Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 19

Greek Art in Motion

Studies in honour of Sir John Boardman on the


occasion of his 90th birthday

edited by
Rui Morais, Delfim Leão, Diana Rodríguez Pérez
with
Daniela Ferreira

Archaeopress Archaeology
Archaeopress Publishing Ltd
Summertown Pavilion
18-24 Middle Way
Summertown
Oxford OX2 7LG

www.archaeopress.com

ISBN 978 1 78969 023 1


ISBN 978 1 78969 024 8 (e-Pdf)

© Archaeopress and the individual authors 2019

Cover: Head of Alexander in profile. Tourmaline intaglio, 25 x 25 mm, Ashmolean (1892.1499)


G.J. Chester Bequest. Photo: C. Wagner.

All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced, or transmitted, in any form or by any means,
electronic, mechanical, photocopying or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the copyright owners.

Printed in England by Oxuniprint, Oxford

This book is available direct from Archaeopress or from our website www.archaeopress.com
Contents

Preface ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������1
John Boardman and Greek Sculpture �����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������3
Olga Palagia
Sanctuaries and the Hellenistic Polis: An Architectural Approach �����������������������������������������������������������������������������������14
Milena Melfi
‘Even the fragments, however, merit scrutiny’: Ancient Terracottas in the Field and the Museum ��������������������������������23
Lucilla Burn
The Good, the Bad, and the Misleading: A Network of Names on (Mainly) Athenian Vases� ��������������������������������������������31
Thomas Mannack

Studying Gems: Collectors and Scholars ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������37


Claudia Wagner

Buildings and History ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������46


P. J. Rhodes

John Boardman at 90: ‘New’ Archaeology or ‘Old’? Confessions of a Crypto-Archaeologist ��������������������������������������������55


Paul Cartledge

Some Recent Developments in the Study of Greeks Overseas ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������59


Gocha R. Tsetskhladze

Sculpture
Godlike Images: Priestesses in Greek Sculpture �����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������69
Iphigeneia Leventi

The Nude Constantinople: Masterpieces of Greek Sculpture at Byzantium according to the Greek Anthology ��������������������� 78
Carlos A. Martins de Jesus

Ornaments or Amulets: A Peculiar Jewel on Dedicatory Statues ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������85


Olympia Bobou

Architecture
Greek Emporios in Chios: The Archaeological Data from the Excavations of the Last Decades ����������������������������������������93
Kokona Roungou and Eleni Vouligea

Temples with a Double Cella: New Thoughts on a Little-Known Type of Temple ������������������������������������������������������������ 106
Ugo Fusco

i
Terracotas and Metal
Images of Dionysos, Images for Dionysos: The God’s Terracottas at Cycladic Sanctuaries ��������������������������������������������� 115
Erica Angliker

An Unusual Sympotic Scene on a Silver Cup from Ancient Thrace: Questions of Iconography and Manufacture ��������� 127
Amalia Avramidou

Forgeries in a Museum: A New Approach to Ancient Greek Pottery ������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 136


Claudina Romero Mayorga

Beyond Trade: The presence of Archaic and Classical Greek Bronze Vessels in the Northern Black Sea Area �������������� 139
Chiara Tarditi

Greek Pottery
Makron’s Eleusinian Mysteries: Vase-Painting, Myth, and Dress in Late Archaic Greece ���������������������������������������������� 153
Anthony Mangieri

Timagoras: An Athenian Potter to be Rediscovered �������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 164


Christine Walter

Revisiting a Plate in the Ashmolean Museum: A New Interpretation ������������������������������������������������������������������������������ 174


Marianne Bergeron

The Greek Pottery of the Tagus Estuary ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 185


Ana Margarida Arruda and Elisa de Sousa

Vases on Vases: An Overview of Approaches�������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 194


Konstantina Tsonaka

Intriguing Objects of Desire: Collecting Greek Vases, a Short History Unfolded ������������������������������������������������������������ 204
Daniela Freitas Ferreira

Youth in an Enclosed Context: New Notes on the Attic Pottery from the Iberian Tútugi Necropolis (Granada, Galera)���� 212
Carmen Rueda and Ricardo Olmos

An Overview of Brazilian Studies on Greek Pottery: Tradition and Future Perspectives ����������������������������������������������� 226
Carolina Kesser Barcellos Dias and Camila Diogo de Souza

Coins
Sculptures and Coins: A Contextual Case Study from Side ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 239
Alice Landskron

The Romanitas of Mark Antony’s Eastern Coins ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 249


João Paulo Simões Valério

War and Numismatics in Greek Sicily: Two Sides of the Same Coin �������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 259
José Miguel Puebla Morón

ii
Iconography of Poseidon in Greek Coinage ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 264
María Rodríguez López

The Silver Akragatine Tetradrachms with Quadriga: A New Catalogue ��������������������������������������������������������������������������� 276
Viviana Lo Monaco

Gems and Glass


Why was Actaeon Punished? Reading and Seeing the Evolution of a Myth ��������������������������������������������������������������������� 287
José Malheiro Magalhães

Greek Myth on Magical Gems: Survivals and Revivals ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 299


Paolo Vitellozzi

From Routine to Reconstruction ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������311


Susan Walker

Greek History and Archaeology


The Database of the Iberia Graeca Centre ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ 325
Xavier Aquilué, Paloma Cabrera and Pol Carreras

The Greeks Overseas: A Bioarchaeological Approach ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ 335


Tasos Zisis and Christina Papageorgopoulou

The Messenian Island of Prote and its Relation to Navigation in Greece and the Mediterranean���������������������������������� 343
Stamatis A. Fritzilas

Naukratis - Yet Again��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������355


Astrid Möller

The Tomb of the Roaring Lions at Veii: Its Relation to Greek Geometric and Early Orientalizing Art ��������������������������� 358
Gabriele Koiner

Perserschutt in Eretria? Pottery from a Pit in the Agora �������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 366


Tamara Saggini

Greeks Overseas
A Bridge to Overseas: Insight into the geomorphology, harbourworks and harbour layouts of the Archaic and Classical
Greek harbours �����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������377
Chiara Maria Mauro

Gandharan Odalisque: Mounted Nereids on Gandharan Stone Palettes �������������������������������������������������������������������������� 386


SeungJung Kim

The Attic Pottery from the Persephoneion of Locri Epizefiri between Ritual Practices and Worship���������������������������� 396
Elvia Giudice and Giada Giudice

Was Knossos a Home for Phoenician Traders? ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 408


Judith Muñoz Sogas

iii
Greek Divine Cures Overseas: Italian Realisations of the Greek Paradigm����������������������������������������������������������������������417
Lidia Ożarowska

Reception and Collecting


Wine and Blood? Dionysus, Other Gods and Heroes in a Catholic Chapel of Britiande (Lamego, Portugal) �������������������431
Nuno Resende

