Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 764

. , . , .

n . 12-
.
n n .

10-

.
. 8-

. , .

. n. 5 -
. , . , .
, . 2-
. , .
. 5-

.
r n. 5-

.
r n n. 3-

. , .
. 4-
.
n. 3-

. , .
n . 7-
.
. 6-
. ,. , .

r . 8-
.
n n . 8-
.-.
,

MACROECONOMICS
Fifth Edition
ANDREW . ABEL
h

Wharton School of the


University of Pennsylvania

BEN S. BERNANKE
Woodrow Wilson School
of Pulic and Intemational Affairs
Princeton University
with the assistance of Dean Croushore
University of Richmond

Boston San Francisco New York


London Toronto Sydney Tokyo Singapore Madrid
Mexico City Munich Paris Town Hong Kong Montreal

MAI<POI<OHOMI<A
, I<

5-

-

Master of Busiess Admiistratio () ,


IMISP

-
--

2010

65.010.3
330.101.541

14

., .

14

. 5- . -

.: , 2010. -

768 .: . - ( <<

).

ISBN 978-5-469-01110-1
.

. ,
, ,

.
, :

1973

, ,

, ,
. ,

.
, , ,
, .

Master of Business Administration

() ,
.

no

65.010.3
330.101 .541

Pearson Education lnc.

n . n
n n.

ISBN 0-321-16212-9 ( . )
ISBN 978-5-469-01110-1

Peason Education lnc., 2005


, 2010
, 2010

000
000

14

16

1.


1.1.

25

29

25

26 1

29 1

31

34 1

31

35

1.2. ,
36 1 37
,

38 1

39

1.3. , , 41
42 1 45

46

47
Q

47

;;:

111

48

11

::.

49

tD

:r::

:s:

49

tD

53

2.1. : ,

53

2.2.

57

56 1

57

62 1

65

2.3. 68

68 1

2.4.

74

2.5.

76 1

78

82

86

83

70 1

87

89

90

88

93

2.

94

3.1.
3.2.

98

101

1 105

107




Ql

:s:
:z:
Ql
:;

111

3.3.

111

119

3.4.

115
116

108

115

10

1 , 113

ID

97

116

1 120

124

125

3.5. 130

131

? 133

134

.. :

138

143

144

145

143

148

150

152

4.1.

155

15

159

160

157

132

164

n 164

4.2.

174

n n

174

n n

187

188

4.3.

1 n 167

178

197

201

202

202

201

207

209

4. 211
n n?

211

n n? nn

n n

217

214

1
218 1

n n

225

233
5.1. 234
n

235

237

n n
n

5.2.

239

111
111

244

:::.

5.3 . 246

250

5.4. 257
5.5. 260
-

260

262

26

270
270

271

272

274

276

279
6.1.

280

282

.2. :

;;:

241

290

:1:

1 ,

291

300 1

308

.3.

310

310 1

311

313

314

314

315

31

318

320

323

7 .1. ? 323

Q.l

:s

:z:
Q.l

7 .2.

326

330

111

::

ta

324 1

331 1

332 1

331

332

333

7 .3.

333

334 1

336 1

334 1

337 1

7 .4.

335 1

339 1

340

344

345

346

7 .5. 348

351

353

354

355

355

354

357

3.

358



8.1.

? 32

361

8.2.

:
n

365

8.3.

365

365

368

367

374

383

8.4.

384

381

395

395
396

15-LM/AD-AS:

397

9.1. FE:

IS:

FE '03

LM:

404

IS 406

409

410

401

402

9.3.

388

393

9.2.

409

9.4. IS-LM 417


IS-LM:

423

111

430

AD-AS 434 1

418

IS-LM 428

429

433

AD-AS 435

437

443

443

444

447

9.

449

IS-LM 453 1

454

IS-LM

AD-AS 449

1 452

1 451

AD-AS 454 1

455

::.
:z:

;;:

Cll

LM 413

9.5. 421

9.6.

385

386

374

1 380

1 378

375

370

455

10.1.

458

458

474

469

10.2.

477

477

- n

478

478

10.3.

479

- n

493

493

:z:

494

11;
11

::"'

483
1

493

Ql

486

480

489

Ql

457

497

499

10.

n

500

AD-AS

500
n n

500

500

:
503
11.1.

504

n n
n

505

504

n n

11.2.

509

508

506
1

FE 510

512

512

11.3. - 518
- n 519 1 - 522
11.4. 526

526

1 529

534

53

538

538

539

542

544

11.
546

546 1

547

11.

4.

550

553

12.1. : ? 554
n 556 1
n n
n

12.2. 58
568

no

560

566
n

12.3. 577
578 1

565

569

575

582

586

588

588

589

588

590

01
111

592

:.

13.1.

:z:

595

59

596

1 597

13.2.

nn n

599 1

n : n
n

13.3.

599 1

602

IS-LM
IS

609

11

61

616 1

IS

618

13.4. n 19
619 1 622
13.5. 25
625 1
- n
?

642

644

635 1

630

635

:s:

44

45

48

50

1.

IS-LM

51


14.1.

655

n n

656

656

661

14.2.

658

667

667

669

662

664

674

671

676

14.3. - n : n n 679
n 682 1

685

695

99

701

702

702

701

704

705

709

15.1. : 709

709

1 712

15.2.

715

718 1

721

718

721

15.3. 726
726 1

728

732

735

15.4.

737

737

739

743

745

746

747

745

750

751

15.

. l

753

.2

.4 n
.

761

759

757

755

.3

.5.

.7 n

760

758

752

753

757

&

The Whanon School,

,
( The Whanon School)
,

Ph. D.
.

,
-

.

,
-
- , ,

;
.
,
.

,
,

.

Carnegie-Rochester Conference.

& &

Woodrow Wilson School of Pulic and Intemational Affairs,

,
-
, ,

Ph. D.

1979 . -
Stanford Graduate School of Business. 1985 .
,
1995 2002 r.

- -


, ,

60

, .

.
,

:
,

Review.
Economic
American
.
- .

>
~

"

>
)(

~-

-----~--_;,_--'

2002 .

.

, .


. ,
,

.

,

,

.

, ,

)

,
,
,
,
.

,
.

1.



, .

,

,


,

,

- .

,

.

.

,

,


8Wl iU .


(, ,

).
,

:
,

,
.

"'

5s
:1f
Q.

1::


. ,

).
( ,

-,
, .

,
-
).

. ,

.
,-


,
, .

. ,
,

.
,


,

, , ,


,

,


.
,


-

.


,
.

.1 .

,
.

, ,

( 3) ( 4).

6

,
.

1973 . ; ,
;

; .

. :

1990- .

..u1U .
. -
,

,

, . ,

; 6

;
7


; 8
;
12- ;
14

, -

r - 5 13. 5 ,

,

,

1994 . lll .
13

. -,

, .

, ,

. . . :

( 13)

,

2002 .

...::::J

.
,
. 8
,

( ).
9-11

. . :

1980-
.

Cll


( 8); , NBERl

8);
2001 . (

( 10), ,

8);

10).

- .

, .
( 14)
( 10), ( 11)

2002

. (

4);

2001

. (

4);

,
,

1980- rr. ( 8),


2001 . ( 14).

:s:

"'

<:;

:s:
q
w

Q.

r:::

,
.

, .


( 3).

12,

( 11 ),

( 12)
(

15).

. :

( 10),

12).

.
,
, ,
.

1-2)
(

.
,

( 3-7)
,


.
, , ,
(

8- 11 )

. ,

( 12- 15)


.
.

. ,

.



.

. ,

1. .
2.

3. , .
4. , .
7. , .
9. IS-LM/AD-AS:

1 2

: 3

, 3 4
,
7 , 9

,

( ,
) .

. ,


.

:

56

"

:s;

, 1
. ,
(
),

::::J
m

];:>

.
1 2
8 9,

IS-LM/AD-AS. 8 9

, , 3-7,

, : .
,

,
II.
8-10 III

. ,

- ( 12),

- (
( 15).

14)

, .
,
-

::,

"'

:s;

10

) . ,

5 (
)

6 (

) .

, . 5
,
. 13

, ,

( 5 ,
13).
,
.

ID

5s

::[

Q.

,
, .
,

, ,

, .

, , ,
"> , .

. :;
,

. , ,
:
( 3);
.
( 4); 2001

( 4);
( 5); ( 10);
( 13);
( 14);
( 15).

.
- ,

. :

( 2);
( 4);
(

7);

12);
13);

(
( 15).

, ,
.

, ,
, ( 3),
( 5), ( 8),
.

. ,
, ,

, .

(, AD-AS)
,

, , ,

.
,

,
,

.

, ,
;

.
;
,
;
,

,
,

FRED
- ,
, .

( ,
)
.

, ,


, . ,
,
,

, ,
.

::::1

"m

]::>

"'::,
"'m"'
(')

1
1

1.1.



, ,

.
,

1i I
?
1870 .
,
.

,

,


?

1
?

1980- .
1990- .
1991 .
1,5%
, r

1994 .
, 1990- .,
.

,

?

1t ? 1930-
.

. ,

,
2%
.
?



?

?
i
1970- .
10% 1980- .,
4%
1990- .

1922-

1923

.)


!
?

,

r.
, ? 1990-
.


,
,
,


, ,

,
,

.
? 1980- 1990-


, ,
1960- 1970- r.

, ,

"

:J:

c:t

"'

:!

...
.

......
111
7


,
?

,


.
.



- ,

,
. ,

,


. 1.1
130

1
;

1869 .



,
.

1.1,
()
n;

n (), n
n n

1 n, n .

2.

ti..:

10

i""

8.~

ct"'

2001 .

1':1:1:
1=

1D
::1:1:

'0:
'St
>:1
]
:1:

1990-1991

1981 - 1982

7
.

:;

1973- 1975 . \

1941-1945

1917-191 8

0 ~~~~==~~~~~--~~~~

1870 1880 1890 1900 1910 1920 1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980
1990 2000

()

1930-2002 .
()
1930 .;

1.1

1869-2002 rr.

1996 . (. 2).


,

(19291940),
(1941 - 1945) 1973- 1975, 1981- 1982, 1990- 1991 2002 .
: 1869-1929 rr. .:
. .
: ,
1869- 1908 11 Journal of Political Economy. 1997.
1 ( 1989). . 22- 23; 1930-2002 1. .: FRED,

- , research.stlouisfed.org/fred/series/ GDPCA
. 1996 r.

tD

"'m
J::>
m
,.m
J:



, ,
.

, .

,

. ,

,

,
.
. 1.2 ,
,

, 1900 . 2002 .


,
. (
).

,
,

"'
"'
w
"'
,.
:

:1>

"

J:

"''<

1'11

11

..

t-"'CO
u:s:m

65

ct::Ec
11 :z: 1(

.-

1'1 1'11

60

:s: "' :z:

OI'I

Cl.ll:t

COII
:

70

.. .

55

~U

50

oi~

45

~110]
>:S: 1'1
]

:z: ..

40

:;

35

..,

30

:z:

1970 -

rr.

25

1950-1960

rr.

20
15
10

:s:
I

c:t

1900

"'

1910

1920

1930

1940

1950

1960

1970

1980

1990

!!)

2000

)
,
,

.
1950- 1960- rr., -

. , .

1900-2002

1.1.

14 (1900- 1947) 16 (1948-2002)


1970 .
1900- 1969 . //
2003, -36;
. 126- 127; 1970-1990 . .: ,
LNU02, data.is.gov / servlet/
2000 - 2002 . . : w- ,

SurveyOutputServlet. - ,
1.1.
, n .
:


1970- 1990- .
2,5% 1949
.
,
1973 . 1,0% 1973 1995 .

.,
1995 2002
.
1,9%,

,

,

,
. ,

,
.
-
,

,
,

. ,
,

,

.
,

,
,
,


,
,
. 1.1, ,

,
.

1929 1945 . ,

. 1929-19 33 rr.

,
,

30%.

1939-19 44 rr.,

,
. 1945 .
,
1929-1945 rr.


, 1960- rr., ,

,
1991 .

1973- 1975, 1981-19 82

1990-

~. 1 ,

,
,

, .

,

,
,

.
,

,
,

, .

,

OJ

"'m

:s:

"'

:
)>

"'
"'

."

(J)

,

,
,

,
.


.


,

1
8.

, n
,

n .

:s:

"'"'

,
(

1.3
) . .

.



. .
24,9%,

1930- rr. 1933 .


.


. 1944 .
1,2%.

rr.
1982
1981

.1 ,

10,8%.

1.3. 2000 .,
, .

4%.

s:

:I:

"'

[!)

- ->
~]:s

~~i

ou~
10 >:S
01;

Q,O'(,)
.,

10

LQI'II:z:

Q.

si

..5!

~=

:i

(,)

:s

28

26

24

22
20
18

2001

1890- .

1990-1991

1981-1982

16

14

12

197-1975 \.

10
8
6
4
2

1890 1900

1910 1920

1930 1940 1950 1960

1990 2000

1970 1980



.
1890- 1930- rr. ,

1.3


, 1890-2002 .

1920 .
.

1973- 1975

1981 - 1982 rr.

14 - 1947 r. 16 -
: (

rr.
1970
1890
r.)
1947

, 2003, -42.
1970- rr. . 15; 1971- 2002 rr. .:

11

1 10,8% 1982 . ,

. 1.3, ,
. 1982 .
12

9,7%.

, ,

, ,
. 1.4

. 1 ,
1812 .,
.
,
.

,
. ,
(1918 .)
, 1800 ., .

1929- 1933 rr., . ,
, ,

1990- .

XXI

1.4 ,

10 .

, ,

. , ,
10%, , ,
, 10%.
, ,
1- 2% (, )
1000% (,
1990- rr.),

.
, ,

. ,
,
.



, . . ,
. (
.) ,

, 1
(CPI)
2. , CPI
( ).
,
, . ,
, , ,

1.4,

, ,

, .

;;;'
111
111
111

...
OJ

"'m
1:>
m
::t

"'m
"'
>
"'
"'
::t
::

."

\j)

::

"'"''<

::i..:g 180
~~

..."

170
160
u "i li:
.AN 150
0:::: s
01 Q.
1-,.. 140
~~
130

..
120
~8.
110
~>
100
~
90
s
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10

)(
~ 01 1'1

:1:

1917-1918

1861-1865

1812r.

\1


n
1929-1933 .

1860

1880

<::I

1800

"'

1820

1840

1900

1920

1940

1960

1980

...
.

1-

':

, ( )
( ).

111

2000

1800-2002 rr.


. . 1.4 -

, (CPI) (.
2). CPI ()
r
( - 1982-1984 .). , CPI, 179,90

2003 ., , , $100 19821984 ., 2003 r. $179,90.

: 1800- 1970 rr. (1967 . = 100) //


1970 . . 210-211; 1970-2002 rr. (19821984 rr. = 100) .: , 2003, - 60. 1971 .

1982- 1984 rr.,

100.

,
,

.

,
, - . . 1.5

. ,
; ,
,

. ,
. 1.5
.
, 1950- 1960- .,

- ~

l;,:~:z:
~

18

...

: 10

:S ID

se~

t-ID

a.;t-

10


1980-, 1990-
2000- .

t; 17

::!:

fioo

: 1- ID
(1)01'1

~~

Q.

16
15

14

13
12
11
10

9
8
7
6
5

4
3
2
1

1870 1880 1890 1900 1910 1920 1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000

(
) ( ),

1.5

n n ,

1869-2002

: -

( )
. 1980-, 1990- 2000- .,

( ).
: n n

1869-1959 rr. //
. 864-865; 1960-2002 rr.- w-
1 ; n: 1869-1928 rr. .:

1970 r.

, , .
. . :
, 1869-1908// Journal of Political Economy. 1997. 1 ( 1989). . 22-23; 19292002 . () .: w- .

. , , ,

:r
:s:
m

"'
""
"":r
:

)>

."

IJ}

1.5 ,

. ,

,
,

. , ,

. 1980- r., ,
, 1990-

2000- r., .

o:J

"'mm

1.5.

, ,
.

?
? ,
, .

:s:

""
'<

, (
), ,
, . ,
,
, .


.
: - . ,
,

, .
-

:I:

:[

"'

...
....11

:r
"'""

(Federal Reseve System, Fed).



.
, 1990- .,
,

$400 2003 .

1.6,

. 1 ,
, ,

. 1.6-
,
. ,

43%

.
1930- .,
, ,

,

,

1940 .
1980-,
1990- .
, .

1980- .

(. .

1.5).

,
4 .

? , , ?

,
.


:
1

(, , ),

, .

I'I

:z: 50

111,1'1

\1) ~

~~111

: i:

45

~,gt; 40
[~
.. 111
> "'

g~ ~

-.
11<

35

] :s:
:z: :z:
:z:

30

1!!~

25

lig

20

"=

1980-,
1990- .

8_u

>'
u

15

10

1998-2001

5
0~--~--~--~--L---L---L-~--~--~--~--~---L---L

1870 1880 1890 1900 1910 1920 1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000

(
) ( )


. (
) ,

1.6


nn

1869-2002

)- . -

.
, ,
1980- 1990- .
: 1869-1929 . 11
1970 . . 1104; 1930 . .: ,
, . 1.2; : 1869-1928 . .: .
. : , 18691908 11 Journal of Political Economy. 1997. 1 ( 1989). . 22-23; 1929-2003 . ()
.: w- .

.
, , ,

,
. ,
, ,
,

,
.

;
, .

,
, , -

"'m

::t

"'
>
"'
:

"

UJ

"'

::t

"'"'

.
, ,
,
. , ,

VCR-

DVD-, , .

,
, .

.
,

, , ,
,
. 1

1.2.

:s:
I

ct

I,

"'

, ,
,

?
, ,
, , ,
.


,
, . ,
,

,
. ,
,

(
), r

.
!
,
, :

?
- (
)? ,
?

, 1900-

2000- .,

?~ 1

rr

~.

,
. ,
,
.

,

, ?
, . , ,

, (
?),

(
,

).
, , -
. ,
,

.
, , -
,
( ), (
).


,
,
. ,
, . ,

, ,
. .
,
.

,
,
,
.
, ,

,
.
, -

,
, ,

.
.

,
, .

, ,
,
? , , . -
,

:;;'
01

111

01

...
o:J

"'m

]::!

m
:1:

:s:

"'
>
"'
"'"'
:

."

:1:

:s:

"'"'

. ,
, ,
.

,
, . 1990- .

,

. 2002 .

,
.
,
,
w
:s;
:J:

"'

:!

, , ,
, .
1990- ., , ,

.
,

, .



:
, ,
.

, .

, ,
, ,


.
? ,
, ,


. . ,

,
.
,

.
, , ,

? ,

,
r,

, -.~ .

, (,

,
) (
).

,
, . ,

(, )
(,

).
.

? ,

. -

, .
,


. ,
.

1.
2.

3.


? ,
?

4.

( , )
-..

o:J

"'m
1::>
m
I

:s:

"'
:1>
""
""
:


1.1.

""

\J)

.
, ,
.
,

.
2. , ,
,

, ,
.

:s:

""'<

1.1


n n n , n
n, , ,
, .
, , n,

t .

, .
. .

.. n ?
. n n,
. n
( )

.
.. .
, ,
, .

:s:
I
w

<::[

"'

!)

....
.

11.1

"'

'j'

. .
.. , ,

.. n n: 1) ; 2)
; 3) . n
, n, , n
.

. .

n , ,
.

u..

n , ,
.
t.t ,
, 2- 5.
..
: , ( )
.

, ,

3-5.

..

, ,
n .

n, ,

, ,
, ,

, .

. , ,

r, ,
. ,

~ , -

,
.

, ,
,
.
, ,
. ,
,
, 4, 4~.
. ,

, -
. -
, ,
, _!

1.3.

,
,

, ,
. ,
,
, -, ,


. , ,
?2


. ,
,
,

;;;'
111
Cll

111

...


, .
,
, , ,
.

,
,

,
, .
,

1
,
, .: . . ,
: 11 journal of Economic

Perspectives. 1990 ().


2

3-12.

, ,

, .
, , ,

: ...

...

tD

"'

)::J

m
I

:s:

"'
>
"
:

(j)

"I

:s:

"'<

. ,
5%,

.
,
, ,

, .

-
, - - .
, :

,
, ( ).
~!> -~!> , ,
, (
).

:s

, ,
, .
,

:[

.
, .

"'

[Q

...
....D

"'

,
.

1776 .

~ !>, .

,
,
. . ,

.
. .

, , ,
;
,
.
, , .
.
, (, ,
)

,
.


: , ,

, ,
,
. ,
, . ,
, ,

. ,
, ,
.


,
,
. , , -

.
.
,
.

.
, . .
, ,

,
.

. ,
, ,
. ,
,


, .

, ,
( ),

;;'
111

111

...
111

o:J

"'

:
m

:s:

,
, .
, ,
,
.

.
. ,

, ~ , ~

1936 . , 160 ~
1936 .

~ .

.
,
. ,
,
. .
. . ,

. -

:I:

"'
"'
"'
:
)>
"

UJ

:I:

:s:

"''<

,
. ,


, . . ,

.
,

, .

,
, ,
, ,

.1

. . :
,
. . . ,

, ,
,
. , . . ,

<:t

"'

a::J

...
....11

v
ra


, ,
. ,

.

,
1970- . .


,
,
. , ,
.

1970- .

, ,
( ) .
,
. ,

,
,

,

. ,

1970- .
, ,
,
.
1 .
. ,
, ~ .
, ,



. , ,

.
,
, .


, ,

.
- ,
. ,
,

.
, ,

,
, .
,

, .

, ,
, , ,
,

, (
). ,
,
:

1.

,
, .
. ,
,

: , ( n

, , )
. , n
,
.

2.


.
, .

, ,
<

( 1.1,
,
).

.


,
, ,

"'m

J::>
m
:t
:s:
m

"'
"'
w
"'
:t
:
)>

."

:s:

"''<

, ,
, ,
.

3.


, , ,

, .


'! ,

3-7)

,
(

8-13).

4.
,

s
:
w
o::t
w

.
,

!!)

, .

1.


, , ,

.
,

, , ,
, .

2.

'!

, , ,
, ,

, .

r
.

3.

, ,

, ( ) r
, , ,

, .

4.


.
r ,
, . .
,
, .

, ,
, ,

5.


,
.
,

. r -

,
, -
.

6.

;

.


,
.

7.


.
, -

. ,
,
, ,
.

:;;'

]::>

::t

111
111

111

...

"'mm
:s:

"'
>
"'
"'::t
:

."


1.

2.

?
? ?

3.

4.

?
?

Ul

:s:

"'
'<

5.

.
?

1970 . ?

6.

1900

,
.

7.
? ?

8.

?
.

9.
w

:s:
:r
w
c:t

.
?

10.

?
?


1.

2002-2003

2002 r.
12000
1000
100
1100
2 1

2003 r.
14300
11 00
5

1150
2,5 1

,
, .

,
:

2002

2003

.;

)
2002 . );

2002

2003

(2003 .

.;

2002 . ) .
2. ,
NIPA~. . 1.1 <<
(2003

( ) , . .

3.2

() .

(www.bea.doc.gov):

) ,
,
.
;

,

.

1.

?
?

2.

2003 .

1890 .

3.

4.

1890

.? ( ), ?

,
,
, . ?

,
)

;
) ;
)

)
.

5.

2002

. ,

, .
,

. .
, ,

.

?
?

, ,

FRED -,
: research.stlouisfed.org/ fred

~
111

111

111

...
OJ
m

"'

:r

"'m

"'
:

>

""
"
:r

UJ

""'

'<

1.


1950-, 1960, 1970, 1980 1990- . ( ).

?
,

(1 + g)lO = 1 + G,
g- ,
(, 0,05 5%), G- (
,

).
G

w
s
w
:!
w

:t:

"'

...

g,

)
2000- .

2.

1-

"'

:r


1961 . .
1969-1970, 1973-1975, 1980,

1981-1982 1990-1991 .? ,
2001 . .
1990- .
1960-, 1970- 1980- .?

3.

(CPI)

( ,
) 1948 .

?
(. . )?

, , ,
.

. , ,

( ,
) ,
(
), ,

,
. , ,
,

, , ,
.

, .

,
.

,
, .
,

.

2.1.

:

,

. (
, . ~
: .)
,

1)

, ,
(
);

2)
3)

,
( );

,
( ).

.
,

, , (
)

:1:

:[

"'

[Q

. , :
juicelnc.

Orangelnc

Orangelnc

. ,

]i!, .

Orangelnc

n, n

Orangefnc

$15000
5000
35000
10000
25000

Juicefnc

$10000
2000
25000
40000

, n
, n n

Orangefnc
Orangefnc Juicelnc

Juicelnc

n,
,

n n

Orangefnc

, n n n

Orangelnc $15 000


,
$35 000 ($10 000 , $25 000 ji!). , Orangelnc
$35 000- $15 000 = $20 000. Orangelnc $5000
, $15 000.
juicelnc $25 000 Orangelnc
$10 000
. $40 000, ,
$5000 ($40 000- $25 000- $10 000).
$2000 $3000.

?
: ,

, .

(National Income and Product Accounts, NIPA).


,
. 1930-1940- . ,

.

1909

1929 .,


(Bureau of Economic Analysis,
) , .

,
, ,
.

estimates)

( advance~

- .

( p reliminary ~ estimates)

( final ~ figures) - .
, .
~

2.3

2001

~.

NIP

, ~survey

of Current Business (
Business Statistics~ ( , ),
Economic Report of the President,
. NIPA
) ,

, n
. - www.bea.doc.gov
.

NIPA -
research.stlouisfed.orgjfred.

(Organization

for Ecoomic Cooperation and Development, OECD) National Accounts~,


(International Monetary Fund, IMF) World Economic
Outlook ~ National Accounts Statistics~.

;;;'
111

Cll

111
N

..,Q
'<

..,~
1. iII

, ,

.

,

)>

I
)>

J:;.

:s:

)>

::;,

r:r
I

:S:<

\JJ

"'

:s:

:s:

"'

Orangelnc
$35 000, }i!- $40 000.

$35 000 $40 000 .

,
: ajuicelnc

$25 000

$40 000,
$15 000 ($40 000 - $25 000). Orangelnc -

, ,

$35 000. ,
:

2.

$35 000 + $15 000 =$50 000.

. ,

Orangelnc
$35 000 $15 000,
$20 000. ]i!

w
:s:
:I:

$40 000,
$25 000 $10 000,
$5000. $20 000 Orangelnc, $5000 ]i!
$25 000 , ,
$50 000, . . ,
.

<:I
w

"'

. ,

/)

...
...
.

\,1

111

, .
, Orangelnc $15 000,
a]uicelnc- $3000.
, $18 000, $25 000
(, ) $7000
, $50 000, . .
.

3.

.
. ]i!

, ( )
. ,

Orangelnc $1 000 ]i! $40 000,


$50 000, . . ,
. 1

, ,
, . ,
.

, , -,
,
,

. ]il
1

( ),

, .

$40 000 ,
.
,
( ) (
)

. 1
-, , , ,
, .
, ,

, , , ,
.
,
. ,
, ,

.

:

= =

(2.1)

, (
, ).
2.1
.
( - ,
.) 2.2 ,

.

2.2.

;;'
111
111
111
N

() . . 2.1,
,
. ,

, , .


()
,

,
, .
, .
- , ?

-.

, ,
.
, .

"'

:I:

:s:
:s:

"'

.
, . . .
,
. , ,

,
7 100 .
107.
,

. ,
$ 10 000, - $60.
,
, $70 000
(7 $ 10 000), , $6000 (100 $60).
,
$70 000 + $6000 = $76 000.
,

:s:

:I:

c:t

"'

CQ

...
.D

...

1.1

"'

:r

.
, .
-

. 1
,
, , ,

(
) .
,

( )

( .

2.1).

. ,

.
, ~

(,
), , ,
( ) . ,

, , , ,

~, <<~,
,
, . ,

, , ,
, , .
,
.

. .,
Survey of Current Business.
.: .

11

1985

() . .

24- 48.

. 1
,
, , ,

, ,
. ,
,
,
. ,

.

: ,

. .
,
. .
.


, .

,
.
, ,

, . (
, , . )
,

, , .

. ,
,
. ,

, . , ,
, ,
. ,

, .
,

. , , ,
, -

()

-1
'<

."

";:;!

."

>

::t

>

]:::

"'

::t

>
:::,

::t

. , ,
, ?
,

, .
1
NIPA .:
: // Survey of Current Business. 1984 (/).
,

, . : . : ,
1930-1980 rr. / / IMF Staff Papers. 1983 (). . 283-305.

cr

"''
"
IJ)

::t

""'"'

2.1


- , , (, ),
, .



. .

1.

.
, ,


. ,

.

:s:
:I:

:[

"'

tQ

2.

.
, : $100

, 10%
, , $90 .
,

$90

($100,

), 1

- , .


. ,
,

. , ,
,
,

. ,

, ,
.

,

- .

, ( ,
) .

.
, .
- , (
, ) . -

, .

, .
,

.

( ).

, , , ,

. 1 , ,

$1000, $1100.

$100, .

, . 2
,

Orangelnc

]uicelnc ,


(
) .

, ,
,

.
, , , ,
,

111
1111

111
N

()

, (

."

),

Orangelnc

]i!.

-i

'<

"';;!

. ,

."

,
,

:J:

1991

() , . 1991 .
,
,
.

,
.
-
,
1

r,

tiaK .
2

- () ,

, .

.

)>

)>

.r:::
s

:J:
)>
~
<

:J:

S<

()
( ,
).

.
, , ,
. , , ,
,

,
, . ,
,

( ), (
, ).

, , ,
,

"'

:J:

:[

, .

(NFP)

"'

,
, ,

...

...
.

. ,

1'11

GDP = GNP - NFP.

(2.2)


. , 2002 .

$10 446 ,

$10 437

, . .

, , 1%. , , ,
, ,

.
, ,
, .



.

.

: , ,
, .

:
=

GDP = ;
=
=

;
;

- ;

IG-

;
;

NX-

,
:

Y=C+l+G+NX.

(2.3)

2.3, 2.1,
. 2.3 -
, , + I + G + NX.

2002

. .

2.1.

2.1.

n ()

(NX)

() ()

(G)

2002

'!

7303,7
871 ,9
2115,0
4316,8
1593,2
1117,4
269,3
848,1
471,9
3,9
1972,9
693,7
447,4
246,3
1279,2
-423,6
1014,9
1438,5
10446,2

69,9
8,3
20,2
41 ,3
15,3
10,7
2,6
8,1
4,5
0,0
18,9
6,6
4,3
2,4

12,2
-4,1
9,7
13,8
100,0

: - .

: w- , www.ea.doc.gov, .

;'
111
111
111
N

1.1, 28 2003 .

. -
, ,

. 1 ,
2/3 .
:

1)

,
, , ( ,
) ;

2)

,
, , , ;

3)

, , ,
.

.
( ) , 1

n, n

nn , n .

1.1)

"'
::t

::

:s:
:s:

"'

( ).
:

1)

,
(, , ,
) (, ,
, ), ;

2)

,
.

,
() .

,
, .
1/ 6 .
,
. ,

:s:
:I:

<:[

"'

[()

, ,
.

.
,
. , ,
>.> .
.

,

, - .


1/ 5 . , , . 2.1,


, .
, ,
.

, ,
. . (
) - .

.

.



(, ) , -
(, ).

1996 .

(,

)
. -
$300 , 1/ 5
. ,

<, ,

I.


, .
. -
1, - ,

, , ,
.

,
( ) ,

. ,
,
.
(+ I + G + NX) ,
, . ,

,
. ,

.

, ,

, , .
.

- (.

1.

2.2

2002

. ).

.. (
), ,

, (
), .

2.2,
, 2002 .

2.

57%

. 1

.1-1 .
( ).
(,
),

,
. 2002 .

3.

7%.

. ,
, ,
.


. , ,

, .

U>

"'

::1:

:s:
:s:

"'

2.2.

2002



:
rn ( pyrne )

: (NNP)

: (GNP)
, -

: (GDP)

'l

5977
757
142
787
684
8348
695
9043
1394
10437
278
288
10446

57,2
7,2
1,4
7,5
6,5
79,9
6,7
86,6
13,3
99,9
2,7
2,8
100,0

: - .

: w- , www.ea.doc.gov, .

1.9, 28 2003

, n .
2002 . 1,4% . 1

4.

...
....D

. , , . .
, ,
.
, ,
.

1\1

,
, . (7,5% 2002 .),
.

5.

. ,

,
.

25

5 8%

;
;

, ,
.


, ,
, .

( ), .

2.2. 2

1
,
, . .

,
, .

2
,

. .

( ) -
, ,

.1 (
,
) () .


.
() .

,
.
, ,
- (. 2.2).
, . 2.2,

.
.
,

. , , ,
(
), - ,
,
. ,

,
, .

, ,
,

. , ,
,
, ,

, .

= + NFP + TR

+ IN-

(2.4)

- (), . .
, ; NFP-
- ; TR - ,
; IN- ; - .
2.4,
, ()

( - ),
2

"'<
~

"

)>

::t
)>

.r::
s

::t

"

::t

S<

(
) , .

, .
, ,
(n ) n
, ero n n
. n, n, n -

n .
2

, , n ,

(GDP + NFP) = GNP.

IJJ

"'

::t

"'s

(
):

2.4

2.5,

TR -

IN.

(2.5)

. .

, +

NFP,

. .

2.3.

.
, ,
,

w
:s:
w

"'

Cl)

...
...v
.

"'

'3'

. , ,
, $1 , ,
,
, ,
.
,

( ), ( ).
m () .
,
,

.
m.
, ,
: , -
, , ,
2% .
,
, .
.

, .
.
, ,
.



.
()
.

: ,
. . 1
.

. ,
,
.

2.4,

spvt = -
= (+ NFP- + TR + IN) - ,

(2 .6)

1.

(+
:

S".,= (+ NFPS!I'= (-

TR + IN7)-

TR-IN7)- G.

S= S".,+ S!I'=

NFP}

NFP- - G

Spvt - .
, ,

. , ,
,
,

.

. 1

(NIP )

1996 .

. 1996 .
(. 2.5)
.
Sgovt ,
i:
sgovt = -
=(- TR - IN) - G.

= (2. 7)

2. 7 G
.

01
111
01
N

(")

-1

."

'<

, ,
;
() ,

, .

NIP

1996 .

( ),

2

( ). -

."

>
I

>
.r=

:s;

<

"''w
"'

,
,
.
.
. , , ,
1

, .

.
2

.

:s;

"':s;

.
,

$300 ; . 1

, , ,

. , , , ,
, ,

.
,

, 2.7.
, , ,
,

:s;
:I:

<:[

"'

:!

...
.

...

1.1

"'

:r

,
.

.

.
G, TR
IN.
- (G + TR + IN), , 2.7, ,

.
.
. ,
,

.
S:

S = Sp<t + Sgort =

2.8

(+

NFP-

=+

2.6 2.7,

TR + IN- ) + (- TR NFP- - G.

IN -

G) = ( 2 8)
.

, '

+ NFP ( )
(

G).


?
,

,
.

1 ,
n

~ 1 11
,
111 .

,
, , -, -

2.3)
2.8) + I + G + NX:

S=

+ I + G + NX) + NFP -

G.

(2.9)

S= I + (NX + NFP).
(

2.9)


- . 1 , -

NX + NFP,

, (
), ,

2.9,

NX + NFP

(2.10)

S=I + .

spvt" 2.8 , spvt


Sgovc
, Sgovt 2.10,

Spvt = I + ( -Sgovt)

-Sgovt -

+,

(2.11)

2.11

, . ,
:

(J).
,

1)

2)

(- Sgoot).
(. . S

),

"'

( ) , ;

3)

."
)>

:r

() . ,

L:

, .
,

- , ,
, , .
-

::;,

,
, 1980-, 1990- 2000- .,
1

-1
'<

, ,

( . 5).
.

)>

:s:

:r
)>

cr
:r

:S:<

"'

:r

:s:
:s:

"'

- ,

. ,

.

,
. 1

(NBER),

:s:
::t:

<:[

"'

CQ

2001

2001

, , ,
. 2

2000

.,

NBER

2001

. , ,

. ,
11 2001 . , .
, 11 ,
0,6 ,
.
, ,
, 1,9%

2001

( )


.
( <<advance!> estiates) .

( preliinary!> estiates)
, ( final!> figures) -
.
2001 r. 30 2002 . ,
. ,
,
2001 . 0,2% . ,

( ),

5,4%,

9,2%.

38,4%!

1

5.
2
, , . 8.


,
,

.
,
, . ,
23,7%
.

28

2002

.,

, :
, 2001 .

1,4%. ,
1 , 2%- ,
.

, ,
.

28 2002 .
, ,
2001 . 1,7%.
, 0,3%-
. ,

2001

,
.

2001

, ,

.
2001 . , , ,

2001

NBER,

.
, NBER
, , ,

. , ,

2001

..,

(")
."

'<

"':.!
."
)>

I
)>

, .

J::

, ,

:s:

)>

, 5,1%
2001 ., ,

. 1
, NBER . ,

"'


, , ,
2001 .!

NBER

,
.

,
. .

2002

:::.

"

:S:

:s:
:s:

"'

.
2001 . :
n

2002 .

2002 .

2001

1- .

2- .

3- .

4- .

1,3
-0,6

0,3

-1,3
-0,3

1,7
2,7

-1,6

2002 .,
2001 .
. 2003 . NBER
, 2001 .

NBER ,

3
,

.
.
, ,
.

.-4

...
.

\,1

1\1

:r

. ,
, ,
, (,

). ,
. ,

, iI, .
,

, ,
. :

15 ,
1 2004 .

.
, .
.
( )
. (
) ; (
) . (
) .

.
,

. ,
,- (
, )
(, ).
(, )

.
(,

), ,
.

. -
. :

1)

, ,

, 1

2)

,
, ) (
,
).

,
,
.

, ,

,
. ,
- , , JTO .

- (
)
.


. -,

, . ,
1990- .

. ,
,

.
-
.
,

.

()
-i

S=I+

"'<

2.10.

: 1)
I
2)

, ().
,
,

. , ,

. , ,
,
.
1

, .

, , -
.

"';;!
"

)>

::t:
)>

.r=

"'

::t:

s;
r:

::t:

"''

"'

::t:

"'
"'"'


?
-
.

, . 1
, .
S = I + , , , I ,

S,
. ,


1980- rr.
, , ,
,
.

2.4. ,

"'w
::

r::t
w

"'

, ,

- .
.
,

:r

.-4
.

...

"'

- , , .
, ,

, ,

, . ,
,


, .



,
. , . 2.3,
(
: ). .

$46 000 (5

$1200

200 $200 ). 2 $66 000


(10 $600 250 $240 ),
43,5% 1. 43,5%-
, 43,5%
1
,
,
t. ., .:

Business Economics. 1992 (). . 42-46.

11

2.3.

1 ()

2 ()

1,%

5
200

10
250

+100
+25

$1200/
$200/

$600/ n
$240/

-50
+20

$6000
$40000
$46000

$6000
$60000
$66000

+50
+43,5

n
n

n
n

43,5%

, .


43,5%?

$200 ),

1.

2 (10

($1200

250 )
$62 000, . 2.4. $62 000 - 2,
1.

, ,
.
. ,

, , -

2.4.

( )

(")
-i

."

"'"';;!

200

$6000
$40000
$46000
$12000
$50000
$62000

$1200
$200

10
250

$1200
$200

(-

5
200

2)

10
250

=>

<

$3000
$48000
$51000

$6000
$60000
$66000

$600
$240

$600
$240

= ($66 000- $51 000)/$51 000 = 29,4%

)>

"'

2
n

)>

.t:

1
n

."
)>

S<

= ($62 000- $46 000)/ $46 000 = 34,8%

111

111
N

(- 1)
n

111

s
s

"'

,
. , ,


. 2 $66 000;
, (. . 2) .
1?
1 ($1200 $200 )

.
5 200 $46 000.

1, .
,
; ,
.
,
.

:s:

:I:

r:t

"'

2 1.

$62 000,

1 - $46 000,

, , 34,8%

1.


, ,

.
, .

. -
,
, ,

= /( / 100).

100)- ,

( , )
.

, ,

=

1 (

100

/ .

, 100.
, 100.

2 $66 000 (. . 2.3),


$62 000 (. . 2.4) , 2 : 100
$66 000/ $62 000 = 106,5, . . 6,5% , 1.

, ,
, 2 6,5% , 1.


. 2.2 ,
,
.

&

2.2

,
.
1980- 1990- rr.,*
10%.t

.
, ,
. 2.3 2.4,
. ,
1 34,8% 2
1. , . 2.4
,

2. 2 ,
1. ,
$600, - $240.
5 200 , 1, $51 000.
n 2 , n
, ,

$66 000. , 2, ,
n $51 000 1 $66 000 2, 29,4%.
. 1
34,8%, n 2 -
29,4%. ?
2 1 100% ( 5 10),
- 25% ( 200 250). n

34,8% n 1 29,4% n
2 - n
. -
. 1, n
1 , n

, n.

;;'
01
111
01

n n,
2.
n~?
, n .
, 1996 .
.
n n n 1 2

n - ,
n 1 , n ,
2 . (
32,1%, n n

11

27-41.

n n . 1 : . .
Brooki11g Paper
n n n: ?

11

Economic Actiuity. 1994 (2).

273-317.

n . : . :

n // -: -. 1995 (

), : NIPA w- : www.bea.doc.gov/

bea/anjnipaguid.htm

"'

::I:

.: . .
Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City Economic Review. 1998 (
?
). .

Ul

.)*

s
s

"'

n n
, n 1987 .

, ,

. , n ,
.

.
.

.
. -

= +

1 + G + NX

. , n
, -

w
:s:

c:t
w

CD

!!)


. ,
,
? 1987 .

n 1994 .,
5,1%.
- 4,0%.

, 3/ 5
.

. 36 .
:
1 r >, Survey of Current Business, 1995 . . 31 - 38.

.
, .
(CPI) .
, ,

CPI
CPI,

,
, , , . CPI


,
100.

,
, .
1982-1984 ., n

100
1982 1984 . , CPI 2003 . 185, ,
85% , 1982-

1984 .
, CPI, -
, (
1993- 1995 .)

. ,

&

2.3

?
1995-1996 rr. ,

,

. , ,

CPI,
1 - 2%-
. ,
3%
, 12% .
CPI n
?

. ,

, 10%

, 10%

: 10% ,
10%-

.

, 10%- ,

.

,
( )
.
,

24 ? , CPI

.

.

, CPI

, .
,


. -

,

.


, ,

-
;


.
CPI,

,
,
. CPI
,
. ,
CPI


,
( )

.

- .

, . -,

, , n
,

(
) .
CPI (
)

. -
, r
CPI.
,

, CPI. ,
CPI,
,

. ,

()

..,....
'<

..,"''<

....

)>

:r
)>
.t=

:s:

:r
)>
:::>
<
:r

:S:<

UJ

"'

:r

:s:
:s:

"'


, CPI, ,
.

CPI.


.
: .
: CPI .
. .
. . 1 .
. 1996..
r 11 Macroeconomics Annual. ,

.
, ,
CPI,
, . (

, , ,
,
, ,

s:
:r

.,

, 1993-1995 .)

, ,

. 2.3

CPI.

. , ,

. , CPI

100 105 ,

(105 - 100)/ 100 5/ 100 0,05 5% .


(112

112,
CPI
- 105)/ 105 7/ 105 0,0667 6,67%. 1 -

t,

1+ 1 -

t + 1,

t t + 1 1t1 + 1

Pe+t- - L+1
-
t:iPt+t 1+ 1

1 1

.,
. 2.1 1960-2002

.
1960- 1970- rr. , 1980- .
1990-

2.5.

rr.


. , ,

$100 8% , ,

$108, . . $100
.

$8
4,

.

-~
so
10

IIID

ic#!

:1:

:1:

