.. - ) , . (), ()18.
1990- ,
. , . , , . , , . , . , ,
, .
: , 19.
15
. ( ) // . VI.
, 1782. . 15.
16
.: . . : -
, 1973.
17
. . . . 15.
18
.
19
.: . : // : . .: -, 1999. . 6970.

113

 14 3 2011

() , -20.
.. ,
, 21.
,
. .
. , ,
-.
- ,
, , . , ; .
. , 135 22;
4 . , 80% : 60%
( -), 20% . 15% , 5% .
. , ;


. ,
, .
,
.

.
.
: ? .
, ,
, , . , , . . .
.: .. : , . ... . . . , 2010.
22
.: . . . ..
282 , - , . 20 , : (), 11
(), 1 (), (), (), 11 () . , , ,
.
20
21

114

14 3 2011

, -
.
,
.. ( , )
: ,
. .
, ,
, . , , - .
,
, .
, , ( ); ,
. ,
, ,
.
, , , . , , , ,
(, , ), ,
.
- ,
. : , , , . . , , , , , .
; .
, ,
, , , (.. ), ,
.
,
( 1990- . 2000- .) ,
, .
,
, , .
-
,
.
,
115

 14 3 2011

, - . , ; .

, ,
( ). , . , , ;
. , , .

, ,
.

. .. : , , , - : , , ,
, , , 23.
, , , , . ,
, , .
-, --, , -, - . , ,
-. ,
. , 2006
300 . ; , . , , .
. , - , , , ; ,
.
. 23

.. IV . ., 1999. . 12.

116

14 3 2011

, . ,
, , , .
,
, . , - .
.
,
, , . 1990- 2000- .. .

-


- ,
, . .. ; - .
- , - - ,
( -), .
, , , , - .
: , , , ,
.
, ,
. - ; . , .
, ; , .
; , 300 . . .
117

 14 3 2011

, , .
. ; , .
- ,
. , - ,
.
, , ,
(
). ( );
.
, .
,
.
- .-. . , , ,
. , ,
, , .
- , . . (
) . , .
27 2011 , ,
!
!; . , , , . ,
.
; , ,
, ,
., .
- ,
-, , .

, ,
118

14 3 2011

, . .
, , , , ; , , . - , - - .
, ,

; , .
, ,
, , . , ,
,
- . , , ,
40% .
( , )
. , , -
,
.

119

 14 3 2011

:
, ,

, ,

(, )

() , - , ,
,
.. - ,
-

.
20082011
( ; , ; , ;
)
, .

120

14 3 2011

2007
2010 . ,

, , .

, , ,
.
-1
, ;
,
,

..
,
, , , , .
20082011 2. ( ,
,
, , ,
,
, .
2
.: Clarke S., Pringle T. Can Party-led Trade
Unions Represent Their Members? // Post-Communist
Economies, 2009, Vol. 21, No. 1. P. 85101; .. -
// , 2009, 1. . 6370; ..
//
- ,
2010, . 10, 4. . 7983; ..
- //
, 2009, 5. . 27
31; .
. .: . , 2010.
. 346349; .
1

,
, .)
3.
( ,
)
()4
.

;
,
.
, ,
-
( , ).

(, , , , ), (, , ) ,

().
: . .:
c . , 2010. . 2326.
3
., : . ( ) // , 1999, 6; . - // , 2000, 4 (10); .
// , 1997, 2;
. : // ,
2000, 4 (10); .
80- 90- //
, 1998, 14; .
: // ,
2000, 4 (10), .
4
.

121

 14 3 2011

,
- .
:
. ,
,

-, ,
;
-, ,
, ,
-, -
.

1.


- ; , (
.. ) ( ,
).
;
, , . ( )5; 1992 , 1993 , 1994 , 1998
, 2000 .
, .
, 6.
7.

,
.
. (
, - ).
5
.: // - [www.parliament.am].
6
.: // - [www.dem.az].
7
.: // -
[www.fprk.kz].

122

14 3 2011

, XXII
()
20102015 8. (),
, 26 ,
95 131 .
, 2010 .
.
. ,
- ,

9.
( )

, .
, 2010 17 678 89 939 , 19,7% .
40% ( : 52, 72, 78, 80,
80,1, 82)10.
, , . -.
,
,
.

. ,
( ,
)11.
;
.: 20102015 . 3 2010 . [www.fprk.kz].
.: Labor Law of Islamic Republic of Afghanistan, 7 February 2007 // Web-site of International Labor
Organization (ILO) [www.ilo.org].
10
.: , 12 2010 // - [www.azertag.com].
11
.: , 24 2010
[www.vkp.ru].
8
9

123

 14 3 2011

- ,
, ,
12.

(, .. ). , , . ,
2010 13, : ,
.
, 2011 ;

, , , 14.
2011 () - 15.
,

, ,
() . , (
, ) ,
16.
,
, , .
( ) : 19401950 .
, 79 (1946 .) , 109 (1958 .) , .


, ,
12
.: ..
.
, 12 2010 // - - [www.press-service.uz].
13
Afghanistan Adopts First Ever Decent Work Country Programme, 17 July 2010 [www.ilo.org].
14
.: ,
10 2011 [www.fprk.kz].
15
.: , 6 2011 [www.sfp.uz].
16
.: , -, 6 2011 [www.vkp.ru].

124

14 3 2011

, , 17.
, ,
(20082010 .).

, ; ();
() .
- .
, - , , . ( : 2,5 .
, . 60% ; 85%
18.)

2. ,


, ,
(), ().
, , -
, 2011 ( 9,6% 9,7%)19.
(
15% 11%).
, - , .
, ( , ,
52%20, 75%21). , , 17
.: .. , 24 2008 // - [www.akorda.kz].
18
.: .. // , 2009, 4. . 86.
19
.: // , 2011, 5.
. 43.
20
.: . , //
, 2011, 4. . 50.
21
.: Georgia: Labor Code Tears Fundamental Rights to Shreds // Web-site of International Trade Union
Confederation [www.ituc-csi.org].

125

 14 3 2011

, , . , . ( ,
.)

. ,
, , .. ,
. , .
, (, 300 . 1 ,
, ,
)22.
-
.
20102011 ( ) ; , , - (
)23.
. , ,
, .
, 20082011 ( , ) , , , , , ,
.
. , , , , . ( , ; ,

; 1983 20% , 2007
12%24. 22
.: , 4
2011 [www.fprk.k].
23
.: // , 2011, 5.
. 44.
24
.: The Changing Union Movement, 15 September 2009 // Web-site of U.S. Department of State
[ipdigital.usembassy.gov].

126

14 3 2011

,
.)
( , , )
( )25.
,
,
. , .
20082011
. , , ,

26. ( ), ..
, , ; ,
27. , 28.
- , 29.
? , ,
30. , . Global Unions Database,

31.
, - . , , ,
,
32,
. -
, , , , , .
25
.: . // , 2011, 4. . 27.
26
Serious Workers Rights Problems in Armenia, 8 April 2010 [www.ituc-csi.org].
27
Georgia: Life Toll to Neo-liberal Success Policies, 4 February, 2011 [www.ituc-csi.org].
28
.: Georgias Anti-Union Laws Prompt EU Probe Push, 8 June 2011 [www.ituc-csi.org]; Georgia
Violation of the Fundamental Trade Union Rights of the Communication Workers Trade Union [www.ituccsi.org].
29
.: //
, 2011, 3. . 14.
30
.: . . .
31
.: Afghanistan [www.younionize.info].
32
.: .. VII // -
[premier.gov.ru].

127

 14 3 2011

3.


