You are on page 1of 208

32

l61

. .

_"

Ratio politicus et facinoris civiles

..


,

>>.

,

ItW

2004

66.3
26

n 1. n
n

...................

10

1.1. -

.
.:

, 2004.-416

. . .

19

. .

27

.. . . . . .. . . . .....

31

1.3.
1.4.

ISBN 5-98227-006-7

n 1. n
n n

. . . . . . . . . . . 44

2.1.
v

-
.

44

2.2. ..... 5 2
v

2.3. . .. . ..

..

..

2.4.

. . . . . . .

60
66

n 3. nr n
n ............ . 79


. n

3.1

, .

'

86

.
v

3.2.

< 66.3

ISBN 5-98227-006-7

10

1.2.

: .-

26

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

88

3.3. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

94

. ., 2004

3.4. .

, 2004

3.5.

..

..

1 1

111

3.6. -

3.7. -
3.8. -

.
.

. 121
.

. 130

............ 154

"

n 4. n ():

n ...... 181
4.1.

...... ......... ......... ... ........ ... 182

4.2.

..

..

.193

n 5. n :

. 1980-- 1990-

n . ........ ... .. ..... .............. 217


5. 1

- :

. 218

229

5.2.

1980-

,



,
,
1990-

.

,
- ,

5.3.

..

..

242

5.4.
........................... 26 8

5.5.

.....

..

...

.
.

.
.

..

..

..

... .
.

295
309

..

. .. .. ...
.

-
. .

..
.

..
.

..

.
.

. 313

.. 347
.

364


,
,
,
, .

:
, !( ,
5

,
.

, ,
?
. ,

.
,

,
?

:
{)

, - - ,

(NASP).

_ti, -

(Policy Studies),

(Journal of Policy Analysis and

Management), (Journal of

, , ,

Puiic Policy), (Puiic

Administration) .


( -) (Decision-Making

Theory, Policy Making Studies)

,
, , -

,
,

(Puiic Policy Making, Policy

Process Puiic Policy) ,

. 30

.
1970- ,
,

, 2 , ,

. ., . . 11 . 1998. N2 3;
. . - 11
. 2001. N2 1; . .
_

. :

11 . 2002. N2 2; . .

11 . 2003. N2 1, 2, 3.

,
- -

Lynn L. The Changing Puic Policy Curriculum: lntroduction 11 Journal


of Policy Analysis and Management. 2001. Vol. 20. N2 1. . 161.
2


3, ,

- , , -

.
:r -

,
, , -

, ,
,

, ,
,

, .
, ,

,
( ) .

,
,

- ,
, -

.
-

-,

, ?

, , -,

- .

? ,

- ,

.
, -

.

, -

., : . . -

: , , ,
. ., 2000; :
/ . . . . ., 2000; . .,
. . . ., 1996; . .
: . ., 2001.

, , ,
.
. .
. .
, ,
,
.
-

,
, .


, ,


,
.

: -, ,
-

,
.

, ; -

: ,

t, -

, ,

-,

1.1.

._

.
,

,
.

,
.

, , -

, , -

,
:
.
"
" , - -

,
.

1 ,

,
, -

Undiom Ch., Woodhouse . The Policy-Making Process. Englewood


Cliffs, 1993. . 8.

10

11

1.

, -,

Q . ,

, ,

. .),

, ,

-,

, -

( ),

, ,

. -, -

. ,

, -

(,

-),

, (

). -

n -

. , ,

: , -, -

, -, .
-

, ,

, ,

, -

( , ,

>>

, () ,

1980- ).

,
.
12

, . ,
,

13

1.

"

""3

, ,

, -

, ,

2 ,

, ,

"

, -

, -

(. , . ,

. .), (

(puiic policy),

, -

(policy)

, , -

. - -

(implemetation) ,

: .

(policy-making phase)

.- 5

. -,

, . , . , .

,
-

, -

?,-

, ,
-


( 1960)

:
,

Anderson J. Puic Policymaking: An lntroduction. Boston, 1994. . 22-25.

14

Simon . The New Science of Management Decision. N. .; Evanston,

1960. . 1.
4 .: ., ., . .
., 1992
5 Hi/1 . The Policy Process in the Modern State. L., 1997. . 7.
.

15

1.

, ,
.
-

, ,
,

-, ,

, .


. ( -

, -

) (, )

().

().

-,

, -

- , -

, .

. ,

, (,

n ,

}. ,

, ,

politics

(, ,

polity,

2001

policy,

, , n.

- ).

-,

, -

, ,

puiic policy.

, -

, -

-. -

, --,

( ),

(non-decisions) (out of decisions),

( )

, ,

7
6

.: Hi/1 .

The Policy Process in the Modern State. . 7-8.

. :

. . . .,

1998. . 4. .

16

17
2 n n

1.

, -'

9
1

n ( n

10 ,

policy)

( q_ )

(puiic

n ( },

, n

. -

} .

n ,

n ( -)

. .
-
.
n

, ,
,

,
,
, , -

. ,
, ,
( )
-- .

...
,
-

1.2.


.
:
,
,

, -

Allison G., Zelikow . Essence ofDecision: Explaining the Cuban Missile


Crisis. N. ., 1999. . 16.
9

10

Anderson J. Puiic Policymaking: An lntroduction. . 4-5.

n:
. . . . ., 2000. . 219.

18

19
2*

1.


?
,

-
, ,

(
),-

( ),

- - ,

, . . 12

11

,
,

. ,
-

, -

-,

: 13

, , -

XIX .

- ,

. -

-, -

. ? -,

. -, -

11

.: . .

20

11 . 1996. N2 3.

12

: . . 54.

13

. .: 2 . . 2. .,

1991. . 133.
21

1.


'

- -

- ,

, -

(,

. ,

) , ,

- -

15

- . -,

(, XIX-XX

, -

),

, -

XXI ).

, ,

14

, , ,

(. , . , . , .

, -,

.), -

- . ,

, -

, -

, ,

. , ,

, !5-

. ,

, -

, ,

- -

, :

( ),

, ,

- ,

, -

- ,

- , (

- . , -

) ,

.
14

.: Henry N. Puic Administration and Puic Affairs. Atlanta, 1995.

. 55.

15

22

.: Henry N. Puic Administration and Puic Affairs. . 58.

23

1.



)17

,
(

.

)
rn
e
tt
a
p

. ,


, (

)


-
.

111

,
-

(1971).

1962

.),

,
, ()
() 16.


?
.
1, .

-

, ,


,

.
,

.

, , ,
, .
. ,
1 11

() . -,
- ,
.: Allison G., Ze/ikow . Essence of Decision: Explaining the Cub an
Missile Crisis. . 5-8, 389-391.
16

24

11

ng the Cuban Missile


ni
ai
pl
Ex
:
on
isi
ec
D
of
e
nc
se
Allison G., Zelikow . Es

Crisis. . 5.

25

1.

( )

. . ,

11)

-,

(),

, ;

( 1

, (

- -,

) .

(-)

- ,

?18

, , -

, -

. ,
,

, , -

(bargaining games),

i5

n_

- .

n . , -

1.3.

- ,

, ,

-, n

. -

1) ; 2)
; 3) .

:
's

.: Allison G., Zelikow . Essence of Decision: Explaining the Cuban

Missile Crisis. . 6.

26

27

1.

, -

. -

, -

...

r n,

.
nr

(, ,

, .) (

{ 1887)

, -

.).

: ,

: -

, ,

- 19

, ,

, .

, ,

, - .

. ,

,
.

-
,

19

.: Wilson W. The Study of Administration 11 Political Science

Ouarterly. 1987. No 2. . 197-222.

28

29

------

1.

,
20

, -

( ), -

, -

) ,

, , ,

. . -

(, , . .),

- . -

: , ,

- -

: ,

, ,

1.4.

), . ,

; -

, ,

; ,

, , -

( , ,

. . ),

- :

, ,

, , . .

- - ,
-

, , -

30

20

. : . . . . 7.

31

1.

, , -

, -

(, 450

. ,

), ,

. . ,

( ,

),

, ,

( ),

, ,

()21 , -

, ,

, -

'?

, -

- , -

, , , -

: ,

, -

: ( ),

- ,

( ),

. ,

),

, ,

), 22

.
,

. ,

1
1
1
1
1

11

. . . .,

1998. . 15.
11 . : . . 1, 2.

32

1.

, n

, ,

, ,

-
.

, ,
:
);

2)

1)

, (

, );

3)

, (

5)

). -

!3 .

);
( );

4)

n . , ,


, n

,
.
-

,
,

( 1975)

. ,
, -

. . -

,
,

. .

, - , -

. :

1998 .

: (

23

..

), (
, . ),

- (

), (

, n

) , ,

: , -

). ,

( ),


, - -

.
-

34

23

. . ., 2001. . 65.
35

1.

( ).
,

, , . .

. ,
, -

. ,
,

, .

, 24 -


. -

. ,


,. ,

26 (,
, .)

,
.

, ,

, , ,

, ,

, , .

,
,

),

. ,

( -

: ,

, )25.

? , ,
, ,
- , -

24

, - , -

. .

., 2000. . 199-200.
25

.: . .

11

. 1996. N2 .

26

.: . .

i1: .... . . ..,

36

1994. . 18-21.

37

1.


(n

,
-

, ,
. ,

(?)

(?)

, .


- .

,
- -
.

, , :
? (
?)
? (
?)
? (
?)
, ,
, : (?),
( ?), (?) (?)-

(. 1 ).
-, .
n , ,
.
,
,
, ,

.
, , , :
38

( ?)
1

1}

2}
,

).

,
.

,

-
-

.
39

1.


n , - ,
-

, .

.
, ,

,
: ?,

, - ? -,

?,
? . n. , ,

. , - ,

.
-,

,
,


, ,

,
.

: ,
, - ,

.
-

, .

(. 2001 ),
,

-,

.
(,

(
), (

, , . .),

)
(, ,

n 27
n

, , , ,
, .). ,

- , ,
, , . ,

, ,

. : . ., . ., . .

. ., 2001. . 20.

40

27

( ), (
), (
- ).

41

1.

-,

( , ,

). -,

. -

- -

,;t .

, . 1990-

- r_

, , ,

-. ,

. ,

. -

, , -, -

- (policy

decisios)/ - (routine decisios)

; -, ()

(. ) (nonprogram

med disins)j (programmed decisions)

; -,

(. )28, -

, ,

, -

- (,

).

. ,

, -

..

29

. -, _ ._.-

, "
s
11
( , ,

\v

.). -, -
()
-

19
.
,
, , ,

16

.: Anderson J. Puiic Policymaking: An lntroduction. . 7; Simon .

The New Science of Management Decision. . 8.

42

( . ., . .

. / , 2000. . 170).

43

..

-
. ,
q
, ,
,
- 1
, -

, -

. -

, ,

. ,

, (

() ,

.
,

)
( ),

.
, .
, .
,
.

2.1.

, , , ,

, - ,

, , 2

. , ,

:- ,


,
.

44

1 Dror . Puiic Policymaking Reexamined. New Brunswick; Oxford, 1989.


. xiii.
2

. . ., 1995. . 56.
45

2.


.
, , 7, ,
:-... ( )
, ,
- 3

, IV
. ., - (
) (
) ,

.
-

, ,
() (),
.
, Xl . .,

. , ,
, , " ". - ,
, . , ,
<. ,
, .
, ,
( - IV . .),

. ., 1992. . 142.
4 . 11 . .,
3

2001..147.
46

-
(),
, ( ), ,

-, .

.
11,

,
. ,
, ,
_ ,
IV . .,
, , .
- , ,
,
-

- , , -,
,
(60-1 0- IV . .).
-, , ,

:
,
,
,
- .
,

47

2.

,
,

.
-,

(, .).
<;> ,



-





,
-

(, -

),- ,-

, - 7 , , -

. , , ,


,
,

,

.
, ,
,
,

,

. -

,- , -

5





.


:

:
- , ,

6 ,
-


- .



,

(
, ,

.), -

. . 131 .

. . .: 4

. 3. ., 1993. . 93.



. (
)

, 8

?

-

(phronesis)

(proairesis).

,
:
, , ,
.
(
),
, ,

.
7

. .: 4 . . 4. ., 1984. . 515.

.: . . 95-105, 172-184.

48

49
4

2.

(. ,
. .) (. , . , .-.
-

( ) : ,
, (), ,

(),
,

.-.

.).

: (. ),

, (
) (to eskhaton),

{. ,

. ),

9. ,
- ( ,

(. )

(.-. ),

) ,
( , )

, .

,
,

(, ).

.
,

, -
, , -,
.
,

, -,

()


.
. .: 4 . . 4. .
9
10 . . 103.

180-181.

) .

. ,

( ),

, ,
- 10 ,
, ,

(.

, - , :-
,
, 11

-

, .


, -

, ,
12 ,
,

.
-

11
12

. . .,

1982. . 381.

n . . . : .

. .,

50

1997.

51
4*

-------

2.

2.2.

'

n
,
,

,


- ,
- (policy sciences),
- .
1930-40-

policy sciences.
,

,
( 1948)

.

- ,
(process of
policy making)

- , - 1.

1) -


? .
: -

, -

Lasswe/1 . Power and Personality.


52

N. ., 1948. . 120.

13


14
,

, l

>+<

-
. -,

,
(

>.<

,

9


cy sciences).
o\i
(p

-
n

, ,

-
,

);
,

2)
);


14

Lasswe/1 . Power and Personality.

. 121 .

53

2.

3) ( ,


n ,

, , )
.
, -

. -n,

- ,

-

q n,
.

( ,

40-50-

, ()). -,

1950-

, ,-

( 1951)

. ( )

(1951),

(1951),

( -)

( 1947).

n ). ,
n-
-

- , ,

-

(-, -
.}, n

? ,

- .

, , ,

.

,- . ,-

,

,

15.
-

15

Lind/om Ch. The Policy-Making Process. Englewood Cliffs, 1968. . 2.

.
-


-
-

, ,
n.
-n,


, ,
16

(pro\em solving},
16

. n n
v

1920-40- ,

1943

n. . :
. . n 11
. 1994. N2 1; Simon . Decision-Making and
Administrative Organization: Part ofPh. D. Thesis. Chicago, 1944.

54

55

...,._
_
_
___
_

--

2.


..

(policy cycle). -,

: (.
)
(. ). .



,


,
.
, -
, . ,

,



17
-

(new puiic management),


, ,

-
, .

,
, .
,
1930-50-
( . .
, 1939 ),
19 ,
9

( )

(puiic administration),

.


, ,

,
,
.
,
.


,

( 1960)

1940-60-
-

,


,
18 , 1980-90-
,

, :
1 .
1950- 1960- .
2.
1960- 1970- .
3.
1980-90- : -

.
-

.
- (policy

sciences) .
1950-70- ,
: --

17

.: Simon . Administrative Behavior: Study of Decision-Making

Process in Administrative Organizations. N. ., 1997. Ch. V, Vlll.


18

.: Simon . The New Science of Management Decision. N. .;

19
'

Evanston, 1960.

56

. : Henry N. Puiic Administration and Puic

Affairs. Atlanta, 1995. Ch. 3; Lawton ., Rose . Organization and Management


in the Puic Sector. L., 1994. Ch. 2 .

57

2.


(puiic policy},

king
ma
licy
po
ic
(pu

n.

n ,

.
,
- (

, .),
(


, , .).

(1951}, :
( 1956},
- (1970)


- ( 1971 ) 20
- (policy movement)
: , , ,
.21
, , ,
Puiic Admin istration Review
1950-60-

,

1972 < .

, , -

,
-

(Policy Studies Organization}, 1979 -


-

. , . , . (,
}, . .
.

Analysis
(Associat1on for Puiic Policy

and Management), 80

, ,

n n
. n

.
( 1968).
-

,
(, ,
, .).


- ,
(policy analysis),

.: The Policy Sciences: Recent Developments in Scope and Method 1


Ed. . Lasswell and D. Lerner. Stanford, 1951; Lasswe/1 . The Decision
Process: Seven Categories of Functional Analysis. College Park, 1956;
20

Lasswe/1 . The Emerging Conception of Policy Sciences 11 Policy Sciences.


1970. N2 1; Lassw e/1 . Pre-view of Policy Sciences. N. ., 1971; .
21
, . : SnyderR. Decision-Making Approach to the
Study of Political Phenomenon 11 Approaches to the Study of Politics 1 Ed.
Roland Young. Evanston, 1958; Sorensen . Decision-Making in the White
House: The Olive Branch and the Arrows. N. ., 1963; Allison G. Essence of
Decision. Boston, 1971 ; .

58

of
(, Journal
European Puiic Policy, Journal of Puiic Polic y .).

XXI -
- , ,


. n -

, ,


.
59

'

2.

2.3.


, ,
-

, ,

n ,

24 . ,

. .

1951

- :

: -

(policy sciences) :

1) ,

1) (policy-issue knowledge),

n-

(pol1cy process);

2)

3)

), , ,


22 , ,

2)

(policymaking knowledge),
, -

. .