6
5
4

3
2

LL~--~~~~~~~~~~~~--~~

~~~~~~~~

1960

1964

1968

1972

1976

1980

1984

1988

1992

1996

2000


)i .
1960- 1970- rr. , ,
1980- rr., .
1980- rr.
1990- rr.

2.1

1960-2002

: , , .

www.bea.doc.gov/ea/dn/nipaweb

7.1 NIPA,

;;;'
111

111

(. : ~
.

4. 1).

,
, - ,

(
).

,
, . ,

~.
. , ,

~, , ,

111
N

Q
...,
'<

~
I

>

r::
s

~
r

S<

Ul

"'

, : ,
( , )
, , -

"'s

t ( ).

, , ,
$300 4% .
$312,
; $312
4% , $300
. 4%, ,
$300 , $312, ,
, .


,
. (
)- , (

) .
(,
)

.
( )- ,

:s:

:z:
<:[

CD
)

....

...

"'

i.

- = i- n.

(2.12)

2.12 ,
. .7. 1 ,
4% . ,
4%
0% , . . 4%.
,
4% , .
4%,
4% 4%, . . 0%.

, .

1960-2002 rr. . 2.2.
1970- .;
,
. ,
1980- .,

.
.

, irne,
.

? ,
2.12,
- , .
.

2.12

, ,

. ,
.

:[

=
::11

16
15
14
13
12

ti~

111
al

111

':1

11

8.

t:

10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1

-1
-2
1960

1964

1968

1972

1976

1980

1984

1988

1992

1996

2000

( )
. -

2.2

1960-2002

( ) 1970- rr. 1980- rr. ,


. r .

: , , . 7.1 NIPA,
www.bea.doc.gov/eajdnjnipaweb. 2003 2004 rr. 2%.
-
15 , www.federalreserve.govjreleasesjh15.

n
-i

"'<

"';:;!
"

}>

, ,

I
}>

.[:::

, ,

<

.
,

, .

r=i -1t,

r-

, 1te -

(2.13)

2.13 2.12, ,
, . . -

".,

(J)

"'

s
s

"'

,
, .
,
, -, ,
.
.
, , .

,
,
. ,

. ,

.
w

:I:

<:t
w

ID

CD

1.

...

...

, .

"'

, ,

2.

() -
,
.

, ;

.
:

, , ~
,

, , .

3.

(
) .
,
( -

) , , (

),
, .


.
.

4.

- ,
.
, ,
.
, , ,
-

(,

). (
)
.

; -

5. ,

,
.
.

6.


, , .

.
, ,

,

, .

7.

- ,
, .


. ,
100.

8.

.
,
. (CPI)
, .

- ,
,

9.

;;;'
111
111
111
N

CPI.

- ,

. - ,

.

-
(

).
,

,.

(J)

:I:

,.:s::s:




()

:s:

:z:
q

"'

...
.11

......

"'

':1'


= =

(2.1)


,
,

(2.3)

Y=C+I+ G+NX.

-
: ,

I,

Spvt =

(+

NFP -

TR + IN) -

NX.
.

(2.6)

, -
TR , , IN

NFP,

Sgovt =( - TR -

IN) -

G.

(2.7)

TR,
IN G.

S = Spvt + Sgovt = + NFP - - G.

(2.8)

S
. , ,

, -

NFP

S=l+

G.
(2.10)

( ) ,

.
.

(2.11)

I,

-Sgovt
( ) ,

r=i - n.

(2.13)

r -

i n.


1.

2.


?

?

3.


? ,

, ?

4.

5.

?
?

6.
7.

?
?
- -

? ?

8.

()
-1

."

CPI

,
?

CPI,

CPI.

"'

."
)>

:I:
)>
)::

:s:

:I:
)>

::.
rr

:I:

:S:<
\j)

;><;

:I:

:s:
:s:

;><;

9. ,

.
?
?


1.

100 . 100 ,
.
.

:s:
:I:

<:[

,
. ?

"'

CQ

...

1-

"'

:r

, ,
,
,
. .
1000 500 .
. 200
, 100 ,
.

2.

, ,

. , , -

,
?

) , $6
, .
.

) , $6
, . .
) , $6 ,
.
.

3.

, $6 ,
. .


$20 .
( ) $2 .
$1 , - $100 000,

- $200 000.

XYZ .
, XYZ

000 (
$200 000, - $100 000
). XYZ $30 .
XYZ $1 .
$800
$500 000, -

, .
, XYZ $800 000,

,
, .

) ), ,
$500 000
.

4.


.
, .

10 $1,40 .

( ) $1,30 .

)
$1 .
)
$20 000 . $8000
.

$100 , . (

: - ,
.)

)
)

, $3
- .
-

$5000,

)
, $100

General Motors.
$40 .
,

5.

$60

()

'<

= 40.
= 30.
() = 200.
= - 20.
= 60.

= 25.

= 15 ( ,
).

- =

7.

= 9.

, ,
:

) .
)

-i
-

"''<
-i

)>

:I:
)>
.

:s:

:I:

"

:I:

:S:<
<J)

"'

:I:

:s:

"':s:

- .

) .
.

) .

6.

: , . (
) :

3000
6000
8000

$2
$3
$4

:s:

4000
14000
32000

$3
$2
$5

"'

.
?

) .
?
) .

?
)

7.


,
, ?

1930
50,0

1929
51,3

CPI

8.

1930 1933 .,

.
?

1932
40,9

1931
45,6

1933
38,8


1 2003 . $500.
,

$545, 1 2004 .

, CPI 1 2003 . 200, 1


2004 .- 214. , ;
,

9.

CPI

2004 .

210.

, ,
,
.

10.

1 2002 .
1 2004 . 242, 1

200.

2005

266,2.

1 2002 1 2004 .? , -

)

1 2002 1 2005 .?
) -
-
0
, .- ,
,
1t

:

1.

,


.

2.



. 2

$3 . ,
, $2 .



. 2
.
.
,
:

$2

. .

3.


.
,
.

111

111

)

.


,
.

,

, ;

111
N

)

,


.
, ,

- ,

.
,

(J)

""

:s:
:s:

""

? :
.

4.


TR + IN),
- ( G +

G-


. ,


GCE GI, -
+ TR + IN).
GCE
(
:

5.

w
:r

"'


,
?


,
<<Survey of

NIP

,
Current Business ~ - www.bea.doc.gov

. 5.1 ~ ~.
,


,
,

:[

"'

[Q

.
,

it


, ,

,
-

FRED
d
d.orgjfre
.stlouisfe
research
:

1.



1947 .


. -
?

2.


,
,
1947 . (
;

.)

3.


) CPI (

.
1960

,
?

:

4.

, , ,

) . 1948 .,

( <~:

CPI

. (

CPI

.) ,

?

(,



),
,
?



1948 .

Q
~

"

)>

:t
)>

.r:::

"'

:t
)>
::;,
'

:t

"''
"':t
(J)

"'
"'"'

: . ,

.
.

, ,
. - ,
,

, ,
, .

, ,
, , ,

1,

, ,

: ( ),
(

4) ( 7).
2, ,

, . 3,
, -
.

, ,

, ,
: .
,

,
, .
, ,

, :

1) (,
2) , . .
. 1,
-
, , )

<:t

. ,

""

, ,

"

::

:I:

"-

, .

::

<:t

, -

"'
"'""

(, ) ,

:I:

<(

"'

(!)

; ,

,
,

. , ,

3.1.


, :
, , ,
. . .
,
(

, ).
, , ,
.
,

?
, , , ,

, . ,
, .

,
.


(, ) ().

. ,

, . <~
3.4 <~ ,


.
( )

.
. ,

,
, , ,
.


, .

- ,
.
:

(3.1)

Y = AF(K, N),

- ; -
, ; -
, ; N -
, ;

F-

N.

3.1,

( , N- ,
) , (
, N- ,
).

3.1, , (
) ,
N.
3.1, F(K, N),
.
. ,

, ,
10% 10% .

,
.


w
)>

:t

"'
-i

)>

"'s
-i

(3.2)
,

.."

"'mw

3.2,
3.1),

)>

F(K, N) .03NJ 7 . (

, ;

, , . .6.)

3.2 , 1

. .

3.1

N,

<:t

sQ.

:f:

::
:

Q.

L
:;

1980 .
1, 2 3 ( ),

.
1996 . , -
. 4 .

, , .

3.1,

.
,

4,

3.2.

= Yj(J<.0 3NJ7 ),

<(

, =

<:t

.,
"'
s

:f:

::

""

(!)

3.2. 2001 . , , . 3.1


9215, = 10115 N 135,1; , 2001 .

9215/ [(10115) 03 (135,1) 07 ], 18,69.


3.2

, . 3.1,
, - ,
, ,
- .
, 5,

, .
, . 3.1,
.

- ,

. (2,3%)
1982 ., , ,
, 1983 1984 .
2,6 3,2%. 19901991 . 2001 .

,
. 3
, .
-, 1980 1995 .
, 0,9% . ,
1970- .,

0,4%

, 1950 1970 .
, 2,1% . 1995 .
, 1,4% .

1
-
. - =AKN', < < 1.

-
, ,

1-

. ,

,
.

3.1.

1980-2001 rr.

,
($

($

1996 r.)

,
( , %)

4
99,3
100,4
99,5
100,8
105,0
107,2
109,6
112,4
115,0
117,3
118,8
117,7
118,5
120,3
123,1
124,9
126,7
129,6
131,5
133,5
135.2
135,1

3
5569
5783
5948
6091
6309
6545
6735
6899
7071
7249
7419
7538
7649
7798
7973
8191
8448
8749
9100
9457
9849
10115

2
4901
5021
4919
5132
5505
5717
5912
6113
6368
6592
6708
6676
6880
7063
7348
7544
7813
8160
8509
8859
9191
9215

1980
1981
1982
1983
1984
1985
1986
1987
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001

( )

1996 r.)

14,75
14,82
14,49
14,87
15,34
15,54
15,68
15,81
16,10
16,30
16,34
16,28
16,63
16,80
17,08
17,22
17,49
17,80
18,16
18,49
18,78
18,69

0,5
-2,3
2,6
3,2
1,3
0,9
0,8
1,8
1,3
0,2
-{),3
2,1
1,0
1,7
0,8
1,6
1,7
2,0
1,8
1,6
-{),5

* = Y/(~f'/J. 7 ).
: (

1996 .)- research.stlouisfed.orgjfredjseries/GDPCA; (


, , 1996 .) , http:jjwww.bea.doc.gov/eajdnjfaweb/ AIIF ATales.asp; N ( ) - , ftp:j/
ftp.ls.gov j pu jspecial.requestsj lfjaat 1. txt.
-

:::J

."

m
:1::>
m

::,
m

::t


, 3.1,
.
-
, , ,

. 1
,

2001

135,1

(. .

18,69

2001

N,

3.1).
3.2)

. (

7) =

579,52 .0 .

""
!"
"'
"""'
)>

::t

~
r:

"'

"'m
"'
."

"'
"'""

= A.0 JifJ = (18,69)(.0 )(135,1


1

:::J
'<

()

)>

:
3

"'m
"'\!:

.J::
)>

(. 3.1 ),
, -
.

2001

,
. ,
2001 .: ($10 115 )
,
c:t

($9 215

)- .

, .

3.1,

, :

Q.

1.

::


. ,
.

::r

:I:
:

2.

Q.

. ,
,

L..
:;

c:t

"'
<
s"'
::r

:I:

9215
9000

"'

(1)

8000

________ c____ _

6977
6400
6000
5667

J-~\.--~557

2001 .

---------------=733

----------

5000
4000
3000
2000
1000
oL-~----~--~----~--~----~--~~---L----~---U--

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

7000

8000

9000

1 115

, ,
S 1996 r.

2001

2001

3.1

. -

t~

$1000
$733 , $1000
D

$577

,
, ,
. 3.1. , ,

$2000 . $1000
, $3000 .
?
$733 ($6400

$5667 ).
$733
$2000 $3000
.

, , , $1000
.

D ,

$4000 . D
$577 ($6977 D
$6400 }, , $733
.
.
.
,
- (
).

dY.

()

,
.
dY ,


dj.

d /.
d/ - ,
dY,

, ,
1
.

. . 3.2

. ,

2000,

.
2

:::t
-

J::>
m
::,
m
I

:s:
m

"':::t\!:

, .

1.

.
.
,

2.


.
,

'<

"'
!"
w
)>

"'

..;

..;
<

:s:

"'mw

)>

"'..;

, .

, . .2.
2

, .

:s:

r::

)>

>:..:
-

ll

8000

j!!

u ..

~=
11 :1:

"' Ql
:1:::1

&.

c:f

6000
5667

$.,

5000

:11

~
s
Q.

6977

4000

<:
::

3000

::t:

:r

Q.

2000

ct

1000

<(

"'s

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

::

, ,

::t:

"'

1996 .

(1)

N
.

...

"'

':1'

()

j3.2

D, -

, D. , ,
.

. .

D,

3.2,

2000.

4000,

m
.
: ,

( )
;

,
. ,
, ,
( ),
,
- .
.
,

,
.

. . 3.1 3.2

2001 ., .


, . ,

2001 .,
$10 115 , 2001 .,
18,69 (. . 3.1). ( 3.2)

= A.0 3JV0 7 = (18,69)(101153 )(JV07)

= 297,23JV07

(.

135,1

, =

$9 215

3.3).
2001 .: N =

,
, - , ,

. 1
,
, .
:

, (

) .
, MPN, - ,
,
6./6.N. ,
MPN
, .
.

3.3 , , 30
MPN
90 , MPN

.
, ,

,
,

:::t
"
m
J:>
m

:::.

::r

1!:

"':::t
'<

"
!'

::r

, , , . 2
, , ,

UJ

)>
:

-<

-<
\

s
1

N 0,7, -

0,3, ,

, ,
, .

"'mUJ
~

"'-<

.t:

)>

.
,

9215
9000
8000

2001

6935
w

<:t

6000

sQ.

w
:

5000

:f:

:J:
:

Q.

<::

4000
3214
3000

2000

"'
"'s
:f:

1000

<:t
<(

:J:

"'

oL--L--~~--~~---L--L-~--~~--~--L--L~~~--

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90 100 110 120

()

N,

10
~

150

...u

135,1

2001

(MPN)

2001

j:s.:s

. -

MPN

,
.

, ,
,
.


, ;
, ,

; ,

,
.

, ,
.
3.4
, .

,N

,
, , .

3.4

. ,
,

( ),

. 1 ,
n

. 2

3.2.

:::1
"

m
J:>
m
::,
m

:I:

, ,

"'m

. . 3.1
- , (,

!1:

). ,
.

, .


1

.
- .

, , . 3.4, ,
, .
2
,
, .

"'

:::1

'<

;>;

!'
UJ

>

:I:

"'-i

Q
"

"'

"'m

UJ
"

>

"'-i
I=
"'>

. ,
,


. ,
,

.
, .

6,

<:t

"'w

,
, . ,
.
-
.

0..

r::::

J:
;r

0..

:;

<:t

11)

<

"'"'
~

J:

"'

(1)

N
.

. ,
, ,
.

3.3 - , .

,

, .

. ,
:

...

1.

:r"'

2.

.
, , , . .

,

. , ,

, ,
,
,
. , .

3.

). ,
.

,
,
.
, - ,

.
, .
,
(

) ( ).



Clip
joint, . Clipjoint , -

, ,

3.2.

Clipjoint ( 2),
( 1).
, .

MPN Clip joint 3.


Clipjoint 11, N
11. Clipjoint
11 20, 9, MPN - 9. . .
3 , Clip]oint

MPN ,

Clip ]oint
. ,
(

, .)

3.2.

Clip joint

MRPN =MPN
=$10

, MPN

1
2
3
4
5
6

11
20
27
32
35
36

11
9
7
5
3
1

$110
$90
$70
$50
$30
$10

1 )

.
,

MRPN,


. MRPN,
. Clipjoint $10

, MRPN $11 ( 11
$10 ).

( ) , ,
, MPN:

MRPN = MPN.

(3.3)

Clipjoint $10, MRPN


( 4) MPN ( 3),
$10.
, W, Clip joint
,
$80 . ( W,
,

.) Clip]oint,
? , Clipjoint

:::J
"D

J::>
m

::::.

s:

"'2:

:::J

'<

"'

!"

"'::r
)>

d"'

".

s:

"'m

"'
"'
-i
"D
)>

s:

.r::
)>

.
, , -

w
<:t

:s:
.

w
<::
~

':;

MRPN.
, , -
W.
3.2 , MRPN $11 ,
$80,
Clip joint.
Clipjoint, MRPN ($90 )

.
Clip joint, MRPN ($70

) , ($80 ).
,
$80 - Clipjoint-

.
Clipjoint

, .
, .

<:t

"'<
:s:
"'
I

"'

()

Clip joint
,
, . . MPN.

, . . , .

W,

() .

W $80 ,
() - $10, w
($80 )/($10 ) , 8 .
, Clipjoint

(MPN). MPN 11

, 8
, . . .
, MPN 8 .
, MPN
7 ,
. Clip joint , ,
, . . ,
.

, ,
,
. ,
,

, . ,

, MRPN
$70, $80,
. . 2
,
.

Clip joint

,
.

2.


n,

,
n

MPN>w
(MPN> WIP)
MPN> W
(MRPN> W)

MPN<w
(MPN< WIP)
P x MPN<W
(MRPN<W)

MPN-
- ()

MKPN- = MPN

W-
W- = WIP


Clip joint

$80. ,

$60

, Clip ]oint?
,

. $60
,
$10,

6 ($60 )j($10

) . 3 . 3.2 , MPN
7 ,
.

Clipjoint.
, MPN (5
) , (6

).

::;,

MPN

]::>

Clip]oint,
.
3.5 ,
.

...,:::1

MPN

MPN

MPN;
N,

, .
w*.
w* ,

( ,

), ,

MPN.

::r

"'
"'
!'"

![

:::1

w
::r

)>

"'

-i

...,"'w
m

)>

"'S1

J::.

)>

:[

:s:
Q..

MPN

w
:

ND

::

Q..

----

0~--------~-------------------------------------

, N

N*

:[

<

<(

""

:s:
~

::

""

(1)


MPN, MPN

; ,

,-

3.5

. , w*, MPN

, - N*. ND

.

MPN.

N*. N*

? , , N*,

MPN
(


);

N*, ,

(MPN < w*),

N*,

.
, ( ), ,
MPN .

, , .
MPN
,

,
-
,
1 MPN, ,
MPN.

MPN,

-,
Clipjoint.

, I< ,
Clip j oint.
1

MPN

( ).

,

, ,

. -,

Clip ] oint

,
,
. 3.5,

, ,
N. N
,

I,

,
,


.

.

,
,



. , ,

, , ,
MPN
, , ,
,
MPN .

MPN

;

.

Clip j oint
: ,


~ New Age~
.


Clip joint,
. 3.3. ,

MPN

.
Clipjointp

(. . 3.2) ,
- 8
. 3.3 ,

Clipjoint

, MPN ( 1
)

3.3.

:::J

."

:::>

""m
"'
\[

:::J

'<

Clip joint

!>"'
w

)>

n ,

MPN

, MRPN =MPN
( =$10

1 )

22
40
3

54

4
5

64
70
72

22
18
14
10
6
2

I
::

-i

-i

""

"'mw

."

$220
$180
$140
$100
$60
$20

)>

"'-i

""
r::.
)>

MPN

w
r::t

:s:

Q.

w
:

:r

:r

Q.

:;

-----

0~----------------------------------------------

,N

r::t

"'
:s:
"'
<(

:r

"'

()

N
.D

...

\,1

"'

,
MPN ,

MPN .
MPN,
2
ND' t ND .

3.6

n
n


. Clipjoint

)

(6
MPN


, .

MPN

. 3.6.


, MPN .

N ,
2
ND 1 ND . 3.6.

,
2

ND ,

,
1
ND

3.


MPN

MPN


MPN
MPN


, - .

,
(

MPN


. 1

, Clip]oint.

,
. .

, ,
, ,
.

,
(. 3.5).

, ,

,
.

. ,

,
.

3.3.

3.

,
.

,


(
. .),
.


.
,
,
.



,

.
-
,
-
.
(,
, , ,
. . )

. 2
,


,

,

,
.

:::J

."

m
J:>
m
::,
m
::

2:

:::J
'<

"
!"
"'
)>

::

::

r:r

"'
m


,

. ,

.

(,


) .

"'

."

)>

s"'

r::.
)>


,
,
. ,
,

,
, $35
( ).

:[

s
w

0..

0..

L...
:;

:[

"'
<(

"'
s

"'

()

N
.

1-

10

j'

, ,

,

1
,

- .

.
, ,
: <<

~
?

~
,

,
, ,
,

?~
,

;
.
,

$35,

(,

(,
)

.
),
, ,


$35 ,

.
- ,


,
.
,



,
-
(,


,

.
, )
.

. - .. .
n
. n,
n


. ,
,

40

n ,
n
,
n n .

1
2




. -,

(
)


.
(
)

-,

,

. -, ,


.


. ,


:

,
.

:

.
, ,


( ).

.
, $35
,

,


,
,
.
$35
, , ,

.
, $350

. ,

, :
,
~.
,
(. .


.

.

,
,

r
.
: r

.

.


, $300 000.

,
$300 000

, .
,

.
I
-

$35 , -

. ,

:::1
-

::,
m

:s:

"'

\[
:::1

'<

"'
!"
w

>

"'

-i

-i

:s:

"'w

m
-

>

"'

-i

:s:

J:::

>

c::r

D.

<::
:

:>::
:

D.

1....

<::;

c::r

"'
"'s
<(

:>::

"'

(1')

,
.

, ,
)

$50


1
,

,

, ,

. ,

,
,

, ,
,
.


$50

.
( ), ,
,
,


? ,
,

. ,


, .


, ,

, . . .

,
,

,
,
.
,


? ,
-
,

,
,


,

,
,

(
,


(
,

,
)


. ,

,
,
, .



,
1 ,


$50

,
.

,

,


.
- ,
?

1



,

, , ,
.

,
,

,

. ,

,
:

,


, ,


:


,
.


~
~: ~
~ .



(

),
.

3.7

-
.
,
(

)
.

,
. ,

:::J

."

]::,

:,

m
::t

:s:

. , ,


,
,
,

,
. ,

(,
)


. ,
. 3.8,

.:

11 , : Cambridge University

Press, 1983. . . 3.1- 3.5 4.2- 4.4.

UJ
)>

::t

"'-<

-<

:s:
0'1

UJ
."
)>

0'1

-<
:s:
>=
)>

NS

:(

s:
.

:I:

;r

L..

::

QL---------------------------------------------------,N

:(

"'
~

:I:

"'

, .

()

,
,

s:

N
Jl

3.7

':r

) .

1-

"'


. ,
,

. 3.8
.


-
,

, ,


. ,

. -

,

,
, ,


. -,

,
,

,
,

.
)

-
.
.

0~----------------------

------------------------

----

,N






. ,


t .


3.8

,
,

,




n
.


,


(,


)



,


(


).

,





;


4.

:s;
m

"'\!:

:::J

'<

"
!"

>
:r

"'
-i

-i

<

:s;

:r

:::J
."

m
I::>
m
::,

,
,

"'wm

."

>

"'

-i

:s;
I=

>



&
&

3.9,
.
.
1930 - .

:{

:s:

Q.

::

:I:
:

Q.

L...
:;

:{

"'<

"'

:s:

1869


1930- .
.

,
,

XIX

:I:

"'

(1)

...v
.

"'

'j'

~z 8

56

1'11

.11 ,._

~ot
:~
~s

54
52

50

Q.,.

.,. 1'11

48

II<Q.

8.
(J

/,

46

/ ~::~~

44

42
40

38
36
34

1949 1959 1969 1979 1989 1999


1869 1879 1889 1909 1919 1929 1939

XIX

3.9

n
,
n.

1919 r.



.
:
1860- 1970 . 1973 ()

,
-
let.
s.govj servletjSurveyOutputServ
213, , data.
.

212-

. ,

1930- .

,
.

1940-
.

-
,






1950- 1960- .

, ,

:

, . 3.9,
,



.
.

3.10
,
.


.

() ,
-
.. 11

1-

uu

54

..

- 52

~:

1- ;

~~

;~
o,s
~

CL7

-8

CL

50
48

- .!

46
44

42

38

n8 8

40

36

n \

8
8

111
111
111

8
8

34

;'

8 n

8 ~ /flt

:::J
."
m

32

8 8

:::.

:r
:s:

30

1000

2000

3000

4000

"'!1:

5000

6000

7000

8000

:::J
'<

9000

"'
)>

,
,

1980 r.

w
)>
:r

"'

3.10

-i

-i

<

:s:

"'mw

."
)>

"'

:
.: United Nation
Statisti cal Yearook.
1985- 1986 rr. . 89;
-
,
n
n
: 1950- 1980 rr.
Review of Income and Wealth . 1984 (). . 259261.

11

-i

:s:
.r:::.
)>




.
) ,

,
(
( ,


).

c::t

, ,

.
,

sQ.
w
::

I
:

Q.

L...

<::;

c::t

"'<
s"'

"'

()

...1.1
.

"'

':

3.4.

.

(
,

,
),

, ,
. ,

;
,


.
,

,
. 3.11.

N.

w.

.
,
.


- , , -

ND

-QL- ----- ----- ----- --L- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----, N
N*

n


.

( ).

3.11

-


.
. 3.12,


,
ND 1 ND 2


, ,




,


.

.
,




( iii ),

2

(
1
2 ).




,




.

,


.
, ,

,

,

,

.


,



, ,

-

1.

::J
."

]::1

::,
m

2.

:s;
m

''
'
'''

2.

"'

\[
::J

'<

OL---------------~---

"'
);>

-~-------------------

---


( . .

3.4),




.

, ND 1
ND 2,


.

UJ
);>

' 3.12


n
n

N1

N2

w2 ,

"'
-i

-i

:s;

"'m
UJ
."
);>

"'
:s;

-i

I::
);>


().
.
,
,




. ,

N.

,


c:t

"'
Q.

:I:
;

Q.

L...
:;

c:t
lt1

<

"'"'
~

:I:

"'

(1)
N

...v

"'

(3.4)

Y=A F(K ,N).

::

3.1 ):

3.4


: (N)
.

,
(N)
,
,
().
,

3.12),
MPN (.
.


1.
,

'j'

2.

3.4.

N



. 3.12.
,

3.4.





,
,
-


,
-

,
. . 3.13
(

.
2002
1960
),

rr.,
4
-197
1973

:
,

()

-198 0 .
; - 1979

1979 .
,

-
. ,
1990 .

.
.
. 1990

. 3.13.

1980

~! :1
190

~~~

:r&
~~

..
....

160

150
140

~
Cl
z

1979- 1980

170

~
g;

is

180

130
120
110

1973- 1974

100

1990 .

90
80
70
60
50
40
1960

1965

1970

1975

1980

1985

1990

1995

2000



-
,


.
1973 -1974
1979 -980 .,

1980- rr.
1990 .


ett .

3.13

1960- 2002

:
-
-
,
data.s.gov;servlet/ Surve yOutp
utServ let; -
, . 7.1
NIPA, www.ea.doc.gov/ea/dn/nipaaweb.

11 1992 .
100.

-

,


,



. ,

-


.

?

1970 - 1980 rr. . 1

-




,

.
,
-
1979 -

1980 rr.


5,7% .
,
,

,
1979
-1980 .

,
.

1

.:


? / . .

Puhlic Policy . 1988 () .

, .

28.

// Camegie-Rochester Conference Series

:J
-

~
m
::;,

::t:

"'!!:
:J
'<

;>;

!'

,.....,
"'
::t:

1
<
s

"'
,..
"'

m
...,

s
r::
)>

.
,

1973-1974, 1979-1980 .

1990 .

1973 1975 .
.
1991 . -8%, 1989
1981

5%, 1978


2%. ,


;
,
.

::[

:s:

0..

0..

L..

<::;

::[

"'
<{

"'

:s:

"'

()

N
.
~

"'


,
,


,
.

.


: 1)

1970 .

; 2)

.
.
,


,
.

1970 1995 . (

<~



~ . 3.1: ;~

~) .

MPN


.
60

)
66%

. 6

.

-
, ,
- .



, . .

1

. ,
.
: . , .

i

rr.:
1980-

Economic Review. 1992

11

(). .

371 - 392.


,
,

.

,



, ,

,



. ,


,
,

,

10 15% ,
,

. '

3.14

-
,
.


,
,
2.
n

2
111

1.

2.

Ql

1.

nporpecc,

Ql

1'1

111

Ql

:z:

2.

...

1
1
1
1

:.

2. -

'i :

:
:
oL---------~~----------

. (),

. ().

.

MPN,

,

- r,

MPN
MPN

. MPN

ND',. ND 2,.

3.14


n,

,

. (). MPN

,

, ND'nsk ND 2""'*
. (). ,

,




.
1 .:

1984- 1989 rr.


QJtterlyjoumal of Economics. 1993
() . . 33-60.

11

::1
-
m

]::1

:1:

:s:

"'

2:

::1
'<

n
><

!>
UJ

>

:1:
:0
-i

!:1
r

:s:

"'
m

UJ
-

>

"'

-i

:s:


:

:


.1

- . 3.14, ,


. 3.14, .
-


,
-

:s;

Q.

:I:

:r

Q.

:;

"'
<(

"'

:s;

:I:

"'

(')

...v
.

"'

':1"

,

,


MPN
.

1
3.14,
ND sk .

ND\nsk . 3.14, ,

(. .


. 3.14, ,


MPN
. 3.14, .

.
,
,
- ,

,
,

MPN


(
(

MPN
, ),

).

MPN



, -
2 . 3.14, ),
1

ND sk
( ND sk
sk
( ND\n

ND 2unsk . 3.14, ).


,
,
,

,



,
.

3.5 .


,

,

,
:
,

, NumJ.r N.. -
: = AF(K, Nsk' N.),
r,
-



F ,
,

, ,
. , , ,
, ; .

,

.

,
12. ,
,
.

&&

(BLS) 50 000 .

16

, (
) (
) ;

, ,
;

,

(, ,
).

3.4 ,
2003 . (

~ :
. ) 137,4 8,5 .
,
, 2003 . 145,9 (137,4

). ( 16 )
2003 . 220,2 , 74,3 ,

8,5

::;]
"

gJ

m
::t

3.4.

2003

"'m
"'

ll

137,4

::;]

,%

, '!

94,2

62.4
( )

8,5

5,8

3,9

( )

(+ )

145,9

74,3
220,2


( +
)

"'
!"
"'>
::t
"'-1

!:)
<1'

100,0

66,3
( )

33,7
100,0

"'
"'m

"'
>
"

"'-1
.r::
"'
>

: -
.

: ,

'<

2003

. , . .

( 220,2
145,9 , ).
,

<:[

, .
1 - , ,
. 2003 . 5,8% (8,5
145,9 ) . 1.3
1890 .

220,2
2003 . 145,9 ,
66,3%.

J:

';

<:[

"'

<(

><
s

J:

><

()

- , .

2003 . 62,4% (137,4 JIH


220,2 ). 62,4%,
37,6% 2003 .
37,6, 3,9% , 33,7% - ,

.
, ,
, , -
( ).


.
,

, - .
3.15 , (. .
, )
.
,

1
. ,
, 1% ,

1%,

,
.

? 3.15 ,
22% ,
13% .
65% . 13%
, , -
, . . ,
.
,
,
.

1
. 3.15 , ,
, . 3.4 . : . , .
.:

. . -, Russell Sage Foundation, 2001.

1976 2000 r.

2%
74,3

8,5
13%

2%

3%

1%

22%

137,4



,

,

.
,

3.15


1%, , 1% ,
,

;
22%, ,
22% ,
,


?
65% ,

,

. ,

,
.

.

,
.
-
,

, , ,

. -

,
.


,
.

1.



, .

,
,

.
,
,
,
100 .
,


,
. ,


.

2.

;'
01
111

01

::J

."

m
1:>
m
::::,
m
::t
m
"'
"'!1:

::J

'<

;;

!'

"'
)>

::t

"'

-i

-i

"

"'
"'
0'1

."
)>

0'1

-i

"'

I=

)>




,
.

<:f

Q.

t:

:I:

:r

Q.

L..
:;

<:f

"'<
><
s

:I:

><

(1)

N
.D
11,/

"'

www.bls.gov/ news.release/
~ (
,

empsit.nrO.htm). ,
,
,

.
,


, .
,
,

,
, Employ

the Presiden t.
ment and Earnings , Econom ic Indicators, Economic Report of

,
,

:
,

.
(
.
400 000

n)


n.
n
,

.
,

,


,


,
- . ,
-


.
.
,

,
.: :
. . 1990. . 22-23.

,
, 86%,

:
.

- ,

:

15 ?
1 ,

,
, 1 .

15

67%,
,

,
.


,


.

,
,

.

,
.
,
.
,
:
,
,
. , ,
,
.
,
, , , ,
(

),
,

, ,
, ,
. -


,
.
, - ,

,

,
. -
,

,

,

, ,
.
. ,

,
,
.


, ,
,

.

.

.

, ,

,
.

. -
,


. ,
,

.

,

.

,
-
,
.





, ,
. -
,
, ,
,


.
-


.

:::>

."

m
J::>
m

:::.

);

"'2::::>

'<

()

;><

!'

"'

>
);

"'....
()
....
<

s
0'1

"'>
."

0'1

....

s
.
>


r ,


(, )
,

(,

c:r

:s:

0..

:r:
::

0..

L
:::

c:r

"'
"'

<(

:s:

:r:

"'

()

.
.

10

:r

.
),
(,


,
).
,

,
,

.

. -

.
,

, ii.
.

,
,

,
6% 1980- rr.
4 5% 1950- .

,

.
1990-

5,5%
12.


, .
,

- ii, -

ii -


,
,
.

3.6.

..,
:


,
.

,
,

rr.

1960




2%-

. 1 2

-
=2(u-u ).

(3.5)

3.5 ,

. 3.5
,

, ,

6%,

$10 000 . 7%,

,

1%. , ,

2% (2
1%) ,

. $10 000 ,

$200

(2% $10 000 ).
, 1

, 1%,
(
)

. ,


,
: ,
;

;
, -
.

10 .

:

-=3-2,

(3 .6)

/ -
, -

.
3.6 ,
(!:.> 0),

, 3%
,

.
3.6,
,

,
.
3.6

,
.

3.16

:::J

."

J:>

m
~

m
::t

:s;
m

"':::J!1:
'<

":1>

...,
:1>

::t

....
"'

....

.
-

1
(,

:s;

<

3 (9% - 6%),

6 9%), ,
50% (3% - 50% 6%).

2
(.: :

11

. ,
, Brookings Institution .
1970. . 132- 145), UJ , , . .




3 .
2.

m
...,
."

:1>

....
:s;
J::

:1>


111
111

~ID

'i!

:z:

111

:[

s:

1>.

>-i ><]

13
12
11
10

1;

8.

:I:

"

1>.

L..
:[

>

2
1

<(

-1

"'s:

-2

:;

OL

:I:

-2

"'

-1

()

!!. ,

N
.

1-

1.1

"'

':1'

n
n ( )
( ).

n (
3.6). - 2, ,
1 n n

OL

3. 16

1951-2002

n 2 n n 3% n
n .
,

n n


n n n
0).
=
(Du
, http://
: - . 1 .2 \v-
- w-

jnipaweb.
.gov/eajdn
www.bea.doc
, data.ls.gov.

)
(

(

1951- 2002 rr. OL

-2, ,

.
2%.
1%
OL

3%. ,

, 3%,


.

1.



. ,

, ,

, .

,


,

2.

(

),
().

,

,

.
,


.
(MPN)

,

). MPN,

,

, ,

.

3.

,
(MRPN )
W, ,
, ,

4.

5.

MPN w.

MPN.



, .
,

,


, .

-
.
,

,

, (

)
(

).

6.





- .
,

,

,

.

:::>
-

m
:1:>
m
::,
m
::t

:s:

"'

!!:
:::>

'<

n
><

:?

cr

s:
Q.

7.

<:::

) . ,

:t:

:r

Q.

';

cr

<

<

"'
2:

s:

:t:


,
,


.
,

"'

()

N
.

"'


r.


, ,

2:

...u

8.

':1'


() .

9.


.


.

10.

11.


, ,
;



.

. -
.

,


,

, -

.


, ,

,
-

, -




. :

.



.

12.

,

1% 2%.

:~:>-

\0.

:s:~

1'1

CL

Y=AF(K, N)

, ,

;'




N.

111
1111

111

=
AF(K, N), (

,
)

.


, ,

ti

, ,

,


. ,



,

.

t:. !:1 ,
!:1 1t:.
, .
-

"'
)>

::

"'-<

Q
7'

"'m
"'
"

)>

"'-<

J::
)>

. ,


1
.

,

,


,- .

w
o::t

, -

s:
0..

:I:

0..

L..

<:;

s:

"'
"'

:I:

o::t

<

"'

()

ND

0~----------------~----------------------, N

N,
, N - .


,
.

ND




. ,

MPN,

NS ,

.

1, - .

,

,
.

,

,
.
,

(.
. 3).

,

,

.
,
,


,

(. .

4).

(MRPN)

()
(MPN)


Y=AF(K ,N).

(3.1)

,

,
N

(3.4)

Y=AF(K ,N).

,
-

r::r

..

:f:

:r
..

u,

-=3-2l.

';
11)

<

"'s:f:

:t:

"'

()

N
.

...

nl

':r

(3.6)

r::r

(3.5)

=2(u-u ).

1%-
,

2%

:t:

N.

3%,


. 3.6,
,
,

,
.


1.

2.

,
?

,
?
,

.
.

4.


()?
?

,

5.

6.

3.

MPN?

MPN

?
?


,
.

7.

?
?

8.

9.
10.
11.

12.



.




?
?

,

,
?

~,
~.
~ ~.



.


?

?

?

13.
14.

15.

?


?



.


?

2
,

?
,


1.

1960
1970
1980
1990
2000

2377
3578
4901
6708
9191

111
111

111

2606
3850
5569
7419
9849

w
N

65,8
78,7
99,3
118,8
135,2


,
. 3.1.
,

= AJ<O .NJ 1 .
)


1960 1970 .?
1970
1980 . ? 1980
1990 .? 1990
2000 .?
)


1960 2000 .?

1

.
(

N
,

2.



1,0.)
,

::::1

J::J
m
::::>
m

:r
:s:

"'2:

::::1

'<

!'"'
UJ

)>

:r

"'
6
n
-<

".

:s:

"'m

UJ
"

)>

"'-<

:s:

.r::
)>

=0,2( +.fN ).
=

?
.

::[



110.

100


. N
110

MPN


120.

"'w

"-

::t:

:r

"-

L
:;

::[

100 N = 100.

3.

Acme Widget Inc.

"'<
"'"'

::t:

"'

3
4
5
6

(!)

..

1.1

"'

':r

15
21
26
30
33

MPN .

$5


)

,
.
$22?

$27?


$38?

Acme


?

e.
Acm

$38,
,

.
$1

$5

Acme

?

,
)
$5,

,
$38


.
?



,
) )?

4.

MPN = (100- N),


N-

$2,00.

) = 1,0,

$1 ? $20?

.
,

95?

) )

5.

= 2,0.

,

MPN =
= 309 - 2N, N-
.

NS = 22 + 12w + 2, w -

, -
.

) , = 35.

6.

) ,
35,


,

7.



?
,
= 9I05 5
N!


MPN = 4,5I05N-05 .

= 25.

NS =
= 100[ (1- t)w]2, w-
, t -

,
,

(1- t)w -


.
)

,
t =.

,


.
) )
,

t= 0,6.

) ,
w = 2.

t =,


?

7. 500
,
.
5


. ,

1 20


,
.
, 1
20

,

)

?
)

?
?
)
?


,

( ),

8.

9.

,
. 3.15,
?

.

?

<:t

..

8%

950

6%
1030

7%
1033,5

5%
1127,5

:I:

:r

..

L..
:;

6%


(- )/ = 2( - ii).

<:t


)
.
2, 3 4

,

).

,

,

"'
"'s
<(

:I:

"'

(1')

1-

3.6).

.
,

10

':

10.


2000 . 1900

40
.

10


) ,

?
?
?


. 4%,
)
2,5%.

0,2%
,


,
,
. ,

1%,

1,4%.




?

?
?



,
?


1.


-
10%. ,

,
.

) , 10 %-

MPN
10%
. (:
ll
D.N?)
)

MPN?
.

?
, .

2.


, .

)
- .
)
,

3.

1980- 1990 -
rr.
.

~
~ .

,


1980- 1990 - ., ,

( ,
,
) .
)


(
)

,

4.

)
,
,

. ,


.


r

. )

5.

::::1

:::,
m
::t

:s:

"'
\[

::::1

'<

)
,

,
,
,

"m
]::J

,




6%.
,
, . .

,
.

?

,


?

"'
)>

UJ
)>

:r

"'
~

:s:

"'
m

UJ

"

)>

"'

:s:

I=

)>

6.




? .

7.

:s:
..

:I:
::

..

L
:;

2003 .

$87 000.
12,4%

4~.
$87 000


,
,

,
788.
$87 000 0,124 = $10


$105 242, . .

242.
$105
12,4% ,


15%,

$87 000.

,

,

ID



$105 242 0,124 = $13 050,

(
= $13 050).
0,15

000
$87

<
:s:

"'

:I:

"'

()

...

"'

\,1

000
- $150

'j

?
?


,
.

$50

000 .

? ,
.

it


,
,

,

FRED
/ fred.
: research.stlouisfed.org

1.

3.2,
,


. 3.1,
1948 .

? ?

?
.?
1990

.
-1980
1979
.,
1973- 1975

2.


1948 .
,

(
,


),

,

.
w-
www.hls.g

ovj cpsj cpsat abs.h

tm



20

20 .

,
?

3.




1979 .
. (
FRE D

)

?

(1953

- 1954, 1957 - 1958 , 1960- 1961 ,1969- 1970,


1973- 1975, 1980, 1981- 1982, 1990- 1991
2001 rr.) ?

;'
111
111
111

::J
."

~
m

::.

:r

"'m
!!:
"'

::J

'<

!'"'
UJ

>

:r

"'
d
<:1

<

"'
"'m

UJ

."

>

"'~
.t:
"'>

:[

Q.

w
:

:I:

Q.

3.6),
(

(

,

3.5):
-

:;

(3.5)

=2(u -u).

:[

"'<
s""

~ =-2u +2u.
-1+

""

(1)

....
u

"'

:I:

-1



,
,



0),
( llii

ll(Y / ) = - 2/lu.
/ ,
,
jY,

,

ll(Y /)/( /). (


/
jY, 1.)


, ,

( ,


. .7),

. 3%
3%
(

3.6).

.

,



.
,

,
,
,

2,

(
)
:

(
),


(
)

( ).



,





,
,
. .

(

5).

,
-

. .

4.1


, .

.

4.2

,


.
,


( )


.

-
,
,



. -,



,

(,
)
.

,
, -

,

. -,



. ,

,

, .
,

:

<:[

Q.

:r

Q.

<:;

<:[

"'
s"'
<(

"'

()

N
.

1-

"'

':t'

,

,

,

;

,


, ,

.

, ,

, ,

,

,
.

. ,

,

.

:
3

?!>


,

.

(


,
,


3)

).

,


.


,
.

4.1 .

,



.

,





.

,
,
,


,

.

,

,

, -
,
$400 0


,
0 ,
$370
,

,

$300 ($4000 - $3700) .
$300 .

,

$3700 ($4000 -$30 0) . ,

,
,
,


,


(yi



,
.


,

,

(yi



. ,

(!,
,


,
(!_




,


.

sti

, ,


. 2
- (NFP)

2.8),

(
),

S = - - G, -
, -
,
G - .


Sd -

,

,

sti

(!_

:

Sd =

- (yi - G.

(4.1)

,



,
,


.
4


.



,
Spectacular Eyeglasse
s Company.
$20 000
.
, ,

,
$20 000
.
, ,

.
-,
, $20
000 .

,
?
,
.

,
,
-

:::::1

s..,

"'

:;,
m
:I:

:s:

..,"'m

;.;
m

:I:

:s:

"'

:s:
:s:

:I:

"'m

~
:s:
-'=
:s:
:s:

.
,



,

,

;


-
.

"'
.

r:::

::

::r

L..
::;

<:[

"'
<(

"'

"'
~

::

"'

()

N
.

1-

"'


,
,
$5000,


, ,
.
$25 000



.
000
$20

,
, , ,
,

.

,

, .

.

.
,

r


,
,


, ,
, ,
r .

,
(

1 + r
( )

, ,
) .

$1,


$1.

r,

,
1 + r .

1 + r
$1

,

.
1 + r
r
1 +

,
.

,
(1 + r)
~
.
,

1 + r

1 + r


,
.

-
?
.

,

.

, .

1 ,

$1

r
,
.

r)
+
(1


,
.




.
, ,


.

,

.

-


-

.
,



,



.

,

,

.

,


r , ,

. ,
,


.
,
,



$3000,
$3000. (

$3000,

; . . ,



,
$3000.)

?


.
,

$3000, - ,

,
.

,
,

:::J

"

!1

::.


,

,

.





.
(

)
(



).
,
,

,
,

.


()

,

.


,

.
, ,

,
0,4, 0,4, 40%,

. ,
$3000,


(0,4) ( $3000) = $1200.

!1

m
m
"

""m
s"'
I

"'
m

!:1s

.[:

s
s

s;
Q.

t:
~

:r

Q.

1...
:

"'<
s;
"'
~

,
, ,
$3000 - $1200 = $1800.

,
.

,

.


$400 0,

,

(0,4)( $400 0) = $1600,
0,4,
.
$2400
$4000 - $1600
, ,

, ,
,

,
,

)
(

,
CJ1.
, .
1, ()i
Sd

,
.

"'

(1)

N
.

1-

\,1

/11


,
,

,
. , ,
,



$3000

, ,

,

)
$3000 (

, ,


. ,
,
,

,

, .

,
,

. , ,
)

$1000


,
.


$1000 .

$1000

$1000


,

, $1000(1 + r). ,

$1000

0,05,

$1000(1,05) = $1050.
,
$3000
$1050
-
, $3000 - $1050 = $1950,


. ,



, .
, ,


,

.


: ,

,

(Jl
,
Sd .



,
,


?

.

,
-:

1990-1991 .-.

1990 -199 1


,
, ,
,

.
,
,
, ,
.

,
.


.

,
The Conference Board -,
,
The Surve y Research
Center- .

.
100 1966 .,

. The
Survey Research Center

Surveys of Consumer Attitud
es,
www.sca.isr.umich.edu

0'1

m
...,

m
~

:I:

:s:

"

:s:
:s:

:I:

"'m
~

:s:
:s:
:s:

I::


. 4.1
1994 ., . 4.1 1987

.



,

c:t

w
<::
:

:I:

:;

c:t

"'
s"'
<(
:

:I:

"'

()

..../1

nl

(,
,

)
, ,
(,

).

,
,

,

1990 .,

8'1

~;

100

1::;

:!~
sca

95

90

IO:z:

85

:s;

80
75

1987 .

70

1990 .

65
60
1987

1988

1989

1990

1991

1987 .

1992

1993

1995

1994

1987

. -

1994

1990 . , 1991 .,
.
,
)
( n
: n
.org/fred
stlouisfed
research.

w-

.:

5100

.:

600

01
01

01
01

580

...

560

=
~

540

~
&::;

520

4/t

4900

:1:

11
[

n
( )

4700

11

Q.
&::;

:1

4/t

:1:

4500
4300

500
480

4100

460

3900

1987r.
( )

3700

440

420

n (n )
3sooL-----~----~----~----~----

1987

:1

1988

-L----~----~----~

1989

1990

1991

1992

1993

400
1995

1994

.

1987 .,

1990-199 1

4.1&

1987-1994

.,

1990 .

,
1987 .

1990-199 1 rr.

::J

: n nn
n
1996 r. - w- .

:;j

m
01

::::.

.
. 4 . 1 ,


1990 . -
.

0,8%,
- 3,0%.
. 4.1,
1991 .
,
,
. 1992 .

,

, , ,
.

,
, 1993 .





,

1991

:1:

"'m
n

01

m
"
m

""m
"'
"'
"'
m
"'~
"'
"'"'
:1:

:1:


,
,

2,

.


, ,
.

,

,

,
, , ,

w
<:!

:s;
Q.

::

Q.

':;

<:!

"'<

"'

:s;
:

:z:

"'

()

.
50
,

$3000. $3000, ,


$3000, .

,
$3000,
, ,

$3000

4.3:
.

.
4 ~
.
~

, -

.

, ,


,
,

?

.

1 + r ,

.
.
,

.
,
,

$1400

,
,

- .

,

, ,

,
, $1400.
,

,

.
,

,

.


1 + r


.

,
,
,
.

.

,



, ,

. ,

-
,

.
,
,

.


,

,

,
.


,
,
.
,
,


.
,


, . .

,
.




,
.
,
,



.
,
(. .
). ,

.
,

, .

.
,

,


-

:::J

."

"'
"'m

::.
m
:z:

"'

m
m

."

"':z:

"'
:s:

",

"':z:

"'
"'"'

)::

,
.
.

.
,
.

w
c::t

s
.

:I:
;

::

c::t
:)

<
s

""

:I:

""

()

,
, (

) ,
,


,
. ,


,
.

,

: (

.
)

,


, ,
.

,
,

i,

,

, t - .

, ,

t
,

t)
1
(

t)i.
, ( 1

r0 _ 1 -

1t,

r0 _ 1 = (1- t)i- 1t.

(4.2)

.
,

. 4.1




. ,

()
,

, ,

, r

. ,


,
.

4.1.

i - = 5%
'- = 2%
1
t- = 30%

(1 -

~i

=(1 - 0,30}5% =3,5%

(1 -

~i- '

=(1 - 0,30}5%- 2% =1,5%

t- = 20%

(1 -

~i

=(1 - 0,20}5% =4%

(1 -

~i- '

=(1 - 0,20}5%- 2% =2%

,
, . ,
-
- ,

.


, ,
.
, 15.

( ),
.

, , ,

:::J

S1
."

"'m:::.
:I:

."

),

"'m

m
~
m

:I:

"s

:I:

"'m

(Ji

. ,
, , . .

.t:

, ,
.

Sd

- (Ji - G

s
s
s




,
, , , .

c:r


New York Times 26 2003 .

:s:
Q.

w
<::
~

::
:

3-

Q.

r:;

c:r

"'
<

""

:s:

::

""

(!)
N
.

1-

1.1
111
';f'

1-
30-
n

4,25%
1,25
1,12
1,13
3,89
4,81
4,87

4,75%
1,81
1,73
1,88
5,11
5,62
5,31

- ,
.

- ,
.
, -
, -
- . (
)
. - ,
.
, ,
.

. ,
, ,

- ,
.
.
,
, .
110

j!: ..
:z:.
'if-

:s -

8.=

(\\

1-

u
3
2

L-------~--------~--------~

10

3 0

,
,

, .
, ( ) ,
.

2003

. ( )

.
,
,
.

, ,

.
,
, ,

, .
,

. ,

, ,
,
2002 2003 . ,

,
, . . -
.

. -, ,

:
G

, (Jl $1,
($1) 5<'.
-,

,
S<' = - (Jl_ G.
, ,

:
.

. ,

G $10 , ,
. , ,
. (
5
.)

. ,

, .
, ,

$10
$1 .

( )
(
) $10 . ,
,

, . 1
1 ,

1.

::::J

..,-i

m
0'1
::;,
m

:J:

s:

0'1

..,m
m

*s:
m

:J:

::0

s:
s:

:J:

"'
!:1
m

s:
s:
s:

r::.

$10 ,
, $6 .
,
?
. ,

r::r

$10 ,
. $10
,
.

:s:
Q.

w
::

:f:

:I:

. ,
$6 ,
, ,

Q.

':;

r::r

"'
<
:s:
"'
:f:

:I:

"'

(1)
N

...

1.1
nl

':1'

,
?

- ()i - G,
G, , ()i,
$6 ,
$6 .

G $10

- ()i - G $4
. 1 ,
, ,

,
.
, ,

, .
m. ,

$10

. ,

, , ,

(. .

100
$100 ).
G
- ()i - G

()i, :
?

:
?
$1
( ) $10 ,
( , , $10 ).
$10
. ,
, $10
$10 .
1 , $4 , n
n n

n.

$10
, ,
.

,
, . .
. , ,

- ,
- , .

,


,
! ,
, ,
, 1
. 2

( .
15).
.
,


, ( )

(
),

.
, , ,
.
, ,

,

.
, ,
, - , -
,

.
,
,

:::J

-i
-

"'
~

m
::1:
:s;
m

"'m
m
-

"'

::1:
:s;

"'
:s;
1

n n

$10

, n,

n ,
$10 .
$1 - , n $1 .
, , n

, .
XIX . ,

2
n

n .
~ ,
,

:s;
::1:

"'m

Q
:s;

&:.


:
,

:[

"'
Q.

:1:

.
,
;

.
, ,
.

5.

::

:r

5.

Q.

:[

"'
"'"':1:
<(

::

"'

.....,


: , ,

:r"'

(1)


, r



,
; ,

2001

. , ~

~>

Gowth

and

Relief Reconciliation Act (EGTRRA)),

(Economic

, .

EGTRRA
. 2001 .

$300,
- $500, - $600.

EGTRRA .
$12 000 m 15 10%.

, ,

39,6 35%
3 .

2001 . $180,3

( )

. ,


. ,
-
, ,

,
( )
.

2001

2001 ., ,

.,

.
.

$245 ( )
2001 ., .

$212 ,
.


, ,

. (,

, ,
.


.)

.
2001 .

1 .

2001
1324,1
173,7
1150,4
374,9
271 ,5
103,4
1699,0

. .

2001
1536,6
302,2
1233,4
130,0
47,3
82,7
1665,6

211,5
128,5
83,0
-244,9
-224,2

-20,7
-33,4

:::1

-i

."

"'m
~

"'mm
."

"'

: .

: w- www.ea.doc.gov, .

5.1.

;"

s
s

2001 . . .
,

"'nm

.t::

2001 . 1 ,

,
, .

.:

2001 r.?

11 , 9308. 2002 ().

-i

s
s
s

4.2.

:
. , ,
,
. ,
, .
w

, (

Q.

- ,
),

::;:

2,
,
( , .),
, , ,

"'

:I:

:r

Q.

L..
~

10

. -, ,

<(

"'""
:1:

, ,

, .

:I:

""

()

N
Jl

...
\,1

1\1

::r


.
,

3.

, n
.

3,

).
,
, ,
.


, ,
, .

, ,

.
, ,
,

. ,
. , ,

. ,
, ,

, , ,

3.

3,

- ,

!,

.

.

.
,
Kyle's Bakery Inc., . ,
- ,
, ,

. ,
.
.

1. $100
( ) .

2. ,
.
.1

10%

. -

10%.

90% .

3. ( )
(
8% .

1 )

( - Kyle's Bakery Inc.):

.- ($100 );

d-

()

r-

(10%

:::1

);

-i
"

(8% ).

g:

m
s

:I:

!"

Kyle's Bakery Inc.

(")

"'mm
"

: .

- .

$100 ,
$90. $10

, ()

10%.


, . 1 . ,
,

""s

:I:
:0

s
s

:I:
Cll

s
.r:::
s

s:

8%,
8% $100 . ,

, , ,

$8
- , , ,
.

, ,

, ,

Q.

, ,

:s:

t:

1:

:I:
:

Q.

L
::

"'
"'1:
<
:s:

:I:

"'

()

. $100, ,
8%, , $100
.
.

,
.

...

uc = rpk + dpk = (r + d)pk.

10
'3'

i . rpk,
dpk, uc

(4.3)

Kyle's Bakery Inc.

uc = 0,08($100 )+ 0,10($100 )=
= $18 .
,
$18 .

, ,
, .

4.2

Kyle's Bakery Inc.


. MPKf
.

MPKf
; !
,

. MPKf ,
(

).
( $18
)
.

, Kyle's Bakery Inc.


, 5000 ,
. 4.2.

! uc. -

5000

, =uc

4
oL-----~-------L-------L------~------~------~----

(5000
) -
,

. 5000
,

4000

MPKf

4.2

n
n

uc. MPKI

uc, ,
,

. MPKI

uc,

,
.

6000

, , 5000 , Kyle's Bakery Inc.


, (
). , .

:::1

"'
"'m::.

4.2 ,
4000 MPKI
$20 ,
$18.
4000 ,

$20 , $18
. ,
, 4000 , .
.

4.2

, ,

5000

, MPKI
,

uc; Kyle's
,
( ).

Bakery Inc.
,

MPKI = uc.

,
3. ,
- ,
. -

:r

"'m

"'

m
m

"'

"'
m

:r

"'"'
"'
:r
"'
"'m

!:1

"'
"'"'

I=

, ~ (
).


4.1

"-

::

, MPKI

. Kyle's Bakery Inc.,


8 6%. r
0,06, d pk
0,10 $100 ,

"
L..

c::t
ID

<
~
s

(r+ d)pkc $18 (0,06 + 0,10)$100, $16 .

, uc 1 uc2 . 4.3
. /.(1

()

:1!

g;.

5000 ( ), $18

28

..-:
!:; ~

24

~11~

~~::~
::
2s 20
~::~~:;1
t:t~g~

~1;11111

a~sa8.

18
16

1
1
1

nl

:!! 12

1.

1
1

'

2.

i;-~
~

:
:

1
1
1

6
n, ,

Kyle's Bakery Inc.


8 6%
$18
$16

uc 2

4.3

5000 ( ) 6000 ( ). 6000

MPKI

$16

&

4.1



.
,

(. .
, . 4.3).

, .

q- ,

, .

. ,

. ,
1,
,
. , q 1,

q,

.

, :
. V,

.- .
, (
V) q ,
. ,

, .

.
.
, q-
, . , ,
,

MPKI,

r .
q :

1)
,
q; 2)

( ,

q),

;
3)

q q.
q,

, .

0'1

m
"
m

iiE

m
::t

:s:
:.:.
:s:
:s:

::t

"'

:s:
:s:
:s:

.t:

, ,

$16 ( ). Kyle's Bakery Inc.


, 6000 ,

MPKI $16 (

). ,
- ,

:s:
..

:1:

..

L
:;

q:

"'<

"':1::s:

"'

(1)

...

!, . ,

"'

12,5%

, .

12,5%

. .

4.4

MPKI MPKfl
MPKf2.

$18 ,
5000 6000

. 6000 ( D)

MPKI

. ,


;:

q:

1.

u!;.
:::.-32
~ ... ri.s
- ~ .. :s
~L'II"'

" ' L'll

~'

::~"'li~ 28

s~~~

~~
!So;

24

C[:SOL'II
1'1

,.. ... 111:.

~~~8.L'll

iIE

20
18
16

1
1

''
'

12

'

2.

1
1

,
:

:
:
:

1
1
1
1
1

1
1
1
1
1

, ,

r


MPKf MPKf

MPKf' MPKf2.
5000 ( )
6000 ( D) .



n n

6000 MPKf
uc, $18 .

m .
.

, Kyle's Bakery Inc.


20%. ,
, , $20,

$16, $4

. ,

, MPKI $16 (
MPKI $20)

. , 't -

(1- 't)MPKI.

(1 - 't)MPKI = uc.

1-

't,

! = _!!:!:..__ = (r+d)P .
1-'t

1- 't

(4.4)

4.4 ucj (1 - 't)

,
,

't


, ,


. - ,
, , ,

, , . ,

- ,

,
. ,

, ,

, .

, . , ,

10%, ,

$15 000, $1500 (10%

$15 000) , .
,

,
-

::::J

-i

."

"'

=>
m
:r

"m

"'m

."

"'"
m

:r

"'
"
":r

"'m

-i

"
""

.r::

, .
:
-r,
, ? ,

Cf

:s
..

w
::

:1:

::
:

..

L
::

<:[

"'
"'
:1:
<(

:s

. , , ,
,

. , ,

.

. 4.2

1990 .
(28,0%), (25,9%) (24,0%).

, ,
. 1990 .

,
, .

::

"'

(1')

4.2.

1990 .

25,9
-33,4'

4,6
-72,8'
6,1
1,0
28,0
24,0

14,6

, .

: . n: n

11 Notes International. 1993 (19 n). . 1.





?
.

,
,
,
.
. ,

,
. , ,

,
,


,
.


. ,

2002

.
,



,
,

,
,
18% 2000 . 16% 2001 .,
,
2002 . 15% .

,
,
.

, ,

1

.
, ,
, ,

,
1962 .
1986 . ,
.




,
.
(
),
,


(,

-)

,
,



. ,


,
,
,
,

,
, ,

, ,


,
, , ,

,
. ,

-0,66.

,
, ,

10%,

6,6% ,
.



-0,25.
1
.:


Brookings Papers Economic Actiuity. 1994 (2). . 1-59.

.: , .

:
. . .
, : MIT Press, 1997.

11

11

::::1

..,

."

"'::,

::t:

"'m
(')

"'

m
."
m

"'

::t:

"'
"'
"'
"'m
~

:0

::t:

"'

.r::

"'"'

:[

:s:
..
w

:I:
J

..

L..
;

:[

"'
"'

<(

( )
.

,


-,


.

,

,
- . -
).
(
-


,

,
; ,

- ,
.
-
,
.

:s:

:I:

I, -

"'

(1)

...u
.

"'

t;

t;

,+ 1 -
t) .

t + 1 (,


, . .

t,

t dK1,
Kt+t- 1

d -
:

= -

( 4.5)

Kt+t - Kt = It - dKt.
,
( )

. 4.5
, .
,

1929 .;

,
. ,


,

1930- r.,


( 1941

1945 rr.).



4.5. -,

It = Kt+t - Kt + dKt,

,

.1

1 ,


1.
:

1, =p(K,+t - , + dK,).

1,

:1:111

20

18
16
14

~~~~

:<#!
z

12
10

8
6
4
2

-2
-4
-6
-8
-10
-12
1930

1940

1950

1960

1970

1980

1990

2000



1929 .
.

4.5

1929-2002 rr.

: ,



1.1,

- w- ,
.

1.9

5.2.

,
,

t,

*,
(
t + 1).
,

,

t
(Kt+l)

*. * Kt+l

::J

-i

."

"'::,m
::t
"'m
()

(4.6)

4.6 ,

11

: 1)

*- 2)
,
1

, -
dK

1



.



, ,


,


.
, 4.6
, ,


*,

It.
.
,



-

"'

m
."

m
OIE

::J:

"'
"'
"'::t

:0

"'m

"'
"'

];:.

"'

$1

;
$1

"'w
..

.


,

, ,
.

:I:

::r

..

<:[

"'<
"'"'

:I:

"'

(1)

6. ,


,~

,
(

(

), ,
.

),
,

2,
.



, .
,
,

)
(
.

,


,
.

,

,
, ,

100 150, . ., ,
,
.

50


.

,

,
,

1)

, 2) ,

,

.

,

50 .

.
,
,

,

.
,

-
(
, ,
).
,

,

4.3.

, ,

, .
,

,



. ,

,
,

?
-

,
:

::J

?
,

g:

"'m

3),


.

,

. (
~
,
,
,
, .)

:

= ()1 + Jd

4.7

+ G.

(4.7)

, ,

3. -

."

:r:

()

"'m
m
."

""m
"'
"'
"':r:
"'!:1
.t:
"'
"'"'
:r:
::

4.7- .


,

,

Jd
0',
1

G. 4.7
.

:[

"'w

ll.
=

I
J

ll.

':;

:[

"'
<(

"'"'

"'

()

.....u

"'



= + I + G (

-
-
2.3 NX = 0).

( )

.
,
.

,
,

-
.

2),

) . , ,


,
.
,

,

'+ G
-

4. 7:

0'-G=J d.


- '- G -

).
4.1

, Sd (.
:

(4.8)

,
,

,

.

4.8

, 4.8


,

4.7).

-

,

, ,

,
, G
G .

,
1


.
,


. 1



- (. 4.6).

,
- r
. S


( . . 4.1)


.
,




, I< r

4.8.
, (6%
),-
,

------ ------ ------ -


,

::::1

-i

L---------------L----L--------

850

"'m

--~-----------

1000

1500

, tfl,
, fl

~
m
:z:

:s:
m
()

.



6%
-

0'1

4.6


,
1000. , ,
, 3%,
( 1500)
(850),

.


,
6%.