Pavlovsk Imperial Villa and its Collections: From the First Stage of Antiquities Collecting and Archaeology in Russia ���441
Anastasia Bukina and Anna Petrakova

Art and Myth


Greek Myths Abroad: A Comparative, Iconographic Study of Their Funerary Uses in Ancient Italy������������������������������455
Valeria Riedemann Lorca

Orphica Non Grata? Underworld Palace Scenes on Apulian Red-Figure Pottery Revisited���������������������������������������������465
Karolina Sekita

Geryon in Tatarli���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������475
Malcolm Davies

New Identifications of Heroes and Heroines on the West Pediment of the Parthenon: The Case of P, Q, and R ������������480
Ioannis Mitsios

A New Sicilian Curse Corpus: A Blueprint for a Geographical and Chronological Analysis of Defixiones from Sicily �����489
Thea Sommerschield

Once Again: A Sacrificing Goddess� Demeter - What´s up with her Attribute? ����������������������������������������������������������������502
Maria Christidis and Heinrike Dourdoumas

iv
A New Sicilian Curse Corpus: A Blueprint for a Geographical and
Chronological Analysis of Defixiones from Sicily

Thea Sommerschield1

Introduction1

In this paper I will offer an analysis of the geographical and


chronological diffusion of the practice of defixio writing,
attested in Sicily between 550 BCE and 200 CE. Sicilian evidence
for cursing has, on one hand, been the subject of largely
linguistically-focussed studies and, on the other hand, never
been collected in a single, updated corpus (despite several
attempts having been made to this end).2 The present work
aims to expand and update this situation, in order to pose
new questions to Sicilian defixiones thanks to the compiling
of a new digital corpus of the Sicilian evidence, which may be
analysed, geographically mapped and chronologically parsed.

I� Figure 1. ISicDef 4 - Inv. nr. 42578. Museo Archeologico Regionale ‘A.


Salinas’ di Palermo. Provenienza: Necropoli di Buffa. Editio princeps
Curse tablets, commonly referred to with the Latin term Brugnone 1976, pp. 68-73. By kind concession of Dr Francesca
defixiones and named κατάδεσμοι in Greek, are texts inscribed Spatafora; photograph by the author.
or scratched on thin sheets of lead (or lead alloys).3 The
tablets were then folded or rolled up and sometimes pierced
by a nail.

The evidence from Sicily at the heart of this discussion


is written exclusively in Greek. Latin does appear in later
defixiones, but will not be discussed here.4 Defixiones were
placed in tombs, sanctuaries, and in later periods in wells
or bodies of water.5 The purpose of curse tablets is to affect
the wellbeing, actions, and fortunes of a person or persons
(or animals!) against their will, by wishing upon them
some adversity or hardship. This is achieved by invoking
a supernatural force, a demon or deity to annihilate or
undermine the adversary in will and sometimes even in bodily
functions. From an anthropological perspective, cursing
has the potential to defuse social tensions by resorting to Figure 2. ISicDef 3 - Inv. nr. 42579. Museo Archeologico Regionale ‘A.
‘extended connective justice’:6 when legal institutions fail (as Salinas’ di Palermo. Provenienza: Necropoli di Buffa. Editio princeps
in the case of covert crimes or improper law enforcement), Brugnone 1976, pp. 73-79. By kind concession of Dr Francesca
metaphysical forces alternative to the existing socio-political Spatafora; photograph by the author.

1 
DPhil candidate, University of Oxford institutions are called upon through a curse to bring about
2 
See Section II for an overview of the most relevant contributions. the punitive consequences of an illicit action.
3 
For a discussion on the possible elective affinity between the
symbolic value of the choice of a cold metal and the malign intentions Written cursing in Greek is first documented is Sicily. The
for cursing guiding its inscription, see Gordon 2015, pp. 154-156.
4 
Mixed language defixiones, ones with the Greek transliteration of a
oldest defixiones hail from Selinunte, Gela and Agrigento, and
Latin term, and ones mentioning Latin names will be considered in date to c. 550 BCE at the earliest.7 Scholars have rarely spared
the present discussion. much attention to this fact and to what factors this survival
5 
Faraone 1991b, p. 3. With regards to the Sicilian material, known record may be ascribed is a troublesome matter. The rising of
find spots the Selinunte necropolis (ISicDef 3, 4, 5, 9, 17); the Kamarina written curses in late sixth-century Sicily has been correlated
necropolis (ISicDef 1, 2, 13, 20, 23, 24, 26, 27, 28); the Messina necropolis
(ISicDef 31); the Lilybaeum necropolis (ISicDef 29, 32, 65, 66); the Gela
to the birth of rhetoric on the island during roughly the
necropolis (ISicDef 18); a total of 13 defixiones were discovered at the same period,8 just as the large number of curses from Attica
Malophoros Sanctuary of Selinunte (ISicDef 6, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, dating late 5th – 4th century BCE have been associated with
16, 21, 22, 25, 43, 57, 58). It is however impossible to ascertain with
a degree of certainty the original context of many defixiones, for a
considerable number achieved final publication and conservation 7 
The earliest epigraphical documents attested in Sicily date c. 600-
only after long periods in illegal hands. 550 BCE.
6 
Assmann 1992, p. 151; Faraone 1999, p. 102. 8 
Eidinow 2007, p. 142.