, -

( 1894-1898)

, ,
-

, ,
:
__
... - n :- ,

,
25

, , ,

- .

. -,

, , ,
23 ,

- :

policy science.

. -

, -

. .

, - . , - ,

.
n -

(policy

making) (policy-executing),

. .

, - (policy

sc1ence) ,

26 -,

n, -

Lasswe / . The Policy Orientation 11 The Policy


Sciences: Recent
Developments 1n Scope and Method. . 4.
22

23

1898.

. 10.

. . . . 111:
.
.

( 1970)

Dror . Puiic Policymaking Reexamined. . 7.


25 .: lbld. . 8.
26 Lasswe/1 . The Policy Orientation 11 The Policy Sciences: Recent

24

Developments in Scope and Method. . 14.

60

61

2.

: ,

-
-

, , ,
--, --

(kowledge in the policy process),

28.

, ;

, , ,
27. ,

.
-


, ,

. -,

(
. )

, policy sciences
, -

, -

.
,

- . -,

, -
,

,
29. , -

. .

- -

- ,
,
-
.

27

.:

Lasswe/1 . The Emerging Conception of Policy Sci ences. . 13.


(policy studies) --

(analysis of policy) -- (analysis for policy). .,


:

Hi/1 . The Policy Process in the Modern State. L., 1997. . 2-3.
62

) (
),

, - ,
-

28 .:

. . 11 . .
-. . 12, . 1996. N2 4.
29 .: Hi/1 . The Policy Process in the Modern State. . 6.

63

...

2.

,
,

, .
-

. : .
31 .

q
,

- ,

- , (

- (policy

) : 1)
;

3)

kowledge) . ,

;
30

2)

23 ,

. :
1) (, .); 2) (


1940-60-

, , .);

. , . , . .

3) (,

. ,

,. .)

4) ( 2
, , )3 .

,
,

, ,

, .

.,..

, -

: -

; -

,
,
,
-

. , -

- ( ,
. .)
, , -

; - ,
, :
-


. ,
-

30

. . 11
. 1997. N2 3; . ., . .
. :

11 .
1998. N2 3; . . -

11 . 2001. N2 1; .

, ,

31

Simon . Administrative Behavior: Study of Decision-Making Process

in Administrative Organizations. N. ., 1997. . 6.


32
. : Dror . Puiic Policymaking Reexamined. . 320-326.

64

65
5 n n

2.

n
-

34 ,

(political decisions)33 , -

- -

, ?

, , -

( d e cision analysis )35,

,
,
-

,
-

-
.
-

.
-

-,

. ,

2.4.

,
.


, ,


. -


-
-

,
-

,
-

(. }, (. },

,
-

n (. , . }

( 1994)


, ,

. n
, , ,
- ,

- , ,
,
-

33

, 36

. : Und/om Ch. The Policy-Making Process. . 3.

34

White L. Values, Ethics and Standards in Policy Analysis 11 Encyc

lopedia in Policy Studies 1 Ed. S. Nagel. N. ., 1994. . 872.


3s

. : ., .

11 . 1991. N2 3. . 172-180;
Ouade . Analysis for Puiic Decisions. Englewood Cliffs, 1989. . 46-63.

. : Nelson . Puic Policy and Administration: An Overview 11 New


Handbook of Political Science 1 Ed. R. Goodin, .-0. Klingemann. Oxford,
1996. . 566; Henry N. Puic Administration and Puiic Affairs. Atlanta, 1995.
. 21 ; Miogue . Theory and Practice in Puic Policy and Administration 11
The Policy Process 1 Ed. . Hill. L., 1994. . 25; Kettl . Puic Administra
tion: The State of the Field 1 Ed. . Finifter. Washington, 1993. . 407.
36

66

67

_J88
__
__
_______

2.

,
,
, , .


, --

{policy cycle). 1960-- 1970-



{case studies)

,
.

(. , .
.). 1970--
1980-
- , , ,
,
{policy determination, input studies),
(studies of policy outputs),
,
,
-

(studies of policy

content), (
, , .),
(studies of policy process)37.

37

.: Policy Output Studies 1 1 Blackwell Encyclopedia of Political

Sc1 nce. L., 1992. . 433-435; Gordon /., Lewis 1., Young . Perspectives on
Pol1cy Analysis 11 Puic Administration Bulletin. 1997. N2 25; Hogwood .

Gunn L. Policy Analysis for the Real World. Oxford, 1984.


-
-

(types of study of puic policy making) .: Hi/1 . The Policy Process in the

Modern State. . 2-5.

68

;
s)
ie
ud
st
n
io
at
ul
(policy formation/form
.
entat1on stud1es)
em
pl
1m
y
1c
ol
(p

, , -
ies).
ud
st
ct
pa
im
n/
tio
ua
al
ev
y
ic
ol
(p

0 1960-7
,


9.


)
.

.
(

,
,

-
an al ys is of
e
(th

policy systems),

>40
>

SabatierP.
4;
3.
.
ate
St
ern
od
M
e
th
in
s
es
oc
Pr
y
lic
.: Hi/1 . Th e Po
cess 11 Political Science:
Pro
licy
Po
the
s
of
rie
eo
Th
r
tte
Be
rd
Puic Policy: Towa
. 266; Dunn W.
1.
199
n,
sto
an
Ev
y.
ott
Cr
.
W

.
Ed
1
2
Looking to the Future. Vol.
ffs, 1994. . 15-19.
Cli
od
wo
gle
En
.
on
cti
du
ro
lnt
An
:
sis
Puic Policy Analy
. Th e Policy-Making Process.
39 .: Undiom Ch
Policy Analysis 11 Puiic
on
es
tiv
ec
rsp
Pe
.
g
un
Yo
1.,
s
wi
Le
/.,
Gordon
. 9.
Administration Bulletin. 1997. N2 25.

69

2.

.
.

, ,

,
;

,


42. . .

2)
(
187

43.
-

, :

,
,
-
.
, -

, -

(policy networks), (policy issues),


(policy environment), -
(policy design), , .

,


?
:



,
,
,


- .

, ,

(evaluation studies),

. ,
, , ,

, 41.
, ,

: ,

-
.

- , ( -

( 1918)

.


, ,

( ),
)44
(,

).

42

. ., 1998.
. 11 .

. 263.

. . . ., 1872. . 350.
11 .
44 .: .

43
41

. : Almond G. Disciplie Divided:

Schools and Sects i Political Science. Beverl y Hills, 1990.


70

. ., 1990. . 652-653.

71

2.


( ,
, ),
.
-
,
.
,

.
( ),
XIX
,

.
-,
- (
)
( )45

,
.
,
n

. -
,

, -

46


?
n

,
)

)
(

-,
?

,
,

. -


.

.

:
;

1)

. : . . 11
. 1999. No 2. . 8-19.

L L. Puiic Management as Art, Science and Profession. Chatam,


1996. . 147.

4s

46

73

72

_
_
_ ,_

_
,;...
..__.

2.

2) ,

3)

47
, ,

, .
, ?
, -

,
, ,
. ,
-

,
.
:

1)

;
-

2)
3)

;
,

. ( )
-

(policy-making knowledge),

(policy-issue knowledge),


48 .

'

),

,
( )
,

,
)

(
.
,
,

, .


-

: 1)


, 2)
-


,
49

1 Ed.

Sec tor Ma nag em ent : Theory, Cri tics and Pra ctic e
. Lawton. L.,

D. Mc Ke nt,

1994. . 7-8).

(skills) ,


. ,
:
(. .)
(best practice),


,
,
(applied heuristics), ,


Management as Art,
(.: Lynn L. Puic

(.: Oakeshott . Rationalism in Politics

Science and Profession.

49

47

. : Lind/om Ch. Comments on Decisions in Organizations

Perspectives on Organizational Design and Behavior


W. Joyce. N. .,
48

1 Ed.

11

. Van de Ven,

1981. . 246.

Dror . Puic Policymaking Reexamined.

. 8.

. , .
(rules),

11 Puic

. 97-98).
75

74

_
_
-_AJ811

_
_
_
___

___

2.

,
-

50
, .

, - ,
.

. .

( , , ),

. -

, , 51

- - .


. -

, ,

, , -

()

? , ,

,
-

( 1979). , , ,

? ,

52 -

, -

(), (

, -

) (),

. ,

, , , , , ,
-

. ,
,
,

n
. ,
, -

50

(
. . , . ., 1999. . 24). .
: . . : . ... .
. . ., 1972.
51

.: / L., Deal . Reframig Organizations: Artistry, Choice and

Leadership. San-Francisco, 1991 . . 19.


52

.: Wildavsky Speaking Truth to Power: The Art and Craft of Policy

Analysis. Boston; Toronto, 1979. . 16.

76

77

----4118-----

-------

2.

n ( ,
n )

,
-n n

0 , n

,
n
.

,

n n ,
n ,

, ,

n . .

, n

n n :

, , - ,
.
,

n , ,
.
, , n

( - n

), ,

, ,
,

53

, n n

-n, -

-n ,

-
,
n nn -
n
. n

n ,
n , n

, n
n .

n nn
n-n : n
n , n
, n n
1 ,
nn ,

n
n , n

. n n
nn
n
n.
n n ,
n. n
n

53

. . .,

1994.

146.

. :

11

: 1 . .
. .,

1999. . 552.

78

79

--&-..---

.-.

3.

,
.
v

, pe-

'

- -7

.
-


, ,

,
v

, (,
).

.
v


. -

,
. ( )


, , ,

. ,

(
)

(
)

, ,
-

( ).
, -

( )
, ,
.

, 2
,
v

, -

,
v

. - v


,
- : v

, , .
. . ,


( . . ,


. ., 2000. . 10).
2


,

,

80

81
6


( ) ,

.
,

,
, -

( -
),

.
,

,
, , -

,
.


, 4

,
.

, ,
-


, ,

- ,

(case stud y)

- .
:

- ,


. -

, , ,

. ,

. ,


( . . )


: , 3

, . . :
4

,
,

( . . . ., 1984. .

George . Presidential Decision-Making in Foreign Policy: The


Effective Use of lnformation and Advice. Boulder, 1980.
3

.:

., :

Quade

17).
Analysis for Puiic Decisions. Englewood

Cliffs, 1989.

82

83
6*

-----------

3.


'

, ,


.
,
.
, -


, , ,

. -


6 , - ,

.
,
, ,
.
-
. ,

,
,

{,
versus ).

,

,

.
,


, ,
,
,
, . .
, q -
/,
- / (structure /
g). ,
( ),
( )7
,

(. .},
{. , . , . .),
{. , . .)
(. , . .).

(. , . .},
(. , . .),
{. , . .),
-

.
: .
. 544.
.


.
-

84

. : . . .,

1996. . 268-276; Turner . Actions, Actors, Systems 11 The Blackwell


Companion to Social Theory 1 Ed. . urner. Oxford, 1996. . 1 08-11 .
85

3.

(.

, . .). ,


,

,
, .



- .



.

.
,
. .

.

effects)8 -, -

,
-

, -

. ,
,
,

(homo politicos),

(), (
). ,
>s_
.
-,

(private motives)

(puic interest) .

3.1.

(compensation/

, , .

replacement).

1930-50- .

, :

-, - . -,

(), (),

(), () .

( )

. : , ,

( 1936) ,

, ,

, -

, .

( 1948).
() ,
,
,

(decision

situations)
( decision outcomes 1
86


, -

, ,
8

.: Lasswell . Power and Personality. N. ., 1948. . 105-107.

87

3.

. ,
,

.



,

(, ,

. .).
-


,

,
,
, ,

-
.
,
-

1960-70- (
.
. ),

.
, .


(groupthink),

-
9
-

n.
-

n , 193040-
, ..

( 1943).
. , . , . , -


.
.
,
(bouded rationality).
-

?
( 1995)
, .
-
, " "

10 .
. , , - -

, ,

3.2.


.



,


Janis 1. Groupthink: Psychological Studies of Policy
Decisions and Fiascos. Boston, 1972.
9

. n:

88

.

. .
,
' - . (
)
,
to

Parsons W. Puic Policy: An lntroduction to the Theory and Practice of

Policy Analysis. Aldershot, 1995. . 353.

89

3.

'


? ?

? .

1950-60- ,
>+_ ,

cognitio

, ),

.
,

, ,

11 . ,

, '
. -
, , ,

,
.

13. , ,
,

- . -

,
,
. .


( 1960):

. ,
, ,

14

. . ,

, ,

, ,
,

, 12

,
, .
.

(proem solving)

. .
( 191

11

.:

. . . ., 2001.

. 54-55.
12
Simon . Administrative Behavior: Study of Decision-Making Process
in Administrative Organizations. N. ., 1997. . 1.
90

, ,
. .
,
-

,
,
-

., ., . .
., 1995. . 212.
13

14

Simon . New Science of Management Decision. N. .; Evanston, 1960.

. 5.
91

, , ,

. :
-

(well-structured)
- (ill-structured),

, -
. ,
-

, , -

,

,
.
-



,
.
, .

, - ,
-

, .
,

,
. , , ?
, - , -
-



.
.

, -

-

,

,

,
( 1957)
-

.
? -, .

,
,

, ,
-


. -, ,

,
.

-, , ,
-

.
,

.
, -, -


.
-

, -

15. ,

, -

. .

(
15

Simon . Administrative Behavior: Study of Decision-Making Process

in Administrative Organizations. N. ., 1997. . 84.

92

(satisfycing),

,
93

3.

, .

, -

? :

, .

- -, , -

3.3.
.

,
. ,
, 1959
Puiic Administration Review,
,
-

1960-70- . , . . ,
, ,
j /
, .
,
.
,
, .
?
, -


,

.

.
(incrementalism)
increment,
-
, 94

-
(ends) (means)
-

,
;
-

, (
)
;
- , , ,
-


;
- , -

,

,
,
;
-
,
-

, ,

-

,
.

( 1993),
. . .
95

,
,
.

7
1

,

-

,
.
.

,


;

,
-

"" -

,

,
16.
, ,
. ,

. 1950-60-

( . },
1970-

. ( 1977)

,

. ,

,


. 1960-

(partisan mutual adjustment},
,
,
, , -

1960 .

(normative-optimal)

. .
11

16

Lnd/om Ch., Woodhouse . The Policy-Making Process. Upper

Saddle R1ver, 1993. . Vll.

.: Smith G., . The Artificial Debate between Rationalist and

lncrementalist Models of Decision Making 11 Policy and Politics. 1980. N2 8.


. 151-152.

97

96
7

3.


(mixed-s
canning)
- n

18
n

n n



,
, n
n
.
n
n:




, .
n
n

, n

n
,
n


,
- n


.
,
,

.
.

.
.
, . n

n
n
. -n
,

( .
)

e
( xtrarational) n
:
,

,
,
. n. -
,
n

n


n
.

,
,

, n
n
,
. , n
n

,

n n
n
19 -

, .

n

: ,

.
,

::::: n-,n n, n
" ,

::: ,
,

;: .

.
20

.: D ro r
. Mudd/ing Thro
ugh- 'S ci e n ce ' or /n
e rt ia 1 1 P u ic
Administration Revie
w. 1964. N 2 24; Efz
ioni . Mixed Scann
ing: Third
Approach to Decisio

. ,

:

() , . .
(1968) .



( n ),

:'

18

. -

, n

. .

. , n

.
r

,
. . ' ,
.
,
, ,

n-Making 11 Pu
ic Administration Revie
19
w. 1967. N2 27.
Dror . . cit. . 164
.

Parsons W. Pu/ic Policy: An /ntroduction to the Theory and Practice of

Policy Analysis. . 298

98
99
7*

21


.
.

,

.
,


(across the proem),

,
-




(some areas of the proem).

:
{

)
(
).




.
.

,
, ,
,

.

( 1988) .


(

)

,
.

(
),

{
). .


,

, ,
-

-
22. - .
1940-60- ,
. .
,

- .
1940-60-
,

,
, ,
.

21

Efzioni . Mixed Scanning: Thi


rd Approach to Decision-Mak
ing 11
Puiic Administration Review. 1967. N2
27. .

387.

100

3.4.

.
(comprehensive

rationality),
.
:

(puic choice),

{social choice), (collective choice),


>> (game theory), {rational actor) . .

,
, .
-
: ,

22

Efzioni . The Moral Dimension: Toward

New Economics. N. .; L.,

1988. . Xl.

101

3.



homo

1993

,
conomicos.

, -

, ,

,
.


24.

,
, 8

,

-

, ,
- , -

,
23 ,
,
: 1950-
.
( 1951) . ( 1957),

; 1960- .
. (1962), .
( 1962) .
: n (1965),

, 1970-
.
(1971 ), .
(1975) , , . (1976),
-

.

. .
,
,
,

__

, . . .

23

. : . : -

11 . 1995. N2 2.

102



;

1


;
11

24 .
. 29-30.
Thesis. 1993. . 1. . 1.

103

3.



;
-



25.

:::: :::

,




,

.

'




.
. ,



( 1957)



(
1967),

. .