,
,


.
,

.

m
m

"'
;.;

:z:

:s:

"'

:s:
:s:

:z:

"'m
~

:s:

.1::

:s:
:s:

,
.
,

6%,
1000.



6%? ,

:s:

ll.

ll.

::

"'
:s:
"
<(

"

()

N
.

...

1.1

"'

. 4.6,
3%.
3%,


(850).

(1500)

,
,
-

, <<~

.

,
6%,
,
.


6%,

,
,
,

,
,


.


.


. 4.6
,
,

(Jl + Jd

+ G (

. 4.3,
4.7).
,

4.6.
.

4500

(Jl
1500 .
.

Jd
,
-

4.3.

Cd

fd

2150
2000

1500
1000

3%
6%

4500
4500

, .

1500
1500

4.3,

S"= Y-Cd-G
850
1000

Cd+fd+G
5150
4500

(Jl = 2000. ,
6%,
(Jl- G = 4500- 2000- 1500 = 1000.
Sd = 1000.
=
Jd

r= 6%,

6%, . 4.6.

,
,

,
,

6%,

, (Jl + Jd + G = 2000
4500,

+ 1000 +


+ 1500 = 4500.
, 6%.

4.8)
( 4.7

. 4.3
,



.
,


3%.

( (Ji Jd)



3%,

6%.
,
,
,

.
3% ( Cd + Jd + G =
2150 +
+ 1500 + 1500 = 5150) ,
(= 4500).
. 4.3 ,

3%
(ld = 1500)
(Sd = 850)
.
. 4.6,
6%

,
.
.


,
,



,
,
,

,
. ( . 5

.)

,
. .

==~
~~.:

:1:

4.7

=~~
. 8. li=
7
:::J

"

g:

m
:I:

"'m
m
"

~
m

~--------------~--~--------

850

:I:

--------------

1000

n , stl,
n , fl
,


,


,
,
S" Sl.

:I:

"'

s
s
s

;::

F. -


1000 850.

s"'

6 7%

,
(


,
(
,
).

w
q

s
Q.
w

1:

:r

Q.

':;

"'
s"'
1:
<(

"'

()

.
.

."

::r

6%,
. 4.6)

1000

1
52.
, 5

7%,

F,

6%

4. 7 ,
,

850 .
1000

,

-

.



,

.
, ,


- ,
.

,


,
,

,
,
,

1000

1100

, ffl,
, fl


,
,

,
,

4.8

.
G.

J1

6 8%,

1000 1100 .

. (. .

6,


.)

4.8.

J1

.,

G.

6 8%,

.

1000 1100 ,


, ,
, ,

,
. ,

7
,
. 5

,


. 6

, .

1987 . 19

. Standa rd and
Poor's 500 20%,
16%-
,
.

$1
( ).

1990- rr. ,
- ,
,
, .

,
$5 ,

:

q.
,


1987 .,
1990- rr.

2000 - rr.

.

,


; , -

:::J

s
m
""'
g:

::r:
s

"'m
m

""'
;.;

::r:
s

"'

::r:

"'m
1

s
r:
s
s

0,71

g 11600
II):Z:

a,CD

t!l ~

0,70
1400

0,69 .

~ 11200

:s
1>.

r::

s
:z:
CD

!Hi
CD S

ID
ID

0,68

( )

:
8.1000

0,67
800

0,66

:1:

:r

600

0,65

1>.

.....
:;

400

"'<

0,64

S&P 500

( )

0,63

200

""

:s

----~--~----~--~

oL----L----~----~--~----~

:1:

1988

1990

1992

1994

1996

1998

2000

""

()

N
.

....

1.1

"'

0,62

2002

(
500,
) S&P

4.9

, .
1987-20 02 .
1987 .,
1995
2000 .

. ,
1987 r.

,
.,
1990-

2000- r.,

r.
-
1990

.
w- Yahoo finance.yahoo.com;
: S&P 500-
S&P 500,

500
S&P

-
; , n

research.stlouisfed.org/fred.

S&P 500,
, . 4.9
.

1987

1987 .
,
,

,
$1

, ,


25 ,
,

$40 (
, ,

).

, ,

$40 . ,
, ,
$40 . 1
, ?
, ,

- 39% 8 .
, , 1987 .
,
.

, . 2


1990- .
1990- rr.
S&P 500
. ,

,
,
1990-

rr.

,
, 1979 . 3
,
1980- 1990- . ,
. .

4.9 , 1995 1998 .


,

2000- .
2000 .
, $5 .

,
. . 4.9 ,

: 67% 1990 . 70% 2002 .


,
: 1)
;

2)

, , ,

. : .
?
Economic Review, . 1988 () .
. 3- 6; .
Quarterly Reuiew,
. 1988 (). . 2-7.
2
. ,

Journal of Finance. 2001 () . . 815- 849. ,
.
1

11

11

11

,
.

.: ?

NBER Macroeconomics Annual . . . .
: I Press, 1999.

11

:::J

-i

."

g:

:t

0"1

m
m

."

:.;

m
:t

:D

:t

"'m

!:1s

.t:

s
s

, 3)
r 1990- rr.
, ~ ~.
2000- ., , ,
r .

r ,
,- q,

<:[

sQ.
t:
~

:I:

4.1

~ ~.

q-

q 1,

Q.

. ,

'r::;

<:[

m
<{

"'s
~

q,

4.10

( ). ,

:I:

"'

(1)
N

...u
.

"'

':r

3,0

:i..: 1600
~~

~~
u><
1400
~

t7

:z:u

2,5 s

:z:
:z:

\0

:S::s
: 1200

Q.

2,0

0:

:1

1000

tlt

800

1,5

600

1,0

400
0,5
200

0,0
1988

1990

1992

1996

1994

1998

2000

2002

1996 .
q,

),

,
. ,
q

1987-2002

, .

: - - research.stlouisfed.org/
q - n ,
. . 102 r r ,
, n ( ).

fred;

1990- .,

2000

. ,

1987 ., q
-. , q
,

,
. q

2000

.,

, . (
) q,
. ,

,
.

1.


,
- .

, ;

,

2.


,
.


, .
,


; - ,
,
,
.

3.


. -,

(
1 + r ,
).

,
. ,

,

. - ,

,

. ,

"'m

."

m
m

""
"s

:r
s

s
:r

"'m

!:!s

.t:

s
s

, ,
.
,
,
.

4.
w

t:[

(
) (
)
,
. ,

"'

Q.

::

:1:

Q.

L..

:;

t:[

, .

10

<

"'"'

5.

:1:

, ,

"'

()

...

N
.

6.

1,/

ro

:r


.
,

, .
,
, -

Ql- G

7.

. (

) , ,

,
,
.
,

8.

- ,

.

.

, (
- ) (
, ).

9.

, .
, ,
.

10.

-
.
(

)
. ,
;

,
.

11.

, ( )

,
. , ,


.

.

12.



-.
,

.
,

,

, . ,

,
.

::::1

-4

"

~
m
:r
s

,S

0'1

m
"

;.:

:r

::0

:r

"'m

s
s

Q L---------------~-------------------------S1
,
1
1
, fl

tfl,


, ,

,
. -, ,


.

..

..

L
::

Jd,

. (

.)
Sd = - '- G,
- , ' - , G-

"'
"'
<(

:s;
~

"'

Sd

5,
.
,

(1)

:s;
:

r,

N
.11

...v

1'0

,

. ,

,
, Sd = Jd.

.
5" - 5 1, 5 1 =11

r1 -


:
', Jd
G, = '+ Jd + G. Sd = - '- G,

Sd = Jd.

,
,

; ,
,
. ,
, . 5.

; . . 6.

,
.


gJ = - ()1- G.

(4.1)

Sd
, ,
.

4.1

()i
.
ra - t

= (1 - t)i

- 7t

(4.2)


ra - t - (1- t)i
7te.

::::

-i
...,

m
0'1
::,
m

- ,
t

:I:

m
m

:s:

0'1

...,

(4.3)

,..

m
:I:

uc -
rpk dpk, d - , pk -

:s:
Xl

:s:
:s:
:I:

"'m

MRKJ =_!:!_= (r+d)P.

1-'t

1- 't

(4.4)

, - ,

MPKI
n ucj ( 1 - t), t-
(, , ).

!:1:s:

r=

:s:
:s:

(4.7)
,
,

(J1 + Jd

+ G.

(4.8)
w

:[

:s
0..

4. 7.

1::
:

:I:

:r

0..


1.
? ?

::

:[

"'
""

2.


,
?

3.

<
:s
:

:I:

""

()

1-

nl

4.

':t'

, -

?
?

5.

?
,

6.

?
,

7.


?
?

8.

.
, ,
.

9.

, -

, ,

,
.


1.


. ,

$50 000 . ,
,
10% . (
- ,
). .
,
: 1)
$12 600 ; 2)
, (
) 3)
, .

)
? ?

,
, (
)?

$50 000 $54 200.

)
$54 200.
)


, ).

$1050

)
$14 700.
)

2.

$50 000

$12 600

10 25%.

$100. Hi -Ho
, .

Hula

100
150
180
195
205
210

2
3

4
5
6

$1.

) (
) . MPKI ,

, -

, .

) ($ )

20%

12%

>

m
m

."

, .

) ) 8% .
) ) 40%-
.

)
. -

m
:1:

""
"'"'
"'
"'
m
"'
~
"'
"'"'
:1:

J;:

12%

8%

? ,

20%

3. ,
. , :
. $200 000,

w
c:t

s
Q.

:1:

:J:
:

Q.

10% (
), 10% .

,
,

30%.
, .

c:t

(, . .)
6% . ,

L..
~

"'
"":1:s
<(

:J:

""

(1)

5%

. ,
.
.

) ?
) ,

?
.

4. The Missing Link Chain-Link Fence

,

.

, 60

, - 51
. ,
. ,

165- 2,

- . ,
. 10%
.

, .

) ,
.

Missing Link

) , Missing Link , 40%


.
?
)

, 40%- ,
),
,
20% .

Missing Link? (

:
.)


9000 2000 .

5.

6100

6000

5900
5800
5700

1500
1400
1300
1200
1100

5
6
)

,
?

)
.
)

,
? ,
,
4.7 4.8, .
,
, .

6.

) ,
1600 . ,
, ,
.


6000 1200 .

:

ai = 3600- 2000r + 0,10;


Jd = 1200 - 4000r,

:::1

- , r - .
) ,

Sd r


, .

4.7

4.8,

::r
:s:

"'m
"

;.;

, ,

:0

1440

? .

7.

g:
m

) ,

-1
"
m

,
MPKI = 20 - 0,02, -
. d 20% .
900 .
. -

::r
:s:
:s:
:s:
::r

"'mn

-1

:s:
:s:
:s:

.r:

, 50% .

= 100 + O,SY- 200r, -



, - , r -

. 200 ,

- 1000 .

10%

<:t

s:
0..

) ,

.

, :

:1::
:

0..


r.

<:;

<:t

"'

<
s:

"'

r.

, ,


,
. ,

:1::

"'

()

N
.

11.1

tll

':r

8.

20 , 90

10%
)

PVLR

110

( ;

4)

)
(
4),

, .

,
, . .
, .
) ?

11

11

11 ?

9.

4 ,
,
.
200 , 800

200

. 300

. .
,


.
)


?
,
, ?

) ,
,

300

. . ).

,
, ,
?


1.

-
,
. .
)
.

)
, .
,
.

) (

,
).

2.

,
.
.

::::1

."

) ,
?

)
?

) , ,
n .
n, ,
, .

) , .

?

3.

)
( n )
, , ,
, .
, ,

-i
m

g:
::t:

s:
m

"'mm

."

;.;
m

::t:

s:
>

s:
s:

::t:

"'mn....

s:
s:
s:

r=

. ,
(

).

) ,
( ,
), , ,

, ,

. ,

:[

:s:
0..

. (:

, ,
,
. , ,

:f:

:1:

0..

, ,
.)

'-

:[

"'
<

4.

"':s:
:f:

. -
,

:r

(). , (
)
?

"'

{1)

...
.

\J

10

( , , ), .

,
.
-

,
, .


? ,
( ) ?

,
, ( )

5.

~ , ,

,
~.

- ,

,
. (:
, ,

.)

6.

4
, .
, ,

, . ,

.
, -


. m
.

7.

(,

,
) .

r1 ,

r,


. ,

rl' r

.
,

r1


. (:

,
,
)
.


, ,

,
-

FRED

: research.stlouisfed.orgj fred
,
r

1.

1965 . 1969-1970,
1973- 1975, 1980, 1981 - 1982, 1990-1991 2001 rr.?



1965 .

2.

S&P,

,
,

S&P
CPI. (

,

ahoo.com
500, w- finance.y
GSPC.)

.,
1961
S&P 500.


1970- . ?

,

1970- rr.
r

rr.?
1980-

1960-


.
1960

?
.

-1
m

."

S&P 500

:::J

"'m

::.
:I:

:s;
m

"'

m
."
m

;.;
m

:I:

:s;

"':s;
:s;
:I:
>

-1

:s;
J::.
:s;
:s;

3.

(
)

1961 .
.


: (1- t)i- 1t, i -
,

t - , 1t - .





i,

w
<:t

s:
Q.
w

CPI.
t
(, )


.

:J:

::r

Q.

L..

4.

:;

? ?

1947 . ,

,
.
) ,

,
.

<:t

.,
<

""s:

:J:

""

(1)

N
.D

1-

1,1

-. -
,
.

"'

5.

,

.

1975 .,

,

,
,
,

.
?
? .

? , n.

6.

, 1948 .
-

?
? (:


?)


4.

:
,

1.

, ,

: () .

,
,

2.

,
.

3.


,

, ,

?


,
.

,
,

1

$14 000 ,

000.
$11


$6000 (
,

10% .

($14 000);
($11 000) 2;

yf-


- ()
($6000);

r - (10%);

- (
);
.
,

yl ,

. yl
1

.
,

:::::1

-i

"'

:r
s:

"'

m
m

"'

"'

:r
s:

"':s:

s:

:r

"'!

s:
s:
s:

I=

d-

).

, ,

,
cf,
. ,

, ,

,
.
,

:[

+-

::

+ -
.
r,

(
)

:f:

:r

(+ - )(1

L...

+ r) + yf. -

:;

:[

. 1

"'
"':f:s

<(

cf

cf =(+ - )(1 + r) + yf.

(4.1)

4.1
.
,

"'

(1)

cf

, . 2
,
4.1,
,

,
,

,

. . 4.1

N
.11

...

IJ

nl

::r

,
,

cf,

,

.

, .

r,

(

) (1 + r) .


( 1 + r)
, - ( 1 + r).

10%
. 4.1

- 1,10.
.


.

,

, .

1

,
-

. ,

2 ,
4.1,
,

,
,
,
.
4.1
,
,

.

--~

33 000

30000

s:z:

27500

1
~

22 000
20000

LD

16 500

11000
10000
5500

1
1
1
1
1
------ - --~-------1
1
1
1
1
1

----- - 1~-- - - - ---- - ------L--1


1
1
1
1
1

1
1
1
1
1

1
1
1
1
1

1
1
1
1
1

---- --------~---------~ - - - ------t--1


1
1
1
1

1
1

1
1

1
1

1
1

-( 1 +)= - 1,10

----~---------~----------------r---------~-- --

1
1

1
1

1
1

1
1

1
1

1
1

1
1

1
1

5000

10000

15000

20000

30000

25000


/,
.

4.1

- (1 +)= - 1,10. =

= PVLR = 30 000. ,


( ,
= 30 000.
PVLR
+)=
!/(1
+

$13 200
, ,

,

.


?
200.
$13


.

i

10%,

$13 200, ,

000,
$12

000.
$12

10% ,

$1200 (10% $12 000), ,
,

200.
$13
$12 000,
$12 000.

200
$13

10%,

i
,
, ,

1 + i .

$13 200/
$13 200,

200,
$13

( 1 + i),
i = 10%
,

i).
+
(1
200/
$13

,

, $13 200

20%
12 000. i
$13 200/ 1,10
$11 000.
1,20
200/
$13

$13 200

.

,


, ,

:::J

-1
m

."

tn

:::.

m
I

:s:
m

()

tn

m
m
~
m

."

:s:

"':s:
:s:
I

"'n

-1

:s:
:s:
:s:

.:

i.


, ,

r,

i.

w
r::t

s:

Q.

::

:I:
;;r

Q.

r

.

(PVLR), ,



.

L..
:;

PVLR= y + yfj (1 + r) +,

r::t

"'

<(

><

s:
~

:I:

><

()

(4.2)

. . , 1

yf .
PVL R =

= 14 000 + 11 000/1,10 + 6000 = 30 000.

4.1

( 1 + r)

d/(1 + r) =(+ yfj (1 + r) +;

(4.)

PVLC=PVLR.
4.

+ d/(1 + r),
PVLC.
4. ,

(PVLC)

PVLR.
. 4.1,

, PVLR

,

, d
.
d, , 4.,

,
PVLR. = PVLR

.


?

,
,

,
. ,

,


.


.

,


.

1
,

, ,
. 4.2
.

1
, Z IC ,

, Z.

,

. 4.2:

1. . ,

, ,
, ,
1
= 15 000, d = 15 000. , -

21000 ----- -- ---- - -- - --- - --- - 17000


15 000
13000

------------------------J'

--0~----------------~~--~----L-----------
,


,
.


. IC2

, ,

, /" .
.
,


W,

Z, W
W,
. IC2,
1
,
, IC ,
Z.

. 4.1,
,

.
,

,
, . 4. 1 .

0'1

"

m
~
m
::

"'
"'

:0

"'

::

"'m
~

"'
"'"'

s:::.

=
13 000.
,

15 000,



. ,

!=
ct

"'w
::

:I:

Q.


. ,
,

';

ct
<(

,
. ,

Q.

"'
"'"'

21 000,

= 13 000,
, . .
.

2.

:I:

W, . 4.2
.
,

, W
,
, . . W,
.
, JC 1

"'

()

...

\,1

"'

, ,

IC. ,

,
W,
ICl

JC 1 ,

,
,
, .

3.

,
4.

,


,

,
. 4.2:

(= 13 000, d = 21 000), W(c= 17 000, d = 17 000)


Z
(= 21 000, d = 13 000). , W

.
Z

.
,
, W

, Z:

W 17 000,
(13 000) Z (21 000);

W 17 000, . .

(21 000) Z (13 000).

W
Z, ,
W,
. W Z

JC1 (
Z). , W ,
Z. , W
1
1
JC , - JC

, . 4.2.


(
) (
),
: ,
~ , ,

,
,

. 4. .

....(,)

s
:z:

Ql

27500

16500
:::J

11 000

-i

"

g:

m
I

:s:

01

0~---L----L---~----~--~--~~-------------
5000 1 000 15 000 20 000 25 000 30 000
,

m
"
m
~
m
I

:s:

( )


,
( D).
, , ,

4.

, IC*, ,
D, IC*.

, ,
,

D,

, ,
.

"':s:

:s:
I

"'m

!:1:s:

>=
:s:

:s:

D,

, -,

JC*,
, D. (

, , ),

D,

, JC*.
, ,

w
c:t

s
Q.
w

:1:

:
:

Q.

L..
::

c:t
10
<(

":1:s

"

()

N
.D

...

, D.
, ,
. 4.., , D,
, , JC*;

, ,

,
.

D.

,
, , D,
.

15 000,

- 16 500.
s,

\,/

"'

':1'

s = -

14 000- 15 000 = -1000.

1000.

, ,

,
, ,

, (PVLR).
. ,
4000, 14 000
18 000. (6000), (11 000)
(10%) ; ,
4000
, (PVLR).


,
?
. 4.4.
BL 1 - ,
D , , .


, ,

. , , ,
4000

..

s:

~ 20900

ID

18 700
16 500

PVLR

4000

,
j ,
PVLR 4000, ,

4.4

4000, BL 1 .
-

D, ,
, ,
.
, ],

D. ] ,

PVLR

4000.

Jc.

::::1

PVLR,
4000. - (1 + r) = -1,10

r .

, =

4000

4000,

BL 1

BL 2

.

BL 2 4000
.

, BL 2,
,

()

--1

."

400

4400.


, ,

( ) ,
BL 2 , (
) ( ).
, . 4.4,

"'mm
."

"'

"s
s

"'
m

()

--1

s
s
s

J;::.

], BL 2
IC** . ] = 17 000, of = 18 700,
s = 18 000 - 17 000 = 1000. ,
] , D ( = 15 000, of = 16 500).
] 1000 , D (
1000),
2000 , 4000.

c:t

:s:

, .

. ,

Q.

:I:
:

4000 ,
14 000. ,

4400,

'-

Q.

:;

yf 11 000,

15 400.

c:t

"'
:s:
"'

10%

4400/ 1,10 = 4000. ,

<(

:I:

"'

(1)

...

"'

, ,

PVLR 4000
.
,
, 4000 (
. 4.4).
, ,
,
,
. ,

.
- ,

( 2000 ),
, ( 2000, -1000 -3000).
, ,

.
.

.
,
,

PVLR.


4000, PVLR 4000.
, . 4.4.
PVLR 4000
4000, BL 1 BL 2. ,
D (
) ] ( ).
( 15 000 D

17 000 ]), (14 000),


( -1000 D -3000
]). ,

.
,
, -

, PVLR.
,
, .
.

yf.

, , yf. ,
, ,

PVLR, .
,

PVLR, ,
, ,

,
.

, 1950 - .
. ,
PVLR
, .
, , . .

,
, . ,

, ,
, ,
1
.
:

. ,

.

. ,
,

, .
, 1950- .
,

::;,
m

, .
. 4.5. . 4.5,
.
20 (
)

80

).
, . 4.5, .

-,
, -

1
n . n,
,
, .
:

, ,
, .


, , .

PVLR

::::1
-i
"

"'
I

:s:
m

"'

m
"
m
m

""
"':s:

:s:

:s:
I

"'

n
-i
:s:
~
:s:
:s:

ct

:11: ..

i.

:*

"'1:

:11:

r::t

0..

<::

20

80

:1:
:

0..

r::;

"'
<(

"'s
~

:1:

6)

li~

:11: ..

i.
*

"'
(")

"'

()

-----

1-

IJ

20

40

"'

60

65

80

':1'

)
.

, .


, , .
.
) - ;
.
, .
;
, ,
.

, .

. (

) .
- ,
, ,
. . 4.5,
,
,

,
.
, . 4.5, 6,
, . 4.5, .

, .
,
, .

, . ,

.
,
, ,
.


, ,
, .
. ,
,
.
, - .

, , ,
, ,

.
.
,
,
PVLR . ,
(
4), :

PVLR

CJi

CJi -

G.

, ,
, , 100.
100,

( ) .
100,
,

100 ( ). ,
. ,
, , 10%,

110 ,
n


. ,

15

) . ,
110,
110. ,

100,
110. 10%

-100,

100 .
PVLR ,
( )

"'...,m

m
~
m
:1:

"'"'
"'
"'
m
"'

:1:

~
.r::

"'
"'"'

.
, ,

,
, ,

, .
.

,
, ,

PVLR.

"-

, ,

.
,
,

:s:
w

:r

"-

L..
:;

"'
<{

""
:s:
~

""

()

N
.

...

,
, . ,
, , ,
, .
,

, ,
.



. ,

, ,

. ,
,
. ,
,
- ,

1\1


.
.


,
, ,
.

:
,

, ,
. ,

. 1
1
,
,
, ,

20 50%
. ., .: , .

. , :
NBER
Macroeconomic Annual . . . , , :
I Press, 1989; . : . , . .

1982

() . .

461 - 481.

11

no 11 Econometrica.

,
r . ,

14 000, yf 11 000,

6000
r, 10%. ( , . 4.1)
1
. 4.6 BL , ,
1
- 10 76%.

. ,

...u

46200

:11:
:1:
CD

33000

'-__;:lr----

1076%

LO

11 000

10 76%

(1 +), n
10%,

' 4.6

n
BL 1 -1, 10. 1
BL , n , n .
n n,
n.
n n , n
BU. BL' - 1,76,
n

76%.

n n
, n , n
.

n 67% ,
n n .

::::1

-1
...,

"':::.m

:r

~m

"'...,

m
m
m

""'
:r
s

"'s
s
:r

"'

Q
s
s
s

.t:

, BL 1.

,
,

(= + =

(d =

yf = 11 000).

20 000),

, (

), -
( ). ,
,
. , ,

.

w
<:t
:s:
Q.
w

::

:I:
:

Q.

, ,
, .
, - ( 1 + r).

L..

t:;

<:t

r 10 76%,
-1,10 -1,76; . .
. ,

"'

<

""

:s:
::

:I:

, , ,
.

""

(1)

. 4,
1 + r,
, ,

N
.

1-

10

:r

, ,

1 + r .

.

,

.
, 4.
. 4.7 .

10%,
BL 1 ,

, BL 1 / 1 ,
, . 1
10%

10 76%,

BL 2
( ,
, )
BL 2,



. BL 2,
, Ict.
,
, .

BL 2 V,
1

IC2.

, , . 4.7,

. 4.4.

..CJ

46200

t
i

1076%

33000

LQ

16 280
11 000

1
1

----------------------,-1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1

, 10%
,
,

4.7

1
BL 1
/ .
76%
2
BL 1 BL , . 4.6.
2
BL , ,
1

IC

, ,
. V,
BL2 10.

3000 V

.

n,
n 20 000 17 000 n V,
3000.
V n
.

. n n

n (

n ), ,
, n
n , n . 4.7.
n

, n n n
. 4,

n (, ,
) n,
( n ), -

!1

m
m
:.
m

."

:I:

s:
:

s:
s:

:I:

"'

Q
s:

J::

s:
s:

, .
'

. ,

<:t
:s:

..

:r

::r

..

:;

<:t

<(

""

:s:
:

:r

""

()

...
.

"'

':1'

, .

.
. .
4.8

,
.

....()

46200

:1:

33000

23100
21428

1076%

16500

11 000

,
D

BL' .
76%
BL 1

BL'.
1)

D BL 1"' 2) BLint

BL'.

D BL 1"', -

Q BL 2 , ,

, ,

, .

1
10% - BL ,
1
1
, BL JC

D. 10%
15 000, -

16 500.

20 000

14 000

6000),
15 000, 5000 .

D ,

D , ),

, .
10 76% , ,
,
, ,
BL 2

,
2
1
BL BL .
BL 1

,

D ,

BL 2 (. . -1,76).
BLint.
2
, BLint BL .

,
,
.
D BL 2 BLint.



, D ( = 12 000,

d = 21 428) BLint.

, D .

, V . 4. 7,

BLint

:::::1

2
BL 2 BL J

."

:::,
m

Q, Q.

,
Q .
Q
. ,
, , -

. 4.8

D Q.
,

D , ,
Q. . 4.8

, Q,
D. ,
Q ,

D.

m
::t:

n
m
m
m

."

"'

m
::t:

"'

s
s

::t:

"'mn
~

r:.
s
s

.
4,

s:

:1:

::
:

<:;

<:1:
~

<

"'
s:

:1:

::

"'

(1)

...
.

C.l

111
:

) .
( ,

),
( );
, ,

.
, ,
.

, -

4, ,

,
,
.

.
,

( -, ,
).
,

, , ,
,
,

.

:

,
,
. , ,
, ,

,
.

,
, , . ,
(

),
1980- 1990- .
,

, .
, ,

, i<
. ,
1970- ., (less developed
countries- LDC)
, ,
. 1980- . LDC-

LDC -

, ,

?

w

:[

"'w
0..

::

:f:

:1:
:

0..

? , ,

,
. ,
, ,

4,

::

'

:[

"'
<(

"'"'

:f:

:1:

"'

(1)

.D

t:i

"'

, ,
- , .
,


.
,

. ,
,
.
,

. , ,
,
.
, ,

5.1.

13.

,
.
, 2,
. ( :
,
.) . 5.1,
2002 .;
, ,

.
, ,

: ,
, ;
, ,
.

.

5.1.

2002

., $

-435,5

(NX)

971,9

682,6
289,3

-1407,4

-1166,9
-240,5

r
-

-11,9

(NFP)

244,6
-256,5

, -
, r

-56,0

-503,4

()
Ji

0,7
474,2

-1 56,2


( )

-3,7
-152,5

630,4


( )

96,6
533,7

474,9
28,5

(F)


:
( )

-435,5
-447,4

=
=
=
,


= 3, 7- 96,6

- 92,9

: n ,
(n).

(")

"'m

: - .

."

2002

. . . .

18 11

Survey of Curent Business. 2003

""ms
:J:

:.>


,
, .

1)
2) - 3)

:
,
.

.
NX
2. ,

: .

, ,
. , , ,

:J:

"'

!:)

s
~
s
s

"'-i
"'
1!:

."

-i

S<
!J)

"'

:J:

"'



,
, ()
.

<:!:

"'w
Q.

::

:J:
J

Q.

:;

<:!:
10

<

""'

::

:J:

"

(1)

...1.1
.

"'

:r

,
, , ~ survey of Current

Business.

~survey of Current Business. , ,
.

5.1, , ~ Federal
Reserve Bulletin Economic Report of the President~,

. w-
www.ea.doc.gov, ~ .

,

. ,

.
( )
,

, .

. ,
, ,

. , ,
.
.: .
: , .
Washington, D. . : U. S. Government Printing Office, 1990. (www.ea.doc.gov// ARICLES/

INTERNAT/BPA/Meth/opmp. pdf)

) ( ,
).
, ,

, , .
, , , ,
, . .

( ,
).

( ) .
, ,

.

- r. 1 -
, - ,

1
-
(NIPA), - () .
(
Survey of Current Business~ )

NIPA

. - ,

2. NFP
- ,
.

, ,

, ,

, , ,

(, ,
) . , ,


, ,
, ,
, - .

,
, m ,

, ,
. , ,

, ,

, ,

. -
, -
, .
( )
, .
,

, .

, , ,
.
. 5.1 ,
.

i!: .
,

, i!: .
( ),
.
( ),
. . 5.1, 2002 .

$503,4 ,
(NX = -$435,5 ),
- (NFP = - $11,9 )

( -$56,0

).

()

"'

m
m

"'
:.;
m

:I:

"'s
s

:I:

"'

~
s
s
s

.t:

"'

-i

><

"'

!!:

"''
Ul


( , )
,
.

, (,

><

:I:

s
><
m

, r ).


. . 5.1,
2002 .

$1

<:t

s:
..

w
t::

:I:
:

..

:;

<:t

"'
<
"'s:
~

:I:

"'

()


. ( 1999 .
, : ,

1999 ., ~ ~ ,
. )
,
. ,

,
,
.
- ,

, -
(

) ,


() ().
, ,


. ,

,
. . 5.1 , 2002 .
(

) $156,2 ,
$630,4 . ,

2002 .
$47 4,2 ($630,4 - $156,2 ).

.
,
.
. .

5.1

:
.

, (,

) ,
, .

- ,
, ,

. ,
,

r ,
. ,
,

. .

5.1,

2002

$3,7

. 1

, ,
$96,6 (. ).
, , -
( )
. ,

, , ,
,
. 2002 .
$92,9 ($3, 7 $96,6
,
). 2002 .

$92,9 .
, ,
, ,
.
13, .

, ,

. - ,
KFA- ,
+F

=0.

(5.1)

, 5.1, ,
,
.

, + KFA.

.
5.2 . ,
,
$75.
$75.
, , $75.

? ,

.

;;'
111
111
111

Ul

"'mm
."

:IE
m
:r
s
Xl

s
s
:r

"'

Q
s

J::

s
s

"'

, .

."

$75.

$75

. KFA
, -, ,
.

KFA

, .

-i

"'12:

S<
\1)

"'

:r

"'
m

$75
, - .
.

$75 ,
$75 ,
.
+ F .

<:1:

s..

5.2.

, ,

::

::

1:
$75

:1:
:

..

$75;

:::

<:1:

+$75

:::lli

"'<
"'s

:1:

::

KFA

"'

()

+ KFA

2:
$75

...
.

$75;

\,1

"'

':

:::lli

-$75


n
n,

lli
KFA

n,

+$75
+ KFA

3: $75;
$75

n

:::lli

-$75

( )
,

lli

KFA

+$75
+ KFA

,
.
, -

, ,

.
. , $75
, $75,
. , 1
$75,
.
$75 . (
, ),
1

,
.

&

5.1

?
.
- ,
,

.
?
, ,

. ,
(International Monetary Fund, IMF ()) 2002 . :
$217 ,

- $55 ,
( ) -
$10 ,
$152 .
, ,

,
.
,
. , ,
, ,
, .


,
, .

,
,
.
: ,

, 1987 . ; ,
, 2003 ., . 27 , . 206,
www.imf.org
()
0'1

$75,

, .

,
.
, ,
. ,


, ,
, . . 5.1,
2002 . $28,5 . 5.1
,

m
"
m

"'

m
:

s:

"'s:
s:

"'m

n
-j
s:
,1::
s:
s:

"'
"'

-j
"

![
-j

S:<


&

, (, ,
, ),

"'

s:

"'m

(
, ).
, ,

1)

(,
, , ,

);

"

::

::

:r

"-

1....

<:;

c:r

<
s

"'
:

::

"'

(1)

N
.

11.1

"'

':1'

2)

,
?
, ,

. , ,

$10 , ,
$10 ( ,

- NFP
). $10


. ,
$1 .
,

$10

, ,

, .
$1 .

$10

. ,

Honda Motor

,
.

,
,
, , .

General Motors Corporation. ,



.

5.1
. + F =, ,
,
. ,
,

. . 7

7.

$10

$10
$10
$10
$10 ( r NFP

1980- .
, . .
, . 1980- rr.
.
(

).

,
.
,
2001 . -$2309 .
,

1
$2309 .
, $2 , -

. $726
2000 . $393

()
01

m
"
m

:.:m
:1:

:s:

2001 .;
(, ),

"':s:

, ,

"'mQ

.
,
. -,
, ,

. , ,

$2309 - 23% ( 2001 .


$10 082 ). ,

:s:

:1:

:s:
:s:
:s:

.r::

"'
"'sz:

"

:S:<
\1)

"'

, ,

. - ,

100%

:1:
:

:s:

"'
m

1
.: . . I
2001 r.// Survey of t Business. 2002 (). . 10-19.

,
~ ~ ~~ .
, . . ,


, ,

, . 2001 .

c:r

sQ.

$2290 ,
- $2527 . 1

,

Q.

),
, . ,
,

'~

c:r

"'
s"'

<(

, ,
, .
,

"'

()

N
Jl

...

"'


, .

';/'

5.2.

,
.

,

.

.
4

. ,
,

.
.

S = I+

+ (NX + NFP).

2
2.9):

(5.2)

1
.: . .
2001 .
Survey of Cu"ent Business. 2002 (). . 14-16.

11

, ,

, . ,

.: , . .

2001 .

11 Survey of ~ Business. 2002 (). . 25- 35.

5.2-
. ,
:

1)

2)

(,

5.2 , (
) -
NX - NFP.

).

5.2 ,

( ) .


.
, 5.2 :

,Sd = Jd +

= Jd + (NX + NFP),

(5.3)

,Sd Jd-

. 5.3
,
1
, .
, 5.3 ,

,Sd
Jd

. ,

5.3

= .

NFP

.
, NFP = ,

,
(

5.3)

""

m
m

."

Sd=Jd + NX.

(5.4)

5.4
, . ,
, NX
, .
,

.

, NX
,

;.;

m
:t

"'
"'

:0

"'m

:t
:>

"'
"'"'

J::.

"'
-i
"'
!!:

."

-i

:S:<

(5.5)

(JJ

"'

:t

, ,

, .

, ,

"'"'m

- ,

rJi -

, G -

.
5.4.1

5.5

NX =

Cf

"'
..

::

:I:
:

..

:;

<:[

"'

(rJi + Jd + G).

(5.6)

5.6 ,



( ) ,

(Ji

+ Jd + G.

. ,
5.6 , ,
, (NX >)
, ,

,
.

(NX <)

<
~

"'
::

:I:

()

5.3.

~ Q.

,
,
. - ,

,
.
,
(, ,

).
,
,

,
.

, , ,
.

- . , ,
,
()

r"',
. -

ro,

r"',

, ,

r"',

1 ,
5.5 5.4, (}! + G
5.5 - (}! - G Jd + NX.
Sd, ,

5.4.

,
1
, , 7'1'.
. 5.1
.
, .

4% ( ), - $3
( ).
.

, 7'1'

4%, .
, 7'1' 6%,
$5 , - $1 ,
$4 .

$4 ?
.
,

=~

:-:

:;

,S

-6

$4

8.

"' 11

= 1;
&:

~ ~
!

5
4

&3

1
()
D1

~----------,-----;------,------+------------

,
, fl, S

.
,

6%.

$5 ( ), - $1
( ) . , -

sd,

5.1

$4

( ).

"m~

m
::t

"'
"'
"'m
"'
~
"'
"'"'
"'~

::t

""'2:
~

"''
"'

(J)

,
,

. ,
1

( ,
) .

::t

"'m"'

$4
.

,

$5 ,
- $1 , - $4
(. 5.4 , NX

w
c::t

:s:
Q.

:z:
::r

Q.

':;

c::t

"'
<(

"'

:s:

:z:

"'

()

......,.11

"'

':1'

- ) .
,
7"', 2, 6%. . 5.2,

$1 ,
- $5 ,

$4 . , ,
$4 .

? , ,
($1 ) ($5 )
( -$4 ) . ,

. ,

.

, . 5.1 5.2,
. 5.3. ~ ,

,
$20 ,
G $4 . -

=~

]\

Q)

.
~ 6

, S

111 1'11

=t

~ ~

8.

111
0.1'11

=$4

~----~----~~----,------.------+------------

, Efl,
, fl, $
,

5.1,


$1 ( ),

2%.

$5

i 5.2

$4 ( D) ,
, , .

D) .

5.3.

, $

20

(1)

(1) , 1"
(2) , "
(3) , 1"

15
5

(2)
4
13
3

(3)

20

16
5
4
4

6
11

24
1
-4
-4

(4) , "+ 1" + G


(5) , Sd= - "- G
(6) , NX= -
(7) , Sd-1"

: ,

NFP


'f'1l
.
,
(
) .

.

'f'l'. ,

'f'11 =6%, . 5.1.

(3) . 5.3 , 'f'1l 6%, (J1


$11 ( 2), Jd $1 ( 3).
(Ji, $11 , - ()1 - G

$5

5).

, Sfi - Jd $4 ( 7), . . ,
.

5.1.
r"' = 2%, . 5.2, ( 1) . 5.3
, $1 ( 5),
- $5 ( 3).
Sfi - Jd - $4 ( 7), . .
$4 . ,
. 5.2.
, . 5.3,
, ,

,
,

. , 'f'1l =

6%,

(J1 $11 , Jd $1 .
G $4 . r"' = 6%
( ) (J1

$16

4,

+ Jd + G

3).

5.6).

'f'1l =

6%,

$20

"'mm

"'>
m

::1:

"'s
s

::1:

"'m

n
~
s
.t:
s
s

"'

"'"'

![
~

S<

"'::1:

"'m

- $16 , NX $4 ,
. 5.1. 2%,
(
)

$16

$24

4,

1).

($24 )
($20 ), -

(NX = -$4 ). ,
w

l:l

:s:

$4
$4 ,

5.2.

1>.

w
:

:I:

1>.


. , ,

l:l

<
:s:

"'

:I:

"'

(')

...

1.1

"

':r

,
,
, ,
-

.
.
, .

1: .

, -
. ,
.

5.3.
S1 J1 .

f1' (, ,
) .
.


, ,

S1 52. ,
, .

.
.

AD.

- ,
, .
,
,

. ,
, , .

( )

2: .

, -

2.

1.
'----

~~----------~~-

L______________________________________________

,
, , $

51 -

11 -

r"'

sd,

n
n

(, , )- -

, .

,
, 5 1 5'2.

OD,

AD.

MPKf.

5 1 J1

(.

5.4).

("')

"'mm
"

;.;

! ,

:I:

s:

"s:

:I:

J1 fl.

FB.

?
,
, ,

. 1

s:

n
s:
~
s:
s:

-;

-;

"'
"

!l
-;

, ,
r
,
1

.
.
, ,

S:<
IJ)

"':I:

s:

"'

1.

2.

,Wf-------0

:[

sQ.

r::

:z:
:

Q.

L __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __

'::

,
, fl, $

:[

"'
""

sd,

<{

""

(1)

....
v
ra

'j'

5.3,
- 5 1 J1

:z:

r"'

. (MPKf) ,

J1

OF.

J2,

,
,

FB.


1970- . (LDC) 1
,
. 1972-1981 rr.
,
() 2 ,
,
18% .

,
, . 1986 .
60% .
1

LDC,

LDC,

DC -

2 , ,

, , , , , -', , ,
, , , , , .
World Economic Outlook 1994 . ,
.

1982 . , ,
LDC, ,

.
,

.
, ,

LDC

-,

. - ,
, (

) ,
.

LDC.

, ,

1982-1989

.
, .

LDC

( )

,

.

LDC ,
. , ,
, ,

1980- .
- .

1989 .

-,

- ,

()
111

(, ),
, -.

."

,
LDC.
, -
,
.
LDC

m
m

"'

m
:J:

:0

s
s

:J:

"'
m

!:)
s
s
s

l::

"'

."

-i

LDC 1989 . ,
,
. LDC :
1990-

rr.

LDC . , 1994 .,

-i

"2:

S<
(J)

"

:J:

"m

(. ~ .

1994 .~)

. ,
, 1999 .,
$98 , ,
.

w
c:t

:s:
Q.

w
:

::

LDC :
1. LDC .

. t .?

LDC,

::r

Q.

, ,

:;

"'<
:s:
""

, (, ,

c:t

::

""

(1)

5.5.

) .
.

,
.

.
, .

~------------------------------------------ ~t ,
, fl, S

(
) , n

l s.s

sd,

r"' ( ) -


( ) . ,

. -

, , , n .

,
.
, - ,

LDC

,
,
.

LDC
1973- 1974 1979-1980 .


1970- .

,
LDC, .
,

LDC, ,

,
, .


.
. 5.3 .
,
, LDC, -
, -
, .

LDC.

~.
2. LDC ,
..?
, - LDC,
.

1979-1982 ., LDC.
- LDC


,
.
1980- . .
LDC ,

(')

..,"'m
~

m
:1:

s
s

:1:
CD

s
1::
s
s

LDC

LDC

1970- . , ,

, -

CD
~

..,"'
1!:
d
S<

. 1970- . ,

Ul

3. z LDC z .. ?
LDC

~ , - ;

"'

:1:

::

"'

. , ,
, .
,

. ,
LDC , ,

. ,

:s:
0..

0..

L
:;

"'
"":s:

""

(1)

N
.

1-

"'

':r

1994 .
1980- . .

1982 .
LDC, 1986 .

(- ).
.

1987 .

1990- .

,
(. ~ .
~),
-
.
,
.

(Noth American Free


1993 r.,

Trade Agreement, NAFTA)

, . 1
NAFT
.
, ,

,
. 1992 1993 .

8% ,
. , ,

. , 1992 1993 .
8% .
, 1992- 1993 . 1

1994 r.

.: . .

Economic Reuiew, . 1996 (/
). . 1-20.

11

.
1994 . ,
.

-
. ,

. 1994 .

, .
,
1
.



. , ,

(
, ) .
,

.
.
,

( ,
) . ,


. ,
,

.

111


, .
,
.
, 1980- 1 990- rr.
,

2002

. ,

;;;'

1982 . 2

111

111
Ul

"'mm
'

;.;

m
:t

:s:

"'

:s:
:s:

5.4.

rrj, J

,
, ,
,

. ,

( )

:t

"'m

:s:
>=
:s:
:s:

"'
-1
"'
!!:

'

-1

:S:<
IJ)

"'
:t

n ,

:s:

13.
2
. : . ?
. 2002 (/) .

11 Southwest Economy,

"'

, ,
,

. ,
, . .
, .

Cl

s:
Q.

t::
l:

:1:

:r

: 1) , ,
2) (
). . 5.6 -
. 5.6, S

I . 5.6,
SFor IF0, .

Q.

1...

Cl

"'<
"'s:
l:

,
,

. -

:1:

"'

()

SFor

...

"'

L--.,...----,---.,...-----

200

400

600

'---.,---,...----,.-----

800

.nw .n.,w

R, sd, .nw
, fl, S.n

n , n

, n
,

. ,

400

600

800

.nw .n .. w

, S:or .nw
88,~0,,$.n
)

200

5%,

$200 ($400 $200 ,


),

, $200 ($700
, DE). 5% -
n . n
5%, n n
n ( no $200 ) .

$500

? ,
,
, ,
. :
, ,
,
.


, . 5.6. ,
r"' 6%.
? 5.6, ,

6% $450 .

$300 ,

$300 .
, ,
. 5.6, . 6%
$550 ,
- $650 .


$100 ($650 - $550 ) . ,
$300 , , 6%

6%

,
.

6%

,
6%. ,

5%. 5.6, ,
$200 ,
$200 . . 5.6,
, 5%
$500 ,
- $700 ,
$200 .
5%
( $200 ),

5%.

r"' = 5% . 5.6, ,

-
DE,

DE . 5.6,

5%.

;;;'
111

111

\11

m
"'
"m
;;

m
:s:

:1:
:

:s:
:s:

:1:
Cll

:s:
.r::
:s:
:s:
Cll

"11:""
3

:S:<

- .

\IJ

. ,

:1:

( .

5.6, ), -

, .

, ( DE . 5.6, ), . ,

:s:
m

""


, ,
- (

)
, (
) .

,
w
q

s:

"w

I
:

"-

:;

"'
<

"'s:
~

"'

()


. ,
, ,
-
-.

- . ,
,


, . ,



,
.

5.5.

1980- 1990- .
,
. ?
, , ,

. , ,

<< ,
.
: ,
.

, ,

:
,

.

,
. . 5.7

2.

1.

, $1,
, fl, S


,

.
S',

5.7

.
, 1
, 5 Sl.
I
.

.
,
, n , .

()

1"'. S
I , "'
,
. ,
. ,

"'m

, ,

:I:

"

~
m

:I:

:s:

"'

:s:
:s:

"'m

, .
, . 5.7,
,

n
-i
:s:
r:
:s:
:s:

.
,

-i

. ,

51

52.

, ,

"'

"'
"

!!:
-i

:S:<
\j)

"'

:I:

:s:

"'

. ,

,
. , ,
, ,
, ,
, . . .
(

:s:

).

..

<::
::

:I:

::r

..

<:;

<:t

"'

<

":s:
::

:I:

"

(1)

..




:

- .

, m .
,
, ,
.

: (

1.1

",
':

4),

G Sd =
= - ()1- G. 1 2 , ,
,
, , ,
,
.

, m . ,

. G

Sd = - ()1 - G
, ()1.
?

4, ,
, ,
(
)
. ,

; -

1
,
, , rY

. ,

, ()f
G
.

NFP =,

Sd = - rY- G.

Sd = + NFP- rY- G, ,

,
. ,

,
,
.


.
,
, ,
.

4,

, ,

. ,
, ,

, . -
,


.



1960-2002 rr. . 5.8.

(
) ,
, .




, .

n
0'1
m
-
m

>
m

:I:

,
. , . 5.8,

"

:s;

rr.

:s;
:s;

:I:

"'


,
. 1
. 1960-

:s;

J;:

:s;
:s;

"'
-i
"'2:

-i

,
1960- rr. .
.

:s;

.
,

15.

S<

UJ

"'

:I:

"'

111
111

25

15

naeeiii

... 20

Q.

15

<:[

10

:s:
0..

iii

::r
0..

':;

<:[

-5

"'
:s:
"'

<(

-1QL-----~-----L----~------L-----~-----L----~------L-

1960

"'

1965

1970

1975

1980

1985

1990

1995

2000

()

N
.

1.1

...
111
':

2002

5.8

1960-

n ,

2002

. (
- -

1960-

.
1980- 1990- .
.
: n n, , n

- w- www.ea.doc.gov, . 3.1 3.2 NIP; - w- ,


. 1.1 NIPA. - w- , . 1 n.

1980- 1990- .

1981

1983 .

3%

0,1%

2% 5% .

(
,

(Economic Recovery

Act) 198 1

.)

. ,

1984 .

1981 .
2,5% .

198 0 -
1

rr.

1 990 - .l

1991 . 0,1%


1980-
1990- rr. ,
.

( ,

),
,

, ,

.
1980-
rr.

1990-

, ,

,
. ,


( . 1.5

1.6).

1975

3%

)
,
, . 5.8. , 1990- . ,

4,5%


,
, ,
.

2001


(. ~ . ? 4).

,
, . ,
,

1990- ., .
. 1980- .

,
, , -
. -


. 1 (
, 2.11 ),

;'
Al
ID
Al
\JI
("")

"'mm
."

;.;

m
:J:

"'s
s

:J:

"'m

Q
s
s=
s
s

s"'
"'

."


,
, ,

2:

-<

S<
(J)

"'

:J:
:

. : , .
Economic Reuiew, .

1

11

1991

(/). .

1-11.

"'m


1.
.
, , -

. ,
, .
, ,

::[

..

2.

:1::
:

..

,
- , -
, ( ). ,

::

L...

::[

, ( ) .

"'
<
"'s

,
NX.

:1::

"'

(1)

- ,
( ), ,

N
.
~

( ),

\,/

"

:r

3.

, ,

F . ,
,
;

.

4.

. ,
( )

().

5.


; ,

.
,


, ,
(,
, ).

6.


. -



. , , ,
-

-. ,

7.

~,
1980- 1990- rr.

. ,
, . ,
,

. , -,
, ,
,
, ,
,

,$

~--------------~------------~-------------------

11

s,

n n ,
n , fl, Sn

sd,

-
,

.

"'

::1:

::

"'m"'

;
S" 1d
.

1"'
, .

:s:

5 1 ,
- ( 3).

Q.

r::
1:

:1:
:

Q.

r::;

5 1 - 11 . ,
,

:s:

1:

:1:

(1)

"'

,
KFA .

;r

r"'t> 51'
- 11 NX

CD

...u

5.4).

,
. , ( .

5), :

;
;
;

G;

,

.

,
,

(. .

6)

MPKf;


,
. - ,

,
,

KFA.
,
,
.

, SFor

QL - - - - - - - - - - - -

IFor

QL------------

, sd,
, $

, S~oro
, ~0, , $
)

,
, . .
,
.

-,
, -
( ) .

r'"

, ,
.

"'m

"m

"'

(S I)

:t

(SFor IFo,) ,
, (

:s;

4).

:s;

"'
:s;

:t

"'m

-i

4) ,

r'"

, ,
.

,

.
,
, ,

.

:s;
I=
:s;
:s;

"'

-i

""'!Z:-i

,.,

"'

:t

:s;

"'


. 1"' -
1
,

(
,
)
(

""w
:

""
u

<:!

<
s

"

:I:

"

()

N
.11

...

"'

':1"

:I:

CD).

3 4.


. ,

,

. ,

,
.

-


.

KFA

=.

(5.1)

, - ,
KFA
. ,
, ;
+ KFA .

Sti=Jd+NX.

(5.4)

Sd

Jd,
.
, ( ,

NX.

(5.6)

,
,
Cd + Jd + G.


1.


. ?
?

2.

,
?

3.

$200
.

. - ,

.

4.

,
?


, , ,
, ?

5.

, : )
; )
.

6.

LDC

1970- .?

7.

?

?

8.


?
?

9.

10.

:{

:s:



?
, ?
?
?

Q.

1.

(
):

:I:
:

100
125
, 90
, 80

Q.

L
;

:{

"'
":s:
<(

, - ,

110
150

, ,

:I:

"

()

160

1-


, 200

111

N
.

30

35

, ,

, ,
,
.

2.

(
) $25 , - $6 ,
- .

5%

$3

3%

$12
$13
$14

$4
$5

2%

$15

$6

4%

, .

.
?

3.

Jd = $15

$50

Sd = $10 + ($100 ) 1"';

($100

) 1"';

G = $10 ;

1"' =

0,03.

) , ,
, ,

.
)
,

$2
. ) .

4.

: .
:

Jd= 150- 2007"';

=
=

320 + 0,4(- 1)- 2007"';

1000;

200;

G = 275.

CYFor= 480 + 0,4(For- For)- 3007"';


Jd For = 225 - 3007"';
YFor = 1500;

For =

300;

GFor =

300.

)
? ,
,
?

) ,
50 325. 50

.
?
, ,

5. , ,
() (F).

n
0'1
m
."
m

"'"'

"'s

/ =300 -

G=

500r

155
1000

.t::

"'-1
"'
!L

."

225 + , 7,- 600r


IF = 250 - 200r
,=

G, = 190
,= 1200

r.

)
?

"'m"'
-1

()

= 100 + 0,5- 500r

-1

S<
\J)

"'
"'
s
"'m

) ,
, ,
?

6.


. ,

.
$1 ,

r::t
s:

0..

::

.
$500 000.
5% .
$1 025 000 . ,
, ,

:r:
:

0..

':;

, , ?

r::t

"'
<(

"s:

:r:

"

()


1.

,
.

,
.

1-

"'

F-16

)
.
)

) -
.

) -
.


,
.

) .

2.

, 1,

, KFA,

, +

3.

KFA

,
.

4.

,
. ,
.
,

,
?

5.

, ,

?
) (

).

) .
) .
)

(
, ,
).

6.


,
.


, .
,
?

7.


:
. ,

,
. - ,


. ,

,
.

8.

:
.

.

$1 , .
,
.
$10 , $5
, , $5 -
, .
:

;;'
111
111
111

\11

n
t71
m
"

""s

::

s
s

::

Cll

q
s

I:

s
s

Cll

=1

"'
"

lt

d
S
(J)

"'

::

]\:

, ,

. ,

. -

"'


? (:


?)

c:t

:s:
Q.
w

<::
~

, ,
FRED -,
: research.stlouisfed.org/ fred

1.

Q.

, .
,

::

c:t

"'
<(

"'

"'

1947 .

? ,

:s:
I

2.

()

1961 .,
( -
) .

,
. (

....

"'

/ ,
.)
?

3.

1950 .,
(
)

~?

.
,

,
.

