Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
..-
Scripta
antiqua
Scripta
antiqua
, ,
The Almanac
Volume Four
Sobranie
oscow 2015
2015
94(3)+902/904+7.032
63.3(0)3+63.442+63.443+63.2+80+85
45
ISSN 2221-9560
:
. (), . (), .-. (),
.. (), .. (), . (),
.-. (), .. (), .. (),
. (), . (), . (),
. (), .- (), .. (),
.-. (), . (), . (),
. (), . (), . ()
..
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15
..
..
-
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25
:
.., .., .., .., ..,
.., .., .., ..,
.., ..
..
. . . . . . . 33
S cientific C ouncil :
P.Bernard (France), G.W.Bowersock (USA), J.-Ch. Balty (Belgium),
M.D.Bukharin (Russia), M.A.Dandamaev (Russia), P.Ducrey (Switzerland),
J.-L.Ferrary (France), H.Heinen (Germany), L.Hannestad (Danemark),
M.Hatzopoulos (Greece), P.-F.Callieri (Italy), N.N.Kazansky (Russia),
G..Koshelenko (Russia), .Marth (Hungary), F.Millar (Great Britain),
H.Parzinger (Germany), S.Rosen (Sweden), N.Sims-Williams (Great Britain),
S.Shaked (Israel), V.Schiltz (France), I.Kh.Urilov (Russia)
.., ..
. . . . . . . . . . . 63
E ditor-in- C hief
.D.Bukharin
E ditorial B oard :
A.Yu.Alexeev, N.P.Grintser, D.V.Zhuravlev, ..Zavoykin, L.L.Kofanov,
I..Ladynin, .V.Muravyev, ..Nemirovsky, .V.Podosinov,
S.Yu.Saprykin, S.R.Tokhtasyev
ISBN 978-5-9606-0135-1 (. 4)
ISBN 978-5-9606-0113-9
.., , 2015
. , 2015
..
. . . . 100
..
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111
..
- . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 127
..
: . . . . . . . . 151
..
-
IVIX . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 183
..
1934 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 199
PERSONALIA
..
..
. . . . . . . . 231
..
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 263
.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 281
.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 283
W.Stancomb
The Earliest Bronze Coins of Asia Minor and their Influence
on Coinage in the Black Sea Region. 5 . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . 295
E.Pavlovska
Gold Staters Coin Hoard from Skopje Region . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 307
..
(
) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 315
..
IV
III . ..
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .335
..
. . . . . . . 370
..
-
- . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 380
Th.Kourempanas
Two Rare Overstrikes of the Late Hellenistic Coins
of Thessaloniki . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 395
.
III . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . 397
.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 418
.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 424
., .
Via Diagonalis ( . , o,
. ) I . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 437
.
I . ..
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 445
.., ..
IIII . ..
(2009 .) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 451
..
- . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 492
.., .
. , . (
) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 502
S.Filipova
Coin Circulation along the Upper Struma Rivers Region
during The Late Antiquity (294498) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 521
D.Vladimirova-Aladzhova
Silver Minting Amidst Rome and Byzantium . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 551
CONTENS
..-
:
.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 554
Fr. de Callata
Early Numismatic Research on Royal Bosporan Coins
(XVIIthXVIIIth century) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 561
..
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 593
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 605
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 609
ARCHAEOLOGY
M.A.Mamedov
Archaeology and Protection of the Historical Monuments
of Turkmenistan . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .15
S.V.Laptev
On the Contacts between the Peoples of South-East
and Central Asia in Antiquity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25
M.M.Kazansky
German Elements in Material Culture of Abkhazia
in the Late Roman Time and Great Migration Period . . . . . . . . . . . . 33
10
Contens
PERSONALIA
Contents
11
E.Ya.Turovsky
Some Controversial Problems
of the Numismatics of Chersonesos . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 370
T.N.Smekalova
New Greek Settlement Chokrak-Verkhniy
on the Cap Tarkhankut . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 380
Th.Kourempanas
Two Rare Overstrikes of the Late Hellenistic Coins
of Thessaloniki . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 395
I.Prokopov
Transition from Late Hellenistic to Roman Monetary System
in Thrace, 2nd1st Centuries BC . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 397
I.V.Tunkina
M.I.Rostovtsev at the Junction of Russian and German
Classical Archaeology before The First World War . . . . . . . . . . . . 231
B.Ruseva
Silver Tetradrachms of Odessos of the Alexander Type
with Signature a Prototype of the Silver Issues
of Dionysopolis with Signature . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 418
K.D.Nikolskaya
About my Father . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 263
M.Manov
Scythian Kings in Dobroudzha . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 424
CLASSICAL NUMISMATICS
Towards the Jubilee of Nina Andreevna Frolova . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 281
Publications of N.A.Frolova . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 283
W.Stancomb
The Earliest Bronze Coins of Asia Minor and their Influence
on Coinage in the Black Sea Region . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 295
E.Pavlovska
Gold Staters Coin Hoard from Skopje Region . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 307
I.E.Surikov
Plato and Aristotle on the Coin (to the Comparison of Ancient
and Contemporary Scholarly Opinions on the Emergence
of Coinage in Greece) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 315
A.V.Strelkov
Athenian Bronze Coins of the mid. 4th mid. 3rd Centuries B.C.
in the Collection of Numismatic Department
of the State Historical Museum . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 335
E.Paunov, M.Slavova
As of Sextus Pompeius from Via Diagonalis in Thrace
(Near City Lyubimets, Khaskovo Region, Republic of Bulgaria)
of the I cent. B.C. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 437
S.Topalov
Towards the Attribution of the Round Overstrike Wheel
with Spoke and Teeth Used in the Western Pontic Coast
in the First century B.C. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 445
M.G.Abramzon, N.F.Fedoseev
A Hoard of Bronze Bosporan Coins
of the late 1st 3rd Century AD from Panticapaeum (2009) . . . . . . 451
A.V.Maksimov
The Coins of Bosporus and Olbia in the Collection
of Yaroslavl Museum . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .492
V.K.Peshekhonov, A.Davidova
The Coins of Panticapaeum from the Collections
of the Archaeological Museum of Plovdiv
(Republic of Bulgaria) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 502
12
Contens
S.Filipova
Coin Circulation along the Upper Struma Rivers Region
during the Late Antiquity (294498) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 521
D.Vladimirova-Aladzhova
Silver Minting Amidst Rome and Byzantium . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 551
T.A.Izbash-Gatskan
The Forgotten Pages of Classical Numismatics:
E.E.Lyutsenko . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 554
Fr. de Callata
Early Numismatic Research on Royal Bosporan Coins
(XVIIthXVIIIth century) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 561
V.V.Khukharev
Numismatic Addictions
of Russian philosopher Vasiliy Rozanov
and his Archaeology of Ancient Miniatures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 593
Abbreviations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 605
Our Authors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 609
..
. . :
; , ;
; , - .
.
17 1993 .
.
30 1994 . ,
.
,
- , 1999 ,
(. 12; .
), 2005 . (. 3; .
), 2007 . .
1994 . ,
16
. 2. . -
(National Department
for Protection, Research and Restoration of Historical and Cultural
Monuments), , , , - ,
,
.
, ,
,
,
,
. , , , - .
...
17
- ( , )
,
( ) .
, ,
: ) ; ) ; ) -. .
.
, ,
- (. 45), -
.., ,
IIIII ..
, -
(BMAC),
, , , .
-,
15 , 2001 . -
- ().
. 4. -.
18
. 5. -.
.
(. 6), .,
90- - . ( ).
- (. 7)
... - (. 8)
. (
).
- . (CNRS)
90-
. 6. .
...
19
. 7. -.
- (. 910)
- . .
( ), . 2001 . -
(. 1112). 2011 . .- (NRS).