'





,
,

.
f<
'"'
..,

::

: : =;

;:: :


:
:
:

: Monroe . R.
The Theory ( Ration
.
al Action. What ls
ls lt for Polrtrcal Science .
IH How Useful
. .
? // lot
1 5 crence:
r rca
Lookin9 rn th Future. V
Theory and Practice
ol. 1. The
( Political Science
.

C
ro
tt

Evanston.' 1991.
.
G_reen 0., Shapiro
1. P atholo isE.
( R at ro n al C h o rc e :
o
Applrcatron in Political
.
C
rr
trque (
Scienceo New-H;v
en, L., 1994. . 14-17
, etc.
2s

'!"'

7;

( 1942) . ,
n ,

n ,
n
26
. ,
,
.
,
. ,
.
, , ,

(,
,
; ;
). .
-

,

.
(, , , )
,
, ,

. . ,

,
,
.

,
- .

26

. , . ., 1995.

104
105

. 355.

3.

,
.
(1971) .

.
,

, . ,
-

. ,

,
,

,

. .

,
-

. ,

.
,



(puiic choice).

,

,

,
, ,

"", ",

"
-

106

'

- >>27
1986
- ,
(1962)28
. .

-



(). ,
_


, ,

.
,
,
.
.

.
,
,

. ,

, ,
1990-

27

. :
. 1994. N 3. . 53.
28

.:

11

., . 11 .

1. ., 1997. .
( 8 1986 .);

. .

;
.

107

3.

n . ,
n n ,
n
,
, n

. n
n n
n . n, n
n ,
, n
n
, n
. n
n nn nn
n29.

n n
n , n n
n -n

. -n,

n n
n, , n (
) ( ), n
n
. n
,
n n n n
. .
. n:
, n n, n

29

'

.: Shepsle . Studying lnstitutions: Lessons from the Rational Choice

' n - n n30

, n
nn
n n n
, n , n
n n
nn , , ,
-

.
-, n
n

. n,

- - n ,

:
1) -n,
;

2) -n,

3)

-,

31
(
)
n.
n
()
n . -n, ,

, ,
, n n n
n
(, .). -,
n n

Approach 11 Journal of Theoretical Politics. 198 9. Vol. 1 .

.: .

30

11 :

31

1 . . , .-. . ., 1999.

108

., . . ., 1997. . 83.
.: Coleman 1. Foundations of Social Theory. Cambridge; L., 1990.

. 19-23.

109

'

, ,

3.5.

,
,

.
.

, .
, . ,
,
,
(,

) ,
, 2. -

(.

, .)

,


. , -
, ,
(. .),
- ,

33 , 1990-

( 1994), , ,

4.

32

. 11

Thesis. 1993. . 1. . 3. . 27.


33

.: Monroe . R. The Theory of Ratioal Actio: What ls lt? How Useful ls

lt for Political Sciece? /1 Political Science: Looking in the Future. Vol. 1. The Theory
and Practice of Political Science 1 Ed. W. Crotty. Evanston, 1991. . 80-81.

34 . : Green D., Shapiro /. P athologies of Rational Choice: Critique of


Application in Pol itical Science. New-Haven; L., 1984; The Rational Choice
Controversy: Economic Models of Politics Reconsidered 1 Ed. J. Friedman.
New-Haven; L., 1996.

110

111

3.

, ,

. ,
-

;::

. . ,

, - , ,-
"
" "",

n 35
, , .

,
,

. ,
,

, ,

, .

, ,
-
-

.
35

. , . . 323.

.
'

. . ,
. :

08

.
n

) .
(
9

( 195 1

n .


-
5
1
9


npe

npa

,
.

e
n
c

( 1961 ).

'

:

.
n
.

,
,

113

112
8 n n

_
..,
,.,

___

'

.).

,
.

(.
n


, .

:
, -

, -

1)
s):
ea
-ar
ue
(iss

;
3)
;

2)
;

4)

1950- r .




. -,

?

,
,
?36 ,

?,

-
?. , ,
.
-, - ,
- ,

,
,
-


. .

,
,

.
-

, . ,- ,

7.
, << ,


{ ),

(. , . ,
. .). -, (

36

) ,

Dahl R. Who Governs? Democracy and Power in American City. New

Haven; L., 1961. . 3.

37 Iid. . 5.


.
-

.
-

, 1970-90- , . ,

.


.

. 1990-

,

.
30-40

114

115
8*

_ -.,
_
_
_

, ,

,
-

39 ,


. 1950-60- .
,


,

,

- ,
s.

, , . -

,
,

(1969) ,

, ,
.

. , .


( , , , )

.
,

.
-
, (. .)

, (. . .).
. .

,
. . status quo

. , 38

.: . . ., 2000. . 111-112.
116

.
. ,

(
(1977) ). ,

, .
9.: . . . ., 1959; Dye . Who's
Running America? The Clinton ears. Englewood Cliffs, 1995.

117

'

(.

,

.
,

,
-
.


(core executive)

-

, . .), -

,
: ,

.
,
? ( 1998)
-


.


,

, ,

. :

, ,


.
,

n ,

4.
,
,
-

. n ,

- )


,
42 .


1970-90-

-
, -

).

,-
. . ,- (

41. ,

(n

? ( 197 4):

,
-

40

.: Domhoff W. Who Rules America? Power and Politics in the Year

. - ( 1978),

, , ,

. . .: Domhoff

2000. L.; Toronto, 2000. .

W. Who Really Rules? New-Haven and Commuity Power Reexamined. New

Brunswick; L., 1978.


41

. ., . ., . .

42

.: Rhodes R. From Prime Ministerial Power to Core Executive 11

: .

Prime Minister, Cainet and Core Executive 1 Ed. R. Rhodes and . Dunleavy.

., 2001. . 329.

Basingstoke, 1995.

119

118

3.

(
)
s



43 .

:
.




(
),


.
( . .
, . .
. . .), n
s

:

44



?
-

-, n,
,




,

r

-
. -,


- ,



,

-

,

. -,

, ,
-

-r .


-

(, , ,


r ,

. , -

,
. , ,
-

.

-


,
-

r .
- - .
-

....

3.6. -
-

1997. N2 2. . 57.
44

.:

. 11
.

:r . ., . ., .

. .,

120

1999.

(policy etworks)

(network approach)

. , ,
-

43

.),


, - ,
: - ... , ,

121

,
,
.
, ,

,

. ?
-,

n?
,
,
,
-
(, , }46

, , ,

.
.

, -

, .

-, 1960-70-

t-t .

- .

: -, ,

, -, -

. . ,

, -

. 1930-

etworks)47

,
"
" ,

, n

, " "
-

. ,

- , ,

. -

, ,

,
,

1940-50- ,

,
45
1960-

(issue

,
,

- .
-

45

Griffifh . The lmpasse of Democracy. N. ., 1938. . 182.


122

., : Freeman J. The Political Process. N. ., 1964.


47 .: / H.lssue Networks and Executive Estaishment 11 The New

46

American Political System 1 Ed. . King. Washington, 1978. . 87-124.

123

,
,

1970-80-

- . ,
(communities) . , (streams) .
, . .


.

( 1996)


,

,
.

,- . ,

, ,
(network society),
48 ,

,

.
-
? --

48

. 11

1 . .

. 494.
124

. . ., 1999.

,
1

cy
ro


.

-

,
:

9,
4

. -,

. . .
( ,

n-)
,-

,
.


- ?

Politics in the US,


ur
bo
La
:
ks
or
tw
Ne
y
lic
Po
g
. Comparin
49 Knoke . et al
idge, 1996. . 3.
br
am
C
n.
pa
Ja
d
an
y
an
m
er
G
11 n
r . . n
2001. N2 3. . 108.
.
so

125

,

.

( 1 82},


. -, , , ,

.
, ,
. , ,


, ,

S1
.

(, , ),
- (policy domains).
,
, .
?

-
: - ;
;

52
? -, -
(
},
,

51

.: Knoke 0., Kuklinski J. Network Analysis. Beverly Hills, 1982. . 9.

52

Knoke . et al. Comparing Policy Networks: Labour Politics in the US,

Germany and Japan. . 1 .

126

)
ns
tio
cia
so
as
k
ea
(p


. .),

'

(
,

)
.
.

. -
:


( , . .).

)
.
.

,
(
-

-
.

),

),

-

,

: -

s.
:

1)

:_

2}
;
British Government.
s3.: Marsh ., Rhodes R. Policy Networks in
Oxford, 1992.

127

3.

3) ;
4)

,
-

2) ,



.

:
1 ) ;

2) , ;
3) ,


;
4) .

. -,

:



?

, :

? -
,


,

, ,

54

,

v

, ,

,
,
.




. ,

,

7)

1)

, ;

3)

4)

5) ; 6) ;

55 , ,


, , ,
-

.

-

,
.
.
,

.
,
(
),
,
.
.
, ,
,
,
.

(networking) ,
. , -

,
-

54
)),
,

. . : .
:
. ., 2000. . 103-1
34.

128

55

.: ., Richards . The Tangled Web of Westminster and

Whitehall: The Discourse, Strategy and Practice of Networking within the British
Core Executive 11 Puiic Administration. 2000. Vol. 76. N2 2.
'

129


( )
, -

,
. ,

.
-

- :
1) , , ,

.
-

-
,

, ;
2) (
-

- .

), ,

<7

. 3.7. -

.
,
-

- -

1) ;

, -

2) ;

, -

3)


- .

, .
. ,
- ,
-

, -

56 , ,
-
-

, . ,
1950-60- ,
-

, , 1940-50-
-

'

. , 1970-80- ,
(. , . , . .), , -

.
?
, -
-

.
. ,

56

Hi/1 . The Policy Process in the Modern State. L., 1997. . 85.

. 1950-

131

130
9*

3.

,
,

,
, .

, -

57


. -,

. ,

, n

.



, .

,
. -, -

. .

(1950),

.
,
. .

,
, .
-

.
, , , -

, (
environment)

,
,

.

-

.
-

( 1949) . ,

1930-40-

. . .


.
-, ,

,

.
.
, ,


58.

,

>>

1980-90-
,


59
,
, - -

. , ,

59 .: Di Maggio ., Powe/1 W. The lron Cage: lnstitutionallsomorphism


57 Parsons W. Puic Policy: Anlntroduction to the Theory and Practice of

Policy Analysis. . 32 4.

and Collective Rationality in Organizational Fields 11 American Sociological


Review. 1983. Vol. 48. N2 2; The New lnstitutionalism in Organizational
Analysis 1 Ed. W. Powell and . Di Maggio. Chicago, 1991.

58 .: Selznik . and the Grass Roots. Berkeley, 1949.

132

133

.


.
.

.

,

.
,


,

,
, ,

,
.

.

-

, .
, ,

,


,
-

,
.



, ,
.

.


-
,


,


,
,

.


,
: 1)
; 2)
; 3) . ,

,

,
.
, ,

,



, ,


-

134

- - ,

.

'

.
, , , ,

, , ,
, ,

.

. .
-
.
-



. -
. .
.

: ( 1984),
,
-

,
-

, 60
, .

.: March J., 0/sen J. The New lnstitutionalism: Organizational Factors


in Political Life 11 American Political Science Review. 1984. Vol. 78; March J.,
0/sen J. Rediscovering lnstitutions: The Organizational Basis of Politics. N. ., 1989.
6

135

. -

,
. ,

-
.


. -

,
)


n
)
nt
me
ce
pla
re

61,
,
: -, ,
, , -, ,
.
,
-

'

(
), -
. . , :-
,
, , ,

62.
,

, ,
, ,
,
, , , ,
.
,
?
-,
,

.
-

61

: . .
: 11 : 1
. . , .-. . ., 1999. . 218-23; . .
. ., 1998. . 99-1 04.
62

March J., 0/sen J. The New lstitutionalism: Organizational Factors in

Political Life 11 Comparative Politics: Notes and Readings 1 Ed. . Brown


and R. Macridis. Belmont, 1996. . 289.

136

137


, . .
. ,
,
,
,
.
,
,
.

,
, .

. -:
, -
, , ,

. , , ,

.
, ,
. .
. ,
,
,
.

,

, .


.

'

138

,
. .

,
,
, , . .

1970-
. . ,
.
(garbage can)63
,
. : ,
( solutions), , ,
. ,
,
- , ,
,
,
.

, ( )
.
, ,
,
,

64
'

63

.: Cohen ., March J., 0/sen J. Garbage Model of Organi

zational Choice 11 Administrative Science Ouarterly. 1972. N!2 17. . 1-25.


64

Hi/1 . The Policy Process in the Modern State. . 107.


139

3.



. -

,
( )

,
, -

. -

, . , -

, ,

, - ,

, ,

. -,

,
( ),

. . ,

. ,


( )

-
.
1

(, , . .).
.

,
,

, ,
-

, , -

(decision situations).

,
,

, >65

( )


- .

. ,
1980-90-

,
. -


66 .

, .

March J. 1 0/sen J. lnstitutional Perspectives on Political lnstitutions 11

:
, . ,

65

Governance. 1996. Vol. 9. N2 3. . 251.

.: Osfrom . An Agenda for the Study of lnstitution 11 Puiic Choice.


1986. N2 48; Osfrom . Method of lnstitutional Analysis 11 Guidancel Control
66

,
.

and Evaluation in the Puiic Sector 1 Ed. F. Kaufman1 G. Magone and . Ostrom.

Berlin; N. . 1 1986; Osfrom . Governing the Commons. Cambridge 1 1990; etc.

141

140

__

...__

3.


, , ,

, , . ,
, -, ,

. ,

. . -,

, -

, -

. -

67 ,

....

, -

- ,

. ,

. .

),

), (

1980-90-

). -

. , . , . , .

, . , . , . .

XIX .

, ,
,

,
1960-70-

- .
-

,

.

142



:
(1993), . . .
,
,
- : ,
, ,

Skockpol . Br inging the State Back ln: Strategies of Analysis in


Current Research 11 Bringing the State Back ln 1 Ed. . Evans,
67 .:

D. Reuschemeyer and . Skockpol. Cambridge, 1985.

143

,
,
, , ,
, ,

.
,

?
,
.
. ,
.
{, ,
)
,

,




-
,

. . .


, ,
,
:

7)

,
;

8) . ;

9)

,
68
. .
,

. -,

1)


,
;
2)

,

;
3)

:
. -, ,

,
( , ),

4)

5)

, ;
6)

n

,
;


, .

, .

,
.

.

n :

68

.: Weaver R., Rockman . Assessing the Effects of lnstitutions 11 Do

lnstitutions Matter? Government Capailities in the United States and Abroad


1 Ed. R. Weaver and . Rockman. Washington, 1993. . 446-453.

144

145
10

3.


-, .
,

69

( ),
,

. , . . .

. . -

11
.
:

1)

2) ; 3) (
); 4)
(

5)


. ,
() ()

-

,
', . -

);

, . -
, . ,


, , -

.
-

, ,

. -,

. -,

, , , -

, -

- ( )

, -

1 .

. . -

. .

t(\

. .

( 1902). -

()

t-i ,

, .

70

.: // . Governing the Economy: The Politics of State lntervention

Allison G., Zelikow . Essence of Decision: Explaining the Cuban Missile


Crisis. N. ., 1999. . 143.

69

1960-70-

in Britain and France. Cambridge, 1986.

146

147

3.


(outputs) ,
(patterns) .
,

,
, ,

, ,
.
.
,
,

.

.
.
,

71
, ,
(organizational outputs).
. ,

1962 . ,

,

,
. ,

.
,

-, ,

,
. ,


. .


,
,
, ,

. .
,
,

( ),

( ),
,
( - ) , ,


. ,

,
(interactive compexity),

, .
- , .
.

( 1958)

:
.

71

Kelly R., Palumbo . Theories of Policy Making 11 Encyclopedia of

Government and Politics 1 Ed. . Hawksworm and . Kogan. L.; N. .,

1992. . 649-650.
148

149

3.

, -

,
.

, ,

, ,

, ,
.

,
...

-,


,- . , -

: (
); (

.
72

,
, ); -

, ,
1

, , ,
,
.

,
.

-,
-

, 1941 :

. ,

22

, 7 -

. ?

,- ,

(),

(, ).

.
,

71

150

Allison G., Zelikow . Essence of Decision. Boston, 1971. . 170.


151

_!

....
_
. _

, -,

. ,

. n

, n

. ,

, , -

, (

.....

) , .

, ,

) : 1)

, ,

, ,

. .

, 2)

. ,

73 , -

. ,

, , , -

, :

74

; 2)

1)

. , ,

3)

,
. , . ,
,

73

.: Offe . Designing lnstitutions in East European Transitions/ / The

Theory of lnstitutional Design 1 Ed. R. Goodin. Cambridge, 1996. . 203.


74

.: Egeberg . The lmpact of Bureaucratic Structure on Policy

Making j j Puiic Administration. 1999. Vol. 77. N 1. . 156-159.