?
, ,
.
, , , , , , .
, , - , ( )
33.
, -
, -
, - . ,
.

, , .
n

-, .

-, , , ,
; , . ( ,
,
34.)

,
,
. ,
(.. , 35)
, .
33
.: , 15 2010 //
- [www.kremlin.ru].
34
.: , , , 27 2011 [www.vkp.ru].
35
.: The Global Unions Washington Declaration. Trade Union Statement to the G20 Crisis Summit in
Washington, 15 November 2008; Global Unions London Declaration Statement to the London G20 Summit;
Global Unions Pittsburgh Declaration. Trade Union Statement to the Pittsburgh Summit 2425 September
2009 // Web-site of the Trade Union Advisory Committee (TUAC) [www.tuac.org].

128

14 3 2011

, ,
.
;
.
,
- . ,
,
- .
, , . ,
18821924 (
1895 .),
, . , ( ), , - , ,
, - - . , ,
36.
, .
.
. 37, (, , , , .)
, , .
,
, , , , , .
,
;
, ,
.: The Changing Union Movement, 15 September 2009 [iipdigital.usembassy.gov].
., : ( 12- . , 1619 2011) // , 2011, 6. . 4243; The Athens Manifesto // Web-site
of the European Trade Union Confederation [www.etuc.org].
36
37

129

 14 3 2011

38. ( , , , - . ,
. -
- 39.)
. , 1987 ,
2007 40, 41.
, , ,
( , 111 ).
2011
42.
( ) ( ,
)
. (, ) , , .
,
43
44.
, - . ( ..
)
, ,
, 45, ( );
38
, ,

.
39
.: . // , 2011, 4. . 46.
40
.: Labor Law of Islamic Republic of Afghanistan, 7 February 2007.
41
.: Ordinance No. 103 of the Presidium of the Revolutionary Council of the Democratic Republic of
Afghanistan to adopt the Labor Code [www.ilo.org].
42
.: New Project to Improve Afghan Labor Laws and Administration, Promote Decent Work, 2 June
2011 [www.ilo.org].
43
.: .. XXI ,
31 2005 // - [www.akorda.kz].
44
.: . ,
, 2
2011 // - [www.jahonnews.u].
45
.: ,
31 2010 [www.vkp.ru].

130

14 3 2011

. ,
.

; , . : , .
;
2008
46.
, ,
( , , ). , , , 47,
. -
,
.
- 48.
(, ,
- 49).
, , , (
, 60
,
).
, , ( ) , . ; ( ) ..
50.

, , 46
.: , 15 2010 [www.vkp.ru].
47

-, 28 2011 [www.vkp.ru].
48
.: .
49
.: -, 17 2011 [www.vkp.ru].
50
.: , , , (.: , 2010 [www.vkp.ru]).

131

 14 3 2011

. .
; ,
, . , .
,
,
.

,
,
- (),
(IPSA)
(, )
,

, 1.
.

.
-

1
.: . // , 2001,
5. . 54.

132

14 3 2011

, ,
, ( , , , ),
/ .
2
,
2
.: .. //
. .. , 2007, . 8, 35. . 54
64; .
// : , 2008, . 4, 4. . 1840;
. : // , 2009, 6. . 1730; ..
: // ( ), 2009, 2. . 7795;
.. 2000- .: // . . . , 2009, 4 (102). . 3849; ..
: //
, 2008, 3 (33). . 411; .., . : , , // , 2004, 4. . 89 .

, -
.
, -,
- - ,
; , ,
. ,
, . (-, -), , ,

.

19881991 . , .
3 3
( . ivil + . archy) , , . , , . -

133

 14 3 2011

.
, 4, , /.

.
5, ,
6.
,
.
n

-, - - .

-, 7 8 .
/

, .

-, ,
.

-, , .

: - .

: () (.: .. : [http://www.espi.ru/Content/
Conferences/Papers2006/2006razd1/Aleksanyan.htm]).
4
. : . , . ., 2006. . 3.
. 179.
5
.. . ., 1883. . 2. . 332.
6
. . ., 2005. . 102.
7
. // . ., 1990. . 645.
8
. . ., 2001. . 135150.

134

14 3 2011

. ,
9 .
(
), , : , ( ) , , ,
, , () , , , / , , , , , , , 1 0 ..
.
, , . , , ( ) , ; , ,
. , , , ..
, , - ,
. , , . ,
, , . .
,
, , , - . . -
/ 9
.. .
.: : / . . .. . .,
2005. . 127.
10
.: Dahl R.A. Patterns of Opposition. .: Political Oppositions in Western Democracies. New Haven
London: Yale University Press, 1966, P. 342; Held D. Models of Democracy. Stanford, 1996; . : ? // , 2004, 4. . 54; .., . . .
. 627; .. // , 2004, 2. . 7684; .. // ,
2004, 2. . 6475; .. : // , 1996,
5. . 515; . . .

135

 14 3 2011

. , , , ,
.
- , , -, - ( ).
, , , . , , .
, .
11/
, .
.
- , - .
: , , , , . , ,
.
,
. , , ; , ; ; ;
; ..
-
.
. , .

( ), , 11
. : ;
; ; ; ; ; .

136

14 3 2011

, .
,
. , .
, . , .
;
. , . 12.
,
, -.
, , , : , , ; ,
, 13,
14.
, , . . , . , . , , . , ,
, . , ,
, . , , 15.

1980- (), 12
.: . // , 1997, 1. . 62; .. // , 2000, 3. . 104; .. . . 127; . : // , 1997, 6. . 2527; . // , 1992, 12. . 84; ., .
: 20062007 // , 2008,
9. . 5874; .. // , 2008, 1. . 161179; .. // . , 2009, 34. . 22
36; .. // , 2009, 2. . 166171; ..
// , 2009, 2. . 816 .
13
. . XX . ., 2003. . 23.
14
. . .: . . . . ., 1995. . 224.
15
. . ., 1993. . 46; . . . . 278; . . ., 2003. . 262; .. . . 127; . // , 2004,
2. . 70.

137

 14 3 2011

().
.
, -
, 1980- .
, , 16.
. ,
, 17.

,
18.
, - ,
.



; .

- ,
, - , 1920 .
1918-
, - , (, , ,
..)19; . , , , .
. , , , , 20. , ,
.
.. . ., 1987. . 27.
.
18
. . 28.
19
.: . . , 1982. . 153263; . . ., 1990. . 7. . 125126 .
20
. . ., 1996. . 167.
16
17

138

14 3 2011

:
, , .
, (), (), :
21.
, 1990- ,
,
.
20 1990 :
() .
.
4 1990 . - ,
: (38 ), (11 ), (10 ), (10 ); ()
(12 )22.
,
; 23 1990 ,
. 21 1991 ()
.
,
.
23 .

1995 , . 1991
- - (, - - ). , 20
- . / 1995 , . . . 46.
17 1990
(26 ) (31 ), 6 1991 (25 ) (21 ). 28 1991
(10 ) ([.: [http://www.parliament.am]).
23
.: .. . . . 6.
21
22

139

 14 3 2011

. , 19951998 ,
.
19951999
. 190 (150 40
)
(. . 1).
1

1995 24

1.

20

50

2.

20

3.

15

4.

-
()

7,5

5.

()

7,5

6.

( )

31

7.

( )

17

* .