- ( ., ) - ( ., )
(. 13) ,
.
-
- (. 14) - - .. ( ). , - , . , . ( ),
(. 1516),
. ,
. ( ), -.
, 90-
,
.
20
...
. 10. -
. 9. -
.
- . ,
, ,
.
- , .
- .
. 11. -.
21
22
...
23
. 14. -.
. 12. -.
. 13. .
-
,
. , , , , ,
, , .
(XII .). ,
, ,
.
15 , .
,
,
- . ,
-
, , .
24
. 15. .
. 16. .
Summary
Archaeology and Protection of the Historical Monuments
of Turkmenistan
by M.A.Mamedov (Ashgabat)
The article presents a sketch of the activity of historians and archaeologists in studying the ancient history of Turkmenistan as well as the
efforts of the National Department for Protection, Research and Restoration
of Historical and Cultural Monuments of Republic of Turkmenistan for
better preservation and presentation of ancient history of the country.
..
- , . ,
1, , , , - ,
. , ,
, , ,
, , 2.
- ,
-
, .
,
. 19421943 . , ,
(II . . . VI . ..)3. ,
. 2000- , -
- .
2006 . . ,
, .
2006: 116119.
1995.
3
Malleret 19471950: 189199; 19511952: 7588.
1
2
26
, ,
, , ,
- :
,
. , , , ,
, , (. 1).
.
(III . ..
III . ..)4. ,
,
, , , ,
, , ,
- .
, , .
,
. 20101012 . -
.
, ,
, ,
. , , (. 2).
VIIV . .., 5.
-
.
, ,
VIII . ..6
, ,
.
2009: 226227.
1989: 10.
6
1999: 1317.
4
... - ...
27
. 1. ( 2009: 148)
. 2. . .
. 3. ( 2009: 159)
. 4. -I (Takashi Miyazaki 1988: 259)
. 5. .
. 6. .
. 7. - (Sarianidi 1985)
. 8. , (L Xun
Dim, ao Linh Cu, Vo Si Khai 1995)
. 9. .
I . .. VIII . ..7,
III . ..
III . .., III . .. .
.
.
, ,
- .
2009: 230231.
28
,
IVII . .., 2000 .,
20062007 . 2007 .
35 - 8. ,
-
, .
. , 9.
- ,
20072012 ., .
- ,
, . ,
.
-
. ,
.
, .
, ,
(. 3). , ,
-I ()
10. IIII . ..11
, , (. 4).
,
. , . , (. 5).
Lapteff 2008.
2006.
10
1985: 121, 125.
11
Takashi Miyazaki 1988: 359.
8
9
... - ...
29
, ,
,
(. 6).
(IVII . ..)12 - 13. , . II . .. I . ..14 (. 7).
15 IIII . ..
, . (. 8)16. ,
(VII . ..) , , -,
,
, , . ,
17. ,
.
, ,
- ,
IIIII .., , ,
18.
.
.
, ,
. , II
.. ,
12
L Xun Dim 1996: 3437; Nguyn Duy T, Nguyn Phng Anh 1995:
63, 77.
13
Richter 2000: 39, 179.
14
Sarianidi 1985: 86.
15
1985: 85, 109110.
16
L Xun Dim, o Linh Cu, V S Khi 1995: . . 1728.
17
Inagaki, Green 2002: 7898.
18
2006: 189.
30
, XIII . ..19
2007 . , . . 2012
. .
, , , .
, (. 9) ,
.
, -
, . , , .
, -
.
20. - , ( ), .. ,
. IIII . .. ,
, ,
.
-
. ,
- (250125 . ..) (180 . .. 10 . ..).
- ,
. ,
-,
( )21.
,
,
, -
.
... - ...
31
, ,
- ,
,
. , , ,
- , , , .
Summary
1995 .. -
XIII . , 1995.
1989 . = (
). , 1989. ( . .).
1985 : / . .
... , 1985.
2002 . =
( ). ,
2002. ( . .).
2009 . = ( ).
, 2009. ( . .).
2006 .. -. .
, 2006.
1999 . : . - = ( ). , 1999. ( . .).
32
1996 . .
= ( : VIII ...). ,
1996. ( . .).
2006 . M = (
). . I. , 2006. ( . .).
Cds 2001 Cds G. Les peuples de la pninsule indochinoise: Histoire et
civilisations. Phnom Penh, 2001.
Inagaki, Green 2002 Miho Museum. The Treasures of Ancient Bactria /
Ed. by H. Inagaki, A. Green. Shigaraki, 2002.
Lapteff 2009 Lapteff S.V. Phum Snay Site and the Origins of Pre-Angkor
Cambodia. Moscow, 2009.
L Xun Dim 1996 L Xun Dim, V Kim Lc. C vt Champa. Ha Ni,
1996. ( . .).
L Xun Dim, ao Linh Cu, Vo Si Khai 1995 L Xun Dim, ao Linh
Cu, Vo Si Khai. Vn hoa Oc Eo. Nhng kham pha mi. Ha Ni, 1995. (
. .).
Malleret 19471950 Malleret L. Aperu de la glyptique dOco // Bulletin
de lcole Franaise dExtrme-Orient. 19471950. T. XLIV, Fasc. 1. . 189199.
Malleret 19511952 Malleret L. Les fouilles dOco (1944): Rapport
prliminaire // Bulletin de lcole Franaise dExtrme-Orient. 19511952.
T. XLV, Fasc. 1. . 7588.
Nguyn Duy Ty, Nguyn Phung Anh 1995 Nguyn Duy Ty, Nguyn Phung
Anh. Nhng hin vt vn hoa Oc Eo bao tang tinh Cn Th. Cn Th, 1995. (
. .).
Richter 2000 Richter A. The Jewelry of Southeast Asia. L., 2000.
Sarianidi 1985 Sarianidi V. The Golden Hoard of Bactria. From the Tillyatepe Excavations in Northern Afghanistan. Leningrad; New York, 1985.
Takashi Miyazaki 1988 The Silk Road: The Oasis and Steppe Routes /
Ed. by Takashi Miyazaki. Nara, 1988.
Miho Museum 1997 MIHO MUSEUM / Ed. by
T.Umehara. Shigaraki, 1997. ( . .).
..
254256 . -
.
(, , )
. ,
(, ,
), ( , ) ( , )
1.
( )
. ,
, , ,
.
,
,
.
, I/1 (170/200
260/270 .) III, .. 380/400-440/450- .2 , IV .3
1
1991; Kazanski 1991: 491492; , 1992;
, 1997: 12, 1827.
2
O .: Kazanski, Mastykova 2007:
2025.
3
1975: 66.
34
18,6%
4, - 29,5%, - 14,8%, - 16,6%,
- 12,5%, - 13,3%5. 1%, .. 43
467 6.
, ,
, , , ..7
,
, .
8, ( ,
).
,
. ,
() , ,
, , ,
. , - 9,
.
,
, , 10. , , . ., 19 -
IIIVII ., 1% 11. , III
IV . , 3, 1971: 123.
1975: 65.
6
2003: 91.
7
1975: 68; 2010: 3943.
8
54 - ( 1975: 65).
( 2006: 31).
9
2010: 92.
10
1975: 67.
11
2008: 643.
4
5
... ...
35
12. ,
10 , .
169 174 III ., 115,
151 153 III IV .
98, 100, V VI .13
7, VVI .14 ,
, .
,
.
, 15. , (
),
(, )
. ,
- 16
- 17.
11 (. 1.8), 18. ,
I (170/200330/340 .) II (320/330 400/410 .),
.. . . , ,
..
,
, , 2003: 187.
, 2003: 189; 2008.
14
1980: 97.
15
1971: 125; 1975: 68.
16
O .: Nowakowski 1996.