152

153

3.8. -

2)

'; 4) (feedback), -

-
. ,
, -
, , , :
(policy process), (stagist),
(circular), (policy cycle)
(policy life cycle)l5 1970-80-

76
XXI
, .
-
, ,
-


( ).
. -,
,
,
1950-60- . .
-.
(
) :
1) (input),

3)

(output),
-

()
, 77
,.
-
, (policy process)
-
(political process).
, ,
- ,
- , -

- n .
,

, . . ,
. .
1910-40-
(proiem solving): n
- -
(. ), -
()- (. ). .
:
(1956)
, :
, , , ,
, . ,

75

., : The Policy Cycle 1 Ed. J. and . Wildavsky.

Beverly Hills, 197 8.


76 .:

Kelly R., Palumbo .

Theories of Policy Making 11 Encyclopedia

of Government and Politics 1 Ed. . Hawksworm and . Kogan. . 651.

154

77

.:

. . .

8.
155

I I

) n (

, )

- ,
-



- (,

, .), - (

, ,

. ) .

(. , . .),
(. , .
,
. .). ,
(. ),

(. ), , ,


? -,

. -,
> ,

. -,

n,
.
-

-,



156

. -

.
-

, ,
.
-
(. ,.) (. ),

.

1980- ..

1970 -

-,

(1978)
- : 1)
; 2) ; 3) ; 4) ;
5) ; 6) ; 7)
:

. -,
- . .
( )

(1984),
: 1) ,

2)

, ;

5)
; 6) ; 7)
, ; 8) ; 9)
3) ;

4)

, 78

,
(,

.: Jenkins W. Policy Analysis: Political and Organizational


Perspective. L., 1978. . 17; Hogwood 8., Gunn L. Policy Analysis for the Real
78

World. L., 1984. . 4.

157

),

, . , .

, ,

(, ,

, ,

, , ,

).

:
;

1)

2)

3) ; 4)
; 5)
.....

, ,

. ,

1970-80-

. . , -

, - ,

? -,

. -,

80 ,

. -,

: -, -

. -,

-, -

( ) ,

, -

. , -,

, , , -,

79.

, .

79

Anderso n 1. Puiic Policymaking: An lntroduction. Boston, 1994. . 37;

Ounn W. Puiic Policy Analysis: An lntroduction. Englewood Cliffs, 1994. . 17.


. n . -

n (termination) (.: Kel/y R., Palumbo . Theories of Policy


Making 11 Encyclopedia of Goverment and Politics 1 Ed. . Hawksworm

.
.

and . Kogan. . 651 }. n


(.: . .
. . 169-176).

158

80

.: O ro r . Muddling Through- 'Science' o r lnertia 1 1 Puic

Administration Review. 1964. No 24. . 129-153.

159

1998 , ,

, ,

. , -

. -

, , -

, ,

, -

, , -

, 81

, . -

- -

. , -

- - -

( )

, -

( ) .

- , -

, -


, , -

, ,
-

. , ,

18 36 . .
, -,
(metapolicymakig), ,
; -,
-

(policymakig stage),
, , -

81

.: . Muddling Through - 'Science' or lnertia 11 Puiic

Administration Review. 1964. N2 24. . 157.

, (post-policymakig stage),
,
-

160

161
11

. -

, -

( . ) :

, -

1. :

, ,

) ;

. . ,

) ;

1960-80- ,

) ;

- . .

) ;

, , ,

) ;

) , ;

) - .

- 82

2. :

onpe-

) ;

1970-80- ,

. .

)
, n;

(textbook policy science)

)
;

3.

83

) ;

1)

) ;
n) ;
) ,

.

, -
,
;

2)

, .
,
,

.
, ,
<< ,

,
.
, -

3)

- ,

Parsons W. Puic Policy: An lntroduction to the Theory and Practice of


Policy Analysis. . 437.
82

83

.: Nakamura R. The extbook Policy and lmplementation Research 11

Policy Studies Review. 1987. N2 7. . 142-154. .

. , . , .

, . .

162

163
1 t

3.

( , )

: (proem stream),

4)

- (

, ) -

(policy stream) (political stream).


.

, ;

5)

1976-79 ,

_,

247 ,
, 23 -

- 84

. ,

, -

, ,

, ,

. . ,

-:

: -, ,

- (policy streams)

, (advocacy coalitions)

, , (rounds model)

); -, ,

. ,

, , ,

, ( 1984).

; -

, ,

, -

.
-

. -

. . ,

-, -
.

84

.: Policy Change and Learning: An Advocacy Coalition Approach 1 Ed.

. Sabatier and . Jenkins-Smith. Boulder, 1993. . 1-4.

164

-
, .
165

, -

85 ,

(policy etrepreeurs),

, ,

86 -

. ,

, -

- , ,

, .

,
. , ,
,
( );

( ,
); (
) , ,
(, .). -

. .

,
,

,
.


, ,
,

. . ,
, -
,
, . ,
,
,
(
,
).
,

- ,
,

86

, :
Sabafier . An Advocacy Coalition Framework of Policy Change and the Role

of Policy-Oriented Learning Therein 11 Policy Sciences. 1988. N2 21; Sabafier .


Policy Change over Decade or More 11 Policy Change and Learning: An
Advocacy Coalition Approach 1 Ed. . Sabatier and . Jenkins-Smith.

85

ingdon J. Agendas, Alternatives and Puiic Policies. Boston, 1984. . 151.

166

Boulder, 1993.

167

. ,
, :

;
;
;
,
- .

- .

4:
::I::
u

:r
I4:

:::;

._
4:u
0..
c
u
:>:'c:t

1-

Cl)
:s:
1

.....

:.:
:s:
o
:s:
:

:.:
u
Cl)
7
1:

:
Cll

g.
:.:

Cl) .lJ
",

"'
Q.
Q)
J)
....

-------

",

\D

"'
u

g.Q.
>-\

:;

.
:
(
); ( ,

Cll

); -

Cl)

Cl)

Q. U
-

:s:
u

",

>-

:.:\0

( };

u
Cll

(, ) (

) . {.

2).


- ,

- . -

(policy subsystem)


,
.

, , .

..

0..
1-

4:_
..
4:

-u
..
u
:;
s
4:
u
..

1.!)
1-

..0
I

.-s
u._
s
u

su
I
3

"'

Q)
)(

rt1

168

169

( ) .

, ,
,
.
- (policy
brokers),
.
,
,
. -
-

,

,
- .


,
,
. ,
- ,
,
.


, .
-
. ,
, -

- . -,
,

-,
- ,
-

,

-

( ,
). -,
, ,
-

,
....

,
-
, ,
.
, .
- ,


.

,
. ,
-

,
,
.

.

- . .
:
,
- , ,

(, ).

: (

170

171

3.

);
; ;
.
, , ,

- ,
.

,

, .

, , , ,




( ).
, , - .



, (
) . ,
,

87 -,
-

. ,


. -, .

,

,
,

. -,
-

,
:
?, :
?. -,
,
,

. , , , ,

-

, n
. , .
,

, ,
.

- -

(,

.) (, , .),

n ,

.: Parsons W. Puiic Policy: An lntroduction to the Theory and

. . ,

87

Practice of Policy Analysis. . 200-203.

172

. ,
173

, n (folders)

(lences) . . .

, . ,

, , -

( decision making round)

, .

, , ,
.

1990- .

....

, -

--

(rows of decisions),

? .

. (,

: ""

) ,

, , ,

(, ),

, -

, -
.


,
. ,
,
,
88
-

,
, ,
.
-

, .
, , ,

, .

,
,

-
-

, .
, ,

88 Teisman G. Decision-Making Processes: Phases, Streams and Rounds

, ,

Models 11 Puic Administration. 2000. N2 4. . 943.

174

. . :
175



""
89.
, -

1

n n n
w

,
.

N5!

nn-

n 1

,
-

, ,
-

'

, .
-

. -,
-

- ,

(
-, - ).

(. , . , . .)
-
,

, -

, -

, - w

, -

, -

, -

--

t:i-

, -

, -
. ,

-,
(. , . , . .)

- , - , , (analytical device),

, -

, -

),

89 eisman G. Decision-Making Processes: Phases, Streams and Rounds

Models 11 Puiic Administration. 2000. N 4. . 947.

176

177
12

3.

r
1

1
1

N!:!

- -

1
-

(-

-),

, -

--

'- /

, -

,
.I]_-

, - ,

, -

, -

- , -


-
, -

(-

),

()

, -

90. ,

N!:!

, -

(-

,
.

. -,

Palumbo D. Theories of Policy Making // Encyclopedia of


Government and Politics / Ed. . Hawksworm and . Kogan. . 651-652.
9

K elly R.,

. . .

178

179
12*

3.

'

; ;
; .
: ,
, , -

n ,

, --

. ,
, n .
-

. ,

:
. ( ),
- . .

(policy-makig system / policy system)1



,

( -

. 2 , '

,
,

, ,
. -,

():

- ),

. (-,
, n),
(, -
) . , -

, , -

,
, , -

, . . 2

-

( - ) ,
,
,
-, -
-

. ,

,
,

, n ,
.
180

.: Gordon /., Lewis J., Young . Perspectives

Policy Analysis 11

The Policy Process 1 Ed. . Hill. L., 1994.


2

.:

. .

11
.

2002. No 2. . 120-121 .
181

4.

- .

, .
-

4.1.

, .

, -

? ,

(i1 Q.11_&J4
- f

1960-

':!1. _;
(policymakig structure}

{puiic policymakig structure},


: 1} (uits}; 2} ;

3)

; 4} -

. -, ( } _
- ,

. -, -

,
-

. -,

. ,

, , ,

, -

'I

. -

- -

, ,
-

,
, ,

. -,

, -

, ,
, . ,

m:.

Dror . Puic Policymaking Reexamined. New Brunswick; Oxford, 1989.

4 .: Dror . Puic Policymaking Reexamined. . 199-200.

. 197.

182

183

l
.,

4.

', .!
1 t
"' ,

f) l,;

, t

. -,

, , . .

, -

, -

; 3) .

, -

, -

, -

. ,

_, ,

(, , ,

.)

( ,

.),

, ,

, ,

1)

2)

. . 5

't._.

-, .

t1

, , ,

. -

1)

(units)

2)

, .

3) 6

( ) ,

, -

. ,

.
5
6

.: Dror .
.:

Puic Policymaking Reexamined. . 78-84.

Iid. . 203-209.
184

185

4.


,
.

{!_

.
, -

,- (
)

.
-, . -

'i , , ,

(, , )
,

: ,
, , ,

8
,

. ,

, -, .

. .
-

.
-

-
, ,

, ,

. .

, , ,

1
- t


,
.
,


7

Dror . Puic Policymaking Reexamined. . 205.

186

, n
_,

,
. ,


. .
8

Dror . Puiic Policymaking Reexamined. . 207.

187

4.

, -

,
-

. -,

- ,
-

. , ,

- .

. .

. -,

( ,

). , -,

, ,

, ,

, -

,
, -


().

. .

(. . 2).

, 1970-

: ,

- ,

, ,

? -,

Dror . Puiic Policymaking Reexamined. . 208.


188

, ,
, - ,

189

'

4.

,
1

; -, -

n ()

N2

nn

1. 1. -

( )

,
; -, -

1.1 . 1. -

, n


....

1. 1.2. -

, , -

1.2. -

( )

1.2.1. -

1.2.2. -

2.1. -

2.1.1. -

( )

.
.

2.1. 2. -

- l:i

2.2.1. -

2. 2. -

()

. - (-

) w - ()
. -

2.2.2. -

3. 1 -

-
()

:
. -

3. 1.1. -

- ,

, -

3. 1. 2. -

, -

,.

, -

3.2. -

3.2.1. -

-1

()

3.2.2. -

190

'

,
. ,
-

, ,

191

1
1

4.

( ) (11
), , (1

,
. ,

),
- ,

:
, -

.


.
.

, n - .

, ,

. ,

, .

, n
,

,
,

4.2.

-
,

,
, ,

.
, ,

- ,
-
- .


, -

, ,

,
, .

,
.

- ,
, ,

? ( )
-

, -

,
,

- . ,

'
1
)

- ?

?
193

192
13

------

------ -------

'

4.

,

, ,


,

,
( ,
)
,

1991 ,



,

,
, ,


.


,


-
.

- :

1) ; 2) - ;
3) ; 4) : .
,
,
,

.

,
_

. . ,
,

.
, , ,

, ,
12
_
, ,
. ,

, : -,

, ,

-
: , , .
-,
, .
,
, , , 13.

(peak associations) 11 .


:
-
? ,
,
,

.
. ,

,
-
.
- (policy
domain) ,
,


, -
. , : - ...
-
,



(

),

10
-

- .

11

.: Hi/1 . The Policy Process in the Modern State. L., 1997. 109;

Knoke D. . cit. . 11.


12 .
: Und/om Ch., Woodhouse . The Policy-Making Process. Upper
Sadle River, 1993. . 34-36.

Knoke D. Policy-Making in the Organizational State. Cambridge, 1996.

. 9.

.: Anderson J. Puiic Policymaking: An lntroduction. Boston, 1994.

. 54-72.
194

195

_, -

13*

4.


,

,
,
(
,
, ,
.),
, ,

,
14.


( )


,
,

. ,



,



.

.) - ,

.
(,

),
, ,
15.
-

-.., -
- ,

.
, _ ,


,
,
1
(official 1 unofficial),
.
,
1
(proximate 1 improximate),
. ,

. .
,
,
,

(primary) (supplem
entary) .
,



. (


-

, , ,
(.

3).


,
, ,
,
,
16. ,
, ,

-
,

15 .: Anderson J. Puiic Policymakig: An lntroduction. . 54-55.


16

, . . .
:

14

.: . ., . ., . .,

. . :
, .
, 1992.

,
. ,
, , :
, . . ( :
. . 1 . . . . . ., 2000. . 56).

196

197

,.

4.

. . ,
: , .
-

, ?
-

, ,
. :

... ,

.
3. ,

.

_





.
,

,


, ,

:

,


;

;


;
;

;


. ,


,

,






.



.


-


-
,
. -
,
.
,
, ( -

) 17 .
, , ,

. ,

198

..

. . 1992 . .
1999 ,
. , -
-
,

-
.

17 . : . . 11 .
. -. . 11, . 1998. N2 5.

199

:-

4.

, , .

,

-

,
,
,

,



,

.

, ,
, ,
, ,
- ?


. ,
,
t .

,
,
,

- ,
?



,

.
,
,

,
,

.
,

,

.
,
.
,

,

, .
,

-





.



.
,
, ,
,

-

,
.
200

,

, ?
, ,
,
,
, ,
-

- ,

. . .
,
,
,

18


.
,
,
,
,

, .
1s

.: Lindblom Ch., Woodhouse . The Policy-Making Process. . 45-46.


201

4.


;
2) - ; 3)

.
.
,

-

. -,

19,
. . .

_

, ,
-

) ,
- : 1) (
( );

3) ; 4) ; 5) ;
6) . , ,


, , ,

,


)
( ,


( ).

,
,
-
,

, ,
:
-

_
- : 1)

. -


,
(, ,
. .)
. .) (,


,
2) ; 3) ; 4)

. -

19


,

)

( , ,

. .).

, ,
, ,


- ,


,
.


,
-
,

. (

( ;
;

2)

, :r

) ;

1)

,
, (

. .). ,

Lind/om Ch., Woodhouse . The Policy-Making Process. . 46.


202

203

----

4.

-,

,

. ,

. 1990-
, .
, ,
,
( , (

, , - .

) , . .) -
( , -

. ,-

- ,

20

. .), , ,

(, , .).

( , .),
.

-,
, ,

, ,
. :

,
, ?

- ,

,
,
,

.
-

4-5 ,
,
-

,
,

, .

.
,

?
,

, . -

20

204

Und/om Ch., Woodhouse . The Policy-Making Process. . 53.


205

..

4.

( , )
. - ,

.....J ,

. ,

, , ,

"

' :

, _!, , ,

, , . -


. , -

,
( ,

\
'

- .
, ,

, : ) _=
.
,

, , .
, , ,

, (
) ,

, -

. ,
,

, ,

. ,

. , , - -

,
, npecc

.


,
, .

-
.

, ,

, .

,

.
(

).

r "\

.. .
,. . ,
n
, n,

206

, ,
,

.


207

4.

- , ,

, ?

- ,

) .

. , :

. ,
21

] , ,

/: "

'lfJ , , (
.,
,
..

, ,

, - ,

, -

, , -

. . -

. . -

, -

, ,

: . ,

. , . , . . ,-

: Who is Mister

Putin?. , ,

: ,

22

, ,

: ,

, ,

, ? -

21

. : . .

: . . ... . .
. ., 2002.

1
1
1
1
'

22

.: - . .

. ., 1988; George . Presidetial


Decision-Making in Forein Policy: The Effective Use of lnformation and Advice.
Boulder, 1980.

208

209
14

4.

, , , ,

. , ,
,

.
, 1990-

vJ

- , -

. . . .

. 2.

,'1

_
t
.
.

,
.

.
, -

,
. ,

, ,

, 1998
. ,

.
1980- , -

. . .