489
Greek Art in Motion. Studies in honour of Sir John Boardman on the occasion of his 90th birthday

the Athenian propensity for lawsuits developing in the same implications of the texts have passed mostly unnoticed. Upon
time frame.9 Both explanations should be regarded critically, first engaging with this situation, I concluded that only a
for on one hand, such historical correlates remain essentially digital corpus of all published Sicilian curse tablets could lead
speculative; on the other, there remains the question of to a comprehensive study open to continuous updating.13 In
unevenness in the survival record (Athens is one of the most addition to incorporating new material, a digital database can
excavated centres of the ancient world, and Selinunte has also enable a highly flexible typological study of defixiones so that
historically been the object of intense formal and clandestine further questions may be posed to this class of objects.14 The
archaeological attention). The reasons for survival of evidence result is ISicDef, a corpus which offers both an organic analysis
in the modern archaeological record and the historical of the curse tablets for the purpose of identifying specific
motivations underlying survival are important considerations patterns in Sicilian defixiones, and is soon to become an open
which will be taken into account in the following discussion of source tool for the scholarly community to pursue the study
the geographical and chronological survival or extinction of of any aspect of the material.15 The references I will make
the defixiones for a site. For the moment, let us simply respect throughout this study to specific defixiones and behavioural
the current state of the evidence available to us: the earliest patterns visible in the existing harvest of evidence have
examples of written curses known to us are from Sicily. The emerged through the data plotting from the ISicDef corpus,
most ancient Sicilian material does indeed demonstrate the and a concordance table is available at the end of this paper.
signs of a practice taking its first steps into the written form:
they are simple lists of names (the people cursed).10 Indeed, More than 1,600 curse tablets are currently known from the
Gager and Eidinow have suggested that an oral phase may entire Graeco-Roman world. A total of 68 curses in Greek from
have preceded by many centuries the writing of curses in Sicily have been published over the last fifty years,16 a number
centres such as Sicily and Attica where the written form first which rivals only Attica in number of finds.17 Wünsch collected
appeared.11 220 curses from Attica in his 1897 DTA, and Audollent’s 1904
DT adds a further 33 to this count. The 55 curses of Jordan’s
Having now framed the practice of cursing in the ancient 1985 SGD and further 24 from Jordan’s 2000 NGTC must then
world, it is time to study more closely the Sicilian evidence be added.18 Roughly speaking (no updated corpus of all Attic
for cursing, by means of an investigation of its distribution in defixiones exists), we are dealing with a total number of about
time and space in Sicily. 300-350 curses from Attica. To contextualise these numbers,
it would be fruitful to compare the number of defixiones dating
II� 5th - early 4th century BCE discovered in Athens with those
from Selinunte for the same time-period. The choice of cities
The aim of the following paragraphs is firstly, to identify is an equitable one, for both have been the particular focus of
patterns characterising the curses in both time diffusion archaeological attention, and have both produced the highest
and geographical distribution; secondly, to investigate the percentage of all discovered curses in their wider territory
reasons underlying these survival (or extinction) patterns; in the time frame under consideration.19 For 5th - early 4th
and finally, to compare and contrast the Sicilian cursing century BCE Selinunte, 38 curses have been discovered. This
culture with the wider Sicilian epigraphic culture in virtue number must clearly be correlated to a population estimate:
of such geographical and chronological characteristics. It De Angelis proposes a population size of 14,000-19,000 for
will, therefore, become apparent whether an island-wide Selinunte in this time span.20 Let us move to the Athenian
phenomenon may be traceable, or whether the overall
picture is fragmented into individual centres of production in
well-defined time periods. This study will not be addressing documentary evidence for the Megarese dialects. The studies
potential patterns in the cursing language, as this is the by Bettarini (2005a), Dubois (1989) and Arena (1989) have
programmatically focussed on the linguistic study of defixiones.
subject of my forthcoming research. Collections such as Lopez-Jimeno (1991) is a commendable attempt at
an organic corpus of Sicilian curses (but regrettably contains several
Any systematic collection of Sicilian defixiones in Greek faces erroneous transcriptions).
the risk of being swiftly outdated. Despite this situation being 13 
Such a project had been proposed by Felicetti and Murano (2011).
anything but rare in the study of evidence of the ancient Their project, however, was never put into effect.
14 
Adding them to the single digital corpus of Sicilian inscriptions
world, in the case of rolled up lead lamellae of the average size directed by Dr Jonathan R. W. Prag (sicily.classics.ox.ac.uk), and
of a business card, the constant discovery of new material encoding them in a standard accessible format (TEI-XML mark-up
and the untraceable disappearance of known evidence has according to the EpiDoc schema) are the next steps.
made the creation of an undisputed and comprehensive 15 
I chose to adopt the relational database MySQL built with Cake
reference for Sicilian defixiones a near impossible task. PHP, as it most effectively approaches queries by using the Model-
View-Controller pattern. This makes the MySQL relational database
Furthermore, the majority of studies examining selections of highly adept at exporting its contents into, for instance, XML markup
defixiones have focussed principally on the linguistic features language, and creating a fully-fledged semantic network based on
of the tablets,12 whereas the magical aspects and the social linking properties.
16 
Most notably: Jordan - SGD (1985); Dubois - IGDS (1989); Arena -
IGASM (1989); Lopez Jimeno (1991); Curbera (1999); Jordan - NGTC
9 
Faraone 1999b. (2000a); Bettarini (2005); Eidinow – OCR (2007).
10 
21 curses from Sicily are in the list-form. 17 
Bouffier 2010, p. 89.
11 
Gager 1992, p. 7; Eidinow 2007, p. 141. The passage from oral to 18 
Greek curse tablets: DTA counts 220, DT 305 (of which 166 are in
written cursing in the early Classical period has been linked to the Greek), SGD ‘over 650’. The subtotal is therefore of about 1,100. The
broader spread of literacy taking place more broadly in Greek society number of Latin curse tablets is over 500. All numbers are from
at the time, and must have implied conspicuous ideological and Ankarloo-Clark 1999.
sociological repercussions. See Faraone 1991b, p. 5; Eidinow 2007, p. 19 
The continuity of settlement in Athens as opposed to the disruption
154; Gordon 2015, p. 149 for further discussion. affecting post-409 BCE Selinunte must be noted.
12 
For instance, the Selinunte defixiones have been fundamental as 20 
De Angelis 2016, p. 197.