, , . 1870 .
,
, ,
. 6.1 . ,
,

( , . 6.1), ,
1870 . , .
,

128

1,4% , 1998 .
1870 .

2,6% 1998 . ,
1870 .
2,6%
1,4% . 1990 . ,

,
10%.
1998 .
. . 6.1,
; , ,

. , , ,
,

.
, . 6.1,
,

. ,

1973 .

1947

1973 rr.

6.1. ,

1870-1998 rr.
w

1870 .

1913 .

1950 .

1998 .

3645
1695
1876
1821
737
1664
3191
2445

5715
4447
3485
3648
1385
3096
4921
5301

7493
7437
5270
3881
1926
6738
6907
9561

20390
20559
19558
17799
20084
18685
18714
27331

ct

"'
0..

:I:

::r

:
.

0..

L...
:;

1990 .

1870'-1998 .
1.4%
2,0
1,8
1,8
2,6
1,9
1,4
1,9

ct

"'
"'"'

: , : , :

OECD, 2001 r.

<(

:I:

"'

(!)

4,0% , 1973 2002 .- 2,9% .


, ,

, . . ,
4,0% , 2,9%,
. , 2002 .
36%
$3,8 , $13 000 (

2002

.).

,
, .
, ,
. ,
. ,
,
,

. ,

.
,

, ,
.

6.1.


, ,

.
, 3:

Y=AF(K,N).

6.1

(6.1)

N, .

, . . . -

, ,

. ,
:

!l

(6.2)

-=-+--+N--

N'

;
N

N -

; -

; aN-
.
6.2
- ,

1%,
aN-
, 1%.
1

. 1

6.2, , -
6.1 ), .

,
10% .
( 6.1)

10%-

6.2
10%,
/ 10%. ,

10%.


, .
,
10%),
10% (!l.jK
.
? ,

, . -
(.

3)

, ,
, 10%. .
,

"'

.J:

n
s

"'

S<

""

-i

"'

!l.jK - 1,
. (

1::>

:::;,

...,

0,3.

, 10%-

6.2

3% (0,3 10%).

0,7. ,
(N/N= 10%) -

6.2,

10%-

, . . .7.

6.2,

""

.J:
I
:

::J

s""

1::>
m


7% (0,7 10%). 1


6.2 /
:

1)
2)
3)

c:t

"

"-

L..

/;
/;

aN !J.Nj N.

(. .

6.2

) :

) . / ,

:;

c:t

/ !J.NjN .

"'
<

"'s

. ,
,
, . -

"'

(1)

N
.

...

6.2.

1'0

'3'

1. ,

t>.Y


t>.

t>.N
N

=40%;

= 20%;

= 30%

2.

= 0,3 = 0,7
3.

t>.
=
=(0,3)(20%) =6%;

t>.N
= N
=(0, 7)(30%) =21%

4. ( ,

)
:

t>.A

t>.

t>.

= =-- -

t>.N

= 40 - 6-21 =13%

AI<!'3N'1

,
-r, , (0,3),
, ,

N
. , . 7 .

(0,7),- .

,
, ,
, , .
) .
aN' , 0,3
, 7 .
)

/N.

/ N

) . ,
,

.
/

6.2,
, DA/ . ,

, . . -
1
.

?
,
, Brookings Institution.
. 6.3

1929-1982 .,
1982-2001 .

6.3. ( ),%

1829-1948 rr. 1948-1973 rr. 1973-1982 rr.


(3)
(1)
(2)

1929-1982 rr. 1982-2001 rr.


(5)
(4)

"

::J:

1,42
0,11
1,53
1,01
2,54

1,40
0,77
2,17
1,53
3,70

1,13
0,69
1,82
...(),27
1,55

1,34
0,56
1,90
1,02
2,92

1,45
1,18
2,63
0,97
3,60

: 1-4: . , ,
1929- 1982, : The Brookings lnstitution, 1985, . 8.1, . 111; 5: w-
, n, . 1, n

www.gov / news.release/ prod3.t01.htm

n
s

"

S<
"

"'
..,"'

"

::J:

,
. 3.1,
,
1

. ,

,
,
3;
,

3.

:::J

m
"

1929-1982

2,92% .
( 4), 1,34%
.


, . (
, .)

<:t

:s:
Q.

<::
~

:>:

Q.

L
:;

<:t

"'
"'

..:
:s:
~

:>:

"'

()

N
.

...

"'

j'

, 0,56%
. ,
1,90%.
(2,92%) ,
(1,90%), 1,02%.

1,02%

. , ,

1929 .

1-3 . 6.3 .

1973-1982 rr. ( 3).


, ,
1982 . , 1973 .!
( ,
, . .
1973 ..) 2 3 ,
1973-1982 rr.

1948- 1973 rr. 1,82 (1,53- 0,27)


2,15 (3,70- 1,55).

1973 .,

, ,

, .
,


. , ,
,
,

.
? , ,
. 6.3,
. 1982-2001 rr.
0,97% .

, 0,97% -
, ,
1973 .



1973 .
.

6.3 , 1973 .
, .

, 1973-1982 .
. ?

, ,
, ,

.

, ,

.
, - ,

,
.

. ,
, , ,

, .
,
,

.
(. 2.3 4
?~

2).


,
,
.

, ,

.
.
Brookings Institution,
, . -
. 1 ,

. - : ,
1967 1986 .

40%1 ,

(,
, no ,
),
.
,

, 1973 .
1973 . ,
,

, ,
, 1973 . ,
,
1

.: ,
Brookings Papers on Ecoomic Activity. 1988. . 2. . 347-420.

11

\J)

""
,.

:t

,.,.,""
."

"'
J:>

::.
...,

."

:t

,."'
m

."

J:>
m

1973 .

, -
.

<:!

. ,

1973-1982 rr., , .
. , .
, 1973 . ,
.

.1

:s:
::

:I:

':;

<:!

"'
<
"':s:

:I:

"'
m

, ,

- . ,

0,05%

,
.
1970- .,
. .
2 , ,

, ,

1967

1980 .

-
.
,

50

. ,
,
,
. ,
, 1 ,
n,

,
n , n .
n

no

, n , , n n n
, n n .
n n n .

2.1

2.

2 . :
n n n

11 American Economic Review. 1989 () . . 178- 197.

-,

. 1

1973

? ,


,
.

. ,

. ,
,



- ,

1973

. ,

,
, .

,
(1973 .), ,

,
.

,
, , .
.
-

? ,

. , 2 , -
,
, , .
~ ~
.

,
,
. - , ,

,
-. -

"'

:t

J:.

"'s

"''

."

J::>

:::.

."

11

.:
European Economic Review. 1982 (/) . . 131- 158.
2 .: / Brookings Papers Economic Activity.
1

1982. . 2.

423- 454.

n // 1 . .

MIT Press, 1989.

11



/ . . . n. : University of Chicago Press, 1990.

. :

J:.

:;:,
m

."

3 .: . , . , . . ,

. . , :

:t

s:

g
m

,
,
1980-

w ?

<::[

:s:
Q.
w

::<:
:

Q.

':;

<::[
CD

<
:s:

""
~

::<:

""

()

rr.

1974,

1
, 1973 .
(IT).


, ,
.
, ,

.
-

, ,

XVIII


. 1830- rr.,
.

1973 .

.
, ,

1970- rr. !-,


.
,

1 99 0 - . !-.

2 -

, , 1 970- rr.
, ,
, ,

, .
, , 1 98 0 -
199 0 - rr., . , ,

XXI

1973 .

.
,

. , ,
1

.
Policy. 1997 () . . 49-95.

i
2

1974 // Camegie-Rochester Conference Series

: /

1American Economic Review. 2001 ().

1203- 1220.

,
. , 1990-

rr.

,
. ?


?
1973 .

-
( ,

) . . 6.4,
12% , 1975 .,

.

6.4.

, '!

1970-1975 rr.
1975-1980 rr.
1980-1985 rr.
1985-1990 rr.
1990-1995 rr.
1995-2000 rr.

12,3
5,9
8,9
6,7
7,9
13,0

n
: ,
W
.

BLS,

\VWW.ls.gov


1990- rr. ,
13,0% 1995-2000 rr.

.
1990- rr.

,
,
,

, .

1990- rr.? ,

(IKT),

1
1990- . - ,
1995 . ,

. : . .

11

. , .

. . , -: Princeton University Press, 2002;

.: . , . . :

11

Brookings s Economic Activity. 2000.



1. . 125-211; .: . , . .
]ournal of Economic
1990- rr.: ?
Perspectives. 2000 (). . 3-22.
.

11

w
><

::t:

:s;
L

n
><
:s;
S<
-

"'

]:

::,

::t:

:::>

m
-
:s;

]:

, .

<~ ~, 1965 .,
, ( ,

), ;

18 12 . 1

1995 .

, . .
.

c::r:
s;

Q.

-, ,

"'

:J:
:

Q.

<:;

c::r:

"'
""s;
<(

:J:

""

(!)

N
.

1-

1\1

,
. ,
2000 .
.
, .
-,

IKT

- . ,


.
<~ ~>
, , , ,
- , .
,

,
. ,

IKT , ;
, IKT

.
. -
, 2001 .,

.

-, ,

,
. , , -

6.2.

, ,

, . ,
1 .:
. .

. , .

. . , -: Princeton University Press, 2002. . 22.

11


, .


. ,

, 3,
, ,
.

, 1950- .

1 , ,
.

,
:

1.

,
, , - ?

2.

? ,
'?

3.

- ,
?


.

, ,

N1 -

, ,
n. , n 0,05,
5% , .

t
( , . )
t 1 N1

1 ,

- . ,

,2

I, -

::

::

n
;><
s

S<
"

"'

1:1

::,

"

::

t,

()

::::J

t,

"

11

: . .
Quarterlyjoum al of Economics. 1956 (). . 65- 94.
2 3
1

::

J't -

""

1:1
m

t,

(6.3)
6.3 ,
.

:s:
.

:J:

:r

,
, .
:

1
Yt = - t;

Nt

L
::

"'
"':s:

=-1

t;

Nt

<(

:J:

"'

()

N
.11

...

1\1

':1'

k1 = -

Nt

k1

t.

-, .

,
, -
. 1
.
, ,

, .

, N.

:

(6.4)
6.4 , t

1
k/
F,
1ta .
, -

1

, . ,

, ,

,
.

2
, 6.4,
, ,

. , , 10 %-
10 %- .
6.2 , + = 1. .

, ,

1
, 6.4.
n.

6.1. - (
) kt ,
Yt - .

. ,

,

.
. ,

, ,

- ,
n

,
, . .

Yt

2
ct kt . , -

>;

1!!

u
q:W
s
111 :z:
...
s
0\1)

Yt=f(kt!

.,

Cl.ca

8~

:z:

"'::J:

::

:s:

-,

kt

"'

:s:

:S:<


, /(k,)
,

- k,. ,
- k, ,
1

6.1

...,
::

""

.
.

= 1.
, -1,
2
, ,

-1

"'
1::.
n


, -

, n

""

n,

::J:

::

:::J
m

""
:s:

1::.
m

, , .

.

, () It t

: 1) - (
) ; 2) . d-

,
,

:[

t dKt.

, .

"'w
..

<::

KtfNt ,
, ,
. .
n. ,

:I:
:

..

nKt.1
,
nKt dK :

L..
;

:[

"'

It =

""'

+ d)Kt ( ).

(6.5)

:I:

"

(!)

Ct = Yt- (n + d)Kt (

6.5

6.3:

).

(6.6)

6.6 ,
, ,
. ,
6.6 Nt, ,

ct= CtfNt,yt= YtfNt, kt=KtfNt.


( 6.4) af(kt)

= f(k)

+ d)k

( ).

(6.7)

6.7
- k .

, t.
6.7 m, - k

. -,

f(k). -,
-

, (n + d)k.
, ,

.
. 6.2 . .

6.2,

- k
.
= /(k),

.
1

6.1.

,+,

.-

n, ,.,= (1 + n)K,. ,+,



, ,
1 + n), - ,= ,.

=(


n , (n + d)k
)

n
,
=

kG

kmax

f(k)

-,

s .
:IC"
W

.. s

')~

~,g

s"

g
":IC

kG

kmax

-,

n-

UJ
><

6.2

:J:

) - k

s:

/(k).
(n + d)k
n + d.
-

n
><
s:

S:<

- n

( ). , - kG,
cG.
) - k
. 6.2,

. 6.2, 6
. 6.2, . , , ,
-
. , -, r

kG,
-. -, kmax'
, .

..;

"'

]::,

:::>
-,

L
:J:

:::J

s:

]::,

(n + tl)k. 6.7 ,


= f(k) ( + tl)k.
- .

- .
6.2, .
- k

. 6.2, . , ,

<:[

, -

Q.

::

k (, kc . 6.2) ,

. -,

Q.

:;

kc

. 1
k (,
kc)

<:[

"'
<
"'s

-,

. ,
k
= k . 6.2,
- ,

!

"'

()

N
.

1-

:r"'

6.2,


, ,

- .

6.2

), - . ,
, ,
-

,
. .

,

. , . 6.2 ,

,

, C1lueuu
.
,

?

.


. 2
, ,
6.7,
, -

n + d.
1

2 .:
. , . , . .
:
Reuiew of Economic Studies. 1989 (

). .

1- 20.

11

, -

.
.
. -,
, ,
, . -,

, ; . .

-
, .

,
.
, ,

(6.8)
51 - t t, S - ,
.

$1 , , ,
$1 (. 4), s 1.

6.8

,
.

, .
51 Ic
,

sY1 = (n + d)K1 (

(6.9)

),

(.

6.8),

- ( . 6.5).
6.9

Kt,
.
, 6.9
N ( 6.4)

J't

1 af(k 1):

sf(k) = (n + d)k

( ) .

(6.10)

, sf(k)
(n + d)k .

6.10

, t .
6.1
- , ,

. 6.3. -
, -
.

,
sf(k) -.
, -
1
,
.

\J}

"'

:I:

"'m
"'"'
"''
L

()

."

()

..;

"'

!::>

::.

()

."

L
:I:

::J

."

"'

!::>
m



, (n + d) k

sf(k )

::[

".

(n + d )k1 -----

..

:r:
J

..

:;

::[

"'
""

-,

<

".

:r:

""

()

N
.11

...

10

- k"
,
sf(k)

(n + d)k .
- k

6.3

n
n -- n

, -

. , -
k . -
k ( , k) , sf(k) i
( + d)k"
- k, . ,
- , .

- k (,

- .

k2),


.
,
,
f(k), s.
. 6.3 ( n + cl)k
.
,

- -

.

6.10, -

.
- , ,

6.3

k*,

. .

k,

k*- -
1
.

- k*

.
6.4
k*
*

*= f(k*).
6.7
*
*
(n

+ d)k*:
*= /(k*)-

(n + d)k*.

,
- k*
*.
,
,

k*.
,

k*

k* . ,

.

- ,
k*, -

k*,

? , . ,

k*; , k 1, . 6.3.
k 1
sf(k 1) , ,
- (n + d)k 1

(J)

- .

:I:

, - k 1 k *.
- k*
(, k k2), ,
, .
- k*, ,
,

6.3 k, k2,
.)
- k 2 k*,
. ,

-. ( .

, , ,
,
. -

k = , n
, n . n

n n n,
n n.

;;

:s:

.J:.

n
;;
:s:

:S:<

"

-i

"'

:1::>

:::.
...,

".J:.

:I:

::::1

":s:

g
m

-,
. (
, n,
.) ,

. ,
.

:[

sQ.

:I:
:

Q.

:;

:[

"'
<{

"'s
:

:I:

"'

(1')

,

,
?

, t

. ,
: ,
( . 8).

8.

...

"'

n n
,
n n

n

n n

n
n; ,
n n

. ,
,

. 6.4. ,
s , sJ(k).
1
s
1

).}.
-
,

k\-

( ).
, ,

,
s s
1
2
-.

, sJ(k)
s.j(k). -
k* k* , k\,

2
2

. -

1.

(n + d)k

s2f(k)


, s 1f(k)

1
1
1
1

1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1

1
1

:_-:
1

1
1

1
1

2.
-

. -----------------QE-------------------------~.----~

k2
k1
-,

s, s2
sj(k)

,
s.j(k). ,

- k* 1 k* 2

6.4

-
, .


,
.

,
,
, -

.
:
,
.
- ,

.
.

.

.
.

,
.
, -

"'

:s:
L

n
:s:

"'

:S:<

."

"'

I:1

::;,

...,

."

::::1
m

."

:s:

I:1
m

1.

(n 2 + d)k



, (n 1 + d)k

w
<:!

1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1

sQ.

:r

Q.

i___L'

1
1
1

::

<:!

2.

1
1
1

sf(k)

1
1

0~----------------~--------~~~---------------------

"'<
"'"'

k;

k1

-,

"'

()

N
.

...

1.1

111

:r

n 1 n 2
(n + d)k
1
(n 2 + d)k.

,

n 1 + + d n + d. ,
2

, -

6.5




n--

, -

k, k 2

- n .

,
?
, ,
6.5. -

k *
1
.
, , ,

n 1

n 2 ?
,
, , ,
. .
-

. , n

( 1 + tf)k (n + tf)k.
2


( 2 + d).

(n 1 + tf)

. -

- k* 2, k* 1.
- ,

, .
, ,

: .
, , ,
:

. ,

.

, , ,
. -

, n
,

, n .
, ,
, .
(, )

,
. , ,

,
.

-, ,

.

,

. ,
, XXI .

,

, .

,
. ,
1870 . 27 !
? ,
: .

- , ,
- - . 6.6 6.7.

, . . -
. . 6.6
= / 1(k)
= / 2(k), .
,

"'

:t

n
s

"'

S<
"

"'

..,=>

"

:t

:::J

3.
. 6. 7


. ,


;
-

k\.

"


~----
= f2(k)

_.....:.----


= f 1(k)

"'

Q.

:I:
:

Q.

L
::

"'
"'"'

QL---------- ------------ ------------ --------

<

:I:

"'
(1)
N
.

1-

\,/

"'

-,

6.6


= / 1(k) = / (k). 2
- k .


. s
,

- .

sf (k)
1
sf2(k),

. -
k* 2, ,

- k* .
1
,
,
. -,

-. -,
. 6.7, ,
- .
.

.
,
. -

, (
100%1) .

.
, , -

,
(n + d)k

1.

s2f(k)

, s f(k)

''
''
'
''

''
'''
'
'
''

:z
''

'
'
:'

2.

'
'
''


- ,




i &.7

= /,(k)
= / (k),


2

n

-.


,
n-- n



s/1(k) s/2 (k). ,




,


-
k*, k*
,
2

-
.



.
,
,


.
,


11
,
.

\.1)

"'

::t:

:s;
L

(')

"'

:s;

S<




.
?

, ~>?

?


.
,

,

.




:
,


.

"

(')

.....

"'

"'-,

"

::t:

:::1

":s;

,


,

,
.



w
c:t

"'w
Q.

:1:

:1::
;;


,
:


,
,
. ,

,
- ,
.



,

,
,

-



.

c:t

,
,

<

,
,

Q.

:;

.,

"':1:"'

:1::

"'

()

N
.

...

\,1

111

-

,


,

-

-
,
, ,



.
,


,
,

,

.


,
(,

,
,

.
.



,


,


,
,


,

,
.


(

, -
) .

(
,

),
,

.
?
(

),

:


,

.

, 1
-

1950-1985 .,

1870 .,

.

. . 2

1870

1980 .

.
,

,
,

,
.

,
,

, 1870
., -
,
, ,
, ,
,

. , .

,

3

1960

-1985 .

, ,

,
,
,

\J)

"'

"'
"'"'
.

).


,


-- 4

,


.

,

-

"''
"

"'

1::.

::;,

"

.: ,
:

// Ameri
can Economic Review. 1986 () . . 10722 .:
1085.
,
:
American
Economic Review. 1988 () . . 1138- 1154.
3
.:
/ Quarte
rly jouma l of
Economics. 1992 (). . 407- 438.
4
. : // jouma l of Politic
al Economy. 1992 (). . 223-2 51.

11

:::>
m
"

g"'
m



,
-

w
q

:s:
Q.

) .
(

, ,
.

'-

.

,

.
,

"'
"

I
:

Q.

:;

<(

:s:
~

"

()


. , ,

.
,


, ,

,
.

,
r
,
-
1


. , . . ,

,


(
,

).

,

.
.

(6.11 )

=,

, -
-

.

6.11

.
:

) . . 1002(
1986
.

al
Politic
of
l
jouma

jouma l of Monetary

1037; .
. :
n
Economics. 1988 (). . 3- 42. n
() .
1994
ctives.
Perspe
mic
Econo
of
l
jouma

.
1

11

11

11

3- 22.

. (

6.11)

. , ,

, ,
6.11,
.
, ,
, - .

.
- , ,
, .

~ , ,

,

.

,

. ,

(R&D). ,
, .

, R&D,

,
.

"'

:I:

:s;
L

, ,
6.11,

, ,

. ,
,
S

, S = s.

. ,
( )

I=

+ d. ,

,.,"'
:s;

..,

"'

!:>

::0
-,

n
-

L
:I:

::J

m
-

dK =

s.

:s;

(6.12)

6.12 d

!:>

(6.13)

-=sA-d .

,
/ /.
,

6.13

=sA-d.

(6.14)

:s:
"

::

:r

"-

::

"'
:s:
"'
<(
~

"'

{1)

N
.

...

"'

6.14

,
s.

6.14,

s. , ,
,


, ,

R&D.

. ,

R&D

.
, ,

. -,

. ,

,

,

, ,
.

6.3.

,
.

. ,
,

. ,
, ,
,
( )
( ).
,
, ,

.
,

, ,
;
~ . ,
, ,
.

?
, ,
. , ,
,
, ,
, .

4,

,
.
, ,

; ,

.
~ ( 5) ,

. ,

.
,

"'

:s;
L

(")

"'
"''
:s;

(")

-i

"'

1::1

,
, -
, -
.

.
1

, .
. ,
,
.

:::.
...,

(")
-

::::1

m
."
:s;

1::1
m

, ,

, ,

. 1
, ,
,

:[

:s:
.
w

:r

. .
,

. 2
,
. ,
n . ,

.
, , ,
, .

';

:[

"'
:s:
"'
<{

, ,

(,

),

"'

(1')

, ,

,
. ,
,
, ,

.
,

, . ,
,
.
,

. 3
.

- .

(, 1 ., .: . . :

11 Chicago Fed Letter. . 1988 () .


2 .: ,
. 11 :
?

1 . . , . . :

Brookings Institution, 1992.


3

. : . . :

1990 ().

1.

893- 921.

11 joumal of Political Economy.

). ,
- ,

, .
, ,
,
. ,
,

1.

-
. ,
,

2.

-
,

, .

.
( ) 1973 .
.

, .

,
,
.

3.


, .
,

, ,
.

4.

,

: ,
,

( ) .
.

6.

:s:
L

5.

(J)

"'

::t

n
:s:

"'

"''

"

"'
..,:=.

]::>

"L


, .

, ,
.
.
, ,
-

::t

::J

":s:

]::>

. ,

.

7.

::[


,
.

() ,

s:

, .

::

:1:

:I:
:

L...
::

::[

"'<
"'s::1:

:I:

"'

()

...u
.

ilY

ilK

t:.N
N

(6.2)

-=-+-+N--

"'

':r

,
ilY/ Y M j A,
M j K t:.Nj N.

1%.
aN
,

1%.

(6.4)

Yt =f(kJ

Yt

(
) kt.

c=f(k)- (n + d)k.

(6.7)



/(k) (n + d)k.

/(k), k - -
.
:
- nk -

dk.
sf(k) =

+ d)k.

(6.10)

,
sf( k)
( + d)k. s,
f(k).
=.

(6.11)

. ,

( 6.11 ),
.

-=sA-d.

(6.14)

/
- s.
.


1.

?
?

2.

,
,
1973 .?

3.



,
?

4.

, ,
- ,

.
.

5.

,
, :

) .
) .
) .

6.

?
.
? ?

7.


?
?

8.

,
? ,

"'

:s:
L

"':s:

S
"

-i

"'

.,"'

"

::J

m
"

:s:

, , ,
.

, ?

s:
Q.

1.

, , 1950 .

$5000.
3% , - 1% .

2000 . ?

:I:

, ,

::r

Q.

'<:;

"'
"'

<{

s:

2.
1000 1300, - 2500 3250,
500 575.
. ,

:I:

()

"'

) , =

0,3,

) , =

0,5 = 0,5.

...
.

"'

:r

0,7;

3.

N:

1
2
3

200
250
250
300

1000
1000
1250
1250

- .
) ,
-
. , - .


? , .
) ), ,
8
= J<.U:3NJ

4. . 6.1
1950-1998 rr. (
.: z
(1 + z} 48 = 199J 1950 z,
, .)
, , ,
, 1950 . .

,
.

5.

Yt= 3kto,s,
, - ,
- .

0,05.

S1 =

S, -

k, -
0,1,

0,31 ,

, ,

) -,

?

,
.

) ) ,
) )

0,4.
0,08 (

0,3).

Yt= 4kto,s.
,
.

6.

1% .

= 6.../k, -

.
14% .

k-

:I:

,
?

L
m

) ,
.

7.

) 90% ,
10%. .

"'

"'

"'"'
..,"''

- ,
?

"'
1::1
..,

)?

n
..,

n 1% .
0,5(1 - t)Y, t - , -
.

=
, k

8.../k, -

-.

d = 9% . ,

t =.

L
:I:

:::1

..,
"'
m

1::1
m

)

- k.

-,

,
?

) ,

.
, t 0,5.

:s;

Q.

) .

::r

Q.

:;

1.

"'
..:
""



(. . ) ?

:s;

""

()

) (
) .

N
.11

...
u

10

'j'

- .

)
( ).

2.


. -
.

)
,
,

) ,

?

3.

.
,

,
gN,. ,
t, ,,
. S,

,
)

- , s - .

) ,
.

,
, ?
,
?

4.

, ,
S,

S1 = sY1 - hK1
hK, , , (
) , . (

.)

,
.
h?

5. , ,
-, . ,

,
? ,
? , ,
?

6.

,
,

k .
= /(k) ,

.
, ,

,

7.

+ aN= 1.

= Akh 1- , - , -
, k -
, h - ,
, .
,
-

s,

;;'
111
111
111

01

"'

:I:

s:
L

"'s:

S:<
"

-i

"'

1::>

::.

L
:I:

d. ,

; , ,
. ,
,
, . . h = Bk,

,
.

"

::J

m
"

s:

1::>
m

, ,
FRED -,
: esearch.stlouisfed . ogjfred.

1.

1948 .,

, ( -

:s:

"'

w-

www.bea.doc.gov, . 9.1)
0,3, aN= 0,7,

. =

:I:

"'

<::;

"'<
:s:
"'

:I:

"'

...

1973 .

1973

. -
3.13. , -,

(1)

Jl

1948

2.

"'

-
1948 . (

w-

www.bea.doc.gov, . 9.1

).

?
.

?

, -

3.

?
, ()
()
?

.
)

1950

(
w-

www.bea.doc.govjeajregioaVdata/htm ).
1950 . ?
1950 .
?

?
.

) }, -
( ) . 1950 .
, . ?
(

) : ,
-- . 11joumal of Political . 1992
(). .

223- 251.

(J)

"'

::t

s.r:;
m

"'s

S<
'

"'

::0

'

.r:;
::t

::J

'

g
m

3 4
, .
, .

,
, , , , , .

, ,
.

, ,
. ,

, , ,
, .
, ,
, . ,
,

,
. ,


, 3 .
,
.
,
. , ,
( ), -
,
.
( )
. ,
.

- . . - ,

7.1.

,
. -. -. ,

, : >>
~. , , ~
, .

:
(. 7.1 ).
.
,
w

(, )

<:1

:s:
Q.
w
:

:
;

Q.

<:1

"'
:s:
"'

..:
~

"'

()

...

"'


-
,

- .
: , -

. , ,

.

,
. ,
, -, , ,
, ,
. ,
,
,
, - .


. , ,

, .
,
.
,
.
,
,

.
,
.
,
, .
.

.
. ,

, , ,
. ,

. ,
- , -

General Motors

, -

.
, ,
.
( ),

&n

1.1


,
,
. . . t
,

(prisoner-of-war, POW)

POW. , ,

POW.

POW
, .
, ,

.
r,
, ,
. , , , ,
, , . ,
,

, .
. -,
,
.
. , ,
, .
, ,
, .

.
, -
POW?
(). ,
, .

,
. ,
.

, ( )
: ,
, .
,
.

"::r

![

;><;
)>

...
"'"'
"'
:1:>
;><;

POW.

::r

]:::

..,
r

"'
"'
m

::r

![

* Economica. 1945

(). .

189-201.

( ) .

, ,
. .
, ,
,
. -

,
,
.

.
. ,
. ,

:[

s:
Q.

:1:

:r

Q.


, (, ,
) .

, ,

'--

? ,

<:;

:[

<

<{

"'
:1:

,
.

s:

"'

(')

:
,
.

, ,

, .

...

"'

, ,

mutual funds, MMMFs),

(money maket
1970- rr. MMMFs

. MMMFs
.

, . . (
), - . , MMMFs
,

, .

MMMFs


, ,

.
.
r .
,

.
1 2.
. 7.1. ,
, :
~.

arpera Mi. 1
.
, 1 ( ,



1, 2 3
()
r. 1971 . 1 ,
2 3.
,
.

, , ,
,
. 16.30
1 , 2 3 ,
.
; ., ,
~ ~.

~wall Street journal~.


~Federal Reserve Bulletin~, FRED
-, : research.stlouisfed.orgj fred, ~Eco
nomic Report of the President~ w-
www.federalreserve.govjreleasesjH .

.


, .

; . 7.2 ~ ? ~ ), ,
, (
) .
,

order of withdrawal, NOW)


( automatic transfer service, ATS). 1 ,
(negotiale

7.1.

2003

"t1

!1:

:t

"'
)>

"':s:
"'
-i

"'

. )

]:::.

:t

1252,1
642,3
7,5
307,6
294,8
5988,3
1252,1
2942,2


2
1

MMDAs

864,0

MMMFs ()

930,0

: - .
: .6,
.

29

2003

..,

"

:s:
:s:

:t

!1:

&

7.2

?
2002 . $609 ,
$2100 , . .
, $2100
$8400?

<:1

,
$100 .
$2000 ?
, ,
, ti
$100 ~ $2000.

:s:
Q.
w
:

:I:
:

Q.

,
( , ),

L..

<:;

<:1

"'
:s:
""
<(

. ,
, $125
. , ~ 55 70% - .

:I:

""

?
, ,

()

...
.

10

:r

75%

1990- .

. ,

, ( )

, . ,
,
, , .


, ,

,
. ,
1988 1995 rr., , -
,

( . :
7.5).
1
, ,

1 . ,
, ,
.

1960 . ( )
1991 .,
n 1990 .

1960 1998 .

- -

) : . , . .

: ? //
). .

Federal Reserve Bulletin. 1996

883- 903.

1999 . ,

r n
.

, ,
.

,
.

( ,
).

!
.

2. 1
, , 2 .

, 2,
, (

$100 000)

,
1

MMMFs,
, (money market deposit ac-

-
(

counts, MMDAs).

). ,

MMMFs

,

. MMDAs

MMMFs, ,
,
. . 7.1 , Fedeial
Reserve Bulletin~>, MMDAs
t .
3. ,
, 1 2, .

2 , (

$100 000)

n,

MMMFs,

(repchase (RP) agreements) ,


. R-
,
, ,
. -

( ,

"'

!Z:

:1:

"'
....
"'s:

>

"'
-"'

, ,

]::J

).

...,

, ( ,

2), ,
.
, , ,
. ,

, .

Ii .
.
MMMFs, , ,
, .

m
:1:
1

s:
s:

:r

!Z:

, ,
.
, , ,
, .

. , ,

, .

,
, . 1
,

:::[

:s
Q.

::

( , ) ,
.

:f:

:z:
:r

Q.

L..
:;

:::[

<(

. 2

.,

, -

"'

:s
:f:

:z:

,
, ,

"'

(1')

N
.

1IJ

:r"'

14.

,
, .


. ?
, , ,
, ,
(). ,

, ,
.
,
, . .

,
,
.
, .

, . .

. ,

$1
, -
$1
1

.: . r,

, .

Economic Literature. 1992

(). . 2086- 2119.


2
.

11 joumal of

$1 .
$1 .

- - $1 .

.'

,
,

,
. 2

1, 2 - .
,
.

7 .2.

,
, .

, .

, , ,
,
. ,
, . ,
,
.
.
, ,
, ,
.

: ,

1\1

"
-

!L

::t

,.

:1>

:s:

1::>

m
::t

-
. , - 2 , ,
,
. , ,
1

? , ,
, ,

,
.

111

"'
~

;;'
1\1

15.

...,cr

:s:
:s:
r:

m
::t
!L

. - ,
, . ,

:

,
, .
w

<:[

, . ,
.

, .

1:

(
,

..

:z:
;r

..

),
. 1

::

<:[

"'

<(

"'s

1:

:z:

"'

(1)


- .
,

.
-, ,

, ,
. ,
,

, ,
.

-
, .

- ,
, .
, .

:
,
; -, ,

.

, ,
. , ,
,


.

1

. ,

1% , ,
(
) 1% , .

, .

, ,

. ,

,
.



,
, :

( ) ,-
, . ,
, ,

,
.
,
, .
- ,


. , ,
$10 000 $5000 , $4000- , $1000
.

7 .3.

$10 000.

- ,
, .

, , -
. , -
- ,
, .

. -
- . -

1
. -, (

, -
). -
.
.
,
.

. ,
.

,
(, )
, , .

1::>
m

:I:

rr
...,

:s:
:s:

.t:
m

:I:

!1:

,
, : ,

, ;

"'

, ,
.

0..

:I:

0..

L
:;

"'
<
"'"'

:I:

"'

()

,
, ,
. ,


; ,

$1.
, ,
-

, - , , , ,
. , ,
, .
, , 1940 .,
, ,

.
.

.
, ,

. ,
,
, .


, .

,
,
.

1%
1%. ,
, , ,

. ,

, ,


. -

,
.

, , ,

.
-
;
.
,
, ,
.

.
,


, , .
, ,
$10 000, $8000
8% , $2000 - NOW 3% .
NOW ,

.
10%, NOW ,
$1000 NOW .

, (

) $2000 $1000. , ,
.
, ,
, , .
,

NOW

3, 5%, 8%,
$1000,
$7000, NOW $3000. ,
,

, ,

NOW,


.
.

,
. ,
( . :

4.1),

.
,

i,

. i
1t" r,

4.

J:>

m
:1:

1
-,

s
s

m
:1:

!r


. , ,

,
im. ,

i
, im

"'
0..

1::
~

I
:

0..

Md = L(Y, i),

'<::;

(7.1)

"'
<
"""'

1::[

""

(!)
N

.11
1-

\,1

"'

:r

Md - ;

- ; - ; i -
, ; L -
7.1 , Md

. ,
( ),

Md , ,


. 7.1 ,

( L)
i.
,
.

i ,
.

7.1

im,

. , , ,

,
(,

),
7.1 .
im .

i
.

2.13,

i rc. ,

7.1,

i + rc.

rc i

Md = L(Y, + rc).

(7.2)

, rc

7.2

.


.

Md
(, , . .).
.

7.2 ,

Md

-=PxL(Y,r+t" ).

(7.3)

7.3

, , ,

, . Md/
, ,

. 7.3 , Mdjp
( )
,


,
7.3, .

t.

L,

I, I

( 7.3)
, ,
.

, ,
, ,
, .

.
,
.

.
.
.

!1:
I

"'
"'
"'"'
"'
J::>
)>

-1

..,r:r

"'

"'m

( - ),

.t::

- . ,

!1:

, ,

,
, .


. 1
, , .
: . r, .
Q;Jarterly Review of Economics and Business. 1986 (). . 73-83.

1

11

9. ,

<J

n n

0..

<:;

"'<
~

n
n

:1:


}!

(1)

N
.

"'

'3'

1-

'

s:

:1:

s:
t:

0..


n
r n

.
,
, (
) ,

. ,
(
), ,
.

.
,
.
,

. ,

, .
,
.

.
, .
,

<J - ,
<J . (automatic teller machines,
), , , ,

,
. ,
.

,
~~ ,

, .

, ,

, .
.


.
,
, -

, . ,
r

1%. , ,
2/ 3,
3% 2% (2/3 3% = 2%).

1%.

, .
, ,

6%

1%, .
20%- , 6% 20% ,
5%.1 ,
,

-0,1, 5 6%
2% ( -0,1 - 20% = -2%). , ,

, .

?
,

. -,
,

. ,

1973 .

1, ,
, ,
2/ 3. 2 1
5 6%
20%.

2 .:

577-638.

/ / Brookings Paper Economic Activity. 1973.

4.

):

.,.:1:...,
s
s

t::

m
:1:

!!:

, .
,

1,

1,

1.

, .
w

<t

:s:
Q.
w

:1::
;

,
, .

-,
,
. , ,

Q.

L
;

-0,1

- 0,2.

<t

, ,

"'<

:s:

"'
~

:1::

"'

(1)

.
,

7 .3.

...u

"'

, ,
, .
~~

.
( , )
.
V,

V=

(7.4)

,
, . .

, ,
7.1 1
2 1959 2002 .

, . 1
.

,
:

Md

-=kY

'

(7.5)

1

, , XIX -
. .: . .

. - : Macmillan, 1911.

.z

10

111

~
:11:

11

'

5
4

2

LL~~--L-~-L~~--L-~~~~--~L-~-L~~--~~~

1960

1964

1968

1972

1976

1980

1984

1988

1992

1996

2000

1
1,
2 -
2.

Ml

1959-2002 rr.

1 1981 .,
1980- . ,
, . 2
, 1,

.
: 1 2 -

FRED

-,

- w- r .

Mdj - , - ,

k-

L( ,

7.5

r + 7t) k .

,
, 1/ k,
. 1

? . 7.1, 1

."
2:
::t

"'
"'-1
"'"'
J'
)>

):::1

::t

..,
r:

.,

"'

rr. , . 1
1980- rr. .

r:.

1981

1980-

: ,
,

1
1
,
, Md
(
) .

V= 1/k.

"'

m
::t

2:

, , . (
, , ,

),

1980- .
1980- .

s:
0..

:I:
:

0..

L
~

, 1
1.
2 , . 7.1,
. . 7.2

1.
2
,
.

c:t

<
><

s:
:

:I:

"'

(1)

1-

1.1

"'

1973

. ,

1 ,

7.3, .
.

1974

1976

. 1 (.

, ,

7.2)

~ .'
1970- . 1

1980- . , ,
- , .


. ,
,
1970- 1980- .


,
.

(1), .
1970- .
1.
,

~ .

,
1

683-730.

11 Brookings Paper Economic Activity. 1976. . 3.

1, 1

. 1980-

NOW,

rr.,

1. 1,
1, .

7.2.

4% 1 1979 21% 1
1982 . 1 ,
1 1970- rr. , ,
, , 1980- rr.

1990- . 1 .

1994 . sw-,
(
14).
, 1,

18

15

'#.

i
]

(MMDAs),

2,

12

6
3

-3
-6~~~~L_~_L~~~L_~_L_L~_ _L_L_~_L~~~L_~-L

1960

1964

1968

1972

1976

1980

1984

1988

1992

1996

2000

1 2
r

. 1

1960-2002

Ml

, -

1970- . 1

1980- 1990- . 2
1970- ., 1990- .,


.
:

FRED

-.

1 : . .

396. , ,
.

11 American Economic Review. 1984 (). . 392-

1. ,
,
MMDAs, sw-

.
1 1994 .

<:t

Q.

r=

:1:

:I:
J

Q.

, sw-. 1994
2000 ., ,
1. 1 . 7.1

1 . (, 1
1,
1 .)
sw- 1,
2,

, 2,

:;

2 . , 2

MMDAs,

<:t

. 1990- .

"'
<

(. . , 2),

:1:

:I:

(1)

, ,
, .
2 ,
. 2000- . 2 ,
1992 .

1-

111

. ,

,
.
,

.

7 .4.

,
, .

(, )-
,
. ,
.

.
,

(
, ,
. . ).
,


( ).
,

. ,
.

:

3 4,
.
,
,
.

, -
.

.
,

:
- .
, ,
. ,
,
im.
.

, , , ,
. . ,
,

i = r + n, r- ,
.
NM.

n -

, ,
, ,

.
, ,

,
.
,
.
,

d, nd,
,
, ,

Md.

NMd. ,
,

7.6

"'

"'

Md + NMd = .

"'

>
::j
s

..,

.
,

:t>

+ nd = .

!!:

(7.6)

s
s

};:

I
\[


.
,

NM = .

:s:
0..

w
:

:t:
:

0..

L..

7.7

7.6,

NM,

(7.7)

(Md- ) + (NMd - N) = .

(7.8)

Md - 7.8
, ,
. NMd - NM
7.8 . aiCmuo.
, Md

, Md- .
7.8 , , Md - , NMd- NM

ID

; . .

c::t
<(

":s:

:t:

"

(')

...
.


: ,

1.1

. ,
,
.
, .

"'

. ,
,

. ,
, . .

= L(Y, r+n" ).

7.9 -

(7.9)

. -

Mdj P,

7.3. 7.9,

,
, .

aiCmuo :

, , ,
r n.


. ,
(
) .
-

,
:
,

r .

,


.
,
,

, ,


, 1


,
,
,

3,

-

.
4 ,




).

-
.


,


,

L(Y, r +

7.9

1t8 ),

P=---L(Y, r + 1t 8 )

(7.1 0)

7.10,



L(Y, r + 1t8 ).

,

r

1t"

L( , r + 1t")

,
,


.



,

,
.

7.10

, , .


7.5.

7.10 ?
,

,
;

9,




.
,
9

,

,





1

3,

"t:J
!1:
::t:

"'
>

"'
"'
:t:>

::t:
f1'

...,

s
s

::t:

!2:

,
).
7.10

7 .5.


,
, ,

c:r
:s:
Q.

:I:

::r

Q.

c:r

"'<
:s:
"'

7.4

-
.


,
,

,
.
,

,


,
.

,
,

:

7.1

:I:

"'

(1)
N

1-

"'

':1'

tll>

, r + n )

(7.11 )

- L(Y ,r+n")'



!).


.

7.11 -

n.
,

M j P,
,

7.11

7.10 ,


.
r+ n). ( , . 7
L(Y,

7.11

.)

,


, ,
euez

7.11

ua .

,
.

,


7.11
.

7.3),
(


: (

r + n.


.

.


11





Y
Yj
rtyf).

,

/


,
7.11,


rt~j

1%.

f).Yj Y -

(7.1 2)

7.12


.

7.12
,






, ,
.


10% ,

3%
,


2/ 3.
7.12 ,
10%

- (2/ 3)(3 %), 8% .


,


.
(
),
,


-

,

( ,


),



.


( .
7.12)

(
, ,

).




.


,
:


2/3,

15% , ,
7.12,


10%
(2/3 15%).

2/3,


15% ,

-10

% .


20%

.



.

7.3,

199 5-20

01 r. ,

4


( cou ntri es
in tran sitio n).

\!:

:I:

"'
)>

"'

-i

:s:

"'

~
1:>

:I:

..,
:s:
t

:s:

s::
m
:I:

\!:

140

'#.
i 120
~

i:z:

100

:s

:z:
11)

w
o::t

Q,

80

>

:s

Q.

60

:1:

:r

Q.

40

L..

<:;

o::t

"'
:s
"'

20

<(

60

:1:

"'

(1)

80

100

N
.

...v

10




1995 - 2001 rr.


,

,
.

120

140

160

180

,%

7.3

, ,



80% .
80% ,

-



.
:

2003 .,
International Financial Statistics, , .





. ,



- ,
80%


80% .

,


?


,
,
)


.

,

,

(


,


)


.
,




.

,
,

.

r (


),

1t"

,

r + 1t .

,

,
7.12,


,

.

(,

,
)


7.12

. ,
-



.
7.12
,

.
7.12,

,

111
111
111

.....

7.12)

( ,



).

.


,
-

-



.

,



,

.

r,



),

r + 1t"
,


1t .
,

(,

),

1::>

m
::t

..,cr

"'

"'

.r::.
m
::t

11:


,
,
,

.
,
.



;
.


, ,

. 7.4.

w
q:

:s:
Q.

w
:

:t:
:

Q.

';

q:


.
,

rr.,
1960- 1970-

1960

2003

<
:s:

""

:t:

""

()

~ 18

11

.,. 16

,_
.

14

\,1

"'

':1'

12
10

8
6
4
2
-

-~------~-----'---

~------~-----'----

'------~----~----

1960

1965

1970

1975

1980

1990

1985

1995

2000


n ,

1960-2003 rr.

(,
,

1980- .),
,

-.
FRED




n
.

,

(,
,
.

n

1980- rr.),

1980- rr.

. , 1970 - 1980- .


, ,

1970- .
1980- rr.
(. . 2.2,

.)

1.

- ,

.
,

2.


-

.
,

, .
1


, 2


.
.

3.


:
,
.

4.

.

,
,
: ,
.

.

,

, .

5.

::I:

.
-

,
,

,
.

,

2
, 1,

2
.

6.

1::1

,

, -

cr
.,

"'

"'
m

t=
::I:

sz:

),
(


,

,

7.
w
<:1


.
.


.
,

"'w
..

1::

:1:

:I:
:

..

r:;

<:1

"'
"':1:"'
<(

:I:

"'

(1)
N

......
.

"'

':1'

1
2


Md

(7.3)

-=Px L(Y, r+t").

d;
,

,


.
.

i (

t")
r



.

V=

(7.4)

)
( ,

.
.

=L(Y, r+1t) .

(7.9)


,
/

L(Y, r + 7t).

(7.12)

/
.


Jr

.iY/Y .


1.
2.

.



?
?

3.


? ,

4.

?

?

5.

6.


.

.

7.

8.

9.

m
:t

..,rr

s:
s:
r:
m

:t
!!:


1.

J:>

Md

-=500+0,2 -100 0i.

= 100,

1000, i

= 0,1 0.

= 100 = 200.

,
, ),

,
,

)
w

ct
s

.
,

Q.

$100 000,

.

)
(

000
$50


, $5000

2.

:J:

:r

Q.

:;

ct

10

<
s

"'

:J:

,
)

.
?


) ,

"'

()

...
.

"'

3.

$80 000 $20 000

.

?

,
, 5.


10 000,

2.
)

.
5000

,
,
,


,
.
?
6000

4.

r= 0,10.
= 100
0,5,

- 0,1.



)
106
=


,
:
(
?
0,10)

( r

7.11.)

r = 0,11

100)?

5.

) ,

r= , 11.

,
,
?
,


:

L(Y, r + n) =

0,01,
r+ne

-
, 1t" -

.

, =
150.


, r = 0,05
.
) ,

10% ,
,

= 300.


? (
:

,
?)
) ,
=
300.
,


5%
.

,

,


?

6.



.

2/3,


-0,1.

4,5%
,

, ,
.



.
)

)
,


!!:
:r

><

)>

><

-i

"'"'
!!'

1.



?
2?
.


,
m

,

)
,

,


.

J:>
m

:r

...,rr

"'

"'

:r
!!:


(
).

rr. 1
. 7.1 , 1980-
.

2.
w

:[

"'w

( 7.1),
,

Q.

J::

3.



)
(

Q.

,_

:;

:[

,

) ( .)

"'<
"'"'

"'

()

4.



, ,

,
.


?

.

.


,
. -tt:,


t: FRED
fred
j
: research.stlouisfed.org

1.

,

1959 .

,
1 2

.)
(



.
1 2 1961

, 1978 .-

(
1976, 1977 1978 r.

1978 .-

1977 1978 r.)
1976,


1 2?
( )

2.

)?




?


1961
.

.

."
![
:

><
}>

><
-i
s

"'
"'1:>
m
...,.,.

s
s

![

I I
R


,
. -
, -

.
,

,

,
,

'l .


,

,

-

.
,



,

,

.
,


,


.

, n


,

n
,
,


( )

.

:

3

2)
;

1)
.

<

"'

s
fs

:;

1,

,
.

"'u

<

"'

w
';
s

:1:

::

"'
<
"':1:
(')

..

s
:JS

:;

"':::1

w
:JS

10

:;

~
1'1'1
.

1-

"'

)
-
(

,
,

9- 11.

.


,

8.1 . ?

,
~

.

1848 ., ,

~

.
~

Reseach, NER),
(National ureau of Economic

R
NE
.
1920
,

,


. NER

1946 .

. ) (
1970 1978

,

NER).


) .
(


() ,

,

;

-
. 1



.
.

1.

,

,

.

,
,


,


,

2.

8.1 -


- ,

.



,



.

,
.

,
.


, (1),

.
,


,
()
.

,
(),

.


-

''
'_;,' -

- :
:

()

1
1

:1::1
m

:::.

"'

!!:

.r::

QL-----~---------

:s:
~

!!:

~--------~-------

.

()
. -

--~~-------

,

- .
, ,




,
.

1 .

, . .

Research, 1946 . . 1.

. - : National Bure

au ofEconomic


,

.
,

8.1

.
()

<
s

><
f-

::

"'
u

<
><

><

,

,

1

.

~
><
<

NBER.

:1:

::1:

.

,

:1:

Jj

"'

:;


, ,

.
,



.

1:::[
1"1
.11

...u

:r"'

3.



.
,

~.

,
,


- .

,
,
,

4.


.

,


. ( 8.1

-
,

,
-
.)



, . .



.
,


,
,

. ,

,

5.

, -

, n

n,
,

.
n

-
,

,
t

.

8. 2. ,k1
:

NBER
, 1
. 8.1.

,
1854 .

(1914 - 1918 . )

(1861 - 1865 . )



.
, . 8.1,


. ,


65

1873

1879

. ,
,


1870-

rr.
338 ,
382 .

1945 r.

2000 .
(554 )

(96 ) .
1854- 1914 rr.

,
, -


1930- rr.
1920- .


1929 .,
,

1929 .,
.
1929 .
1933 .
30%.


3 25%, ,
,
. ,


(1973 - 1975 1981- 1982
.).
30 % -
25%-


1973 -1975 .

3,4%,
4 9%;

1981- 1982 rr.
2,8%,

7 11 %.

,

,

.


NBER . : . ,

.
NBER
:

1986.

11

. . .
:
NBER w-

University of Chicago Press,


NBER, www.nher.or g

:
m
:::,

"'

sz:
m


8.1.
)
NBER

1854 . (

<(

"'sf-

(

)

1857 .
1860 .
1865 .

18
8
32

1869 .
1873 .
1882 .
1887 .
1890 .
1893 .
1895 .
1899 .
1902 .
1907 .
1910 .
1913 .
r 1918 .

18
65
38
13
10

(
)

:;

1854 .
1858 .
1861 .

"'
<(

"'w

:1:

:I:

"'"'
"':1:

..

<(

s
JS

:;

"'::rs
w
JS

"'

:;

1867 .
1870 .
1879 .
1885 .
1888 .
1891 .
1894 .
1897 .
1900 .
r 1904 .
1908 .
1912 .
1914 .

lt\
.

f-

1.1

"'

':r

1919 .
1921 .
1924 .
1927 .

1933 .

1938 .

1945 .
1949 .

1954 .
n 1958 .
1961 .

1970 .
1975 .
1980 .
1982 .
1991 .
2001 .

: w-

30

22
46
( )

18

34
36
22
27
20
18
24
21
33
19
12
44

( )

10
22
27
21

1920 .
1923 .
1926 .
r 1929 .

1937 .

80

()

13
()

1948 .
1953 .

11
10

( )

39
24
106

18
14
13
43

18
18
23
13
24
23
7

1945 .

( )

37
45

17

1957 .
1960 .
1969 .

8
10
11

1973 .
1980 .
1981 .
1990 .
2001 .

16
6
16
8
8

( )

36
58
12
92
120

NBER, www.ner.org/c ycles. html

,
,

;

,
-

. ,


, ~ .
.

,

,

, .
8.1.

1929
1933 .


.

1933
.
,
,
4
,

,


,
1933 1937 . 1937 .
1929 .,


14%.
,
,


1929 .,



,
.

1937 .
,
.
,

1938 ., 1939 r.
17%.



.
-


1941 .

. -


,
,


1939 1944 . .

2%
1944 .,

1943 -1945 .,

1,2%.





1945 .

,
.


1946 . ,

.
,

,
1945 1970 rr.,

,

NBE R

.

1945 1970 rr.

3,3%

1957-1958 rr.,

8,1%
.

1949

-1953 rr., ,

1961 -1969 rr.


1945 1970 rr.
,
,

~.

106 -
1961 - 1969 rr., -

;'
111
111
111

00

m
:::,

"'

!L
m

.t:

s:

"':::,
!L

...:

"'::s;f-

::s;
;

0:

...:

"'


,

,


1960- rr.

. ,

,
() 1973 .


.

3,4%,

2!


1973- 1975 .

,
9%

,
,

rr.,
1970

1973- 1975 rr.

"'

=r

::s;
:f:

:I:

"'

Q.

"'

...:

:f:

::s;
;

::s;

:::r

2!

"'

c:t

,
,

1981 -1982 .


, 1973 -1975 rr.,
,
.


11%,

;

, 11

11.

4%

.
.

1981 - 1982 rr.,

.
,
, 1990 .

1991 .,

7,7% 1992 .-

).


1990- 1991 rr.

107
2000 . ,
. ,

, 1990- rr.


,
,

rr.

1990 1980-
1960- .



2001 .,

.



,
200 1 .




(NBER),

,

. NER

1854 . ( . . 8.1).
2001 .
,

1990 1991 .

. ,

1982

2001 rr.,

, , ,

,

.

2000 . ,
2001 .
11 2001 . ,

- (
)

,
.


,
,


- ,

NER,
, -

2001.

2001

. ,

,

NER.

,

,

( , );

);

(
,

) .

,

, ,
- 2000 2001
rr. ,
.
(. 8.2)

2000 .


(, ,
. .),


- ,

2000

. (

2/ 3 .


,
,

2000 .
.
2001
. (. 8.3),

2001 . (
,

2000 .).