1995 25 :
, , 26.
, 1991
,
[http://www.parliament.am].
(31 ). 21
- .
(17 ) (.: [http://www.parliament.am]).
26
.. . ., 2003. . 165.
24

25

140

14 3 2011

. 1996 ,
, .
1995
, 2005 . , , 27.
1998
, . -28, , , - . , , ,
, 1995 .
1999 , -
. , ( 131 75 , 56
), 5%- 6 :
41,69% (29 ), 12,09% (8 ),
7,96% (6 ), 7,86% (5 ), 5,28% (4 ) 5,17% (4 )29.
, ; .
, . , 1999 , ()
(). .
. . 27 1999 , , .
. ( . ). 2003 , ,
, , 13,71% (. . 2).
,
, . ,
, .
, , 2007 . , (
) . , ,
. . . . 228.
.. . . . 184.
29
[http://www.parliament.am].
27
28

141

 14 3 2011

,
,
, 2003 30

23

23,66

1.

2.

14

13,71

3.

12

12,60

4.

11

11,45

5.

8,91

6.

5,67

, , (. . 3).
3
, ,
, 2007

30

1.

2.

64
(458 258)

33,91

25
(204 483)

15,13

3.

16
(177 907)

13,16

4.

8
(95 324)

7,05

5.

[http://www.parliament.am].

142

7
(81 048)

6,00

14 3 2011

2008
.. , 52,82% . , .
. , ,
(. . 4).
4
,
19 2008

( %)

1.

862,369
(52,82)

2.

351,222
(21,50)

3.

272,427
(17,70)

4.

100,966
(6,20)

5.

21,075
(1,30)

6.

9,792
(0,60)

7.

7,524
(0,46)

8.

4,399
(0,27)

9.

2,892
(0,17)

2008 , ;
(),
,
.


, .

143

 14 3 2011

, , , .
- ,
-,
.
, , ,
.
.
10 ,
70. , ; .

, ,
. , .
, ,
. , , ,
. , ,
.
, .
, .

2005 , .
, , , , - .
, ,
.
. .
144

14 3 2011

, , , .
, ,
- . - .
.

145

 14 3 2011

:

,


,


-
(, , )

, () ,
, .
,
,
,


.

-

- 1.

1
.: Mearsheimer J. A Realist View of China //
Conversations with History. Institute of International
Studies. UC Berkley, 8 April 2002; The Rise of China
Will Not Be Peaceful at All // The Australian, 18 November 2005; The Tragedy of Great Power Politics.
New York: W.W. Norton and Company, 2003; Blank St.
China, Kazakh Energy, and Russia: An Unlikely Mnage
Trois // The China-Eurasia Forum, 2005, Vol. 3, No. 3;
Russia, China, and Central Asia: The Strange Alliance //
The China-Eurasia Forum, Fall 2004; Cohen A. How the
Obama Administration Should Engage Russia // Prospects
for Engagement with Russia. Senate Foreign Relations
Committee Hearings, 19 March 2009.

146

14 3 2011

, , , ,
,
. , , .
-
- .
,
, , , .

, .

,
(
() ),
.

, .


.
; ;
; ; -

. , , ,

, .

:
; ,

;
, . ,
,
, -
, , , , .
,
, - ,

-
.
-

.
,
,
- .

(),

147

 14 3 2011

2. , , , ,
:

2
, , , ,
. () , , , , , .

.
,
- ,
:

, 3.
3
Weitz R. Averting a New Great Game in Central Asia // The Washington Quarterly, Summer 2006,
Vol. 29, No. 3.

?

,
, ,
4. - , :

. , , .

.
,
, .
5,
4
,
.
. , - , ,
.
5

, , ,
, , , , ,
.

148

14 3 2011

- . ,
,
. , , , [ ] ,
2000 6. 2000 :
7. ,
, 8.
9. , - :
10.
. , ,
, , , 11.
, , .
. ,
.
, ,
12. . .
13;
- , ,
14. .: . .. . , 2004. . 81.
, 2000 [http://www.nationalsecurity.ru/library/
00014/index.htm].
8
. // , 2000,
10 (155).
9
.: // , 24
2008 [http://www.rian.ru/defense_safety/20080524/108253521.html].
10
// , 23
2010 [http://rian.ru/politics/20101123/299979326.html].
11
. : // , 2004, 2. . 168 [www.globalaffairs.ru/number/n_2861]. .
.
12
, // , 27 2006
[http://rian.ru/society/20060927/54306767.html].
13
Bazhanov Ye. Russia Is Much Smarter This Time // The Moscow Times, 20 February 2009 [http://
www.moscowtimes.ru/article/1016/42/374713.htm]. .
.
14
Bazhanov Ye. The Illusory U.S.-Chinese Axis // The Moscow Times, 13 September 2009.
,
XVII (.: // , 15 2007 [http://rian.ru/politics/foreign/20071015/83877720.html]).
6
7

149

 14 3 2011

, [ ] 15.

, - - , .
.
, 2002 . ,
;
(TAPI),
;
. , .
, 16. 2002
, 17. - .
1972 , ,
, . - , -, .

-, , , . , ,
, , ,
[] 18. ,
[]19.
,
. Bazhanov Ye. China as a Partner, Not as a Threat // The Moscow Times, 25 March 2009.
Yeltsin Voices Concern at Growing U.S. Interest in North Caucasus // Deutsche Presse-Agentur, 20 August 1997.
17
.: Loeb V. Footprints in the Steppes of Central Asia: New Bases Indicate U.S. Presence will be Felt after
Afghan War // The Washington Post, 9 February 2002.
18
Trofimov D. Russian Foreign Policy Objectives in Central Asia // Russian Regional Perspectives Journal,
Vol. 1, Issue 2, The International Institute for Strategic Studies [http://www.iiss.org/programmes/russia-and-eurasia/
russian-regional-perspectives-journal/rrp-volume-1-issue-2/russian-foreign-policy-objectives-in-central-asia/]. . .
19
. : Zviagelskaia I. The Russian Policy Debate on Central Asia // Royal Institute of International
Affairs, 1995 [http://www.ca-c.org/dataeng/st_08_zvjag.shtml]. . .
15
16

150

14 3 2011

:
, , ,
, 20
, 1990-
, , ,
, , . , , ; 21.
,
,
. -
.

1998
. , , 22. :
[ ] , : , [] , .
. , : - [ ]23.
:
;
; ; ; 24.
,
, 20
2007 . [http://
www.mid.ru/brp_4.nsf/0/3647DA97748A106BC32572AB002AC4DD].
21
. : Loeb V. Op. cit.
22
The U.S. Role in Caucasus and Central Asia. Statement of Steve Sestanovich, Ambassador at Large for the
New Independent States. U.S. Department of State. Committee on International Relations, U.S. House of Representatives, 30 April 1998 [http://commdocs.house.gov/committees/intlrel/hfa50308.000/hfa50308_0f.htm].
23
Clinton Sees Areas of Disagreement with Russia // RFE/RL, 6 March 2009.
24
Blank St. American Grand Strategy and the Transcaspian Region // World Affairs, Fall 2000, No. 163.
P. 68.

151

 14 3 2011

: , 25
[ ], , , 26.
,
. , , . : , - [] , 27 [] 28.
, ,
, . , , ,
, ,
29.

, , .

,
; , , , .
11 2001
. ,

, , , [] 25
Rumer E. The U.S. Interests and Role in Central Asia after K2 // The Washington Quarterly, Summer
2006, Vol. 29, No. 3. . .
26
Ibidem.
27
US-Kyrgyz Relations Back on Solid Ground but for How Long? // Eurasia Insight, 23 August 2006
[http://eurasianet.org/departments/insight/articles/eav082306aa.shtml].
28
Washington Seeks to Steer Central Asian States towards South Asian Allies // Eurasia Insight, 28 April
2006 [http://eurasianet.org/departments/insight/articles/eav042806.shtml].
29
: // , 29 2006 [http://rian.ru/analytics/200608
29/53264829.html].