-.
17
2006: 27.
18
1971: 234. . 36.1.
12
13
36
... ...
5
6
7
8
10
9
13
11
14
15
16
12
18
19
20
21 22
32
25
26 27 28 29 30
(. )
-19.
. 20, 21, . 22.
, , 23.
, .
III .
, 5,
I II ., 6 II III .
, . 24, . , ,
II . .. IV . ..25 ,
in situ 300, V ., 26.
, , 27, -1, 267; -2, 29428.
III
(380/400440/450 .).
10
17
24
37
31
19
2001: 34; 2006: 3031; . 2006: 117118;
Shchukin, Kazanski, Sharov 2006: 102. Fig. 28.20, 122.33.
20
H.: Nowakowski 1994: Abb. 2.8a.
21
1994: . 6.1.
22
H.: Kivikoski 1973: Taf. 34.286.
23
ivi 2011: 118. Fig. 26.
24
2008: 132.
25
1993: 7273.
26
1979: 222. . 6.7.
27
C. : Kazanski, Mastykova, 2007: 57.
28
2003: 53, 59.
38
, II .29
.
, , 30, , , 31.
, , , , ,
, , ,
.
, ,
, ,
.. . ,
32.
, , c, . ,
,
. - (. 5.5)33, , , -134 (. 5.13),
(. 5.4),
- 235. , .. 2008: 2830.
2011: 44; : .
31
2008: 309; : .
32
2003; 2010: 8190; , 1982; , 2009; 2011.
33
C.: Bishop, Coulston 1993: Fig. 111.12.
34
, 1982: 127.
35
, 1982: 127. .: Kazanski 1994:
458; Kazanski, Mastykova 2007: 29.
51 -
( 1975: . 13.1).
; .: Kazanski 1994: 450451.
29
30
... ...
39
, , ,
.
(. 5.911),
, , , , .. 380-,
450 . ,
36. ,
.
,
, . ,
,
, . ,
.
,
, . , II III .37 -
,
, , II .38 ,
. , 39. ,
: ( 11) , 40.
36
. : 2012; : . - ,
, . :
2012: 120121; , 2013: 9899.
37
Kazanski 1994: 436.
38
2011: 220. . 8.
39
Kazanski 1991: 501502.
40
Kazanski 1994: Fig. 6.9; Shchukin, Kazanski, Sharov 2006: 11.
40
, ,
I/1 (170/200260/270 .), 41,
, , Zieling M-R142.
II/34 (320/330400/410 .)
. , , -/Zieling H2,
Zieling K2, I/2 (260/270330/340 .) II
(320/330400/410 .) .
-/Zieling H243 (. 2.7) C2C3 , .. 250370 .44, , ,
.
, -1, 127,
I/2II/3, .. 260/270 360/370 ., -1, 17,
II/3 (320/330360/370 .)45. ,
. Ravna/
Campsa, Boljetin/Smorna, Capidava, Histria46.
..47 .
(Korzen)/Ziling P (. 3.10,25), , , C1bC3, .. 220/230360/370 .48,
-1, 255, I/2
II, .. 260/270 400/410 ., 177, II (320/330
400/410 .), 119, II/3 ( 320/330
360/370 .)49.
, , 1978: . 48.8.
.: Kazanski 1994: 437.
43
. .: Zieling 1989.
44
Kazanski 1994: 438; Kazanski, Mastykova 2007: 31.
45
2003: . 7.9, 64.7.
46
Glad 2013: Pl. 12.1, 26.3, 78.4.
, .
47
H.: Waurick 1994: Abb. 4.4.
48
Kazanski 1994: 438439; Kazanski, Mastykova 2007: 31.
49
2003: . 60.4, 89.5, 119.17.
... ...
41
2
3
8
7
19
14
13
15
10
41
12
42
17
11
16
18
42
Zieling K2 (. 4.4) 50. -1,
41, 223, II (320/330400/410 .), 60 61, III
(380/400440/450 .)51, , , 1252, -, 25/38, III53.
, . /
Saldum, /Novae54, 55.
1 (. 1.18), ,
(-, 54)56, ,
57.
II/4, D1
, ..
(360/370400/410 .),
(. 5.6), ,
(. 5.8), ( ),
, 58.
, III/58 (380/400440/450 .) , -, . , , /Zieling E2,
(. 6.13), 59, 60. - -4, 461. ,
- (. 5.12),
, ,
62. (. 5.7)
Kazanski 1994: 438439; Kazanski, Mastykova 2007: 3132.
2003: . 16.5, 25.15, 28.8, 105.6.
52
2009: . 16.7, 31.41.
53
1978: . 37.6.
54
Glad 2013: Pl. 9.5.
55
. .: Kazanski 1988: Fig. 14.1; Quast 2012: Abb. 5, 6.23.
56
1971: . 31.2.
57
Kazanski 1994: 440441.
58
Kazanski 1988: Fig. 67; 1994: 440, 443, 447.
59
H.: Glad 2013: 539541. Pl. 58.1.
60
Quast 2012: Abb. 5.1.
61
, 1973: . 4.30.
62
Kazanski 1994: 443, 445446, 448.
... ...
43
3
8
2
6
1
15
10
17
11
14
13
12
16
18
22
21
23
26
20
19
50
51
24
25
27
44
... ...
, . (Misery), ,
63.
275 -164, II III ( 360/370410 .),
, (. 4.30).
IIIIV65. 430460 .66 ,
.
, .. ,
,
.
Zieling S1, 2, (. 1.19, 3.13, 4.5),
67, -, 5468,
-1, 17, I (170/200330/340 .), -1,
41 119, II/3 (320/340360/370 .), -1,
349, II/4 (360/370400/410 .), -1, 61, III (380/400440/450 .)69 Zieling X,
(. 2.8), 70, -1, 127, I/2 II/3
(260/270360/370 .), -1, 60, II (320/330
400/410 .)71, III (380/400440/450 .)
-, 6, 60, 2772, -, 25/3873, - -4, 574, , , 1275. ,
, (. 7, . ).
Bhme 1974: Taf. 128.6.
64
2003: . 129.13.
65
Hbener 1989: Abb. 2.
66
Koch 2001: 8081, Abb. 18M3; ., .: Mller 1976: Taf. 8.Grab 23.1;
Quast 1993: Taf. 7.5.
67
Kazanski 1994: 449.
68
1971: . 31.3.
69
2003: . 7.9, 16.5, 28.9, 60.4, 162.13.
70
Kazanski 1994: 451452.
71
2003: . 25.15, 64.8.
72
1971: . 3.5, 11.3; 1978: . 12.4.
73
1978: . 37.6.
74
, 1973: . 4.31.
75
2009: . 16.7, 31.44.
45
4
2
5
11
3
10
13
12
14
17
15
16
20
18
63
19
26
21
30
27
25
22
28
29
24
31
23
46
), .
78.
. ,
, , .
.
(. 6.4041). 6 -479, 383 -280.
III, .. 380/400440/450 .
,
(. 8.17). 190
-1, -
IV ., .. II (320/330400/410 .)81, 419 -2, , , II82.
III 6 20 -83, 171
-184 363 420 -285.
.
, ,
, - (Dresden-Dobritz/Gbs)86. XX/1, 2,
.. 250/260300/320 ., ,
87. , 3, , V V II .88
Kazanski 1994: 450.
, 1973: . 7.2021.
80
2003: . 181.5.
81
2003: . 91.17.
82
2003: . 200.910.
83
1971: . 34.11; 1975: . 23.5.
84
2003: . 85.8.
85
2003: . 169.12, 201.21.
86
Birch Iversen 2010: 4851, Abb. 24.
87
Kaczanowski 1995: 25, Tabl. 14.4; . 2006: 121, 148; , 1999: 255.