, ?

, n

n n -

-
1980- - 1990-
- .

- .

, . .

XXI .

( 1887)

, -

( 1900)

n, -

.
23

Anderson 1.

Puiic Policymaking: An lntroduction.

. 58.

210

211
14*

4.

, -, .

,

,
24

.

: ,

,
.
,
,
.



,
.
{

,
-

,
, ,
-

25 . -, -

--_.-J

. ,





-,
.


. -,

, ,
-


,
,
. , -

. -,
,
,
.
, , , , ,
-

.
( decisio
making rule-making,
).
,
, , -

24

. 11

: 1 . . ,
. . ., 2003. . 44.
25

: Lind/om Ch., Woodhouse . The Policy


Making Process. . 59; Anderson J. Puiic Policymaking: An lntroduction. . 60.

212

,


,

.


,


,
-
, ,
. ,


,

.



: {
213

4.

), ( ) ,
, (

).

,

,

- ,

. . ,
-

.

. ,

.. ,

( ), , -

,
1 .

, .

,
,

; ,

,
26 . -

, ); ,

(street-level bureaucracy)

() (,
-


, ; -


, ,

, , .

,
,
.
, ,
- ,

. ',

).

,
-
, 4-5 8-10 ,

.
,

( ,
-

. , -

, ).


,

,

- -, , ,
,
11.

16

Lind/om Ch., Woodhouse . The Policy-Making Process. . 59.

214

215

4.

-, r

(


:
_

.
,

(
),

?
,

,
cy cycle),
oli
(p

;
;t , ,
- -,
r ,

, ,

. . : ,
"" , -

.
(
) 27 ,

. ,
.
,

- .

. v

: 11 . . .,

: 1 .

27

. ,

2003. . 529.

217

216

5.


,
. ,
.

5.1. - :

-

- . .
. . 1
-
,
.
,
-

(1992)

(po/icy cycle)

(analytica/

(i


licy cycle approach)
po
/
s
es
oc
pr
icy
ol
(p


().

,
,

,
,

-,

. ,

-
-

.
-

,
-

device),

, ,
-

2

- ,
, -.

.: . .

( 111) 11
.
2

2003. N2 3. . 157-161.

Kelly R., Palumbo . Theories of Policy Making 11 Encyclopedia of

Government and Politics 1 Ed. . Hawksworm and . Kogan. L.; N. .,

1992. . 651-652.
3

The Policy Cycle 1 Ed. J. and . Wildavsky. Beverly Hills, 1978.

219

218

- d-.--

5.


. ,


(
).
-,

, -

-
s. -, -

,

,
.
,



.
,




(
, ,

),

.

,
, ,


,

,

.
,

,
,
,

_!'

. -
,

. - , ,

,
( ),
( ,
, ).
-,

, -, -

-

.




. ,


,
,
,
4

(, ,

.). ,
- ,
, , -
,
.
(
) ,

.: Anderson J. Puiic Policymaking: An lnt


roduction. Boston, 1994.

. 29-30.

.: Lind/om Ch., Woodhouse . The Policy-Making Process.

Englewood Cliffs, 1993; eisman G. Models for Research into Decision-Making


.
Process: On P hases, S treams and Decision Making Rounds 11 Pu l1c

Administration. 2000. Vol. 78. N 4; Theories of Policy Process 1 Ed. Sabat1er

Boulder, 2001 .

220

221

5.


.



,


, ,

-
.
-,
-


.
,
J:i

,
,
,
,
,
.
,
-

-

,


.
,
,

-
(
).



:

2-3
.



-
,
. ,

-



(, , )-
,


(. , . ),


():
; ,
;

222

; ;

; , ,

(.

, . ).

,
,
( , ),
, . 1950- ,

-
6
,

. -
. J.?

7!/



. -
, - . . , , ,

>/.
, ,

,

,
. ,
-
(. .

3).

.: Lasswe/1 . The Decision Process: Seven Categories of Functional

Analysis. College Park, 1956.


7

Manheim J., Rich R. Empirical Political Analysis: Research Methods in

Political Science. N. ., 1991. . 349.

223

5.

N2

{1910)

{1998)

. . -

(1961)

(2003)

8
...

, .
, ; 2) -; 3) -
.
. , -

1980- . ,
. . 1

( )

; 2) , -

: 1) --

._

"
"

10

11

. . -

{ 1999)

7
N2

1)

; 3) ,

8 .: McCool D. Puiic Policy Theeries, Models and Coucepts.


Englewood Cliffs, 1995.

224

225
15

V-fHrt
1

5.


9 -


r
r<

fi'.AJ
..
,."..
71
-..:... -

2)
; 3)
;

,
.

,
. ,


. -,

1
{ . . ) . - ,

1,.


{, . ). -,


(, , . ). , -,

( ),

,
,

,
,


.
-

N2

.....
): 1)


( . . ) (. . 4).

,
,
. n
-

,
. ,

.:

., . : ,
., 1981. . 35-53.

. -

226

227
15*

5.

,

-


,
--

12 {. . 5).


,
. . ,

...

( analysis versus politics)10

( ),
- ,

, _Q ,

. ,
>?

. ,

, , ,
? . .

,
,

5.2.

, ,
3
.
1


11 ,

- -

, .

. ?
,

-
{) (

) ,


. ,

? ,

, ? , ,
12

10

.: Lind/om Ch. The Policy-Making Process. Englewood Cliffs, 1968.

.214.
11

.: Dunn W. Puiic Policy Analysis: An lntroduction. Englewood Cliffs,


1994. . 15-19.
228

.: AndersonJ. Puic Policymaking: An lntroduction. . 28; Dunn W.


Puic Policy Analysis: An lntroduction. . 16; r .
. . 163-17 6.
1
3 Manheim J., Rich R. Empirical Political Analysis: Research Methods in
Political Science. . 349.

229

5.

:
,

1 n-nr

. , . .

N2


14, . .

( , ),
( ,

) , ,
( )15

. . ,
, :

,,,-

);

3)

16


- . ,

: ;

17

2)

( n) (,

.) ( );

1)

, -

)
, : -


- .


.
,
.

230

, , ,
-


, .

R., / . Theories of Policy Making 11 Encyclopedia


of Government and Politics 1 Ed. . Hawksworm and . Kogan. . 651.
15 .: M anheim J., Rich R. Empirical Political Analysis: Research Methods
i n Political Science. . 350.
6
1 .: Hogwood ., Gunn L.Policy Analysis for the Real World. L., 1984.
. 7-8.
17 .: Jenkins W. Policy Analysis. Oxford, 1978.
14

.: Kelly

231

5.

.
( )
: -,
, - (
) , -, ,
18

. , -
. ,- ,
,

, ,
, 19 ,
, ,
,
,

.
,


,


, .

, .

, ,
?
, ?
1970-

(issue-attention cycle)

, -

18

.: r . .

19

Anderson J. Puiic Policymaking: An lntroduction. . 85.

232

., 1973. . 484.

. -,
, ,
.

. -,
.
-
, , ,
,? .
-,
,
. ,
. ,

,


.
.
.
,
. , ,

. , ,
,
,
. -
,
20
,

.
,

20

.: Downs Up and Down with Ecology: The lssue-Attention Cycle 11

Puiic lnterest. 1972. Vol. 32. . 38-50.

233

S.

- . ,

, .


, -

-,

, ,
,

, .

(, , ,

).

: ,

( ),-
( )-

.

( ) . -

,
.

(),

,
,

,

,

. ,

234

,
- ()
() .
, ,
,
,
. ( )

, ti
,
. ,
,
,
21 ,
n ,


, .
,

,
. (
-) ?

n

( 1984)

- (policy
proems) ,
,
22 n

proema, ,
,

21

R., Elder Ch. Participation in American Politics: The Dynamics of

Agenda-Building. Baltimore, 1983.


11

.: Dery D. Proem Definition in Policy Analysis. Laurence, 1984.

235

5.

23

, .

, ,

, n ?

- .

-,

()

, -

, , -

, ,

24

- -

, -

, -

, -

- ,

: ,

, .

-,

25 - , -

- .

, ,
:

23

.: . ., 1982. . 400.

24

.: Dewey J. The Puic and lts Proems. Denver, 1927. . 15-16;

Dunn W. Puic Policy Analysis: An lntroduction. . 185.


25

/ L. Puiic Policy Analysis: An lntroduction. Scarborough, 1992. . 119.


236

-
,
,
;
237

5.

:
I't
, ,


, ,
- - ,

, , ,

, .

. ,

27 ,

, , -

, >>, -

, , , 1950- ,

, ,

- (

, ,

. .

.)

,
,

.
: , ,

,
,

( )
?

, 1990-
6-

?
1960-70-


. , ,

(nondecisions),

.
, ,

, ,- -

26

. -
;

26

. Bachrach ., Barats . Decisions and Non-Decisions: An Analytical

Framework 11 American Political Science Review. 1963. Vol. 57; BachrachP.,

Barats . Two Faces of Power 11 Power1 Ed. S. Lukes. Oxford; Cambridge,


27

1986.

Bachrach ., Barats . Power and Poverty. N. ., 1970. . 44.


239

238

... <--

5.


,



2s.






,

>


.




,


,


.



.

8

,

,
-




.

,


(
)
(
),


.



,

,




.











,
-


.
,

-


2003
8


-

29 (20002004)
201 ,
. ,

- ,
,
, 30.
,,

,
.
:

.
, -

. , 1990-

: . .
, . .
, . . . 31


32

.
,

29

.:

16 2003 . ., 2003. . 38.


30

.: (2000-2004)

201 1 . . .
11 . 2000. 11 .
31

.: . 2004. 11 .

32

.: :

.
11

28



.
., 2001. . 231.


1 . . . . .
.,21.

240

241
16

....
....
...
-------------------------

----

5.

, , -

34

, -

, . .

, , -

, -

, ,

, - -

, -

, , ,

, -

- . ,

, ,

(policy formulation)

, -

...,

5.3.

, ,
-

. , . , -
(
, )
33
,

33

Anderson 1. Puiic Po\icymaking: An lntroduction. . 1 1 .


242


,

.

?
. ,
: -,
, ,
; -,

,
; -,_

34

.: . . . . 170.
243

5.

, -

; -

, ,

35 ,

. 1993

450 178

, , 89

, ,

. , ,

. ,

. ,

, ,

, ,

, ,

-,

, 1990-

. ,

,
, .

, , -

, . -

35

.: Anderson J. Puic Policymaking: An lntroduction. .102.


244

,
245

f)

5.

:
,

. r -

, , ,

. n

1/), Juf .1;,

(;

. , n

6 -q ,

, ,

. .

, , -

- ,

. .

, ,

, .

, , ,

. ,

. ) -

2002-2003 .

..!! , - ,

1980- ,

- ,

. ,

m :a J4Jt"?

, ,

. , npa- 1

' -

I.Q_ t:t :


.
,

At ;
t

'

'-

1 . -

( ad hoc).

, , -

246

247

CJ:f ;,,,

5.

(Congressional Research Service),

, -

- , -

()1-rl

.
,

, .

, ,

36 ,

. ,

_ .

, .

_l] .

,
. ,

rJ(

}. ?
l
v
...t
t :
,

: ,

, -,

, -,

, , -

, -

. ,

. , -V
, 1


(Office of Legislative Counsel)

, ,

, ,
36

Anderson J. Puic Policymaking: An lntroduction. . 1 05.


248

,
-

249

5.

,.

)R J7 t ,

38 -

.
') J.,.r'

tp\1'1.--

'"

, -

, ,

39

, 1980-

, . .

(solution analysis),

1) ;

),

; 4) 40 .

37

5)

1) ; 2)

3) ;

4) ;

41 ,

. . .

, : v

; ;

!
V

, -

v-c)w

WIJ
1/t;)../

" (
....G'

/JJ
{\
V {t
' ,.., ' . .
. ..

3)

2)

? ,

tt
ii

; ;
( );

.r

38

.: . . .

., 1984;

., 2000;
1997; .

Golub .

. .

Decision Analysis: An lntergrated Approach. N. .,

,
.: Ande rs on J. Puic Policymaking: An lntroduction.

250

. 106.

. 1.

39

Golub . lbld.

40

.: Weimer D., Vining . Policy Analysis: Concepts and Practice.

Englewood Cliffs,
37

41

199 2. . 205.

.: Go/ub . Decision Analysis: An lntergrated Approach.

251

. 9-11.

'

5.

;
;

_L . ,

; ; -

, ,

;
;

-
,

42 ,
,

.
? -

,
, ,

44 ,

,
,

er/' Cf..l.f t 1

...

/r


, -

t}J
"
u1

()

.
1

--:

1)

, ,

2)

,
,
, ,

4)

. :

, .
( )

, .
, - . . , - -

,
43
, ,
, .

1\ot./11
r,
1{

1). ,-J

f\

3) ;

\l


. ,

? ,
- n
,
?
,
,

, .
, ,
, 44
,

.
43 . . 89.

42

.:

252

. . .

85.
44

.:

. . .

253

81 .

5.

(,

( )
,

( ),

, . .),
, ,

: (,
) ( , ).

()
,

, , ,

45. ,

,
, ,
. ,

. ,

,
,
, ,
,
, . .


-

- - (
Three : Efficiency - Effectiveness - Equity),

1

.

(
). ? . ,

, . ,
-

( -)
,

, , -

46. , ,

, ,

( ).

.
1


45.: . . . . 81;
Weimer ., Vining Policy Analysis: Concepts and Practice. . 223; Golub

Decision Analysis: An lntergrated Approach. . 84; .

254

(policy priorities). ,
1
46 Anderson J. Puic Policymaking: An lntroduction. . 85-86.

255

5.

. , , -

, -

- -

, , -

: , ,

: ,

( ) ?

, ,

, ,

, -

- , -

- , -

. ,

. . ,

- ,

( ) ,

-,: 47

, -

, -

. . . : -

48

- ,

, .

, ,

, - 47 .: . . . . 85.

1
1
1
1
1

48 . .
. ., 1989. . 30.

256

257
17

5.

, ,

. , ,

, -

1994 , ,

1999 .

, ,

, ,

1998 . , -

, ,

-,

q., .

,
1

. ,

, ,

. -

, , -

49. -

: , -

, ( ).

. ?

. . , ,

) .

50 ,

, -

. ,

, , -

, .

, -.

49

. . . . 89.

50

258

. . . . 90.
259

17*

5.

( )

, , 9 ,

, 1 ,

51 ,

( ) ,

. -

, ,

. .

, -

Urals

25 30 ,

. , -

- -

( ),

- -

12-15

- -.

, -

(cost-beefit analysis).

( )

, , .

.

260

51

. . . . 91-92.

261

5.

... "53

. ,

, , ,

, ( 2003 -

21 ,6 .

(, , ,

), ,

).

. ,

:
(1992) . .

- :
(impacts) ;
;
52
: -
,
-

, -, ,
, -
,
,
, .
,
,

,
, -

,
-

,
-

: .

9
-


11,
15% 54
, ,
,
.



.

, ,

, 55 - ,
-

. , ( )

, .

-, - . . . -


"
, . . " "

52

.: Weimer 0., Vining . Policy Analysis: Concepts and Practice.

. 228-236.

262

53

. . . . 89.

54

.: . 11 . 2003. 8 anp.

55

Golub

Decision Analysis: An lntergrated Approach. . 100.

263

5.

; --

( -

, -

, -

. .),

( )

, - ,

, -

(general matrix approach)

( , ,

n ( ,

. . }56

(. .

6).


, ,

6
-

n- 1 2 3

.

()
,
, -
. :

,
? ,

,
,
56 .: McRae .

Whittingfon . Expert Advice for Policy Choice:

Analysis and Discourse. Washington 1997. . 15-16.


1

264

. , ,

265

5.

(super-optimal solutions),

- ,

, - .

. .- - ,

57

) .

, ,

59 -,

. ,

(,



,
1
, ,
.
, . ,
,

,
58 ,

57

., . 11

1 . . . ,
. . . ., 1998. . 373.
58

. , 11

, ). , -,


{,
, .)
.
,
. , -,


{ . ),
,
,
. .
,

, :
1 . . , . . ., 1999. . 64.

266

59

.: . . . . 101-103.

267

...._

S.

, . ,

, -

, , , ,

, 61. ,

, . . . ,

1 )

, , -

- ,

60. , ,

. -

, -

, ,

) .

,
,

5.4.

. ,
( )

,


, ,
(
, )

,
-

, , .
,
(policy-adoptio stage),- . ,-

60

.:

. .
268

. 103.

62. ,

,
,
.
( ,
-

,
-

. .)

61 AndersonJ. Puic Policymaking: An lntroduction. . 119.


62 .: 1 . . . ,
. . . ., 1999. . 400-403; 1
. . . , . . . ., 1999. . 95-98.
269

5.

, -

. , -

, (-

), -

, ,

. .). ,

63 -

, -

, .

. ,

. ,

. . ,

( )

, -

, -

, ,

, -

, .

