Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 198

O

, , .
,
().
30 .

: :
(., 2006),
:
(., 2008)

(., 2008).
(-
).


.
-
.
: , ,
,
, ,
.


2009
71 2
31

08-04-16223

:
                                                               

                                                    21

. .  

31 :
. .: , 2009. 392 . 
ISBN 978-5-9551-0318-1 
;,;                28
, - 
- 
, .
- ,                                      43
- 
( )                       
,
 
.

, - 
-
modus vivendi, modus operandi modus loquendi.                              77
, 
, . -                                          90
-
- . "
                                   111
- ,
, -  
, 
.
71 2 

                          144
.             147


ISBN 978-5-9551-0318-1              
                    171
. . , 2009
, 2009 
                                  190
,
.
4

  


                             201
          206 
                           213
         
          228 
  
        
              238 
" 
 
                                                    
 
             266        

         
       
                       277 
                      283 
 
                            303 1 
                                311        
 
      
     

                     

7UDQVLWLRQ                  
       
 
 
                                                  
                                  336 
                                       341 

                                                        343
          
                                                        377        >
RQWHQWV                                                                389 F@        
6XPPDU\                                                               391 
>:HLJKWPDQ@
>%lFNVWU|P@
6 7

                 
        
         
              
 
     
             
 
 
       
  
       
        
 
 
       
  
   LQGLH       
 
        
       
       
 
       
        
               
                
;,;       
 
                   
             
       
               
          
     
  
  
                
  
         
8 9

              
      
 
          
          
                
             
             PRGXV YLYHQGL PRGXV RSHUDQGL  PRGXV
   ORTXHQGL
 
      
        
      
          
       
      
           
 
 
 
        
        Shadowa L. A.6XFKHXQG([SHULPHQW$XVGHU*HVFKLFKWHGHUUXVVLVFKHQ
          XQG 6RYMHWLVFKHQ .XQVW =ZLVFKHQ  XQG  'UHVGHQ 
       7KH*UHDW([SHULPHQW5XVVLDQ$UW/7KH5XVVLDQ
      ([SHULPHQW LQ $UW  1 <  Stites R. 5HYROXWLRQDU\
     'UHDPV8WRSLDQ9LVLRQDQG([SHULPHQWDO/LIHLQWKH5XVVLDQ5HYROXWLRQ
      1 < 2[IRUG  /DERUDWRU\ RI 'UHDPV 7KH 5XVVLDQ$YDQW*DUGH
       DQG&XOWXUDO([SHULPHQW6WDQIRUG&$
VXLJHQHULV        
         
             Bowra . . 7KH FUHDWLYH H[SHULPHQW /
  
      
       
 
 
        
     
         
      
10 11

  


      
                 
 Laboratory of Dreams
   
      
     : Langer G.
 .XQVW:LVVHQVFKDIW8WRSLH'LH8HEHUZLQGXQJGHU.XOWXUNULVH
 EHL9,YDQRY$%ORN$%HO\MXQG9&KOHEQLNRY)DP0
            
      
      
        
       'LH
   .RQVWUXNWLRQGHU8WRSLHlVWKHWLVFKH$YDQWJDUGHXQGSROLWLVFKH8WRSLHLQ
  GHQHU-DKUHQ0DUEXUJ
>*ORVVDULXPGHUUXVVLVFKHQ$YDQWJDUGH@            
       
      "       
      
              
           
        
                
         
        
       
 


 
 
            
 
              
        
          
 
        
              
12 13

       
          
               
             
   
  
         
 
 
            
 
 
 
       
 
           
 
 
      
 ORJRV          
        
 
 
       
 
          
 OyJRQGLGyQDL         
  .
          . .
  
  
  .
           
 
       
         
        
 
         
14 

  
  
     
             
 
       ORJRV VSHUPDWLNRV   
       
  
           
 
         
          
      
 
        
                   
   
       
                
               
         
  
               
         -
           
  
          
         
        
       
        
   , 
         
   
  
           .
 .   
       
       
 
16 17

 
2 
       
            
       
      . .  Cassedy S.)OLJKWIURP(GHQ7KH2ULJLQVRI
      ;;      0RGHUQ/LWHUDU\&ULWLFLVPDQG7KHRU\%HUNHOH\3 
 
      
          
       
.                
      
        
        
Seifrid Th.7KH:RUG0DGH   
6HOI5XVVLDQ:ULWLQJVRQ/DQJXDJH,WKDFD/      
       
           
      
                  
 
   
     
             
         
    ;,;;;    
      
        
        
              
                 
          
 
          
 
   -
  
      
          
        
;;           
 
  
18 19

   -      


               
             
   
      
                
   
                  
 
 
 
      
          
 
      HUJRQ   
HQHUJHLD   
       
                 
          
 
 
 
 
 
         
      
     

       
                 
  
 . .       
          
              
       
       
        
          
 
       
20

          
       

       
       
        

 
 
 




     
         
      
      
       
    

      
    
     

      
 
 
        

      
       

        

        



22 23

      
 
    
        
 
                
              
    
 
        
       
        
          
 
      
       
          
     
 >@ 
  
   > @  
 >@
      
     > @
 >@ 
 
     
      
            
        
                
         
        >&RVHULX @      
       
        
       >@
                  >
  @      
            
      
24 

       
>@  
>@         
         
> 
@        
        
>   @         >  @     
            
       
>@ >@
        
  
       
>@        
      
      
 
>0DUNRY@  
      
      >@ 
                 
       
        >@  
              
               
           >@ 
 
      >
        @
          
 
 
 
               
        
     
   
                     
             
26 27

           
         
       
       
>@>@  
        
       
         
 


       
      


     



       




       


    
     
     
       

         
       


     

   
      
1. 29


         
 
       
    
  
         
;,;        

         
 


 

    
       

1. >@
, XIX . 

,;;; 
 
 
       
      
 
         
>7KHOLQJXLVWLFWXUQ@ 
      
       
        
 
          ;,;     
 
                 
  
      
        
 
  
        
,;,; >@
30 1. 1. 31

 
;,;  
        
                
  
    >@
      
 
         
        
            
 
       
 
                
  
         
        
 
  
 
     >&RVHULX @   
 
  > @      
          >@
 >@
 
 


        
   
    
    
          
"  
"          
         
 
  
32 1. 1. 33

        
           
 
                  
  
 
         
          
      > 
         @
       
 
         y
 
 
    > @
       
         
               
  
   VLJQDWXP         
 VLJQDQV  
  
  VLJQXP        
         
          
 
              
                 
          
            
  
            
       >  
 @        
>@       
      
 >@
 
 
34 1. 1. 

 
 
  >   @    
         
              
                  
                 
 
  
       
         
         
        
 
  zyy  
         
          
        
 
 
    >   @          
         
                    
          
>@ ;,; 
                    
       
   
 
 
       
        
       
           
   
          
          
       
         
       
36 1. 1. 37

          
      
       
 
       
       
        
        
     
       
        
          
       
  >  @    
 
       
         
   >@
        
                
                   
  
        
          
     
         
       
                
          >  @ 
 
>@        
         
                 
             
 
           
 
>@  
        
        
38 1. 1. 39

 
         
 
             
 
 
 >@
      
 
   
    
  
       
       
               
  >/DQJDJHHWSHQVpH@
/DQJDJHHWSHQVpH@
HWSHQVpH@
HWSHQVpH@
SHQVpH@
SHQVpH@
pH@
H@
@
   
               
     >   
@           
        
            
 
 
        
;,;;; 
  
  
 
 
 "
>@       
      
         
 
           >@
        
         
             
  
40 1. 1. 41

         
 
  SDUH[FHOOHQFH
        
    
          
           
            
        
  
 
 
  
 
 
>@ >E@  
      
         
>@ >@
 ;,;
 
>@ 
        
       
3        
          
          
4  
       
             
             
 
 
 
        
 
 . 
          
Ivanova I./HU{OHGHlInstitut ivogo Slova 3HWURJUDG GDQVODFXOWXUH

UXVVHGXGpEXWGX;;qPHVLqFOH/DQJDJHHWSHQVpH8QLRQ6RYLpWLTXHDQQpHV
Cahiers de lILSLQ 
  
Ivanova I.2SFLW3        
42 1. 2. 43

        
                
         
 >@ 
                   
         
        
   
         
;,;
;,;
 "
;,; "


        
 
     
 
           
>@    
              
      
        
               
            
 
 
     
>@         
      
      
       
 2. :
 , I .

              
       
        
 
 
 >@ 
44 1. 2. 

          
         
        
      
 
       
         
         
        
 >@
 
       
         
>@  
     
     
      
 
>@ 
               
 
>@           
                   
 >@
          
        
                  
               
         
      
;,;;;         
              
  
   
      
        
      
 
         
      
46 1. 2. 47

            
              
          
               
 
          
               
    >  @          
      
 
       
         
  >@
 
>E@
E@
@  >@ 
 
 >  @     
 
>@   >  @     
 
              
         
        
           
 
 
 >@ 
       
>@  

>@
 
   ,      
       
                
 
         
 


48 1. 2. 49


     
       
               
      >  @    .   
             
 
 
 
   
 
 
             
 
   "
 >@         
             
    
      
        >@
 
       
        
        
         
 "
 
 >@  
       
        
 
 
 
 
           
         
 
          
 
  
       
         
 1. 3. 

             
                
>@        
       
        
       
        
       
  
     
         
 
 3. :
       


>@       
               
       > 
         :LHU]ELFND 
        -DPHVRQ&KYDW N6WHLQHU
 7RPDQ@
@
  
      
  
    LQGH[ 
LQGH[ 
    
        
LFRQ 
LFRQ 
   V\PERO 
V\PERO 
     
 
   
 
>@       
  
          
    
      
 
        ;,;      
;;             
        
              
 1. 3. 

        
   
             
        
         
       
   >@
        
         >@ 
 > @         
 
                 
>  @   >  3RPRUVND  
/DQJXDJH 3RHWU\ DQG 3RHWLFV @    >@
 
    
                
         
      6  >@ 
        
    (LQVWHOOXQJ 
(LQVWHOOXQJ 
             
        >@
>  @            
         
           
      

      
              
  
         
         
   >  @        
        
           
     
 


  >  @    
        
      
      
 1. 3. 

     
 
        
                 
  7      
             
       
        
        
    
           
    >  @   8
 
  
        
        
        
                  
>@   
      
         
  . .1980
  
  . 
    ,     . .   
                  . .
         . 
 
. 

Ageeva I. V.9RORLQRY
          HW*SHWGHX[SRLQWVGHYXHVXUODVpPLRWLTXH/DQJDJHHWSHQVpH8QLRQ
 6RYLpWLTXHDQQpHV&DKLHUVGHO,/6/Q3
 Freiberger E.
                 
 >E@
          

  
        
> @        
 . .  . .
         >@ . . 
               
 
 1. 3. 

               
   > @           
               
 
9 
              
       , 
        
       
 -
10 >@.
 
              
 
      
  
    
          
           
        
           
         
        
         >@
      
>@ 
 
 
               >  @
VXLJHQHULV
VXLJHQHULV
JHQHULV
JHQHULV
 
      RPLQD  
          -      
>@ 
       
          
 
 .  
;9,,,  
  
. .           
 . .         
  
 1. 3. 

             
  
        
 
 
         
,           
$UV/XOOLDQD            
D >@
 
            
       
        "
       
FKDUDFWH FKDUDFWH    
ULVWLFXPD   
        
 >@        
          -        
       
                
        
              
 >@
         
  
      
               
                    
  11 >   @   >@
                   
       
 
 12
        
          

  
         
      
     > @   
>@            
 >@
60 1. 3. 61

 
          
    
 >  @       
       
       
              
              
       
        
             
                 
              
>@  >@
 "
  SHUVRQDFUHDQV
SHUVRQDFUHDQV
FUHDQV
FUHDQV

      "
  
   
 
       
       
        
  >  @      
 
 
>@        
       
"           
  
 
    >  @  
 
  
        
            
       
            
                
       >@
62 1. 3. 63

        
 
        
         
  
       
          
      
         -
 
 
       
        
 
   
      

         
        
 
 
> @         
 
         
        -      
 
 
         , ,
      ,   
         
      
>@ 
      
             
       
        ODQJXH  SDUROH 
   ODQJXH     
 SDUROH
      
         
64 1. 3. 

  ODQJXH  SDUROH    


        
      , 
" 
         
            
        
       >@
   pFULWXUH 
       
       
           
              
                 
                 
     > @          
>  @        
 
 
  13
     >@
  >  @         
             
       
           
  
 
  
                 
       
 >@
 -
pFDUWVW\OLVWLTXH
FDUWVW\OLVWLTXH
VW\OLVWLTXH
VW\OLVWLTXH
  
 
          
      
pULWXUH       
 
         
        
  

        
   
6 1. 3. 67

      
>@ 
  SULYDWHODQJXDJH 
 
  
       
          
                 
 
 " 
          
          
             >  @    
          
     
        
   >  @     
   
                
      
              
        
          
      
           
   
       
   
       
          
 
   
          
          
     
   
>@ . .      
 
 
      
68 1. 3. 69

>@      
         
               
           
  
        
         
         
 
    
               
            
>@       
  >   @            
        
 
 
         >  @     
       

 





       
 
   
 

 

 
 
        
       
       


        
 
  


       

        
      >  @



DGKRF

       
       
 
     ,
70 1. 3. 71

 
 
  
        
>@       
 
 
  
      
        
           
 
 
>@ 
             
        
         >@
  
     > @         
        
  
         
 >@
          
 
          
        
        
>@ 
        
       >@ 
          
 
        
>@  
 SDUROHODQJXHSDUROH
>@ 
        
        
        
72 1. 3. 73

          
           
        
         
 - 
,         
      
        
       
            
 GLQJOLFK 
GLQJOLFK 

 
          16       
 
         
        
      
      
  >  @         
        
               
       
 17
 
      c  
       
>@       
      
       
       
       

      
      
      

14



           

 
       

 . .  
.  . 
         
  

74 1. 3. 

         
             
         
             
18 
              
 
 
  21
               
        
        
              
       
        22
 
 
19 
   
       
         
       
              
 
 ;,;;;
     
       
       
  
         > @      
              
        

      
 20
 
  
 
 
 
      
          

  

76 1.