88
1988: 4142, VII.
78
79
... ...
47
10
11
12
. 5. , , .
1: , . 5; 2: -1, . 118; 3: -1, . 278;
4: , . 2; 5: -1, . 54; 6: -, .
6; 7: - -4, . 5; 8: -, .;
9: - -3, . 2; 10: - -4,
. 7; 11: ; 12: -, . 12. 14: : Kazanski
1994; 5, 811: : , 1982; 6, 12: : 1971; 7: :
, 1973
76
77
48
, . 289.
2
3, .. 270330 .90 3 -, 91. 2, .. 260/270300/330 .92
, XX/2, 293.
- (CsongrdKenderfldek) (
) 94. -
VIVII .95
,
, . ,
, , , 96.
(. 8.9). 97. -1, 251, I/2, .. 290/300
330/340 .98, -1, 248, II/3, ..
320/330360/370 .99, -1, 250, 89
, 1999: 254255, . 3.2; . 2006: 119121,
. 7.2.
90
. 2006: 147151.
91
, 1999: 256, . 5.2.
92
. 2006: 153.
93
, 1999: 256; . 2006: 121.
94
Istvnovits, Kulcsr 1995: Kp. 4.1.
, , , .: von
Freeden 1991: Abb. 16.4.
95
Swanton 1974: Fig. 4c,e, 5d, 6a; Kerep 2006: 90. Fig. 2.4.
96
,
: , (, 1980: . 9.6),
, 2/17 ( 1978: . 17.3).
, , , , , .: von
Freeden 1991.
97
, 1982: 124, 126.
98
2003: . 118.13.
99
2003: . 116.22.
49
... ...
4
3
13
1
14
15
10
11
12
7
18
26
19
16 17
27
20 21 22 23 24 25
30
29
28
35
34
32
33
36
31
37
38
39
40
41
43
44
46
45
42
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
50
... ...
II/4, .. 360/370370400/410 .100, -, 25, - (. )101, -1, 77, III102, -2, 362, III103, , 6, III104, -, 14, IV/9, .. 450550 .105
.
5 11, 3D1 (300/320
400/410 .) 2/1 (160180 .), 106.
.
, ,
.
107. -, 12, 23, ..
250/260350/370 .108 , 109.
III VI . 110. ,
111.
, , .
,
, , , .
,
.
2003: . 117.9.
1975: 31, . 23.4.
102
2003: . 37.8.
103
2003: . 169.4.
104
1971: . 34.10.
105
1971: . 8.2.
106
Ilkjaer 1990: 5359, 7984; , 1999: 255; .
2006: 121, 156.
107
, 1999: 256.
108
, 1999: 255256. . 4.1; . 2006: 121,
. 7.6.
109
, 1999: 255.
110
Glad 2013: 637638, Pl. 73.1,3,13,15; 74.14.
111
. 2006: 156.
51
5
6
7
8
9
12
11
100
101
13
14
16
10
15
17
18
52
, . ,
, , ,
,
. ,
112, , , - .
, ,
(. 9.12), I/2 (260/270330/340 .) 113. , IV .
, 114.
I/2 (260/270330/340 .)
(. 9.9)115, 116. 46 -117 184 -1118.
III/58 (380/400440/450 .)
,
. , ,
IAA (. 10.22) 78 -1119. ,
, .
, ,
- ,
.
. 2009: 78.
1999; Kazanski, Mastykova 2007: 4647.
114
1999: 173; Boye, Lund Hansen 2013: 5764.
115
, 1997: 15, . 24.17.
116
. : , 1989.
117
, 1979: . 7.9.
118
2003: . 87.17.
119
2003: . 38.10; Kazanski, Mastykova 2007: 35.
... ...
53
4
6
112
113
7
8
54
(. 9.3),
, , 120.
- (. 9.6), ,
186 -1121. II,
.. 320/330400/410 . ,
, . ,
, -
.
C2D2 ,
, , , , D2/D3, 260/270460/470 .122
,
,
, . , ,
, , (IV. 9).
,
- . I/2, .. 260/270330/349 ., . ,
.. 123,
,
124. , III .
125.
III (380/400
2004.
2003: . 91.21.
122
Schuster 2011.
123
1969; 2006: 314.
124
Kazanski, Mastykova 2007: 910.
125
: Kazanski 1991.
... ...
55
2
10
11
3
4
14
13
12
15
16
21
18
17
19
20
23
22
24
26
25
28
27
120
121
29
30
56
440/450 ). , , IV V . , ,
, 126,
127. ,
- ,
- . ,
395 . - .
Summary
German Elements in Material Culture of Abkhazia
in the Late Roman Time and Great Migration Period
by M.M.Kazanski (Paris)
For late Roman time archaeologists note the emergence in the material
culture of Abkhazia some German elements and connect this fact with
the expansion of the Germans. It is believed that the German influence is
evident in the armor, suit and funeral rites of ancient Abkhazian population.
Some of these features are not relevant to the Germans, as they are known
on the Black Sea coast of the Caucasus before the arrival of the Germans.
It concerns the cremation rite, known in the West Caucasus already in the
early Iron Age. The custom of ritual burial weapon damage is also well
known among the population of the Black Sea coast of the Caucasus
already in III centuries. That probably goes back to the North Caucasian
burial traditions of the early Iron Age. Some types of weapons taken for
German, distributed among different peoples. In reality, no doubt to the
German traits in the material culture of the Roman period of Abkhazia and
the Great Migration period include certain types of umbo and handles of
shields and certain types of spears. Also German in origin are some metal
and amber pendants female attire. Later appear discoid amber beads with
threaded linear decoration, for the same time is awarded only one find of
German brooches. No other specific features of German culture in Abkhazia
have been detected, and the weapons and ornaments German appearance
2011.
Kazanski, Mastykova 2007: 31.
126
127
... ...
57
1993 ..
(III . .. IV . ..). , 1993.
1980 .. // /
.. (.). ., 1980. . 92113.
, 1989 .., ..
- // .
1989. 3. . 163171.
, 1980 .., ..
. , 1980.
, 1999 .., ..
: // / .. ().
, 1999. . 252276.
2003 .. : 19771986 . , 2003.
2006 .. // ..
. , 2006. . I. . 12292.
2009 .. // .. . , 2009. . II. . 365430.
2010 .. // .. . , 2010. . III. . 5140.
, 1982 .., .. IVVII . //
VVIII / . . .., .., 1982. . 121165.
, 1973 .., ..
// . 1973. 1. . 171191.
, 1979 .., ..
(IIIV . ..) // . 1979. 1.
. 181198.
, 2003 .., ..
IIIIV // , -
, IVXIII / .. (.). ., 2003. . 187191.
, 1997 .., .. ( ). M., 1997.
1978 .. .
T, 1978.
1979 ..
. //
58
. 1979. 4. . 212229.
1994 ..
( IV V .). ., 1994.
1988 . IIVIII . , 1988.
2006 .. -
e // /
. (.). , 2006. . 2641.
2008 .. O //
. 1 / .. (.). ,
2008. . 304325.
2011 .. (VI
VII .) // Stratum Plus. 2011. 5. . 4350.
2011 .. V .
// : ( 70- ..) /
.. (.). , 2011. . 146152.
2012 .. //
Stratum Plus. 2012. 5. . 111124.
, 2009 .., ..
(IIVII .) // . . . . . 2009. . 11, 9 (64). . 2531.
, 2011 .., ..
: (IIVII .) //
: 2- . . .
. .. / .. (.). , 2011. . 102116.
, 2013 .., .. //
/ .., .., .. (.).
.; ., 2013. . 97112.
1991 .. // / .. (.). , 1991. . 5860.
, 1992 .., ..
( ) // . 1992. . 2. . 113126.