, ,

, ,

--

, -

,
63

. . 96.
270

.
271

5.


: 1) -; 2) -
; 3) -,
, , ,
,
. ,
.
,

,
( )
.

,
- , ,
-1 ( 1)
-2 (
1 ),
2.


, ,
. -
.
, , - , ,
,

.


- -

,
,
. , ,


(, )
, , ,
,
,


.
(
), ,
,
,
, ,
.
,
,
.
, , ,
XXI . ,


. 2003
, ,
,
-

1
1
1
1
1

272

273
18

5.

n.

n,

(n n

), -

(. , . .), n nn n

: n n

(n, .), n , ,

. -

, n n

. , ,

( 2001 n n

. n

, n

11 n
). n

. . , n

n n
n 2003-2004 .

: .

, n, -

n n ,

, n n -

nn, - n

. n n

-n -. n

, - n n

n ,

, nn,

. n

n (

n n, n-

n ) n,

nn n ,

n . nn,

n n

- , n

n -

n n.

, n-

(, ..) ,

. , . .

n ,

, n

, , ,

n, n, n

n n nn.

274

275
18*

5.


. -

- ,
(, .), (

, > . ,

, .) (,

- ,
,
. -

.) .
.
( )

,

, .

, .

- ,

. ,
-

, .
! ,
, ,
.
<? -

, ,
.

(. .),
. ,

. , -

. , ,

.
- ,

30%.

276

,
-

,
,

(, .) .

277

5.

, -

, -

, -

. , .

, -

, , -

2003


(, .).

-

,
, , -

. , : -
,

64 ,
,
.

. ,
, (

) ,

, n

- .

, -

, ,

, , { ):

1) n;

? , :

, - .

n -

? -

, -

, , { ),

, ,
. ,

(
); , 278

2)

n;

3)

. . .
,

64

Anderson J. Puiic Policymaking: An lntroduction. . 125.

279

5.

,
65
, ,
,

, .
:

.
,
. ,
-

< ,
,

:
,

, , , ,

,
.
-

. ,

, ,
.
, ,

-
, , ,
.
, ,
, ,

.
, ,

, .

, ,

, .

,
-

, ,

. ( )
, ()
(50%+ 1 ),

( )

66

2/3

, -

. ,
,
,
( )

(66%+

1 )

3/4 (75%+

1 ),


,
-
.
-
,

65

. . . . 106.

66

.: . . 115.
280

,
281

5.

.
,

, ,
. ,

.

,
, ,

,
. ,

67. ,
,
,

. ,
,

.
( )

,

. , ,

, , -, ,
67

. . . 117.
282

, , -
, , ,

.

:
, -

.

,
. , ,
? ,

.-
?

.

.
? -,
,
:
- (), - ,
, ,
68 -,
-
:

1)

( ),

6s

.: . .

2003.

( 111) 11

N2 3. . 157; Offe . Designing lnstitutions in East

European Transitions 11 The Theory of lnstitutional Design. Cambridge, 1996.

. 203.
283

5.

() ;

2)

-,

, (

);

3)

-,

, -

-
-

, -

, -

- ,

69

(. .

7).

,

.

...

r-

,
:
,
,

, ,
. -

, (
, .),


. ,
, ,
-, -
; -, ,
,
(
-}; -,
-

-, -

-
,
.

( 1971)

.
(),

. . ,
-

69

.: . . . .

284

99-1 02.

285

5.

,
,

70 ,

, -

-,

, -

.. ,

71 . . ,

,
, l
72 ,

,
:
,
. .73 -

(20-30

,
,
n
. , ,
-

70

Allison G., Zelikow . Essence of Decision: Exp\aining the Cuban Missi\e

Crisis. N. ., 1999. . 170.


71

.: . ., . ., . .

. ., 2001. . 40-41;
1 . . . , . . . ., 1999. . 386.
72

. .

,

, (
)

11 :

1 . . . . ., 2001. . 44.

73

.:

11
. 1998. No 7; 11
1 .
. . . ., 2000.

286

,
-,
, , ,
,
-

287

5.

,
74

.
,

, -

- .

,
.

, ,

. ,
: -

. -

- ,

,
- ,

, ,
,

,
.

( , )

, , -:

2)

1)

- ;

-;

3)

--

, ;
,

. , - -

;
;

- ,
;

, ,
. ,



.
, -

1
1
1
1
1

74

.: . . :

. ., 1996. . 106-107.

288

289
19 I

5.

:
- -

: -

, ,

, ,
76

-,

. , , -

-
-

, ),

, -

, .

. -

, -

. -

( - -

). ,

, -

75

, , -

76

.: . .

.: Washingfon 5. Consultation and Communications: lntegrating

Multiple lnterests into Policy 11 Puic Management Occasional Papers. 1997.

11

No 17.

1 . . . . ., 1998. . 151-155.

75

290

291
19*

5.

-,

, -

, ,

77

- ):

1)

2)

. n

(,

);

3) (,
- ); 4)

, ,

(,

n -

);

78

, n

);

(,

, ,

),

7) (,

). , n

, n

( )

, ,

79

n .

(, );

5)

6)

, , ,
-

. . 1990- ,
nn .

78

.: Smith . Reforming the United Nations Security Council:

Decision-making Analysis 11 Policymaking and : Multinational


77

.: . . . . 179-181;

n 1 . . . , . . n. ., 1999.
. 285-287.

292

Anthology 1 Ed. S Nagel. Latham, 2003. . 46-47.


79

. :

. ., 2000. . 224.

293

5.

, .

, ,

80, - . .

81 n

( ) .

, -
-


,
:

1)

{
);

2)



);

3)

{ n
,

);

4)

,

-

. ,
,
(
)
, : .
-



, .

-
.

( ) n ,
-

);

5)

5.5.

, ,

).

. -

80

Anderson J. Puic Policymaking: An lntroduction. . 137.

294

81 Anderson J. Puiic Policymaking: An lntroduction. . 141.


295

5.

, -

, ,

: 1) -

; 2) -;

3)

. . . ,

( )

( )

, , ,

, -

( )

84

J,

. .

(policy

implementation),

. , , ,

82

-. .

. . ,

, -

85 , ,

83 ,

, ,

- -

, 84
82

PressmanJ., WildavskyA.Implementation. Berkely, 1984. .XXIII.

83

. . . ., 2001.. 72.
296

.: Ripley R., Franklin G. Policy lmplementation and Bureaucracy.

Chicago, 1986..4-5.
85

Anderson J. Puiic Policymaking: An lntroduction. .189.

297

5.

1970- . ,

. 1970-

, -

(.

, . ,

. , . .)

:
-

(missing link) -

, -

(top-down). 1973

, n

() . .

(implementation), . , -

, , , -

, -

(lmplementation) ,

- , , , -

, -

: -

. 1960-

, ?

, ,

, : ,

, , , ,

( 1968-1971)

, ? ,

100%? -

, -

, -

, -,

298

299

5.

),
.
, ,

, ?

,
(

3 .).

,
.
, ,

,
, -, (

) (policy),
,

(implementation),
.

,- ,-

,
6
8

, (

),
, ,


: t1,

, t2 87
,
2 3

-


,
,

,


.

,
, -

.
,
-


.

. ,
,
.

,

,
. - ,

.

86

., . 11
: 1 .

, . . ., 2003.

300

466.

2003
87

., .

301

. 463.

5.


750 ,
,
.
,
. . ,

(
)
- -.


,
-

. , ,

,
.
( )

- , ,- ,
: -


- ,
88
,

-
.
, ,

88

., . . . 464.
302


:
,
,
-, ,
.

, ,
.
,
, ,
.

(veto decision point)
(clearance point} -

. ,
,
,-
.- ,
,
89. ,

,
,

.
-
, .
,

:
1. .
2.

89

., . r. . 464.
303

5.

3. -

-
.

4. .
-

5. - -

( )

( ).

6. -
-


90 .

,

-

, -

.
-

1970-80-
-

,
-

(bottom-up). -

, -
-

(. .)
{. .)
.
{. , . , . .)
.
-,
, ,
-

90

,
, ,
.
-,

,
-


,

. ,


,

.
-,
,
, {
)

, - ,


(
) .
-

, -,


,




,

, ,


91. ,

,

.



?


,
-
-
-

.: Sabatier . op-dawn and Bottom-up A pproaches to lmplementation

Reseach 11 Policy Process 1 Ed. . Hill. L., 1994. . 268-269.

91

.: Sabatier . Top-dawn and Bottom-up Approaches to lmplementation

Reseach 11 Policy Process. . 275-276.

304
20

305

---------

5.

, - ,

93.

, -

, ,

(street-level bureaucrats), -

. , 1970-

. . -,

92. ,

- ,

, , -

. ,

, ,

, ,

, -

,
,

, , -

, . -


, -

- ,

, , ,

, -

- ,

, . ,

" ,

11

,- :-
,

93

. n

: 11
92

.: Lipsky . Street Level Bureaucracy. N. ., 1979.

: . . 530.

307
20*

5.

,
( , ,

, , .).
,

,
,

, .

. .

, :

; ,

, .

, 94

, -

. .

, ,

,
,

.

- ,

, .

, -

- :

1)

; 2)
94

.: Sabatier . op-dawn and Bottom-up Approaches to lmplementation

Reseach 11 Policy Process. . 279-280.

308

, , ,

309

, ;

: ,
,

3)

, , -

, . .
, (-

--

),

,
-

: ,

. , ,

, , , -
, - -

. ,
,

, .
1 ( 1 )
-

, .
-

. ,
, ,


- (policy sciences),

,
, ,

. - --

.
, ,

,
-

-
, ,
- ,
,
-
.
,
,

.
-
( ,
), 310

, ,
, ,

(, .).

, . Logos Praxis,
, - ,

.
,

-

.
,
311

-

, .



.

,
.

,
, ,
,
.

,
,
,
.
:
(

.),


,
.
- ,
,
,
313

<>>
,

. . . . ,

: -

) (

).

(
),

1.

, , -






.
, ,

-


.

( ) .



,
.
- ,

1 ,


.
.

,

. : . ., . .

11 :
1 . .-. . . . ., 2000;
. . - 11
. 2001. N 1; . .
-


,

.


,
,



(,


). ,

,
,


,


,
-

,

11 . 2002. N 2; . .

11 . 2003. N 1, 2, 3.

314

. .,

1999.

.,

. .

. 27.

315

,

,

.
1.1.

-
;
- ,

1.2.

: 1) -
( 1-2); 2)

( 3-7); 3)

, -,

-
{),

-,

;

-
;

-
{);

),


( .8-13); 4) ( 14),
.


: )
; )

;
) (,

, ,
)
,

316


, .
,

.
,

.

-,

317


- ()
.




,

.

1.3.

2.

;

-

, I

(
)

. :

1)

)
dy
stu
se
ca
(

2)


> ;

3)

4) ,

2.1.

- ,


;


-
;


.
-
, _
,

319

318

__
__
__ Ai8.____________________
__

__

))

,
-

Process. Englewood Cliffs, 1993; Parsons W. Puiic Policy: An

Aldershot, 1995. -,

, ,

: ;

( Puiic Administration) ( Journal

(work shops); ( decision

of Policy Analysis and Management)

conference); ;

(tutorials);

,
,

l n troduction to the Theory and Practice of Policy Analysis.

1 (


, - -

) 2 (
); -

, , -

- .
-

. ,

( top-town

. .
-

.
,
, - , ,

, , , ,

.

-,



2.2.

,
-

.
-

- .
-,

, .

- Anderson J. Puiic Policymaking. Boston, 2003 (


). -, <
:
: . . / . .
. . . ., 2000; Allison G., Zelikow . Essence of
Decision. N. ., 1999; Hi/1 . The Policy Process in the Modern
State. L., 1997; Lind/om Ch., Woodhouse . The Policy-Making

bottom-up)

2.3.
1
1
1
1
1

320
21

321

>>
( )

: ,

( )

, (

, )

. :

: (,

(, ), (

, , , .);

) ( )

, ;

( )

; (

3. , ,

); (

) . 1,


, -



2.4.

-.
-


- ,

1,

. , 1

r n .
:

2)

1)

3)

-;

4) ; 5) ; 6)
.

3

.: . . 11

. ., 2002;

. . .
() . ., 2003; . .

,
.

,
,
-


-

.
-

11 . . -. . 12,

. 2003. N2 5.

322

323
21*

((>>

. -, ,

>>

(, , !),

. ,

( )

, , ), -

, . -,

(, ,

1 ),

. .). , ,

()

. ,

1) ( 2),

2.5.

. ,

(,

, - 2,

).

( ,

, : -,
-

, . .),
324

325

>>
3.1.


,
-,
. ,
:
,

, . ,


(analysis of policy)

. -,

(analysis for policy }4,

. ,

- 5,

- -

( 1 )

, ,

,
.

3.2.

-20%

20%

(workshop),

-30%

-30%

, -

.

: , ,
.
, ,
. ,
,

.
,
,
, ,
.

The Policy Process in the Modern State. L., 1997. . 2.

.: Hi/1 .

. :

11

- .

326

2003. N 1 . . 159-161 .
327

3.2.1.

. -

( ),
.
(workshop)
? , , ,
:

. ?
:
.

,
(,
, ).
,

, ,
,
-.
-

, ,
);

3)

,
;

4) ,

,
(,

,_ . . );

5)

(),

4 .

3.2.3.
,
, :
.

(

15-20

.) ,

,
,
, ,
(

3.2.2.

Power Point

- ,

). ,

(puiic policy)

(decision conference

seminar),

.
:

1)

3.3.

n ,

2)

(, ,

328

329

>>

, ,
.
r:

, ,
,
. .

n
.

, -

. , ,
.

, .
-


.
,
.
, ,
-

, , (
, ,
),
(, ,
. .).

6,
(, ,
>>, . .).
6

., : . .

: . ., 2001; 1 .
. . , . . . ., 1999; .

332

4.2.



. ,
( -

, }, ( ).
-

,
,
( -
) (

:).

,
,

.
-

,
.

.
,

,
, ,

.
4.3.



333

))

. ,

: (essay)-

) ,

- ,

: , ,

2).

1)

.
4.3.1.

1)

, : >-

- -

, , -,

: -

),

. ,

(., ,

: -

2)

1- 7-8 .,

-, (

2- 15-20 .
30 60 ( 1 ,5 ,
12, Times New Roman).

<www .legislature.ru>).

4.3.2.

,
.
,
,

. -,

. ,

334

335

))
,



(


, , . .),
,
, , ,

-, -,
.


. - ,

, ,


)/.
( -)

,

4.3.3.





).
, (


, .

:
} ( ,

- 8.
:
- , ;
- ;

- r:
;
- ;
- , , ,
. 9
-

( ) ,
.



,
,




.

-

. . .

.
--.

.


,
,- . .

-,


, ,
.
,

-.

Chekovich ., Kirp . Cases and Controversies: How Novitiates Are

Trained to Masters of the Puiic Policy Universe 11 Journal of Policy Analysis


and Management. 2001. Vol. 20. N2 2. . 284.
8

. : Case Studies in Puic Service Management 1 Ed.

. Lawton, D. McKevitt. Oxford, 1996;

Barnes L., Chrisfensen ., Hansen

. Teaching and the Case Method: lnstructor's Guide. Boston, 1994.


9

.: . ., . .

. . 46-47.

337

336
22

))

4.4.

. ,- , , , ,

, )>10 ,
-

, 1 2
,
, , ,

. , ,
?

,

1 2.
-,
,

,
. ,
( )
-

( ),
( ),
.
,

?

: ,
,
.

-



. _

, .
,

7 2 . -

11
,
- (policy
network),
.
,
-

,

. -, -

1
.
-

,

(,
17 1997 N 2 0
).
-. , - .


. 1 ,

.

10 r ., . : . ., 1997.
. 60.
11 : . . . .,
.

1994.

338

339
22*

>>
4.4.1.

1, ,
.

(
) . ,
( },

1)

-

, ,
.

,
.

, . ,

,
,

,

, ,

,
,

(. 1 ).
,

. . ,

. -,

, ,

( > )
. -,
, -

12
4.4.2.
(


. 2
.

()
.

1)


.
12

., .

. ., 1993. . 53.

340

341

<

, . 1980-90- ,

{. 3).

13.


,
-

15.

.
-
(

) n ,
.
,
,
.

,
. ,

,
, 16.

.
4.4.4.

, . .

2)

, ,
, , ,
14. ,

, , ,

,
{. 2).
4.4.3. ()
(


-
,
8
,
: . ,

,
111

1)

8-13).

-
-

15

.: . . .. , 1996.

. 86-91; . . :
13

.: Knoke D. Political Networks: The Structural Perspective. Cam

bridge, 1990; . . ..... .


.. ., 2001.
14

.: . . .., 2001.

. 59-68.

342

. ., 2001 . .19-29;

GolubA. Decision Analysis: An lntegrated Approach. N. ., 1997. . 7-23.


16

. : .

11
1 .. . ., .. .., 1998. .4.

343



4.4.6.

,

,
(
).