      


       
        

 
 
 
  

 
 



       
 1.
       
               H[SHULPHQW   
        H[SHUL
H[SHUL
 HQFH 

        
     

        
        
     
    
 
    

  
       
     23  

 
          
     
    >-DNREVRQ   
@

  > @    
78 2. - 1. 79

 
experiment 
        
               
    
        
  
 
        
         >
 @ 
             
   
       
   >@
>@ 
   
       >@
  
  
 
         
  
;,;
;,;
 
        
  
  
       
       
        
      
               
 
        
 
 
        

      >  *RUKDP 
@       
80 2. - 1. 81

   


        
   
       
               
  >   @          
      
    [SHULPHQWXP         
         
           
       
 
      
        
        
                 
  >  @  
       
 
           
           
       
        
         
 
 
>@ 
 
  
  
  >  
@
         
,          
        
      24
      
      
 
        

       

          
82 2. - 1. 83

              
          
      
        
                    
             
        
 
     - 
          
        
        
     
      >@
 
     
       
      
          
. .      
 
 >@
 
 
             
        
      
        

      
       
 
 
 
 . .  
              
      
        
      
    

 
 
 > E
E
 @        
 
        
84 2. - 1. 

            >  @   
   
 
          
 
    
        
         >@
      "    
        
        
 
       
       
>@ 
 
 
       
                
"        
        
       
 
   .        
>  @         VXL JHQHULV >  @   
       
         SDUH[FHOOHQFH
 
          
       
 
>@       
        
       >
 @
  
       >@
            > 
         @
  >KWWS@
86 2. - 1. 87

    >6FKZHUWH  'DV 


([SHULPHQWLQ/LWHUDWXUXQG.XQVW+HLVVHQE WWHO+RUFK 
'|KOKWWS@         
        
       
"          
      
        
                  
 %HJULIIVVFKULIW
 
       
      ;,;   
                  
      
        
                  
        
             
 
 
        
         
        >  
  @         
   
>@ 
 
         
         
               >  @
               
 
 
 
        
            
              
       >  @ 
 
88 2. - 1. 89

           
            >  @ 
 
     
>:HVWVWHLMQ@       
               
       
> 
@ 
           
         
       
               
       
         >
          @
              
            
       
 > @            
               
          
       
 26 
 
              
        
         
          
>@  
 
 
  
 
        
            
         
      
      

>@ 
 >@
90 2. - 2. 91

        
      
               
>@27 >@
            
  
     
      
      
                 
 
      
        
         
  
 
  
         
           
   
 
  
>@
2.  

 ;,;        
         
                 
 
 
 
>@  
 
       
         
        
>@ 
 >@

 
>@     
92 2. - 2. 93

               
      
             
          
>@       
               
       >@
         
            
  >@ 
 >/DFRXH/DEDUWKH  >@
 3HQVpH GH l H[SpULHQFH @    >@
              
       
         
               
         
                  
             
        
>@  
 
 
 
  
       
  >@
 .   
      
           >@
>@ 
     
         
        
      
       
        
        >@
         
>@ 
94 2. - 2. 

            
  
   >5LFKDUGV@ 
 
>@ 
       
         
   
   
        .   >  @  
 
"         
" 
      "  
 
 >@>@ 
        
 
 
  
       
                  
             
            
           
 >@
       
        
          
        
                 
              
             >  @
       
         
      
        
 
 
     .
96 2. - 2. 97

        
  
 >@ 
>E@  >@ 
       
  
  
 
 
 
 
 
 
        
        -
 
       -
>@          
       
        
              
      -
 >     
]  
       >@
 >0DUNRY
0DUNRY @     
        
  
      >@
      
 >@
>6KDGRZD@        
       
       
               
             
 >@
        
       
    
98 2. - 2. 99

                
 28             
      
            > 
           @    
            >3RJJLROL@>% UJHU@ 
      
               
29 
              
       
   
   
        
 
        
>@  
  
       
  
          
 30      
       
 
. .          >@
       
 . 
         
 
 >@
 
. .

       
 .   >@
KWWSZZZUXVVUXFXOWXUHWHNVW\GLDOHNWLNDBDYDQJDUGD 
  
 


                       
   Greenberg C.$YDQW*DUGH DQG .LWVFK  
3DUWLVDQ 5HYLHZ9, QR     .   
              Rodrigues O/DUWLVWHOHVDYDQW
      HW OLQGXVWULHO  7UDQVODWHG DQG TXRWHG LQ Calinescu M. 7KH )LYH )DFHV RI
;,; 0RGHUQLW\ 0RGHUQLVP $YDQW*DUGH 'HFDGHQFH .LWVFK 3RVWPRGHUQLVP
       'XUKDP3 
100 2. - 2. 101

            
        
         
              
 

       
 
   
      
>@       
       
       
                
        
    
  
                
 
           
  
         
        
      
       
   >  @           
               
             
>@      
           
      
  
  >  @    
       
   
               
        > @  
> @      
   31


 
  > @      ><DJXHOOR@
102 2. - 2. 103

                 
 
                 
                
     
                
 
 
        
      
  
             
 
      
           
 
 
            
>@ 
       
        
       >@
       
       
               
>@        
>@         
 
        
  >
>
           
] >]            
 
         
         
       
        >@
     
 
  
>@  
104 2. - 2. 

 
          
               
 
 
       
 
 


                
        
       
         
          
        >@

        
      
       

       
     
        
  
 >6FKPLGW@ 

       
      
       
        
           
 
>@






 
          
 
       
106 2. - 2. 107

      
         >@ 
       >   
  @        
        
       
         
 
           
 
              
         
  
.    
  
             
         
       
 >@ 
       
  
        
       
         
    
 
      
      
         
 
  
   
                
  
       
        
    >  @  
           
        
 
108 2. - 2. 109

     
             
    >  @  
                  
       
> 
@ 
      
 
        
            
           > @     
        
  >  @    
        
  
               
  
 
                
               
          
>  @        >  @    
       
       
        
     
         
  
 
 >@ 

    
             
            
         
       
     ;,;        32 

>@  

110 2. - 3. ? 111

       
         
       
        
       
 
>@        
      
 
           >  @
          
           
  
            
  
         
 
          
>@            
                 
             
 
       
 33
>@ 
   
       


 3. ?

       
              
            
        

   
   . .    
       
 
        
 
112 2. - 3. ? 113

         
         
      36 
     
        
        
 
 
           
 
      >  @ 
             
           
          
        
        
 
>@ 
          
               
                 
                  
        
   
                  
>@34
      

 
. . 
        
        
       
 >@
  

 
 
  ., .,
 . 
        
          KWWSDYDQWJDUGHQDURGUXPLVFHOODQHD
         VKDSLUKWP 
       
        
114 2. - 3. ? 

>@  


 
       
  
       
      
            38
         
        
           
  
 
             
37 

 
      
        
        
 
   
  
@         
 
            
               ">@ 
         
 
  
           

         


 
              
               
      
           . .
              
          
 .
  . .
       
 . 
           
. .
          
116 2. - 3. ? 117

       
      "       "
         >@
       " 
      
 
              
       
FKHIGRHXYUHD    >  @  
        
>@       
        
      
          
 
       . .   >@
 
 
   >  @  
               
                
 
 
       
        
. . >@ 
 >@
            
 "                 
         "   
"        
                    
 
 "          
" " 
                   
"  
 
" >@       
   
118 2. - 3. ? 119

      
      
 
         39
           
     
         
 
         
                  
      
 >@
           
         
 "
 ""
           +RZWKHDYDQWJDUGHZRUNV 
 
                 
      
   
     
 "
 
      
  
 
        
 >@
 
         
         
         
        
        
                
 
              

          
.
120 2. - 3. ? 121

        
  
 >@
                 
                  
       
 
 
 
 
 
 
       
 
       
     >  @   
 
         
      
     "
    
 

                
 
 
 
            
              
    
 
               
               
      > @    >   
>@  @         
            
          
              
         
          
122 2. - 3. ? 123

        .            
>E@
E@
@ 
       
 
>@       
      
  
         
       
          >  @ 
         .       
        
         
            
        
        
       
                
 
 
       
              
 
      
           
 
           
        "40
             
         

  

       
 
 
        
 



  >@
      >@
124 2. - 3. ? 

         
      
   
        
        
        
 "
             
               
               
 
                
>@  
     
      
            
        
y>@            
   
          
y   
>@ 
 
          
         
   
     >@
        
       
 
         
          
               
        
 
         
         
        >
       @       
126 2. - 3. ? 127

 
        
               
                
    
   
           
             
>@  
       
             
       
>@ >@  
       
 >@
  
        
           
       
           
  >@
          
 
 
         
          
        
   
        
41         

 
        
         
               
                
               
                
         
          
           
            
128 2. - 3. ? 129

                 >  @
        
 
         
       
       
 
 


  ;;       
         
          
             
        
                
          
                      
 
        

     > @   

  ,            
               
                
 
  
 
       >@
                 
      

          
         

 
  FRQ FRQ
             WUDGLFWLR LQ DGMHFWR       
          
   
        
  . .          
 . . >@
%HUQ
         
Janecek G.=DXP7KH7UDQVUDWLRQDO3RHWU\RI5XVVLDQ)XWXULVP6DQ'LHJR
> 
@ 
130 2. - 3. ? 131

  >@
.          
>@ 
 
                
        >@
      
         
  
  
  
   
                
      
           .       
  >@
.         
           
         
>@         
      
                
             
  > @            
         
          
42 
" >@ 
    .      
       
 >  @             
        

 
          
 > @            
       >2UDL7ROLF@
 >  @     
        


     
>@       
132 2. - 3. ? 133

     
       >@
        
 
 
  
   
   
         
        >@
             
 
          
         
        
 
>@      
             
          
          
  
>@        
       
          
       >@
            
          
      
         
 
         
         
>@       
          >  @  
               
           
      >  @   
        
                      
          
134 2. - 3. ? 

            
       >@
 
      
>@       
                  
   
 
          >@
>@    
        
         
 
 
 
         
        
  
         
        
>@ 
 
 
   
 
 >KWWS@
KWWS@
@
 
 
       
  >  @   > 
@ 
> @             
   
 
 
                
                
        
 
  
136 2. - 3. ? 137

           > 
        @
 
         
               
 
        
   
       
  
           
          
         
    >  @
          
      
 
       
 >@ 
           
       
  
  VXL JHQHULV      
 
  
  
 
 
 
                  
 
      
        
           
              
       
          
 
         
       
138 2. - 3. ? 139

         
       
      
            
>@        
        
    
  
         
         
       
 /           
    /              
    IRUPVXFKHQGH  
JHVWDOWVXFKHQGH'LFKWXQJ        
       
    >  @ 
             
                  
              
                 
   
      
 
        
        
         
  
        
        
 

       
              
        
" 
 
 "           
         
" 
140 2. - 3. ? 141

           
        
       
      
      
 
    
            
             
             
       
 
        
 
 
   >  @    
 
       
 
      
       
        
 >@
 
       >  @ 
        >  @
          
    
        
       
              
           
             
               
            
          
               
               >  @
         
      
142 2. - 3. ? 143

                   
              
      
>@ 
           
             
 
 
. . 

     

      

     
         


       




      
         
>@



         

      


>@  
 

      
       
          
1. . 


        
      
             


 
  

  
 
   
 >@ 

      
1. .         

     >  @
 
    ,     
       
      
       43
         
       
     
      
     
         
      
            

        
               
        
        
    . .   
         
 


        
 
146 3. 2. . 147

 
 
 
>E@ >@
   
               
    
         
         
           
          
       
         

>@ 2. .

         
   44 
          
 46 
       
           
        
 
>  @        
         
       
          >@
            

 
      
         
 


 
      
   
          ;;
,  7(;786 . .
   
          
 . 
 . .        
148 3. 2. . 149

         
47 
          
      
 
          
       
 HUJRQ  
         
 HQHUJHLD  
 
          
               
        
                  
 
 
          
 
  
 
    
   
         
        
              
"        

 
          
        
        
 .  
 . . 
 .   
 , ,,,  
;;Weststeijn W. G. $$3RWHEQMD 
DQG 5XVVLDQ 6\PEROLVP  5XVVLDQ /LWHUXDWXUH 9,,  .   
               
'LVVHUWDWLRQHV6ODYLFDH;9,,6]HJHG . 


 %HUJDPR  .    
                 
          
 3. 2. . 

  
         
        
 
       
  
           
 
        
          
         
        
       
              
                  
          
               
            
                  
  
       
 
     
 
>@ 
         
  
 
 
  
  
        
 >E@
        
 
                   
        >  @  
            
        
        
 3. 3. 

        
48       
 
 
 
  
 
         3. :
        
.
        
   >  @     

     




      
"
    

      >  @

      

        

     





       




      
      
       
         






> E @     
>@
     
       
   

  

 

        




        
 
. .   HSRV       
 . . P\WKRV  ORJRV 

 3. 3. 

   >6WHLQEHUJ


 @ 
        
                   
        
>@       
        
           
        
                
          
                 
 
      
          
 
        
       
   
           
           
           
  >@           
          
             
  
         
         >E@
     
       
  
        
  
  
 
   
    >'HSSHUPDQQ   
@  
  
  
 3. 3. 

               
             
              
           
     
         
   >@
   
 
             
 
 
 
       
          
         >E@
          
              
                  
   
             
 
 . . >E@ 
       
        
        
       
             
         
           
       
>@  
        
              
 
         >  @      
       
       
         
         
 3. 3. 

           >0DQGHONHU
0DQGHONHU  %H\HU  7RPLFKH @    
        
        
 
>@      
       $P$QIDQJVFKXI*RWW+LPPHOXQG(UGHQ
        
 

 >E@ 
         $P
  
 
                 
 P
 P
    Q $Q      
 
                
        
 Q
 
        
                
          >@
       $XURUD  
          
  

 DPDQDQ DP$QIDQJ 
  P Q    DPDQ  PDQ 
             manJWL   
       man-am  mana
  manah, man-mamanWUD
 manaVmamnDWHPQ
 minHWL   menos
 menVmenPH 
>@ $P$QIDQJ      DPDQDQ  
        PDQD Q DP$QIDQJ   -
        
160 3. 3. 161

     
 
     $QIDQJ   

      
$GDP.DGPRQ

DGDGDPRQ  0DQD
  
 
 
DPDQ PDQD  DPH  
 QQ         
>@ 
;      
          
 
>@49 
          dendrRQ  
          
          
        
  >@

  >  @           
  "             
 > @        
 
      LQ
 VWDWX QDVFHQGL         
>@ 
        
 
  
          
  
 
         
         
  OLQJXD LJQRWD     
;,,, 
>@ >@



  
>@  
162 3. 3. 163

                   
 

  
 
 
 
>@ 

 
 
         
  
>@  
  >@ 
        
       
                 
      
 
                 
            
        >@
 
  
  
 
  >@
  
 
>@       
  
 . .  
        