1969 .. // . 1969. 2.
. 7593.
2001 . . . Lublin, 2001.
2008 - : ( ) / .. (. .). ., 2008.
1999 .. -
// / .. (.). , 1999.
... ...
59
. 171202.
2004 ..
// . 2004. 3. . 5567.
2009 .. IV VI . .. ., 2009.
. 2006 - /
.., .., .., .. ., 2006.
2008 .. I
// - . .,
2008. . 8. . 642643.
1971 .. . T, 1971. . 3: .
1975 .. . , 1975. . 4: .
2011 ..
// :
VII . . . / .., .., . (.). , 2011. . 217233.
Birch Iversen 2010 Birch Iversen R. Kragehul Mose: Ein Kriegerbeuteopfer
auf Sdwestfnen. Moesegrd, 2010.
Bishop, Coulston 1993 Bishop M.C., Coulston C.N. Roman Military
Equipment. L., 1993.
Bhme 1974 Bhme H.W. Germanische Grabfunde des 4. bis 5. Jahrhunderts
zwischen unterer Elbe und Loire. Mnchen, 1974.
Boye, Lund Hansen 2013 Boye L., Lund Hansen U. Glass and Amber Beads
in Late Roman Age: Relations between Danemark and the Black Sea Area with
Special focus on the Graves from Eastern Zealand // Inter Ambo Maria: Northern
Barbarians from Scandinavia towards the Black Sea / Khrapunov I., Stylegar F.-A.
(eds.). Kristiansand; Simferopol, 2013. P. 4068.
Glad 2013 Glad D. Larmement dans la rgion balkanique lpoque
romaine tardive et proto-byzantine (284641). Hritage, adaptation et innovation:
. , - -1- 25.10.2013 .
Hbener 1989 Hbener W. ber merowingerzeitliche Schildbuckel // Acta
Praehistorica et Archaeologica. 1989. Bd. 21. S. 8597.
Ilkjaer 1990 Ilkjaer J. Illerup Adal 1: Die Lancen und Speere. Aarhus, 1990.
Istvnovits, Kulcsr 1995 Istvnovits, E., Kulcsr, V. Szlfegyverek s
jak a Duntl keletre fekv krpt-medencei szarmata Barbaricumban // Altum
Castrum. 1995. 4. 932 old.
Kazanski 1988 Kazanski M. Quelques parallles entre larmement en Occident et Byzance (IVeVIIe s.) // Gaule mrovingienne et monde mditerranen:
Les derniers Romains en Septimanie, IVeVIIIe sicles / Landes C. (dir.). Lattes,
1988. P. 7587.
Kazanski 1991 Kazanski M. Contribution lhistoire de la dfense de la
frontire pontique au Bas-Empire // Travaux et Mmoires. 1991. 11. P. 487526.
Kazanski 1994 Kazanski M. Les perons, les umbo, les manipules de
boucliers et les haches de lpoque romaine tardive dans la rgion pontique
origine et diffusion // Beitrge zu rmischer und barbarischer Bewaffnung in den
ersten fier nachchirstlichen Jahrhunderten / C. von Carnap-Bornheim (Hrsg.).
60
.., ..
,
, . ,
,
, , , .
.
.
, , ( ) . , , 1. , , ,
2. , , , , 3, .
14-01-00006.
1
., : Stronach 1985: 605628.
2
., : Shenkar 2007: 169194. .:
1994: 128139.
.
3
., : , 2002: 154160; Betts, Yagodin
2007: 435454.
*
64
.., ...
65
, ,
. ,
. ..,
( -1, -21, ),
4.
, ..
5. , , ,
, ,
.., .
. , . ,
, I ..6
, ..
, 7. , 2500 1500 . ..,
2500/24001700 . .. , 17001500 .
.. 8. .. 9 1000 . ..,
10.
, , ,
, 500 ( )
, .
,
.
( )11, , -12, -
( ), XIVXIII . ..13
. ,
, , , -14
15.
.
, , ,
,
16. , vedi.
, 17. pavi.
,
. , 18.
, .,
4
., : 1986; 1989: 152169; 1990; 1990: 161167;
1993; 2005; 2008; 2010; Sarianidi 1986: 520; 1994: 388397; 1998a; 1998b;
2002. , . .: , - 1989: 174.
5
.
.. ( 1989: 152169)
,
. .: 1989: 170171; ,
1989: 171174; , - 1989: 174177;
1989: 177179; 1989: 179181.
6
Francfort 2005b: 293.
7
-
, . .-. . .: Francfort 2005b: 253.
8
Francfort 2005b: 258262.
.. ( 1998: 144145).
9
.-. -
, .. . .: Francfort
2005b: 277.
10
, . (Shenkar 2007: 169)
.
11
, 1983; Askarov, Shirinov 1994: 1326.
12
1989: 645.
. (Bernard 1991: 160164) , , ,
13001000 . ..,
.
, .
13
Helms et al. 2000: 344.
14
- .: Gnoli 2004: 97100.
15
.: Boyce 1975a.
16
Boyce 1975a: 165166.
17
Oldenberg 1894: 341343; Gonda 1960: 141.
18
Boyce 1975b: 455.
66
.., ...
67
IV . ..19 .,
, ,
20. .. ..21.
,
I ..,
(
) . ,
, .
. , , ,
.
,
, .
- 22 (. 1).
, , 750 . .. VI . ..23
(
30 ) ,
( , , ),
(12 4 ), ,
( 11 7 , 8 )
( 24) , , ,
. (
40 25 13 ).
, , .
, , Boyce 1975a: 167.
Nyberg 1966: 369.
21
, 1980: 327.
22
Stronach 1968; Roaf, Stronach 1973: 129140; 2007; Curtis 1984;
Schippmann 1971: 474475.
23
, ., ( )
. .: Curtis 2005: 237.
24
Garrison 1999: 614.
19
20
. 1. . -
, , ,
.
,
daivadna, , 25.
, , , .
, , ,
26.
.
, , -, 27,
. , ,
, . 28,
, ,
. . .: Stronach 1977:
697698.
26
Azarnoush 1987: 391401.
27
Stronach 2003: 238; Shenkar 2007: 172.
28
Boyce 1982: 21; Radner 2003a: 64.
25
68
29 ( ) ,
.
. , II 30 , , , , , (FHG II. 568569. Fr. 16)31.
,
,
32. ,
II (Plut. Art. XXVII)33. ,
III , , , 34.
, ,
, .
, , ,
( ) .
:
, :
(iJerav), , ,
(Arr. VI. 27. 4). .
: ,
(sacris) (Curt. X. 1. 3). , , .
,
, .
, - , Radner 2003b: 119131; Shenkar 2007: 172.
( ).
.. .: Boyce 1982: 217.
31
. .: , 1980: 313.
32
Ghirshman 1976: 186.
33
II
, .
.: 1969: 49. C. : Boyce 1982: 220.
34
Pol. X. 27. 12 o{ te na aujto; oJ t Ai[nh.
. .: Walbank 1967: 235.
4 . .: Boyce 1982: 218219.
29
30
.., ...
69
,
. , ,
.
, , ,
, .
,
35. 700 . ..
,
.
VI . .. ,
, .
,
. :
1. , []
( ).
, , , , ,
(
), .
(
) .
, , ,
(Herod. I. 131). 2. . , ,
.
,
,
. , .
(Herod. I. 132) 36.
, , , , ,
37. ,
,
Shenkar 2007: 172.
... . : Benveniste 1929: 23.
37
Benveniste 1929: 5051.
35
36
70
: , (
, ) (Strab. XV.
3. 13)38.
, . , , ,
, , ,
.
, , ,
(Cic. De Republica III. 9. 14). ,
, . ,
, :
( ...
). : . ,
( ,
, ,
) (Strab. XV. 3. 15).