NER

2001

.
-

g~

"'

i~

::

8.~

<

:s:
f:s:

"

"'
u
"'
w

:s:

<

:r
:s:
::

117

::

119

11

~ ~

115

i~

s 113

8.

:I:

"'"'

111

Q..

"'

<

::

109

:s:
:Jj
::

"'::r

:s:

:Jj

"'

::

107
----------------L---

105 ~--------------~~------------~2002
2001
2000

2003

w
1:::{


n
n

.
2000
n
2000 .,
NBER

n
,

n ,- 2001 .,

2003

8.2

2000-

2003

.
:

.stlouisfed.org/fred
FRED -, research


,
,
,

.

, 2001 . ,
2001 .
. ,
1,6 ,

,
(

NBER

. w-

NBER www.nber.org/cycles j recessions.html).

,
,

,

. ,
,

,

,
.

1929 .

-

1945 .
,
1929 .

,
NBER (. . 8.1),

'

..

)(

"'"'"'
~5s
~J

133,0

t:
go.

z.

:1 z

~ j

132,5

,J
Z>S

~=
"'
~
\Q

132,0

131,5

131,0

130,5

130,0
2000

2001

2002

2003

n




2000 n
2003 .
2001 .,
,
n NBER

n.

i 1.3

2003

FRED -,

2000

research.stlouisfed.org/fred


,
-

1945

,



,


1990- .
,


,

1945
.
1929 .



.

, -


,




. ,
,


,


,

.

,

,
,


,
. 1

.:
n
?

11 American
314-334;
:
1869- 1908 rr. // joum al of Political Economy.
1989
(). . 1- 37;
n
n // Quarterly
joum al of Economics. 1991 (). . 1-31.
Economic Reuiew . 1986

(). .

1929 .

<
s:
1s:

"'

::

"'
u
"'

<

s:

"'
"'<

(!)

Q.

s:
::;;

~
::r

s:

::;;

"'

::

q:

,

,

,


, ,

.

,
1 1929 .

,
,
.

.
,

1929 .

,


,
.



, 1980- rr.

1980-

rr.



,
,

, ,

,

, ,

,

,

20 40%

33%,


- 27, - 50%.

,


,
,


.

.

1984 .,

,
,
,
,

,

.

- ,


,
,

.
,


,
,

1991 .
2,

, .

.

,
1



.
,


. ,





.
,


- 1 ,

.
,
,
,
-,

,
;

1980-

rr. ,

,


,


.

, .

,

1980- rr.


. 1970- rr.



.
,


,
,


.

,


. ,

,

15%

,

-
15%.

,
.

1960- 1970- .
.



.
1979 .

,

,


1

. :

11 Economic
Policy Review.
-
. 2002 (). . 183- 202.

~
m

::,

"'

!l
m

20 30%
. ,
,

<
><
s

::
0:

<

><
u
w
:r
s

::r


, ,
20
15%,

30%,


15%.

:J:

><
m

Q.

><

<

::r
s

8.3 .

, (

.

,

:
. .


,
],
[


,
1
.


(, ,

),

,
.

.

10 11, ,




,
,
,
.

.


..u,

1 . .

on Pulic Policy/

11 Carnegie-Rochester Conference Series

. . . . .

1977 (). . 5. 10.

,
,

(
),
.
,


(
),
. ,


, .
- ..
.
( )
.

,

.
,



.

,



.
,

,

,

,


,

,

.
, ~
-

. 1
, ,

~
. .

;

,

. , The
Conference Board

.
~ usiness
Cycle Indicators,

.


, The Conference d .

.


. 1.1- 1.4.

10.

-

,

News week, 19
. : Little Broun, 2002.
1

1966 .,

. : .

;;;'
111
111

111

Cll

::.

"'

!l:

10.

)
i (

<
"'s

1-

:;

::
::

<

"'

w
;

1:

:z:

"'
()

Q.

"'

<

1:

s
:

:;

"'::r

"'

:;

:{

n"

n'

Conference Board.
" n Conference Board.
:
2003 .
: ,
57 (
47 ( ); :
86 (

:
);
; :
)

:
);

30

29 (
(

41 ( );
); :
106 (
); :

: 43 (

: 120 ( 6
2 );
500 );
19 (
); :
114 (
:

119

( 01),

},
91-
) .

109 (

. . 8.4

1947 .


. 8.4-8. 1
8.1).
.
NBER (.

, . ,

- ,

.



,

(NBE R)

1938 .


,*


.
NBER

,




1968 . 1995 .



, The Confe
rence Board .


, .



,

.


-
:

1.

2.


, ,

3.


,

.

4.

. -


,
.


,


. ,
(


The Conference Board ),
, n
,
,
.
,
r ,

,
,

,
,


,
.
,



.
0

, ,



,
,



. ,
1969 .

; 1970 .
.
NBER ,


1969 . ,

.
,

1973 1974 . , 1974
.
,
- . NBER
,
-


(-: Natio nal Burea
u of
Economic Research, 1938).

**. :


:
jomal of Aencan Statistical Associ
ation. 1991 ().
. 603-6 10.

11

.

1973 ., n

,

n

,
. , n

<

"'

:s:
:s:

1<:;

<::

"'
u
"'w
<

::r

:s:
:

:1:

"'"'
<
"'

Q.

:s:
Jj

<:;

"'::r

:s:
w

Jj
ID

<:;

I:I

n
n ,
, n
n n.


, n

n 1979 ., n
n, n , n

.,
1969
n ,

1973


. ,- .


n n ,
n ,

.
, - n

n
- n



n .
n

, ,
n
n


n .
n n
.
2001

1990

no
, n

nn n
,
n

n
.
1990

n .

n
n,
2001 .
2000

10%.

10%. , n

.
n


n n
n n n

,
n-n

n ,
, ,


. , nn
n

.
n

n
n

,
. .
I Press, 1989. . 351-39 4.

NBER Macroeconomics Annual. :

, ,
(
,
) (
), -
,

,
.

, )
(

,
(, )
.

,

,


8.5
.

,

,

.
,

.

,

,
, ,

wr

60

40

oL-~---L--~----

1950

1955 1960

L---~--~---L--~

1965

1970

1975 1980

----L---~--~---

1985

1990

1995 2000

r



,

,

.


.

.
:

8.4

FRED -

research.stlouisfed.org/fred

.



,
-,
,

. 1


, ,
,

(
),

,

.
-, ,


. ,
,

,

,


(
1%) ,


,


1973-1975, 1981
-1982 . 2001 .

, -,

.
,

,



.

10 ,

1:::1
m

::

"'

![

4500

~:;

::rco

j! 8: 4000

<(

"

s
fs

::

"'
<(

"uw

:I:

"'

=~
s: :z:

:z:

s:~

i~~
:;

3000

:;

:::

f~

2500

2000

"-

"

1500

<(

1000

J5

::

"'s::1

500

w
J5

"'

::

1970

1965

1975

1980

1985

1995

1990

2000

.
,
, , ,

l a.s

,
,
.
,

FRED r /'0 -,

research.stlouisfed.org!fred

,

.


. 8.6
;

-
1959 .


,

.

,

,
. 8.7




( ,

).

rence
. The Confe
,
. 1

Board


~.


. 8.6 8.7

~~

~:

150

11!
~.

140

~:11

i!g.
g ti

120

110

zU

100
90
80
70
6oLL-----L----~----~--

1960

1965

1970

1975

----------~----~----

1980

~----~--

1985

1990

1995

2000

-



.

: FRED

-, research.stlouisfed.org/f
red

1990-1991 .

2001

8.6

. ,

.

, ~
~.

1990- 1991

1990- .

1960- .

1::1
m
::,


.
1,
-

.
. 8.8
,

(
),

.



,
. 1 The Conference Board
1

3 ,

"'
2:

~~ 12
~ ~
11
Q, ~

<

""

s
fs

:;

>-
\0

[ 10

"'
""

<

9
8

u
w

:r
s

"'""
<
""

Q.

s
:5
:;

""

::r

1960

w
:5

"'

1965

1970

1975

1980

:;


. n
n
n

1985

1990

1995

2000

8.7


: n

n
, n ,
.

.stlouisfed.org/fred
FRED -, research

1
.

3,

(,
,

, . .
) ,

, . 8.8,
.
,

n n n
.: . .
Economic Activity. 1979 (2). . 447-46 1.
Papers
gs
Brookin
/

,
2 ., .: ,
// Southe m Econom icjoum al. 1985 (

, .
) . . 1162-1173; ,



n :

266.
joumal of Political Economy. 1988 (). . 1232-1
I
, ,

n
.

(). . 1-25.
1994
ic.
Econom
of
al
rlyjoum
Quarte
?//

11

130

1960

1965

1970

1975

1980

1985

1990

1995

2000

-
,
1973 . .
:

8.8

FRED -, researciJ.st louisfed.or


g!fred


,
,
. . 8.9
,

2, 1959 . 1 ,


. .
8.9 ,

.
,
-

.
, 2

1867

,
.

8.9,

.
,

2 . .

7.1.

, .

8.9

;
. .

, 1867-19 60 rr.
, -: Princeto n
University Press for NBER, 1963 .
, 10.

:
m
:::,

"'
m

!!:

NC(

:
CD

25

~~

<{

""

s
fs

:;

0::

<{

""

11 ai 20
~~

CDII

:i,:z:
s
s

15
10

::

"""'
"""

<{

s
1i
:;

1960

1965

1970

1975

1980

1990

1985

1995

2000

""s

:r
w

1i

"'

:;

2 , .

, -, -


. ,


,
.

FRED -, research.stlouisfed.org/fred

,
,


. ,
1990- .


,
(

,
-

).
( ,



. 8.10, -
. ,


.
(
,

)

.

,

,

7 ,

111

lt

1'00

~~

'#,

18
17

16
Cl.>!~
15
111
a< OI
01 ... 14
z u 13
.

12
z
:1:
11
:

10

6'ni

8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1

1950

1955 1960

1965

1970

1975 1980

1985

1990

1995 2000

,

.

FRED

-, research.stlouisfed.org/fred



. ,

1973-1 975 .,

1981-1 982 rr. (

. 2.2.)
,

. ,

,

,





.
,
.

,

.
-
:


,
-

1:1
m

::.

"'

1!:

.r::
:s:

"::.

1!:

-----.

----,
- - - - " " '

<
~

:s:
f:s:

--------.

:;

t::

- - - - - -"'-

"'<

w
:

:s:

::

:r

~
1\

"~

<

::

:s:
J5

~
:s:

::::r
w
J5

"'

:;

:[

1961 1965

1970

1975

1980

1985

1990

1995

2000

.
:

n n


,
.

,
:

2003

.,

n) .
(

.
.

8.11

1961 .

1975, 1982, 1991 2001 rr.

,
8. 11
.
,

8.4.

, ,
,
. ,


.
,


,
,

,
,

&

8.1

( ).
5%
,
(-),
8% , ,
(-). ,

(-)
4%.
,
,
85%
l

. 8.4-8.1 1?

t.



,


.


. ,

,
,


ti


. ,

1.

2.

3.

,
.

,

4.


.

,

(, ,

).


,
,

5.



: 1)
, , ,

; 2)
, , ,


; 3)

,
.


10,
,

, ,

.
,


( ,

)
-

.:

11 joumal of Political Economy. 1989 (). . 503-534.

.
,

. ,

<(

"'

:s:
1:s:
;

<::

:;

<(

"'

:s:
::

:r:

"'

"'

"'

<(
::

:s:

::z;
;

"':::r

:s:

"'

9- 11,

,
,
,

,
.

3
,

,

,
.

.
,

(, ,

).

, ..

- .

,

:
r
(
; ,
.
)


,
. ,
, 1



, AD-AS.

AD-AS

.
,

, IS-LM,
AD-AS

9-11 .

AD-AS ,
AD-AS .
; 2)

1)
. 8.12, :
; 3)

,


,

. 8.12,
.

AD


L ,

. 8.12, ,
. AD


AD 9.

.

,
, .

,
,


.
,

,
,
,
,
.

LRAS

AD ,

, n

.
(SRAS)

, ,

,
,

.

,
(LRAS)


.

,
AD SRAS, -
AD LRAS.

AD


.


,

,
AD ( ,

,
AD ).
, ,
,

,
AD .


,
AD .

AD. ,



AD .


,

. . 8.12
:
, -
.

(SRAS), . 8.12,

.
,


.


, ,

. ,
-

111
111
111

00

(
,
).

<
s

"'

1-

:;

"'u

,

,




, ,

<

:r

"'w
s

:I:

"'

..

"'

<

s
25

:;

"'::r

SRAS.

25

"'
:;

1::{

3,

.
,

,
,

z
.
. 8.12,

(LRAS)

.


AD SRAS

.
.

8.12

AD LRAS

. , -


,
.


. ,
AD-AS

AD.

.
, AD
,


,

,
,

8.13.

, ,

1
AD
,

2
AD
2
( AD SRAS) F,

1 .
2 ,

F,

.
,

Q,

LRAS

.11

:1:

011

ID

!
1
1

1
1

2 --------------------~--------1

1
1
1
1
1
1


AD
, ;

.

8.13

n

n

AD 1 -

AD2
F,
,
.
2

,

2

, .
,

,


.

.

-
-

AD 2 LRAS.

,
2

,
,
AD ,

,
.

?


, ,

,

, .
,



,

,

,

. ,

AD,

Dl

111
Dl

<
~

...:s::s:
:;

<::

"'

<
~
u
w

:s:

:<:

"'

..

<
:

:s:
1i
:;
~

:s:

::1

w
1i

"'

:;

(LRAS).

,
,

. ,

r
, 1,


.

)
, ( ,
,
, .

,
, , .
,
-

8.13)
.

~
(

2

, ,

,
.


. ,

. .

8.13

, ,

AD 2

AD

AD 1,

,
LRAS

(LRAS).

,
,

8.14

,
.
.
,


( , ,

,
) .
. 8.14,

LRAS


AD. ,

,


;
1

, LRAS LRAS2.

Yz

F,

, .

LRAs2

LRAS 1

------- - ---- - ------


-+-- ,
AD


, , .
_s
1
2

,

8.14

LRAS LRAS'l.

1


'!

F.

!!_ J:!.. 'l


~ ,
1 2
2

F
F.


. ,
,
,
1
2

10.


, -



. ,



. 11

,

,

1.



( )

(,
).

,
-
.

2.

.
-

]::1
m

:::.

"'
m
\[

~
s
fs

3.

, . .

g;

<

"w

:1:

:>::

4.

"

Q.

"<:1:
s
Jj

=r
w
Jj

"'

.:;:
1"1

...
.

",

,


.

.
1929

1929 .

.
.


1973-1 975

.
1982

rr.
1982
1981


~ ,
91 rr .
1990-19

\,1

.
,
1929 .
,

:;2

:r

, . .
.
.

5.


.


,


.
,

.

.

6.

,
,

7.

10. ,

.
,

,
, ,



. .

8.

: 1)
,
; 2)
(,
AD-AS
) ,
.
AD-AS

9.

.


,



.

,

. ,
,



, ,



.


1.

,

. ,

2.

3.

,

?
,
?

4.

,
?

;'
111

111

111



?

,

5.


? ?

s
~
s
~

"'""

<

6.

:1::

::

7.
8.

"""'
<>.
<
"":1::

?
? ?

?
,
?



? ,


1.



NBER.

NBER
.
1927


om1Uto.eu


(
. 8.1). ,

r
,

.

8.1

2.

,

,

, ,

3.

.

?

,

,

. .
. :
) . . 573-609; .
(
1994
History.
c
Economi
of
journal
//

, .
() . . 289-298 .
1996
onomic.
Macroec
of
joumal
//

? (
:
= +

.)

)

, 3?

4.

1973- 1975 .


.
,

? ,
AD-AS.

5.

,

. AD-AS ,
,

.
,
?

it

, ,

FRED -
,
: research.stlouisfed.orgjfred

1.

),


.


.

1961

., ,

(
)

0,2

: ( ).

0,2

:
;

3)

1) ; 2)
?

, ,

, ?

2.


NBER
(
www.nb

data),

er.org/

1959



NBER, . 8.1?

3.

!

? ,

.
)

) .
) .

1::1
m

::,

"'2:

)
.
<(

""

s:
1s:

::

4.

::

<(

""w

"j

s:

; S&P 500

hoo.com)
finance.ya

. ,

:I:

""
""
(11

Q.

<(

s:

1961 .,

( S&P 500

5.

::!!

( www.oecd .og

w
::!!

~
s:
:::r

:!:


) .

?

15-LM/AD-AS:

8 ,
.
, . - ,

,
,
. 3, 4
7,

. , ,
, .

, ,

.
, ,

IS-LM. ( ,
: I
S, L .)
IS-LM 1937 .
, 1
, , 1936 ., ~
, ~. ,

(. . 1.3), IS-LM
, ,

.
IS-LM,
,

.

IS-LM
. , ,

IS-LM -
. IS-LM
,
. IS-LM,
,

IS-L , .: :

11 Econometrica. 1937 () . . 137- 159.

. , /S-LM
AD-AS, . 8.4.
, AD-AS /S-LM,

AD-AS

<

f-

"'s:
s:

<::;

::

0:

<

"'

:r
s:

:1:

::t:

"'
<
"'
:1:
(1)

Q.

s:
21

s:

:::!

21

/S-LM
. -,

. -,
,

,
, . ,
/S-LM ( )


.
/S-LM

. 9
. , ,
,

"'
q

1'11

, .

<::;

1-

\,1

, .

, , ,

13

, .

"'

9.1.

FE:

:
, .
,

, .

3
.

1t 1t .

- ,

,
.

1t . -

1t1t 1tu,. 1<.U

1t . = AF(K, N), -
, - , F- ( .

3.4).

.
, FE . 9.1.

= ,


1
.

, ,
, ,
n .

...

FE
.

FE

.L

N,

.
FE
= .

FE

, FE. ,

FE

N) ,

.
,


FE.
.

11

FE.

11.

(FE)


n FE

MPN ,


. ,
MPN,

"'

::>

1:1

1:1

!l

IS:

9.2.
<

""

:s:
1:s:

<:::

.

,

4,
,

<

. ,

u
w
:
:s:

""

::;:

:J:

""
<
""::;:

()

Q.

:s:


, IS.

( ) IS
.

r,

IS

Jd Sd.

.,

:;

,
. 9.2 IS

9.2,

3).

(.
4


-,

5000).

4000
(



). ,

(
.

5000
=

,
4000.
=

4,

,
.

9.2, .

,

, ,


,
5000.
=

4000,
=

4000,

5000,

7%.

9.2,

5%.

IS

D,

F,

-
IS

IS. (
. = 4000 r= 7% D
. 9.2, .)
, D . 9.2, D


, = 5000, ,

5%.


F IS


. 9.2, , F . 9.2, . ,


, , ,

S(Y=4000)

7
1
1

----------- -1-
,

1
1
1
1

1
1

/S

1
1
1

sd,
,

4000 5000

fl


: 4000 5000 (

lt.z

JS

,
).

(),


.
, 4000,
,
, 7% ( D).
,
5000, ,

,

5%

6)

F).

IS

,
.
IS
. . 9.2, ,

4000, ,

, 7% ( D); ,
5000,
, , 5% (
F).

,

, IS .

111
111

111

10
:

g
m

::,
<

iii
1

IS

;'

r-

~
:


( )
,

IS

. , ,

F . 9.2, .

IS,

F,

,
. 1

,

F, Sd Jd.

Sd = - ()1 - G ,

, , = ()1
+ Jd + G F.
1

)
1

V>

"'s

::J

1::1

1::1
\!:

, -

5 7%. 4,

<
s

"'

1-

:
:;

<
u

"'

"'"'

..

"'
<

s
:z;

Ci (

),

Jd, ,

.
5000, ,

. D . 9.2,

( 5000 4000),

.1 ,

,
,

IS

:;

"'

:z;

, IS

"'

::1

:;

,.,
.

1-

\,/

t'CI
j

IS

,
,

IS.

,


,

, ,
IS .


, ,

IS,

IS

. 12.

, , IS.
IS
. 9.3. . 9.3, -
1
1
S I . S

(),
1.
JS

IS

4500. 9.3,

n, n ,

,
, n

n. ,
$ 1,
$1 n

$1

(Ji $1 (. . n,

4, 1).
,
n n,
, , n.

12.


/S

IS

n ( n
}, n
, n

n ( n
}, n


n G

(
} , ,
n

n, n

,
n

n ( )

, n


n ,
,
n , n r

n '

,
n , n r

n,
n , n

4500, . 9.3, , . 9.3, 6.


,

6%.

G.

, . ,

4,

()1 - G
(. .

5),

st 52 . 9.3, .

,
4500,

6 7%

( F .

9.3, ).

4500,

9.3, 6.

, ,

F.

6 7%,

IS,

!5'2, F

IS, !5 1.

IS

IS

, IS,

( )

"'

:s:

:::J

]::1

]::1
![

.:

i
t

<(

"'"
s

f-

01

<:;

::

"'
u
"'w
"

<(

------------------------- ~ -

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 01 -

..~
:.

:I:

"'
"'
(!)

0..

<(

"1i

4500

sd,
, fl

<:;

"'"

1i

"'

<:;

:[

,..,
...
.

\,1

111

:r

) -

G

4500.


, S' 52.

9 .3

/5


F,

6 7%.
,

)
.
,
!52.
IS , IS'
4500,
,
,

( F).
7%

)
(
6

. ,

,
.

IS

(;d

Jd.

,
,

,

IS

IS,

. ,
,

(;d + Jd + G,

.

,
c;d Jd.


,
IS .

9.3 .

L:

,
7.

,
,

,

.

, (

,
)
,

( ,
) .

, ,

:
. ,



im.
,

NM,

i (

n)

r.


,
,

.
,


LM.
,

,
7, -

,
cma(f}
Co

,
, -

, .

(
).

,
. ,

$10 000; (

)
- . 1 ,

$9615 .

$385 ($1 000
- $9615), 4%
$9615 . ,

, ,

4% .
, -


$1 000 $9524
.
1
,
- ,
uco1tm1to
.

111
Cll

111
10
:

I:l
m

:::.

(;;
r-'

~
:

'

(/1

D'1

:s:

m
::t

I:l

I:l

2:

<
:s:
f:s:

"'

r:

<
"'
"'

:s:

:f:

:I:

"'
<
"':f:

()

Q.

:s:
:z;
;

"'::r

$4 76 ( $1 000

- $9524), 5% . ,
, (

)

.


,
,


),

,
.


,
.


0

1t
,

:s:

:z;

"'

1:::{

LM,


,
, ,

.

,

.
- ,

9.4,

- . MS

, Mj P.

.

,
Mj P
, = 2000, = 2,
MS .
MS Mj P = 1000.


7,
MD . 9.4, .

r,

.
.


= 4000
MD

, 4000;

= 5000

, 5000.
,

MD

=
= 4000.

5000 ,

,
.

MD (= 4000),
, 4000,
.
. 9.4,

3%.

, .

7,

.:

MD(Y = SOOO)

MS

LM

11
IV

-------------------------

~
~-

11
IV
:1:

.a -

:.

1000

1200

4000 5000


, /,

, 1llfl/
)

)


9.4
.

LM

1000.
4000,


MD ( =
4000); ,
,
3%
( ).
5000,
n



MD (= 5000).

,
, 5% (
).
)
. )
LM.

LM n n
,
n
. n n
, 4000,
LM n,
n ,

, 5% ( ).
n n

,
n
, n
,
LM .

4000,


) , 3%.
3%

4000

1000,

.

,

4000 5000?


.

,
MD (= 4000).

3%,


. . 9.4,


1200,
, 1000.

5%.

1::.
m
:::,

rr

;;;

'

r-

3:
.......
:

'

"'

"'

:s:

m
:::1

1::.

2:

5%,

1000,


(

. 9.4, ) .



3%

5000
4000

. 9.4, ).
( MD


, . .

,
,

,
, ,
,

,

.

9.4,

MD

5000


).

,

,
.

,

5%.
3

. ,

,


LM. LM

,



, . .

LM


,
L


,
P.
Mj

,
LM,

r
. 9.4, ,

, -

LM. ,

. 9.4, ,
, -

3%.

4000,
5000,
LM

5%;




. 9.4, .

9.4, ,

LM

. ,

,
.

, 13
LM

LM

. ,

(,
),


,
.

LM. ,
,


,

'U,
,
LM .

,


,
,
,
LM
.
,
LM

. . 13

,
L.

13.


LM

LM

, n

,

(

n"

f'

, n

,
,
,
,
n
,
L . ,
, {.
. 9):
;



,

;

::

1:1
m

::.

(;;
,....1
:

.......
)>

'

)>

"'

"'

:::>

1:1

/

,
,

LM

9.5

. 9.5,
- .
,
/

1:1
\!:

'#.

.:

LM(M/ P= 1000)

ci

"...
ID

<

"'..."'
"'
:;

1>:

<
u

"'
"'

:I:

"'
<
"'
"'JS
(!)

0..

:;

"'"'

:::r

JS

"'

:;

110

Q.

110

MD

:z:

(=4000)

Ql
Q.

LM(M/ P= 1200)

1000

1200

4000


, /,

, <1/
)


)
,


MS' M!Jl.

9.5

LM

,
n
,
,
.
, 4000,

MD (= 4000)
D).
, 3 ( ) 2% (
,


LM.

,


4000,

. , ,
,

. LM
D)
(
2%

)
(
3

,
LM (/= 1200).

, LM (/= 1000)

4000,
1000

MD (= 4000).
,


3%. LM,


1000, LM (/
,

1000) . 9.5, .
4000,
- . 9.5,


3%.
4000,

LM,
,
1000,
3%.
,

,
1200.
4000 1000

1 MS'l . 9.5, .
, MS
D,

,
4000,
,

2%.
,
,
,
3%


, . .
,
,
,
,
.
,

. ,


,
,

,
.

,


.
,
2% D . 9.5, ,

4000

LM
9.5, 6.

,
, 3 2%.
D, = 4000, r = 2%,

. ,

.
,

LM

. LM
/ = 1200
D
LM / = 1000.

LM


, ,

LM


?
Mj
P, ,

,
, .

.

,
,
LM.
,


,
,

LM
.


LM
.
. 9.6
,
,

. 9.5. ,
-
. 9.6, .
4000,



- MD 1

1000.


,
MD 1

MS.

,
, 3%.

,
,

,
.
-

"'s

#.

.:
~

<

"'

:s;
f-

:s;
::

"'
u
"'

<

:s;
:

~111

111

i!=
::

----

------ ------ ------ ------ -

CL

111

i!=

::

8.

::
.

"'

.:
~

MS

(!)

>.

"'<

1000

:s;

4000

1300

nnn

, /,

::z;
::

, "/

"'

:s;

:;;

"'

::


4000
1000
.

,

2
MD' MD ,

LM

,
,
(

9.1

( )

6%

G).


)
~:>r
4000
LM.
,
,


3 ( ) 6% ( G). ,

,


LM ,

LM'

LW.


,

im,
.

,

MD 1 MD . 9.6, .

3%

1000;
1300,

3%

,
,


,
,

?
.

.

,
,

(1000) .
3% 6% G.

. 9.6,

LM,
LM1,

LM.

, ,
4000
,
, 3%. (
. 9.6, .
9.6, .)

4000
, ,
6%.
LM
G ( G
. 9.6, ), = 4000, r= 6%.
LM,

L2, LI,
,
,

.

9.4.

I5-L M

. ,

,
. . 9. 7
IS-LM, ,

. r:

FE,

IS,

LM,


,F

/S

v;

D'1

n,

m
::;,

9.7

IS-LM

IS, LM
FE. ,
,
,

!Z:

,
,

.

...:

"'

:s;
f-

:s;
;

::

"'
u
"'w
...:

:r
:s;

"'m
"...:
"'


, ,
.

,

,
,
.
,

, IS FE -
,
, LM

,

. 9.5
.
.

1)
, :

FE; 2)
IS

,

1i

IS FE.
,
,

,

,

"'

IS-LM : I
I

:s;
;

:s;
:::1

1i

"'

t:{

.......

"'

':1'

IS-LM.


,
. ,

, -

,

(-
1

).



, ,

,
, ,
.

9.8,

FE,


IS LM, LM

,
,

FE1,

FE

FE,

IS LM.

,
.

FE,

(. .

3.12).

, ,


, ,

3.1, ~ AF(K, N),


&, ,
,


N.

15

.
6)

9.8

; ~

FE ,

FP FP.
F,

IS.

FP

L , LM1 L2,
,
F. F
,


, ,

FE

n, n

n n . ? . n

3,

n n

n n n :, AF(K, N), n

1) ,

iii,

; 2)

n,


FJ!2 . 9.8, .

FE, FE 1

IS.

IS


-
(. 9.2)
n
,

. n

n,

( , ,

) .


-

"'
:s:

::J

:1::>

:1::>
!1:

<(

"'

:s:
f:s:
<:;

"'
u
"'
w

. .

- .

IS

"'
"'
(1)

<l.

<(
~

:s:
1i

:s:

::::r

w
1i

"'

<:;

::[

...
.

1.1

"'

':1'

9.8,

, Fifl ( FE), IS L'.

:s:


LM.

<(

IS.

IS,

IS,
1
.
, LM.

9.5,-

FE,

LM , LM
IS.
, FE


LM ,

/

,
9.8,
.

.

,
F, LM

L' L'l. ,
/ (. .

13),


. (

) ,

? -

, . ,

), .

,
.

.
1. 3,

.

2.

, F,
. 9.8, , ,

.

3.

4.

, - ,

,
, .

~ :

I<
. , ,

IS-LM,

(.

9.1).


IS .
1

WOKAM

1973- 1974

1979-1980 rr. (. 4
.
,
~>

3).

,

, .
,
IS-LM,
.
,

,

8.5 ,
,

.
1973
1974 .
1,8%,
- 11,1%.
1980 .

2,3%,
- 9,0%.

,

1973- 1974 1979- 1980


rr. ( . . 8.9).
,

.

,

.
2
,

,
,
, ,

(

) .
,

.

, ,


.

1979- 1980 rr.,
- 1973- 1974 .
( . . 2.2).

,

1973- 1974 rr.

1979- 1980 rr. ,



: . 3.13 , ,
1979- 1980 rr.,


1973- 1974 rr.

::0
11'

(ii
1

~
:.

t)
1
:.

(/)

01

:s:

m
:::J

9.5.


,
LM ,

IS FE.


-

sz:

&
<
s
fs

"
.:::

<>:

<
u

"w
:

::

:1:

"

(1)

ll.

"<
::

s
:JS

.:::
s

"

::

:JS

"'.:::

c::t
rt'l

...
u
.D

1\1

-:r

9.1

IS-LM, ,

.

IS-L).
( , ,

. -

(, ,

).


. -,

t ()

.

,

,

(,
. -,

),
,

)
(
(,
,

, ,
, ).

ut () .

, IS-LM,
,
,

,

, .


, ,
, IS-LM,
,

. ,

r,
,

,
. ,


,
,


,
,

700 1200. ,

nr

-nr

Chase Econometrics

700

nr
(n )



Data Resources, tnc.

1000

Wharton Econometric Forecasting


Associates

1200

(1983

.), .

5-18.

30%
10%

1.

.: // New England Economic


(/). .

70%
20%
5%
5%
55%
30%
10%
5%
60%

Review. 1983

,
.


,
,

,

r,
, 1 (

,
),

(
).

,



.

.: .
? r

(/ ). . 41- 52;
.

11

New England Economic Reuiew . 1990

: ,
. :
( . 18).

University of Chicago Press, 1992,



:
.

IS-LM , ,

(
)

-

,

10%.

,
/
10%.

? 9.9
,

IS-LM.
9.9 ,

.
,

9.9,

IS,

FE LM,

LM,
.

1000,
5%.
JS, LM

, , 5% -
,

,

, 100.

/

IS

FE,


, /

,
, ,
.

. 9.5, ,

LM , LM

Ll.

LM

,
-

"'
:s:

m
:::J

\[

FE

'*.:'
:f

1
LM (P = 100)

11
al

<{

1-

"'

s
1s

11:
al

z1z

<;

111

::1

"'
u
"'w

<{

11:

...z

:t:

IS

111

"'

11.

"'

<{
~

= 1000

s
)

:;;
<;

"'::r

...

...

ci
0:

:;;

"'

w
r::::[

11:

<;

,.,
.

11.1

"'

ci
0:
11

11

FE

t;

LM 1

FE

LM1

( =

100)

11:

z
1z

111

::1

8.

11:

11:

z...

...

111

111

1200

1000

1000

1000, n
5%, 100.
6) 10%-

9.9

L' L2. F,
LM ,
L2, n

LM,

IS

.

3%,

1200 (,
,
, 1000).

n

)
.

F,
n n

, 100 110,
1
LM
LM

,

1000,
n n
100 110.


.
, ,
LM
, Ll, .
9.9, , ,
.
, ,

. -
,

.

IS-LM

L), ,
,

( FE)
,

,

.
( JS)
- .
, ,

,
,
.

IS

LM.

, ,

FE,

IS-LM


.
,


,

,
F . 9.9, ,
LM,

Ll,

IS. F ( 1200) ,

(3%) ,

. F,

,
. ( F

, ,


,
.)



F?
,
,
:


,


.
,
>>
. ,

,
,


-
.


()1
Jd,
.

,
: ,

,
,

( )

"'
s

m
:::J

)::J

!!:


.
,

<

"'

s:
1s:
t:;

::

"'<
u
"'w
;

s:

:I:

"'
<
"'

(!')

<>.

s:
2i

s:

::I

w
2i

"'

t:;

t:I
/'1'1

...
.

\,1

"'

'j'


, ,

,
F . 9.9,

,
:
.

1)

IS LM; 2)
,
( )
,



(),

, ,
.

9.9,

F IS,

,
,
.

,

,

F. , ,

F,


.
,


,
3). ,
(

,

F

, .
,

,
,
,

MjP, , ,

,
,

LM


LM
.

LM

. 9.9, ,

.



.
, .

9.9,

9.9, , ,
10%


.

,


n.
10%-

10% ( = 110). ,
10%?
LM
,

/
.

10%, , /
,
10%.

n
.
,
7 (. 7.10),

,

.

, ,
n

10%,


10%. ,
,
n
,
10%.


( ),
.

. . 9.9 n

10%-

10%-
.

.
.

,

,
7% ,

/.
LM /,

LM ,
,

n,


3% - 10%, -
7%.

/ 3% (10% - 7%),
LM .
,

4%,
7% , LM
, 3%-
(4% - 7% = -3%)

,

t (t) 1t
(7%
)

LM.

~ ~.
,


()
(,
7 10% ).

"'

;::,

:t:>

:t:>

1!:

,
~

(,

<

"'

:s:
f:s:
;

"'
"'
w

,
7 4%).

~
,

,
,
,

,
.

<
u

:r
:s:

1:

J:

"'"'

0..

"'<

1:

:s:
:0
;

"':::1

:s:

w
:0

10

q
1'1
Jj

...u

:r"'


IS-L M


1)
2)

?
-


. 8.4
IS-LM.

AD-AS.

.

,

1t .

,

FE,

IS LM



LM ,
, . 9.9, .

. 9.9, .
,
LM
, IS

,
.
,

LM ,


,
,

.
,


. ,

-
. 8.4,

.
,




. ,
,

1
,
.

),
(
.

, ,

)
(



,
,

r,
1.

,
. ,
,
, ,

,

/5 LM;
FE
.

/5-LM

.


,


. ,




,
,
,
. ,

,


,

.
,
/5-LM




.
.

; . .
,

. 9.9, , ,
. 9.9, ,
, . 9.9, .
,
,

, , ,


,

.

,

(. . 9.9, ).

, ,

( ),
.

,
.

10

11.

:1::>
m

:::>
1

V;

,...
1

:
........
)>

)>

1/)

0'1

9.6.

/5-LM,

,
,

/5-LM -
(AD-AS), 8. AD-A5

/5-LM,
.

,
,
-

s:
m
::1

:1::>

:1::>
!L

,
.

,
?

<(

"""'
1-

"'
<:;

t::
:;

<(

""
"'

"'""

..

""
"'
<(

JS-L
, .

AD-AS -
,

IS-LM


, ,

,
.
13)
(
;

,

IS-LM.

AD-AS 12,
AD-AS. ,
.


AD-AS IS-LM

,
,

;
.

(Jf

+ Jd + G

-
,


(, ) . ,

AD


.

.



AD

. 10%,
(

10%,


) .
.


,
. 9.1 0.

,
,
LM. ,
IS

,


,

/"
1
IS L'

.
9.10,
.

'
L

LM

, 1
,
"

,
,

1 .

, 2



13),
M j P 1 M j P2 (. .
,

LM

L2.

IS L2

F,

2
, ,


1 2

, , 1 2

.
~=
Cll
111 ..

/S-LM

:z:

11

::r'"

(J
Q,

r2

111

:z:

;Cll

Q,

Cll
::r
.

:z:

Cll

11

Q,

1
1
1

--------------~-----

'

1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1

n 9.10
,
,

n n
IS LM.

n ,
, n LM - LM' ,
, n
, ,.

. 9.10, , . 9.10,
.
,
,
n ,
n

.

) ,
2
n LM
,
LM' LAf2.
n
, n
,
n

IS LM,

2
)
1
2 n n
,
.

n ,
, , n
n
2

:s:

o-

V;
,...1
~
:.

,
,


AD . 9.10, . F . 9.10,
F
9.10, . AD ,

1
:.

"'

"'

:s:

m
::J

LM ;


,


.

,
AD.
AD

,

, .

,

AD,

1!:

AD ,

IS

.

<(

"'

s:
1s:
::

r::

"'

<(

"'

:r
s:

:1:

"'"'
"'

<(
:

LM,

LM
IS
,
.
AD


,

IS LM


,
AD .
,


AD ,

AD

9.11.

IS-

,
.
1
JS - LM
,

9.11,

s:
:;;
::

"'::r

s:

"' .

IS-LM

::

.11

; =
l:i

1i

"'

."'

::

::

!52

::r

Q.

gj.
.11

::

111

>-


)
,
IS

IS' !Sl.

,

,
, 1 2


F.

9.11

)
, AD

,

,
F
6
9.11,
.

.

.

9.11,

, ,

1

IS ,
!52.


IS LM
1
F, ,

,

AD,

, . 9.11, .

, ,

1
F.



,
, AD

, AD 1 AD 2
.

14.

AD, . 14,

AD

9.

AD

,
/S LM
,
, ,
r
,
. 12), :

/S , , ( .

G;

( ,
, . .
);

MPf(l;

,
13), :

LM

, , ( .

11';

i"';

IS-LM

-
. ,

,
,

SRAS
,
. 9.12.

,
.
,

N,

, .
, N,

,
,

:,

AF(K, N) .
-

"'

:s:

1::>

1::>
\[

LRAS
<(

":s:f-

:s:
:;

----------------r----------------SRAS

"'
<(

"uw

:r
:s:
:

:I:

"
""
(1)

<(

:s:
:z;

:::!
w

SRAS

:s:

:z;

"'

:;

9.12

, n n n n


. n
n LRAS = .

LRAS

= , . 9.12.

.
,

LRAS

, ,

,
, LRAS .

FE

IS-LM


LRAS . ,


.
LRAS

,
.

SRAS ,

SRAS

AD-AS


AD-AS . 8.4,

(

) (

).


. 9.13.
AD SRAS,

LRAS,

9.13.

AD

LRAS

.~

!
AD


AD SRAS .

AD-AS

.
, -

AD LRAS

. - ,
,

.

. ,

, ,

(
), - AD, SRAS LRAS-

, .

9.13. .

LM FE,

IS,

, .
, , AD, SRAS LRAS
,

IS, LM

,
FE .

AD-AS

m
::;,

"'(j;
1

~
:

V\

IS-L.

:s;
m

AD-AS

g
g

. 9.14, , - ,
1

, 10%. IS-LM
LM ,

, ,
.
AD , AD 1 AD 2

"'

:::1

2:

<

""

:s:
:s:

1-

;
:

0:

<
u

""

:r
:s:

::t:

"""'
""<

Q..

:s:

10%

AD ,
AD 1 AD2

AD

9.14

AD-AS

, -

10%
, , 10 % -
,

, , .

F ,
, .

2 , 10% , 1
.

, 10%, 1
AD 1, 10%
. . , . .

, , .
1
AD 2, - AD ,

10% , .
, ,

. , ,

Mj P,

LM ,

, , ,

1%
, 10% , .

, 2

10% , 1 ,

2
AD 10% ,
1
D


1
AD 2

AD

F (. IS-LM .

9.9, ).

2 , .

. ~
2
, .

SRAS 1
, , ,

, AD,
LRAS

SRAS2. 10%,
. . , .

,
.
, . . ,

IS-L.

,

, ,
.

8 ,
- . ,

, ,

.
,
,

LRAS -
(. .
SRAS) . ,
, ,
,

,
.
10, ,
11, .

::,
1

V;

-%_

1.

IS-LM


, - ,

- . /5-L
,
,
.

2.

IS-LM
FE,

. ,

"'

"'
"'

m
:::J

)>

)>

FE , ,

,
FE .

!2:

3.
<

IS
,
. IS ,

1:::

,
,
.

0::

"s....
s

r:::;

<

,
,

"u

IS .

"m
Q.

"<
:

:JS
r:::;

IS .
LM

4.

"s

::1

LM

:JS

11"1


, ,
.

...

/V

"'r:::;

c::r
.

\,1

,
,

5.

LM

,
. , IS,
FE LM.

. ,
/

LM ,
FE IS.

6.


, ,
, ,

.

7.

,
,

. IS-LM
,

8.

- (AD-AS)
IS-LM .

: IS-LM
-

AD-AS

AD

, -

9.

IS

LM, - .

LM ,

, .

,
.

,
,

10.

AD



, ,

SRAS

. ,

, . ,

= .

11.

LRAS

,
,

. ,

IS-LM-FE ,

, ,
,
,

AD

LRAS.

. , ,

>~,

12.


,
,

.
~
, ,

. ,
,
,

, .

"'s

"'

::J

1::.

~
sz:

IS-LM

<

...:s::s:"'
:;

IS-LM

.ci
""

11

FE

11

ti

"'w

:z:
:z:

:s:

:r

:1:

:I:

/)

, -

"'

<
u

"'
""'<:1:

:s:

111
11

...
CD

111
11

:z:
Jj

......
..
..
..
..

CD

]!

IS

:;

"'

:s:

;;I

]!

"'

:;

r::::r

r ,

- .

FE
.

- ,

,
= AF(K, N).

N.

IS
r, ,

, , ,

Sd Jd.

,
, IS . IS
r,
,
, , = ()1

+ Jd + G.

LM
,


, /
L( , r + 1t").
,

, ,

LM

,
, FE (. . 11 ).
,
-

,
,
IS .

,

,
,

IS (. . 12).

LM (. . 13).

, LM
LM1,

,


.
( FE),
( IS) (

L) .


,
r

1

,
.

FE, IS

LM LW,
LM ,

IS LM F,


,
. ,
(
)

F,


F
2

.

F
,
, .



/
LM ,

L',
.

::::1

,
,

LM

FE,

,


,
(
) F,
.
,

"'

:s:


,

,

,
.

\[


-
<
s
fs

"
r::

::

"'u~

w
:

:I:

"m

Q.

"<
~

AD-AS


,
,

SRAS.
AD LRAS.

AD

- .


AD

.
,

,
,

IS

LM (. . 9.10).


LM
.

AD

, .


, .
.

SRAS

. .
, ,

LRAS

=.

,
,


IS LM.
IS-LM
,

, ,

AD . ,

. 14.

AD,

,
,

,

SRAS

. ,

:,

LRAS ,

. , :,



AD SRAS .

AD LRAS .





. ,


,
AD 1 AD 2

F,

. F

,
,

, ,

1
,

2

SRAS2,

1:>
m
::,

<;;

IS

,...1

~
:..

:..

"'

"'
s

m
::1

1:>

1:>

1.

FE?

,
FE .

2.

IS?

IS , ,

IS

1!:

3.
<

"'

s:
s:

1<:;

4.

s:

"'
"<
"'

5.

s:
11

"'

6.

::r
w
11

<:;

IS-LM.

s:

(\

<:;

,
.
,

LM

"'
u
"'
w
<

:r


L?
?
LM , ,

,

7.

?
,

. ,

.
IS-LM


?

AD?


AD ?
,

AD

, .

8.



LRAS.

SRAS
-
,

9.


AD-AS ,
.


1.

()1 = 4000 - 4000r + 0,20 ;

Jd = 2400 - 4000r.

, - , r-
2000.

. G

) ,
Sd r .

) ,

, = 10 000?


, =

10 200?

IS.


) 2400.
)?

, = 1

000?


.
G IS?

2.

Md
-

= 3000 +, 1 -1 OOOOi.

, = 6000, = 2,0, 1t 0 =
0,02.
)
,
= 8000?
= 9000?

3.

LM.

) ) = 6600.

LM LM
)?
) ) = 6000, "=
0,03.
LM LM
)?

1000.


:

(J1 = 200

+ ,( -

) -

500r;

Jd = 200 - 500r.

196,

20 + 0 ,25.

Md

-=0 , 5

250( r+7t"),

1t =
= 9890.

0,10.

)
, ,

?
) ,

G = 216. ,

,

?

4.

"'

:s:

m
:::J

A(5N - 0,0025N2),

1:1

MPN =
, =

- 0,002AN.

2.

NS =55+ 10(1 - t)w,

1:1

1!:


NS- , w -
0,5.

, t-
:


<(

"'

(Jl = 300 + 0,8( - ) - 200r;

Jd = 258,5 - 250r.

:s:
f:s:

"'
<(

"'

:s:

20 + 0,5;

G=50.

::

"'"'
"'

Q.

Md

<(

:s:

0,5 - 250(r + ).

=
= 9150.

:zs

0,02,


,
?


r,
) ,

,

"'

::[

IS. (
;

.)

,
,


,
LM. (
;

),

:

r


.)


,
,

G = 72,5.

, ,
, ,
?

5.

()1 =

Jd

1275 + 0,5(-

= 900 -

L=

)-

200r.

200r.

0,5-

200i.

= 4600.
1t' = .
)

,
, = G = 450, = 9000.

:
(
IS.

r .)
,

. (
,

IS LM

.)
, , ,
?

) , = G = 450, = 4500.
?
, , ,

? ,

.
) ) =

6.

G = 330, = 9000.

( 9.)
, .J! 9,

,
4. , G = 50.
)

fl' / 2, n0 , n",, 0 ,

9.

' ,.,

t0 , t, i0 , i,., 10 , ZY'

z,.,

)
9 ,

, ,
.
) ), ,
G 72,5.


1.

JS-LM

, ,
, , ,
.
)

)
(
) .

2.

15-LM
, (
, ) ,

, , ,
, , ,
. ,

, ,

,
. (,
, .) ,
,

, ,

g
m
::,
1

iii
,...1
~
:.

1
:.

"'

"'s:

::J

!2:

<

3.

,
- .

""f-

""
""
:;

? ,
, ,

"'<
u
""
""

; ,

::r::

"'""

0..

""<
~

""
""""
=:!

Jj
:;

) .

Jj

"'

, ).

:;

:{

) - r .

1"1
.

1-

ra

4.

( 9. )


, .

,

,
.


9.10 :

Jd = i 0 - if + iyY,

iy

, ,
,

5.

( 9.)

7,

im

. ,

9.17 :

Md =10 +/yY-(r+n -im).

9, ,
,

15-LM AD-AS


IS-LM
AD-AS. - ,
-

,
.


IS-LM.
IS-LM

AD,



,
.
3 ( 3.1 ),


= AF(K,

N),

, - ,
N- , -
.

,



,
N
.

(9.1)

2 -

MPN

.
9.1-
1

N,

A(j1 -

2N),

(9.2)


,
,
.

w

ND

"':s:

.
m

(9.3)
-

.
t ( , ~

t < 1), (1- t)w-

, ,

,
N 9.1 .

:::>

]::>

]::>

!!:

(9.4)

<
s:
fs:

"

::

<::

"'
"

<
u

s:

:f:

:I:

NS -

, w


. , ,

,
,

0 9.4.


I .


ND NS ; ND
NS

N.


9. 9.4,

w. w

: 1

"'"

Q.

(9.5)

"<:f:
s:
21

;;!

s:

N = 0 +(1-t)Aj2 w.

=:1

21

"'
q

::

1"'1
.

......

(9.6)

1+(1-t)Aj2 w

9.6,
N
N


9.1:

(9.7)

:r"'

9. 7 -

FE.

9.5 ,
.
(

_

.
w])
/[1 + (1 - t)Af2
2

N.
9.6,
-,
, , ,


9.4. -,

. ,

N.

N,
9.7),
(.

FE .

,

9.5 9.6 ,
0 9.4.

- j 2n0 > .
, /,./2 0 , /1

, r
.
1

, ,

, / 1 - 2n0 > .
9.6 ,
),
(.

>
n
j,,

2 0

N.

n !:!_

0


N.

N,

,
FE .



, ,

(9.8)
( -

1) -

(
- 1), r-
, , cr -
.
0

9.8

- ,
4;



, ,
,
< < 1.

9.8


,



(
).
,

,
,


. 1
0
9.8

(9.9)
(
,

), t -

0

t-

, ~

t < 1,

,



Jd

i0

ir-

= i0 -

if,

(9.1 0)

. 9.1 0
,


,

. ,

,

i .
0

.


4.7,
:
= "

+ Jd + G.

(9.11)

1



9.8,



,
4.

,


.

.


,

9.8.
0
,





0
( - ),

.

"'

"'

:::1

];:1
\[


9.11

S<1 =

Jd, .

( 9.8

<{

"'

:s:
t:s:
:;

9.9) (
,
( 9.11),

9.10)

(9.12)

"'
u
"'w

<{

:s:

(9.13)

:I:

"'

0..

"'
<{

:s:

J5

:;

"'

:s:

;;!


9.13
.
r,

IS. IS
r
, -

, r
r , - .
, 9.13
9.13 r :
(9.14)
,
9.14 15 15

+ io + G - cyt0 .

(9.15)

cr +ir

_1-(1 -t)Cy
.
cr + lr

I'JS-

(9.16)

IS. 9.14
9.14
IS;


,
15

, IS
9.15, IS.
9.14,

p!S'-

a 1so : 1)
,

MPKf,
0 ; 2)

i 0 ; 3)

IS .

G,
a 1so
,

IS


,
i, ,

r

,
8
,

1t

:

Md
8
- = /0 +lyY -l1 (Y, r+1t ),

(9.17)

, - , /0 ly
Md -
/0 ,
.


, ,

(,

).

,
,

.
.
7,
,
(
),
,

M j P.
(
9. 17),

(9.18)

,

n
9.18
r,

. 9.18
LM.
9.18 ,

r :

r= L - (1 / l,)(M/ P) + L, LM,

(9.19)

(9.20)

(9.21)
9. 19 - LM.
9.19
, L - LM;

IS .

9. 19, L - (1/ l,)(M/ P),


LM.
M j P

LM

;;;'
111
111
111

10

n
L LM
.
, ,

! ,
0
L LM
.

IS-LM


.
,

:

9A.S;

9.6,

,
9.7.
,

,

9. 14:

(9.22)

"'

s
m
::J

:t:>

!!:

r (

9.8 9. 10
9.22), 9.9 ,

<

"'

:s:
1:s:

"'

<

"'

:r

I
,
.

.
,

,

9.18
, 9.18 .

:J:


9.22
,

18
9.

"'

(9.23)

:s:

2:

Q.

"'2:

<

:s:
2S

~
:::r

:s:

2S

"'

:;

t::{


9. 23 ,





,
(

.
,
)
,
. 9.22

( 9.8
,


9.10) . ,

9.23,

AD-A S

IS-LM,

AD-AS,

AD,
LRAS,

SRAS



,

, - ,
IS

IS LM.

LM, 9.14 9.19

15 -L +(1 / l,)(M 1 )

13Is + 13L

(9.24)

9.24 -
.

9.24 ,

, , -

AD .

,
9.24
IS LM.

,
IS (,

) LM
(,
) ,

,
,

AD


, :!:
,
, .

SRAS

=, SRAS.

(9.25)


:
=, LRAS .

(9 . 26)



AD

SRAS.


SRAS (
9.25) AD (
9.24)

= s -L +(1 / /,)( 1) .

;;'
111
111
111

10

(9.27)

~lS +~LM


, ,

,

,

.
= ,

9..26

LRAS.

AD

(9..24

LRAS

(9.26)

"'

"'

m
:::>

)::>

(9.28)

)::>

!Z:


9.28
, IS-LM
-FE 9.23.

,
,
L ~L
9. 20 9.21
9.28.

10



,
8. ,

,
, .
,
,

. ,

-

,
.
,

: 1)
2)
( )
,

? ,

,

.

1, n 8 9,

,

,


,
,
n
.

,
,
n
. , ,

n

,

.
,
n .
,
; ,

, ,
.
n


.

.


, ,
,
,

<

"""'
1s:
~

"'
u
""

<

:r

"'

:f:

:r

""

Q.

"":f:
"'

<

11

,
.

AD-AS.
IS-LM/

IS-LM/ AD-AS


. ,

,
,
,

.
,


. ,


,

. ,

. ,
.



,
.


,
,

,
.
,

(

),

,
. . 10.3

.
.

10.1 .

(
:

)
.

8.4


,
,
.


, -
,

,
, ,

,
, .

,
/S-LM
.
,



-
,
,

. ,
( real busine ss cycle theory )
( ), ,

. 1


,
.
/S-LM
/S
FE,

LM.

,
,


,
,
,

,

,

, ,
,
.
,

,


(

)?

3, 8
9. 2 3 ,
(
)

(MPN)


.

(. . 3.12).

, - ,

,


/S-LM (. . 9.8),


.
,


.: Charles
Plosser. Uderstandig Real Busiess Cycles 11 joumal of Econom
ic Perspectives. 1989 ().
. 51- 78; Roert G. ig, Sergio Rebelo. Resuscit
atig Real Busiess Cycles 11 Hadbook of
Macroeconomics 1 . J. Taylor, . Woodford. 1999.