             >  @  
>E@
E@
@    
 
          
        
        
164 3. 3. 

            "       
      > @ 
       
   
 
 
  
 
 
          
           
          
         
     
          
        
 
        
  
      
 
          
 

 
        
          

 
 
        
   
          
 
 
         
         
  
          
 
   
 >@
 >@
166 3. 3. 167

                  
 
       
            
                 
                    
 
 
 
 
              
         
                
 
 
 
          
        
      
>@ 
 
           > @        
        
 
                 
          
 
 
 
 
   
 
 
       
        
 >  @     
 
"         
                 
"                 
168 3. 3. 169

               
                
               
            
 
 >  @               
       
         
        
  
        
  
 >  @      
  
 
       
               
 >@
             
       
       
       > 
@ 
 
        
                 
 
         
>@       
>@ 
       
   
        
                 " 
  
 
       
 
             
>@ 
170 3. 4. . 171

          
                  
                 
    
             
                 
          >@
        
               
              
           
 
 
 
                
  
   
 4. .

 
y 
            
  
 
             >@
          
  
 
  
       
     
       
       
        
        >@
>@  
  
  
 
172 3. 4. . 173

        
> @       
       -----
  - 
          - 
     
   
      
         
 ---  
      
        
         
  
 
  
  
  / 
     
        
    
 
 
         

 -- ----- --- - 
 - --- - -
    
            
         
 >E@
 
      
--             
        
       
-----       
          
      
       
174 3. 4. . 

 >+LQGOH\@>@
           
  
 
  >@ 
               
        
   >  @     
         
 
>@         
 >:RURQ]RII@ 
 
          
 
      
       
 >@
         
          
 >@
  >@
 
         
 
>@ 
 >@
 
 >  @    

 
       
   
 
  >  @        >  @ 
    
       
  
         
>@  
176 3. 4. . 177

 
      
 


          
 
 
          
 
     
 
 >@
 
 



        
 
    >  @
       
         
        
            
    
        
     
        

                
         
         
   
   
        ; , ; ;

       
        
 
"" 
">E@

         
  

         
            
178 3. 4. . 179

     
>@   
  
  
         
                   
               
 
         
       >@
    >  @      
      
      
  
   >@
 
 
 
>E@ >@
 >@ 
          


        
         
                 
        
       >  @    
             
        >@
  
  
  
 >@
 
         
     > EE
 @  
 >@       
       
      
180 3. 4. . 181

                
               
 
        
 >  @         
 
                
           
       >E@
 
 
 /
 
 >E@ 
      
    1HZHOXQJ 
     

        
       

        
            
        
 
  
        
 
   
   

OXQDOXQHOXPHQ0RQGPHQVLV
    >  @    
    >@         
>@
 
      
        
          
       >  @
         
       
 
   
182 3. 4. . 183

       
  - - --
 /  / -
  /  /  - /

- / , / 

 / 
 
        
         
 
       
  
 

        
        
/  /  / /

  /  /  / 
        
       
 
       
          
                    
  


        
                   
 
 >E@
E@
@
 
>@ 

DGKRF
DGKRF
KRF
KRF

  
          
         



  
           
        >  @  
>@         
 


  
             
184 3. 4. . 

       
        


 >@ 
  
         
  
         

  

 

       
   
         
        
         
       
   
       >@
  
 
         
        
>@  
  
        

  
            
 
 
   
     
      
   
   
 
   
     
     >@     
        

 
 
186 3. 4. . 187

   
        
              
      
     >@      
>E@
E@
@


 
 
         
     
       


                 
  
    
    >  @      
         
         > @    
           
                 
          
          
 
  3URPHWKHDQ OLQJXLVWLFV   
          
        
        
  >&ODUN @   > @   

 >@
  
 
 
 
 
 
 >@
        
                  
   
          >@ 
 
 
 
 
 
 

      
                   
  
       
  
188 3. 4. . 189

>@         
        
 
   
 
>  @      
         
       
      >&  @          
 

 
 
       




 
>)DU\QRKWWS@ 
 
>@ 
    >@

>@      
         
         
        
 
       
  
        H[SHULPHQW 
H[SHULPHQW 

        
                  
 
       >@
                  
 
          >  @      
                
          
  
190 3. 5. 191

               
   > @   > @     
 
 
 
 
      
          
5.

. 

        
          
     
       
          
  
  >-DQHFHN(OVZRUWK
       @ 
  >-DQHHN  
(OVZRUWK@    
          
        
  
                
                
        
  ,       
 
 >@ 
 
         
       

>@   
        
     . .   
        
        


 
 
192 3. 5. 193

               
                
                  
       
         

 > E @             
 
 
       
 
            >   @
                
          
  
                  
 
 >  @   
          
      
        >  @      
           
> @               
            >  @ 
    >  @         
 >@
       
        
 
>E@   
      
 
            
  
      
        
            
               
   
       
194 3. 5. 

        
  

DGKRF
 

 
 
               
  
        
   >  @  
 ;
    
          
  
 
        
        
       
    /             
       
       
 
>@ 


         
   
, , -
         , 
       
             
         
             
        , -
 
      
          

196 3. 5. 197

                
       
 
      
      - 
   
          
 >@
       >@
        
           
            
>@ >@
       
          
                    
          > @      
  
          
       
         
       , , ,        
               
         
, , , ! 
  
   
 
        
  
      
         
 
 


 
       
      
 
198 3. 5. 199

 
  >+LQGOH\@ 
 
      
 
  
       
 
 >@
             > @      
" > @      
>E@ 
        
              
        
           
            
                
       
 
 
         
 
        
                 
                 
      SDUROH  VXLJHQHULV
         
         
ODQJXH            >@
  
         
          
         
         
 >@ 
                 
                 
        
                
200 3.

        >  
@

  
      

 
 





1. . :

     
        


        

          
     
>@ 

      
>@ 
"

        

         

  




202 4. 1. 203

        
       
               
"         
 
   

       
  
  
  >
         @ 
      
>@  
>@  
        
 
>@ 

>@

>@ 
 
 
 
  >@
  
 
        
 >@ 
 >@ 
        
                 
        
 
 
  
                 
                   
        
 
  
>@          
204 4. 1. 

        
         
  >@
>@          
              
      
 
        
>@          
 
 
          
         
 >@
 
 
 
   
 
 
           
   
 >@ 
 
       
 
            
                 
        
 
         > E@  
         
 
     
              
                   
 
         
 
          
206 4. 2. . 207

        
       
         
" 
        
2. .        
       
               
        
      
        
                 
                
           
      "    >+DFNHU@ 
    "           
          
          
 >@ 
 >@ 
              
              
        
        
            
        
 
"            
                
            > @   > 
  @        
         
                      
                  
              
            
           
         
          >  @    
       
208 4. 2. . 209

        

       
                
       
        
 
 
 
   
               
               
         
>:HVWVWHMLQ@  
               
 
         
     >*U\JDU           
  @                 
>@          
  
                   
   .        
 
 
         
 >@
       
         
         
 

         
 
 
 



         
              
       "    
210 4. 2. . 211

      
     
 
      
 
 
        
 
  
         
          
 >  @      
 
 
          
 
   
       
       
 
         
               
 
 
    
     
>@ 
  
  
 
>  @      
 

 
 
        
>@        
>-DQHFHN@        


       
 
>@ 
212 4. 3. . 213

   >  @     


 
        
 
          
   
              
       
                 
                 
          
 >@ 
 >:HVWVWHLMQ@ 
 
 

 3. .
"
>@          
                  
>*ROGW @               
 
         
        
>@ 
             
 
 >  @      >@ >@ 
         
         
           
>@ 
 
   
 
         
               
                   
  
 >:HVWVWHMLQ@
214 4. 3. . 

>@        
  
       
                
 >@ 
  > @       
       >6ROLYHWWL@
        >@>,PSRVWL
            @  
         >6FKRO]/DXKXV@
         >@
         >@
>  @   > @      
        
     
       
  >  @             
 
         
       >@
>@           
         
         
          
 
 
 
 
 
         
 
  >@
 
         
              
.   
         
 
.  >@      
 
216 4. 3. . 217

                 
 
>@         
       
  
        
        >   @     
 
  
 
         
 
     > @  
      
 
             
            
      
      
       
        >@
                
           
 ;9,,
         
  
  
                  
         
 
 
         
   
        
 
     "   
 
 
  
       
218 4. 3. . 219

  
 
 






       


  
 

 



  
      



       

       



       
              



 
        
 
        

       




  
  

  
       
  
 
         
           
       
        
220 4. 3. . 221

          
 
 
       "
 
  
>@  
 
 
  
>@  
         
          
         
        
 
  
  
 
 
      
          
                
             
 
         
          
          
 
        
       
          
>@          


      
       
        
          
                
222 4. 3. . 223

          


        
         
        > @  
         
     
  >  @           
    
                
         
         
      
         
         
   
 
                      
          
 
     
      >@
       
           
 
 
 
 
 
        
  
         
       
        
              
                 
          
,,  

 

         /HV0RWV$QJODLV 
        >&DVVHG\@
224 4. 3. . 

9,, 
 

 
 

 
 



 
 "
 
 
 
 
 
 




       
 
        
      
 
 
 

 
 
 
 
 







 
 
 
 
 
 
 
226 4. 3. . 227

 
 
         
         

        

       
             
        
      
 
                 
         >@ 
              
            
          
                
               
          
>  @    >@
     
 
 
        
    
 >@       
 
 
   
 
>@        
  
  
  
>@        
 
       
          
            >  @
                
228 4. 4. 229

         


  
   
  
 
       
>@      
              
        
 
       
         
         
         
>@          
             
         
      
     
       
          
               
                 
              
        
    
         
         
          
        
         
4. .
     
.
         
     
      
>@

     
          
 
;,,,
        
      

>@  
     
230 4. 4. 231

                  
         
   >  @    
 
 
       
          
           
          
>  @                 
           
>@   >@ 
 
  
 
        
 
              
 
                   
 
 
       
        
  
"      
        
  
       
     > @ 
        
        
          >
         @         
         
            
 
 
   >@
 
  

 >@
232 4. 4. 233

>@           
 
        > @  
     
" 
"  
 >@ 
"      
 
        
 
>@ >@

              
        >@
      
  
 
         
        
         
       
       
 >@
                   
      
 
  
         
       
              
        
        
>@ 
        
                 
      .       

 

 
 >@       
234 4. 4. 

              
  
 
         
 
 >@
        
               
 
>@  
      
      > @   
                 
>@ 
         
 
        
    >  @   
  
       
 
       
 >@
 
   
        
        
  
        
         
          
       
"           
      
      >@
    >  @         
         
>@ 
       
        
236 4. 4. 237

        
        
         
        
 
 
 
         
     > E @   
 
        
 
         
           
 
 
  
 
        
      

 >@ 

 


       
         




 
 

        
       


        
1. 239


      

          
        
     
    >  @ 
        
        
        




 6 0
        


        
1. 

 
        

   
        
   >    /DWL @      
          
          
       
          
  .
       

 .-.

 .,
 .       
   .     
  
  .
 
  . .
                  
         
 


240 5. 1. 241

 >@
 
>@ 
 
               
        >@
 
 
   
   
            
             
         
 
         
      
               
       
         
         >@6 1     
        
 >@ 6 2
     
         
 6 3
 
           
>@  6 4
        

  . .
  
  
 
 
  
 >@
 
.    :LHQHU 6ODZLVWLVFKHU $OPDQDFK %G  
 6
 
Stone-Nakhimovsky A. $ /DXJKWHU LQ WKH 9RLG  :LHQHU 6ODZLVWLVFKHU

$OPDQDFK%G6
         
.2EHULXWLDQDKLVWRULFD
              
242 5. 1. 243

                  
             
           
              
 
                   
         
           
        
         
         
           


  
         
,,,         
         
 >@
              
      
" 
       
 6 6 
         
 
  "
    "      
  
>@ 

 
 
 
         

    ;;,;,,  
      .   
        
          
  
 
. KWWSZZZOLWDVKDUXFRORXPQV"LG  W W
244 5. 1. 

>
 @ 
      
         

      
        
         
      
          




>@
 
 
            
                 
         
       
               
 >6WRLPHQRII@       
            
 
         
       
   

      
        
  >  @     
             
                  
          
         
        
          
              
        
        
         
          
    >  @   >@
246 5. 1. 247

 
          
              
 >  @     
               
                    
         
>@      
       
  >1DNKLPRYVN\   @     
                 
                     
                  
                   
 
>@

          
         
       
             
" >@
              
          
"       
          
 >  @            
                   
  
        
         
 
>@ 
       
          
        
 >@
                 
                 
             
248 5. 1. 249

             
 
 
>@  DEVXUGXV
 
 VXUGXV
 
        
 
  
" 
 >@ 
 >@ 
>@       
       
        >@
               
        
       
 
>@ 
 
           
               
          
                 
>  @            
>@>@ 
 
 
>@ 




        
        

DEVXUGXV

 DEVXUGXV     DE 

       

VXUGXV
 
 5. 1. 

              
  
>@ 
 
        >@
 
        
 
        
 

"
   
       
  >@         

 
        
      
          
           
 
          
       
>@ 
         




  
  
      
 
          

         
         
                
                  
 
 
                 
        
 5. 2. , ? 

 
 


2. , ?

 ( . )

"
       
      "
 +S
 S
      "
  
        "
       +
+SS

+"

+
 
        GHHS

WUXWKV       
        
        
              
         
      
        
        > @     
 
                   
 "
      
       
                
     
       
                   
 
 
    >  @  
 
 5. 2. , ? 