152

14 3 2011

30.
. , ,
31.
. ,
,
32; ,
, , , 33. ,
, ,
34, : ,
. 35. ,
,
, . 36. . : , 37.
, ,
2005 ,
, 2006 .

. 2006 : ,
. , 38.
2007 :

39. 30
Moscow on Washingtons Statements about Temporary Presence of U.S. Military Units in Central Asia //
CDI Russia Weekly, 25 January 2002, No. 190.
31
United States Expanded Influence Likely to Remain in Central Asia // The Associated Press, 12 March
2002.
32
Wright R. Powell Seeks Deeper U.S. Ties with Central Asian Nations // Los Angeles Times, 9 December
2001.
33
Secretary of State Colin Powell Testifying before the House International Relations Committee, 6 February 2002.
34
Anger Grows as U.S. Bases Spread // The Observer, 20 January 2002.
35
. : Auerback M. Putin and the Geopolitics of Oil // Prudent Bear, 30 August 2004 [http://www.
energybulletin.net/newswire.php?id=1858].
.
36
Russia Wary of Americas Stance on Military Bases // Telegraph, 10 January 2002; Q&A: U.S. Military
Bases in Central Asia // The New York Times, 26 July 2005.
37
Ibidem (. : [http://www.zatulin.ru/institute/sbornik/044/03.shtml]).
38
U.S. General Charges Russia, China Bullying Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan on Bases // Registan.net, 15 July
2005 [http://www.registan.net/index.php/2005/07/15/us-general-charges-russia-china-bullying-kyrgyzstan-uzbekistanon-bases/].
39
Pan Guang. Bishkek: SCOs Success in the Hinterland of Eurasia // The China and Eurasia Forum
Quarterly, 2007, Vol. 5, No. 4; ., : [http://infoshos.ru/ru/
?id=25].

153

 14 3 2011

[ ] : ,
? , [] 40
, 2008 , ,

, 41, ,
. ,
,
42
, 43. , , .
: , ,
: , 44.
, 2011 ,
, :
[ ] ,
?45

?
, ,
, .
,
. -
, , .
40
NATO Base in Afghanistan Gets Major Expansion // NPR, 11 July 2008 [http://www.npr.org/templates/
story/story.php?storyId=92427328].
41
// , 26 2008
[http://www.rian.ru/politics/20080826/150675270.html].
42
// , 5 2007 [http://
rian.ru/society/20071005/82583255.html].
43
Presence of U.S. Air Base in Kyrgyzstan is Fine if Temporary CSTO Chief // Eurasianet.org, 21 September 2007 [http://eurasianet.org/posts/092107kg.shtml].
44
Obama Loses a Key Base for Afghanistan // Time, 19 February 2009 [http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1880686,00.html].
45
Gutterman St. Russia Opposes Long-term U.S. Bases in Afghanistan // Reuters, 18 February 2011.

154

14 3 2011

, , [ ] , ,
,
, 46. , , . , .
, 47,
, , 48. , , ,
, ,
.

.
, .
,
, . , - ,
.
, , , ,

49.
, . , . , ,
,
.
50, , , 2003
, ,
46
Xing Guangcheng. Chinas Foreign Policy toward Kazakhstan. .: Thinking Strategically / Ed. by
R. Levgold. Massachusetts: MIT Press, 2003. P. 109, 112;
, .
47
. , , : , , //
, 2004, 5 (35). . 131140.
.
48
. , , : , , //
, 2004, 6 (36). . 102111.
49
Hu Jian. Cooperation, Competition, Conflict: China and the U.S. In Central Asia // China-Eurasia Forum,
April-May 2004 [http://www.silkroadstudies.org/new/docs/CEF/CEF_April_May.pdf].
.
50
Daly J. Sino-Kyrgyz Relations after the Tulip Revolution, Kyrgyzstan: US Ambassador Denounces Reports on AWACS Deployment // Ferghana.ru, 18 February 2005 [http://enews.fergananews.com/article.php?
id=821].

155

 14 3 2011

. , , [ ] 51.

-
, , , , , , ,
, 4 000- .
, , , ,
.
, ,
, . - ,

,
, 52, 53.
, , -
, ,
, ,
. , ,
, . - , . , ,
, ,
,
54.


55, 1,9 . 51
Russia Concerned about NATO AWACS Radar Planes Used in Georgia // The Russia Journal, 11 July
2003 [http://www2.russiajournal.com/node/15736].
52
// 22 2004 [http://vshu.ru/files/U1r12.pdf].
53
Address by the Ambassador of the Russian Federation H.E. Mr. Vyacheslav Trubnikov at the National
Defense College, 17 April, 2007 [http://rusembassy.in/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=90&I temid=
102&lang=en].
54
. , , : , , //
, 2004, 6 (36). . 108.
55
. . 103.

156

14 3 2011

,
.
, [] , 56.
, . []
(NED) , , , 57. , ,
,
,
, ,
. ,
58.

- . 2002 , 2011
59.
,
, ,
, , 60, ,
61 ,
, 2014
, 62.
, , , 2002 , , , -
56
Wu Xinbo. The Promise and Limitations of a Sino-U.S. Partnership // The Washington Quarterly, 2004,
Vol. 27, No. 4. P. 115126. ().
57
.: Mackerras C. Pivot of Asia Sees China-Pakistan Maneuvers // Asia Times Online, August 2004.
58
Xing Guangcheng. Op. cit.
59
.: On the Meeting of a U.S. State Department Official with Ilyas Akhmadov // Ministry of Foreign
Affairs of the Russian Federation, 25 January 2002 [http://www.mid.ru/bl.nsf/900b2c3ac91734634325698f002d9dcf/
52ba0078bbd9942a43256b4c004efaa1?OpenDocument];
// , 17 2011 [http://rian.ru/politics/20110217/335249020.html].
60
2007
61
. , // , 2004, 6.
62
, // , 26 2010 [http://rian.ru/defense_safety/20101026/289597331.html].

157

 14 3 2011

, ,
63.

,
, , 64. ,
, , ,

2005 .
, ,
. - , , - ,
, . :
. , 2011
5 . , , , 65.

, ,
. , . , , , .
- . , , .

63

2002.

Hahn G.M. The U.S., Russia and Untying the Gordian Unot in Pankisi // The Russia Journal, 7 March

2007
.: 5 // , 26 2011 [http://www.itar-tass.com/c96/151147.html].
64
65

158

14 3 2011

. ..
(, )

:
,

, ,
.
,


,
, ,
,

().
,

, ,
, .
, -

, - .
:
,
.


: .

,
()


.

.
-

159

 14 3 2011

.
.

-

.

20 . . , , . , , .
: ,
, .
1, , 114- ,

. , . 1999 , , , , - 2.
, , , . 1915 .
,
, .
1
10
.
2
.: Jones S. Turkish Strategic Interests in the Transcaucasus. .: Crossroads and Conflict: Security and
Foreign Policy in the Caucasus and Central Asia. London, 2000. P. 58.

160

14 3 2011

1990-

, , ( ),
( ).

.
, 1990-

, . , ,

( , ).

. . , 1989- 1993 ,

3. .
- .
.
, .
- (
, , ).
,
; , , , .
.
1. ; , , , ( )
.
3
Baran Z. Turkey and the Caucasus. .: Turkish Foreign Policy in Post Cold War Era. Boca Raton,
2004. P. 269.

161

 14 3 2011

2. , , , ,
4.

. ,
. ,
,
, .
, 1990- ,

, , .
,
( ) ,
-.

(, . ),
. , ,
,
.