2
,

;
, .

)>
I
}>

::.
:s:

::.
"'}>

n
n
:s:
J:.

"'...,

1::1
m

::.

...,"'

.t::

:s:
::.

"'
}>

,
, .
,


.
,

<
s

""
f-

<:;

"'
""

<
u

:r

:r

"'"""

""

<

s
JS

<:;


, ,

,
.
().


,
,

)
(

,
-

11 ),
(

""

::r
JS

"'

<:;

:{

,
.

IS-LM ,

,
, ,
,

-
.

,
, . .

:
. - ,

(
,

) ,
.


, ,


, ,


; . .

, .

,
,

.

,

,

,
.

.
,


, ,

,
,

. ,

,
,
.

, ,


. ,
1954-1989 .

1 ,

,

.

, , ,


,

( 1918-1941 rr.),

,
.
, ,

. . 8.13,

AD

, ;

,
.
,



.

,
1973- 1974
1979-1980 .

;;;'
111
111
111

...

:1>

:J:

:s:

""'

s
)>

n
:s:

. ,

,
,

, ,

, . ,

,

,

().

,

1
.: Business Cycles: real Facts and Monetary Myth 11 Q}Jarterly Reuiew,
Federal Reserve
Bank of Minneapolis. 1990 (). . 3-18.

..,"'

J:>
m

"

CD

..,

r::.
:s:

s
)>

,
.

.
,

<(

""

:s:
f:s:

:;


IS-LM, ,

. ,

"'
<(

Y=AF(K, N) ,

u
w
:
:s:


, ,
1

::1:

= N~ - ,

""

""
(!)

..

""

<(
~

:s:
:0
:;

""


- 1.
.

0,3
=

:s:

w
:0

"'

:;

1:::{

,

? ,


. , ,

,
.

,
, ,

,

.
,
,

, ) ,


.


,


, , .

.
,

.
2


, ,

.
(


), .
. 10.1 10.2.

10.1


,

, ,

3
.
1

- (

3). ,

.
,

11

Conference Series

Camegie-Rochester
.: Theory Ahead of Business Cycle Measureme nt

Pulic Policy. 1986 () . . 11- 39; Quarterly Review,

1986.

9-22.

.

.
,

,

, ,

10.1

.
(,

) .

111
111

111

,
. 1
, . 10.1 .
,

. , ,

.
.


:

. ,
, .

,
(. .
). , 1,0,
,

1,0),

, ,

. 1
,
, ,

)>

:>:

"'::."'
"
)>

10.2

....

"'m
"..,
L

1:>
m
::.

..,

I::

"'

)>

11:

~ 1,0

11:

<
s
fs

"'
;

::

"'
u
"'

<

:r
s
~

"'

/\

0..

"'<

;Q.
Q.

0,9
0,8
0,7
0,6
0,5
0,4
0,3
0,2
0,1
0,0

:;;

ID

JS

"':::rs

,
,

10. z


. ,
,

,
.

1,0

10.2


, ,

, , .
,
, .

. , ,
,
.
iI

? , , ,

,
,
.
, ,

. ,
, ,

, .
, , 1973, 1979 1990 rr.,

.

, , ,

. ,
, . 10.3

: 1) ,

;

2)

. 1
. 10.3,
. -

~~

~8

::1 :
111.0
;

s:
1'1

8.

28
26
24
22
20
18

16
14
12
10

8
6
4
2

:>

)>

:::.
s
UJ

"

:::.

-2

)>

36

72

108

144

180

216

252

288

324

()
()

360

()



( )

(
), n n-

"

10.3

:1:>

:::.

.,"'

n .

n , n
n n. ,

"

.
1

, = _ 1

+ 0,01 + ,

- n , _ 1

n , - n .

n -

- 1,0 1,0.

s
:::.
)>

,
, - .
<(

""

1-

<:;

"'
""
<(

:r
s

, ,

.

?

,

:r:

"'""
""
Q.

1 95 0 -

<(
~

, , , , ,

(Solow residual) ,

, 1

rr.

N.

3,

YjKaJVI-a

=.

(10.1)

~ , ,

.

10.1,

,

.

,
,

.
,

, ,
- ,

- (
) .

, ,

. 2
, ,
, ,

, ,
, ,
. ,


, , .
1 .: Technical Change and the
Aggregate Production Function 11 Review of Economics and
Statistics. 1957. . 312-320. 6 m .
2

.
, ,

, .

(,
)
, , (

). ,


,
anu

, u , ,..

, . ,

, , , ;


.
,

, ,

, u.

, ,

( ), ,
,
, , ,

u,JV.

, (. .

).

,

,

:

(10.2)
, , , , ,
N,
,

u,JV.

10.2 (10.1),
,

Dl

111

...
Dl

(10.3)

10.3 ,

,
, (

, ),

, ,.. ,
,
,

"'"'
""::::.:1>

n
n

"'m.s::

..,""

,
(
, ). ,
,

1 -

, .

,
1
.: Capital Utilization and Returns to Scale 11 Macroeconomics Annual 1 .
]. Rotemberg. 1995.

)>
I

Bernanke,

J:>
m

::::.

..,"'

.J::

s"'
:1>

. ,

<{

"s:

1--

s:
:;

::

"'
u
"
w
<{

s:

:J:

"

()

. ,
, ,

10.2, , .

, ,

1
. ,

"

Q.

<{
~

s:
:iS
:;

"

s:
::::r
w

:iS

"'

:;

. ,
31%,
<~ 23%
. ,

6%
. 6%
(3% ), ,
,
, , ,
. 3%

. ,
.
, .

. 2

. ,
, ,
, 16%

, 24%
.
, , ,

, . ,


,
.

,
, .
(labor hoarding) , -

, .
, ,

.
.: Labor and Output Over the Business Cycle
1985 (). . 638-655.
2 .: Seasonal Solow Residuals and Christmas:

11 American Economic Review.

Septemer

Case for Labor Hoarding and Increasing


Returns 11 ]oumal of Money, Credit, and Banking. 1998 (r). 1. . 306-330.

), ,

,
. ,

.

,

(
)

, .

(, ,

, )
.

, .

1 ,

, , , .

, ,

.
,

, ,
.

, ,

;
.

,
, ,
.

,
,
IS-LM.
.

)>
I

>
~
w
"'
"'>
~

n
n

"'
L

...,"'

J:>
m

"'...,

,
, , 1

.:

Why Is Productivity Procyclical? Why Do We Care? //


2000 (11).

"'"'
"'
>
~

<

"

:s:
t:s:
:;

t:
0:

<

"

:s:
::

:1:

"m


. 1

.

- , - ,
, ,

, , - , ,
,
.

, ,
, , , .
( .
2 , ,

"<

.)
10.4
IS-LM.

Q.

::

:s:
Jj

~
:s:
::r

Jj

"'

:;

. 10.4, .
, ,
. 10.4, .
( MPN) ,

f'l'l

.
, ,
, ,
.

...

10

'j'

,
2
.

, ,
,
. ,
, ,

.
3 ,
, , ,
. ,
,
, -

. - ,
- , ,
.
n
, n
n, , , n
.

2 nn, .
, , n n ,

n, n.

...

1.

11

"" .

~~
1- Q)
(,)':!

=s.
:i

Q)

11.
r

'2
'1

ND

2.

,N

Yt 2


. ,

10.4

NS'

NS2.

, F.
)

, FE' FP.


IS ,
IS' IS2. IS2 LM' FP,

,
, ;,

LM

F.

LM'

LJ.fl,

,
.

;;;'
111
11

111

...

)>
I

NS 1

NS2

10.4, .



F,

. 2

10.4,

IS-LM.

-, , ,

)>

=>

UJ

"'=>
)>

n
s
L

..,"'

]:::.

=>



, ,

-
.
,
,
,
, ,


1

2 ,
, ,

4.7.

4,

..,"'

.r::
s

"'=>
)>

.
1 FF.

..:
s:
fs:

"'
::

0:

..:

"'

s:
~

::t:

"'
"..:
"'
t1)

s:
:z;
::

"'s::::!

:z;

::

l:t

FE

FE

FE

IS. ,


,
, IS 1

IS
12). L

/52 (. .

- .

IS, !52, LM, L', FE,


.

FF,

LM

152

FF

( F).

IS ) (

FE ).

),

,
,

. . 10.4, (
!52 L')


. , LM
F
F.

, ,

, ,

, .
,

. -


.

, ,

.

, .

, ,
.

10.2,


: ,

. ,

, .

, ,

. 1 ,

, -
,

? m,


, . .

: ,
.

,

:

, -

-
~ ,
.

, ,

.
, ,

, -

.
,

. ,

, , ,

, .

, , ?

)>
I

~
s

""
>

::.

n
n
s
L

, (
). ,

..,""

,
,

, .
-

,
,

.
1
.: Lawrence Christiano, Martin Eichenbaum . Current Real-Business-Cycle Theories
and
Aggregate Labor-Market Fluctuations 11 American Economic Review. 1992 (). . 430- 450.

,

.

"'

..,"'

.r::
s
""
::.

>

, ,

<(

"s
f-

:;

"'
<(

"

u
w
:r

:r

"'"

..

"
<(
:

-
, .

, ,


, . -

, , ,
. ,
.

. ,

:!S

"'

:;

r:::::[


,
, . ,
,

, : ,
, . ,
. , ,
, ,

- ,

. ,
, ,

,
. , ,
, ,
;

, , .

, -
, . , -,
,

, , ,
.
- ,
,
, ,
. ,
, ,

1
. ,
1

m :

joumal of Political . 1982

David Lilien. Sectoral Shifts and Cyclical Unemployment 11


777-793.

() . .

,

, .
, ,
,
,

.

,
, -
,
.

,

, ;

, . 1

,
, ,
, ,
.


,
. ,



(
).


?


160 000

, 1973-19 86 rr.

11%


.
81%

-
(
).
,
,

.
,


,
.
,
, -,

,
.
10.5

1973-1993
. ,
- 1975, 1981-1982 1990-1 991-

, ,

,

. ,
1973-1975 .
, 1981-1982 rr.
(1984),
. ,
1



2
.: Cross ] Creation, Cross Job Destruction, and Employm

3.
ent Reallocation 11 Quarterly

joumal of Economics. 1992

(r). . 819- 864.


, . 10.5, : John
Baldwin, Timothy Dunne, John
Haltiwanger. Comparison of ] Creation and Job Destruction in Canada
and the United

States 11 Review of Economics and Statistics. 1998 (r).

347- 356.

;;'
111
111
111

....

)>
:t

1;

"'""
""

::.
)>

n
n

""
""
L

1::1
m

::.

..,

.t:

""""

::.
)>

18

~
:s 16

<{

"'

:s:
f:s:
<:;

Q.

1::

14
12

0:

10

"'

<{

u
w
:
:s:
~

"'""
"'

:s:

..

<{
~

1973

1975

1977

1979

1981

1983

1985

1987

1989

1991

1993

::z;
ID

<:;

q:


1973 1993 rr.
- ,

,
. -
,

1973-1993 rr.

John Baldwin, Timothy Dunne, John Haltiwanger. Comparison of job Creation and Job
. 347Destruction in Canada and the United States // Review of Economics and Statistics. 1998 ().
356.
:



rr.
1
1990-199

,

,


, ,
,

, ,



; ,

1

. ,

, ,


. -

,
, (

, ,

Katharine Abraham , Lawrence Katz. Cyclical U nemployment: Sectoral Shifts or Aggregate


Disturbances? 11 joumal of Political Economy. 1986 () . . 507- 522.

1 . :

.
,

,
, ,
.


,
,

,
.

, ,
, .

2,

, . , ,

. ,

, - ,
. ,

. , , ,
, ;
, .
,
,
,

.'
()

, ,
,

, , .

, ,

. .
, 2 ,

, .

111
111
111

....

::t

:s:

UJ

">::.

n
n

:s:
L

"

"'

10.2.

"'...,

.r::

.
,

.: Putting Home Economics into Macroeconomics


. 1993 () . . 2- 11.

11 Quarterly Reuiew,

.: Household Production and Development 11 Economic Review,

1999 (3). . 21 - 35.

:s:

"::.>

- .
-

<

"'

:s:
f:s:
:;

r::

"'<
u
"'

:s:
~

"'
"'<

()

0..

s;
:Jj
:;

"'s;:::r

:Jj

"'

:;

......

:r"'

-
- ()

, (

7). ,

( )


( )
, (
).

9 ,
IS-LM (. 9.9) AD-AS (. 9.14).

,
:
, , , ,
,
, .
,
,
, ,

. -
, ,

, ,
.

6 .

, ,
, , ,
, , ,

,
?
?
- , ,


, ,
. , ,

, ,

. ,
, .
, , ,
, ,

,
, .
(reverse causation) ,
, .

,
,

. 1

.
(

4'->

) ,


,
. ,
,

.

,

(, ,
. .),
.

,

.

,
.
,
,


,
; ,

,

. ,
,
,

,

.

,

, ,
.
,


.

~
111

111

111



,
.
,

.

- .

1960).2

1867-1 960

.'-> ( Monetay istory of the United States,


1867 ,

, ,
-
,

...

)>
:%:

w
"'
"'>:::.

(')
(')

"'.r.
"'

(')

J:>
m

:::.

"'...,


, :

>

.
.

Robert IGng, Charles Plosser. Money, Credit, and Prices in


Real Business Cycle 11 American
. 363-380 .

Economic Review. 1984 ().


.
2

.:

Princeton, N. ].: Princeto n University Press for NBER, 1963.

"':::."'

2.

)
(
,

3.

1.
<
:s:
1:s:

"'
<::;

"'

<

""w

:s:
~

""
"<
""
(\

:s:
J'i

<::;

""
:s:

::r
w

J'i

"'

<::;

,

.

, ,

.
, , ,

(

, ,
-

),

, .



,
- .

.
,

.
1960

,
, .

.,
1979

,
.

-

.
1982
1981

.
1980

.
1982 .
,

(
.
1982
1979

) ,


. ,

.
,
,

10.3
.


,
,
.

10.3.


,
,

11
1 .: Does Monetary Policy Matter? New Test in the Spirit of Friedman and Schwartz
Cambridge, Mass.:
NBERMacroeconomicsAnnual 1 . Oliver Blanchard, Stanley Fischer.
. 1. . Press, 1989.

9 .


. . 9.14,

AD,

, AD
. ,
.

,
.
, ,


, . ,
,

,
.
, 9,

AS, ,
.
,

,
.


,
.,
. 1 (misperception
theory), .

, , , , ..

,
, .

, ,

. ,
,

111
111
111

...
Q

)>
::t

.
.
, ,
. t .

n
s

, .
,
- .
. ,

, , , ,
, - .
,
1
.: Freedman. The Role of Monetary Policy
American Economic Review. 1968 () .
. 1-17. n n :

11

R. Lucas. Expectations and the Neutrality of Money 11 joumal of Economic Theory. 1972
103-124.

"'><
:::.

>
n
.

) . .

(n

n
><

..,

:::.

..,"'

J::

s
><
:::.

>

<

...:s:"":s:

::

"'
u
""

<

:s:
~

""
<
""
(!)

11.
~

:s:
:z;
::

""

:s:

::r

:z;

"'

::

:[

1'1'1

...1.1
.

"'

':

,
. ,
,
.
,
? ,
.
,
. , ,
,
, , , , ,
. ,
. ,
,

.
, ,

, , 5%.
, , 5%?
: ~ ,
5%, , 5%. 5%-
.
, 5%, ,
. :~> .

. ,

5% 5%.
,
, . ,
5%, 5%
.

,
,
. , ,
5%, ,
8%. ,
, ,
, .

.

. ,

5%,

8%.

8%,

. ,
. ,
2%,
5%, ,
,
.

, ,

, ,
.

, ,
. , ,

, ,

= + (- ) ,

(10.4)

- , ,
,
. 10.4

, , , ,

, , , ,

, ,


, 10.4 . 10.6.

, , , ,

, , , .
d = ,

M j dY= 1 / .

.
.
', .{ 10.4)

.
, (

>

),

, .

( < ), .

. 10.6
(SRAS),
, .

SRAS ,

10.4

, SRAS .
, ,

::t

""

( = ).

:1>

:s:

"'

::.
>

n
n

, .

10.4

, .

(LRAS)

, , , 8 9.

:s:
L

"'


, .

,
.

"'

J::.

:s:

~
>

LRAS

.AQ,.

==.

SRAS

ID

g_:r
>

<(

"

:s:
1:s:
:;

"'
"u
<(

;r

:s:
~

"
""

(!)

<(
~

:s:

::;;

:s:

:::1

::;;

"'

:;

c:t

,
"


(SRAS) . SRAS -

10.8

n
n

, ( = "
); , ( > ");
, ( < ").
, .
, (LRAS) = .
. ,

1. 7,
SRAS1

AD 1

, 1 ,
, ,

10%.
1
10% AD , AD
2
2
AD

AD ,

10% , AD 1 1 SRAS

, .

AD2 SRAS 1 ( F).

2 ,

F
, .

,
.

, , ,

, .

, , , .
,

F,

2 ,

1 .
. ,

- ,
tie ,

.0~

LRAS

:CD:

8CD

&,::r
>

----------

1.

----------

,
10%-

AD , AD' AD 2,
AD 2

10.7

10% , AD'. F, -

AD2 SRAS1,
, . ,
.

, AD 2
LRAS.

10%,

, .
, SRAS ,
1
3

.
,
- (LRAS),
. . 10.7 ,
AD 2 LRAS.

:t:

"'w

1 . ,

::.

:, 3 10% ,

3 , SRAS, SRA52, = , .
3
, ,
7qJ

,
.

"'m.r::

n
><

..,

):

::.

. ,
,

. 10.8

.
,

, , . 10.7.
1
, ,

><

)>

10%

IJI

..,

.:

s"'
)>

LRAS
<(

..."'s:s:
.::;

----------

1::

1.

"'

<(

"'u

::r
s:

----------

"'"'
"'

0..

<(
~

s:
:;;
.::;

"'s:::1

10 % -

"'

, AD 10%
AD 1 AD 2 , -

:;;

.::;

~
1"1
.

...v

1'11

10.8

10% 1

3 .

SRAS 1

SRAS2.

, .12,

. ,
10% , . ,
, .

10%

AD

2
AD 1 AD 2, AD
1 SRAS
10% , AD
. , , ,

, .

- , -
10%, 10% 1 3 _!! SRAS,
SRAS2, . 10.8, ,

3 .
, 10% ,

. ,
.
,
. ,
. ,
. , ,

,
.

, , -

. .
-
, , ,
. , , ,


; ,

.



r ~ .
, rr r

, ,
.
,
.
r
,
.
,
,
, .

, .
,
r .

,
, ,
.

(rational expectations) ,
, ,

,
. 1 (
10.1.)
, .
,

r .
,
-
.

)>
::1:

"'"'
"':::,
)>

(")
(")

"'L

m
(")

,
,

"'...,

- .

]::1

.
,
,

.
,
, , 1
.
: Rational Expectations and the Theory of Price Movements
Econometrica.

11

1961

() . .

315- 335.

~~ 1970-

rr.

m
:::,

CD

...,

1::

"':::,"'
)>

&
<
s

..."'s
:;

"'
u
"'
<

10.1

?
- ,
; . .

,
.
. , ,

, -

:t:

"'

()

<>.

"'<
~

s
:z;
:;

"'s

::r

:z;

"'

:;

...

"'

':

, ,

. , ,

, , .
, , ;

,
.


, .
, , ,
, .

, .
,

', = ,

t - 1, t.

, , ,
t. t

',

t.

,
.

, ,
,

,
, , ,

. ,
1970 - 1980- r., ,
, -
-

1973- 1974

1979 rr.

, ,
.

r
. '
,
,

1968 .
, ,
.

. :

Are Ecoomic Forecast Rational? 11 Quarterly Review,


1989 (). . 26- 33.

" ,
, ,
. , r
, , -,


, .

''.:

Inflation Forecast: How Good Are They? // Business Review,


1996 (/). . 15-25.

-
- .
, ,
, -
.

(propagation mechanism) -

. ,

, . ,

.

,
,

.
,

.
, ,
.
,


.
,

( )
.

)>
:J:

:1>

,.::.
UJ

"'
,.

::.
:1>
n

n
.s:

II

..,"'

1.

IS-LM

2.

::.

, .

..,"'

()- ,
(,

r::.

) .

:1>

IS-LM

, ,
.

,
. ,

,.
::.
"'

<
:s:
....
:s:

3.


, ,
. ,

"'

::

.
-
. ,

"'
u
"'w

<

:r

:s:

:t:

:I:

:s:

,
,
, ,
,

:!\

"'
<
"'
:t:
()

Q,

::

"'::1

:s:

4.

:!\

"'


,
. IS-LM

fij

, ,

:[

ftl
.

1-

, - ,

"'

~
.
.

5.

( )
, ,
,
, , .

6.


, , . .

. ,


( )
,
,
. ,

7.

, .
,
,
- ,

.
, ,


1979 .,
.

8.

,
.

, ,

. , ,

, ,

, .

, . ,
, .
(SRAS),
,
,

.
,
.
(LRAS) ,
.

9.

SRAS,
,
( ) .
,

, t
( ) .

,
, .

10.

,
,
.

, ,
,
. -

,
.

)>
I

>

:::>

:s:
w

":::>

>

()
()

(AD)
.

IS LM (. . 9.10).
,

LM .
AD .

,
, ,

:s:
L

m
()

"...,

J:>
m

:::>

CD

...,

:s:

":::>

>

AD-AS

<
s
1s

LRAS

"'

SRAfi2 ( = )

....

SRAS

:r

(=,)

F,,,,'"

2::

:z:

"'

----------

AD

t1'l

"-

"'2::

<
s
:JS

~
s

::1

:JS

11)

r::::{

AD-AS ,


,
.

. ,

, ,

(SRAS)
.
.
, ,

SRAS1

SRASt ,

1
,
,

, . ,

( 1 ),
1
SRAS ,


,
.

, . ,
(LRAS) = ,

AD-AS

7.

IS LM.
, -

IS-LM ,
AD . ,
AD, . 14.

,
. ,

,
.

,
.

SRAS.

AD

, 1'

SRAS1

Ji 1 ,

, 2

, ,

SRAS .

(LRAS)
AD. ( 1) , (2)
(

PJ

, 3 ,

SRAS2

;;'
111
111
111

....

lllo

)>
I

:s:
w

)>

()
()

:s:

()
;;

= + (- ).

( 10.4)

, ,

,
. ( > ),

, ( < ), , .

...,

::::,

"'...,

r:
:s:

)>


1.

IS-LM

IS-L?
?

2.

3.

z .

<(

"'

:s:
f:s:

<(

4.

"'
"'

::r

:s:
~

5.

""

(1')

6.

"'

, ?

<(

, -,

:s:

? ?

1i

:s:

::r

7.

1i

, .

"'

8.

/'11

':1'

,
? . , ?

11.1
10

, ?

"-


? ?

9.

)
?
,

10.


- ?

3
1.

=
-

A(100N - 0,5JV2),

- , N -

. ,
,

MPN=A(100 - N) .
=

1,0,

1, 1.

NS = 45 + 0,1w,
w - .
, -

. ( 3), MNP-
, , MNP
.

) (),

NS= 10 + 0,8w.
) ,
.

, .
:

() ().

2.

+ 0,5( - 1) - 50r.
Jd = 450 - 50r.
L = 0 ,5- 100i.
()1 = 600

= 2210.

1t"=0,05.

,
= G, - .
)

, =

4320 G = 150.
IS-LM ,

, , . (

.)

4752.

(). ?

) ,
4320, 190.
(). ,
( G).
? .

3.

+ 0,5(- 1) - 500r.
Jd = 250 - 500r.

L = 0,5 - 500i.
= 1000.

n"=O.

) , =

G = 200 = 7650.
IS. ,

,
LM.

, ,
. m, ,
, ? ,

) , =

...

)>
::t
)>

:::,

:s:
UJ

;><;

)>

()1 = 250

111
111
111

:::,

;-

G = 200 = 9000.

n
n
:s:
.s:
m
n
;><;

...,

J::>

m
:::,

...,"'

.r::
:s:

)>

, , ,

? , .

""

s:
s:

1-

4.

<>:

<
u

""w

= + 10( - ").

= 500 = 400.

60.

? (: ()

:I:

""

"'
<
""

10.)

) = 700.

0..

, "
.

s:

60.

) , = 700,
.

::z;
::

""

s:

, " ?

"'

AD

) , " =

s:

AD
= 300 + 30(Mj P).

::

::z;

G = 300 = 7650.
AS:

) () =

<

5.

::

c:t

=AJ<0:3NJ ,
- , ,
7

30,
100. 100 2000 . 105 2001 .

2000 2001

) 2000

2001 . ( )
? ,

) () ,
2000 2001 .

10.2.

() ,

6.

3%

2001

3%

2000

: 50 ,
. ~~
, ;

, .

m = 50 m
, ~~ ~~
( ). ,
~~ ~~. 51, 52,
53, 52. -

7.

50

) 100 .
1% ,
, 19% ,
, .

) 5%.
? ?
)
3% .
1%,
19%.
, , .

8.

( 10..) :

IS

r = 2,47 -

0 ,5 -

0,0004.

500(r + n").

= + 100(- ).

, - ,

- . , n" = ,
, , 88 950,

= 6000.
)

9 10.

15 , ~IS' .L' ~L' l ? (:


,

LM.)

) ?
) , =

29,15.


1.

)>

) IS-LM,
,
, , , ,
. ,

:::,

:J:

.
,
.

AD-AS,

. ()?

"':::,
)>

n
s

n
L

"'...,

2.

)>

s
w

IS-LM
100 (

).
100 .

)
.
100

100 ?

];:>

m
:::,

...,"'

.t::

"':::,
)>

) , ,

<

. ,

"'"'
s:

1-

:::

t:

""
"'

<

, .

::

"'

,
, 100 ,

:I:

Q.

3.

:::

,
IS-LM ,
.

? .

:0

"'

) .

:::

1"1
.

1-

-:r"'

IS?

"'"'
"'<
"'
:0
"'"'::1

IS-LM,

4.


, . ,

, ,
(,
). -

.

IS-LM,
. ,

) , .
?
, .

5.

)
10%- .
.


? IS-LM,
, ,

( ),
.

,
FRED
- : research.
stlouisfed.orgjfre

1.

- (,

3.2)
1961 .,

, .

3.1,
,

.

2.

N.


( . 8)?
,


,
.
)

1960 .
,

,
( )

2

4
2
. ( 4 -

2
. )



.



( ).

,

? ,
,
?

;'
111

111

...

111

:1>
:t
>
~
".

""
"'
>
~

n
n

".

.r.

"'...,

:r;:,
m
~

"'

.t:
".

"'
>
~

<(

"'

.s
t.s
:;

t:
IX

<(

"'

w
J

.s
:

"'
f\

lOA


AD-AS

0..

"'

<(
:

.s

25

"'


AD-AS,

9,

AD-AS

:;

q
1'1'1

1-

:r"'

9.
, ,


9 . 24,

(AD)
(10.1)


IS, 15 ~IS'

~L'

L
LM,
9.15 9.16,

9.20 9.21,

/r-

9. 17 .

10.4,

+ ( - ),

(10.2)

10.1)

10.2,

10.1
10.2).

(~ 15

~L) ,

a 2J>2 + 1 - 3 =,

(10.)

2 -

<Prs + r);

<Prs + r) ( - ) - ars + au.{t


0 -

Mj l,.

,
1
2 0
, .
2 0 ,
10.

.
,

.

,
10.:

- 1 +~ai +4 2 0
2 2

(10.4)


,
10.4

10.1
10. 2.
,

10.4.

, ,
10.2 ,


.

,
_Q 10.2

, .

, 9.

;'
111
111
111

....

)>

::r

>

:::.
s

"'

"':::.

>
n

n
s

.t:
m

"'-,

J:>
m

:::.

"'-,

,1;:;

s
:::.
>

"'

11

10
.
,

,
.



.
,

~~, ~
~,
.

,

.
,


; ,


.
, ,
-
-

.



,

.
,
1970- ., ,

, ,

,
.
, -,

~~ ,
,

.

,

,
?
,
,
?

,

-
- ,

;


. .
.

<
~

:s:
:s:

1-

::


.
,

~
~

/S-LM,

w
;r
:s:

?
, :

:I:

Q.
~

<

:s:
1S
;

:s:

"::!

w
1S

"'

ffi

t:t

11.1.


, . 11.2
.

. ,

,
,
(

). ,


, .

,
,


-

.

,
,

,


,
- .
(

),

,
, .

,
,

,


,

, ,

,
.

, ,

,
,

r
,
,

.
,

,
,



.

, ,
,


. ,


, ,
,
,
. (


-

,

.)

,

, ~,
,

(tumo ver cost),

,
.
,

,

. ,

,

,
.


,


.


,

,
, ,

. ,

wage model).


( efficie ncy

;;:;

:S:<

:t

n
:s:

>

:t

-i

"'

>

.


?
~

~.

~,
, ,

, ,
,
.
( George Akerlof), 1

. :

1982

George Akerlof. Labor Contra cts as Partial Gift Exchan

() . .

543- 569.

ge 11 Quarterlyjoumal of Economics.

"
"':t"

:s:

">
;11(

-i

":s:

:t

, , ,
,

<(

...s:"'

s:

<::;

1::
0::

<(

"'

s:

:r:

"'
"'

()

<(
~

s:

"'

<::;

~
1'1'1
.Jj

1-

\,/

"'

,
,
, ,
,
,
,
.

,
ge otive ),
excha
(gift


.
,

<<, ,
,

, ,
1
.
<~

(shirkig d/) ,
,

,
,


,
. ,
,

,
.

,


,

,

, ,
,

.
( -

,

)
.

,
,
,

effort curve ) . 11.1.


(
, , ,
, w,
.

,
.


,

<~ <~ ;
S- .
. ,

,

.

.
,
,


,
.


,
?
,

,
,

w.
,

loyment as
' . : ! Shapiro, Joseph . Stiglitz . Equilibrium Unemp
444.
433.

().
1984
Review.
ic
Device 11 American Econom

Worker Discipline

WA

w*

, ,
,
, w.


,

11.1


,
S- .





. ,

,

E,.f w,..



,

.
-
, w ,

* .

11.1.

,
,

w'
.

;r



, ,

01
111
01

, w
. ,

......

.
,



,
.

,


, ,


. ,

,

,
,
;


.
,



,

(efficiency wage ).

11.1


*.

w,




.

,

,


,
,

.
,

,


.

;>:;

:r
"''
n
"':r
)>

!:)

"'

:
)>

"'"
"'"'

:r

"'"'
)>

*
m

-i

"'"'

r:::
m
:r

<(


,

,
.

"'

:s:
f:s:
::

::

<(

"'

:s:

"'m
"'

Q.

<(

:s:

,
,

11.2.

, -
,

,
, NS.

.'

2i
lt1

::

~
1"1
.11

...1.1

"'

w*,



.
.
w*

,



.

w*,

*,

3,

MPN.
,

,

MPN,
,

MPN,
,
,
-

N. MPN -
.

, ,

),
(
w*

,
. ,

, *,
,

11 .2,
, .
.
.
.

ND*, ,

,
* .
.

ND*

,


MNP, ND*
*,
.

11.2,

,
ND* ,
.

w,


, ,


w*,

,
NS 1

2

, ,

,
,


, ,
1

,
2 tr


, ,


. 11.2. ,
, wE

,

,
.

it

~w*f-------o----~c>-=-----:-:--:----

:
:1

WE

-------------------~--------'

1
1
1

1
1

1
1
1
1
1
1



w, ,

ND

N.

,

w, NS

1

. ,
w ,
-

w
,
.


N.
N,


; . .


, 1:
.
(,
N

NE . 11.2.)
w*,


N.

;;:;



,
. 11.2 ,


. , ,

,
,

,
(NS - N)
1
1

,

?


,

. ,
,

,

,
,
.
1

,
,

,

"''
n
"'>
:1:

:1:

"'

>

"
""'

:1:

""'
>

;.;

!:1

"'"

r::.

:1:

<
s
fs

"'
:;

"'
u
"'
w

<
:

:I:

"'
"'<

0..

s
:z;
:;

"'::1

w
:z;

"'

:;

w
t:[

...u
.

"'

:r

. 11.2,
, ,

.
,
,
.

? 11.1
.

. ,

1 ,

,
,
.

, -


,
,

).

,
(

8).

,
. ,
,


,
, .

,
,
, ;
.
,

,

,

).
(

FE

, , FE
IS-LM

,
.
,


, ,

N,

. 11.2,

*.

, ,

,
, , FE.

FE:


.
.
,
. .

FE

.

FE,

FE

of the Efficiency Wage Hypothesis
Peter Cappelli, Keith Chauvin. Interp lant Test
7.
769-78
.

.
)
(r
Quarte rlyjoum al of Economics. 1991

11

& 11.1



1908 -191 4 .
Ford
Motor

. *


.



,

,


.

,

, Ford ~.

,
.

,
,


,

,
,

,

,

.
:

N2 86 86 ,
N2 86
" " **

,


.
- 10%

, -
.
,


.
1914 .
,
$5
,


,


,


.
-


.


,
:

,
.


87%,

75%,

30%.

Ford
Motor ,


.


,


.

,



1928 . ,
.

,

;:;

m
S<

:t

40% ,

)>

:t


: Daniel . G. Raff,
Lawrence . Summers. Did
Henry Ford Efficiency Wages? 11
joum al of Labor is. 1987 (
) . . S57- S86.
Step hen Mey
er. The Five-Dollar Day: Labor Man
agement and Social
Control in the Ford Moto r Company
, 1908 -192 7, Albany: State University
ofNe w York Press ,
1981.

"'

:
)>

"'

."

(J)

"'

:t

. -
,


. ,

w,


. - ,

,



, .

~
;.;

~
:s:
)(

J:;

:t

11 .2.

<(

"'

:s:
1:s:

::

"'
"'
w

<(

:s:

"'
""'

/)

<(

:s:
::15

::

"':::r

:s:
w

::15

::


, ,
,

,


,




,



.
s)
ines
(pri ce stick



. 11.1 ,


,
-


:
.

,

.

,

.

,
,

, ,

.

,
(

10)

).

(
:



.

.
.
,


,
.
,

,


,
.

11
.



,
,


,

?
:


: 1)



,


,

2)

~.
~
,

,
.


(

IBM )

.

(,
-

),



. (price taker)
- ,

.
,
,
.
, ,
(price setter),



,
,
,
. ,

,
,

,
. .
,

, .

5
, ;
, 5

, .

(

;

; ,

. .),
.

,
.

(, ),

(perfec t compe tition).


,
,



, ,

(mono polisti c compe tition) .


- ,

;;;'
111
11
111

......

"'
m

:S:<

::t

:s:

>

::t

!:1

"'

>
;><;
"

<JJ

, ,
,

.
,

, ,

.
,

.

,
? ,
-
,

;><;

::t

:s:

;><;

>

"'

!:1;><;
:s:

r=

m
::t

(,

).
) (,

<(

"'

:s:
f:s:
<:;

"'
u
"'
<(

:s:
~

::

"'
"'

()

0..

<(
~



. ,
,

- ,
.


, ,

,

:

1. ,

:s:

<:;

"'

:s:
:::r

2.

.
,
,
~>

"'<:;

.
,

3.

,
,

,
,

cost).
(menu

)
(

-
,
. ,


, ,
.


, , -,
,

,
.

.

. ,

5 ,


. ,
.

5 ,

. ,

,
,


.
,
- , -

.

,

,
,
,
,
.
,

~ ,

,
. ,


,

.


.
,

1957- 1966 rr., 1



,
. 11.1,

,


. ,

11
.
,
,

,

11.1.

n
( )

: Dennis W.
.637-658. 1.

13,2
13,0
12,8

10.2
8,7
8,1
5,9

""

S<

::t:

5,4

s
>

4,7
4,3
3,6
Carlton. The Rigidity of Prices 11 American Economic Review.
1986

::t:

-i

"'

().

>

"'
w
"'
."

1990-1 992 rr.


200

.
11 .2
,
,

. , . 11.2
, 10,2%

.
1

.:

The Rigidity of Prices 11 American Economic Review . 1986


() . . 637-65 8.
2
Alan Blinder. On Sticky Prices: Academic Theories Meet
the Real World 11 Monetary Policy 1
N. G. Mankiw. University of Chicago Press, 1994.

:I:

s:

"'>
""~m

"'

.r=

m
::t:

<(

"'

s
fs

,

. 11.2,

,

(49,5%) ,
.

. 22%

"'
<(

"'uw



( )

,%

10,2
39,3
15,6
12,9
7,5
4,3
10,2

1,01 2
2,01 4
4,01 12
12,01 52
52

::

"'
"'
"'

0..

<(

11.2.

the Real World // Monetary


Alan S. Blinder. On Sticky Prices: Academic Theories Meet
4.1.

1994.
Press,
Chicago
of
y
Policy 1 N. G. Mankiw. Uiversit
:

w
:0

"'

q:

. ,

( ).

,
,
. ,

,
, ,

.
,

.

1

12
ent, Inc.
L. L. Bean, Orvis and Recrea tional Equipm

,

.

35 .

,
, ,


,
,

.
,
.

, -,




,
.

,
, .
?

,

,

, .

s
Anil Kashyap. Sticky Prices: New Evidence from Retail Catalog
Economics. 1995 (). . 245-274 .
1

11

Quarterly journal of

, ,

(margina l cost)

.
-

(markup) . , 15%
, 15%.
,
11

, :
=

(1 + 11),

(11.1)

- , , -

. 1


( 11.1 ),
, .
, ,

, ,
.

, ?
~ . ,

( ), ,


.
,

,

. ,

, ,

.

,

. , FE ,

. ,

FE. ,

,

,
.
.

,

, .

, ?

, ND"( ), . 11.3.

, , ( effective labor

demand curve)

;'
111
111

111

......
;;

:S:<
:I:

n
:s:
)>

:I:

!:!

"'

:
)>

><;
."

(j)

><;

:I:

:s:
><;

)>

""m

:
,

,

!:!><;

11.1 .

,
( )
. ,
,
MPN (1 + )w*, w*- ,

MNP w*. ,
.

:s:

.t:

:I:

, ND

(Y)

<(

"'

:s:
:s:

1r::;

0:
<(

"'

u
w
:
:s:

:J:

"'"'

Q.

"'
~

:s:

,
,

<(

:Jj

r::;

"'

:s:

::r
w
:;;

"'
r::;

1'1'1

,
.
,

,
.

.

- , ,
,
, ,
.

"'

...1:

, ,
.


. ,

. 11.3 - ,

(
.

,
r

.)
,

.
,

. 11.3.

FE

. ,


, FE

11.2).
.
(
ND*

, , ,
N, . 11.3.

11.3.

IS-LM , ,

AD-AS.


- -
.


AD-AS.

IS-LM,

-
IS-LM.
IS-LM
IS-LM,

1 . , IS LM ,
FE FE,
.
FE
.

, , ,
,

FE

. -,


, ,

, .
-,

,

FE,

FE .
-


.
, ,

IS,

LM FE,

, ,

,
?
,


. ,

,
IS

LM.



FE.
FE,

, ,
,
.

, ,

, ,
,
,

.

11 .4
IS-LM. ,


, . ,

LM , Lt
Ll (. 11.4).


, IS FE
.

;;<;

:S:<

:r
n
:s:
}>
:r

"'

}>

;><;
"

;><;

::r

:s:

"'
}>

"'

:s:

.r::
m
:r

FE

15-LM

<

""

:s:
f:s:
<:;

"'
""

<
u

IS

:s:

:I:

""
<
""

: 2

''
'
''
''
''
'
''
''
'

()

..

:s:
:z;

:s:
::r

:z;

-----------------------1

'

'

''

"'

<:;

::[

L2; IS
n FE .

LM n, LM

n F,
n ,
n.
,

2
n FE. n
N2, n
6) ,

.

.
,
LM- n

LM

)
).

6),



(- ),

,
.



.
.

IS L2

( F),

r2
2 ,

FE,
IS-LM F
,

_.2 , 2 , ,

.

,
,

2 ,
.
,

- ,

11.4,

,
2

N N2.

- ,

LM

- ,
~.

,
~. ,
LM
,
.



?
,
, ,

, MjP. , ,


,

. 1 ,

(

), .


,
F . 11.4.

.
,

.
,

(
),
2

.

,
LM

Lt

11.4, .

, .
, ,

,
z
.



.


,
,

;'
111
111
111

......
;;:;

S<
:I:

s
>

- AD-AS.

-


AS-AD.

"'

.

,

"
"

. 9.14,

AD-AS, 10%-

, ,

,
.
10, -
,

,

9,


.
1

,
,

:I:

::

>

."

UJ

:I:

::

">
m
""~
"s

.t:
m

:I:

<

"'

:s:
f-

:s:
:;

::

0:

<

"'

u
w
:

:s:
:

:I:

"'
"<
"'
(!)

(SRAS) .


,
,

:s:
]j

:s:

::r
w
]j

"'

:;

r:::r

9.14.

,
, ,

, .

9.14,

SRAS 1

9.14

10%-


,

F).

,
AD 1

AD 2 ,

9,
10%

AD

.
10% AD

AD

F,

, . -


, ,

. , F

,

.

, ,

,
,

. ,

. 9.14,

:f,

2 10% ,

, ,
,


. ,

-
,


.
,
)
(

,
.
. 11.5.
,
( ,

/S-LM

Lfoil

FE

2.

:1

1
1
1
1

1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1

--------------------

----

1
1
1

1
1

)
,


IS
151 ISZ.

11.5

F,

2 ,
r
2

) ~ ,
,

N N ,
.
2
F.

, ,

LM LM' LAfl.
,
, ,
N,

, r
3

Cll
111
Cll

......
;;>:;

""'
:

""
)>

"'"'

, ,
).
) 6)
.



, IS
, IS 1 IS'l (.
. 12).
,
,
F . 11 .5, ,

IS, !52, LI. F


, ,

F
. 11.5, .
-
, IS

,

.
( -

)>
;;

"

"'
;;

""
;;

)>

""~m
""
;;

J::

m
:


),
,

IS

<

"'

:s:
t:s:
~

1::
0:

<

"'

:s:

:I:

"'

"'

Q.

"'

<

:s:
:z;
~

"'

:s:

::1

:z;

"'

~
1'1\
.

...

:r"'"'


(multip lier) ,
,

. , ,

. 11.5, t!.G,
,
11.5 !l ,
.

t!.G.
/
!l


,

1,

$1 ,

$1 .
11.

oe ,
, IS-LM
,

,
.


, .
) ,

FE
FE

. ,


(- )

(. .

.
)
IS-LM


,
,
. (


,

,
.)

Lt LNfl . 11.5, ,
, LM ,
,

. ,

.


11.6).
AD-AS (.

IS

,
.

-
2
,
1

, AD AD


F. F
.
,

.
, ,

,
,

IS-LM.
, ,
.

Q,

1. -

.8
:IC

Q.

2.

>-

SRAi2

SRAS 1

(.
. 11.5).
AD 1 AD2

(
2

F),

n,

11. 6

AD-AS

,

2
.
,

AD2

LRAS. ,
1 2

SRAS 1 SRAS2.

. ,
,

;;'

IS ,

.
,

01
111
01

IS

......

, ,

S<

,

.

;::;

IS? ,

,
.

G
, ,

, -

rY -

IS .'

CD

IS

1
,

, -

,

15.

"'
"'

U>

(
. 11.5 11.6).


n n .
n
n
-

:
)>
-

, , n

4),

G.

:]:

)>

"'
)>

"'s

};:


,

.
,

..:

"'

:s:
f:s:
:;

,
,
,

"'..:
u
"'

11.4.

:s:
~

:r:

"'"'
..:
"'

..

:s:


,
: 1)
,

2)

.
?

:JS

"'

:;

r:::[

FE,
,
.

,
shocks)
demand
e
(aggregat
.

LM
, IS
,
.

IS,


, ,
1

,
.
,


, LM,

.

JS-LM,

, -

.
,

11.7 ,

.
,


,
;

.


,
1 !5'2.

F, ,

IS

!5


, ,


.
,
1 ,
.

FE,
IS,

,
(, ,
-)

, .
11.7.
LM (-

)
;
,
,

.



-,

.

,

,
: 1)

; 2)
,

, 3)
,
,


, ,


.
, 8, ,


.


, , ,

. ,

,
,

Al

11

......
Al

;;<:;

"''
"'
:I:

)>

:I:

!:1

"'

:
)>

""

<J)

"

n, -
n

, IS
, IS 1
F,

, .

11.7

:I:

""'
)>

""'

.r=
m

:I:

ISZ.


.
(

)


<

s:
""
....
s:
;

"'
u
""w
<

::r
s:

:1:

:I:

"""'
"":1:

0..

<

s:

w
Jj
10

IS



,
LM;

,

,

LM

,
)

(-

(

,

.
)

,
. 11.7,
,
.
,

, ,

. ,

,


.
-

,
,

-
, ,

,

(
,

).

,
- ,

.
,

. .

10.1,

~.
, ,

.
,
,

(,
,

)

.

, ,

,
,
,

. ,


,
.


, ,

. , -
-

- ,

.

( IS-LM-FE).

, ,

,
,

, .

, ,
, .
- -

. , , . 11.8.
,
,
,

F.

:;;'

1\1
111
1\1

. , . 11 .7
.

, :

IS

Jst

....
....

;:><;

Is'l.

1990- 1991

"''
I

. (. :

: 1990- 1991 . ).
,

, ? :
1)
- ; 2)

3) .

1. J. .. .

, .

. F . 11.8
, .

"'
}>

-1

"'

~
}>

"'
"'

."

\J)

"'"'
}>

~
m

LM .
LM LM1 Ll,

"'"'

,
(

, )
.

-1

.t::

.._
w

111

1-

Ql

g:::l'

<
:s:
1:s:

"'

<:;

::


.
.

:.

:;

<
u

2. 3

"'
:

:s:

"'
/)

Q.

"'

<
~

:s:
::z;

Q
:s:

=:1

::z;

"'

F
,

/52.

/S , /S'

,
LM

1'1\

LM L2
( 1) .

<:;

..ra
.

\,/

11.8

. ,

,
L2

LM

LM

,
(

2).

- ,
/5 1,
, /S /52

( 3).


,
.

2. . ,

, ,
LW . 11.8. ,

,

LM L'

. .

IS ,
JS' 152.
, . 11.8, .

. -

-
.
,


-,

; ,

. -,

1),
. ,


,
(

LM
.
, -

( 2 3)


.
, ,





,
,
, .

-, -
.

11.2

, ,

.)
,
? ,


.
- -

( , ,

. . ). . 11.8,

, (

) , (

).

, (

) ,
.

- ,

, .

,

,

- .

-


(macroeconomic stailization) .
, ,

(aggregat e demand
managem

ent ),


1960- .

.
,


,

,
.

-
(. 10.1),

. -,

, ,

.
-,

,
-

111
111
111

......
;::;

S:<

:t

s:

>

:t

-i

"'

>
><

"'

w
><

:t

s:
><
>

;.;

~
><
s:

;::;.

:t

<(

"'

s:
~
s:
<:;

::

"'u
<(

"'w
:r

s:

:r

"'
"'
t\

0..

<(
~

s:

1990- .
.
1960 1990 .
,
6%

,

. ,

,
.

,
-

,
,
.

- ,

, ,

1991 .

1990- .
.

,
.

,
,
(
1990 ., ,


1980- . ,


.
,

, ,

, .
,
,
.

-
.


.
,


. ,
.
,

,

:

,
- .


.

- ,



. -

,


,
.
,


, ,
-
.

, ,

(liquidity trap) .

( ) -

.
,



.: Anil . Kashyap. Sorting Out Japan's Financial Crisis 11
, Economic Perspectives. 2002 (4). . 42- 55.


(

,

) . -

,

.

1990-

rr. 151

L' ,
,

- . (

,
,

,

.) , LM
;

, .

FE

r=i= O
(1te = )

, ,

, ,

.
,



; ,

. (
-

1995 . , ,


1997 . ) ,
, -

,
.
.
( IS
1
/5 /Sl) - (
LM
L' L2)


.
3 .

"'
m

:S:<
:I:

:s:
)>

:I:

"'

:
)>

><

."

UJ

><

Adam Posen. Restoring Japan's Economic Growth, Institute of Internati


onal Economics,
Washington, D. ., 1998.

:I:

:s:

><

)>

;.(
m

, .

,

,
. ,

.
,

, ,
,

><

:s:

J::

:I:

.
.

<
s
fs

"'
::

"'u<
"'

:I:

"'
<
"'

0..

s
JS

::

"'

::

JS

"'

::

:[


, ,


~ ~



1970- .

. ,

1973-19 75 rr.


, .


, ,
,

()

rr.,
1970-

.

11.9


3,
, ).
,

,

, .


,
FE1 FF.

FE

,


,

q ,

(
2 . ,

)
.

, ,
.
, ~

. ,
~
,

.

, ,

, ,
, .

1.

2.

; ~

FE .

11.9


,
,
-

,
,

LM , LM1 Ll.

Mj P,



F, ,

,
.

F
, ~.

,
.
LM
, L' L,

.

,


. ,
,

LAfl . 11.9. ,
LM IS
FE,
.
F, LAfl
IS. F
FE, F

~ (),


2 .
,

. ,

1)

; 2)

2

LM ( ; )

111
111

......
;>:;
m
::r

,.,

,.

(')
)>

::r

(')

-i



,
, Mj P.

LM , Li

111

"'

:
)>

"'
"'
::r
,.
"'
"

(J)

)>

"'

,."'~

.r::::

::r

. 11 .9,
,
.



-, -

;:2

s:
fs:

FE;

"'

~ 3 ),
- LM (

::

<

"'u

::r
s:

:J:

"'
<
"'

,
. ,
, ,

-
,

F
~ ,

s:


, ,
,


,
,

:J!

Q.

"'s:

:J!
tO

11.9,


, ,

:ij
r:::{

1.


,
.

,
,

2.

,
.

,
.
, ,

) .

3.

N,


.
.

4.

IS-LM
. FE
,


.
FE

,

.

5.

6.

,
,


.

, ,

.

,

.

7.


IS LM.

FE,


.

,
,

.

LM

8.




AD-AS.


(AD)

(AS) .

,
.

AD

(LRAS).

9.

LM

.

.

10.

; -

,
.



IS ,


.

,

. -

;;'
Dl

......
Dl

"''"'
m

::t

s
>

::t

!:)

"'

...>
...
"

\J)

::t

s
>
;.;

...

...!:)
s

.t:
m
::t

11.

IS (
LM (

, )


) .

<
s
....
s

"'

, ,

:;

::

:;

<

"'uw

'

. .
,

, .

:I:

"'
"<
"'

(!\

12.

-
,

,
.

s
s

Jj
:;

"'::r

Jj

"'

:;

r::::[

/'11

...v

13.

"'


1970- rr., ,
.
,
)


1.

?
?

2.

(
?

3.

?
,

4.



,
?

, ?

5.

6.

7.


(
)?



.



?
?


?
,

,
,

.

?

,
.

8.

, ,
.

9.

;'

10.

111



,
?


?

111

......
111

;:<;
m

"''
I

:s;


1.

)>

"'

8
10
12

~
)>

"
"'"

."

7
10
15
17
19

14
16
18

20

:s;

"

)>

;.;

n
..;

":s;

MPN = E(100 -N)


15
'

.r::
m
I

.
- , N -

?
, ?

,
, , 200

<(

"

:s:
f:s:
:;

"'
"u
<(

2.

? , ?

:

(Jl = 130 - 0,5( - 1)- 500r.

:r

:s:

:J:

"'"

Jd = 100- 500r.
G = 100.
= 100.

r = ,5 - 1ooor.

:s:

1i

=500.

":s:::r

,
,
:

0..

"
<(

:;

1i

1320.


) IS LM. (

r

. )

"'

:;

~
1'1\

, ,
) ,
.


) ,

...1.1
.

1'0

-:r

Jd = 200 - 500r.

,

,
,


? ?
.

3.

+ 0,8( - 1) - 500r.

(Jl = 600

Jd = 400 - 500r.

L = 0,5 - 200i, i >.

1000.
G
rr! .

2,0,

,
8000.



.

,

, ,

,

; ,

LM

,
,
,

~ (. 11 .2).

? ?
)

G, ,

1990- I.
,

.

4.

()1 = 300 + 0,5( - 1) Jd = 100 - 100r.


G= 100.
= 100.
L = 0,5 - 200r.

=6300 .

=700.

r.

) . (
:
,

. ,

.

m ,

,
.)

) , = 15.

, , ?
)
,
, ,
?

5. ( 11.) ,

S<

::t

s
>

::t

Cll

N= ~ -

>

W = 20.

1.1)

) 20


?
)

, ? .

,
IS
)

"'
"'

."

,

, (

) .

LM (

......
;:<;

111

111

=2o.JN ,

;'
ID

:I:

"'>

;.;

-i

"'s

.r::
m
::t

<

"'

:s:
f:s:
:;

1::

"'<
u
"'

/ = 0,5-

300.

IS LM,
.
. ,

,
( ) ().

,
) , ,
?

:s:
~

) , , ,

"'"'
<
"'

135.


, , ,

..

:s:

120- 500r.
500r.

JS
L

6.

1i

( 11 . ) :

325 + 0,5(-1)
Jd = 200 - 500r.
G = 150.
= 150.
L = 0,5 - 1000r.

=6000.

:;

"'

:s:

()1 =

::1

1i

"'

:;

...v
.

"'

500r.

= 1000.

) , ,
.

L' r l, ?
1s>
( 9,

) a 1S'

.)

15.
) , =

?
)

15 ,
G = 150 G = 250.

15

) 11..5,

G = 150 G = 250.

()?


1.

IS-LM

, ,

?
.

).

) (
() ,

).

)

.

2.


,
.

IS-LM

, ,


.
)

,
.
)

, ,

3.

,
,
,
.

,
,

,
.

?
, : )

)

4.

- ,


.
, ,
.

,

,
,

?



, ,
.

: )

) ,

?

5.