        
                 
               
       
        
>@ 
 "
 
               
      
>@       
 >@
       
           
>@ 
 
        
 
       
       
        
              
 
 
     
        
>@ 
 
                  
" 
                  
             
 >@
 
 
 
"        
       >@
     "   
>@ 
 5. 2. , ? 

       
              
       
          
             
6 7       
 
 >@
 >@ 
             
 
        
         
" 
         >@
 
        
 
            
>@          
       
 
        
>@         
                 
 
               
       
       
              
   > @      
      
                 
           
           
        
 
 .               
   . .    
        
         
,,,          
 
 5. 2. , ? 

          
 
 
  
  
        
   
        
 
  
  
 
 
   
 
 
           
""        
"       
 
"          
"" >@
 
 
""         
 
 
         
         
 
  HSRFKH   GRFWD LJQRUDQWLD  
 
           
       
        
         
         
 
 
      
260 5. 2. , ? 261

          
 

 
        
          
           
                
          
        
           
        
       
         
                  
         
       
        
       
      
         
       
        
             

 
 
 
 
 





        



 
  
 
 
 
262 5. 2. , ? 263

  
  
 
               
   
  
         
       
          
 
 
                
         
          
 

           

>@


        
      
        
  

 
       
         
              
        
          
        
 
  
  SDU H[FHOOHQFH       
 
       
   
       
          
   
         
264 5. 2. , ? 

                   
 
                 
     
       
        ""
 ""
         
 
 "
 "6 8
       
         
               
       
 
 
 
 
  
  
         
 >@ >@ 
 
 
 
         
       
 
" 
" 

        
       
" 
        
 

  
.        
 
266 5. 3. 267

 >
   @   
                
        
          
 
        
 
 
          
 "
 
   
 
                 
         
        
  
 
  F
        >@ 
 
 
      
                
         
6 9           > 
@ 
3. : 
       
. .
 
 
        
      
     

      
 
       
 
       
 
      
       
        
      
>)HVKFKHQNR@        
268 5. 3. 269

              
        $%&
          
         
>@ 
        
 
 
                
        
       
 
               
         
       
 
                  
>@ >@
        
               
       
 
 
        Q       
         
>@ >@ 
              
 
 
         
                 
              
     
  
        
       
   
        
 
>@ 
270 5. 3. 271

 
                  
    >  @      >  @ 
            
         
        
      
       
         
                  
         
      
   
      
         
                
 
  


       
         
             
>@ 
 
                
        
          
         >  @    
              
>@ >@
 
        
        
              
                 
           
        
       
 
272 5. 3. 273

 
 
  
      


   
  .   
          
                
         >  @    
 
          
         
        
         
         >@
        
        
        "
             

         
        >  @  
 
  -
      
         
  
 
           
        "
      
                       
   
 
 
 "
 >@
   
 "  
274 5. 3. 

  
"70 

      
            
         
              
>  @       
         
       
 
      
       
          . . 
              
               
          
          
 
>@  
          
  
   >  @    

 

       

  VDUYDGKDUPDVXQ\DWD 


       

>@
 
        
%
        






            

 


       

 
>
@ 
276 5.

      

        
  



 FUHDWLRH[
OLQJXD  
 
        




          

      

  -       1.

       
           
 
 
  >5HYROXWLRQRI
 WKH:RUG%UXQV3HUORII4XDUWHUPDLQ3HUHOPDQ
 @ 
 
 
 
        
     
       
       >@
                
         
 
      
 

        71  

 
$Q2EMHFWLYLVWV$QWKRORJ\1<
278 6. 1. 279

        
        
           
           
     
      
       
>@ 
     
 
 TXDVLVWDQGDUG 
TXDVLVWDQGDUG 
VWDQGDUG 
VWDQGDUG 
 
            
  
          
       
        72 
  
 
       
        >E@
         

        
       
  
 
   
       .  
 
   
        
 
         



         SHUVRQD

     

 
 
   
  
280 6. 1. 281

       /DQJXDJH  >'HNRYHQ
'HNRYHQ @       
          
       
>@ 
            
       
 
       
          
       
     



  



 
>@        
        
 
     
   >@        
       
  
      
 




        
  
  
       
       
             >@
          
         
 
  /HFWXUHVLQ$PHULFD 
            +RZ WR ZULWH   
        7KH 0DNLQJ RI
        $PHULFDQV         
       
 

 
  
                
   
          
   
            
       $ 'LIIHUHQW >'\GR@
282 6. 2. . 283

     
 
 

 2. .

  +RZWR
        ZULWH 
  JUDPPDU PD\ EH UHFRQVWLWXWHG 
    
 
>)DU\QRKWWS@
)DU\QRKWWS@
KWWS@
KWWS@
@       
  7KHJUHDWWKLQJ
>4XDUWHUPDLQ@
4XDUWHUPDLQ@
@ DERXWODQJXDJHLVWKDWZHVKRXOGIRUJHWLWDQGEHJLQRYHUDJDLQ 
 
     
 >@  JUDPPDUPD\FDUU\RSSRUWXQLWLHV 
JUDPPDUPD\FDUU\RSSRUWXQLWLHV 
PD\FDUU\RSSRUWXQLWLHV 
PD\FDUU\RSSRUWXQLWLHV 
FDUU\RSSRUWXQLWLHV 
FDUU\RSSRUWXQLWLHV 
RSSRUWXQLWLHV 
RSSRUWXQLWLHV 

  *UDPPDUOOVPH
  >  @    ZLWKGHOLJKW 
 
                 
 
            >3HUORII @      
        
 
     "   
 
        
>=XNRIVN\@  "  
        
                
        
 
         
            >  @
                
              "
   &RPSRVLWLRQ
&RPSRVLWLRQ DV H[SODQDWLRQ 
    
      3  
       
      
284 6. 2. . 

       SHDSHDFRROHUZLWKDODQGDODQGFRVWLQZLWKDODQGFRVWLQVWUHWFKHV
 :LOOOHDSEHDWZLOOLHZHOODOO7KHUHVWUHVWR[HQRFFDVLRQRFFDVLRQWREH
 VRSXUUHGVRSXUUHGKRZ 7HQGHU%XWWRQV 

         
   Eal us eal us with no pea 
        
        
       
 

 1RWVRIDU
        &RQVWDQWO\DVVHHQ
          1RWDVIDUDVWRPHDQ
,PHDQ,PHDQ
> @     
&RQVWDQWO\

$VIDU
         6RIDU
 )RUERUH
         +HIRUERUH
 7RIRUEHDU
 7KHLUIRUEHDUV 1HZ 

        
       
                
      
       
 
   
 
        

$ W\SH RK RK QHZ QHZ not QR not knealer knealer RI ROG VKRZ 
EHHIVWHDNneitherneither 7HQGHU%XWWRQV         

     
>@


wlii:

,WLVVRDQRLVHWREHLVLWDOHDVWUHPDLQWRUHVWLVLWDVRROGVD\WR  
EHLVLWDOHDGLQJDUHEHHQ(HOXVHDOXVZLWKQRQRSHDQRSHDFRROQR  
286 6. 2. . 287

      > @    


       
                
                
         
                 
        
 $JUDPPDULQ
GLVDVVRFLDWLRQ 
       >'HNRYHQ  @   
          
 WKHUHFUHDWLRQRIODQJXDJH   %HVWDQGPRVWLQLQWHUSOD\ 
      
 UHFDSWXULQJ WKH ZRUG      
         
  
 (LQVWHOOXQJ          
       
        >&RSHODQG@ 
&RSHODQG@ 
@ 
  
        
      >@
>'HNRYHQ@
'HNRYHQ@
@           
        
         
           
         
    
      
 
>@ 
      
      
              
>@      
              
                
  
      
288 6. 2. . 289

+RZDQ\WKLQJFRPLQJLQWRWKDWRQHFRPHVRXWRIWKDWRQHKRZVRPH 
WKLQJVFRPLQJLQWRWKDWRQHKDUGO\DUHFRPLQJRXWRIWKDWRQHKRZPXFK >'XEQLFN@
'XEQLFN@
@
WKHWKLQJVFRPLQJRXWRIWKDWRQHDUHGLIIHUHQWIURPWKHWKLQJVJRLQJLQWR  VHFRQGGHJUHHRIJUDP
VHFRQGGHJUHHRIJUDP
GHJUHHRIJUDP
GHJUHHRIJUDP
RIJUDP
RIJUDP
JUDP
JUDP
WKDWRQHKRZTXLFNO\DQGKRZVORZO\KRZFRPSOHWHO\KRZJUDGXDOO\ PDWLFDOQHVVVHPLJUDPPDWLFDOQHVV 
KRZLQWHUPLWWHQWO\KRZQRLVLO\KRZVLOHQWO\KRZKDSSLO\KRZGUHDULO\  WKLUGGHJUHH
KRZGLIFXOWO\KRZJDLO\KRZFRPSOLFDWHGO\KRZVLPSO\KRZMR\RXVO\ RIJUDPPDWLFDOQHVVXQJUDPPDWLFDOQHVV 
KRZERLVWHURXVO\KRZGHVSRQGLQJO\KRZIUDJPHQWDULO\KRZGHOLFDWHO\        
KRZURXJKO\KRZH[FLWHGO\KRZHQHUJHWLFDOO\KRZSHUVLVWHQWO\KRZUH >)DLUOH\@ 
SHDWHGO\ KRZ UHSHDWLQJO\ KRZ GULO\ KRZ VWDUWLQJO\ KRZ IXQQLO\ KRZ  
FHUWDLQO\KRZKHVLWDWLQJO\>6WHLQ@       
         
      KDPSHU  

 
  O\
O\
        
 
                 
       
     >  @   
   
          
    REVFXULW\ 
REVFXULW\ 
 
 <RXFDQGXSOLFDWHDGXSOLFDWH7KH\GXSOL
<RXFDQGXSOLFDWHDGXSOLFDWH7KH\GXSOL
FDQGXSOLFDWHDGXSOLFDWH7KH\GXSOL
FDQGXSOLFDWHDGXSOLFDWH7KH\GXSOL
GXSOLFDWHDGXSOLFDWH7KH\GXSOL
GXSOLFDWHDGXSOLFDWH7KH\GXSOL
DGXSOLFDWH7KH\GXSOL
DGXSOLFDWH7KH\GXSOL
GXSOLFDWH7KH\GXSOL
GXSOLFDWH7KH\GXSOL
7KH\GXSOL
7KH\GXSOL
GXSOL
GXSOL >'XEQLFN@
FDWH RU GXSOLFDWHG WKLV 
        
    6WDUW 6WDUWOH 6WDUWOHG abundance          
 
73                
  6XSSRVH JUDPPDU XVHV LQYHQWLRQ             
         >@
             
          
            
        >6WHLQ@
>@      
       

 
  
                
>6DSLU@
        
>6DSLU@
>-DNREVRQDQG:DXJK@ 
290 6. 2. . 291

  a lake


:KDWLVWKHGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQD
:KDWLVWKHGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQD
LVWKHGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQD
LVWKHGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQD
WKHGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQD
WKHGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQD
GLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQD
GLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQD
EHWZHHQD
EHWZHHQD
D
D

JDQGDQDS
JDQGDQDS
DQGDQDS
DQGDQDS
DQDS
DQDS
DS
DS 
SOH7KHRQHSUHFHGHVWKHRWKHU      a lake      
          
          
               
        
       
       
>@ 
  
      
  
       
          $VHQWHQFHLVPDGHRIDQDUWLFOHDQRXQDQGDYHUE7KHWLPHWRFRPHLV
 DVHQWHQFH
        
         
       
          7KLV
>  @        PDNHV LQVWDQW grammar     
         *UDPPDU,QDEUHDWK 
               UHJXODU   
    LUUHJXODU   
        
         
          
      
     
        
   
        
 
      
 6HQWHQFHV        

$ODNHLVDQDUWLFOHIROORZHGE\DQRXQ 

           
               
292 6. 2. . 293

      >@ 
 
        
5HIRUP WKH SDVW DQG QRW WKH IXWXUH WKLV LV ZKDW WKH SDVW FDQ WHDFK KHU         
UHIRUPWKHSDVWDQGQRWWKHIXWXUHZKLFKFDQEHOHIWWREHKHUHQRZKHUHQRZ        
DVLWLVPDGHWREHPDGHWREHKHUHQRZKHUHQRZ      
5HIRUPWKHIXWXUHQRWWKHSDVWDVIDVWDVODVWDVUVWDVWKLUGDVKDGDVKDQG >@
LWKDVLWKDSSHQHGWREHZK\WKH\GLG'LGWZRWRRWZRZHUHVHQWRQHDWRQFH

DQGRQHDIWHUZDUGV 3DWULDUFKDO3RHWU\ 
>@
        

      
 

        
     
      
 
   reform past future

leftto beherenowmadeastwoone 

 now
to be here nowleft to be (DWWLQJHDWLQJDJUDQGROGPDQVDLGURRIDQGQHYHUQHYHUUHVROXEOHEXUVW
here nowhere now ashere now heremade to be here QRWDQHDUULQJQRWDEHZLOGHUHGQHFNQRWUHDOO\DQ\VXFKED\
  ,VLWVRDQRLVHWREHLVLWDOHDVWUHPDLQWRUHVWLVDVRROGVD\WREHLVLW
 DOHDGLQJDUHEHHQ,VLWVRLVLWVRLVLWVRLVLWVRLVLWVRLVLWVR 7HQGHU
 %XWWRQV 

     
 old man
said roo not a near ring so a noise a least remain to rest a
       leading are been  eat tingre soluble 
         is it so is it so      
 .     
  
          
         
         
   >  @     DG KRF
   FRQFUHVFHQFH
           
  
  
 &RPSRVLWLRQDVH[SODQDWLRQ 
               
       
294 6. 2. . 

 
 

 One is frightened in being one being living. One is not frightened in
 being one being living. One is frightened again. One is again and again not
frightened

 



  


  At any moment when you are you you are you without the memory of
 yourself because if you remember yourself while you are you you are not for
         purposes of creating you

 







falsity of time         
 
        
 
      





      
 ,  
 
  
        
         
And so the human mind is like not being in danger but being killed, there is
  
no remembering, no there is no remembering, and no forgetting because you      
have to remember to forget no there is none in any human mind 
  

 
               
        
296 6. 2. . 297

 morning
  mourning
   warning       
           

  

 
 
  
            
.         