490
Thea Sommerschield – A New Sicilian Curse Corpus

curses. The number of defixiones datable with a certain degree excavations of the Western necropolis of Himera. On the
of certainty to 5th – 4th century BCE Athens (problems of other hand, historical reasons have played a central part
dating persist in the main collections of Athenian curses), in determining the survival record, such as continuous or
is approximately 103. Alain Bresson suggests a population interrupted occupation of settlements, forced or voluntary
estimate for Athens of ‘more than 40,000 citizens in the fifth migrations of peoples, mass enslavements, the movement of
century, and perhaps at least 30,000 in the fourth century’.21 mercenaries, destructions, new foundations, the abandoning
Despite the inability to aspire to entirely precise figures, and re-occupations of settlements.25 To return to the Himera
we find that Athens and Selinunte were cursing in similar case, it could be inferred with a reasonable degree of certainty
proportions in the 5th - 4th century BCE. that the freshly discovered harvest of defixiones must pre-date
the destruction of the city in 409 BCE. If this were proven
What provisional conclusions may be drawn from this data? true by the forthcoming publication of these curses, then the
The practice of cursing on lead appears to have peaked in indication of a peak in defixio writing in production centres
the Classical age in the two centres under investigation. during the late Archaic – early Classical period (which is
What were the social and historical conditions in which we attested by the current state of the remaining evidence for
may contextualise such an ‘enthusiastic’ adoption of written cursing in Sicily, as shall now be discussed in detail) would be
curses in Selinunte and Athens? As a first general observation, further confirmed based on this historical reason for survival
the role played by the spread of literacy must undoubtedly and discontinuation. These are important considerations
be recognised. With ‘literacy’ one must understand both the which will be taken into account in the following discussion
capacity to read, and the aptitude at composing a written of the geographical and chronological survival or extinction
text. We also know from Thucydides that Selinunte was an of the defixiones for a site.
extremely prosperous city at this time, before the Athenian
expedition against Syracuse.22 The material record similarly By observing the geographical distribution of the curses
seems to suggest a significant level of material wealth for across the whole of Sicily, a number of preliminary
Selinunte in this period.23 Selinunte was a city with means, observations may be offered. Firstly, defixiones concentrate
potential and intention to flourish, and its noteworthy in urban contexts. Kamarina and Selinunte appear to be
harvest of curse tablets can indeed be read as a symptom and the most autonomously thriving centres of production.
a setting of the agonistic competition and discourse (political Apart from Morgantina (whose evidence exclusively dates
contentions, judicial contrasts, commercial competition) to the 1st century BCE) and Centuripae (which has only
which has been set at the heart of the practice of cursing.24 yielded a single curse tablet), the phenomenon appears
Then, in 409 BCE, the city was captured by the Carthaginians. to be circumscribed to coastal colonisation centres with
The figures compiled reveal that Selinunte demonstrated a a prominent Greek ethnic component. The absence of
cursing culture fully parallel in time and commensurate in defixiones from the eastern and northern coast must be
number to Athens. noted (albeit no foundations pre-400 BCE are to be found
along the northern coast between Himera and Messina): the
Before moving to the discussion of the geographical and phenomenon seems to have been restricted to the southern
chronological mapping of the defixiones in Sicily, two caveats coast. One may also remark that sub-colonies engage in
are called for. Firstly, I am fully aware that the sample of the practice conversely from their mother-colonies (such
material is not a large one: at the time of writing, 68 defixiones, is the case of Syracuse and Megara Hyblaea). No defixio
raging geographically across the whole of Sicily and has emerged from Elymian sites such as Entella, Erice and
chronologically through almost 700 years, have been recorded. Segesta, despite their known interaction with both Punic
Extreme caution is therefore fundamental. However, despite and Greek cultures. A final noteworthy fact is the exiguity
this apparently limited number of total finds, it nevertheless of curses from Palermo (only one), Motya and Solunto (no
comprises a sample large enough to make some fruitful curses discovered), whereas the other main centre for Punic
observations on the diffusion in time and space of defixiones settlement of the island Lilybaeum has yielded four curses (it
in Sicily, based on both the relative abundance of evidence should however be made explicit that Motya was destroyed
and equally on its relative lack, as shall now be demonstrated. in 397 BCE and Lilybaeum was founded by the survivors of
Secondly, both the historical reasons for survival of evidence this violent event). This exclusively geographical overview
and the subsequent factors which affect the survival and should now be correlated to the chronological plotting of the
recovery of evidence must be meticulously considered. data from the ISicDef corpus, in order to test the existence of
Indeed, the legal and illegal excavations carried out on sites the patterns this paper aims to identify.26 I have divided the
such as necropoleis, the systematic archaeological attention tablets into four chronological ranges, on the basis of the
dedicated to certain centres compared to others (for instance, immediately observable survival patterns in the evidence:
the ‘positive bias’ already discussed towards Selinunte), the late Archaic – early Classical peak (550 - 400 BCE), the
or the late discoveries due to external circumstances can 4th and 3rd century caesura (400 - 200 BCE), the 2nd century
significantly distort the ‘survival-landscape’ of curses to ‘Year Zero’ recommencing (200 - 1 BCE), and finally the
from Sicily. For example, I have only recently been made gradual extinction of cursing in 2nd century CE (1 - 200 CE).
aware through personal communication with Dr Francesca The dating of the curses is based upon the one attributed to
Spatafora of the discovery of 40-60 defixiones during present each defixio by its publishers.

21 
Bresson 2016, p. 61. Morris suggests that by 430 BCE, Athens must
have had a population of 35,000-40,000 (Morris 2005, p. 15).
22 
Thuc. 6.20.4. Souza 2014.
25 
23 
De Angelis 2016, p. 91. 26 
Maps created by means of the visualisation and extraction of GIS
24 
Faraone 1991b. data in Google Maps.

491
Greek Art in Motion. Studies in honour of Sir John Boardman on the occasion of his 90th birthday

Figure 3. The geographical range of defixiones in Sicily between 550 BCE - 200 CE: total numbers of finds per site.

Figure 4. The geographical range of defixiones in Sicily between 550 BCE - 200 CE: bubble chart of total numbers of finds per site.

Cursing begins in Sicily in the late 6th century BCE. Between particular concentration in the southern coast of the island
550 and 400 BCE it can be observed that the practice of cursing in the sub-colonies. As discussed previously, no attestation of
initially spread rapidly across Sicily’s coastal centres, with a defixiones is to be found in the Sicilian hinterland, based on the

492
Thea Sommerschield – A New Sicilian Curse Corpus

Figure 5. Defixiones in Sicily 550-400 BCE.

current data. Between 550-400 BCE, Selinunte27 and Kamarina range drops to 3 for Selinunte (which have been dated to late
are the most thriving centres of production of defixiones. It 5th – early 4th century, but of which certainly 2 and with
must be noted that 5th century Kamarina was struck by all likelihood also the remaining one possibly predate the
major historical vicissitudes: Thucydides recounts how the fateful 409 BCE, and therefore should not be considered for
city was destroyed soon after its founding by its mother-city diagnostic purposes within the 4th century time frame), and
Syracuse in 552 BCE.28 Hippocrates tyrant of Gela refounded it 1 for Kamarina (4th century BCE). Both cities had witnessed
in 492 BCE,29 but soon after it was depopulated and destroyed major conquest and transformation at the end of the 5th
in 485 BCE by Gelon, Hippocrates’ successor.30 The Geloans century, with Selinunte being captured by Carthage in 409
however repopulated it and portioned out its territory in a BCE and Kamarina destroyed by the Carthaginians in 405 BCE.
third foundation (461 BCE).31 The city prospered until 405 A noteworthy gap, therefore, appears in the 4th century, with
BCE, when it was destroyed by the Carthaginians. However, both production centres disappearing and total number of
the existence of curses found at Kamarina throughout this curses decreasing. This slump appears to persist into the 3rd
animated century attests that the city’s life did not freeze century BCE: 3 curses have emerged from Selinunte (300-275
entirely, but instead maintained its social vivacity, traditions, BCE), and one from the recently founded Lilybaeum (250-200
cults and institutions – among which, the practice of writing BCE).
defixiones. It is almost as if the continuous socio-political
discontinuity had nurtured a renovated civic effort to restore It was throughout the 4th – 3rd century BCE that Sicily
and revive the city’s traditions. experienced great social unrest and political upheaval. Randall
Souza has examined how a higher mobility, due to political
Between 400 and 300 BCE, the situation changes quite hegemony bids by the powers of Syracuse, Carthage, and
dramatically. The number of curses recovered from the two Rome, manifested itself in the form of population relocation,
main production centres highlighted in the previous time manipulation and even annihilation.32 One could therefore be
tempted into considering the 4th century BCE as a period of
socio-economic recession and warfare reflected in the sudden
27 
Which has yielded 38 curses, if 3 curses dating 450-350 BCE are decline in defixio (and, as shall soon be discussed, epigraphic)
included in this range, as they are in the following chronological
production. However, correlating epigraphic activity to socio-
range as well.
28 
Thuc. 6.5.3. economic prosperity is a dangerous method, and a wider lens
29 
Hdt. 7.154.3; Thuc. 6.5.3.
30 
Hdt. 7.156.2; Thuc. 6.5.3.
31 
Diod. 11.76.5; Thuc. 6.5.3. 32 
Souza 2014.