( 2)

-
.

,


,


, ,

),

( ,

) (.

4).

4.4.5.

(
, ).
'



, .
,
(
)
(.
*

2)

-

11

.

(. 5).

, -,
,
(

..), -,


.
,


.
344

6).

* *



.
: ,
, -
/ ( )
. (,
. .}
( , ,
. .).
,
(1997-200 3)

,
,
345


.
,
.
,
(
)



))

XXI .
-
-

1 ,


11

347


()


3

)) ( )

" "

-
.
.

-n

1
1
1
1

1- 1""

) ,

nn

1-

()

, -

,
.

...

, . -

_L _L

{ )

.
,

348

349

>>
-
-

n .

(. 57, 60, 61 ).

(. 65 ).
. 132 ,
,


1.
,
-

.

.

1. -

(. 35 ). . 130
, ,
n
, ,
,
.
,
.

2.
,

4.
(. 50 ). -



, . 8

132 .
5.
( 2005 .)
.
: ,

. 1 2004 .

.
,
.
, . 131
.

,
.

n.

( . 34-39 ). . 131 ,
-

11.
.

1 .

3.

. -

( . 2 ).

350

351


2.

111.

1 .

, .

, - -

,

(
. 55 ).
,



,


( ,,
).

(. 21 )

( . 79
).

(. 5, 66, 76
). ,
-


.

,
,
(. 24 ).

3.

-

,
(. 37 ).
4. .
,

,
.
.

(. 14-16, 18 ).
(.11 ).

2. ,


,
.



,


,


(. 19, 20
).

.


,

(. 59
,
66, 76 ).
-

3.



,
,

352
23

353

>>

( ,
)
.

, .

.

8. ,

: -

, ,
, ( ,
-

),

.

.

.
4.

,
.
5.

(, ),

(
).
6.

-

- , , , .
-

,
.
7.
, 354

i.
n . .; . .; n

nn . .; ;
n . .; ;

r-- - -- -- -------- -----

------------------------

..

n

-

( 40 n)

n11

r11

11

n
-

!i


.
(.
)

f-

n11

11

!I

11

,_

n . .
n

nn

!i

no

n np ao
a
o


11
11

n;
;

n:
,

, n,

n
a
: : e: : : :::::::::::::::_ ______ ____________' "-C :
::::::::::::::::::::::::a
l__: ::M
: : :o: :
po
: : o
- ;

------------------------------------ _. _.____________

----

356

_j

_l

JL_____________j

357




(
)

0

, ,
,
.

.
,
.

, ,
.

.
. , , .

,
.
, ,
, n n, n,
.
, ,

. 1 2002

, , ,

,
.

0 -
,

, 0
,
0 ,

.

,
.
,
,

358

,
.
,

: ;


; ,

,
.

359

>>

. ,

,
,

, -

. ,

-
- (. 9 ).

)) , 0
)), )), 0 -

n ,
.

())).
, ,

.
-

- .

.

-



. ,

.
,
6 ,

, .

3
,
. ,

.
,
,
360

,
.

.
,

, -

,
, .
() ,
,
1

, .

.
361

11 .
.
12.


()

.
13.

.
14. 1-
.

15.

1. .

1.
.
2.
.
3. ,

'

16. 2-
.
17.
.
18. 3-
.
19. .

.
4.
,

111. .
20. ,

.
-

11. .

5. (
)

21.
.

.
6.
.
7.
-

.
8. .
-

9. .
1. R- .
362

363

.



.


, ,
,

1.

, -, ,


, , -,

,
.
, ,

,

,

,

. -

,
-
.

, -

:
- - ;

-
( - },
.



- { decision
conference 1 seminar) -, -

364

, .
,
,

.
-

,

,
-
.



,

. -,

365


<< >>

11.

,
>>


,
.


-, ,



,

.
, >>


,
,
.



. ,
, ,
,


,
1979 1994 ,

1990- ,
1998 . .


.
,

. ,
,




,
;

,

,
;

-
.

366

'.


-

(administrative / policy sciences),


.

.: . .

. 4. .,

1984.

180-181.
367

>>

2
,
, ,

- (. , . ,

. , . , . ) ,



.

,

,

.

- 2002

, .
-

1960-70-

1.

. :
.

.

.


,
. ,

.
3 -

, ,
-

. : . .

//
. 2002.
3

N2 2. . 113-125.

., : Andeson J. Puic Policymaking. Boston, 2000;

h J. Primeron Decision Making: How Decisions Happen. N. ., 1994.

,


.



.
-
.



.

-
.


.


.


.



, n

.
n
.

-



.

:


.
8

.
n

.
n

368
24

369

------- -------

:
.

() .
. -

(. , . ,

. .
.

.

. .).


. .
. . -

. ,

.
.

. .

:
,

. - .


. . . -

- . -

11.

. f-

. .
.

. .
() .
. . 1950-60-
. ,
. ,
. . .
(
, ,
).


.
.
. ()
- .
() - . .

. - .


. - -

(. .), (. .),

(. .) (. .).

370

371

>>


. ,
(), ().
.

, ,
.

: -

, - . ,
.
, ,
- -
. .

,
.
-
.

, , , ,
.
,
.
.
4
-

()
.
>>.
. -
: . , .
, . , .
. : , ,
, . .
. .
372

. .
.
.
,
. .
.
[!.
.
.
,
. .
,
. .
.
- .

. .
. ,
, .
.

. .
. -
. .
- .
.
.
.

.
5

-
. ,
. 373

))

. - -

. .

- .

. .

. . .

. .
. .
.
.
. .
.
.
. .
- .

(. .). .
. .

. . ,
.
. .
.
.

-
.
.
. , .
.
,
.
.
.
. .
. -
.
. .
. .

.
. ,
, , .

. .

. ,

. ,

. - .

. .

. -

. , n

374

375

>>

111.

. -
.

. -
. .

: ;

. .
.

;
; .

.

,

- .
.
.

. >>
. .

,
. .

, - .
. .

.
. .


. .

.
(,

, .

.). .
- .

.
. .

.
.

.
. .

, .
.
376

- .
.
.
377

. .


.

10

.
.
.

.

. .
.
.

.
: ; ;
; ;
.
.
. .
.
.
. . ,

.
. ,
. .
.
. (
) .
. .
. -

: , -,
.
.
.
.
.
: ,
. .

: ; ;

; (- ).

() .

. :

. .

; ; ; ;

. .

. . .

. .

378

379

))

.

.


.
.

11


. ,


nsensus omnium.
Co
.


.
.



. .

.
.


.
.
-

380

12


- .
. -

.
,
- .
, , . -

, .
:
- , - -

,
.
- .
,
.
.
(. , . , . .}
. .
(.
.). .
.
.
. : ,
-

, .
.
. ,
.
. .
: ....: ,
. .
,
381

))

.
.

.
.

IV.

14

13

- . .

.
.

.
-

.
.

.
.

. : -
- .

.
.
,

.
.

.
. -

, .

-

.
. -
.
. .

:
.

,
.
. ,
. .
.
.

.
.
.
.
(
, ,
..).
. n .
.

. .
,
. R-

. ,

XXI (, , ,

, .).

382

383

>>

12.


?
13. -

-

?

14.

1.

15. -

?
2.

.
16. -

,
?

.
3. -

17.
?

18. ,
?
19.

?
4.
,
.
5.

20.
?

?
6.

21.
?
22.

?
7. -
?
8.

,
?
9. ,
?
1 . ,

23.
?
24.
v


?
11.

25.
?

26.

384

25

385

))
11. -

27.
?

28.

(->> ).
12. : ,
(
).

?
29.
?

13.

30.
?

(-).
14.
( -).
15.

1. ,

( ).

16.
: (

2.
.

).
17.

3. .

4. :

n, ,

(- ).

( - ).

5.

18.
( ).
19.

(
).
6.

).

).

20.

7.

( ).

(-

).

8.

1.
.
2. :

( ).
9.

, .
3.
- .

( ).

4. .

( ).
1 .

387

386
25*

>>
5. - .
v

6. - .
v

.
v

- .
28.
.
29. - .
v

8. . .
9. . .
1. . .
11. - . .
12. .
13. -
v

.
14. .
15. .
16. -
.
-

17. :
.
18. - :
.

.
30. .
v

31 . v

.
32. -
: .
33. - .
.
34.
.
35.
.
36.
.
37.
.
v

19. - : .
v

20. .
v

38. .
39.
.
40.

21. ():
.

.
41. .

22. , ():
.
23. -

.
42. .
v

43. -

.
v

24. .
v

25. - .
.
26. - :

388

7. -

27. - .

.
v

44. .
45.
.
46.
.
v

389

>>

111.


N!:!

N!:!

()

()

14


()

()

10

11

14

14

126

36

36

54

12

13

14

IV.
14

:
1
2

,

:

390

20%

- 30%
- 20%

30%

391

<<>>

V.

V6. . . -
11

. 2001. N21.

7. . .
. ., 1998.

/8. . . .

., 2000.
9. . .

v 1. . ., . .
11

, ,
, , , .

., 1995.
1. Sabatier . Puic Policy: oward Better Theories of
the Policy Process 11 Political Science: Looking to the
Future. Vol. 2 1 Ed. W. Crotty. Evanston, 1991.
11. Milwa rd . What is Puic Management? 11 The State
of Puic Management 1 Ed. D. Kettl, . Milward.

:
1 _Q. .-. . . . . ,
2000. . 528-544.

2. . .
11 . 2002.
N22. .113-125.
-

Baltimore; L., 1996.

3. ., ., .
. ., 1995. . 21-42.

12. Zelikow . Foreign Policy Engineering: From Theory to


Practice and Back Again

4. Anderson J. Pu ic Policymaking: An lntroduction


.
Boston, 1994. . 4-25.

1994. Vol. 18. N22.

5. Dror . Puic Policymaking Reexamined. New Bruns


wick; Oxford, 1989. . 3-11, 320-326.

6. Lynn L. Puic Management as Art, Science and Profes


sion. Chatam, 1996. . 143-163.

v 1. 1 .
. . . ., 2002.
2. :
1 . . . . ., 200.0
3. . . 11
. 1999. N22.

4. . :
11 :
1 . . , .-.
. ., 1999.
5. . .

11lJ : 1 . .-.
. . . ., 2000.
-

392

11 lnternational Security.

1. .
11 -

. 2000. N26. . 256-266; 2001. N21. . 221-

232.

2. . .

11 .

2003. N21. .159-170; N2 2. . 164-173; N2 3.

. 152-163.
3. Anderson J. Puic Policymaking: An lntroduction.
Boston, 1994. . 25-36,121-126.

4. Hi/1 . The Policy Process in the Modern State. L.,


1997.. 28-47,64-91,99-109.

5. K e lly R., alumbo D. Theories of Policy Making

11
Encyclopedia of Goverment and Politics. Vol. 2 1
393

))

15. Smith G., D. The Artificial Debate Betwee


Ratioalist and lcrementalist Models of Decisio

Ed. . Hawkesworth , . g. L.; N. ., 1992.


. 643-653.
6. Under S., Peters G. The lstitutioal Approach to the
Theory of Policy-Makig: The Role of Guidace Mech
aisms i Policy Formulation 11 Comparative Puic
Admiistratio. Vol. 1 1 Ed. . Maor, J.-E. L.
Aldershot, 1999. . 93-114.

1. ., . 11
. . . 1. ., 1997.
2. ., . :
n.., 1984.
3. . .., 1990.
4. .
: , 11
: 1 . . ,
.-. . ., 1999.
5. .
11 Thesis. 1993. . 3. .16-38.
6. . .
11 . 2001.
N2 3.
7. . 11
. 1997. N2 1.
8. Allison G., Zelikow . Essece of Decisio: Explaiig
the u Missile Crisis. N. ., 1999.
9. Crabb . Policy-Makers d Critics: Coflictig
Theories of America Foreig Policy.N. .; L., 1986.
10. Dror . Basic Cocepts in Advanced Policy Scieces
11 Ecyclopedia of Policy Studies 1 Ed. S. Nagel.
N. ., 1994.
11. Hilsman R. et al. The Politics o f Policy Makig i
Defese and Foreig Affairs: Coceptual Models d
Bureaucratic Politics. Eglewood Cliffs, 1993.
12. Knoke D. Political Networks: The Structural Per
spective. N. ., 1990.
13. March ). Primer Decisio Makig: How Decisios
.N. ., 1994.
14. Simon . Admiistrative Behavior: Study of Deci
sio-Makig Processes i Admiistrative Orgaiza
tios. N. ., 1997.
394

Makig 11 Policy Process 1 Ed. . Hill. L., 1994.


16.

Teisman G. Models for Research ito Decisio


Makig Process: Phases, Streams d Decisio
Makig Rouds 11 Puic Admiistratio. 2000.
Vol. 78. N2 4.

v 1. . . . .,
1998. .163-176.
2. -
1 . . . .
. ., 1986. . 119-139.
3. ., ., .
. ., 1995. . 211-230.
4. Anderson J. Puic Policymakig: ltroductio.
Bosto, 1994. . 46-79.
5. Dror . Puic Policymaking Reexamined.New Brus
wick; Oxford, 1989. . 19-22,197-213.
6. Lind/om Ch., Woodhouse . The Policy-Makig
Process. Eglewood Cliffs, 1993. . 2-22.

1. :
1 . . . . .,
2000.
. .
11 . 1996. N2 3.

. '

3. . . : , ,
UJ.., 1984.
4. . . :
.

., 1988.
5.

1 . . . . , 1988.
395

>>

6.

. ., . .
:
1 1
: . .,

7.
8.

1990.

1.

. .,

t 2.

1978.

( ). .,

3.

1991. N2 1.

4.

2002.

5.

1996.

Knoke D., Pappi F., Broadbent J., Tsujinaka . Com

12.
13.

1996.

" wJ6.
v

1994.

Nafan J., 0/iver J. Foreign Policy Makig and the


American Foreign Policy System. Baltimore,

7.

. .,

2.

4.
5.
6.

110-123.

Parsons W. Puiic Policy: An lntroduction to the

1995. . 184-203.

.
-

11

: 11 .-.
. . . .,

10.

1999.

Alexander J., Oegfyarev ., Ge/ma V. Democra


tization Challenged: The Role of the Regional Elites

11 Fragmented Space in the Russian Federation 11

1993. . 73-103.

Theory and Practice of Policy Analysis. Aldershot,

396

9.

Ed. . Rue, J. Koehn, N. Popson. Baltimore; L.,

Hi/1 . The Policy Process in the Modern State. L.,

1997.

. .,. ., . .

11 :
_s 1 . . .
. ., 1999.

Lind/om Ch., Woodhouse . The Policy-Making


Process. Englewood Cliffs,

1.

1997. . 47-70, 77-81.

Boston, 1994. . 46-79.

N2

. 68-72,81-102.

Anderson J. Puic Policymaking: An lntroduction.

1992-1996 1 i Pro et contra. 1996. . 1.

/ 8. .

. .
. .,

3.

1995.

1999.

1994.

\ 1. ., ., .

1995.

. .,

4
-

. :

Lawfon ., Rose . Organization d Management in


the Puic Sector. L.,

. .,

paring Policy Networks: Labor Politics in the U. S., Ger


may and Japan. Cambridge,

1992.

. ., 1997.

Kegley Ch., Wiffkopf . America Foreign Policy:


Knoke . Policy-making in the Organizational State 11

. . .
.

( ) 11

11.

2002.

: ,

V 9. . .

Pattern and Process. N. .,

. ., . .
11

11 .

10.

1997.

. . . .,

( ). .,

2001.
11.

., Richards . The Tangled Webs of Wes


minster and Whitehall: The Discourse, Strategy and
Networking within the British Core Executive 11 Puiic
Administration. 2000. Vol. 78. N2

397

1.

>>

4. . ,

12. emberfon . Policy Networks and Policy Learning:


UK Economic Policy in the 1960s and 1970s 11 Puic

11 ,

Administration. 2000. Vol. 78. N 4.

13. Pefers G. The Politics of Bureaucracy. N. ., 1995.


14. Smith ., Richards D., Marsh D. Structured Agency
and Agents of Structure. L., 2000.
15.

Waste R. The Ecology of City Policymaking. N. .;


Oxford, 1989.

1 . . , . .
., 1999.

5. . . ., 1999.

6.

11
1

. . . . ., 2000.

. .

1 . . . :

11

2. . ., . .

. ., 1998.

. ., 1988. .19-30, 49-56.

:
. ., 1990. . 18-34.

3. ., ., .
. ., 1995. . 103-115.

?
1 . .

8. . .
ratio (
) 11
. 1995. N 5.

4. Anderson J. Puiic Policymaking: An lntroduction.


Boston, 1994. . 126-134.

9. .

5. Dror . Puic Policymaking Reexamined. New Bruns

1. Arrow . Values and Collective Decision Making 11

wick; Oxford, 1989. . 25-32, 58-69.

6. Hi/1 . The Policy Process in the Modern State. L.,


1997. .175-195.

V 7.