;"
111

111

......
111

;;

S<

:J:

s
>

:J:

>

>
;><;
"

;><;

:J:

s
;><;
>

:.;

, ,
~~

.r:
m


: ,
~~ (
, )

( , ) .
,

(

~
;><;

:J:


.
.

,
,

. ,

.
.

<t

""

:s:
1:s:
<:;

"'<t
u
""


,
?

:r
:s:
~

:r


-
.

""
""<t

) .

) ,

,
.

()

..

:s:

, , .

"'

<:;

ft


, ,
stlouisfed.org/
reseach.
:

FRED
-


fed

1.


1960 .,

(

(


, ()

12

).

? ,

2.

,
-

,
.
1960

.

.
1980

2

?

1980 .?

,

,
2 1980 - ..


, 1980 .?

3.

1 10

111

......
111

;;<;

S:

::1:

s:
)>
::1:

"'

::
)>

"'
"'

."

Ul

::1:

::

s:

"'
)>

!~
m

"'

s:

.t:
m
::1:

11
(

"'

1-

:
:;

"'

"'
()

1>.

"'

s
JS

"'s=r

JS

"'

1'11

...u
.

"'



.

. ,

, .


( ,
).

AD-AS


,
.
,

. ,

.
,

,
- .
.

,


,

,
,

W,
. ,
, w,

, , ,

Wj P.

.

,

,
11.1.
.
, SRAS

2.

1.

,
,


. ,
SRAS 1

11.1

. , .

10% AD , AD 1 AD 2

, F.

. ,

, SRAS1 SRAS2 ,

.
W
10%, , ,

, ,
.




,
. 11 .1 .

, AD 1,
,

SRAS 1 10% AD

AD 2 ( AD 2 10% ,
1
D .)

, - F.
F ,
2
2
,

,

.

,
,

. ,

, ,

.

,

. ,

"
m

S<

::t

)>

::t

!:1
>

::
)>

"
"

Ul

"

::t

::

"
)>

""

"s

.r::
m
::t

.
SRAS 1 S.RAS2.

<

"'s

1-

"'<
"'

u
w
J
s
:

:t:

"'
t!

..

"'<
:

w
Jj

"'

:{

3 ,

W

10% , 1

P,
Wj
,

10%,



.

,

(),

. , ,

,
,

. ,



. ,

, , ,
,

.

,
,

.
,

, , ,


.
.
,
,


, , ,

6%.
,

6%

,
,
, .
.

,
,



. ,

W/

.
,

50% -
, ,


, 50%

6%,
. ,

(3%
3%

3%.

6% - ).


, ,
.

, F . 11.1
, , (
,

) . , ,
, . . ,
.

, ,
. ,
, ,

, , .
(

) (, .

11 .1,

1 , ,

, ,
, ; .

111
11

......

111

:;:;

,.,

m
:

n
s:

>

"'

>

"'
w
"'
"

s:

"'>
;.;
m
Q

"'s:

];:.

m
:

.:

Scott Summer, Stephen Silver. Real Wages, Employment and Phillips Curve 11 joumal
. 706- 720.

of Political Economy. 1989 ().

118

<(

"'
:s
f:s
t:;

::
;

<(

"'

u
w
:

:s
:1:

:I:

"'
"':1:
(\

<(

:s
:21

~
:s

::r
w

:21

"'

t:;

11

,
,

9, ,

G. . -,
G .15 ( IS . 9.14).
. 15
, 9.27. ,

,
G .
G . 15'

a./S' 9.15 :

(11 . 1)

0 , i 0, ' i, t 0 - ,
( . 9) . G 6.G, . 15
6.Gj (c, + i,), . .
6.. 15 =

6.Gj (c, + i,).

(11.2)

, 9..27, ,

= , :

= [ a.Is- .L + (1/ l,)/ (M/ )] / (13Is + IL) .

(11.)

11. . , , . 15 6.. 15'

6.a.1sf(l3 15 + 13L) ,

(11.4)
, 11.2 6.. 15
11 .4,
6.G, :

6.Yj 6.G = 1 / [(, + i,)(l315 + IL)].

(11 . S)

11B.S -
, G .
, .
, (
0 i 0 ) ,
.

,, i,, 13 15 13L ,
.

1. ,
, , , , LM

(. . LM, ~L 0). Lr

, r JS, ,

. , 9. 16

IS, {J [1 - (1 - t)cy] / (c, + i,).

15
LM, ~L ,

~/ ~G=

1/ [1 - (1 - t)cy]

(11 . 6)

, , , '
0,8 , t, 0,25. r ,
11 . . 6, 1/ [1 - (0,75)(0,8) ] = 1/ 0,4, 2,5.

, , . . ~L ,
, 11 .5 ,
.

LM,

;'
111
111
111

......
;;:<;

::S:<
I

n
::s:

>

"'

>

..,"'

IJ)

"'

::s:

"'>

;.;

-i

"'::s:

.r=

~
:
I

, ,

.
,

, .

,

, .

- ~
-

, .

, .

, ,
.
,

- .

- .
,

, . ,
, ,

.

21

~s

ti

:I:

s
s
<

c:t
w
Q.

w
w

<
s

""t-

.
, ,
, .
4, ,
.

13


,
. 14

,
, 15
.

:;

0:

<

""

u
w
:r
s
:f:

:I:

""
<
""
::
/)

Q.

12.1.

:
?


. ,

,
.

.


1
1958 ., . . .

97 , ,
, ,
. ,

, ,
- . . , -
. 1950- 1960- .

,


(Phillips curve).
, . 12.1,
1960- . .

rr.,
12.1
- .

1960-
, . .

,
, , 1961 ., ,
, , 1969 .,
, .
, . .
. 1960- ., ,
,
.


. ,
1 .: . W . Phillips. The Relation Between Unemployment and the Rate of Change of Money
Wage rates in the United ingdom, 1861- 1957 11 Economica. 1958 () . . 283-299.

,; 6
~

t
:s::

5
4
3

1961


, %

1960- r .
, ,
.

,
,

12.1



1960-

rr.

, , .
:

FederaJ Reserve Bank of St. Louis FRED

dataase

research.stlouisfed.org/fred

~ ,

. , 1960-

rr.

, ,

, ,
,
. , , 1960- rr.,
.

: . 12.2

1970-2002 rr.

1960-

rr.,

,
.

1970-

rr.,

(). , 1975 .
8,5% ,
9,1%. ,
, .

, ,

1970 . :


, , ,
, 1958 .

1 960-

rr.?

0'1
w

"
"'
)>

"'

:s:
J::

)>

:s:
:s:
:I:

::;,

"':s:

J::

"'

11

t:I:

i!.
ri 12
~

s:

s:
s:

<
~
Q.

i-z

s:

14

1980

1974 1979

1981

10
01975

w
w

<

"'s:

1973
19700

.....
s:

"'<

"'

u
w

s:

:I:

01977

"'

':1'


,
1970 2002 r.
1960-

10


,%

Q.

...u

01983

"'
<
"'
~

.q

01982

1976

01990

19890
1991
1984
01971

19880
1985
01987

1972
2001
2000

~993 01992
1996 1995 0 1994

1997

1999

1986
2002
1998

:;

1978

rr. ( . . 12.1) 1970 r.

1970-2002


, -,
.

Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis FRED database research.stlouisfed.orgjfred


, , , 1960- . ,
1970 . ? ,

1970 .?
,
? ,
,

?
;
, 1970 . ,
- ,
- 1960- ., ,
. ,
, -

,
.


, -,
1960- r. ,

, 1
2 ,
. , -
.

) (
). 3 , -,
,

.
, ,
.
,

. ( 3
, . )
. ,
, .

,
. -, , ,
.

( )

( , ) .
- ,

.
,
(. . 12.3).
,
, 10%
,
. 10% ,

;'

10% , AD 1 1
AD2 2, . . ,

, , ,

111
11

111

....

."
)>

"'-i

(SRAS)
10%. ?

I::

, .

s;
s;

12.3

10% ( 10% ),
, , SRAS 10%.

. , 1

Milton Friedman. The Role of Monetary Policy 11 Amencan Ecormic Reuiew. 1968 (). . 117.
2
.: Money Wage Dynamics and I...aor Market Equilibrium 11 Microeconomic Foundations of
Employment and Inflation Theory 1 Edmund Phelps. New York: W. W. Norton, 1970. . 124166.
1

3 . ,
- , ,
.
- ,

3.

s;

)>

:r

::.
:0

I::

s;

:0

LRAS

:Jj

tJ

:r
s
s

'</
/

10%

<(

<::[

11 0

Q.

10%

w
w
<(

><
s
fs

<>:

<(

><
u

w
;;
s

:r

:f:

><

(!)

Q.

><
<(

10% ,
AD 10%, AD 1
1 AD 2 2, . .
10% ,

12.3

10%,
10%. ,

10%

, 100 1 110 2, . . 10%


1
SRAS 10% , SRAS 1
SRAS'l 2.

AD SRAS ( 1 F 2)
, , u,

10% .

100, SRAS
100 ( , ),
. 2 110,
- SRAS'l. 2
F, ,
. AD SRAS 10% ,
10%
1

, .
?

, :,

u.


,
, . ,

.
10%- 10%-
, 2 15%
1
10% (. 12.4). , 10% AD
( AD 2 ), 2
15% AD 1 ( AD 2 ).
2,
2 11 ,

, , SRAS'l. 2 -

.DQ.

:IC

LRAS

:IC

ll

&.=-

113

15%

110
100

AD2,

10%
, 10%,


SRAS ,

10%.

12.4

SRAS 1 SRAS'l 2. ,
2 15% 10%, AD
1

AD 2"0 .... D 2 = .
2

, G 113.
13% 10%, r 2 3%.
, , ,
, ( ) .

G, D 2 " 0 SRASl. G

113,

2 13%.
10%, 13%

3% 2. , G

, :,

2
2 13%

?
, 15%- ,

, 10%- .

2 ,
M j P, ,

, ,

. , ,
, ,
, .

, ,
, . 12.3.

, , ,
, .

, , ,

cn

"'
..,"'
"

)>

:s:

J::

)>

:s:
:s:
::r

::,

"'
:s:
"'

J::

, ( ,
25

) .

tJ

~:s:
:I:

:s:
:s:
<(

fif
Q.

u
w
w

<(

"'

:s:
:s:

1::

<::
;

<(

"'w

:s:

,
, ,
(. . 12.1). ,
,

(. .

12.4).

, AD
, ;

( ),
(
) .


, , :
1t -

:I:

"'
"'
~
(1)

Q.

<(

-4'
.

11.1
/11

n =

- h(

- ii ),

1t -

1t' = r

, 1t, ,

1t');

- ii = (
, , , ii );

h = ,
r .
,

,
, , ,
1
, .

n,

1t

= n- h( - ii).

(12.1)

12.1 ,
. ,
(expectation- augmented Pblllips curve), 1t
, n, , ,
,

ii,

, .


,
. ,

- , , ,
,

. ,
.

1 ,

,
.
, .

12.5


-.

1 - 3%.
3% 1 ? 12.1
, ,
( 6%),
. ,

, ,
. ,
1 ,

3%.

3% (
6%), 1
.

, 3
12.5 , 9%

12%.

, 1 PrY.
PrY ( ) ,
12%, , PrY
12%. 1 PrY ,
-;1.

s
~
i"'
::

...
::

111

01
111
01

Q.

>-

---.____

...

3 12%

01

"'

."
)>

"'

:s;
J::
)>

(6%)
- ,

. , 1 -
,

3%.

:s;
:s;

, ,

12.1

, ,
(
6%), .

,
' 3%, 1 3%.
PCl, ,

12%,

, 1

PCl.

PCl 12%.
3 12%

:t

J::
:s;
:

21

~s:

t:J:

s:
s:
<(

<::!

Q.

<(

"'s:

1-

s:
:;

"'
u
"'
<(

,
, .

. ,
,
,

. 12.6. 1
1
6% 3% ( . 12.6 ,
1

. 12.5).
7%,
3%. . 12.6,

PCJ.

, ,
PCJ . 12.6, 7%,
PCJ. ,
, 7%. ,

7%.
-

1:

:J:

11

s:

"'
"'
~

Q.

<(

-4'

...

.11

PCJ,

. -

,
.
, , , ,

:r"'

"#.
~

g:

--...____

6 7%

--------------

:1:

111

!
3 (1te = 3%)
1 (7te=3%)

-

.
1

3%,

u,%

, 6%. , 1 -
, 6%,
3%, . 12.5.

7%,

PCJ. PCJ ,
3%,
, 3%.

. ,
,
. 1

,
.

,
-
. , -

, ,
.

, ,
,
. ,
,

(. 11.2), .

,2
.

,
, ,

. , ,
,
.

, ,
, .

.
.
n .

(.

12.5

12.6)

, . :

,
, ,
1960- .? - ,

,
. . 12.9,

1960- . .

, , 1960- . ,

.
, 1960- .
( . .

12.1).

1
n , nn
, , n .
2
n rn n

. n n,

n, n , ,
.

;;;'
111
111
111

...
N

01

"'
"'
."
)>

:s:
I:::

)>

:s:
:s:

:t:

"'
:s:
"'

I:::

: ,
, 1960- ., , 1970 .
(. 12.2)? , -, ,
1970 .
, 1960- .,
.
1970 . .

"'s
f-

:;

0:
(

"'

:t:

"'"'

, ,
1973-1974 1979-1980 . ,

, ,
, ,
.
1980- ., ,
1990 .

1970 .
. ,
,
.

.q
.11
11.1

1'0

1970 .,
2.1,

Q.

"'
~

(. .

1960-2002

.). ,

- -

, , ,
1
,- 1960- .
,
, , ,

,
. ,
1979-1982 .
1980 - . ,
-
1970- ., 1980- . ,- ,

1970-2002 .,

? . -,
U1Ulu
,
.

1970-2002 . . 12.7. ,
(
),
( , ).
()
,
,

- 1960- r. ,

,
.

=:~..
:1

~#!
s: -

s"
i!:~

-&

8.~

:1:

:z:S:

1979

1974

1973

1970

1~0

2000

1978

1971
2001;:d572 ) t'\1996

1999

-1

199 -1 988

1998

0
1995

01~5

19
0 19 ~1981

v 1987 22

0
1997

-2
-3

1980

1994

...._ 1992

1985

1993 -.............
1976
1984

1982

19860

-2

-1

1983 0


, %

-
r

.
1970- 2002 rr. .

12.7

1970-2002

, r
.
(. . 12.9).
, , , - ,
.
: Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis FRED database research.stlouisfed.org/fred
Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia Livingston Survey www.philfr.org/econjlivjindex.htlm

,
. 12.9.
12.7 , ,
,
, ..
1970-2002 rr. ,
- ( . 12.7 . 12.2). ,
,
1982 1983 rr., ,

- .

,
, - ,
, ,

1970

"'
..,

."
)>

01

:s:

.(::
)>

:s:
:s:

"'
:s:
"'

.(::

:
:25

~
s

~ ,
? ,

IJ:I:

)?

, ,
,

<(

:if
u

..

. :

w
w

<(

""

s
fs

<:;

0::
<(

""

u
w

:r
s
~

:I:

""

!)

..

""
<(

::

'4'
..11
~

\,1

:r"'

- .

,
,
. , ,
, ,

.

,
-
,

, , .

- , (,
- ),
, ,

.

, - ,
. ( 12.1
.)
, , ,

- -

. 1 ,
, ,
, ,
,

, ,

n . - ,

,
, .

, ,

. ,
.


- ,

, ,
, ,
1

1,

- ,


, .

&

12.1


, - , -

100% ,
.
, ,

?
, , ,

. , ,
, ?
,

? , ,
. , ,

, .
.
.

,


. , ,
(Lcas critiqe). ,

, ,

.
,
, ,

. , ,
,

.
.
,

, .

- ,
, - ,
.

)>

"'-i

r: Thomas Sargent. Rational Expectations and Inflation, New York: Harper


& Row, 1986. . 1-2.
Econometric Policy Evaluation: Critique 11 Camegie-Rochester Conference Series Pulic
Policy 1 . Brunner, . . Meltzer. 1976. Vol. 1.

:s:
.

)>

:s:
:s:
::1:

=>

"'

:s:

,
, 1te
1t. ,

12.1),

, ,

1te = 7t, , ,
,
,

u.


(long-run Phillips curve).

"'

,
1i

~s

f-

:I:

s
s

,
=

u,

12.8.


, 10 11.

,
, .

, ,

<(

, ,

<(
::(

1.

""
s

f-

:s;
:;

0::

<(

""

12.2.


, g .

, ,

, ,
.

:I:

""
""
~
!\

1.

<(

'4'
.

1-

"'

, - ,

.
, - . ,

, (
)

j12.8


,
.


? (. 3.5),
, UIUl , 2%
. ,
$10 000 , ,
, ,
$200 .
, ,
,
, ,

,
(

10

).

, ,
, , . ,

,
, ,
.
-
, .
,

, . ,
,
.

,
. -, ,

, ,
- ,
. , -
,

.

,
, ,

, . .
,
,
.

;;;'
111
111
111

...
N

01

UJ
."
)>

0"1

,.
.10:
,.
,.
-i

)>

::,

- , ,

.
,
. 3 ,
;

,."'
"'

.10:

.
1!

~s

. ,
,

t;

:I:

s
s
<

<:1

..

<
><
s
s

...
::

"'

<
><
u

::

:I:

.,.,><


. .

12.9

,
, 1960-

2002 . , . 12.9,
5-5,5%
, , 1960- . ,
1970- 1980- . , ,

6%

.

, , -,
.

12.10,

12.10,

( ,

><

) . , (

16 19 )

..

<

, ,

~
.

>'S~

",

il

......

::

:11

CD 'S
11 ...

'",g
~

10

\,)Q,
l'l

'S~

>'S 'S

~ :z:
ull


7Q.

s>-

t;

6
5

3
1960

1964

1968

1972

1976

1980

1984

1988

1992

1996

2000



1960-2002 rr.


.
,
1960- 1970- r.,

1980

12.1

. .

: , Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis FRED database


research.stlouisfed.orgjfred, UNRATE; :
, www.co.gov, h Economic and Budget Outlook: Ftscal Year 2004-2013, F- 11,

NAIRU.

.,.
i

22

& u

20

"

18

16

Q.

J..
:IC

14

12

10
8
6
4
2

1960

.,.
i
~

10

"

6)

22
20

1965

1970

1975

1980

1985

1990

1995

2000

18

Q.

1')

.8..
:IC

Q.

>

16
14
12
10

;'

111

...

111
111

01

UJ

LL----~----~----~----~----L-----L-----L---~--

1960

1965

1970

1975

1980

,
,

1990

1995

2000
12.10

( )
,
.

: Economic Report of the President. 2003. - 43 . 1972 .


.

) , 1959 ,
. ,

2002 rr.

( .
:

12.10, ) .

Economic Report of the President. 2003.

-43.

:s:

>
:s:
:s:
:r

:::.

1985

)

1959-2002 .

">

"'

"'
:s:
"'

]j

:s:
,_
u
I
:s:
:s:

<
:[

<

"'

,_:s:
:s:
:

<
"'

"'

::

:s:

, ,
( )

, .

, , (
) ,

,
. , - ,



.
,
.
,
, ,
.

"'<
::

.
,
, ,
,

'4'

"'"'

.11
1-

ra

'j'

1980 .


.
, ,

, 1960- 1970- . 1980 .
, ,
.
- ,
. ,

1998 .
24 25% 1980 .

16%
16


1980 .

5 5,5%, ,
1990- rr.
4%, .
, 4,5% .

- ,
.
, , 4,5%,
? ,


, , ,
. ,
1 Roert Shimer. Why is the U. S. Unemployment Rate is So Much Lower? 1I NBER Macroeconomics
Annual 1 . Bernanke,]. Rotemberg, 1998.

, .
,

.
.
, -

,
. 1
,


, 1990- .
, ,
.
,

. ,

2% ,

, , 2%,
.
,

4%

. 2
.
-


.
1980- rr.
.

30

. ,
, 1970- .,

( . 12.11
, , ).
1970-

rr. ,
, 1981- 1982 rr.
(. . 12.9). ,

1980- ., 1990- .

4%
1970- rr. 1980- rr.
, ,

5% .


?
,

, .

(hysteresis)

, ,

,
. .: The High-Pressure U. S. Labor
1

Market of the 1990s 11 Brookings Papers Economic Activity. 1999 (1). . 1- 88.

1990- . The NAIRU in Theory and Practice 11 ,journal

of Economic Perspectives. 2002.

115- 136.

111

111

111

...
N

01

"'
"'-1

."
)>

J:::

)>

s
s

:I:

:;,

"s
"

J:::

'#.

14

tI

s
~

12

10

::zs

s:

10

10

10

<
q

:1:

.."'

>

<
s:
fs:

"

, '

~-

1
1
1
1

1
1

111

11

s:
s:

8
7

' ......

' ... ,_ .

:;

IX

"

<

s:

"
"<
:
/)

..

1961

1966

1971

1976

1981

1986

1991

1996

2001

12.11

-4'

...v

1970- . 8- 10%

1980- .
, . n n

"'

"3'

: - www.s.gov. no
, n n
. no 1990 . n .

, .
,
1970-

rr.,

- ,

. ,
,
.
,
, .

. -, ,


, (
).

.
-, ,
,
. ,
-

. ,
, ,
,

. , 1 97 0- .
,
.
- , (insider- outsider theory)
,
,
( ), ,

, . ,
,

. ,
,
,
. .
- ,

.
, ,

, ,
. ,

1980-

rr. ,
. ,
, . 12.2


3
,
, ~ ,
,
. ,

, ,
.

,
.

1. :
. ,
,
.
,

,
. ,
, ,
. ,
,
,

,
, -

!;;

....

:s:

t:;

:J:

:s:
:s:
<(

(),
. ,

q
w

, . ,

0..

,
.
,
,

<(

"'

:s:
....
:s:
:;

1970-

"'

1966- 1985 .
, , , . ,

::

<(

"'uw

:s:

:J:

...:!'
.

1-

1.1

111

, , ,

<(

12.11).

1) (replaceet ratio),
( 2/3,

(1)

0..

(. .

"'
"'
::

rr.

2/3 , );

2) (beefit dratio), ,
;

3) (eligihility reqireets),
, .
,
. ,
, ,
,
, .
1973 . ,
, .
, ,
1970- rr., , ,
,
.


, - ,

, -
. , (
)
, , 1960- 1970- .,
, . ,

, -,
.

*Joless and igh European Unemployment 11 Barriers tr Growth: Transatlatic


View j

R. Lawrence,

Schultze. \\'ashington, D. .: Brookings Institution, 1987.

. ,

2.

.

, , ,
.

,
,
.
, ,

,
.

3.

.
()
,
,
(. 12.2), ,

. ,
,

. ,
, ,
,
, .

4.

.
,

; ,
.
.

, - -


- , -

. , ,
,
,

.

tl

...,
m

."

. ,

)>

"'
-i

)>

s
s

::t

12.3.

1971

.
,
5%. 1970- .,
, ,
N~

1;

1980

. -

. ,

, ,
.

:::,
Xl

Xl

:z;

~:s:
f-

u
:I:
:s:
:s:
<{

, ,
. ,
: , ,
, .

Q.

, . , ,
,

4%

, ,

4%

- ?

, ,
, 4% ,
,
. ,


. 1
, ?
,
.
, ,
. ,

3%

4%

3%

3%.

7% , . .

, , 4%,
7%,
. ,

, . 2
,
, .

, -
, , , ,
.

.
, ,
,

(shoe leather costs).

, ,
~. ,

, ~. ,
,
.
2 ,

.
,

. . .

4.1.

, . ,
10% 0,3% ,

$30 . 1

-
.
,

. , ,
,

, .
,

. , ,
,
.

r .

, .

, , 4% ,
6%, 2% .

6%- , : 1)
4% 2) 7% ?

6% 4%,
1 ( 7

6%)

3%,

. - ,
, .
, ,
; ,

, .
,
. , ,

, , -
. , , ,
.

.
,
(), ,

, - .
, (
), ,
, .


, , .

, ,

. ,
, -
,

. , 1
.: Stanley Fisher. Toward an Understanding of the Cost of lnflation: 11 11 Camegie-Rochester
Conference Series Puhlic Policy 1 . Brunner, . Meltzer. . 15. 1981 ().

;;;'
1

111

...
1

,
]j

~:s:

1-

::

:s:
:s:

<

:;:f
<>.

<

"'

:s:
1:s:

r::

"'
u
"'
<

,
.
,
(. 12.3).
,
. ,

, ,
, - ,
. ,
,

. , ,
,
, . ,

, ,

, ,

::

, ,

:s:

"'"'
"'<
:

<>.

-4'

...

IJ

1'0

:r

, .

, , ,
, .

(hyperinflation)

. 1 ,

1945 .
19 800% . 2
1281% 1984 . 11 750% 1985 .,
276% 1986 . 3

, ,
. ,
,

,
.
- , , -
( - ,

) , .
, ,
.


.
.

,
. , , 1

( .: The Monetary
Dynamics of Hyperinflation Studies in the Quantity heory of Money 1 Milton Friedman. Chicago:
University of Chicago Press, 1956)
, 50% .G.
2 . 1.
3 C. : Juan-Antonio Morales. Inflation Stabllization 11 Jnflation Stahilization: h Experience of
Jsrael, Argentina, Brazil, Bolivia and Mexico 1 Michael Bruno, Guido Di Tella, Rudiger Dornbush,
Stanley Fisher. Cambridge, Mass.: . 1. . Press, 1988. 7.3.

&

12.3


, ,

, ,

3%,

, ,

3%,
. , 6%,
9%,

3%.

, ,

. ,
,
(
11).

?
,
( ,
) ,

, ,
.
,

, COLAs. ,
, 1%

1%.

1997

, .
, ,

.
,

1984 . 445%.

80% .

,
.

1985 .

,
.

;;;'
111
111
111

...
N

11

w
"

)>

"'~
:s:

.t:
)>

.: Stanley Fisher. Israeli Inflation and Indexation 11 Inflation and Indexation: Argentina,
Brazil, and Israel 1 ]. Williamson; Institute for lnternational Economics, 1985, :
Indexing, Inflation, and Economic Policy, Cambridge, Mass.: . . I. Press, 1986; . : Zalman
F. Shiffer. Adjusting to High Inflation : The Israeli Experience 11 Federal Reseve Bank of St.
Louis Review. 1986 () . . 18- 29.
,

.
,

, ,
. ,

,
.

:s:
:s:
::t
&
:::,
:0

.t:
:s:

:0

,
(.

12.3

).
.

<(

"'

s
fs

:;

<::

<>:

<(

"'

'3'

.;I:

"'"'
"'
::

,
. ,

7,


, .

,
?
7 ( 15),

,
. ,

>.

<(

-4'

...

"'


, :
. ,

( disinflation) -

.
,

12.1,

.
, ,
.

- ,
, ?
:

, , ,
. ( ,

12.1, ,

t, , t',

, , -

u,

.) ,

, ,
, , .
?

: .
,
-

, ~

( cold turkey).

~> -

,
,
, .
,
, , ,
.


,
. ,
- , ,

, ,
;
. ,
,
, ,

,
.

(gradualism) ,

. ,

, ,
, ,
, , -

, ,
. , ,
,
,

. ,

, 12.4.
.

,
-
.
( ,
) ,
, ,

.
. -,

, ,
.

, ,
, . . .
, ,
.

- , ,

. ,
- , ,

cn

."

)>

0'1

..;

:s:

.r::.
)>

:s:
:s:
I

::.
::
.r::.

:s:

::

:25

~
tJ:I:

&

12.4

,
. ,
,

s
<(
:[

0..

u
w
w

<(

"'

s
fs

:;

"'
"'uw
<(

:I:

"'"'
"'
~

0..

<(

..".
.

1-

10

. ,
.

,
. (sacrifice ratio) - ,
, 1%. n,
n , n
rr., n 8,83% ( 12,10%

1980-

3,27%

) . ,

15 , 16,18%
. 16,18%
8,83%, 1,832.
, , ,

1980-

rr.,

1,832%

.
,
, 1960-, 1970-

1980- . ,
,
n, .
1,0 ,
3,0 . ,
,
. ?

1,00

1,50

0,75

2,92

1,74

0,93

1,57

0,79
2,39

, ,
, , .
,
, n

, .
,
,
. ,

,
,

, .

,
. , - ,

. , ,

,
, .

, . ,
, , 1,

. ,

. : What Determines the Sacrifice Ratio? 11 Monetary Policy


University of Chicago Press, 1994. . 155- 188.

1 N. G.

Mankiw. Chicago:

. , ,

, .

1970- .

1971 1974 .

5%. ,
-, . ,

, ,
, .
,
, ,

- .


,
(. 5 ).
, ,
, 1971 . ,
- -
, ,
, .
. , ,

;;;'
111

111

1\1

.....

. ,

, ,

,
. ( ,
) -
, , ,
, - .
?

, ; ,
, , , .

, ,

, .

, ,
,
. ,

,
, ,
. ,

01

UJ
-

)>

"'

-i

.r:
)>
s
s

:I:

::.
:0
.r:
s
:0


:i!

s"'

, -
.

tJ

"'

:I:

14.

"'
<

o::r
w

0..

w
w

<

1.

"'s:
f-

!:::
0::

<
:

1980-

w
J

"':1:

. . 1958 .
,
.

.
1960- ., 1970-

2.

:I:

rr.

,
.
, ,

(!)

0..

<

. ,

-t

(. .

1-

0),


(. . 0).

"'

,
.

3.

,
( )
,
.

.
,

.
1970-

rr.,


, 1970- .
.

4.

,
, ,
. - ,

;
,

,
. , ,
, ,

5.

. ,

. ,


,
.

6.

,
, ,

, , .

7.


. ,
1960- 1970- rr.,

.
.

8.

,
,

, ,
. ,


.
,
,

, () , ,
().

9.

,
.

;i

01

( <~
~)

10.

,
. , (
)

ID

...
N

01

"'
"'
."

)>

"'s:

, <~ ~ (

.t:

s:
s:

) (

) .

. ,

,
.
,

11.

01

- .

,
.
,

)>

:r

::,

"'s:
"'

.t:


:lS

( ) ,

t;

s
(

:if
D.
u

"'s

1-

::

<<

::

"'
(

"'w
u

"'
"'
~

1t = 1te- h( -

<\

D.
(

-4'

...

,jl

1.1

1'0

:r

u).

(12.1)

, 1t - 1te, , ( - u).
,
, ,

u,

, n", ,
.

,
.


1.

? ,
? .

2.

, ,
? ,
, ,
?

3.


1960 -, 1970 - 1980-

rr.?

4.

,
? ?

5.

6.


?

? , ,
?

7.


r . ,
?

8.

,
?

9.


. ?

10. ?
,
?


1.

1t

= 6% (0,06).

= 12% (0,12)


1t

= 7t"- 2(u -

).

, ,

1%,

2%

) . 1t = 0,04, 1t =
= 0,08. 1t = 0,04, 7t" = 0,04.
?

? ?
?
?

01

)
:

0,08

0,04

0,04

0,04

0,10

0,08

0,06

0,04

11

?
?
?

2.

~
CD

...
01
N

...,m
-

)>

"'-1

~
)>

:r

:::,

( ):

AD

300 +

10(/);

SRAS = + - _
(- Y)jY = -2(u- ).
= 500.
=
)

0,06.
, = 1000
= 50.
, , , , , ?

"'s
"'

) ,

...
...:>.
:s:
...
u
J5

:I:

:s:
:s:

? ,

<(

<:[

,
?

Q.

1200.

, , ,
, , ?

3.


1t

<(

...":s:
:s:

:;

<::

n - 2( -

) =

0,06.


0,10.

0,10, ?
) (

"'
u
"
<(

) , 12 (

:s:
:

).
,
() . ,

:I:

"
"
~
(1)

Q.

,
0,10,
?

<(

-4"

...
.

\,1

, ()

"'

0,12
() .

"j

4.

0,08.

AD

4000 + 2(/);

SRAS = + 100( - ) .
( - ) / = -2( - ).
= 6000,

=
)

0,05.

,
4000 ,
. , ,

, , ",
?
)

4000 4488.

, , m

?
?

) (
-11 12.1) ?

1. ,

, ,

) ,

?
) ,

,
- . .

2.

(
) .

, ,
,
.

, ?
?

3.

,
(

)
. ,
,
-

10% .
, ,

10%

31

IU

...

31

31

, , ,

1 31
AD, SRAS, ,

30 2004 . 5%.

) ,

( ),

31
10%. ( ,
1 31 2004 . 15%.) ,

31 ,

,
.

2004 .? 2004 .

;;;'

Cll
IU

01
m
UJ

">

"'~
s
s=
>
s
s

:r

::::,
::0

s=
s

::0

( )?
.

:s;

t;

4.

:s;
:s;
<(

w
w

~. ( )
.

.
? ?

:t:

5.

<(

:.:
:s;

10 % - ,
.
(
) 10% .

f-

:s;
:;

t=

, .

"'
<(

"

;r
:s;
:

:I:

AD-AS, . ,
.

) , ,

"
"
~

(1)

. ?

<(

6.

......

':1'

) - .m

"'

18

) ,
,
.

,
(, ,
. .) .

) ,
, .

it

, ,

FRED z z -,
: research.stlouisfed.orgj fred

1.

1956 .,

) CPI (
) .
) CPI
. (

NAIRU,

web-

(Congressional Budget
Office: www.cbo.gov, ~h Budget and Economic
Outlook~.)

)
.

2.

CPI


. ,
,

, , - ,
.
,

1972 .

CPI
CPI .

,
.

( , 10- ),

(. ., ,
) ( ),
, (
) . , ,


? (:

w-
www.s.gov)

3.

1972 .,

) ;

01
w

"

)>

) ;

"'

-i

) ;
)

w- www.s.gov
,


? (:
, ,

?)

4.

1948

. ,

,
. (
, . . 8.1)
?
, ?

:s:
J::

)>

:s:
:s:
:r

::,

"':s:
"'

J::

9-12 ,
, .
.

, -
,
.

.
- ,

.
,

.
,
,

.
,

, . ,
,

.


, , ,
,

- .
, ,
, ,
,

, ,
, . ,


,
,
.

5)

8-11),

. -

, ,
1i

s
:s;

....

- -
,

:s;

:r::

:s;
<(

() () .

Q.

<(

""
....

:s;

:s;
:;

::

"'
u
""
<(

13.1.


. ,

: ~

t?'J?

: ~

:s;

?'J?

:r
~

:r::

""
""
::?:

I I

Q.

<(

'it
.

...

"'

: ,
,

-
. ( ,

, , ,
. ) - ,

- ,
.

, ,

. ,
110 ,

m (foreign exchange market),


, 110 (
). 110
$1 . ,

(nominal exchange rate)

, enom' -

. ,

= 110 .
(exchange rate), -
, , ,
, .

- .

112

110 ,
108 .

.
(
). (flexile-exchange

rate system), (floating-exchange-rate


system), ,
.
-

. ~ :
~ .


. -
JII i

(fixed-exchange-rate system),
.


. ,
, 1800- 1900- . ,

,
.
, 1920-

rr.,
rr.

1930-


- , -,

1944 . , .
-
, $35
. - 1970-

rr.,

$35 (. ~ :
...~ -
.). -

.
,
.

. , ,
- .

, ,

2002

1991

. , , ,

.
,
,

.
.

13.5.


,
. , ,


110 $1, , ,
, , - -

110

11 $1

. , ,

$1 , (
), .

J:l

st;
s:

:I:

s:
s:

<

o::t
w

Q.

<
>:

s:
s:

1-

<:;

"'<
>:

u
w
:

s:

:1:

:I:

>:
()

, ,
-. , 11
, . , $2
- 1100 ,
, , ,
. 1100 , 110 $1 ,
$10 ( $10 ,
, 1100 , 11 /$1 ). ,

($2 )/($10 ) = 0,20
.
, ( )
.
- ,
, , -

<

-4'

Q.
>:

(real exchange rates).


0,20
.

. ,
:

enom = (110 );
PFor = ,

1-

"'

( 1100

);

($2

).

, ,

),
( ).
:

= enomP/PFor =

= [(110
= 0,20

j$1)($2/ )]/

(1100 / )=

(13.1)

, ,
, ,

. ( , ,
, ;

, .) ,
(
, ), ,

. 1
,
,

, ,

5,

, ,

(, . .). ,
, , ,

1.

(, ), For
,


.
, ,

,
.

15.

IW

( )

( )

(appreciation)
n (revaluation)

(depreciation)
(devaluation)


, ' , ,
, ,

(nominal depreciation).

, ~~ .
,

enom'

(nominal appreciation) . ,
<<~. 1
~~ ~ ~
. ,
,

(devaluation).

( revaluation) .

15.

, ,

appreciation) .

(real


, , ,

, . ,

,
,

(real depreciation).


?
, , 1

. ,
$1,60 ) .

(,

. ,
.

, ,

( ) .

, (

) .
,
, (
) , , 1. = 1,

13.1,

-
Fo
w
w
<(

"'

:s:
f:s:
:;

13.2

je'

(13.2)

. (
, .) ,

, ,

"'
u
"'w

,
, (purchasing power parity, ) . ,

:s:

<(

::r

:I:

"'
"'
::

13.2,

,
, . .

()

= PFo/P.

<(

'4'

...u

Jl

nl
'3'

, (

13.1)


.
. ,
, ,

;
,


, ,

13.1, = enomP/PFor'
11eje, .

. 1

2 11l

/1PFo/PFor

+ 11PjP,

11eje =11eno"/enom + 11/- /1PFo,/PFor

/1 ,

- , 7t,
/1PF0 /PFor' ,
, 1tFor 1 , 7, , -

.
2 ,

- .
.: , 7.

&

13.1


, , ,

, ,

. ~

Economist

2003

cThe Economist 26

. ,

50 , ,
. ,
.
$1,20 $4,52
.

, ,
. ,
, ,
, ,
. , ,

, (

, ). , ,
, .

$2,71
1,40
1,44
2,17
1,20
2,89
3,08
2,18
1,33
2,14
1,31
2,63
4,52

J:l
m
:::,

(13.3)

13.3

. ,

, !J.enomleom'
, IJ.eje,

, 1tFor - .
( ): 1)
- ( ), , ,
, ,

2)

, , ,
.

"'m\!:


JS

s,.

( 13.3) ,

f-

,.
,.
:I:

<

,
.

:[

( relative purchasing power


parity) ,

w
0..
u

,.<
,."
f-

:;

, , ,
.

0::

<

"uw
,.
:

, ,

. , -

:I:

"
"<
:
<1)

0..

-4'
.

1-

1.1

:r"'

,
, ,
, .
,

(tenns of trade ) , ,

.
,

, .
, ,

,
. , ,

,

? ,
,

. ,

; ,
.

.
, , . .

. , ,
(
) . ,
, (
) . ,
- ,
,
.

,
, .

, , , .
,
. ,

, ,
.
, ,
, ,
, ,

. ,

, .
- ,

,

, ,
.

]. , ( )

, . ,
,

~ .
, , ,


.
(),

.
,
,

(,
) .
,


. , ,

OJ

-i

I
\[

( ) ,

;><

"n

( )

. ,
,

. (

,
. )

13.1

( ) .
,

.
, , ,

,
, -

'<
\[

:::,

"'m
\[

Jj

~:s:

1-

u
I
:s:
:s:

NX

<(

c:t

Q.

<(

""

:s:
:s:

...

1-

:s:
:r
s

<(

""

::r
:s:
~

""

()

]-

""
~

Q.

<(

J-

..".

, -

.......

. -

( ).

111

(
). ,

]-

(j curve),
J.

, , (
) ,
. , ,

-
(. << :
~>).


1970-

rr.

13.2
1973 .

,
-

100

140

--

1985

~~

>S 11
]

120 j!:~

~!;

al"'"

100

111 ...
>S

g.

] ::

:i -

80

60

40
20
-OOL-----~-----L----~------L-----~-----L----~~0

1973

1977

1981

1985

1989

1993

1997

2001


1973 . 2003 .

,
( )
.

1973-2003


1980- rr. . 1985 . ,
, , , ]-.
: : , ,
( 1996 . ),
- FRED, esearr;h.stlouisfed.org/fred

www.federalreserve.gov,

(,
).
,
,

1980- rr. 1980 1985 . 50%.



.
,

,
, .
1985 .
.

1987 .,

. ,

,
,

,
. , , -j-

.

1987 .

1i

:s;
f-

u
I

:s;
:s;
<(

:if

Q.

w
w
<(

"'

:s;
f:s;
;

<::

0::
<(

"'

u
w

::r

:s;
~

"'

(1)

Q.

"'
<(

:::

'<t
.11

..,...

"'

':1'

]- : -
?
,
.

? , ,
1980- rr. (

), .

,
, ,

.
, ,
, ,
.
, ,
, 1985 .
. ,
,

,
4 ~. *


1997 2001 .,

, . ,

.
, , ,
.
,
.
.

: Richard .
Baldwin. Hysteresis in lmport Prices: The Beachhead Effect 11 American Economic Review. 1988
(). . 773- 785.

13.2.

.

;
- .

? ,


( . 13.2).

.

13.1,


. ,

. -, ,
.
,
, .

. , ,

10

Wal\ Streetjournal
2003 .

11

2003

. ,


: ( ) .
. - ,

.
, 0,6114 , 10
2003 . $1 0,6114 .
- ,
. , 10 2003 .
30 117,47
. , ,
, 30- , ,

10

(90 180 ).
2003 .

. 30-

, ,
.
,
.


/
( )
(
( )
n ( )

90

180

0,6114
1,3818
1,3805
117,58

0,6126
1,3843
1,3594
117,47

0,6150
1,3893
1,3576
117,25

0,6164
1,3961
1,3550
116,92

,
1q1pcy. ,

' , .
, ,
m.

,
.

13.3 .
,
- , ,
, , S,

,S

~
:s:
tJ:I:

:s:
:s:
<(

<::[

0..

<(

"'

:s:
1:s:
:;

.::

"'
"'
<(

0..

<(

'4'

.
.

."
:

:I:

"'"'
"'
::

:s:


.
,

S,

, ,

D, ,
. , 1

, ";
.

~~ ( ).

- .
,

;
. ,

D,

. , , ,

. 1 '
, .

13.3

. , ,
,

. , - ,
- . ,
:

1)
2)

( )
(
) .

, ,

( ), -



:


. 1


,

:
1)
(
)
2)


) .
,




,


,

.


,



,



,
,






.

13.4

, D 1 D 2
,

1 2



. 2


IS-LM

:
(), ,
,

r.
IS- LM
,

. 13.3,
,


(
)


. ,



,
,
,



,
.

). ,
(

, ,

), , ,

(
)

.



?


,
.
,

, ,
1




5.


,
, -


. ,



,


,


, -

.


1r


.
,
2


n



,


,
.

2.
]j

,S

~:s:

:::::~:::::::::

tJ:r

:s:
:s:
<(

c:t

0..

1.

__ _

1
, D

<(

""

:s:
f:s:

<:;

"'
<(

""

:s:

::

:r

""
""
::
()

0..

<(

....11

1.1

"'

13. 4

1
D 2,

)
(

2
e\om e nom


.
,
, 1Ui .
,

)


(
,
()


, ,

.
, . .


, YFor'

. YFor
)

,
(






, ,
.


. ,
.


.

,



,
.

(

, r, ,

,
,
5, ,
,

.

,


. .:

,
.

N2 4

)
. 1



,

,

.



,

.
,



.

, r,


.
r
,

,
.

,
r
.



, rFor'


. ,




.
,

,


.


.
, rFor'
,

16

17

13 .3. IS -L M



.
,

IS-LM,

13.
IS-L M
AD-AS,


,

,
IS-LM
: IS,

;
LM,

,
FE,
', , n
n
,
(

5),

n
.

,
n
,

.
,


. ,

n

,

n
n
n n

.

,
n

.

(
,
16.
)

:i5

:s:

:s:
:s:

n
() ,

tJI

..:
q

n (),

Q.

YF<x

..:

"'

n,

:s:

:s:

"'..:

:r
:s:

"'
..:
"'
~
/\



n,

n

,
n

n

n, F<

"'u


n n

:;


n
n
n n


n

17.

Q.

.Jj

n
() ,

1.1

n (),

-4'

...

111
:

YF<x


n
n

n
n





n, F<



n
n

,
IS-L M
, ,


LM,


.

,

FE



,
.
IS,
,
IS


,
:
,

1. IS

IS
,
-

).

(,



,
.

,

1 ,

FE

,
IS .

2.
3.

, IS ,
IS .
, ,

IS.


, ,

; ,
, IS .

IS

IS-LM
,

IS I
IS

, .
,

, S<i,
, Jd, S<i - Jd = . , 5,

S<i, , Jd, , NX.


, :

(13.4)
13.4, ,

S<i- Jd,

, - ,
. ,

NX (,
,

) ,

. ,
13.4
, , ,

.

(13.5)

S<i,

13.5

13.4

, - ()1 - G,

. 13.5 ,

, , ,
,

()1 + Jd + G + NX. ,

13.5
.

, S<i - Jd, , NX. ,

,
.
,
r.

;;;'
111
111

111

.....

:z;


, S -/

:s:

t;
I

:s:
:s:
q<

0..

NX

<

":s:r-

:s:

t:;

"'<
"u

:s:

s<J_ fl,

, NX


Sd Jd.

13.5

"
"<
::

0..

-4'
.

......

",
':

NX .
,

, .

(, ,

).

, ,

r 1.

S- !,

r. , ,
,

,
.

NX,

13.5

. . 13.2,
, ,
, (. . 17). NX
.
,
( 13.4 ).
S - 1 NX .

, ,
, - , r1.

IS , ,


(. 13.6). ,

r 1

2
, -

1
1
1
1

----------~-------1
1
1
1
1
1
1

IS

~------~-----L-----

y1

, tfl - 1d1
,

NX

6)

/S

) ) n .

) n ,,

13.6

IS

r,.

n 1 2 -

n
n n .

, S- I n, n (S- /) 1 n (S- /) 2 .
n n n n,
n
,

NX

NX1

NX2.

n r2
) n , n
2

r1 r 2,

F,

IS

tJ]
)>

::0
3

,
. , ,

, ,

(S- !) 1 (S- !) 2 . 13.6, .

NX?
, (
) (. . 17).
, 1 2 ,
NX , N)(1 NX.2.
1
2

F . 13.6, r2
IS . 13.6, , , "

r"


,
2
r 2 .
, ,

IS

:t
!1:
m

"''<
n

"!1:

1:1
m

::0

"'m!1:

:s:

, l'S

f-

, ,

:s:
:s:

<(

u
:r

q:
w

..

u
w
w

<(

""

:s:
f:s:
:;

::

"'
u
""w
<(

:s:
~

:r

""
""
::

..

. .

13.7,

1 , ,

r 1.

. S- 1 (S- [) 1
(S - [) 2 , . 13.7, .

13.7,

F,

r 2
IS.

r1 r2
!5 1 IS2.

IS ,

(!)

IS

IS

IS

, -

<(

"/~'
..

...u

"'

:r

"' ..

"'111 ...

.11 ...

.11 ...

111

111

:r

:f

"'CI.

"'CI.

"':
~

"':

11
111
.

;>.u=

>.u...

Cl.l-

111

111

~;

~;

111

r2

r2
t

, ffl - fl,
,

NX

/S

) )
, "

r1

rocy



. S - I -

13.7

IS

(S- !) 1 (S - !)2
) 1 F )
) r 2 , IS
, /51 IS2.

. ,
,

/S

S- 1

(.

13.7,

),

, /S
, /S
. , , ,

,
. 13.8.

/S .

13.8,

, r .
1
1
, -


.
13.8, , NX 1 N)(l.

NX

, F,

r2
, /S
, /5 1 /S2, . 13.8, .

?

=~':.
:z: 11

:z:

'-

t... :z:

~UCII
:1

:z:ca[
ID~C

111
:z:
:z:

.. 11

... Cll

~~:1

:&.
ID~C

Cll

r2
r2

r,

/52

, !!f1_ fl,
,

NX

/S

]::1

::::,

"'

!l

) ) r
m "

r 1.

) -

13.8

IS

NX1

NX
NX'.

, -

6) 1 )
6) r 1 r 2 F. , IS ,

IS 1

iS2.

;;::.

:s:

"'::::,
!Z:

:
JS

~
s:

t;

:r
s:
s:

,
(. . 17).

<

c:t
w
.

<

"'s:f

<

"'::rw

s:

"'
<
"'
:
(\

...

.11

IS

,
,
IS .
, , ,

, (
); . 1 .
, IS ,

:r

r,o"

:;

t:

IS .


,

,
.
,

s:

!>;

, ,0 ,,

18.

18.

IS

I.J

ra

':

, YF<x

,

/S

fF<x

,

. ,


.
,
, ,

IS-LM

,
IS. IS

(., , . 11 .7).

,

(AD) ,

(SRAS) .

,
.


.
,

, ,

IS

().

13.4.

tt
&

IS-LM ,
,
- - .

, ,

.
:

1)

2)

IS-LM ,


, :

1.

IS-LM ,

2.

9- 11.
13.2 ( , . . 16 17)

,
.

3.

IS-LM


.
, ,

IS.


,

.

IS-LM (
), ,
.

13.9

IS-LM,

) -

, . ,

:;;

"'tJ
"'
"'q

<(

13.9, . ,
IS ,

IS 1 IS2.
FE , FE 1 FF. ,

; ,

0..

<(

"'"'
"'

f-

::

:;

:;

"'

..

~
.

J,
t

111

"'

>.~

...:z: ...

a:CL
:
:z:ca
:z: ..

<(

F,

:z:

1111

"'"'
"'
:

0..

<(

..

~~

... :il!:z:

:~

:z:CL
:z:

CL ..
... 111
u
...
:z: u

:s::

, YFor

IS-LM

IS ,

FE'

!51 !52.

FE

FP.

13.9

.
, -

.
.

) ,
,

IS , !5 1F !52m
, LM L' Fo'
LAfl Fo,. F,
n ,
.

F.

!5'2 FW. ,
LM , Lt L2,

F. F ,

, , ,

r,

.
( 10). , -
, -

.
, ,

. , , ,

. ,
.

,

.
: ,

-
.

. , (
)
(

) . ,

.

( )

5.

. ,
,
,

IS-LM

13.9,

1:>

.
IS /5 1For
For

15'2

m
:::,

"'m2:

IS -LM IS

;:::.

:::,

LM

LWFor L2For). F,
, .
, ,

IS .
,

IS

IS LM

13.9, .

:s:

"'2:

:0

~s:
tJ:I:
s:
s:
<{

, F.
. 1
,

, .

; ,

, , .

w
w

.
.

w
..
u

<{

"'s:f-

, .

s:

:;

<{

::

IS-LM ,
-
. IS-LM

"'w

s:
:I:

"'
"'
~
(1)

..

<{

'4'
.

1-

-:r"'

.
( )
, .

.
. 13.10,
IS-LM .
,
LM , LM1 Ll

13.10, .

IS Ll.

F,

F ,

,
.
.


, . -,
,

. -,


,
.

?
1) ,

,
, 2)
, ,
. ,

.
1 ,
,

, ,

(jeedback effects)

:
-
-
t

- , ,

n,

:
-
-

:
-

IS~or

, YFor

LM ,

LI LJ.

IS
LJ.

13.10

.
. t
; ,
,

, ,
.

6)

, 1'0
IS , !5 1For IS' For

F.

}- ,

.
, ,
,
, .
:
- ?


. 13.10, 6.
, ,


. , IS ,

;;;'
111

111

111

....w

::ll

~:s;
IJ:I:

IS 1For IS'lFor F,
IS'l For LMFor ,
.

:s;

. ,

:s;

<(

<:[

"-

<(

"'f-

:s;

:s;
;

:;

<(

"':r

, .

,
,

. 01

.:. , .
.

:s;

, ,

:I:

, .

"""'

LM

13.10,

LM

"'
~

-t

"-

<(

...
.

\,/

"'

IS

IS\0 ,

13.10, 6

( )
. ,
,

. , ,
.

,
. -

; .
(
) .

,
. ( ,

.) ,

10%
10%. , 13.1 ,
, enom' ePFo/ P, -
, For - , - .
, , , PFor'

10%

() 10%. ,

, .

13.5.

1970-

rr.

. ,

,
.
:

1)

2)

,
1
.

, , ,

,
. 13.11 ,

, enom' ,

s
;;'
111

1111

111

....

-------------------

,

, ""'", ,

13.11

:1:>
m
::,

"'m

!!:

, ''

.<=

::,

, -

!!:

.
,

.
.
1

, .
, .

:s:

"'

(fundamental value of the exchange rate), e1nom' ,


1i

t:;

s
s
<(

q
w

Q.

w
<(

><

s
1s
:;

::

"'
<(

><
u
w
J

><

(!\

Q.

><

<(

-4'
.

IJ

"'

:r


.
, ( overvalued exchange rate)
( ).

,
?

. -,
,
. , ,
. 13.11, ()

1 ,

, ,

.
-,

,
.
,
.


; ,
,
(inconvertile currency).
,
.

-,
- ,
,

. , , .

13.11,

( )

( )
. ,

,
. ( 5),
- ,
,
( ,
,

, ()). ,


. . 13.11
, ,
,

. ,

name'Itoo
. , ,
,

r
,
, ,
. ,

.


, ,
.


-
. (speculative run),
(speculative attack), ,

,
,
,

, ,

. ,

, .

, ,

( .

13.12),


. ,

,

. ,

1994 .

111

ID

111

...w
n
n

D
n nw


Sl,


-

13.12

.
,
, (

) .

,
, S1 SJ.
n .


, .

s
fu
I
s
s
<

r:::t

0..

(. <1:
:

1994 ~). -
1997-1 998 rr., <1: :

~.

( )

,
. ,

<

, -

1<

s
fs

r:;

"'<

1<

::r
s
~

1<

()

0..

1<

<

::

.q

...v
.

"'

, .
,
-
.

, .
. 13.13, (undervalued exchange rate) (

) ,
, ,

.

.
( , ),
, ,
, .

, , ,


.
>:S

:1 ~

:; Q)

:au::CI.