493
Greek Art in Motion. Studies in honour of Sir John Boardman on the occasion of his 90th birthday

Figure 6. Defixiones in Sicily 400-200 BCE.

Figure 7. Defixiones in Sicily 200 - 1 BCE.

494
Thea Sommerschield – A New Sicilian Curse Corpus

Figure 8. Defixiones in Sicily 1 – 200 CE.

is called for.33 This possibility will be further discussed at the Centuripae (ISicDef 39), one of the most important Roman
end of the geographical and chronological analysis. cities in Sicily,35 has been discovered.

In the 2nd and 1st century BCE a written cursing revival III�
takes place in Sicily. New centres of defixio production appear,
whereas the old established ones (such as Selinunte) do not This analysis has revealed that the late 6th - 5th century
resurface. Morgantina, a mixed Greek and Sikel inland centre BCE is undoubtedly the period in which certain centres
seized by the Romans in 214 BCE, has produced a batch of demonstrated the greatest familiarity with defixio writing on
6 curses dating 1st century BCE: the names which appear lead in Greek, and that after the caesura of the 4th century
on the tablets are indeed Latin (ISicDef 35, 36, 37, 38), as are BCE the practice of cursing regained popularity in new
terms such as ‘liberta’ (ISicDef 33, 34). Lilybaeum continues centres of production, spreading inland following the Roman
the production of curses which had begun in the previous expansion into Sicily. However, cursing never regained its
century. Its tablets mention not only Greek names, but Latin former heyday. In the light of the patterns of continuity and
ones as well as foreign names such as Agbor Bucius (ISicDef discontinuity so far observed for the evidence for cursing in
32, possibly a Punic), and Apithamb.al (ISicDef 65, also Punic). Sicily, it would now be worthwhile to compare and contrast
One curse from Phintias, founded in 282 BCE, lists two Greek such patterns against the wider Sicilian epigraphic culture.
names and nine Latin names (ISicDef 30, 150-50 BCE). The aim is to investigate whether similar developments or
disruptions occurred in the wider panorama of epigraphy on
Cursing on lead in Greek disappears in Sicily after the 2nd stone in Sicily, whether the historical reasons were similar,
century CE, although curiously enough the same does not and if therefore Sicilian curses followed the wider patterns of
apply to the Attic cursing tradition, as the latter increases the Sicilian epigraphic habit or displayed their own patterns
exponentially after the 1st – 2nd century CE.34 ISicDef 40 of practice.
from Messina mentions a Latin name, and one curse from
To achieve this, we will be moving from considerations made
by Jonathan Prag’s recent and forthcoming work on Sicilian
33 
Prag 2002, pp. 23. epigraphy in numbers:36 an analysis of the collected data
34 
Curbera 1999, p. 159. In the later Roman period, the southeast of
Sicily witnesses a growth in other types of magical document, such as
amulets, Greek magical papyri, and love-magic incantations (Dickie 35 
Cicero, Verrine II, 4, 50.
2001). 36 
Prag 2002; 2013b; forthcoming.

495
Greek Art in Motion. Studies in honour of Sir John Boardman on the occasion of his 90th birthday

sample from I.Sicily (3240 inscriptions on stone, of which two 4th century BCE. A distinguishing factor of Archaic curses
thirds are probably Greek and of which the datable texts used is the cursing of people’s names in the form of a list, with
in these analyses never exceed circa 2500) demonstrates a no other linguistic, formulaic or graphic embellishment or
rapid growth in the Archaic period beginning in the 7th – expansion. This situation ceases after the 4th century, as
5th century BCE (180 inscriptions on stone). The inscriptions curses become more articulated, direct invocations to the
of this early period are prevalently funerary and votive, and gods begin to appear, magical symbols and targets alternative
their distribution is concentrated in the southern-eastern to the traditional ‘binding of the tongue’ begin to emerge.
coastal area of the island. Sicily then witnesses an almost These observations authorise the inclusion of defixiones
complete slump in the epigraphic production of the 4th from Sicily within the wider epigraphical habit of the island.
century BCE (which drops to circa 25 texts). A revival in Greek Rather than correlating to historical circumstances. Rather
epigraphic culture takes place during the last three centuries than correlating the survival in time and place of defixiones
BCE (minimum 435 inscriptions): a diversity of media and exclusively to socio-economic crisis or prosperity, one could
types of inscription (with an increase in public epigraphy) instead examine the issue in terms of the shifts in contents,
and a penetration in the Sicilian hinterland and northern form and linguistic peculiarities and the historical situation
coast are identified as traits of a developing ‘Hellenistic’ taking place at the time, and examine whether apparent
epigraphic culture, born of the increasing Mediterranean periods of epigraphic silence may actually be a stage of socio-
connectivity in every aspect of human interaction.37 Latin historical or religious development and change.
epigraphy is instead prevalent in the 1st – 3rd century CE.
The wider epigraphic practice on stone in Sicily matches Conclusions
therefore the pattern observed in the chronological and
to some extent even geographical diffusion of defixiones: a In this paper I have aimed to contextualise defixiones both
rapid growth in the Archaic period and an initial limitation geographically and chronologically within the Sicilian cursing
to coastal southern areas (with high numbers of inscriptions horizon, and secondly within the wider Sicilian epigraphic
concentrated almost exclusively in Selinunte and Motya for culture in virtue of shared shifts in ‘quality’ and quantity.
the south-west, and small numbers from a swarm of cities in My analysis so far seems to suggest that we are not dealing
the south-east), followed by an apparent gap in the practice with a unified Sicilian phenomenon, but with a fragmented
in the 4th century BCE, which then sees a gradual rise in panorama within well-defined time periods of individual
the production of defixiones starting in the 3rd century production centres, whose number and survival or extinction
concentrated in the Sicilian eastern interiors and centres of varies in parallel with the socio-historical circumstances
Roman settlement, until the disappearance of the practice affecting the island and its population.
of defixio writing in Greek in the 2nd century CE (as will be
discussed presently). A conclusive word of caution is called for. It has been
noted that 38 curses found in Selinunte between 550-400
In the face of these patterns, it could be suggested that BCE represent a large percentage of the total number of
the 4th century slump in Sicilian epigraphic habit may be defixiones included in the database. Selinunte has in fact been
interpreted as a period of gestation rather than of a recession intensively excavated in recent years, especially the burial
characterising the Sicilian economic, political and social and sanctuary areas usually associated to the deposition of
situation of this period. Prag has in fact identified a set of curses. Further information regarding the new batch of curses
shifting patterns in the limited surviving epigraphy of the 4th from Himera (subsequent to its publication), correlated to a
century BCE: the inscriptions aspire to greater monumentality detailed textual analysis of the language of cursing in Sicilian
and higher quality, thus distinguishing themselves from the evidence are now called for. In so doing, clearer light may be
previous Archaic production on poor local stone and the shed on whether we are dealing with a situation of ‘accidents
limited numbers of public epigraphy.38 The same examination of survival’, historical reasons for survival, or in truth with
must be made for defixiones: an increase in quality and in a more extensive phenomenon involving the practice of
complexity may be identified in the defixiones dating post- cursing in Sicily.