, 1990- . . ; , , 5.
, , , ,
,
, . ,
, ,
.
, ,
,
.: Aydin M. Turkeys Caucasus Policies // UNISCI Discussion Papers, 2010, No. 23. P. 178.
Hale W. Turkey and Regional Politics after the Cold War: Central Asia and the Middle East. .: Turkish Foreign Policy, 17742000. London, 2000. P. 291.
4
5

162

14 3 2011

(, , ).
, , , . -,
(
), -, , , , , , .
, /
, .

( ,
..), , .
. , 1990- , .
, , , .
. . , ,
,
( ) 6.

, .

, -
,
.
, ,
, , .
.
,

, :
.
6
Cem I. Turkey in the 21st Century. Speeches and Texts Presented in International Fora (19952000).
Mersin, 2001. P. 26.

163

 14 3 2011

,
( 1990- ), (1996 .).
,
. , , .
, 1991- 1999 . 7
73 . , ,
, , ,
( , ,
).
11 1990 - , ,
. , 37 , , , - - (, , , , ).
. , / ( , , .);
8.
, 2003 20 , 10
, 4 , 3 ,
, -, , . ( ) 9. 7
,
. , . ,
,
. . , , 2000
. . . ,
,
. , , , ,
, .
8

.
9
.: . // , 2003, 6. . 22.

164

14 3 2011

.
.
,
. . 1990- 88 , 20 , 128 , 218 , 129 ,
, 17 ( ) . 250 .

. ( ), , , . -
(),
, . . . , 1990
2000 .

,
,
/ ,
,
. ( , ..)
. ,
.
. . (19891993 .)
. , ,
.
, ,
.
8 .
, .
: , ,
.
165

 14 3 2011

1 170 10, . - .
.

. , (
- , , ),
. , 1992 ();
.
,
, ,
(). ,
, , .
, , ,
. ,
,
.
, , ,
. , ,
, .
,
.

.
.
, 1994 300 407 783 317 ., 1997
87 494 243 948 .11 , .
,
. , . ,
, 12. ,
10
.: Aydin M. Between Euphoria and Realpolitik: Turkish Policy toward Central Asia and the Caucasus.
.: Turkeys Foreign Policy in the 21st entury: A Changing Role in World Politics. Burlington, 2003. P. 142.
11
.: Ibid. P. 141142.
12
.: Baran Z. Op. cit. P. 271.

166

14 3 2011

,
.
,
, . 1971 () 1990- (). , , ,
13.
, 1990-
, . ,
.

:
?
, ,
,
. 2001 14.
.

, , , (
, ,
).

. , ,
, , , . ,
15, 16.
13
.: . . : ? // , 2003, 9. C. 50.
14
.: Davutolu A. Stratejik Derinlik: Turkiyenin Uluslararasi Konumu (32. baski). Ist., 2009. (1- .
2001 .).
15
. ? . .: , 2010. . 13.
16
Kirisci K. The Transformation of Turkish Foreign Policy: The Rise of the Trading State // New Perspectives on Turkey, 2009, 40. P. 2957.

167

 14 3 2011

,
. , ,
, , .


. , ,
, ,
. , 17.
, ,
, , . ,
, , ,
18. ,
19.
( - ). ,
2000- .
,
, 2002 .
. ,
,
. (
,
) ( - ) .

, ,
,
.
17
.: Davutolu A. I Am Not a Neo-Ottoman // Todays Zaman, 25 November 2009; Kalin I. A NeoOttomanism // The Majalla [http://www.majalla.com/en/interview/article11115.ece].
- .
18
.: Larabbee S. Turkeys New Geopolitics // Survival, 2010, Vol. 52, No. 2. P. 160; Onis Z. The New
Wave of Foreign Policy Activism in Turkey // DIIS Report, 2009. P. 10.
19
.: , 15 2010 [http://ru.trend.az/regions/met/turkey/1751009.html].

168

14 3 2011

20.
: . , , , ,
.
,
.
.
2006
(). ,

. ,
.
- , :
,
, , , , , .

.
( 2005
).
-2. , ,
.

: , , .
, ,
, . ,
, , ,
21.
.: Temel I. Turkey: A New Actor in the Field of Energy Politics // Perceptions, March May 1996. P. 58.
.: Aydin M. Regional Security Issues and Conflicts in the Caucasus and the Caspian Regions. .:
International Security Challenges in a Changing World. Bern, 1999. P. 119120.
20
21

169

 14 3 2011

, . , , .
, .
, ,
.
, ,

,
.
-
.
, ,
, ,
.

.
,
,
.

( ),
.
, ,
, . ; , .
, ,
- ,
, . ,
, . , , , .

170

14 3 2011

,

(, )

10
() .
:
(), ,
.
20 --

.


- . ,
. , :
.

, ,
.
,
,
, .
,
,
, () ,
.
(,
, ), , : , , , 171

 14 3 2011

, , ,
..1
.. ,
, ,
2.

? , - ,
, , , . ,
.
.
.
, , , , , , ..
, ,
.
,
. , , , -
. , ; , (, , ).
.
. , ,
. . , , .
, , , , , , -

.
,
,
- XXI .
1
.: Kohout J.J. III, et al. Alternative Grand Strategy Options for the United States // Comparative Strategy, 1995, Vol. 14. P. 361420.
2
. : Ibid. P. 363.

172

14 3 2011

( ,
), , , , , , , , , , , ,
. , , ,
, . , , , ,
.
, , -,
(, , , .),
-, , -,
, -,
, . .

-

( )
.
-
(). ,
, .
, , N- , , a priori
, (
).
, , , - , ;
. , 3.
, ,
, .
.
, , , :
3

.: . . .: , 1998.

173

 14 3 2011

. .
, , , . , - , , ,
( ). , ,
N, .
, ipso facto ,
. ,
Pax Democratica. ,
:
. ,
.
(
) . , , (
).
,
, ,
, .

( ) .
- .
-
, , , .
.

, (, , , ) ,
.
.

, ,
174

14 3 2011

. .
:
, , . , , , .

.
, , ,
:
n

-,
;

-,
.

,
, , : ,
, , .
, , ,

,
.
. .
,
,
. , ,
,
.
, , ,
.
, ( , , , ), , .
, : , , Pax Democratica.
. : , 175

 14 3 2011

, , , 4.

, , .
, -
. .
,
.

- , .
1. . , , :
, , . , , , .
, ,

.
, . : ,

, 5.
. , ,
, ,
. 6.

. . .

: ,
. , (Heartland),
4
. XXI : , .
: , 1997. . 310.
5
. 25 1998 .
6
.: Stobdan P. Central Asia in Geopolitical Transition Period // Strategic Analysis, April 1998.

176

14 3 2011

.
, ,
.
, ,
Heartland, . - . , ,
. ,
. , ,
7.
.
n

-, ( ) , , .

-, - :
,
.

, ,
, .
, ,
, .
, ,
1996 . , , , , , , , , , , , .


,
.

, , , :
.
1997 , ( )
. ,
, 2000

, , .
,
.
7

, 25 1993.

177

 14 3 2011

, ,
. , .
2. . , , . ,
. , (
oikumene ),
, 1991 . (, .) ; ,
( ) .
, , 1990- . () , 8.
, , , (
).
.
n

-,
- (
).
,
.

-, , , - .
, , , .

-, , , ; ,
- . , , , ,
, , . . ,
, , , ( ).

8
.: . //
, 2002, 2 (20).

178

14 3 2011

. 28 1995:
,
, ... ,
9.
3. . , ,
. ,
.
. .
n

-, ,
,
. , , ,
, ,
. .

-, , ;
.
?

, , -, ,
, , , , . , ,
, .