               
 
>@
 
  UHSHWLWLRQ 
UHSHWLWLRQ 

 LL Q V L V W H Q F H

 

  VOLJKWHVWFKDQJH 
VOLJKWHVWFKDQJH 
FKDQJH 
FKDQJH 

 
 

  
2SLXPGHQRSLXPWKHQRSLXPZKHQ
      







      
         
      
      
>@
         

       
7KHVSLGHUVD\V 
/LVWHQWRPH,,DPDVSLGHU\RXPXVWQRWPLVWDNHPHIRUWKHVN\WKH   
VN\UHGDWQLJKWLVDVDLORUVGHOLJKWWKHVN\UHGLQWKHPRUQLQJLVDVDLORUV 
ZDUQLQJ\RXPXVWQRWPLVWDNHPHIRUWKHVN\,DP,,DPDVSLGHUDQGLQ  >@ 
WKHPRUQLQJDQ\PRUQLQJ,EULQJVDGQHVVDQGPRXUQLQJDQGDWQLJKW,EULQJ 
WKHPGHOLJKW >@
       
           
298 6. 2. . 299

                  
       
         
 
    
 >:KLWHKHDG@
  "
 
      

             
L Q F D Q W D W L R Q  >E@
 
         
               
 
 >.RUJ
.RUJ @       
 
 >'HNRYHQ@ 
             
 
 
 >@
           
>'HNRYHQ@        
      
   
          
 
   
       
 
   WKH WKH KXPDQ PLQG LV QRW FRQ
           FHUQHGZLWKEHLQJRUQRWEHLQJWUXH 
   
                
   
             
         
   FRQWLQXLW\   
300 6. 2. . 301

                 
           
 
               
         
           
 
 
 
  
        
       ZGR\RXOLNHZKDW\RXKDYHKHDUG +LVWRU\PXVWEHGLVWLQJXLVKHG )URP
 PLVWDNHV +LVWRU\ PXVW QRW EH ZKDW LV +DSSHQLQJ +LVWRU\ PXVW QRW EH
DERXW 'RJV DQG EDOOV LQ DOO 7KH PHDQLQJ RI WKRVH :RUGV KLVWRU\ PXVW
5RVHLVDURVHLVDURVHLVDURVHLVDURVH EH 6RPHWKLQJ XQXVXDO DQG 1HYHUWKHOHVV IDPRXV DQG 6XFFHVVIXO +LVWRU\
PXVW %HWKHRFFDVLRQRIKDYLQJ ,QHYHU\ZD\HVWDEOLVKHGD 3UHFHGHQWKLV
WRU\PXVW %HDOOWKHUHLVRIQRLPSRUWDQFH ,QWKHLUZD\VXFFHVVLYHO\ +LVWRU\
 PXVWEHDQRSHQ 5HDVRQIRUQHHGLQJWKHP 7KHUHZKLFKLWLVDVWKH\ $UH
  SHUIHFWO\ZLWKRXWD 'RXEWWKDWLWLVLQWHUHVWHG +LVWRU\PXVWQRWEHDQDF
  FLGHQW

       

    
 
>@          
 
 
         
 
 
 PXOWLGLPHQVLRQDO 
PXOWLGLPHQVLRQDO 
        
 
  
    
  
 
       
  
> @  
302 6. 3. 303

, PHDQ , PHDQ DQG WKDW LV QRW ZKDW , PHDQ , PHDQ WKDW QRW DQ\ 
RQHLVVD\LQJZKDWWKH\DUHPHDQLQJ,PHDQWKDW,PHDQVRPHWKLQJDQG 
,PHDQWKDWQRWDQ\RQHLVWKLQNLQJLVIHHOLQJLVVD\LQJLVFHUWDLQRIWKDW   
WKLQJ,PHDQ,DPQRWFHUWDLQRIWKDWWKLQJ,DPQRWHYHUVD\LQJWKLQNLQJ
IHHOLQJEHLQJFHUWDLQRIWKLVWKLQJ,PHDQ,PHDQ,NQRZZKDW,PHDQ
""         
"       
       
   
                
       
     &RDO DQ\ FRDO LV FRSSHU $ 
VKDZOLVDKDWDQGKXUWDQGDUHGEDOORRQDQGDQXQGHUFRDWDQGDVL]HUD 
VL]HURIWDONV6XJDULVQRWDYHJHWDEOH7HDUVDUHQRWWKHFKRUXV)RRG       
LVQRWWKHFKRUXV0RQH\LVQRWWKHFKRUXV  
   
 >@
 
          
 
  
   
           
        
         
         
 3. .
       
                 
          
  "
          
  
 
 >@  >@
 
 
 
 
304 6. 3. 

        
         
 
 
         
      
>@  
>@  
         >@
         
               
>@ 
  
 > @     
        
   
                  
 
>@         
         
   >@ 
 
        
         
      
 
 





 
>@" 
 
         
 
      

     
               
         
             
306 6. 3. 307

      UHSHDWLQJ
         OLVWHQLQJ 
OLVWHQLQJ 
  UHSHDWLQJ
UHSHDWLQJ
 SRXQGLQJ 
SRXQGLQJ 
  EH
EH
WHPSRUDOV   LQJ 
         
                




 
WKLVVXPPHUVXPPHUQRZVXPPHUUHFHQWO\ 
LQWKHPRUQLQJ   
ZKLOHPRUQLQJSKDVHLVRFFXUULQJ7H
H
H
 VXPPHU6HSWHPEHUVXQ
VXPPHU6HSWHPEHUVXQ
6HSWHPEHUVXQ
6HSWHPEHUVXQ
VXQ
VXQ
   VHWEH
EH EH
     >  @ FRPLQJODWHUDQGODWHU  
ODWHUDQGODWHU  
ODWHUDQGODWHU  
DQGODWHU  
DQGODWHU  
ODWHU  
ODWHU  
  
        
         >@
        
   
      SKDVH
 HYHQWVHYHQWLQJ >@ SKDVHVSKDVLQJORYLQJORYH
 JHUXQGV  WLPLQJWLPH 
 SDUWLFLSOHV 
SDUWLFLSOHV 
 
 
         
        
      PHDQ PHDQ >@
LQJ OLNLQJ NQRZLQg               
 ORYLQJORYH   
   WKH SUHVHQW SDUWLFLSOH   
        
        
          
 SUHVHQWLPPHGLDF\  
        
       >@
       
            
 
 
         
6RPH VORZO\ FRPH WR EH UHSHDWLQJORXGHU DQG PRUH FOHDUO\WKH ERWWRP         
EHLQJWKDWPDNHVWKHP/LVWHQLQJWRUHSHDWLQJNQRZLQJEHLQJLQHYHU\RQH        
ZKRHYHUZDVRUZLOOEHOLYLQJVORZO\FDPHWREHLQPHDORXGHUDQGORXGHU >  @      article  
SRXQGLQJ>6WHLQ@
      articulus  
308 6. 3. 309

          


           
 SDUWLFXODUV  
  HJRFHQWULFSDUWLFXODUV 
 partLFOHV  partLFLSOHV            
 >@
 
       

      LWV RU KLV     
KLVRULWV  
 
 >  @           
       
    
 
 3RUWUDLWVDQGSUD\HUV  
 
+HKHKHKHDQGKHDQGKHDQGDQGKHDQGKHDQGKHDQGDQGDVDQGDV     
KHDQGDVKHDQGKH+HLVDQGDVKHLVDQGDVKHLVDQGKHLVKHLVDQGDVKH       
DQGKHDQGDVKHLVDQGKHDQGKHDQGDQGKHDQGKH   
     
             
he >@ 
 
  :KLFK ZD\ VRPH RQH LV PHDQLQJ DQ\WKLQJ ZKLFK ZD\ VRPH LV PHDQ
LQJHYHU\WKLQJKRZVRPHRQHLVPHDQLQJZKDWWKDWRQHLVVD\LQJPHDQLQJ
 
IHHOLQJWKLQNLQJDQGEHLQJFHUWDLQZKDWWKDWRQHLVGRLQJIHHOLQJWKLQNLQJ
  DQG RI ZKDW WKDW RQH LV FHUWDLQ KRZ WKDW RQH LV JRLQJ RQ PHDQLQJ VRPH
he WKLQJPHDQLQJDQ\WKLQJPHDQLQJHYHU\WKLQJZKLFKZD\WKDWRQHLVJRLQJ
  RQPHDQLQJZKDWWKDWRQHLVVD\LQJIHHOLQJWKLQNLQJGRLQJZKDWFRQQHF
        WLRQWKHUHLVLQWKDWRQHEHWZHHQOLYLQJLQWKDWRQHDQGEHLQJLQWKDWRQH
he >6WHLQ@
        
he     
          
      >&@ 
>@       
        
 
  
310 6. 311

      
         
 
       
 
 
           

            
          "
        
                  
            :KDW
       DUH ZRUGV $Q\ ZRUG LV D ZRUG $QG ZKDW LV ZKDW LV ZKDW LV ZKDW
                
        
 UHFUHDWLRQ             
            
       
 
  
              
 
       
        
     


       
 
     
        
     
      
  
   
    
 
            
       
312 6. 313

 
 
 
 
 
 

 
 






 



 
 
         
 
 
       
          
 
 
 
 
 
          
              
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
314 6.

          





 


            1. .
           .

 $UHZHVSHDFKLQGDQJODLVODQGDGJHRUDUH\RXVSUDNLQVHD'MR\WVFK"
 J. Joyce. Finnegans Wake

 
 
      
         
 
 74
     >   @ 
        
   Stein G. $Q (OXFLGDWLRQ  
WUDQVLWLRQ $SULO         


     


       

       
"
 
 



 
121
316 . 1. 317

" 
 
       
             
        
  
 
      

        
         
                   
 
 >@          
 
   
     
"       
                  

      

         
 
         
        
         
 
 
       



 

  >     @           
>@ 
  
          >@

             
         
        
       
        
 
  
         
318 . 1. 319

       
 ,9
 
 
       
           > @   
        
 
       
 
 
 
         VSHDNLQJLQWRQJXHV 
         
         
               
langwedge,          
langdwage,, langurge,, Atlangthis,, orilingua,
orilingua,, langua,, langthorn,, lang- 
wid, langtenna, longsome, slanguage, Languid, langways, langscape, 
languidoily          
       
Are we speachin danglais landadge or are you sprakin sea 
Djoytsch? 
  ODXJKLQJLQWRQJXHV 
"Djoytschjoy 
                
 "
 rejoice   
 
        
          
 ,KDYHUHDFKHG 
WKH HQG RI (QJOLVK   >(OOPDQQ  @     " 
 
 
    
                   
         
      
        abcedminded 
320 . 1. 321

LI \RX DUH abcedminded WR WKLV FOD\ERRN ZKDW FXULRV RI VLJQV in voina veritas
SOHDVHVWRRS LQWKLVDOODSKEHG 

abcedminded Ivaun the Taurrible the sur of all Russers
absent-minded 
      
 
 Ivaun the Taurrible
 
 
Sdrats ye, Gus Paudheen!     
         
      

Fetch neahere, Pat Koy! And fetch nouyou, Pam Yates!

         

        
       
 
 
 
 
      +&(  
$/3 
$/3

$/3


 
        
/
/
         
       
      
GRXEOHQGVMRLQHG
GRXEOHQGVMRLQHG
MRLQHG
MRLQHG
        
      
>@



        "
           
          
      
 >@           
322 . 1. 323

 riverrunSDVW(YHDQG$GDPVIURPVZHUYHRIVKRUHWREHQGRIED\
 EULQJV XV E\ D FRPPRGLXV YLFXV RI UHFLUFXODWLRQ EDFN WR +RZWK &DVWOH
 DQG (QYLURQV 6LU 7ULVWUDP YLROHU GDPRUHV IURYHU WKH VKRUW VHD KDG
 SDVVHQFRUHUHDUULYHGIURP1RUWKArmoricaRQWKLVVLGHWKHVFUDJJ\LVWKPXV
       RI (XURSH 0LQRU WR ZLHOGHUJKW KLV SHQLVRODWH ZDU QRU KDG WRSVDZ\HUV
       URFNV E\ WKH VWUHDP 2FRQHH H[DJJHUDWHG WKHPVHOVH WR /DXUHQV &RXQW\V
 JRUJLRVZKLOHWKH\ZHQWdoublinWKHLUPXPSHUDOOWKHWLPH>-R\FH@

          rivverrun
         
       
         
        
 river runs
     
  riverrun riverain
 VXSHUIHFXQGDWLRQ   river
>@  
doublinou
         
  Finnegans Wake     riverrun
      wake  riveran 
         
)LQQHJDQ
VZDNH 
      vicus
 
 
  
+HUH&RPHV(YHU\ERG\         
 
finnicFinnimoreFinn no 
moreFinnish, Finnados, Finnfinn the Faineant, finnencee, fingers, Finnk, 
finny, FinnikeanFinnagainFinn       
       
              
                
       

 
 


       
 
324 . 2. Transition: 

  2. Transition:






 .
         -

>@ 
 
        
            "      
 "
   , KDYH SXW ODQJXDJH WR VOHHS           
>(OOPDQQ@       
               
>@ 
 
 
        
 
 
       
  
          
 >@ 
  
 abcedminded  
               
          
          
        
   
      
       

       
 


        
326 . 2. Transition: 327

     HQIHQW WHUULEOH  


    
         
 
 
       
;,;
;,;
 
         
        
          
   
         7KH5HEHO$UW&HWUH 
7KH5HEHO$UW&HWUH 
5HEHO$UW&HWUH 
5HEHO$UW&HWUH 
$UW&HWUH 
$UW&HWUH 
&HWUH 
&HWUH 

 
       
 
 
H[SHULHQFH        
      vortex   
 HQGHDYRXUWRFKDQJHDQGWR vertex 
RZ         
 
      
 >@
>@ 
         
         
           
             
          
>:LQWHUV@        
          
 . ., . .,        
. .  
        