,
( ), 39. : - ,
, ,
, , ( )
(Strab. XI. 8. 4). ,
, ,
40.
, , ,
( ) , . ... . : Benveniste 1929: 51.
VI . .. .: Yamamoto 1979: 27.
40
.: Yamamoto 1979: 28.
38
39
.., ...
71
. , ,
. , , , ( <>
, <> ). , (Plut. Art. III). (Plut.
Art. XXIII). .,
, , 41.
,
, ( ) . ,
,
..,
,
, , : 1)
, 2) , , 3) . , , 42,
, .
, .
. ,
43.
. , , I ayadana, (DB. I. 6364)44.
, 45. Boyce 1982: 220.
, 1980: 331.
43
Cameron 1959: 470476; Kent 1956: 150157; ,
1980: 336. daivadna.
44
.: 1963: 263. ..
.
45
, , 41
42
72
.., ...
73
. 2. . . .
. , ,
.. ..
,
46, ,
.47. ,
, - ,
.
, . , ,
48. , , ,
,
, , , . (. ).
46
, 1980: 334337. .:
2002: 164165.
47
Boyce 1982: 8889.
48
(fire altar) , , (), .
, , , , , , . .: Garrison 1999: 613.
. : Genito 1982: 195245.
. 3. . . .
. .
(plinths) 2 (. 2), . 7
(. 3). 49.
, ayadana, 50. 51.
. ,
, 52.
,
49
Boyce 1975b: 456; Stronach 1966: 217227; Godard 1938: 6772; , 1980: 327328; Stronach 1978; 1985: 606608. Fig. 2. Pl. XXXVIa;
Garrison 1999: 615; Yamamoto 1979: 2830. , ,
. . . .: Bucharlat 2005: 228.
50
Stronach 1985: 606.
51
Stronach 1978: 141142; Garrison 1999: 615.
52
, 1980: 328; Yamamoto 1979: 3031.
74
.53.
, , .
. .. (. 4).
, . . ,
().
. 4. . . .
: .. (1987, ) . (1985, )
.
II,
, ,
54.
, .,
.: 1990: 4558; , 2000: 226240. .
: Schippman 1971: 178180; Stronach 1985: 650652; Francovitch 1966:
207208.
54
Boyce 1982: 222225.
53
.., ...
75
II 55.
, - ,
,
56.
,
, , . .
,
.
57. ,
,
(Curt. X. 1. 3).
,
, 58.
, , .
. III. 187 . .., ,
, (Strab. XVI. 1. 18).
,
, . , ,
(Diod. XXIX. 15), (Diod. XXVII. 3). ,
, ,
(Iust. XXXII. 2. 12).
55
Stronach 1985: 645. ..
V IV . .. ( 1990: 56).
56
.: Boyce 1975b: 457; Shenkar 2007: 177.
.
57
, ,
(Plin. NH. VI. 135). C.:
1989: 29.
58
.: 1989: 4044.
76
IV. . .
, . ,
. , , .
. ,
.
, ,
.
. ,
: - - 59.
, . -
,
. . .,
. , ,
, .. .
. . ,
. , ,
.
-
. . (
) .
( )
. , ,
- .
, .,
. , ., ,
. ,
60.
Ghirshman 1976. ,
.
60
Hansman 1985: 229246.
59
.., ...
77
., ,
600 . ..61
C , ,
62.
, .63. .
, , () (. 5). ,
, II.
.. , , :
1) , 2)
- .
. ( ) 4 , 64 (. 6). - , . -
, .
, 65.
( )
, , --66. Stronach 1974: 239248.
.: , 1980: 328.
63
Dieulafoy 1893: 411412. . : Schmidt 1953: 33; Schippmann 1971:
266269, 474475; 1991: 152154; Yamamoto 1979: 37; ,
2000: 210216.
64
. . ,
.
65
, .
(Schippmann 1971: 266274, 474475) , .
66
Scerrato 1962: 186197; 1966: 930; 1974: 101112; Genito 1986:
287317; Genito 1990: 587604; Mac Dowall, Taddei 1978: 215; Bucharlat 2005:
268269; Shenkar 2007: 175.
61
62
78
. 5. . . .
. 6. . . .
, , ,
.
(. 78).
(54,3 52,2 ) , , (
).
.
, , ,
, , 67 (. 9).
. .
,
.
(. 10). . ,
- 68.
67
:
. ,
- , .
68
Stronach 1985: 608; Gnoli 1993: 584. ,
10 ( I II). .: 1977: 121126.
.., ...
. 7. . - .
79
. 8. . - . .
VI V . .., .
100150 69. , ,
.
,
, 70. . , 71. ,
. . ,
72.
,
: ,
, ., , -
(Garrison 1999: 615).
69
Gnoli 1993: 582583. . Stronach 1985: 610.
70
., , Schippmann 1971: 5057; Boyce 1975b: 458.
, , ..
. (Mac Dowall, Taddei 1978: 215)
(, ).
71
Boyce 1982: 130.
72
Shenkar 2007: 175.
80
.., ...
81
. 11. . - . . .
. 9. . - . .
73. , .
- 74. , .
(. 11).
. ., 60- XX .,
, 75,
, , , , .
76, .., Gnoli 1993: 585.
Gullini 1964; Schippmann 1971: 57; 1991: 152154;
, 2000: 216226.
75
Gullini 1964: 257, Tav. V.
76
., : Stronach 1985: 618619.
73
74
. 10. . - .
82
. 12. . - 2. .
, ,
77. , .
.
.
. --2 IV . ..,
, 78. , 1987: 4964. : Schippmann
1971: 474475.
78
.: 2004.
.., ...
83
, ,
- , .
,
(. 12). ,
24 . .
, .
. ,
. , ,
, .
, ,
, , .
.
, ,
. , , .
. ,
.
--379. , . ,
(. 13).
23 , 19 .
, . ,
. , ,
,
. .. ,
- , .
, ,
--80. IV . ..
IV . .. ,
.
.
77
2004: 243247.
, 1967.
79
80
84
.., ...
85
. 14. . --.
. 13. . --3. .
(. 14). 42 . , . , . . , 15
(. 15).
: ,
, -
86
. 15. . --.
, , ,
,
, , , , 81.
: [.. . .., ..], , -,
;
, , 82.
, , , , 83.
, , ,
84, , - 85. , 1967: 40.
, 1967: 310311. ,
.
83
, .-. (Francfort 2005a: 335), - .
84
(Betts, Yagodin
2007: 438) ,
.
85
Helms, Yagodin 1997: 4364; Helms et al. 2001: 119144; Helms et al.
2000: 344; Betts, Yagodin 2007: 435454. . : Shenkar 2007: 175176.
81
82
.., ...
87
, ,
86.
(110 , 3050 ), , .
. , .
, ,
, , . .
, , , 87.
, , .
() -88. , , VII . .. , .
, ,
89. 20
. ( 1) , ,
.
10. , ,
, , .
( ).
, .
-90. , , .
, .
Helms et al. 2000: 67.
Shenkar 2007: 176.
88
1997: 150172.
89
1997: 155.
90
1948: 9598; , , 1985: 334.
86
87
88
.., ...
89
.
. , C..
(-) 91. , . 92, ..
.
-. ,
, . ,
. 93.
- 94. , , 95.
.
. , , , -96. .
,
,
(. 16). , ,
.
.
.
. , .., , ( 1 6).
. , - 1948: 98.
Shenkar 2007: 169194.
93
, , 1985: 334335.
94
Shenkar 2007: 178.
95
.: , 1958: 347366.
96
1977: 116121.
91
92
. 16. . -. .
, .
DAFA
.
, 97.
, , , . , .-.98 -
97
98
90
, ..99.
, , . , - .
-100.