37 
Prag 2013b, pp. 343-46.
38 
Prag, forthcoming.

496
Thea Sommerschield – A New Sicilian Curse Corpus

497
Greek Art in Motion. Studies in honour of Sir John Boardman on the occasion of his 90th birthday

498
Thea Sommerschield – A New Sicilian Curse Corpus

Acknowledgements Amadasi Guzzo, M. 2007. ‘Une Lamelle Magique a Inscripton


Phoenicienne’, Vicino Oriente 13: 197-206.
I wish to thank the organisers of the Conference in Honour of Sir Ankarloo, B., & Clark, S. 1999. Ancient Greece and Rome
John Boardman on the Occasion of his 90th Birthday, and especially (Witchcraft and Magic in Europe). Philadelphia: University
Dr Diana Perez Rodriguez. I am indebted to my supervisors in of Pennsylvania Press.
Oxford, Professor Jonathan Prag and Dr Josephine Crawley Antonetti, C., & De Vido, S. 2009. Temi selinuntini. Pisa: ETS.
Quinn. Thank you Yannis for helping me <br> new ground Arena, R. 1986. ‘Osservazioni su due defixiones selinuntine’,
with ISicDef. The errors that are found herein are mine alone - Zeitschrift für Papyrologie und Epigraphik 66: 161-164.
proofreading is a real curse. Arena, R. 1989. Iscrizioni greche arcaiche di Sicilia e magna Grecia:
iscrizioni di Sicilia. Milano: Cisalpino-Goliardica.
Selected abbreviations for epigraphic catalogues Assmann, J. 1992. ‘When Justice Fails: Jurisdiction and
Imprecation in Ancient Egypt and the Near East’, The
Bettarini = Bettarini, L. 2005a. Corpus delle defixiones di Selinunte: Journal of Egyptian Archaeology 78: 149-162.
edizione e commento (Hellenica; 15). Alessandria: Edizioni Audollent, A. 1904. Defixionum Tabellae. Paris: Fontemoing
dell’Orso. Repr. Frankfurt a. M.: Minerva GmbH, 1967.
Brugnone st. Manni = Brugnone, A. 1976. ‘Defixiones Inedite Bechtold, B., Frey-Kupper, S., Madella, M., & Brugnone, A. 1999.
Da Selinunte’, In Manni 1976: 67-90). La necropoli di Lilybaeum. Palermo: Roma: Regione Siciliana,
CTBS = Gager, J. 1992. Curse Tablets and Binding Spells from the Assessorato [regionale] dei beni culturali ed ambientali e
Ancient World. New York: Oxford University Press. della pubblica istruzione; L’Erma di Bretschneider.
Curbera = Curbera, J. 1999. ‘Defixiones’, In Gulletta, M. 1999. Bettarini, L. 2005a. Corpus delle defixiones di Selinunte: edizione e
Sicilia epigraphica: Atti del convegno internazionale Erice, 15- commento (Hellenica; 15). Alessandria: Edizioni dell’Orso.
18 ottobre 1998 (Annali della Scuola normale superiore di Bettarini, L. 2005b. ‘Una Nuova Defixio Di Selinunte?’,
Pisa, Classe di lettere e filosofia. Quaderni; ser. 4, 7-8). Pisa: Zeitschrift für Papyrologie und Epigraphik 151: 253–258.
Classe di lettere e filosofia. 159–86. Bettarini, L. 2009. ‘Defixio selinuntina inedita da Manuzza’,
DT = Audollent, A. 1904. Defixionum Tabellae. Paris: Fontemoing Parola del Passato 64: 137-146.
Repr. Frankfurt a. M.: Minerva GmbH, 1967. Bettarini, L. 2012. ‘Testo e lingua nei documenti con Ephesia
DTA = Wünsch, R. 1897. Defixionum Tabellae, IG III iii, Appendix. grammata’, Zeitschrift für Papyrologie und Epigraphik 183:
Berlin: Preußische Akademie der Wissenschaften. [Cited 111-128.
from the reprint, Inscriptiones Atticae, Supplementum Bonanno, D., Bonnet, C., & Cusumano, N. 2010. Alleanze e
Inscriptionarum Atticarum, I. Chicago: Ares Publishers, parentele: Le ‘affinità elettive’ nella storiografia sulla Sicilia
1976]. antica: Convegno internazionale Palermo 14 - 15 aprile 2010
IGASM = Arena, R. 1989. Iscrizioni greche arcaiche di Sicilia e magna (Triskeles). Caltanissetta - Roma: S. Sciascia.
Grecia: iscrizioni di Sicilia. Milano: Cisalpino-Goliardica. Bouffier, S. 2010. ‘Specificites Culturelles En Sicilie Greque a
IGDS = Dubois, L. 1989. Inscriptions grecques dialectales de Sicile: Travers Les Tablettes de Malediction’, In Bonanno et al.
Contribution à l’étude du vocabulaire grec colonial (Collection 2010: 89-112).
de l’École française de Rome, 119). Roma: Ecole française Bresson, A., & Rendall, S. 2016. The making of the ancient Greek
de Rome [Cited from the reprint, 2008. Inscriptions grecques economy: Institutions, markets, and growth in the city-states.
dialectales de Sicile. Tome II (Hautes études du monde gréco- Princeton.
romain; 40). Genève: Droz]. Brugnone, A. 1976. ‘Defixiones Inedite Da Selinunte’, In Manni
López Jimeno = López Jimeno, M. 1991. Las tabellae defixionis 1976: 67-90).
de la Sicilia griega (Classical and Byzantine monographs; v. Brugnone, A. 1999. ‘Le Laminette Iscritte Della Tomba 186’, In
22). Amsterdam: Adolf M. Hakkert. Bechtold et al. 1999: 467-473).
NGTC = Jordan, D. 2000a. ‘New Greek Curse Tablets 1985-2000’, Ciraolo, L., & Seidel, J. 2002. Magic and Divination in the Ancient
Greek, Roman and Byzantine Studies 41 (1): 5-46. World (Ancient Magic and Divination; 2). Leiden: Brill.
OCR = Eidinow, E. 2007. Oracles, Curses and Risk among the Ancient Styx.
Greeks Oxford: Oxford University Press. Collins, D. 2015. The Cambridge History of Magic and Witchcraft in
SGD = Jordan, D. 1985. ‘A survey of Greek defixiones not the West: From Antiquity to the Present. New York.
included in the special corpora’, Greek, Roman & Byzantine Collins, D. 2008. Magic in the Ancient Greek World (Blackwell
Studies 26: 151–97. ancient religions). Malden, Mass.; Oxford: Blackwell
Publishing.
Bibliography Cooley, A., & Burnett, A. 2002. Becoming Roman, writing Latin?
Literacy and epigraphy in the Roman West (Journal of Roman
Agostiniani, L. 1977. Iscrizioni anelleniche di Sicilia (Lingue e archaeology. Supplementary series; 48). Portsmouth, R.I.:
iscrizioni dell’Italia antica; 1). Firenze: Olschki. Journal of Roman Archaeology L.L.C.
Amadasi Guzzo, M. 1986. Scavi a Mozia, le iscrizioni (Collezione di Cordano, F. 1992. Le tessere pubbliche dal Tempio di Atena a
studi fenici; 22). Roma: Consiglio nazionale delle ricerche. Kamarina (Studi pubblicati dall’Istituto italiano per la
Amadasi Guzzo, M. 1990. Iscrizioni fenicie e puniche in Italia storia antica; fasc. 50). Roma: Istituto italiano per la storia
(Itinerari. Comitato nazionale per gli studi e le ricerche antica.
sulla civiltà fenicia e punica; 6). Roma: Libreria dello Stato, Cordano, F. 2011. Kamarina: politica e istituzioni di una città greca
Istituto poligrafico e Zecca dello Stato. (Themata; 8). Tivoli: Tored.
Amadasi Guzzo, M. 2003. ‘Appunti sulla ‘tabella devotionis’ KAI Curbera, J. 1997. ‘The Persons Cursed on a Defixio from
89 da Cartagine’, Epigrafia e storia delle religioni 20: 25-31. Lilybaeum’, Mnemosyne IV 50 (2): 219-225.