 
 
        
        
       
3RXQG          
328 . 2. Transition: 329

       
 
     WUDQVLWLRQ
WUDQVLWLRQ
     
%ODVW  
    
 
      
  WUDQVLWLRQ
WUDQVLWLRQ

 
 
      WUDQVLWLRQ
              W 
W 
  
 
        
              2SHQLQJ SDJHV RI D :RUN LQ 3URJUHVV 
          
 
 
    
           
              
                  
  :RUNLQ3URJUHVV 
  WUDQVLWLRQ 
WUDQVLWLRQ 
 
  +RPDJHWR-DPHV-R\FH 
          
 WUDQVLWLRQ
WUDQVLWLRQ

  
          
 
  WUDQVLWLRQ
WUDQVLWLRQ

              
 
  
 
 
76 
 
. .     
            
. .
           ,,   WUDQVLWLRQ    
 
330 . 2. Transition: 331

                
                  
         WUDQVLWLRQ
               
    )LQQHJDQV :DNH   
   
WUDQVLWLRQ
WUDQVLWLRQ
         
       
WUDQVLWLRQ         
 WUDQVLWLRQ
WUDQVLWLRQ 
 
      5HYROXWLRQ 
6XUUHDOLVWH  'RFXPHQWV   /LWWOH 5HYLHZ 
&ULWHULRQ  7UDQVDWODQWLF 5HYLHZ   6WXUP 
         %ULGJH
      &RQWLQHQWV
WUDQVLWLRQ 
 WUDQVLWLRQ
       transition
     
 
 
                 
  
   
 
       
       
             
       
      
               DQ
 LQWHUQDWLRQDO TXDUWHUO\ IRU FUHDWLYH H[SHULPHQW 
             DQ DQ LQWHUQD
 WLRQDO ZRUNVKRS IRU RUSKLF FUHDWLRQ  
7UDQVLWLRQ   2Q WKH TXHVW    
 
        WUDQVL WUDQVL
              
      WLRQ
        
   
332 . 2. Transition: 333

 
        
 WUDQ WUDQ
      VLWLRQ       
              
       
        77
         
         
   
 WUDQVLWLRQ     
          
            
          
       
             
 WUDQVLWLRQ
WUDQVLWLRQ

WUDQVLWLRQ
WUDQVLWLRQ
          
  
 
                 
          
               
             
    WUDQVLWLRQ        
        
                
    0HWDPRUSKRVLV
0HWDPRUSKRVLV    WUDQVLWLRQ 
WUDQVLWLRQ 
 
   
    "      
      
          
 
 
   
         
            

          
McMillan, D.WUDQVLWLRQWKH+LVWRU\RID/LWHUDU\(UD/
     "   3
334 .

       
     
WUDQVLWLRQ
        
vertical
vertigralvertigral

verticalintegralGraal
      


 2QDpWpWURSKRUL]RQWDOMDLHQYLHGrWUHYHUWLFDO78
 -
     
        
     

 
WUDQVLWLRQ
WUDQVLWLRQ
          
  

 
         
        
 
 
         

          




      

      
         

 
  
336 . 337

 
         








        

       
                  
         
       
       
 
 

          
 
 

Jolas E.3RHWU\LV9HUWLFDO 
WUDQVLWLRQ 0DUFK  
        


        
 
         
       
 
 
 
           
             
       
 
               
       
       
        
      
338 . 339

 
          
 
 
        
 
         


       ,I\RXPHWRQWKHELQJHDSRRUDFKHVH\HOGIURP$LOLQJZKHQWKHWXQH
 RIWKLVWUHPEOHVKRRNVKLPP\RQVKLQZKLOHKLVFRXQWUDU\UDJHGLQWKHZHDN
        RI KLV ZDLOLQJ OLNH D UXJLODXW SXJLODQW /\RQ 2
/\QQ LI KH PDXQGHUHG LQ
PLVOLQHVVSODLQLQJKLVSOLJKWRUSOD\HGIR[DQGOLFHSULFNLQJDQGGURSSLQJ

KLSVWHHWKRUZULQJLQJKLVKDQGFXIIVIRUSHDFHWKHEOLQGEOLJKWHUSUD\LQJ

'LHXIDQG'XPE1RVWUXPVIRKWKRPHWKLQNVWRHDWKLIKHZHDSWZKLOHKH
       OHDSWDQGJXIIDOOHGTXLWKDTXKLPSHUPDGHFROGEORRGDEOXHPXQG\DQGQR
 ERQHVZLWKRXWHFKWDNLQJNLVVNDNHRUNLFNZLWKDVXFNVLJKRUVLPSHUD
 GLIHWRODUQDQGDGLEEOHWROHFKLIWKHIDLQVKLQQHUSHJJHG\RXWRVKDYHKLV
 LPPDUWLDOZHHVNLOOPXVWHUHGVKRXOZLWKKLVRRKKRRGRRGRREURRNLQJZLQ
 WKDWWRZLOHVZRHPDLGVLQKHZDVSDUWLDOZHGRQ
WWKLQN-RQHVZH
GFDUHWR
 WKLVHYHQLQJZRXOG\RX"

          
 
 
 
        
       
        
       
         
 
             
 
 
        
       
       
       
         
        
340 . : 341

 
              
  
        
  
        
         
      
 
          "
         
       
 Jolas E.7KH5HYROXWLRQ
      RI /DQJXDJH DQG -DPHV -R\FH  WUDQVLWLRQ
  )HEUXDU\ 

     7KLV LV WKH ZL[\ ROG
:LOOLQJGRQHSLFNHWXSWKHKDOIRIWKHWKUHHIRLOHGKDWRIOLSROHXPIURPRXG :
RI WKH EOXGGOHOWK  bluddlefilth    
blood 
battlefield -XWH  0XWW 
-XWH  0XWW 
 0XWW 
0XWW 
      
   meldundleize     
         
 thonthorstrok
thor       
constater 
  
       
 

  
           
 
               
 
  
    
 
       
 
342 .


      
     



    
 
   . .
      
  . . 
  
     . .     
 YV
   
 
        . ., . .
 
 
 KWWS  .    
   Jolas E. 3URFODPDWLRQ        
7KH 5HYROXWLRQ RI WKH :RUG  WUDQVLWLRQ  KWWSZZZOHYLQULQHWUX$%287$NVHQRYDKWPO
-XQH     .   


   . .     

-       -


 . . 



   . .  

 . .

   .  
       
344 

           1924  . 
    ;;;;, ;;,
;;,           
      
           . .
 . 
   . .     
            .     
        
   . .      
  .
   .            
 
 .   . . 
 
 . .          
,9 
 . ., . .   .
  .  .
 
 .  E .      .
 
   . .       .     
  
  .  
 . .  
        E .1917
 
   .       .9
 .  .
  .
   .       
  . 
 . E .
  
 . . 
         .
   
 . .  E .        
, 
346 347

 .  . .


      
  .
 .. 
E . 
  .      0DUEXUJ
  . .;;
 . 
E .    .    
 .        
  .     
  . .
E . 
  . ., . . 
 .        
  . .    5XVLVWLFD 
(VSDQROD  . 
  
 .  . . 
       
 . 
 . .    .   
 .  
 . .  . . 
 
    . 
  
  . .         . .    
  
 . 
       .
;,; . . 
1901,,    . .   
 
   . . 
 . . 
1910,,    . .   
 . . 
    . .
 
348 349

 .   . .


 
 . 
 . .  . 
       1922  
. .  . .
 
 . .  . . .
 
,,,  . 
  
 . . 
  . 
 . .     .-     .-.
  
 .   
 
 . .    .     
      
   . .      
      ,  . .
 
   . .        .   
1923 . .    
  
 . .  . .
 . . ,9
    . .   
 . .1946  
. . 
  . .
   . .   
    . .    
 . .        
 
   .        . 
         
     . .     
 ., 
 
 

 . KWWSZZZUXVVUX  . 


FXOWXUHWHNVW\GLDOHNWLNDBDYDQJDUGD 
 . ..  .
 
   . .    -  . .
. .  . .
   .     
. 
   .       
  .
 . .     . .    
;,;;; 
 .  
6DSSRUR 
 . . 
    .   
   . .    
           .    
 
 .   . .
  . .        4XLQTXDJHQDULR
  $OH[DQGUL,OXLQLREODWD
    .      
E  .  
    .    
  .       
       
        .
    . .     
 . . 
      
 
 .  . .
5XVVLDQ/LWHUDWXUH/9,,,,,, 
   .       . .    
 
   . .        .       
 
 . .    . .    
 
 

 .    . .    


 
- . .  
         . .    
         
   - . .     
     ;;   
        .. 
   . .     
   .       ,
  .. 
 .-. 
       
   .      
.  ..
  
   
 . .  . .
   
  . .
   . .      
  - . 
   . .   1919  
.     . .   
 .  ;,;  
  
  . .    .   
  1980       
 ,
   . .     
  . .
 .  
  
 
 . .          
  
 . .  .VXE
 VSHFLHVHPLRWLFDH
 .  
 
 

    . .       
 
 .    . .     
 
 . .     . .  
       
 
          . 
  
 . .  . 
 
 . 
            . .   
 
 .    .    
  ;;,"    7RURQWR 6ODYLF 4XDUWHUO\   6XPPHU      
KWWSZZZXWRURQWRFDWVTNDOP\NRYDVKWPO 
 . .       9,,, 
         
   . .     ,
  . . 
 . .  
 
 . .    . .     
 
      
   . .      
    . .      
;,;;;      .   
 . . 
,,,  . . 
              . ., . ., . .,
         . ., . . 
 
 . 
 .    . .     
         . 
    . .  
   .       . .
 
 

   .        . .   1914  -


 . 
 .1919   . .
 5XVVLDQ/LWHUDWXUH $PVWHUGDP 9RO9,
   . .     ." . .
 
    . .   
 . 
 
 .    . .   
   
 
  . .
 .    .     
        5XVVLDQ /LWHUDWXUH
 . . 9RO
 .   . 
 
   . .       . .
       . . 
  .
 . . 
 . .   . .
   . .    1938
  .
 
 . . 
 . .  .
  . 
   .      
              . .      
       
 . 1921  
.      
    . .     
 . .1933 . .
       
  . 
   . .          . ., . .
 
 

   . .      . 


        
 
 .     . .  
 
         . .
         
   .       
 . .    .     
       
   . .    
  .. 
 . . 
    .   
 :LHQ0RVNDX
   . .    
       


 
- . .
   . .  


9,
 .
- . .
 . 
 
. .
 
 .   . . 
;;
;;
 $UV3RHWLFD
   ,
 .   . . 
       
    ,    
        . .
               
6DSSRUR 
  . .
 
     ., .
   .     
       
 
360 361

 .       


       
   . .        
  
 . .  . .  // . .
            
        
 . . 
 . .  .
 . .       
        
    . .      
;;    . .     
 
 . .   . . 
 
      
  . .
   . .    
 
 
 . ., . .  
      . ., . .
          
9      
   . .   ,
        . 
 
 . .   
  . 
 E. 
9,,,  . .
 .          
 
   . .     .
                 
      
  . 
   . .    
       
362 363

 .     ;;;;,


       
 .         
  
6WXGLD6ODYLFD %XGDSHVW 7     . ., . .
   .           
     ;,;  ;;            
   
 . 2000KWWSDYDQW
KWWSDYDQW
DYDQW
DYDQW    . .    1919 
JDUGHQDURGUX1RPHQNO+WP      
   . .    
  . .
 . 
      
;;,

   .     
 . .
"
   . .    
 .


 .
   .      1916       
 
 . .          
 
9,,, 
          , 
 
 . .  . .
C . .    .    
 . . 
  . .1928 . 
   . .      
    . .     
 . .  
   . . 
   . .    
  . .(JR/RTXHQV
(JR/RTXHQV
/RTXHQV
/RTXHQV

E  . . 
 
   . .            
 
364 

  )DU\QR-   . .


:LHQHU6ODZLVWLVFKHU$OPDQDFK 
%G:LHQ   .    
   . )DU\QR -      
      
0DUEXUJ E . .$XWRSRHWLFD
$XWRSRHWLFD

   .     
 
 . .  .
;; 
  . .
 . .         
" 
  . .
 . .       
       
   - . .    
       E . .
  
 
 - . .     .    
 
     .    
 - . . 
    "          . .    
     
;;;;,
;;;;,
;;,
;;,
  . ., .
         
     . ., . 
  .        
   . .
E .   
  .  
 
 
 .   . 
 
 E . .      . .
        
 
366 367

   . .    E . 


         . 
 
   .       . .
 5XVVLDQ/LWHUDWXUH/9,,,,,,
  .       .
 
 .   . .
       
        
 
   - .     
      
  . 
 . .   
  
  .              
 
 .   . . 
 .  
 
  .         . .    "
            
 
  .        .
   
   . .      
. ,,,   . 
     . . 
 . 
 
 .         
 
 .     .      
 //        
       
 
 . .    . .   . .
.  
368 369

 .     . .     


          
    . .  >  
  @1923 . .
3KLORORJLFD 
 . .8QLYHUVXPYHUVXV    . .      
;9,,,;; 1928 . .     
 . . 
         . .
 1931 . .
 . .  
        .
 
  .
   .     

 .
   .    
 .
      


 .


 . 
. .
 .
 . .

 . . 
  .  . 
   . .   ,, 1922       ;,;;; 
. .  
   . .   ,,, 1926    .
. .  
 .  
   .      
 
 . . 
   .       . .     
. 
 . .  . .
 
;9,,;,;    . .    
 