, , , . ( 600500 .
..)101 ( 7),
. ,
,
102. , , ( 17) ( 500400 . ..), ,
103.
, , - 104,
,
.
.., ...
. 17. . -.
.
91
. 18. . . .
.
, (. 17).
-106.
. ( )
, .
-107 : , IV . .., ,
(. 18).
, . .
, ,
: , - -105.
: ,
VI . .., ( II) , , , ,
. , ,
. . . , .
- .
, .
, 108. ,
IVIII . .. . .
1982: 3040.
, 1979; , 1985: 187192,
. LXIX.
101
.: , 1985: 187.
102
, 1979: 2427.
103
, 1985: 187192. . LXIX.
104
Francfort 2005a: 334.
105
, 2013: 4951. . : Rapin 2001: 3536.
99
100
106
92
, , ,
.
, , ,
, . , ,
( ) . , ,
, . ,
, . ,
. , ,
. . ,
, .
, , ,
(, ) .
II . . ,
,
, .
.
,
. , ,
, . ,
. (- ),
.
.
-
.., ...
93
., II
.
,
,
. ( ) . , ,
. , .
.
.
. ()
. , ., :
,
109.
, , .
: , ,
, ..
, .
. , , , ,
:
, , ,
( , Strab. XV.
3. 16). ,
,
110. , ,
:
[] .
,
.
109
110
94
Summary
Early Sacral Architecture of Iranian Peoples
by G.A.Koshelenko, V.A.Gaibov (Moscow)
Considerable attention is paid to the problems of early sacral
architecture of Iranian peoples in contemporary literature. However we
observe lack of serious progress in investigation of this problem. This can
be explained by two typical mis-approaches in solving this problem: 1) by
the desire to build all the monuments from the most ancient times to the
beginning of Islam into a uniform scheme; 2) by the absence of interest to
the peculiarities of sacral architecture. Having considered all the available
material, authors came to the following conclusions: 1) Herodotus fixed
the end of traditional system of cult, 2) complication of the structure of
the society, that of its culture required modernization of organization of
religious life of all Iranian peoples, 3) such modernization was displayed
in creation of monumental platforms, which imitated raised places,
described by Herodotus, 4) the earliest temples appear in Media, as in the
most developed country, however this tendency to create new temples
can be seen everywhere, especially bright example of local school of sacral
architecture is given by Khorezm, 5) religious reform of Artaxerxes II
resulted not only in appearance of anthropomorphic images of gods, but
also in creation of imperial type of temple, which we know in Persepolis,
Susa and Kukh-i Khoja.
.., ...
95
1963 .. (VI .
..). ., 1963.
, 1980 .., ..
. ., 1980.
, - 1989 .., - ..
? // . 1989. 1. . 174177.
1989 .. ? //
. 1989. 1. . 177179.
, 2000 .., .. ( ). I: . .
. ., 2000.
1989 .. - . .,
1989.
1987 ..
// / . 1987. . 12.
. 4964.
1990 .. . , ,
// /
. 1990. . 16. . 4558.
1991 .. . . ., 1991.
1989 .. -21 // . 1989. 1. . 179181.
1998 .. //
. . I: / ..,
.. (.). , 1998. . 124200.
1994 . //
. 1994. 4. . 128139.
, 1958 .., .. - // / - /
.. (.). . II: 19491953 / .., .. (.). ., 1958.
. 347366.
, 2013 ., .
:
//
: ,
. ; , 2013. . 4258.
1977 .. :
- . ., 1977.
1986 .. // .
., 1986. 188. . 8391.
1989 .. // . 1989. 1. . 152169.
1989 .. . ., 1989.
1990 .. . , 1990.
96
.., ...
97
98
.., ...
99
..
,
, .
, .
, ,
.
.., III ..
- , ,
- 1.
, , . ,
, . ,
,
. ,
, -2. ,
, -, -, Sarianindi, 2005; Sarianidi, 2008.
Berdimuhamedow 2011: 112.
1
2
...
101
VIIIV ..3
..4. .. .. (. 1).
( V . ..), .. 1949 .5
, 6.
. , -I ,
. ,
, , 7.
.
, ,
.
. , .
,
, . ,
, , , , , .
, , ,
. .
,
. Berdimuhamedow 2011: 113.
Sarianidi, Dubowa 2013: 116117.
5
1951: 115.
6
Berdimuhamedow 2011: 116.
7
Berdimuhamedow 2011: 113.
3
4
102
...
103
. ,
, ().
().
(. 2).
, , ,
, , , .
.
, .
. 1.
3230, -. [: Sarianidi, Dubowa 2013: 116]
, , ,
, . (),
. -
. 2. .
104
, ,
. , .
. ,
. , .
, . -, ,
,
, .
. , 8. , , , ,
, ,
.
, .
( .. ..), 9.
, . , (, ), , .
,
, , .
(, , , , , ,
.), -
8
. : 1908; 1970; 1993; 1997: 4155.
9
1945; 1966; , , 1976;
1993.
...
105
.
, , , , . ,
, :
,
, ,
,
.
, , , ,
. , , , , , .
.
XIX . ( 18901896 .)
, . 1917 .
, 1933 .
.
, ,
, , .
, , .
(
); - (Delphinium semibarbatum), ;
, ; . . ,
, ,
, , ,
, (. 3).
, , , , ,
.
, , .
-
106
:
1) ,
2) ,
3)
,
4) .
.
,
.
, ..
,
.
, . 3. .
, .
, , .
.
, - ()
. , 1:10, 80. : , 1% 1% .
.
.
...
107
:
. 1 , 30 .,
18 .
. ,
1:6 ( 1:10,
), .
:
1) ,
2) ,
3) , .. , ,
4) ( ) , ,
5) (, ,
) .
, ,
10.
, ,
,
, .
,
, . , ,
.
, , , , . :
, !11.
1944.
Berdimuhamedow 2011: 166.
10
11
108
Summary
Ancient Traditions of Fabrics Coloring in Turkmenistan
by Z.D.Nurmamedova (Ashgabat)
Traditions of natural dyeing are being carefully preserved in Turkmenistan for centuries. Archaeological material suggests not only the existence
of carpets in the territory of our country in the Eneolithic Period already, but
also proposes their main color spectrum, according to the remains of polychromatic mosaics in Anau, Gonur-depe etc. Natural dyes, which are being in
use for centuries in Turkmenistan, preserve their potential in modern epoch.
As it was shown on the example of carpet yarn, natural dyes proved their
high quality, and their use presents a good opportunity in future development
of textile. For this purpose author not only carefully studies the traditional
methods of dyeing, but also try to improve them and methods of extraction of
pigments experimentally. Study of the ancient origins of natural dyes shows
us how past is connected with future, and tradition with innovation.
:
Berdimuhamedow 2011 BERDIMUHAMEDOW Gurbanguly. Janly rowaat.
Agabat, 2011.
, , 1976 .., .., .. . , 1976.
1966 ..
. , 1966.
1993 .
. , 1993.
1997 ..
(1908, 1909, 1910) // . 1997. 12. . 4155.
1970 .. I
. 19291945 . , 1970.
1951 .. // . ., . 1951. . XXXVII.
C. 106116.
1908 .. . ., 1908.
1945 .. // . 1945. 34. . 123127.
1945 .. //
. 1944. 5. . 60116.
Sarianidi 2005 Sarianidi W. Gourdepe Trkmenistan: alary we hudalary heri. Agabat, 2005.
Sarianidi 2008 Sarianidi W. Margu Trkmenistan: Beik medinieti syrlar
dnsi we onu hakyky kebi. Agabat, 2008.
Sarianidi, Dubowa 2013 Sarianidi W., Dubowa N. Gadymy Margianany
genji-hazynasy: Fotoalbom. Agabat, 2013.