,
, .
,
. ,
.
, , . ,
, , :
, .
9
. // , 28 1995.

179

 14 3 2011

,
, :
. , ,
, . (
, .)

.


:
1) ;
2) ,
;
3) ,
;
4) .

- . , , . :
.
,
,
. () , ( . )10. , :
, . ,
.

. 2002 .

: , , ,
, 10
.: Buzan B. People, States and Fear. An Agenda for International Security Studies in the Post-Cold War
Era. Lynne Rienner Publisher, Boulder, Colorado, 1991. P. 190.

180

14 3 2011

.
11.
, .
.
n

-, (
), .

-, : , - , ,
.

Si vis pacem, para bellum ( ) . , .

, ,
. ,
, .
,
, ,
.
, . , friktion ( ,
). :
? ?
?
, , , , . ,
, , ,
.
, , friktion,
, ,
11

, 25 2002 [www.rg.ru].

181

 14 3 2011

. ,
, .
,
. , , 2002 , -
Pax Democratica.

182

14 3 2011

( )


(, )

(
,
..) , , . ,
, , -1
. ( ) , -

. , ,
.

(), 2010
2,8 87,8
. , 2011

90 1. ,
1
.:
[http://top.rbc.ru/economics/
10/02/2011/541284.shtml].

183

 14 3 2011

, - 20082009 .

,
. Exxon-Mobil,


,

.


2. , 2000 2030
,
26% ( 2005 .
21%)3.

.
. 1970 ( ) 70:30, 1990
55:45; 2009

(50:50).
, 2009 187,43 ;

63 4.



-,
, . 2
[http://www.vz.ru/economy/
2011/1/27/464186.html].
3
.: .
4
.: // Dolgikh Natural Gas Research [http://dolgikh.com/index/
0-39].

() , .


,
.
-, , , .
2003

(
2008 .
147 .), ( ), , , ,
.
,
,
,
.

, .


. ,
,
.
, : Wikileaks, 10
12 ,
12,5 5.
5
.: Wikileaks:
40%, 9 2011
[http://top.rbc.ru/economics/09/02/2011/540527.shtml].

184

14 3 2011

1.

,
.

, , .
, ,
;
.
British Petroleum, ,
, 2010
6 (. . 1).
1

, .
, . ./

39,8

0,6

0,6

1 682

206

107

260

120

101

, . ./

, .

1,82

8,10

1,68

, .

32,2

36,4 (59,5)

64,4

, .

19,6

19,8

48,7

, :

5 , 31,4
( : 1 = 159 ).

3 . .

.: BP Statistical Review of World Energy, June 2010 [www.bp.com/statisticalreview/].

185

 14 3 2011

17 (107 ).

1217 (2/3
).

8 . .

65 .

27 . 7.

5 (31,4 ).

530 (3,3 )

5 . .

3,4 . .

3,5 .

60 . 8.

1520 . .
1,52 (9,412,5 )9.
2010 47 .
(- ),
22,5 .
. 2010- (11 . ).

, .
British Petroleum . , .

Energy Information Administration () 2004 .
7
.: 19- [http://www.mioge.ru/
RU/world/kioge/].
8
.: 15- [http://www.expoplus.ru/index_print.php?id=9153].
9
.: TGC 2011 2-
[http://www.turkmenexpo.ru/db/exhibition/view/7513/].

186

14 3 2011
2

(2004 .)
,

3,6

1213

59,469

0,10,237

12

910

0,0948

6,58

3,94

2627

7585

3

(2004 .)10

,
.

,
.

,
.

22,5

10

20

2123

55

2,53

59

8,79,7

3739

134135

, , , .
, ().
. . Gaffney, Cline & Associates, 4 14 .
300 (
).
,
.
, ,
: ,
.
10
, , Energy Information Administration ().

187

 14 3 2011

2.


,
, . - , 2008 .

, , , ( 1,9 )11.
, ,
(
), , , . , 2021
2005 75% ( 1 . ). , 2004
, 2007 12.
, ; , () , . 15 2010 ,
.
, 34 574 . ( 28 ) .
.
,
, 2014 ( 67 ); 5,4 .
, , 13.
11
, [http://www.ereport.ru/articles/commod/
oilcount.htm].
12
.: . , 2009 [http://www.berg-privileg.
com/archive/detail.php?ID=278].
13
.: . : , , 24 2010 [http://www.
kmg.kz/press/market_news/analytics/4857].

188

14 3 2011

, , . ,
24% , , : , 2020 28%.
, .


. , ( 2022 .).
30% .
,
. 60%
, 2030
8189%14.
2010 4% ( 176 . )
34% ; 23% , , , 19%, 10% 6%15.

. , , ,
- . , , (, , , .)
.
20082009 . , - 2009 44 .
( 7%) 555 . . .
, . , 2009
3,4%, . 12,7%16.
,
.
14
.: 90% 2030 , 16 2010 [http://www.goodvin.
info/news/biznes/17610-es_prognoziruet_uvelichenie_importa_gaza_do_90_k_2030_godu.html].
15
.: 2010 7,2%, 9 2011 [http://www.rbcdaily.ru/
tek/partnernews/151904.shtml].
16
.: . , 24 2010 [http://www.newsru.com/finance/24may2010/gaz.html].

189

 14 3 2011

, 30 .
; 10,5 ( :
2009 . 48 . ). ,
.
, (, , ) , , 17.
- . ( )
; 100 . .
: . ,
.
, ,
.
, , .

. , 10 11,2%,
,
. ,
.

. .
. 1, ,
18.
. ,
,
( , ), .
,
, (
).
. , , , ,
. , 17
.: , 22 2009 [http://lenta.ru/news/2009/12/
22/january/].
18
.: : ? // ,
2009 [http://www.finansy.ru/publ/mirec/003ress2.htm].

190

14 3 2011
1

120

..

.
8,6
8,4

100

8,2
80

8,0
7,8

60

7,6

40

7,4

20
0

7,2
1995

2000

2001

2002

2003

2004

7,0

(..)
100 (.)
:

The European Futomobile Manufacturers Association (ACEA).

, : , .
. , . ,
, 19.

3.

, ,
.
,
.
19
.: , 26 2010 [http://lenta.ru/
news/2010/01/26/reasons/].

191

 14 3 2011

, . ,
, 2003 .
, , , . , ; .
, () 8,7% 2011
8,4% 2012 ( : 2011 . 2,8%,
1,4%, 1,8%). , 2011
2012 9,6% 9,5%.
, , 2016
( ,
2030 .). , c 2011 2016 11,2 .
19 . ( : 18,8 .
15,2 . 2011 .). ,
2016 17,7%, 18%20.
2
, 19912011 *
12,000

. .

10,000

8,000

6,000
4,000

2,000
0
1991

1993

1995

1997

1999

2001

2003

2005

2007

2009

2011

* .
:

20

EIA International Energy Statistics;

Short-Term Energy Outlook (September 2010).

.: , 26 2011 [www.vesti.ru/doc.html].?id=448206&cid=6].

192

14 3 2011

,
: 31% , 30% , 27%
40% . 1 . 4,7
, , 7,7 , , 11,5 , 21 ( ).
,
, . 2004 (210 )
,
189 .
, ,
, .
2020
(36 ).
. XVII 12- (2011
2015 .). , . 2020 15%

40%45%.
3
,
19892009 *
3,500

3,000

2,500
2,000
1,500
1,000
500
0
1989

1991

1993

1995

1997

1999

2001

2003

2005

2007

2009

* 2008 2009 .
:

EIA International Energy Statistics.

21
.: .., ..
, [http://iseswe.org/geo_pol.htm].