. ., 1957.

Philosophy, Politics and Society 1 Ed. R. Laslett.


Oxford, 1967.
11. Axelrod R. The Cognitive Mapping Approach to De

7. Parsons W. Puiic Policy: An lntroduction to the

cision-Making 11 Structure of Decision: The Cognitive

Theory and Practice of Policy Analysis. Aldershot,

Maps of Political Elites 1 Ed. R. Axelrod. N. .; Prince

1995. . 194-203.

ton, 1976.

1. . . - ,

12. lmmerguf . The Rules of the Game: The Logic of


Health Policy-Making in France, Switzerland and Swe

. ., 2002.

den 11 Structuring Politics: Historical lnstitutionalism in

, 1992.

F. Longstreth. Cambridge, 1992.

2. . .

Comparative Analysis 1 Ed. S. Steinmo, . Thelen,

3. . .
-

13. Janis 1. Victims of Groupthink: Psychological Studies of

11

14. Vertzberger . The World in Their Minds: lnfor

1 . . .

mation Processing, Cognition and Perception in For

. ., 2002.
398

Policy Decisios and Fiascoes. Boston, 1983.

eign Policy Decisionmaking. Stanford, 1990.


399

Comparing Policy Networks: Labor Politics in the U.S.,

Germany and Japan. Cambridge, 1996.

10. Ostrom . Governing the Commons: The Evolution of


lnstitutions for Collective Action. N. ., 1990.

\ 1. ., ., .

11. ' oole L. Rational Choice and the Puic Mana

: . . . ., 2000.

gement of lnterorganizational Networks 11 The State

. 531-547.
2. ., ., .

of Puiic Management 1 Ed. D. Kettl , . Milward.


Baltimore; L., 1996.

. ., 1995. . 211-248.

12. The Theory of lnstitutional Design 1 Ed. R. Goodin.

3. Allison G., Zelikow . Essence of Decision: Explaining

Cambridge, 1996.

the Cuban Missile Crisis. N. ., 1999. . 143-163.


4. Egeberg . The lmpact of Bureaucratic Structure on
7

Policy Making 11 Puic Administration. 1999. Vol. 77.


N 1. . 155-168.
5. Hanny ., Wessels W. The Monetary Committee:

Significant Though Not Typical Case 11 EU Com


mittees as lnfluential Policymakers 1 Ed. . Van Schen

V1. : . .

delen. Aldershot, 1998. . 109-126.

1 . . . . . ., 2000.

6. Lawfon ., Rose . Organization and Management in

. 31-63.
-J2. . . :

the Puic Sector. L., 1994. . 134-149 .

11 . 19'[J_.
N 3. . 5-19.

1 ./ 3. .

1 . . . . .,

2000.
2. . . .,

. ., 1996.

. 87-103.
4. Anderson J. Puiic Policymaking: An lntroduction.

1999.
3. . . -
11

Boston, 1994. . 162-178.


5. Kervin . Rulemaking: How Governmental Agencies

. 1997. N 4.

Write Law and Make Policy. Washington, 1999.

4.

. 2-6, 22-36.

1 . . . . ., 1998.
6. . : , ,
. ., 2001.

6. Lind/om Ch., Woodhouse . The Policy-Making


Process. Englewood Cliffs, 1993. . 57-72.
7. Peferson J. Playing the Transparency Game: Consul

7. Graber . Political Communication: Scope, Progress,

tation and Policy-Making in the European Commission


11 Puic Administration. 1995. Vol. 73. N 3.

Promise 1 1 Political Science: The S tate of the


Discipline. 11 1 Ed. . Finifter. Washington,1993.

. 473-492.

8. Handbook of Organizational Behavior 1 Ed. R. Golem


iewski. N. ., 1993.
9. Knoke . et al. Legislative Procedures in the Three Na

. :

V 1. . ., . ., . .
.

tions 11 Knoke D., appi F., Broadbent J., sujinaka .

., 2001.

400

401
26

>>

2. 1
.. . , . . ..,
1999.
3. . .
( ) 11
v

8
,
:

. -

1 . . . . . ., 2000.

., 2001.

. 65-78.
3. Anderson J. Puiic Policymaking: An lntroduction.

\14. :
.., 1998.
'
1 5. . . .

Boston, 1994.. 34-40, 280-290.

4. Kervin . Rulemaking: How Government Agencies

: , .

Write Law and Make Policy. Washington, 1999.


. 40-46, 75-86.
5. Parsons W. Puiic Policy: lntroduction to the
Theory and Practice of Policy Analysis. Aldershot,
1995..76-81, 357-358.
6. Wasfe R. The Ecology of City Policymaking. N. .;
Oxford, 1989. . 29-47.

, 1992.
v 6. . .
11
: 1
. . . .. 2001.
. :.
1
7. .
.., 1997.
" 8. . 11
:
1 .
..., 1991.

11 /_ pe,g.
. ':_.--, 1991. . 386-399.
2. : . .



1 . . . .

V1.

9. 1 . . .
, . . .., 1999.

.
'

. .
11 .

1995. N 9-10.

--

11 . j . ..
.., 1988.

v 12. . .
.., 1997.
13. Cassidi . EURIM Guide to Decisio Makig in the
European Union after Amsterdam. L., 1998.
14. Schr o edel J. Congress, The President, and Poli
cymaking: Historical Analysis. N. .; L., 1994.
15. Sinclair . Unortodox Lawmaking: Legislative Process
in the U. S. Congress. Washington, 1997.

402

'v 1.

11-

. 2000.25 .
2. . . -
: , , .., 2001.
3. . .
.., 2001.

\)4.


11 . 2000. N 8.

v 5.
11
: 1 g .
. . .., 1997.
6.
1 . . . .., 2001.
7.
11 . 2000. 6 .
8.
11
-2001. :
1 . . . . .., 200 1.

403


A.J 9.
..; 1 . .
. . . .,

1.
11.

1981.

. . :

: . .,

George . Strategies for Preventive Diplomacy and

16.

1.
2.

3.

4.

The Policy Cycle 1 Ed. J. , . Wildavsky. Beverly

1978.

4.
5.

404

5.
6.
7.

: . .
1 . . . . . ., 2000.

. 179-192.
.
11 1

Golub . Decision Analysis: An lntegrated Approach.


N. ., 1997. .26-39.

1996-2000 .

. . . ., 2001.
:
1996-1999 1 . . . . . .,

2000.

:
-2000 1 . . . . ., 1999.

8

2000 11

. 2000.11 .

.
11

8.

1991.

.-. . ., 1999. . 240-245, 253-256.


Anderson J. Puiic Policymaking: An lntroduction.
Boston, 1994.. 84-101.

2000.

): . . ...

18. N2 3.

. 389-403.
. ., . : 11 : 1 . . ,

Nacht . U.S. Foreign Policy Strategies 11 Washing

. . . . --,

2.

., 2002.
. ., . .

.
11 -

\13. . .

Conflict Resolution: Scholarship for Policymaking 11


PS: Political Science and Politics. 2000. Vol. 33. N2 1.

Hills,

1995.. 125-142.

. .,

1989.

ton Ouarterly. 1995.Vol.

Theory and Practice of Policy Analysis. Aldershot,

- .

2002.

14.

wick; Oxford,

,/1.

Parsons W. Puic Policy: An lntroduction to the

. .

13.

15.

, ,
11 - . 1993.N2 3.

.
11
1 .- . . . . ., 1997.
Dror . Puiic Policymaking Reexamined. New Bruns

12.

6.

1 . .. . ., 2001.
(2000-2004)


2010 1 . . . 11 .
2000. 11.

Bachrach ., Barats . Two Faces of Power 11


Power 1 Ed. 5. Luke s. Oxford; Cambridge, 1986.
1. Hi/1 . The Policy Process in the Modern State. L.,

9.

11.

1997.

Kingdon J. Agendas, Alternatives and Puic Policies.


N. ., 1984.
405

))

8. Clemen R. Making Hard Decisions: An lntroduction to


Decision Analysis. Boston, 1996.
9. Dror . Puiic Policymaking Reexamined. New Bruns
wick; Oxford, 1989.
1. Golub . Decision Analysis: An lntegrated Approach.
N. ., 1997.
11 . Policy Options for the Strategy (1997-2001): Discussion

10

1. n : . .
1 . . . . n. ., 2000.
. 78-90, 152-176.
' J 2 . . . .

Documents. Chester, 1996.

., 2000. .15-271 35-43, 178-196.

12. Russo J., Shoemaker . Decision Traps: The Ten


Barriers to Brilliant Decision-Making and How to
Overcome Them. N. ., 1989.

3. ., .
11
1 . . . .
, . . . ., 1998. . 373-398.
4. Allison G., Zelikow F. Essence of Decision: Explaining
the Cuban Missile Crisis. N. . 1999. . 13-261 109-129.
5. Anderson J. Puiic Policymaking: An lntroduction.
1

Boston, 1994. . 102-115.


6. Parsons W. Puic Policy: An lntroduction to the
Theory and Practice of Policy Analysis. Aldershot,
1995. . 445-455.

11

2. : . .
1 . . . . . ., 2000.
. 193-232.

1. :
1 . . . . .,
2000.

3. . .
:
(1982-1991 .). ., 1999. . 37-54.

. . .
-

., 1984.
3. 0
11 . .
: . .,

4. . . :
. ., 1996.
. 43-53, 104-108.
5. Anderson J. Puiic Policymaking: An lntroduction.
Boston, 1994. . 137-156.

2001.
4. . . .

6. Narcisi . Local Authority Decision Making: The Traders


of Uffizi Gallery in Florence 11 Case Studies in Puiic

., 201.
5. . . :
.
, 1998.
6.
0

11 :
. 2000. N2 11.
7. . . .
., 1996.

406

1. ., ., . V
:
. ., 1996. . 6-24.

Service Management 1 Ed. . Lawton, D. McKevitt.


Oxford, 1996. . 168-182.

1. . ., . ., . .
.
., 2000. . 4.
2. . ., . ., . .
Homo Deputatus :

. ., 2001.

407

))

3. r

.,

. ., . .

:
. ., 2002. . 7.
4. 2000

12

( ,
) 1 . . . .
. ., 2000.

3. Anderson J. Puic Policyaking: An lntroduction.


Boston, 1994.. 187-223.
4. Parsons W. Puic Policy: An lntroduction to the

5. . .
. ., 1999.
6. : -

Theory and Practice of Policy Analysis. Aldershot,


1995. . 187-223.

1 . . . . ., 2000.
7. . .

5. Pressman J., Wildavsky . lmplementation. Berkeley,


1984. . 163-180.

11
. 1990. N2 11.

6. Sabatier . op-down and Bottom-up Approaches to


lmplementation Research: Critical Analysis and
Suggested Synthesis 11 Policy Process 1 Ed. . Hill.

8.
,

'J9.

11

1 . . . . ., 2000.

. . :
1/_ !i.1995. ti2 4-6.
1. . .

11 :
. 1992. N2 1.

\... 11.

11
. 1998. N2 7.
12. 1
1
1 . . . . ., 2000.
13. . .
11 . 2001. N2 1.
14. Cleiber D., Shu/1 S. Justifying Presidential Decisions:
The Scope of Veto Messages 11 Congress & The
Presidency. 1999. Vol. 26. N2 1.
15. How Our Laws Are Made 1 Ed. . Willet. Washington,
1986.
16. Kerwin . Rulemaking: How Government Agencies
Write Law and Make Policy. Washington, 1999.

408

1. ., r ., .
. ., 1995. . 271-282, 303-322.
2. . .
. ., 1997. . 108-123.

L., 1994.. 266-289.

1. . .
11
(
). ., 2002.
2. . .
:
11

( ). ., 2002.
3. :
1 . . . . .,
2000. . 4.2.
4. . ., . .

1994-1997
11
(
). ., 2002.
5.
11
1 . . .
. ., 2000.
409

6. Parsons W. Puic Policy: An lntroduction to the


Theory and Practice of Policy Analysis. Aldershot,
1995.. 543-559,563-568,600-613.

6.
11
1 .
. . . .,2000.
7. . . n n
: . ., 2001 .

8. n n 1 . . .
. .,1988.
9. . ., . .
n : ,

11
n 1 . . . .
, . . . ., 1998.
3. . .
. ., 1996.

. ., 2000.
1. lmplement ation in Puiic Policy 1 Ed. . Younis.
Aldershot, 1990.
11. Lawfon . lmplementing Community 11 Case
Studies inPuiic Service Management 1 Ed. . Lawton,

4. ., .
11
1 . .
. . , . . . ., 1998.
5. Hermann Ch. Changing Course: When Governments
Choose to Redirect Foreign Policy 11 lnternational

D. McKevitt. Oxford, 1996.


12. Lawton ., Rose . Organization and Management in
thePuiic Sector. L., 1994.
13. Lipsky . Street-LevelBureaucracy. N. ., 1980.
14. Mazmanian 0., Sabafier P. lmplementation andPuic
Policy. Latham, 1989.
15. PefersG. ThePolitics ofBureaucracy. N. ., 1995.

Studies Ouarterly. 1990. Vol. 34. N2 3.


6. Nage/ S. SystematicPolicy Evaluation 11 Encyclopedia
ofPolicy Studies 1 Ed. S. Nagel. N. ., 1994.
7. ierson . When Effect Becomes Cause: Policy
Feedback and Political Change 11 World Politics.
1992. Vol. 45. N2 7.
8. Policy Evaluation: Linking Theory to Practice 1 Ed.
R. Rist. Aldershot, 1995.
9. Rossi ., Freeman . Evaluation: Systematic
Approach. NewburyPark, 1993.
10. Rufman L., Mowbray G. Understanding Program
Evaluation. L., 1983.

13

1. .
11
1 . .
. . , . . . .,1998. . 64-83.
2. ., ., .
. .,1985. . 249-272.
3. .
11
1 . . . .
, . . . ., 1998. . 221-244,
251-262.
4. Anderson J. Puic Policyaking: An lntroduction.
Boston, 1994.. 238-271.
5. ., McA/isfer . Policy Evaluation: lncorporating
Users Views 11Puiic Administration. 1995. Vol. 73.
N2 3.. 413-434.

410

1. . .
11
vL-
1 . . . .
. ., 1988.
2. .

14

1. . .
. ., 1997. . 164-190.
2. : . .
1 . . . . ., 2000.

. 131-152,280-299.
411

((>>

3. . . -
. . 1998. . 66-100.

13. Bachrach ., Barafs . Decisions and Non-Decisions:


An Analyical Framework// American Political Science
Review. 1963. N2 57.
14. Choafe . Agents of lnfluence: How Japan' s Lobbyists
in the United States Manipulate America' s Political and
Economic Systems. N. ., 1990.
15. DeKieffer . The Citizen' s Guide to Lobbying Con
gress. Chicago, 1997.
16. Yergin 0., Sfanislaw J. The Commanding Heights:

4.

. ., . .

11 . 1998. N2 1.

. 100-111.
5. . ., . ., . .
. .,
1999. . 214-252.
6. Hi/1 . The Policy Process in the Modern State. L.,

The Battle Between the Government and the Mar


ketplace that is Remaking the Modern World. N. .,

1997. . 196-224.

1998.

1. . :
// . 1994. N2 6.
2. . .
. ., 1993.
3. . .
// n
. . 9. ., 2000.


-
1. <CD-ROM> . .
//
1 . . .

4. . ., . .
1/
(
). ., 2002.


:
// . . .
., 1998.
3. <www.kremlin.ru> .
4. <www.government.gov.ru> .

5. . . . ., 1995.
6. . .
// . 1998.
N2 9-10.
7. . .

5. <www.duma.gov.ru>

- . ., 2000.
8. :

.
6. <www.council.gov.ru>
.
7. <www.mid.ru > .
8. <www.gov.ru> :

/ . . . . ., 2002.
9. : ,
. ., 2001.
1. :

11

1 . .
. . . ., 1997.
-
1
. . . . . ., 1997.

12. .
, . ., 2001.

412

. ., 2003.
2. <www.auditorium.ru> . .

.
9. <www.mos.ru> .
10. <www.csr.ru> .
11. <www.ilpp.ru>

.
' 12. <www.legislature.ru>
, .

413

>>

13. <www.consultant.ru> :

.
14. <www .garant.ru> :
.
15. <www.inpuma.net> lnternational Puic Management

<<>>

Network.
16. <www .nispa.sk> The Network of lnstitutes and
Schools of Puic Administration in Central and Eastern
Europe.

17. <www.appam.org> Association for Puic Policy


Analysis and Management.

18. <www .naspaa.org> National Association of Schools


of Puiic Affairs and Administration.
19. <www.ksg.harvard.edu> John F. Kennedy School of
Government Harvard University.
1

20. <www .gwu.eduj-gspm> Graduate School of


Political Management George W ashington Uni

versity.
21. <www.rand.org> Rand Corporation.

22. <www.brook.edu> Brookings lnstitution.



..

. .

. .

. .

n
:

414

. /: (095) 939-40-36
E-mail: kdu@kdu.ru