:s~

:l,:s;

:1

i!=

!2
:;
~

e~om

------------------

enom 1---------i:J---'C~-----

,
, ...,,
,
,

13.13

t1 , e' m

,
r , .


1960- 1990- . .
.
1997 .,
.

, , : , ,
10 ,

2 1997 . .

,
, . (

~~

(contagion).)

.
,
.

, ,
.

,
, '
, .
,

.
,
.

? ,
,

, .
, ,
~ ~,


, .

, ,
, ,

.
, - : ~!~
, , .

, ,
,
.
.

1990- rr.
, ,
.

,
. ,

, -

- , ~
(~ , ~crony capitalism ).

. ,
,

15

~s

l:j
:I:

s
s
<
:[

.
1999 r.

0..

. .
-,
,

<

""s
s
f-

:;

:
;

<

""w

. -,

,
, ~ . 1

:I:

"'""

0..

""

<

:
~
.

11.1

"'

'j

,

,

. ?
, - .
,
,

13.1,

(13.6)

13.6

, ,

PFor' , enom'

, , , .

-
,

-
.

13.6

;
,
.
, , , , , ,

13.6 ,
() , .

, , -

: Paul
Krugman. The Return of Depression Economics // New York: W. W . Norton & . , 1999;
Giancarlo Corsetti, Paolo Pesenti, Nouriel Roublni. What Caused the Asian Currency and
Financial Crisis? j / ] and the World Economy. 1999. . 305- 373.
1

,
,

. 1 ,

.

13.14

. 2

.
,


. .

13.14
-

. 1

. !'
(
}, 1 ,

13.14 ,


, . ,
, -

13.14

:::,

""m2:

..

..

. 1 .

( ) -

: ,
.

:t:o
m

.t:

:s

s
2:

. ,

:z;

~:s:

ti
:

:s:
:s:
<(

. 13.14,
, ,
(, ,
) .

Q.

w
<(

"'...:s:

-
, ,

:s:

. , ,

:;

0:

"'uw

<(

:s:
~

"'
"'
~
(\

Q.

<(

-4'
.

1-

10

-:r

1 2 . 13.15,
( _FV1,
1
, ).
,
.

, ,
.
,
() ,


13.15. -

, .

1.

f".l

FV1

n
,

FJ!I,

,
, 1

13.15

, 2


ti
. , ,
,

F1f1

FV2.

2 .

. 13.15 , FV1 FV2.


1 2

, (

FV2

). ,

,
, .
, ,

, , ,

,
- .
,

,
.

:
-

- , (
). 1 ,
, ,


. ,

$35

. ,

, ~. , -
.
(1959-1971 rr.) 2
.
-

.
-

)>

::::,

-i

I
\[

"''<

."

- , ,

\[

,
1960- rr. ,

J:>
m
::::,

&:

. ( 1960- .

"'::::,

~ .)
,

.
1
rr- . : Michael D. Bordo, Barry Eichengreen. Retrospective on the Bretton Woods System. Chicago: University of Chicago Press for
NBER, 1993.
2
1959 r. , , .

tD
\[

:s:
\[

. ,

.

.
, , ,
<(

"":s:
f-

, -

. ,

:s:

- , ,

, .

,

:;

0::
<(

""

, .

:s:

:I:

""

, .

Q.

""

<(

-.t
.

11.1

::r"'

1971

.
-

(),
.


. 1992 .,
, ,
.

-
.

.

1992 .


. .

1992

. ,

1993

- ,
, ;

, ,
.

.


?
, -
- .

,
,

. ,
?

. -, ,

, (

)
.

. -,

~ - ,

.
- ,

. 1
,

. ,

-
.

, .
,

o:J

- . ,

::.

:r:

)>

-i

2::

, ,

;><;

'<
"

2::

::.

"'m2::

(currency union) ,

.
.

, ,

.

1 , r , ,
.

,
. ,
.

-
:s:
<:

::[

, .
,
. -

0..

, . -,

,
.

.
- . ,

, ,
-
. ,
-
.


1991 . , , -
() ,
.

1993 .,

( )

- .
, ,
(
), ,
. 1 1999 .
,
, ,
. 1
-
(),
, , .
,

-,

11
-.
, ,
-
.

,
.

,
1

10

2004

2001

;
; .


,
, .
, -

,
.
,
-.

: - ,
, ,
, ,

1999 . 1

. , ,
, ~ ~. . .
.

(,
) . , 1 2002 .,

,
.
, ~ ,

. ,

11


.
:

1 = 40,3399 ;
= 6,5596 ;
= 1,95583 ;
= 1936,27 ;
= 166,386 .

, -
, ,
. ( , ~
~ - , ~ ~ , ; . 7.)
.

1 1999 .
; ,
6,5596 , 1,95583
, 1 6,5596/ 1,95583 = 3,354
. -,
,


, , 1
. : Carol . Bertaut, Murat F.
Iyigun. The Launch of the Euro 11 Federal Reserve Bulletin. 1999 (). . 655- 666.

-i

::t

1!:
m

"'"<

"n1!:
];:,

::,

CD

1!:
m

.r::

:s:

"'

::,

1!:

1S

~
tJ:I:

s:

s:
s:

.
,
. , , 0,90 .
, $1,
:
=
= 6,5596 0,90 = 5,9036.

<

:{

..

u
w
w

<

""

s:
fs:
<::;

"'
""w

<
u

s:
~

:I:

""
<
""
:

1999 .,
1 = $1,16 (). ,
(. . 13.16).
1 2002 .
1 = $0,89, . .
.

(
!);
, ,
~~ .

()

..

-4'
.11

...
~

"'

':1'

,
. ,
.
,

, .
,
, -

1118. 1,20
1,15
:1
=
~

1,10

1,05
1,00
0,95
0,90
0,85
0,80
1999

2000

2001

2002

2003

1999
2003 . 1999 . 1 $1 ,16,
2000 .
, 2002 .
$0,85 $0,90 .

2002 . ,
2003 . $1, 17 .

13.16

1999-2003 rr.

(
).


,



2000 .,

-
. 1
,

, ,
- ,
. ,
-

-



( . 7.2
?~).


,
,
,
,
. ,
1997 .
.

,
1999 .
.
,

,

.

,
, ,


.
,

;

. ,

.

,
, .

13.16.


2002 .

. ,

,

, .
2002 .,
. 13.16,
- .



2002 .

,
1
.: Hans-W erner Sinn, Frank Westerm ann. Why
Has the Euro Been Falling? An Investigation
into the Determi nations of the Exchange Rate 11 National Bureau
of Economic Research working
paper 8352. 2001 ().



,
:

s
s:
1u
I
s:
s:

<(

Q.

?
.

. 1970-
,


1980- .

1990 .

1975 .! 1980- .
10

,
.

<(

""

s:
s:

1:;

1983 .

~
,

10 000 .
( ~peso Argentino ),

.,
1985

,

,

(austral),

1000

"'
""
<(

s:

""

(!)

Q.

""
<(

::

-<t
.11
1-

"'

1991

1991 .
; ,


1991 .

.
10 000 .

,

,

, ,

.

,

,
.

.
1991

Law),
iility
(Convert


y board )-
. ( currenc

,
,

.
,


.
,

, ,
,

1991


$1


. (
.)
,

,

,
,

.
~ ,

,
,
1991 ., .
,
.
1990- .
-
,
1999 . ,
1995 .
1990-

rr.

: 5,8% 1990
1998 .,
,
,
1975
1990 .,
0,2% . 1990- rr.
1991 .
.
1990- rr.
,
1999 . 3,4%,

. ,
.
,
,
,

.

,
,
.
,
,

, .
r
, 1 2001 . corralito ()
,
$1000 .

,
.



,

, .
1999 .
40%

. 40%-


.
1990- .

,

.


,

,
.

,
.
,


.
,

$155 ,
. ,
2002 .,

.
10 2002 .
29% , $1 0,71 .
1
,
0,49 .
-

.r:::
s

,..

::,

!!:

,
,

,
.

,
. 2002 .

2003 ., 0,36 ,

<
~
s

1-

:;

D:

<
~

1.

.
,

::

:I:

/\

() .

<

::

-

,

. -

2.

:

, , ,

'4'
.11

...u

;:

"'

,
.

3.

,

,

4.

}-.

()
.

, ,
.

5.

; ,

, .

6.

/S-LM

. ,

/S-LM

(
) ,

/S . ,

, ,

7.

/S

-
,
, .

.
, ,

, .
,
.
.

8.

.


,

. ,
( ) ,
(
) .
.

9.


.
,
,

, ,

.

(, ),
. ,
,


. ,

( -

) .
,

:s;

13
:

10.

:s;
:s;

,
- .
,

<

:s:

\.

w
w

<

"'f-

:s;

:s;

:;

"'<

, .

"'w

:s;
~

11.

.
,

"'m
"'<
::

\.

Jl

..,
~


- .

"'

'j

()


]-


(13.1)
, , ,

( ,
),
, For:

(13.3)

l'!..enorrlenom'

, l'!..eje,
, 1tFor - 1t:

Sd - Jd =NX.
(

(13.4)
IS) ,


. 13.4 ,

, , , (J1 + Jd + G + NX,

13.5.


1.
2.

.
?
.
,

, ?

3. , .
? .

4.

j- ?
]-?

5.


?
?

? .

6.

?

? ,
, ,
.

7.

IS-LM IS-LM
?
IS-LM ,
.

8.

-
? -
?
?

9.

10.

? .
coU.lltoc ? ,
, ?

? ?

11.


? ,

;;;'
111

111

111

...w

-
.

:i!

s
s

tJ
:.::

12.


, .

s
s

<
:[
w
.

<
~
s
ts


1. West Buble ,
5 . East Buble ~.
100 .

:;

West

East Buble

~ .

"'<

:r
s

West / 10%-
, East Buble 20%.
-
~.

:1:

:.::

? ?

<

-4'
.

...v

2.

"'

'3'

,
.
40

64

1 .

? (:
,
.

.)

) 3 .

,

,
42 , 60
.
?

)
4 3
45 ,
. ?

54
)

3.

() () ]-.

300 + 0,5 - 200r.


Jd = 200 - 300r.
G= 100.
NX = 150- 0,1 - O,Se.
()1 =

20 + 600r.
=900.

, , ?
) ,
940.
, , ,
?
) ,
940, 132.

,
, , ?

4.

'=

200 + 0,6( - 1) - 200r.


Jd = 300 - 300r.

20 + 0,2.
G= 152.
NX = 150 - 0,08 - 500r.
L = 0,5 - 200r.

=924.

= 1000.

) , ,
, ,
(. . )?
)
62 , 214.
, , ,
, ?
?
)

152, 62

, NX = 212- 0 , 08 - 500r.

, , , ,
?

? ().

5.

AD

AS

400 + 50MjP;

1000.

, - .
, ,
. , , 5

1 .

48

20 ,

?
() ?

;;;'
111
111
111

....

) ,
:z;

50 . ,

!;;

1-

s
1u
:1:
s
s

,
50 ?
) , ,

<(

q
w

Q.

50 .
? (:

w
w

<(

"s

1-

s
.:::

?)

"'
"uw

6.

<(

( 1)
) ,

4,

1.1, 1.2 1. . 1.8

::r
s

1.9

:1:

".,.,
"
~
Q.

LM

IS

, ,

<(

'4"

AD

. ,

62

..,...
Jl

"'

":1'

AD?

)
, ,

, ().
(: ,

SRAS

.)


1.

. , ,
, ,

.
)

IS-LM,

, ,
, ,
.


, ,
? ,
, ,

?
)

, .

,
, , .

2.

IS-LM ,

, 1980- .

.
,
-


. ,

? ?

3.

East / West /.
, West
.

) -
West Buble East Buble
,

East

/ ? ?
.

) West /
u1t East /
?

) , East /
West /. East
1 , East
- West
/? ,
East / ,

? () .
)

West
East /

(
). ?
.

4.

, . 13.6,
,

100

. , ,

.

) ,
,
(
).

? (,: ,

? ,
?)

) ,

100

. -

, .

2!

~:s:

) : ,
:
() ()? ,

t:i
:1:

:s:
:s:
<

5
? .

c:t
w
Q.
u
w
w

<
:s:
:s:

"'

1-

it

<:;

::

<>:

<

"'w

u
7

:s:

'

, ,
1t - FRED : research.stlouisfed.org/

fred
1.

:1:

-
1970- .

"'

()

Q.

"'<
~

'4'

( )

1-

",

. (

1973

. .

':r

1973 . ,

www.statcan.ca/

, ,

start.html)

-
?
) , ,

,
( ).
(

) ,

. (,
, .)

2.

1973

.,

1)

, .

, .

3.

1981

. .

1983

1981 1983 .?
.?

1983 .

1

15-LM


IS-LM IS-LM
, 9, ,
( JS)
. LM FE
.

IS ,
, , 9.8 9.1 0:

()1 = 0 +[ - (t0

+ tY)]-

(13.1)
(13.2)

13..1 ,

, - ,
, r. ( 13.1
9.9 , .) 13.2

,
, r. ,
, i
0
0
.


. ,

:
(13.)

0 , ' xr xrF- . 13.,


, (
)
, YFor (

).
,

r (
,
) , rFor (

). , ,

,
0 13..
,

13.5,

(13.4)


:;;

~
s
tJ:I:
s

s
<(

, Sd = Jd

+ NX,

, 13.1,
, 13.2, , 13.,

, 13.4,

<:!

= +

(13A.S)

, ,

<(

""'sf-

Cy[Y-(to + tY)]- cr+ io- if+ G +


+ XrFFor"

- - XyFYFor - Xf

[1 - (1 - t)c y+ ] = 0 + i 0 + G - cyt0 + 0 +
+ XypYfor + xrFFor - ( + ir + xr)r.

"'
<(

u
""'

(13..6)

13.6 , , ,

r,

IS

:I:

""'(!)

13..6 ,

""'
<(

'

IS

:
(13.7)

= '

15 -

15

~' 15 - ,

~' 15 ,

r ,

(13.8)

(13.9)

, . . 0 = = = = xrF
15 ~' 15 IS ,
15 ~ 15 (. 13.8 13. 9 9.15 9.16).
'

IS

13.7, ,
. -, (

- ~' 15 ). -, ,

IS

IS

IS (

, 15'

' 15 ). ,

, ,

IS . YFor rFor
, ,

, ' 15

IS .

IS-LM

, , ,
( 9.14)

IS

IS

( 13. 7) .

AD-AS

( 9 . ), , 15
~s , (9.24),

, ' 15 ~' 15 .

, , ,

r, , ,
IS-LM AD-AS ,

:
(1.10)
, ' ,

e,F

= ePFojP.

(1.11)

1.10, , YFor'

r, -

- , . ,

, ,
, rFor'-
- . 1.11,

enom'

(13.6),

, ,

, ,

, For .
1.1 0 1.11,
-
.
, , ,

r,

, .
1.10 1.11

, YFor'

, rFor'-
, , , enom (
). ,

. ,

1.10 , , ,
.
, .

1.11 , , '

;"
111
1111

111

...

o:;J
)>

::,

-i

!Z:

"''<

."
()

!Z:

J::>
m
::,

"'m

!Z:
.

:s:

s!Z:

14

,
) -
- (


. (

,
15.)

,
,



-

,


.

, ,
.

(

), ,


,
,

-
.

,

.
,


, ,
( ).

)


,


.

? ,
-

10 11 ),

,

,
.


,

-

-
,
,

,


,

.
,

:s:

tJ
:I:

:s:
:s:

<

:[

0..

.
~>>
~~



-

.

,


,

,

-
.
,

q

q




?

<

"':s:
:s:

14 .1.

f-

t:;

"'<
"'u

:s:

:I:

"'"'

0..

"'<

~
~

.11

?

,
( )
, ,

,

:
,
.
1.
(central ban
k) -
,

-
.'

"'

t!l

':1'

2.

,

.

( depository institutions) -


(, -

),

,

.

3.



(
),


, -
,


.

,
.



.
,

, ,
.
1

XIX
.



,


,
. , ,

, ,

( 7).
,

,
-,
,




,

.

(
. ) ,

.

,

, .

,


?
,

,

,
,


,
.
,
,
,

. ,
,


:
,

,


,
,

,


rut
. .

(legal tender),

,



1
1
.

:

1000000 .

1000000.

,
, ,
,

.


,
.



,

.

,

,
(mo neta ry base
), ,
,
(hig h-po were d mon ey).
,

1 .
,


.




. -

]:::>

."

~
<

I
)>

:0

r,

,
r
.

(
,
1 ., ,
-
,

).

.

. (.
.

:ij

"'t;
:I:

"'
"'<c:r

w
Q.

"'s:

1-

<:;

"'
""w

<
u

:r

"'

:I:

""


.
.


, ,

r
.
,
,

( 1 .) ,

:

()

Q.

""

<

::

-4'

...1.1
.

"'

1000000 .

1000000 .

1 .


.

.

.



,

ves) .
reser
k
(ban

,

,


.

, ,


,

. ,


1 .
ing),
bank
(100% rese rve
100%-

-
100%

.
100%
.

,
,
-
100%

,
).
( . .

,
,
.



,
- ,

.

,

,
.


, , 20%

. 80% .
, !
,
.
(reserve-de posit ratio }, , 20%.
,

, 1,
(fractional reserve baking) .
,
, , ,
,

.


20%

80% (800 000 .) .

.
800 000 . ,
,
800 000 . ,

()

1000000 .

D .

1800000 .

1800000 .

1800000 .

800 000 . (
,

). 1

: 200 000 ., , 800 000 .,


.
1 800 000 . :
1 . 800 000 .
.
, , ,
( )
1 000 000 . 1 800 00 . m ,

20% , 1

. 360 000
.,
0,2 1 800 000 . 640 000 ., 1 000 000 - 360 000 .,

, .
,

, 640 000 .

. ,

.
:

II

()

1000000 .
1440000 .
2440000 .

2440000 .

2440000 .

]::J
m
:I:

;.;
:I:

"'m
"

I:>

s:

-i

:I:

>
:0
::;,

::.
s:
-i
s:

"'>

s:

1 . (360 000 .
640 000 . ) 1440 000 .
(800 000 . 640 000 .
). 2 440 000 . (1 800 000 .

640 000

. ).

.
, ,
(1 .) 20% , 0,2

2 440 000 .

(multiple expansion of loans and deposits) ,


,

,
.

20%

. (

) ,
, 1 ./0,20,
5 .
:

~m~

rn ()

1000000 .
4000000 .
5000000 .

5000000 .

5000000 .

(20%) .

, ,
? ,

, ,
, .

. .
,
1
. ,

,

. , 5 .,
.

= ;

BASE = ;
DEP = ;
1 7, 1
. ,
,
.

RES = ;
res =

= RESj DEP.

M = DEP.

(14.1)

, DEP, ,
, res DEP.
,

( ) .

res

14.2

DEP = BASE.

DEP = BASEj res.

(14.2)
DEP = BASEj res.

(14.3)

,

, .
1 . , , ,
0,20. , 1 ./0,20, 5 . ,
.

, , .
1/ res ,

, .

, .


,
, ,

.

( r 20%
),
.
,
,

. , ~

, .

, ,

.
,
(bank run) .
,
. 1

1::1
m

::I:

;.;
::I:

'

."

1::1

::I:
)>

"

:::J

:::,

)>

1::1
m

."
)>

:::,
!

::I:
)>

1
, , -
- .
( lt's Wonderful Life ).

"

:
~.

&


-

<
~

:s;

t-

:s;
t:;

"'

<
~

( r)
( ).

, .

, , ,

DEP,

, , :

(14.4)

=+D.

:s;

:r:

(!)

. ,

"~

<

::

BASE =

'4'

..
.

/11

':/'

(14.5)

RES.

,
.
, , 14.4, ,

14.5:

Mj BASE =

(+

DEP)(RES +

(14.6)

).

14.6

DEP
Mj BASE=

[(CjDEP)

1] / [(CjDEP)

+ (RESj DEP)] .

(14.7)

14.7 .
- ( -)
(currency-deposit ratio) (CjDEP, ),

.
, ,

, .

) ; , ,
-.

14.7

.
,
. 1

(RESj DEP, res),


, , -

1 ,

, , ,

, res. CU/ DEP res RES/ DEP


14.7 14.7 BASE,
= {(+ 1)/(

+ res))

BASE.

(14.8)

, .

, , ,

14.8

. (+ 1)/( + res),
, ,
(money multiplier).

1 , res 1 (. .
) . , ,
(= 0), 1/ res,

, r ,

( 14.3).
14.1 ,
, ,

. ,

1,0374,
0,1092. (+ 1)/( + res) 1,78.
,
($1274,0 ) ($717,0 ),
1,78.

14.1.

$648,7
$68,3
$717,0
$625,3
$1274,0
0,1092
1,0374
1,78
1.78

RES
, BASE (= + RES)
, DEP
, (= + DEP)
, res (= RESIDEP)
, (= CUIDEP)
, (+ 1)/( + rs)
,

MIBASE

: Federal Reserve Statistical Releases .3 and . , August 21, 2003.

,
1 .
2003 r.
. :

www.federalreserve.govj releases

]:::J
m
:r
m

:w;
:r

"'..,

:s:
-1
:r

>

:10

, ,

::::J

::,

, ,
1
,

:s:
-1
:s:
>
:s:

, . ,

1::.

res. , ,
( ) , ,
,

"

..,

>
::,
1

, , , ,

, .

, ,

res

1,

:r

>

:10

:s

~
:s
:s
:I:

<(

~
.

w
<(

,
,

, .

;
. ,

, ,
. ,
, .

"

:s
1:s
~

"'u
<(

"w

:s
~

:I:

"
"
:
/\

<(

-4'
.

1-

"'

"3'


,
. ,

. . 14.2 ,
.
:

.
14.8 ,
.

,
10%, 1 1100 000 . ? -,
100 000 .

100 000

) .
r :

1100000 .

1100000 .

100 000 .,
100 000 ().
, ,
1 100 000 . ,
10%.
,
10%. ,
100 000 . 100 000 . 1 .,
, . (
;

,
. )
:

900000 .

900000 .

r ( )

900 000

( 7),

( open-m arket purchase 1
).


.


(open-market sale).
.

.


.




,
m .
1930- 1933 rr.
,

- .



. 2 ,

,
.



. ,

, : 1)


1930 . ; 2)
- - Bank of United States
- 1930 . (
, ) ; 3)
1931 .
,

, 4)
1931 .

1933 .
,
~
, 1933 .
.


.
,
~
,


1933 .

( . 14.1). -,

, ,

. (
,

,
.)
, -

]:::1
m

:I:

::.;
:I:

'

"'

."

1::>
:s;

-<

:I:

:1>

:
:J

=>
:s;
-<
:s;

"':1>
:s;

m
1::>
m

."

:1>

1
m ,

,

Milton Friedman, Anna Schwartz. Monetar y istory of the United


States, 1867- 1960.
Princeton, N. ].: Princeton University Press for NBER, 1963.

=>

:I:

:1>

jj

~:s:
t:;

:I:

:s:
:s:
<{

:;!
0..

u
w
w
<{

"'

:s:
t:s:

s s
z z

0,26
0,24

=
=
8.8.
s s

0,22

OQ.

0,20

~!.

0,18

111111

z.

l'l

:l

~Q.

~~

0,16

0,14
0,12
0,10

0,08

<:

0,06

"'
<{

"'

0,04

';

:s:

1933 .

0,02

0,00
1928

:I:

"'

1929

1930

1931

1932

1933

1934

1936

1935

0..

"'

<{

-4'

...
.

\J

1'0
':r

n n

n .

n.

: Milton Friedman, Anna Schwartz. Monetary


History ofthe United States, 1867- 1960. -
- 1 , (1); , ( ) - - 1, (4);

- - 2,

(3).

,
,

,
.
,

14.1,

1933 .

-,

.
,

14.1.

,
,

.

,


. 14.2, ,

3,6

.
1930

6,6
20%,
1933 .


. 14.2, .

,
(
rr.
33
1930-19


,
, ),

35%,

)
(
.

) R

-.

r::to

C.t-

12
.. =
s 11

!!.2

=~
~~

=~

As

Ql]

r::[

Ql

r::[

1933 .

10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3

1928 1929 1930 1931 1932 1933 1934

1935

1936

) R

r::[

l':le,

~i
::Etlt
110

50

1933 .

1':1

Ql

Ql

40

r::[

30

~--~--~~~~--~~~

----~~

1928 1929 1930 1931 1932 1933 1934

1935

1936

14.2

,
, -

: Milton Friedman , Anna Schwartz. Monety


History ofthe United States, 1867- 1960.
- -1, (1); ,
( )
- 1, ( 4); -
- 2, (3); - + ;
r - (+ )/
; - + .

;.;:

::t

m
::t

"'
J::o
"'
'

-i
::t

14.2 .

,

,


.
-

.

)>

::0

:::J

:::.

"'
"'"'
-i

)>

"'

m
J::o
m
'

)>

:::.
<

::t



,
.

)>

::0


]\

:s;

tiI

:s;
:s;
(

0..

w
(

"'

:s;
1:s;

r::;

"'u
(

"'w
::

:s;
:

"'
"'
~

0..

-4'

...Jl

\J

:r"'

1913 1914 .

,

(

, ),

1930-193 3

.,

.
12


,
.
,
. 14.3.

, ,


, ,

.
1980
,
. ,
1980

,
).

(,

*-

1 -

14.3



(Board of Govemo rs of the Federal Reserve
System) ,
, , .

14 ,

4 .


(


)

-

() (Federa

Committee, FOMC).

l Open Market

,
. 1

,

- .

(
) , ,

.

-


,
.

(
)
20 2003 . . 14.2.


,
. ,
10%
.

(
),

. ~

, ,
,
.

14.2.

$0,3
$693,0
$48,6
$752,9

"'
m
:r;:,
-

$11 ,0

:J:

'

m
:J:
m

;.;

, $

]:::1

$694,7
$43,5
$651 ,2

:s:

--i

:J:
)>

::t

n
n n

=n n + =
$65,5
= + =
$716,7

$22,0
$36,2
$752,9

::,

"'
:s:
"'
--i

)>

:s:

: n
- .

:r;:,
m
-

2003

Federal Reserve Statistical Releases

.4 .1 d . .

20

.,.~

:J:
)>

n
n
n ,
,
1

::z;

:s

tJ

::

:s
:s

<

<::!

Q.

<

""

:s
f:s
:;

"'<
u
""

:s
~

::

. ($43,5 )

.
cash)
(vault

,

,
$651,2
,

.

-
,

,


- .

~.

.

,

($22, ) ($43,5 ),
RES.
($65,5 ), ,

14.5,

($651 ,2 ),
( $65,5 )

$716,7 . . 14.4,
)
(694,7



($22,0 ),

$716,7

. 1

""

!)

Q.

""

<

::

($694,7

($22,0

($43,5

(RES)

($65,5



(CU) ($651 ,2 )

($716, 7 )

, , ,
R.ES.

(
).

21, 2003. 20
: Federal Reserve Statistical Releases .3 and .4.1, August
2003

1 , ,

r,

. ,
,
,

(
, r
) .

$1 $1 .
,

,

.

$1 .


.
,

. $1

,

.
$1
( $1 ).

$1 ,
$1 .


,
,

:
~

.

. 19.

19.

, ,

, rs
,

cu

BASE

(+

1)/(cu + res)

: ,

=
[( +

BASE.

1)/(cu + res)]/

.

,
.

,

.

,


(

:1:>

m
'

~
cr

::t
)>

"'


Jj

s
fu
J:
s

s
<(
:[

Q.

<(

"sfs

:;

"'
"u
<(

:r
s
~

J:

"'"
"
~

Q.

<(

~
.

...

1\1

':t'

NOW -).

2003 .


3%

10%

$42,1

$6,0

$42,1 . 1 $6,0
.

,

~, . .


, ,

.
(discoun t

window lending), ,

, (discount rate).

$1

~,

,

1)
:

2)

$1

$1
$1 ,

. ,

,

.


2003 .

~. 2003 .

~, .

,

.
~

(priary credit discont loan)

~,

2003 .

,
. ,

,

( secondary credit discont loan ),


.


,
1

Reserve Bulletin.

1.15 cFederal

( ),

.

( , )
.

.
,

.
,
, .

, ,
,

(Fed funds rate).


-

, ;

14.5
. ( 2003 r. ,

2003 .

. .)

- ,

,

, .
2003 .
,

~ 20
11
11

i8.

15

O L---~--~--~----L---L---~--~--~--~---L--~--

1979

1981

1983 1986 1987 1989 1991

1993 1995 1997 1999 2001

:1::1
m

:.:

:.:

"".
"m"'
1::1

-i

:.:
}>

2003

:0

::;,

::,

r
,


. 2003 r.

14.5

r , r,

.
.

2003 r.

, .
:

FRED database, Federal Reserve Bank of St. I..ouis, research.stlouisfed.orglfred

-i

"'
}>

m
1::1
m

"

}>

::,
<

:r
}>

:0

, .
1i

~
s
tJ:I:

s
s
<

<:t

0..

w
w

<

2003

1
,

( 0,5 ) .

. , ,

. ,

.

"'

s
....
s
:;

"'<

"'

:I:

"'
<
"'
:
()

0..


- ,

(ultimate targets),
.
- ,

(instruments ),

: ,
. ,
, , ,

, ,

,
,

-
. (intermediat e targets),

.,

, ,
1
, .

, 1 2,
, .
,

, . ,
, ,

LM.


, .


.
,

-
,

(. ~ :
~
.) ,

, 1

.:

Richard Davis. Intermediate Targets and Indicators for Monetary Policy: An Introduction to
the Issues 11 ()yarterly Review, . 1990 (). . 71-82.


.
, ,

,

.

?

,

LM , ,

. ,
,
,

, ,

. ,

,

,
.



14.6 ,
LM Lt,



r . , ,

,
,

(, -

) .

LM Lt Ll,


2 3
,


FE

,,'' ///
/

~,.

_,

15

LM

Ll L3

14.6

,
2
3
r

1

, r t'
,

"

1:1

m
"

rr

"'
"'
)>

:0

~
:s
t:;

:I:

:s
:s
<(

0..

<(

"'

:s
f:s
<:;

::

"'
<(

"'


,
1

r 1. , , LM

,
LAfl,

Lt;

LM

LM

, LM Lt .

,
.

,

2 ,

, , -

:s
~

:I:

"'"'
"'
~

0..

<(

-4'
.D

1-

"'

IS-LM
-

AD-AS ,
: ,

,
, ,

AD.

LM

,
-

, ,

()
,

m .

. ,

-
,

.
,

, ,

14.7,
- , .
2

48

- .

) ,

1 t

,
. ,

r !iI

Policy
Ben Bernanke, Mark Gertler. Inside the Black : The Credit Channel of Monetary
27-48.
.
().
1995
s.
Perspective
Economic
of
joumal
//
on
Transmissi

0,4

0,3
0,2

0,1

0,0

-0,1

-0,2

12

18

24

30

36

42

48 ,
-
.

14.7

n,


-
n

, ( )
( ) -

. 1


.

( ). 1

,
-
.

, (

) -
.

-

0,3
(
, 5,0 5,3%).

6-12

-

.

()

,
.

. (

14.7

; ~ ,
,
,

.) ,
-

J::l
m

"~
t

::t
)>



.

,
.
1

"'

Jl

ti

s
s

<

ct
w
Q.

<
s
fs

-
.

16-20
.
,


!
,
-
.


1 -
. 1


()

"'

<:;


6 2 ,

, . -

"'
"'w

<
u

"'
<
"'
::

Q.

-.t
.

...1.1

"'

,
.


-
.

, -

,
,




.
..
,
( . .

),

. ,

,

. ,


, - -

,


. -

-
,
, .

- .

,

, ,

,
.

(. 11),
- , IS-LM
,
,

, ( ).

- ,

,
rate channel) - .

(interest


-,
(. 13).

,
,

1 , , ,

-
, ,

.


,
. -
,

(exchange rate channel).

,
,
(credit channel )
. 14.1

. , ,
,
,
>>
~ -

. , ,
,
,
.
?
,

. ,

( -
),

- (

).
, ,

,
.



, ,

. , -

20
,


. ,


, ~ .

14.3. -
: ,...,

-
?

.
,
,

,

. ,

,
-


.

10 11).

to

-
,

>

m
"

>

::.
"

"'

&

14.1

JS

~:s:

t;

:t:

:s:
:s:

<
q

..

<

""

:s:
f:s:
:;

:
:

<

""

-

,


,
.

,
, ,

,
,
,

,

,
,
. ,
, n
,

n.
,

::

:s:

:t:

""

()

..

""
<

::[

-4'
.

.......

"'

'3"

~

,

. , ,
, n

.
, ,
n ,

.
n ,
(



),

. ,

, ,

.
n ,
( ,

n

-
).

(
, ,

IS) .
?

,
,


1960-1970- rr.,

,


.
,
, (

20

) , ,


()

n
. -

, .
-
,
(,

).
n


, - n
n

,
n
.
,

Bernanke, Mark
.: Ben
ion 11 joumal
Transmiss
Policy
Monetary
of
Channel
Credit
The
:
Black
the
Inside
Gertler.
27-48.
.
of Economic Perspectives. 1995 ().

,
.
,

,
,

-
,

,

,
.

., .: Mark Gertler, Simon Gilchrist. Monetary Policy, Business Cycles,


and the Behavior
of Small Manufacturing Firms 11 Quarterlyjoumal of Economics. 1994 ().
. 309-340.
-

,
,

.
(rules)
, -

. ,

,

. .
,
1%
.
, ,

-
,
(

).
,
;

14.2.

-
, ,
,
, ;

. ,

,

.

. ,
, ,

, ~

4%

:1::1
m

-
.
,

( ),
~
, ,

-
, , ,

"'
I

"
:
."

s:

(discretion) . ,

. ,

,
,
,

.


, .


. ,

-

?

-1

>

"'

::>

::::>

:s:

-1

s:

">
s:

m
J::>
m

."

s;

r:

>

"'

14.2

:JS

~s

f-

u
:r:
s
<(

q:

<(

""

f-

,
,

,
rule)
(Taylor

i = 1t + , 02 + O,Sy + O,S(1t -

:;

0::
<(

""

:r:

"""'

""
<(

'4'

....11u

10

'3'

02),

i -
; = ( - ') j Y

);

1t-

.

, i
,

-1t,

2)
: 1)
2%, 0,02.
,
,

, ,


2%,

2%,

r
. ~
,
,

-
,
2%. ,
,


,

2%, - .
,


.

,

.
.
-

,

, ,

-
. ,


) .

.:

Series
Discretion Versus Policy Rules in Practice 11 Camegie - Rochester Conference

Pulic Policy. 1993.

195-214.

-
,

, .
,


.
.

(monetarism)

,
.


.
, -

,
. 1

-

1. -

.

UJ.t

.


( )



( 10).
,

- -

.
,
( )
, ,
,

12).

2.

, J.t

,


(


). - ,

,


.

,


.
-,
,



(. . 14.7).
,

. n

, ,
,

,
.

-,

, ,
,

,
,
,
.

1 ,
,
.


.
, ,
,

1

Program

Press)

for Monetar y Stabllity (1959) (New York: Fordham University

]::!
m

:z:

"'

:z:

"'
m
J::>
."

-i

:z:

)>

"'

::;,

::0

s
-i
s

"'
)>

m
J::>
m

."

s;
t

:z:

)>

"'

1i

~:s:
f-

u
:r:
:s:
:s:
.q:

"-

w
w


(
.

, ),


3.

1t-


,
, .

, ,


,
. ,


,
.


, ,
,
,

, .

rr.,
933
1929-1
,

.
.

?

,

1t
4.
,

( 1 2)
z.

11t

, ,

-


, ,
-,
.

, ,
,

,

. -


, ,


,
,
.

.,~ -

.,


,
~.
- .



,
.

,

.

.
,




,

.

, ,
,


.



. ,


(

),

.

.


.

, -

,
.
,
,

,
.
,
,
,

. ,

, ,

.

,
,

,
,
. ,



. ,

( credibllit y) , ,

, ,

- .
, : .

, ,

-
,

, .
,
,

111
111

111

...

:JS

:s:

tJ:I:

:s:
:s:

:2

:i7

..

u
w

"'

:s:
:s:

11

"'u
"':rw

:s:
:

:I:

"'m
"'
:
..

'4'

~0:rn

1-

1,/

1'0


. ,

14.8

(
), , .
, ; . , .
.

.
, . ,

:
, .

~>.

.

, ,

.
2)
: 1)

. ,

,
, .


, . ,


, , , ,
.

.

,

: . .

14.8


: . ;
. .

,
.

.
,



. :


- - ,


. , ,

2 . ,
,

.
3 ) . (


, , .
.
, 2

1 .


, ,
3 , -
. ,

).

(
).
, , D ( ,
,
. - ,


( ) , ,
(

14.8
.

,
). ,
(

z).

, .
:

, ( ).

( ) ( ).
,

.
2 ; -

,
D,
( ) ,

. ,
.

14.8 ,

.
,
(. .
,

]::J
m

) .

:r

;.;




,

. r (game theoy) (),
,
,

()
,
.

,

, .

::,


.
.

,


, ,
,
;



, , ,

, .


? ,


, - ,

:r

"'

."

:s:
-i
:r
)>
:

::J

:s:
-i
:s:

"':s:
)>

."

tr

:r
)>

1i

~
s:
tJ:I:

s:
s:
<(

<::{

0..

u
w
w

<(

"'s:1-

s:
<:;

<::

"'
"'uw
<(

s:

1:

:I:

"'"'
"'
::

0..

<(

'4'
.

1-

10

, ,

, .
,
,

, .
,

, ,

, .

, ,

?
(

, ) .
,

. ,
,
(),
(

), ,

. ,

( ),

D ( ).

(2 ) ( 1 ),

. ,


.
,

(), .
.

, .

,
,

IS

LM

FE

( . 14.9) .

, ,

FE

1'11 ..
~

111 1'11
1'11 1-

1;

//' /
, / ' ( /~

... :1
1'11

:.

:.

/
/
/
/
/
/
/

JS

(u=9%)

(u=%)

(u=6%)

.
( )

10%. , /,
, , , , , .

,
.
, LM
LM' Ll
9%
F.
, LM
L' Ll
3% .

1t=O%;

:-1
:

1 1

1t = 10%; = 6%

: 2

=3%

3 1

1t = 10%; = 9%

1t = 0%; = 6%

1t = 0%
1t = 10%
= (6%)
> (9%)
< (3%)

-1

n
. n,

rn
1
1

14.9&


n , n

, , , . ,

n
n ,

( ) n
, , , .

D), n ,
).
n
n; n


) .
n , n,
n,
n, n, n
n n

.
)

F
,
,
.
.
n ,

n (

10% . ,

, M j P, n, LW


. ,
,

10% .
, 6%,

( , )


. ,

,
:
.

10 %-

,
, ,
, ,
10%,

, Mj P,
,

LM


6%,

,

. ,

]:::J
m
::t

JE

::t

'

"'

."

m
:1::>

:s:
-1

::t
)>

"'

:::J

:s:
__,
:s:

"'

)>

:s:

~
m

."
)>
~

"

::t
)>

"'

:JS

~:s:

t:;

:I:

:s:
:s:

<

fif

Q.

w
w

<

"':s:t-

:s:

::

::

"'<

"'uw
::

:s:

:I:

"'"'
"'<
~

Q.

.q

......
.

"'

':f'

.

Mj P, 10%, LM

Ll

(

F).

?
,
,
,
,
.

.

. 14.9.

, ( 10%) ,

. ,
( 10%)
, .
,
;
,
,
, . .


? ,
, :

10%, , , 10%;
D
, 1t = .

10%,

( . 14.9) .
D
, , /

. ,

/ ,

LM

6%.

D , ,

, .

Ll


F . 14 . 9,
9%. ,
, ,

Mj P LM
L.

( . 14 . 9)
3%.

,
,
.
,
. 1
( D)

( ).

.
( D), 1
() - 1

() .

.
,

3%;
- , 10% 9%
.
FE,
. .

. ,
2
( D).

,
1
( D).

,
,
, ,

.
:

, .

.
,
, . .
.

D.

D,

. ,
. ,
,
,


. , ,

, . (
, FE
), .

, ,

, ( )
. ,

. , D (
) . ,

,
D.

, ,

. : ,

( ). ,

D ( ). D
, ~.

D,
,
. D
.
, .

, ,

. ?
,
,
, .

:
m
I
m

, .

""
'
"~

, .

D.

, ,

,
:

, ;

, .

, ?
, ,
,


. , ,

.
, ,

, , -

."

:s;
-1
I

>
:0
::J

::;,

:s;
-1
:s;

">

:s;

m
1::>
m
."

"

>
:0

(
:

D).

, ,
. ,

:s;

t;

:z::

:s;
:s;

. ,

<
q

<

"'

? ,

:s;
f:s;
<:;

, , ,
,
.

1:::

"'<
"'u

:s;
::

. ,

, ( ),

- , ?

:z::

"'

()

, . .
, . ,

"'<

, , ,
,

'4'
.

1-

"'

1970- rr.
,
- .

,
,

: . 1

. ( )

1975 . ,

.: Ben S. Bernanke,
Thomas
Laubach, Frederic S. Mishkin, Adam S. Posen. Inflation Targeting: Lessons from the International
Experience (Princeton, N. J.: Princeton University Press, 1999); Ben S. Bernanke, Mishkin.
Inflation Targeting: New Strategy forMonetary Policy? 11 joumal of Economic Perspectives.
1997 () .
1

1999 .

,
1970- .,
.
,


). ,

Money, ),
( Central Bank

, ,

.
,


1978 .,
.


1975 .,
,

2
1,
:


- , -


; , ,
,
.

, ,
.

, ,



,
, .

.
1980-

. , , ,
,

1980- . i

:r

, 1982 .

.
2000

."

;.;

:r

'

;><;

];::1

:s:
~

:r
)>

"'

::1

1980- .

;><;

, -

.
1980-
1970

,
(. ~ :

,
,

~).

LM

::,

:s:
~
:s:

)>

:s:

];::1

."
)>

::,
<

:r

)>

"'

,

(. .

:Jj

~
s:

14.6).

(

)
.

1-

u
:z:
s:
s:
<
r::[

1980-
.
, ,

..

<
s:
1s:

"

1987 .,
, -
, .

::

"'
"
<

1990 .
-
.
,


,

( ).
,
,

, (
)
.

s:
~

:z:

"'"

..

"<
::
'4'

, , , ,
, ,

.11

1-

.

,

"'

':1'

.


,

u1t (inflation
targeting),
, (

) ,

1-4 . ,

( )


,
.

. , ,

,

. 1

.


, ,
. -,
(~1
)
. -,

1



,

. ,

, ,

.

, ,

.

.

, ,
1

,
,
( ), , ,

) .


,
, .
r ,


(. . 14.7).
,

, ,

.
, ,

- ,
.




-
?

: ~ ,

.

1.

.
- ,
, , ,
.


- ,
, ,

. ,
1979 . ,

(Paul Volker)

- -

)::J
m

:z:
m
~

:z:

'
><
."

:1:>

:s:
-i

:z:

>
:.:>

::J

:::,

:s:
-i
:s:
><

>

:s:

14.6,

, .

,
,
.

:1:>
m

."

>
:::,
<

:z:

>
:.:>

. ~

, .

,
,
. 1

2. .
-

w
w

, ~
( ,

;2

). 2
, ,
.

s:
fs:
:;

"'<
"'uw

, , ,

s:

::t:

"'

, .
.

111

11.

"'

<

3.

-4'
.

.
,

1-

"'

- .
,

(, )

. ,
,

,
, . 14.10,

,3

16 .

1955-1988 rr.
(

, ,

) .
, ,
1 ,

, r : The Optimal Degree
of Commitment to an Intermediate Monetary Target // Q;rterlyjoumal of Economil:s. 1985 (
). . 1169-1189. , ,
r
1981-1982 rr.
2
: Carl Walsh,

Optimal Contracts for Central Bankers // American Economic Reuiew. 1995 (). . 150-167.
Alberto Alesina, Lawrence Summers. Central Bank Independence and Macroeconomi c
Performance // joumal of Money, Credit and Banking. 1993 (). . 151- 162.

~11
'#.
ri

.~
~
....

"

:r::
s;

~
Cl.

//

~---L----L----L----~---L--~----~--~---

0,5

1,0

1,5

2,0

2,5

3,0

3,5

4 ,0

4 ,5


(
,
) 16 n 1955- 1988 rr.
n,

14.10

Alberto Alesina, Lawrence Summers. Central Bank Independence and Macroeconomic


Performance // ]oumal of Money, Credit and Banking. 1993 () . . 151 - 162. 1 .. 1.

, :
, ,
1
, , .
- ,
.
,


, .

J::J
m
I

;.;
I

'

"'""

m
1:1

s:
~

)>

"'

::J

::,

s:
~

"'"'
)>

2001 .

2001

.~ (

m
1:1
m

""
)>

::,

: ,

s:

8),

1
, .

<

I
)>

"'

2S

s
s

iJ

:I:

s
s

<(

:i:f
.

2000 .,
.
, 2001 .

. .
2000 . , ,
,
6,50%. 2001 .,

2001

w
w

. -
, 11

<(

"'s

1:s;

"'
"'w
<(

2001 . 2002 .
5 , 1,75% (. 14.11).
2002 .,
2003 . 1,0%. ,
.

, 2001 . ,
.

:I:

"'
"'
::

(1)

<(

-4'
.11

....

1.1

"'

, .

, ,
,
.

( 1 ), -

11

"#. 7

10-

5
4

3
2

L-----------~----~--------~--------------~-------

2000

2001

2002

2003

) 10-
2000
2003 . , -

2001

, . .
:

14.11

Federal Reserve of St. Louis FRED database, research.stlouisfed.orgjfred

- .

14.11

10- ( ,

,

10 )

, ,
,
. (. 4 ~ :
~
~.)

1.

: ,
.
,
, .
(

) ,
.
,
.

2.

, .

, ,

3.

1.

, res - ,
.
,

1j res

, .

,
.

4.

,
(+ 1)/( + res) , -

( ) ,
.


, ,

. , ,

, res,
.
res,
.

5.

. (

)
. (
,
, ) .

:1:::1
m
I

JE

;><;
."

:s:
-i

)>

"'
:::J

::,

:s:
-i
:s:

;><;
)>

:s:

."

I
)>

"'

6.

,
. ,

,-- ttt; .

-
().

7.

w
w

.
.

8.

-
,

).
,
LM .

9.

, -

, ,

-4"

, -
( ,
) (

...

\,/

"'

':r

10.

).
- ,

() .

-
,
,

.
( ), ,
-

,
,
.

11.

, , , -

-
. , , ,

,
.

12.

.
,

, (),
,
.

13.

,
,

, ,

. ,

,
,

.
,

.
,

14.

,
,


()

100%-


()


=+D.

]::>

."

(14.4)

, , - , ,
, DEP.

BASE =

RES.

(14.5)

::t

>

"'

, ,
, ,
, , RES.
= [(+ 1) /(

+ res) ]BASE.

(14.8)

, , ,

, (+

1)/ (cu + res), - ,


res - , .

<

><
s
fs
;


1.

.
- ?

2.

.ymurutuamopa.
1 00%- ?

"'<><

, ?

:I:

><

(!)

><

<

3.

. ,
,

-t

? ~~

Jl
11.1

"'

, 100%- ?
,

~ ~ ?

4.


? ?

5.
6.

- ?
?

? ,
.

7.

?
- ?
, .

8.

- .
.

9.

- , ,


~.
?

10.

,
?


1.

1 .
, -

. 20% .
,
1 .,
,

.
(: ,
.)

. ?

2.

) $6 ,
$2 , 0,25. ,

, .
) $1 ,
$4 ,
$1 , - $20 .
, .

3.

,
,
. , ,

res = 0,4 - 2r,

res -

1,0,

r-

0,4,

60.

L(Y, i)

= 0,5-

10i,

- , i - .
, ,
.

r= i = 0,10, ,

? , ,
, , 1, ?

) () r= i =

0,05.

) , ,
), .
r= i = 0,05, , ,
?

LM,

, ?
.

4. ,
, 1 2. 1
, . 2 ,
, .

. ,

( ),
.

:Jj

s
1u
:I:
s
s

(, )

(, )

2
5

Q.

(, )

(, )

<(

<(

5
3

, , 1 ,
2 , 1 2 2
2 . ,
. ,

"'s

1-

:;

"'
"'u
<(

::r

1 ( ) , 2,
? (
, . 14.8.) ?
, 2?

::!:

:I:

"'
"'
::

Q.

) , 1 , 1
2 , ( ) ,
. 2
. ?

<(

'4'

...
.

1.1

ra

'j'

1 , 2
, 1,

, 1 ,
, 1 . 2
. ?
1 2


1.

? .
) . (
- ,
.)
)
.


, (
).

) ,
,
.
)

$20
.
.

) .


,

3% . ,

2.

. ,

?

,

?

) ,

IS.

, ?

, ,

?
?
)

3.

().
( FE).

, ,
,
14.2.

, .
) .

) .
) .
) .
) .

4.

14.95,
.


,
, .
,
, ,

.
1 ,

? (,

, , ,

.)

5.

,
? ,
?
, ,
.

I(


., ,
rg/
tlouisfed.o
research.s
:

FRED
-

fred
1.

1 (
,

}:::]
m

:r
m
~

:r

'

"m

.."

1::.

:s:
-1
:r
>

"'

::J

::;,

:s:
-1
:s:
>
:s:

"

1::.
m

.."

>
::;,
1

:r

>

"'

1959 .). ~ 1>


1959 .
1 ~
1>

~:s:

t;


1 ,

:s:
:s:

1959 .

?

<(
<::[

w
Q.
u

? -

, ?

w
w
<(

""

:s:
f:s:

2.

<:;

::

"'
""w
<(

:7

:s:


1961 .

1979- 1982 . ?

1982 .?

""

"'

,

?

Q.

""
::
<(

-.:1"
.

..,

1-

ta
~



.

1979- 1982 .
,

3.

,
,

.

,



, .

1961 . -


?
?

15

,
, -
,-

-
. ,

,
.


-

,

.
.


,
.

15.1. :

,
-



;
,
1)
:

.
.

3)

2) ,

2,



,
:

.
,

: (govemet prchases, G)

1.

, .

,
(govemet
ivestet),

.


(govemet
consuptio expeditres).

2.

<

"'f-""

"'

(transferpayets, TR)
,

.

,
,

,
(
) Medicae (

).'

::

"'<
""

3.

"'
:

(t iterest t
s,

INI)-

:1:

,
,

""
""<

,
.

,
,

1\

Q.



(subsidies less srpluses of govemet eterprises). -

, ,

.

.q

...
.

IJ

"'

'3'

,

(
).

,
.

(,

)
. 15.1

1940 ., ,
.
-

: 1943
1944 .,
,
45% .
(1951 - 1953 rr.)
,
:
15,9% 1950
23,9% 1953 . 1960-
rr. ,
,
23 18% .

15.1 ,
,
, 1950- r.
1980 - rr.,
.

12% .

(,

Medicare Medicaid
1965 . ), (,

,

15.1) ,
.
1

Medicaid

Medicar e

,
.

(1941-1945)

30

20

10
n

~~~~~~~~~~====~

1~1~

1~1~

1~1~

1~1m

11~

1~1~~00

, 1940 .

(1941-194 5 .)
(1951-195 3 .) . ,

15.1

:
,
,

1940-2002


, .
1980 - .
, ,
:

. 1.1; : . 3.1.


. www.cbo.gov

www.bea.doc.gov, August 29, 2003. :

, .

15.1

. ,

,
-
, ,


. ,
- 1,03%
. -,

1941 1,93% 1946 .,



,
,
. -, ,
1979 3,41%

1,75%

rr.,
1980-

...,

~
)>
."

"'

m
::t:
::t:

2:

."
)>

)::>

2:

:s:
:s:

1989 .

,

1980-

::t:

rr. r

1990- . ,

:s:

::t:
)>

n
:s:

"'::t:

."

)>

:s:


1i

~:s:
tJ
:1:

:s:
:s:
(

2002

...:s:""
:s:
:;

"'
u
""w
(

:s:

:f:

:1:

"'""

Q.

""

-4'

..../1
u

10

':

, % ,

35,6
38,6
48,6
54,0
47,7
40,9
40,6
36,0
51,9
50,2
55,3
49,2
46,3
44,6
34,4
47,3
39,8
58,3

<:[

w
w

18

Q.

15.1.

OECD, National Accounts,

15.1

073

Annex

Tales,

www.oecd.org

18

().

34,4% - ; - 35,6%.

,
(
).

: ,

, ,
,
. . 15.2



, .
,
,
16,5% 1940
30,5% 2000 ., 2001 2002 rr., .

t (personal

taxes),

. m

(

) .

,

. 1913 . 16-

.



, 1,9% 1940 8,9%
1945 . -

35

.,.

30

111
111

i...

ID

25

1234-

:z:
20

15
10

5
2
~--~~--~

~--~--~--~--~-OL---L---L---~--J---

1~1~

1~1~

1~1~

1~1~

1~1~

1~1~WOO

).

15. 2

: ,

1940-200 2

.

.

, ,
: r
: . 3.1.
29, 2003. : . 1.1;

www.hea.doc.gov,

;'
01
111
01

1945 .

-


1981 .


1964 .


2000- .


. 15.2 ,
,


e) (
insranc
social
for
( contribtions

).



;
,

.

,
,


.

,

, .

-
,
.

taxes),
(indirect bsiness

,

.
-

....

1.11

-,

()

'<

J:>

".

."
()

-i

"'::t

m
::t

\!:

m
."

".
()

J:>
\!:

:s:
:s:

:s:

::t

".

::t
()

:s:

."

"'::t
"'
".

::ij

~:s:

ti:I:

:s:
:s:
<

o::t

w
w

<
:s:
~
:s:

"

<:;

t:

"'<
u
"
w
:r

:s:

1:

:I:

"'

(!)

"'<

~
~

...Jl

1.1

"'



(coporate taxes),
. . 15.2

,

1950- 1980- rr.

2 3%
.

:

.
,

. 15.1, ,
. 15.2,
,
.


,
-
.<