370 371

 . &RVHULX   Coseriu E. 7KHVHQ ]XP 7KHPD 6SUDFKH XQG
 . 'LFKWXQJ%HLWUDHJH]XU7H[WOLQJXLVWLN0XHQFKHQ
 'HNRYHQ   Dekoven M.$ 'LIIHUHQW /DQJXDJH *HUWUXGH 6WHLQV
 . ([SHULPHQWDO:ULWLQJ0DGLVRQ
 . . 'HSSHUPDQQDeppermann M.$QGUHM%HO\MVDHVWKHWLVFKH7KHRULH
 . . GHV VFKRHSIHULVFKHQ %HZXVVWVHLQV 6\PEROLVLHUXQJ XQG .ULVH GHU
 .XOWXUXPGLH-DKUKXQGHUWZHQGH0XHQFKHQ
 . '|KOKWWSDhl R([SHULPHQWXQG6SUDFKH/LWHUDWXUXQG([SHULPHQW
 KWWSZZZQHW]OLWHUDWXUQHWH[SHULPHQWH[SHULPHKWP
 . . 'XEQLFNDubnick R7KH6WUXFWXUHRI2EVFXULW\*HUWUXGH6WHLQ
  /DQJXDJHDQG&XELVP8UEDQD
 '\GR   Dydo U. E. *HUWUXGH 6WHLQ 7KH /DQJXDJH 7KDW 5LVHV
   . .    (YDQVWD
(OOPDQQ   Ellmann R -DPHV -R\FH 1HZ DQG 5HYLVHG (GLWLRQ

2[IRUG1<7RURQWR0HOERXUQH
 .
(OVZRUWKElsworth J7KHFRQFHSWRIUK\WKPLQ%HO\VDHVWKHWLF
6WRFNKROP
WKRXJKW$QGUH\%HO\&HQWHQDU\SDSHUV$PVWHUGDP
'DV ([SHULPHQW LQ /LWHUDWXU   'DV ([SHULPHQW LQ /LWHUDWXU XQG
%lFNVWU|P   Bckstrm P. $YDQWJDUGH 9DQJXDUG RU $YDQW
.XQVW *UXQGIUDJHQGHU/LWHUDWXUZLVVHQVFKDIW 0QFKHQ
*DUGH:KDWZHDUHWDONLQJDERXWZKHQZHDUHWDONLQJDERXWDYDQW )DLUOH\Fairley I.((&XPPLQJV 8QJUDPPDU1<
JDUGH  5HSUHVHQWLQJ *HQGHU 1DWLRQ DQG (WKQLFLW\ LQ :RUG DQG )DU\QR KWWS  Faryno J    
,PDJH7URPV ,QWHUQHWZZZDYDQWJDUGHQDURGUXMIBPD\DNKWP
%H\HU   Beyer T. R. $QGUHM %HO\MV *ORVVDOROLMD $ %HUOLQ )HVKFKHQNRFeshchenko V. V.6HPLRWLFVDQG$YDQWJDUGHDV7ZR
*ORVVRODOLMD(XURSD2ULHQWDOLV   :D\VRI6LJQ0DNLQJDQG6HQVH0DNLQJ$FWD6HPLRWLFD)HQQLFD
%RZUD Bowra . .7KHFUHDWLYHH[SHULPHQW/  FRPLQJXS 
%UXQVBruns G. L0RGHUQSRHWU\DQGWKHLGHDRIODQJXDJH1HZ *ORVVDULXPGHUUXVVLVFKHQ$YDQWJDUGH*ORVVDULXPGHUUXVVLVFKHQ
+DYHQ $YDQWJDUGH*UD]:LHQ
%UJHUBrger P.7KHRULHGHU$YDQWJDUGH)UDQNIXUW0 *ROGWGoldt R6SUDFKHXQG0\WKRVEHL9&KOHEQLNRY0DLQ]
&DOLQHVFX Calinescu M.7KH)LYH)DFHVRI0RGHUQLW\0RGHUQLVP 
$YDQW*DUGH'HFDGHQFH.LWVFK3RVWPRGHUQLVP'XUKDP *RUKDPGorham M. S. 6SHDNLQJLQ6RYLHW7RQJXHV/DQJXDJH
&DVVHG\Cassedy S.)OLJKWIURP(GHQ7KH2ULJLQVRI0RGHUQ &XOWXUH DQG WKH 3ROLWLFV RI 9RLFH LQ 5HYROXWLRQDU\ 5XVVLD 'H.DOE
/LWHUDU\&ULWLFLVPDQG7KHRU\%HUNHOH\ 
&KYDWtNChvatk Kv. 6WUXNWXUDOLVPXVXQG$YDQWJDUGH$XIVlW]H *U\JDU   Grygar M  
 
 
]XU.XQVWXQG/LWHUDWXU0QFKHQ 9HOLPLU&KOHEQLNRY  0\WKDQG5HDOLW\$PVWHU
9HOLPLU&KOHEQLNRY  0\WKDQG5HDOLW\$PVWHU
&ODUN   Clark K. 3URPHWKHDQ /LQJXLVWLFV DV D 0RPHQW LQ WKH GDP 6\PSRVLXP RQ WKH &HQWHQQDU\ RI9HOLPLU &KOHEQLNRY$PVWHU
3UHKLVWRU\ RI 6WDOLQLVW &XOWXUH  'LH $NWXDOLWDW GHV 9HUGUDQJWHQ GDP
6WXGLHQ ]XU *HVFKLFKWH GHU 6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIW LP  -DKUKXQGHUW +DFNHU Hacker A.9.KOHEQLNRYV'RVNL6XGE\7H[W'LVFRXUVH
+HLGHOEHUJ 9LVLRQ/$&DOLIRUQLD
&RSHODQGCopeland C. F./DQJXDJH 7LPH *HUWUXGH6WHLQ +DFNHUHacker L.'LH1HRORJLVPHQ$QGUHM%HO\MV0XHQFKHQ
,RZD&LW\ 
372 373

+HLVVHQEWWHO   Heissenbttel H. .HLQH ([SHULPHQWH" 0DQGHONHU  Mandelker A. 6\QDHVWKHVLD DQG 6HPLRVLV ,FRQ DQG
$QPHUNXQJHQ ]X HLQHP 6FKODJZRUW  =XU 7UDGLWLRQ GHU 0RGHUQH /RJRV LQ$QGUHM %HO\MV *ORVVDOROLMD DQG .RWLN /HWDHY  The Slavic
%HUOLQ and East European Journal, 9RO 6XPPHU 
+RUFK   Horch H. O. ([SHULPHQW  0RGHUQH /LWHUDWXU LQ 0DUNRY Markov V.5XVVLDQIXWXULVP$KLVWRU\%HUNHOH\/$
*UXQGEHJULIIHQ)UDQNIXUW0DLQ 
-DNREVRQJakobson R. 9OLYUHYROXFHYUXVNMD]\N3UDKD 1DNKLPRYVN\  Nakhimovsky A. S. /DXJKWHU ,Q WKH 9RLG $Q
-DNREVRQDQG:DXJK Jakobson R., Waugh L.7KH6RXQG6KDSHRI ,QWURGXFWLRQ WR WKH :ULWLQJV RI 'DQLLO &KDUPV DQG $OH[DQGHU
/DQJXDJH%ORRPLQJWRQ 9YHGHQVNLL:LHQ
-DPHVRQJameson F. 7KH3ULVRQ+RXVHRI/DQJXDJH$&ULWLFDO 2UDL7ROLF Orai Tolic D. 5XVVLDQ/LWHUDWXUH
$FFRXQWRI6WUXFWXUDOLVPDQG5XVVLDQ)RUPDOLVP3ULQFHWRQ ;9,,$PVWHUGDP
-DQHFHN Janecek G.5K\WKPLQ3URVH7KH6SHFLDO&DVHRI%HO\ 3HQVpH GH OH[SpULHQFH  3HQVpH GH OH[SpULHQFH WUDYDLO GH
$QGUH\%HO\$&ULWLFDO5HYLHZ/H[LQJWRQ OH[SpULPHQWDWLRQ DX VHLQ GHV VXUUpDOLVPHV HW GHV DYDQWJDUGHV HQ
-DQHFHNJanecek G.%DXGRXLQGH&RXUWHQD\YHUVXV.UXFHQ\FK (XURSH3DULV
5XVVLDQ/LWHUDWXUH9RO;
3HUHOPDQ Perelman B.7KH7URXEOHZLWK*HQLXV5HDGLQJ3RXQG
-R\FH  Joyce J. )LQQHJDQV :DNH 3HQJXLQ 7ZHQWLHWK &HQWXU\
-R\FH6WHLQDQG=XNRIVN\%HUNHOH\&$
&ODVVLFV 
3HUORII   Perloff M. 7KH )XWXULVW 0RPHQW $YDQW*DUGH $YDQW
,PSRVWL   Imposti G. 3RHWLFD H WHRULD GHOOD OLQJXD LQ 9HOLPLU
*XHUUHDQGWKH/DQJXDJHRI5XSWXUH&KLFDJR/
&KOHEQLNRY6DPRYLWRHVORYRH]DXP6WXGLDLWDOLDQLGLOLQJXLVWLFD
3HUORII   Perloff M. *UDPPDU LQ 8VH:LWWJHQVWHLQ  *HUWUXGH
WHRULFDHWDSSOLFDWD3DGRYDDQQR;12
.RUJ  Korg J. 5LWXDO DQG ([SHULPHQW LQ 0RGHUQ 3RHWU\ 1< 6WHLQ0DULQHWWLSouth Central Review9RO)XWXULVPDQG
 WKH$YDQW*DUGH 6XPPHU$XWXPQ
/DERUDWRU\RI'UHDPV/DERUDWRU\RI'UHDPV7KH5XVVLDQ$YDQW 3RJJLROL   Poggioli R 7HRULD GHOODUWH GDYDQJXDUGLD %RORJQD
*DUGHDQG&XOWXUDO([SHULPHQW6WDQIRUG&$ 
/DFRXH/DEDUWKHLacoue-Labarthe Ph./DSRHVLHFRPPHH[SHUL 3RPRUVND Pomorska . 5XVVLDQ)RUPDOLVW7KHRU\DQGLWV3RHWLF
HQFH3DULV $PELHQFH7KH+DJXH
/DQJDJHHWSHQVpH/DQJDJHHWSHQVpH8QLRQ6RYLpWLTXHDQQpHV 5HYROXWLRQRIWKH:RUG5HYROXWLRQRIWKH:RUG$1HZ*DWKHULQJ
Cahiers de lILSL RI$PHULFDQ$YDQW*DUGH3RHWU\%RVWRQ
/DQJHU   Langer G. .XQVW  :LVVHQVFKDIW  8WRSLH 'LH 5LFKDUGV Richards I. A.6FLHQFHDQG3RHWU\
8HEHUZLQGXQJGHU.XOWXUNULVHEHL9,YDQRY$%ORN$%HO\MXQG 4XDUWHUPDLQ Quartermain P.'LVMXQFWLYHSRHWLFV)URP*HUWUXGH
9&KOHEQLNRY)UDQNIXUWD0 6WHLQ DQG /RXLV =XNRIVN\ WR 6XVDQ +RZH &DPEULGJH 6WXGLHV LQ
/DQJXDJH 3RHWU\ DQG 3RHWLFV   /DQJXDJH 3RHWU\ DQG 3RHWLFV $PHULFDQ/LWHUDWXUHDQG&XOWXUH &DPEULGJH8QLY3UHVV
7KH*HQHUDWLRQRIV-DNREVRQ7UXEHWVNR\0DMDNRYVNLM%HUOLQ 6DSLU  Sapir E.$EQRUPDO7\SHV RI 6SHHFK LQ 1RRWND  
 Sapir E.6HOHFWHG:ULWLQJV%HUNHOH\&DOLI
/DWL   Latifi A. 3DUDGLJPH UXVNH DYDQJDUGQH L SRVWPRGHUQH 6DSLU Sapir E./DQJXDJH$Q,QWURGXFWLRQWRWKH6WXG\RI6SHHFK
XPHWQRVWL%HRJUDG 1<
/DXKXV Lauhus A.'LH.RQ]HS]LRQGHU6SUDFKHLQGHU3RHWLNGHV 6FKPLGW   Schmidt H. :RUWPXVLN 6FKULIWWDQ] 7H[WELOGHU
5XVVLVFKHQ)XWXULVPXV5XVVLVFKH$YDQWJDUGH  %RQQ ,QWHUPHGLDOH 6SUDFKNRQ]HSWLRQHQ LQ GHU UXVVLVFKHQ 3RHVLH GHV
 -DKUKXQGHUWV%RFKXP
/LQJXLVWLF 7XUQ   7KH /LQJXLVWLF 7XUQ 5HFHQW (VVD\V LQ 6FKRO]   Scholz F. 'LH $QIlQJH GHV UXVVLVFKHQ )XWXULVPXV LQ
3KLORVRSKLFDO0HWKRG&KLFDJR VSUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKHU6LFKW3RHWLFD  
374 

6FKZHUWH   Schwerte H. 'HU %HJULII GHV ([SHULPHQWV LQ GHU :LQWHUVWinters Y.7KH([SHULPHQWDO6FKRROLQ$PHULFDQ3RHWU\
'LFKWXQJ/LWHUDWXUXQG*HLVWHVJHVFKLFKWH)HVWJDEHIU2WWR%XUJHU  3ULPLWLYLVP DQG 'HFDGHQFH $ 6WXG\ RI $PHULFDQ ([SHULPHQWDO
%HUOLQ 3RHWU\
6HLIULG   Seifrid Th. 7KH :RUG 0DGH 6HOI 5XVVLDQ :ULWLQJV RQ :RURQ]RIIWoronzoff Al.$QGUHM%HO\MV3HWHUEXUJ-DPHV-R\FHV
/DQJXDJH,WKDFD/ 8O\VVHVDQGWKH6\PEROLVWPRYHPHQW%HUQ
6KDGRZD  Shadowa L. A. 6XFKH XQG ([SHULPHQW $XV GHU <DJXHOORYaguello M./HV/DQJXHV,PDJLQDLUHV0\WKHVXWRSLHV
*HVFKLFKWHGHUUXVVLVFKHQXQGVRZLHWLVFKHQ.XQVW]ZLVFKHQXQG IDQWDVPHVFKLPHUHVHWFWLRQVOLQJXLVWLTXHV3DULV
=XNRIVN\   Zukofsky L.$ 6WDWHPHQW IRU 3RHWU\  3RHWLFV RI WKH
'UHVGHQ
1HZ$PHULFDQ3RHWU\1<
6ROLYHWWL   Solivetti C.  
5XVVLDQ/LWHUDWXUH/9,,,,,,
6WHLQStein G7KH0DNLQJRI$PHULFDQV%HLQJD+LVWRU\RID
)DPLO\V3URJUHVV $PHULFDQ/LWHUDWXUH6HULHV ,OOLQRLV
6WHLQEHUJSteinberg A:RUGDQGPXVLFLQWKHQRYHOVRI$QGUH\
%HO\&DPEULGJH
6WHLQHUSteiner P5XVVLDQ)RUPDOLVP$0HWDSRHWLFV,WKDFD/