193

 14 3 2011

: , , .
; 2015
3,9 8,3%,
.
: , 2015
67% 22.

;
, . -
, , ,
.

. 2010 2,972 ., 2009 34,7%.
1,577 . ( 31,3%),
1,394 . ( 38,7%).
2010 (
479,7 ., 31,8%), ( 385,34 ., 29,2%)
( 299,77 ., 30,2%)23.
,

.
2009 35% ,
60% (
80%).

4.



, .
22
.: 12- ,
-2, 14 2011 [energyfuture.ru].
23
.: 3 [http://www.vz.ru/news/2011/1/
11/460101.html].

194

14 3 2011

,
, , .
, , ,
, , , , .
, , -; ,
. , , , , .
:
.
: (, ) , ,
- .
, , , ,
, .
. , . , ( ) , . ,
.

.
, .
, , .
, -
. , ,
; .
, .

: , .
195

 14 3 2011

. , 10 . 24.
, 40 . ;
20 . ( 10 . ),
60 . .
,
, 1020 . .
CNPC
.
, , ,
, . , .
: 2009 4 . 2011
4,1 .25 .
. The Financial Times, (China Development Bank China Export-Import Bank) 20092010
110 . ( :
2008 2010 100,3 .).
,
.
, , 2,5 .26

,
, . , , ,

.

, .
24
.: 1,5 10 ,
30 2011 [http://www.upmonitor.ru/news/russia/910554a/].
25
.: , NABUCCO, 27 2011 [www.regnum.ru/news/1399160.html].
26
.: , 18 2011 [http://
lenta.ru/news/2011/01/18/lending/].

196

14 3 2011

, ,
: , .
,
.

:


,
-
(, )

, , , .
.
:
1)
1990- , 1989 .

2) 2016
.
, ,


:
? ? ?

,
.

.
197

 14 3 2011

.
( ) ; 1990- 1.
1989 ( ,
)2 , .
.
.

.
19921994 : 1015% .

. ;
1) () 7 1993 3.
2) 9 1997 - .
, , .

,
.
-
,
45 80%, .
1 . , .
1
, . 1993
. 1992- .
2
1988
, . , .
3
, 4 .

198

14 3 2011

: 14
(1 000 . 180 ., ).
, (. . 1)4, , 2016
.
1

1 000

2016

5-

440 M

2011 ()

300 M

2010

1 100

200

2,3 .

2008

: . , , .

,
2,3 . ( ), , ( 130 .)6.
,
: ?
4
.: . -
// 21- , 2008, 4 (22). C. 23 ( . .).
5
, , , , , . ( .: Hydropower Potential of Armenia
[http://www.renewableenergyarmenia.am/], 22 2011).
6
.: . , 2 2008 //
Deutsche Welle [http://www.dw-world.de/dw/article/0,,3843202,00.html], May 2011.

199

 14 3 2011

,
, . 1 . ,
, 3 . . , ,
.
,
1994 ,
, ,
. 1990-
, 10 . , , .
, , .
2004 -
; 2008 .

,
. .
1. .
2. .
, .
n

-, ( 2,3 . ),
, .
, ; , .

-, , ,
( - ), . , ,
( ).

, . , -,
; -, , ,
, - ; -,
.
,
.

.
200

14 3 2011

;
, ,
.
, ( ).
,
, 20 4 7.
: - ,
, : - . ,
,
.

:


, 1995 , . 30 40% ,
8, .
1990-
,
,
.
2003 ,
, , .
7
,
.
2007 , ,
? ,

(, - ).
7
.: Iran Country Analyses Brief (2010) Energy Information Administration [http://www.eia.doe.gov/
cabs/Iran/pdf.pdf. P.11], 21 May 2011.
8
8% .

201

 14 3 2011

;
, .
6- . , , , , - 9. ,
.
2005 , ,
. :
2006 . 10.
, , : 2011
5- 440 , -440.
, , ; , (
400 ).
(
).
29 2007 .
, 2012- 2016 , 20162048 , ,
11.
27 2009
, 1 200 .
. : , , , .. -
. : .
, , 10 9
.: //
, 8 2004 [http://rian.ru/economy/20040708/629389.html], 22 2011.
10
.: . // , 22 2006, 093 (479).
11
.: //
, 27 2007 [http://www.armtown.com/news/ru/pan/20071129/24225/], 26 2010.

202

14 3 2011

, . , , , , , 12.

, , . , , , - ; - , . ,
.
.
n

,
.

, .

, , .

.
, , .
, :
5000 ( 1500 ).

- . 3 2009
. . , ( 1 060 , 60 ) . - . , 13.
,
5 . , , , , .
. , 20 2010 ,
14.
. , , 19 2009.
[http://www.regnum.ru/news/1231523.html].
14
, 5 .
(.: // , 21 2010, 153 (4453)).
, -
-1000.
12
13

203

 14 3 2011

20% ,
15.
2011 , . , , , , ; . , 2016
( )
.

. , , , 16.
, 5 10
( )

. , 2016
,
.

. , 1988 , (
) , .

- . , ( ) : , ,
, .
, , .
, , , 17.
: .
. ( ), 10 - ( 1990- .). 15
.: 20% // Radio Liberty
Armenia [http://www.azatutyun.org/articleprintview/2133108.html], 17 2011.
16
.:
[http://www.atominfo.ru/news4/d0761.htm], 1 2011.
17
?
[http://news.am/rus/news/54459.html], 1 2011.

204

14 3 2011

,
, ,
, . , ,
,
18.
. , , . ,
19,
.

. ,

.

. :
- 20 2011 . :
, . , 20.
, ,
, . ,
. ,
, ,
21.
,
,
. -
, 1995 ; .

15
, . 18
Brown P. EU Halts Aid to Armenia over Quake-zone Nuclear Plant // The Guardian, Wednesday, 2 June
2004; Lavelle M., Garthwaite J. Is Armenias Nuclear Plant the Worlds Most Dangerous?, 1 April 2011 [http://
news.nationalgeographic.com/news/energy/2011/04/110412-most-dangerous-nuclear-plant-armenia/], 1 May 2011.
19
.: [http://www.georgiatimes.info/news/
55176.html], 1 2011; [http://www.rosbalt.ru/kavkaz/
2011/03/21/830475.html], 1 2011.
20
[http://www.
panarmenian.net/rus/economy/news/67727/], 1 2011.
21
9 [http://www.newsarmenia.
ru/society/20110315/42413102.html], 1 2011.

205

 14 3 2011

; ,
. ,
, ,
.
, . .
; , , .
, , . : .

206

14 3 2011

, ,



(, )

,

(, )

. ( 1 . )
( ,
,

, ,
, .).
,

? , ?
, ,
?

.

207

 14 3 2011

, . , - ,
(, ), , , , .
, , .
43 ,
. (15)
(14 2 ); 12,
2.
:
, . ,
: - ,
- .
, 80 , , ; (31 ), (28 ) (27 ).
, ,
, , , , .
,
. , .

, , , , . ,
.
, , ,
.
. , ,
,
.
, . , , , .

, . , ,
,
.
208

14 3 2011

.

.
; .

. , . - , , , ,
.
,
: , . 64 . , 100 .;
.
, 0,5%. , , , 2%1. ,
. , ,
.

, .
1. ( ).
.
2.
( ). .
3.
, .
1
.: 2009. . .:
, - , 2009.

209

 14 3 2011

4. , -
. , , . .

, , , , -
, , , .
2003 2, 10 . , , . .
1215 2010 - , . 100
12 , , -,
3.
, , , , , , , ,
.

,
. , , : , , , . ,
, .
,
, . . 2
.: : ,
. , , , 14 2003 , .
3
[http://www.world-russian.com/forum/680/18686].