499
Greek Art in Motion. Studies in honour of Sir John Boardman on the occasion of his 90th birthday

Curbera, J. 1999. ‘Defixiones’, In Gulletta 1999: 159–86). University of Zaragoza, 30 Sept.-1 Oct. 2005 (Religions in the
Curbera, J. & Kotansky, R. 2007. ‘Unpublished Lead Tablets in Graeco-Roman World; v. 168). Leiden; Boston: Brill.
the Getty’, Mediterraneo Antico VII 2: 681-691. Gordon, R. 2012. ‘Memory and Authority in the Magical
De Angelis, F. 2016. Archaic and Classical Greek Sicily: A Social and Papyri’. In Dignas et al. 2012: 145-80).
Economic History. Oxford University Press. Gordon, R. 2013. ‘Gods, Guilt and Suffering: Psychological
Felicetti, F., & Murano, A. ‘Defixio Digital(is): A Semantic- Aspects of Cursing in The North-Western Provinces of
enabled Digital Archive for the Study of Ancient Curse the Roman Empire’, Acta Classica Univ. Scient. Debrecen 49:
Tablets’. In Dellepiane, M., & European Association for 255–281.
Computer Graphics, eds. Short and Project Papers / VAST Gordon, R. 2015. ‘Showing the Gods the Way: Curse-tablets as
2011, the 12th International Symposium on Virtual Reality, Deictic Persuasion’, RRE 1, 148–180.
Archaeology, and Cultural Heritage; the 9th EUROGRAPHICS Graf, F. 1997. Magic in the Ancient World (Revealing Antiquity,
Workshop on Graphics and Cultural Heritage; Prato, Italy, 10). Cambridge, Mass.; London: Harvard University Press.
October 18 - 21, 2011. Goslar: Eurographics Association [u.a.], Graf, F. & Iles Johnston, S. 2013. Ritual Texts for the Afterlife:
2011. Orpheus and the Bacchic Gold Tablets. London; New York:
Dickie, M. 2001. Magic and Magicians in the Greco-Roman World. Routledge.
London: Routledge. Gulletta, M. 1999. Sicilia epigraphica: Atti del convegno
Dignas, B., Smith, R., & Price, S. 2012. Historical and Religious internazionale Erice, 15-18 ottobre 1998 (Annali della Scuola
Memory in the Ancient World. Oxford: Oxford University normale superiore di Pisa, Classe di lettere e filosofia.
Press. Quaderni; ser. 4, 7-8). Pisa: Classe di lettere e filosofia.
Donner, H., & Röllig, W. 2002. Kanaanäische und aramäische Hoffmann, F. 2015. ‘Ancient Egypt’. In Collins 2015: 52–82).
Inschriften (5., erw. und überarbeitete Auflage. ed.). Iannucci, A., Muccioli, F. & Zaccarini, M. 2015. La città inquieta:
Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz. Selinunte tra lex sacra e defixiones (Diádema, 2). Milano:
Dubois, L. 1989. Inscriptions grecques dialectales de Sicile: Mimesis.
Contribution à l’étude du vocabulaire grec colonial (Collection Jameson, M., Jordan, D., & Kotansky, R. 1993. A Lex Sacra from
de l’École française de Rome, 119). Roma: Ecole française Selinous (Greek, Roman, and Byzantine monographs, 11).
de Rome [Cited from the reprint, 2008. Inscriptions grecques Durham: Duke University.
dialectales de Sicile. Tome II (Hautes études du monde gréco- Jordan, D. 1985. ‘A survey of Greek defixiones not included
romain, 40). Genève: Droz]. in the special corpora’, Greek, Roman and Byzantine Studies
Dupraz, E., & Sowa, W. 2015. Genres épigraphiques et langues 26(2):151–196.
d’attestation fragmentaire dans l’espace méditerranéen Jordan, D. 1997. ‘Two Curse Tablets from Lilybaeum’, Greek,
(Issue 9 of Cahiers de l’ERIAC, Série Fonctionnements Roman and Byzantine Studies 38 (4): 387-396.
linguistiques). Presses universitaires de Rouen et du Jordan, D. 2000a. ‘New Greek Curse Tablets 1985-2000’, Greek,
Havre, 2015. Roman and Byzantine Studies 41 (1): 5-46.
Eidinow, E. 2007. Oracles, Curses, and Risk Among the Ancient Jordan, D. 2000b. ‘Ephesia Grammata at Himera’, Zeitschrift für
Greeks. Oxford University Press. Papyrologie und Epigraphik 130: 104–107.
Eidinow, E. & Kindt, J. 2017. The Oxford Handbook of Ancient Jordan, D. & Kotansky, R. 2011. ‘Ritual Hexameters in the Getty
Greek Religion (Oxford handbooks). Oxford. Museum Preliminary Edition’, Zeitschrift für Papyrologie
Erdas, D., & Carmine, A. 2016. ‘Notizia preliminare su due und Epigraphik 178: 54–62.
laminette plumbee con defixiones’. In Spatafora 2016: Jordan, D. Rocca, G., & Threatte L. 2014. ‘Una nuova defixio
295-298). dalla Sicilia (Schoyen Collection MS 1700’, Zeitschrift für
Faraone, C., & Obbink, D. 1991a. Magika Hiera: Ancient Greek Papyrologie und Epigraphik 188: 231–236.
Magic and Religion. New York; Oxford: Oxford University López Jimeno, M. 1991. Las tabellae defixionis de la Sicilia griega
Press. (Classical and Byzantine monographs; v. 22). Amsterdam:
Faraone, C., & Obbink, D. 1991b. ‘The Agonistic Context of Adolf M. Hakkert.
Early Greek Binding Spells’, In Faraone et al. 1991a: 2-32). Luck, G. 1985. Arcana mundi: Magic and the occult in the Greek
Faraone, C. 1999a. Ancient Greek Love Magic. Cambridge, Mass.; and Roman worlds: A collection of ancient texts. Baltimore;
London: Harvard University Press. London: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Faraone, C. 1999b. ‘Curses and Law Control’, Dike 2: 99-121. Manganaro, G. 1977. ‘Tavolette Di Piombo Inscritte Della
Faraone, C., Garnand, B., & Lopez Ruiz, C. 2005. ‘Micah’s Sicilia Greca’, AnnPisa, III, 7 (4): 1329–1349.
Mother (Judg. 17:1??4) and a Curse from Carthage (KAI 89): Manganaro, G. 1995. ‘Sikelika I’, Quaderni Urbinati Di Cultura
Canaanite Precedents for Greek and Latin Curses against Classica 49: 93-109.
Thieves?’, Journal of Near Eastern Studies 64 (3): 161–86. Manganaro, G. 1997. ‘Nuove Tavolette Di Piombo Inscritte
Faraone, C. & Kropp, A. 2010. ‘Inversion, Adversion and Siceliote’, La Parola Del Passato 52: 306–48.
Perversion as Strategies in Latin Curse Tablets’. In Gordon Manganaro, G. 1999. Sikelika: Studi di antichità e di epigrafia
et al. 2010: 381–98). della Sicilia greca (Biblioteca di Quaderni urbinati di
Frankfurter, D. 2005. ‘Curses, Blessings, and Ritual Authority: cultura classica; 8). Pisa: Istituti editoriali e poligrafici
Egyptian Magic in Comparative Perspective’, Journal of internazionali.
Ancient Near Eastern Religions 5 (1):157–185. Manni, E. 1976. Studi di storia antica offerti dagli allievi a Eugenio
Gager, J. 1992. Curse Tablets and Binding Spells from the Ancient Manni. Roma: G. Bretschneider.
World. New York: Oxford University Press. Meyer, M., & Mirecki, P. 1995. Ancient Magic and Ritual Power
Gordon, R., & Marco Simón, F. 2010. Magical Practice in the Latin (Religions in the Graeco-Roman world, v. 129). Leiden:
West: Papers from the International Conference Held at the Brill.