6WRLPHQRIIStoimenoff L.*UXQGODJHQXQG9HUIDKUHQGHVVSUDFKOL
FKHQ([SHULPHQWVLP)UKZHUNYRQ'DQLLO,&KDUPV)UDQNIXUWD0
%HUQ1<
7RPDQToman J.7KHPDJLFRIDFRPPRQODQJXDJH-DNREVRQ
0DWKHVLXV7UXEHW]NR\DQGWKH3UDJXH/LQJXLVWLF&LUFOH&DPEULGJH

7RPLFKHTomiche A.*ORVVRODOLHVGXVDFUpDXSRpWLTXH5HYXH
GHOLWWpUDWXUHFRPSDUpHQ
:DOGURS   Waldrop R. $JDLQVW /DQJXDJH" 'LVVDWLVIDFWLRQ ZLWK
/DQJXDJHDV7KHPHDQGDV,PSXOVHWRZDUGV([SHULPHQWVLQ7ZHQWLHWK
&HQWXU\3RHWU\7KH+DJXH
:HLJKWPDQ   Weightman J 7KH &RQFHSW RI WKH Avant-Garde
([SORUDWLRQVLQ0RGHUQLVP./
:HVWVWHLMQ   Weststeijn W. G. &KOHEQLNRYV ODQJXDJH H[SHUL
PHQWV'XWFKFRQWULEXWLRQVWRWKH(LJKWK,QW&RQJUHVVRI6ODYLVWV
$PVWHUGDP
:HVWVWHLMQ   Weststeijn W. G. 9HOLPLU &KOHEQLNRY DQG WKH
'HYHORSPHQW RI 3RHWLFDO /DQJXDJH LQ 5XVVLDQ 6\PEROLVP DQG
)XWXULVP$PVWHUGDP
:KLWHKHDGWhitehead A. N.3URFHVVDQG5HDOLW\1<
:LHU]ELFNDWierzbicka A.5RV\MVNDV]NRODSRHW\NLOLQJXLVWLF]QHM
DM]\NR]QDZVWZRVWUXNWXUDOQH3DPLWQLNOLWHUDFN\


        



   
   
   
   
   
   
 $JHHYD,    
   
303  
   
        
  
   
   
   
  
  117
   
   
   
   %H\HU7  
   
       
  
   
   
         
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
378 379

      


      
       
      
      
       
      
      
       
    283  
      
          
210     
     
            
      *UHHQEHUJ&  
       
   %UJHU3      *U\JDU0  
       
     
     
            
              
 277   
       
     
           
      
             
      
            
      
         'HNRYHQ0  
 %RZUD         
           
      
 %UXQV*        
       
       
       
       
       'HSSHUPDQQ0 
   :HVWVWHLMQ:     
           
380 381

            
     XPPLQJV  
  -R\FH-       
         
     6HLIULG7K     
         
    -RODV (       
      
       
       
       
       
       
   =XNRIVN\/      
     4XDUWHUPDLQ 3    
    
           
274      
          
          
   &ODUN.    &DVVHG\6  
 'XEQLFN5      
       ,YDQRYD,      
      
       
       
       
     /DWL$  
       
       
       
       
       
     
   
 
     
 
   &RVHULX(    
 
   
 
     
 
   &RSHODQG&)    
     
     

         
 
 &DOLQHVFX0     
 
     
382 383

       


      
     1DNKLPRYVN\$6   
      
           
      186
      
       
       
            
      
297           
          
          
      
       3RJJLROL5  
     
       
       
    
       
          
         
  > @      
 0F0LOODQ'          
   > @     2UDL7ROLF '        
   131 167
            
          
297   
       
       
  0DQGHONHU $        
          
          
          
         
     3RXQG (      
277           
      
       
      3HUORII 0     
  0DUNRY 9      283       
   
384 

           
      
           
322       
     
      
       
  109  
     :KLWHKHDG$    
 5LFKDUGV,    6ROLYHWWL&      
     
       
  5RGULJXHV 2        
   6WHLQ *         
      
        
     
    
   6WHLQEHUJ$     
         
      
        )DU\QR 
   -        
   
           
      
       
     
       
         
       
     
               
     
      
    334  
       
       
    6DSLU (        
    
       
       
            
      
386 387

    +DFNHU$  6FKRO]) 


    +HLVVHQEWWHO+  6FKZHUWH+ 
    +LQGOH\/  6KDGRZD/ 
    +RUFK+2  6WHLQHU3 
        ,PSRVWL*  6WLWHV5 
   ,YDQRYD,  6WRLPHQRII/ 
     -DPHVRQ)  7RPDQ- 
       .RUJ-  7RPLFKH$ 
   /DFRXH/DEDUWKH3K  :DXJK/ 
   /DQJHU*  :HLJKWPDQ- 
    /DXKXV$  :LHU]ELFND$ 
    3HUHOPDQ%  :LQWHUV< 
    3RPRUVND.  :RURQ]RII$O 
    6FKPLGW+  <DJXHOOR0 
 
   
   
 
   
   
   -DNREVRQ 5   
  
  
  
        
  
  
   
   
    -DQHFHN *   
  
   
   
 
  %lFNVWU|P3 
  &KYDWtN.Y 
  '|KO5 
'\GR8 
  (OOPDQQ5 
  (OVZRUWK- 
        )DLUOH\, 
 )UHLEHUJHU( 
*ROGW5 
  *RUKDP0 
Contents

3UHIDFH                                   
,QWURGXFWRU\UHPDUNV                          
&+$37(5/DQJXDJHDVFUHDWLYLW\
&UHDWLYHDVSHFWVRIODQJXDJHLQSKLORVRSK\
VHPLRWLFVOLQJXLVWLFVDQGSRHWLFV
7KH/LQJXLVWLF7XUQDQGWKH7XUQWRWKH/RJRV
LQ3KLORVRSK\6HPLRWLFVDQG/LQJXLVWLFV
DWWKH7XUQRIWKH;;WK&HQWXU\                  
/DQJXDJHDVWKH&UHDWLYH3URFHVV&RQFHSWVRI/DQJXDJH
LQ/LQJXLVWLFV6HPLRWLFVDQG3RHWLFVRIWKH/DWH;,;WK
DQG(DUO\;;WK&HQWXULHV                     
7KH3RHWLFVRI/DQJXDJHDQG7KH/DQJXDJHRI3RHWU\
7KH0DNLQJRIWKH1HZ6XEMHFWRI5HVHDUFK           
&+$37(57KHPHVWRZDOW]RIH[SHULPHQWLQJ
7KHODQJXDJHH[SHULPHQWDVDPHWKRG
DQGSULQFLSOHLQSRHWLFVDQGSRHWU\
7KH&RQFHSWRIWKH/DQJXDJH([SHULPHQW            
3DUDPHWHUVDQG&KDUDFWHULVWLFVRIWKH/DQJXDJH([SHULPHQW
LQWKH$YDQW*DUGH)RUPDWLRQ                    
+RZWKH$YDQW*DUGH:RUNV3UDJPDWLF)HDWXUHV
RIWKH$YDQW*DUGH&RPPXQLFDWLYH6WUDWHJLHV          111
&+$37(57KHP\WKRIWKHZRUG
7KHH[SHULPHQWZLWKWKHZRUGDQGUK\WKP
LQ$QGUH\%HO\VSRHWLFV\VWHP
$%HO\DVWKH/LQJXLVWDQG/DQJXDJH&UHDWRU          144
7KRXJKWDQG/DQJXDJHLQ$%HO\V6\PEROLVW'RFWULQH     147
2QWKH:RUGLQ3RHWU\7KH6WDWXVRIWKH:RUG
LQ$%HO\V/DQJXDJH([SHULPHQW                
$%HO\V0\WKRORJ\DQG0RUSKRORJ\RI/DQJXDJH       171
7KH&RUUHODWLRQRI:RUGDQG5K\WKP
LQ$%HO\V7KHRU\DQG3RHWLF3UDFWLFH             190
390 Contents

&+$37(57KHEUHDNWKURXJKLQWRODQJXDJHV
7KHH[SHULPHQWZLWKODQJXDJHV
LQ9HOLPLU.KOHEQLNRYVSRHWLFV
9.KOHEQLNRY)URPWKH6\PEROLF Summary
WRWKH1XPHULF0RGHORIWKH8QLYHUVHDQG/DQJXDJH      201
7KH4XHVWIRUWKH6HOI&HQWHUHG:RUG
LQ9.KOHEQLNRYV3RHWU\                    206 9ODGLPLU9)HVKFKHQNR
9.KOHEQLNRYDVWKH/LQJXDH&RQVWUXFWRU           213 Moscow, Russia
/LIH&UHDWLRQDQG/DQJXDJH&UHDWLRQ
$'\QDPLF$SSURDFKWR9.KOHEQLNRYV2HXYUH        228 /DERUDWRU\RIWKH/RJRV7KH/DQJXDJH([SHULPHQWLQ$YDQW*DUGH
&+$37(57KH&ROOLVLRQRIZRUGPHDQLQJV &UHDWLYLW\
7KHH[SHULPHQWZLWKVHPDQWLFV
LQ$OH[DQGU9YHGHQVN\VSRHWU\ 7KLVPRQRJUDSKGHDOVZLWKLVVXHVRIODQJXDJHFUHDWLYLW\LQWKHSRHWU\
DQG SURVH RI WKH 5XVVLDQ DQG $QJOR$PHULFDQ DYDQWJDUGH DV ZHOO DV
2%(5,8DQG&KLQDULV/DQJXDJH([SHULPHQW          238
ZLWK KRZ WKHVH LVVXHV UHODWH WR WKH FRQFXUUHQW VFKRODUO\ H[SHULHQFH LQ
8QGHUVWDQGLQJ0LVXQGHUVWDQGLQJRU1RQ8QGHUVWDQGLQJ"
WKHRUHWLFDOSRHWLFVDQGOLQJXLVWLFVRIWKHHDUO\;;WKFHQWXU\
&RQFHUQLQJWKH=HUR&RPPXQLFDWLRQ
7KH VWXG\V WKHRUHWLFDO EDVLV DOORZV WR WKURZ D EULGJH IURP WKH
LQ$9YHGHQVN\V3RHWU\RI1RQVHQVH              
KLVWRULFDORXWOLQHRIWKHWRSLFZKLFKLVWKHVRFDOOHGHUDRIWKHKLVWRULFDO
,PDJLQDULHVLQ6HPDQWLFV6HPLRWLF)HDWXUHVRI$9YHGHQVN\
DYDQWJDUGH RU SRVWV\PEROLVP WR WKH H[WUDKLVWRULFDO IRXQGDWLRQV
DQG<D'UXVNLQV&KLQDULDQ/DQJXDJH             266
ZKHUHE\ WKH DYDQWJDUGH FUHDWLYLW\ LV UHJDUGHG DV D VSHFLF PRGHO RI
&+$37(5,QVWDQWJUDPPDU7KHH[SHULPHQW ODQJXDJHFUHDWLYLW\DQGVHPLRWLFEHKDYLRXU
ZLWKJUDPPDULQ*HUWUXGH6WHLQVZRUNV :LWKRXWOHDYLQJDVLGHWKHLQWHJULW\DQGGLYHUVLW\RIWKHDYDQWJDUGH
*6WHLQDVWKH/DQJXDJH,QYHVWLJDWRU             277 ZRUOGYLHZV WKH DXWKRU VXJJHVWV WR QDUURZ GRZQ WKH IRFXV RI DWWHQWLRQ
*6WHLQV([SHULPHQWDO*UDPPDU                283 WRWKHOLQJXLVWLFVHPLRWLFDQGOLQJXLVWLFSKLORVRSKLFDOSHUVSHFWLYHRQWKH
2Q3DUWVRI6SHHFKLQ*6WHLQV3RHWLF*UDPPDU        303 QDWXUH RI WKH DYDQWJDUGH PRGXV YLYHQGL PRGXV RSHUDQGL DQG PRGXV
$SSHQGL[*6WHLQ(OXFLGDWLRQ WULQWR5XVVLDQ           311 ORTXHQGL 7KH FRQFHSW RI WKH ODQJXDJH H[SHULPHQW LV LQWURGXFHG DQG
GHYHORSHGDVDEDVLFQRWLRQWKURXJKZKLFKWKHWRSLFLVHODERUDWHG)RUWKLV
ADDENDUM7ZRHVVD\VIXUWKHUWRWKHWRSLF SXUSRVHWKHDYDQWJDUGHFUHDWLYLW\LVYLHZHGIURPWKHSHUVSHFWLYHRILWV
&RPLFDOLW\LV&RVPLFDOLW\ H[SHULPHQWDOOLQJXLVWLFFRQVWLWXHQW
/DXJKLQJLQ7RQJXHVLQWKH/DWH-DPHV-R\FH            7KHERRNLVLQWHQGHGQRWRQO\IRUWKHRUHWLFDOOLQJXLVWVVHPLRWLFLDQVDQG
7UDQVLWLRQ7KH&DVHRIWKH7UDQVDWODQWLF$YDQW*DUGH        VFKRODUVLQOLWHUDWXUHVWXGLHVEXWDOVRIRUDEURDGFRPPXQLW\RIFRQFHUQHG
APPENDIX7KUHHPDQLIHVWRVE\(-RODV WULQWR5XVVLDQ UHDGHUV IRU ZKRP WKH LVVXHV RI ODQJXDJH FUHDWLYLW\ DQG LQQRYDWLRQ LQ
WKLQNLQJZULWLQJDQGDUWVDUHQRWLGOHDQGH[WUDQHRXV
3RHWU\,V9HUWLFDO                           
7KH5HYROXWLRQRI/DQJXDJHDQG-DPHV-R\FH            336
3URFODPDWLRQ7KH5HYROXWLRQRIWKH:RUG              341
/LVWRIUHIHUHQFHV                           343
,QGH[RI1DPHV                             377
&RQWHQWV                                389
6XPPDU\                                391

. .

.
- .
.

10.04.2009. 6090 1/16.


1, . Times.
. . . 24,5. 800.

- .
1037789030641.
.: 95-171-95. E-mail: Lrc.phouse@gmail.com
Site: http://www.lrc-press.ru, http://www.lrc-lib.ru

.
./: (499) 255-77-57, .: (499) 246-05-48, e-mail: gnosis@pochta.ru
( 10 18 .).
: , 2, . 1
( )

Foreign customers may order this publication


by E-mail: koshelev47@gmail.com