210

14 3 2011

, .
, .
. , .
, , , (,
), , .
,
.
.
, 10%.
- , , , . :
, .
, : , , .

,



: .
, , , . ,
, . ,
,
, .
, , , . , , .

( ),
.
211

 14 3 2011

,

( )

6 (4/3)

12,7

60,5

36,6

476,4

1,5

1,5

1,5

100,0

2007

, %

2000
2007

,
./.

2007

103,6

225,1

164,4

217,3

2007

32,5

28,3

30,4

87,1

2007

45,0

1 696,5

, .

2007

,
.
2007

,
.

2007

, %

,
.

014
, %

( %)

2006
2007

870,8 3 770,0

5 225,2 10 626,3 7 925,8

59,6

203,4

2 385,4 1 222,5 4 002,3

6 468,8 12 180,8 9 324,8

188,3

3,8

4,3

4,1

113,2

2006

57,8

65,9

61,9

114,0

2006

62,2

70,8

66,5

113,8

2005

36,0

56,4

46,2

156,7

, %

:
2009. .
.: , - , 2009. . 352353.

212

14 3 2011

1 2 , . , 014 (. . 1) (32,5% 28,3%). .

, , .
. 2 ,
37 , . , , , 2007 10,3% , 2,7%.
30 (31 ), ,
(): . ,
, 20002008 2
,

( )

( %)

6 (4/3)

,
.

2007

, %

2000
2007

5,1

4,5

4,8

88,2

,
., 2000 .

1990
1992

1 703,3

4 244,0

2 973,7

249,2

2003
2005

2 578,1

7 801,0

5 189,6

302,6

,
%

2007

21,0

11,1

16,1

52,9

2007

25,7

28,6

27,2

111,3

2007

43,8

50,6

47,2

115,5

213

48 265,5 1 770 334,6 909 300,1 3 667,9

 14 3 2011

2 ()

6 (4/3)

, %

2007

72,6

61,8

67,2

85,1

, %

2007

14,5

13,9

14,2

95,9

, %

2007

23,2

22,7

23,0

97,8

, %

2007

10,3

2,7

6,5

26,2

, %

, %

2000
2003

15,5

6,4

11,0

41,3

:
2009. .
. 356357.

, ,
(. . 3). 2009 17% ( 22 .)
, .
, ,
, . , . ,
2009 58%
, .
. 3 , , , , ,
(2,0% 2,5% 2009 .). , , 2009 0,3% 0,1% 2008 . , , 0,2% 0,1%.
,
, , , , ,
. , ,
214

14 3 2011
3

20072009 ( . %)

2007

2008

2009

2007

2008

2009

2 100

1 771

1 114

2 268

1 929

1 101

1 444

1 018

566

1 924

1 572

821

565

630

478

292

296

229

63

72

59

11

10

164

183

117

56

82

47

78

90

68

47

38

23

259

282

233

178

166

153

91

123

70

52

61

51

42,5

62,1

50,5

5,3

5,8

4,2

26

32

28

16

26

22

68,8

57,5

50,8

84,8

81,5

74,5

26,9

35,6

42,9

12,9

15,4

20,8

3,0

4,1

5,3

0,5

0,5

0,5

7,8

10,3

10,5

2,5

4,3

4,3

3,7

5,1

6,1

2,1

2,0

2,1

12,3

15,9

20,9

7,9

8,6

13,9

4,3

6,9

6,3

2,3

3,1

4,6

,
*

2,0

3,5

4,5

0,2

0,3

0,4

,
-
-

,
*

:
%

,
-

215

 14 3 2011

3 ()

2007

2008

2009

2007

2008

2009

1,2

1,8

2,5

0,1

0,2

0,1

0,7

1,5

2,0

0,2

0,1

0,3

0,3

0,4

0,4

0,0

0,0

0,0

* ,
.
: ;
, ;
.
:

UNCTAD: World Investment Report 2010: Investing in Low-Carbon

Economy, New York, Geneva, 2010.

, , 4.

, .
, ; .
, .

() , (
) ( 2009 . 4 )
, . , 15 . , ,
(. . 4).
. 5 ,
, . ,
, .
4
.: , 2010. . . : , 2010. . 1819.

216

14 3 2011
4

726,1/56,4*

426,6/33,2*

405,9

1 286,7

395

368,1/23,0

888,1/55,5

520,0/32,5

413,4

1 599,3

492

1997

330,2/20,1

952,5/58,1

622,3/38,0

490,8

1 638,9

506

1998

359,3/19,0

1 000,0/52,8

640,7/33,9

504,9

1 892,3

585

1999

383,1/20,8

919,1/49,8

536,0/29,0

535,1

1 845,5

571

2000

446,9/23,4

966,2/50,5

519,3/27,2

539,5

1 911,6

593

2001

539,6/25,1

977,6/45,4

438,0/20,3

555,1

2 153,3

659

2002

697,6/29,4

1 107,1/46,6

409,5/17,2

573,4

2 376,3

740

2003

903,5/32,2

1 405,9/50,1

502,4/17,9

578,8

2 807,1

874

2004

984,9/27,5

1 513,6/42,3

528,7/14,8

533,5

3 576,6

1 113

2005

1 336,6/27,3

1 983,8/40,5

647,2/13,2

457,7

4 902,8

1 523

2006

1 407,6/22,0

2 328,5/36,5

920,9/14,4

416,0

6 386,7

1 982

2007

1 152,3/12,5

3 267,8/35,5

2 115,5/23,0

342,1

9 206,0

2 853

2008

1 057,2/9,1

4 426,1/38,0

3 368,9/28,9

306,0

11 662,0

3 606

2009

710,4/10,8

3 321,1/38,9

2 610,9/30,6

363,3

8 541,0

2 633

2010

1 011,4/10,8

3 782,9/40,3

2 771,5/29,5

373,7

9 391,6

2 879

11 988,0/16,8

29 566,4/41,5

17 578,4/24,7

461,8

71 177,7

1 375,3

1995

299,5/23,3*

1996

,
.

,
.

,
,
19952010

* ., .
: .

1. .
2. .
3. .
217

 14 3 2011

,
,
19952010

20072010 .
, %

, %

19952000 . 20012006 .
, %

, %

19952010 .

12,33

5,45

11,05

18,00

0,48

0,039

5,50

1,009

10,28

0,930

5,60

0,311

14,19

1,151

4,14

0,760

9,67

0,875

21,50

1,194

25,47

2,066

2,98

0,547

8,74

0,791 55,40

3,078

: 4.

, , . : , 9
(. . 6).
, , ,
, .
, , . , , ,
() , ,
.
,
.
218

14 3 2011
6

.
2007

2007

-
(% )
20002006

, 2005

180

0,21

116

0,22

15

490

0,68

346

439

1,15

840

12

145

0,18

39

2 635

0,59

375

96

0,28

1 470

23

0,20

134

0,69

353

406

0,80

1 214

11

89

14

887

0,46

1 178

0,10

7 815

0,76

328

2 105

1,03

1 314

157

44 145

2,52

155 922

14

41 596

1,42

336 988

30

615

0,60

64 584

52

16 396

3,23

110 633

33

3 609

2,39

105 549

46

45 572

1,80

63 066

19

205 320

2,61

228 655

28

708 086

2,30

1807 189

18

: World Development Indicators 2009. . . 314316.

219

 14 3 2011

, .
, .
,
,
,
.
,
. , , -
.

, , ; . - ,
, .
, .
, .

,
1) ;
2) ;
3) ;
4) , .
,
, , , , ,
,
.

220