500
Thea Sommerschield – A New Sicilian Curse Corpus

Mirecki, P., & Meyer, M. 2002. Magic and Ritual in the Ancient Rocca, G. 2015. ‘Les defixiones siciliennes: aspects publics et
World (Religions in the Graeco-Roman world, v. 141). privés’. In Dupraz et al. 2015: 305-313).
Leiden: Brill. Schwemer, D. 2015. ‘The Ancient Near East’. In Collins 2015:
Morris, I. 2005. ‘The Growth of Greek Cities in the First 17-51).
Millennium BC’, Princeton/Stanford Working Papers in Souza, R. 2014. The Mobility of Sicilian Populations and the Nature
Classics December 2005: 1-29. of Sicilian Citizenship, 409-202 BCE, Ph.D thesis, University of
Parker, R. 1983. Miasma: Pollution and Purification in Early Greek California, Berkeley.
Religion. Oxford: Clarendon Press. Souza, R. 2016. ‘Hellenistic Sicilian Real Estate Contracts
Parker, R. 2005a. Polytheism and Society at Athens. Oxford: Inscribed on Lead Tablets: New Readings and
Oxford University Press. Implications For The Economic Independence Of
Prag, J. 2002. ‘Epigraphy by Numbers: Latin and the Epigraphic Women’, Zeitschrift für Papyrologie und Epigraphik 197:
Culture in Sicily’, In Cooley 2002: 15-31). 149–166.
Prag, J. & Quinn, J. 2013a. The Hellenistic West: Rethinking the Spatafora, F. 2016. Il Thesmophorion di Entella: scavi in Contrada
Ancient Mediterranean. Cambridge. Petraro. Pisa: Edizioni della Normale.
Prag, J. 2013b. ‘Epigraphy in the Western Mediterranean: a Stratton, K. 2015. ‘Early Greco-Roman Antiquity’. In Collins
Hellenistic Phenomenon?’. In Prag. J, & Quinn, J. 2013: 2015: 83–112).
320-347). Versnel, H. 1991a. ‘Beyond cursing: The appeal for justice in
Riess, W. 2012. Performing Interpersonal Violence. Court, Curse, and judicial prayers’. In Faraone et al. 1991: 60-106).
Comedy in Fourth-Century BCE Athens. Berlin, Boston: De Gruyter. Versnel, H. 1991b. ‘Some Reflections on the Relationship
Rocca, G. 2009a. Nuove Iscrizioni da Selinunte (Hellenica, 31). Magic-Religion’, Numen, 38 (2): 177-197.
Alessandria: Edizioni dell’Orso. Versnel, H. 2015. ‘Prayer and Curse’. In Eidinow et al. 2015:
Rocca, G. 2009b. ‘Due inediti da Selinunte’. In Antonietti et al. 447-459).
2009: 269-276). Wünsch, R. 1897. Defixionum Tabellae, IG III iii, Appendix. Berlin:
Rocca, G. 2012. ‘Grecità Di Sicilia: Il Caso Defixiones. Un Nuovo Preußische Akademie der Wissenschaften. [Cited from the
Testo Da Selinunte’, Aristonothos. Scritti per Il Mediterraneo reprint, Inscriptiones Atticae, Supplementum Inscriptionarum
Antico, 4: 209–218. Atticarum, I. Chicago: Ares Publishers, 1976].

501

Вам также может понравиться