..
IV II . .. -
,
335 . ..
, , ,
. , , .2. 3. ,
,
( , ), .
.
IVII .
.., . 375 . .. , ,
,
(Plut. Pelop. 1617). , , , .. ,
, . 362 . ..
,
(Front. Strat. II. 1. 12; Polyaen. II. 3. 14),
Alexander von Humboldt-Stiftung.
Roesch 1979: 243251; tienne, Roesch: 359374.
3
, .: Krke 1878: 301422; Schild-Xenidou 1972; Heimberg
1973: 1536; 2000: 848892.
1
2
112
..
. 335 . ..
.
(Diod. XVII. 11. 2), ,
,
. ,
, ,
, , (Arr. Anab. I. 7. 8). ,
, ,
.
-, ,
. ,
.
, ,
. , (Diod. XVII.
12. 5; Arr. Anab. I. 8. 7). , , , .
, (Anab. II. 7. 8). , , 330 329 . .. 23 , ,
(IG. VII. 3206)4. ,
, - ,
, , .
, ,
, , , , , (ll. 13, 15), (IG. VII.
2716. l.1) (IG. VII. 2781. l.4), ,
, 5.
Foucart 1879: 452459.
5
Gelder 1901: 283286; 1914: 251, . 1.
4
...
113
313 . ..
5000 500 ,
, 2200 1300 (Diod. XIX. 77. 4). (
)6,
, . ,
,
,
. , , , ,
, V . .. (Hell. Oxyr. 11. 34).
(1:1,7)
,
.
, 279 . ..,
10000
500 (Paus. X. 20. 3),
.
, ,
(1:20) . ,
, - . ,
, ,
(Paus. X. 21. 2).
227 . .. ,
, (Polyb.
XX. 5. 78). , , ,
.
,
.
6
Bizire 1975: 108, ad l.17.
.: Beloch 1906: 48, Anm. 1.
114
, 223 . ..
III 2000 200 (Polyb. II. 65. 4).
1:10
. , .
171 . ..
,
. , 146 . .. ,
(Paus. II. 1. 2; VII. 14. 7, 16. 910; Oros. V. 3. 2).
, , ,
. (11. 4) , VIV .
.. 1100 ,
900 , 408 . .. (Diod.
XIII. 72. 4).
(.: Front. Strat. II. 2. 12; IV. 7. 21; Diod.
XV. 52. 3, 68. 1, 71. 3, 94. 2; XVI. 39. 2; Plut. Pelop. 27. 3, 35. 1; Polyaen.
II. 3. 14). (11. 4), , , , ,
. ,
, , . , (IV.
96. 5) teh7.
, , , , , , .
(Diod. XV. 85. 2, 86. 1),
. , ,
, .
7
...
115
116
...
117
12
10
13
118
...
119
, , ,
(. 1)18. -
, -
-
, ,
. V IV .
.. , -, .
, .
(. 2)19. ,
, ,
, , , ,
, , , , . ,
, , , . IV . ..
, , 20.
( 32050) , , ,
, ,
,
(. 3)21, .. , ,
.
( 2027) : , ,
, ,
,
22. ,
Vermeule, Comstock 1972: 85, 9596. Fig. 76.
Homann-Wedeking 1940: 1820, Taf. 19.2; 22.12; Sekunda 1994: 181.
Fig. 200ab.
20
: LIMC. Vol. VI: 2: 715, 602; : Schild-Xenidou
1972: 4546, 50; : Demakopoulou, Konsola 1981: 42. P. 40.
Fig. 7; : 1934: 1920, 35; Schild-Xenidou 1972: 2223,
22; Heimberg 1973: 2226, Taf. 3b.
21
LIMC. Vol. VI, 2: 716, 610.
22
Krke 1878: 371, 123.
18
19
120
. 1. (480470 . ..).
, 99.339. (?)
, , , (: Vermeule, Comstock 1972:
96. Fig. 76)
IV . .., , -, , , (, ) 23. ,
.
, ,
.
, IV . .., 1968: . 16.
23
...
121
, .
,
. S-
, ,
24. .
, (. ), (Strab. IX. 2. 5, 25),
. 2006: 82. . 36b.
24
122
(. 4)25.
,
, ,
; : , 26.
,
, ,
,
,
,
, . 3. ,
.
, , .
.
, ,
, 32050 (: LIMC. Vol. VI,
2. P. 716, 610)
,
(Jos. Bel. Jud. III. 5. 5 (96)),
27.
, , , .
, ,
, .
Krke 1878: 361375, 95133; Ridder 1922: 268269; 1934:
5051, 178194; 2000: 848892
26
, III . .., .: Krke 1878: 365, 107;
1971: 221, . 192.
27
Head 1982: 100.
25
...
123
,
.
,
.
,
, ,
,
(ID. 1417.
Face A. Col. 1. l.35)28.
,
. .
,
, . 4. - .
,
, - , .
, 182
. - (: Ridder 1922: 270. Fig. 40)
, .
,
29. , .
Nefedkin 2009: 356366.
Roesch 1979: 247248.
28
29
124
, .. , . , ,
, , . , , (Thuc. II. 22. 2).
:
/ , , . , ,
,
, 30. ,
III . ..
, ,
, - .
Summary
Boeotian Cavalry of Hellenistic Epoch
by A.K.Nefedkin (St. Petersburg)
The military organization of the Boeotian league was typical for Greece
in the Hellenistic epoch. Traditionally, the army of the league consisted of
the contingents of the poleis. The local commanders led their troops, in
the cavalry there were ilai. In the Classical epoch, the Boeotian horse was
typical Greek cavalry who fought with the spears in distant and close battle.
In great field battles, the foot hamippoi fought beside their cavalrymen.
In the Hellenistic period, the cavalry armament changed, i.e. the Boeotian
horsemen got long butted lances and shields. This armament meant the
military reform according to Macedonian pattern in the second half of the
3rd century BC. This cavalry usually fought in close combat.
30
...
125
126
..
- 1
( )
. ,
,
. ,
,
, .
. /
, . ,
, , ,
, ,
. , VI . .., . ()
. () .
-
,
,
,
2.
,
, 12-01-00122
12-01-0011 .
2
1999: 217; Saprykin 1999: 3141.
1
128
, ,
.
.
(-)
,
-
.
, ,
, ,
,
, ,
. , , .
, , . ,
, ,
,
, , IV . .. 3. (IosPE I. 35)
(IosPE I. 352) , .
(
) . , , ,
- ,
.
.
-
,
III . .. (. 1). .., ,
, .., . 4:
3
4
2013: 119126.
.. 1968 . .: 1984: 77, 348.
... -
129
. 1. .
iJ i; [......]
i; [............] u` uj[]u`
:
1. . 1 uj[]
2. [] o; [..........]
3. . 23 iJ i; [.............. ]
4. a; [ujh`? ] :u~5. [ujh~? i[]
: ! (...)!
(), ? ,
? .
[] [] () .
, , - , .
, , , - . , , ,
5.
5
, 2014: 5065. ,
130
1999 . -, . .
,
(. 2). II .
.. I . ..:
1.
2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. [] 8. [?...]
: , ?().
,
,
, , . , , , ( ,
, -) -
6.
, , . ,
.. , (
), (Plato.
Resp. 341c), , , ,
.
- ,
,
(. LSJ s.v. = ; .
, , ,
).
I . .. - - : () 7.
, .
(IG XII. 8. 585 = SEG XI. 1020)
, ,
().
6
.: , 2014 ( ).
.: 2004: 1617.
7
1970: 5153.
... -
131
. 2.
. -
, . ,
.
- 1989 . ..
.. ,
,
,
- (. 3).
.. :
132
[ ], -
[ ] [ ]
[ ]
[ ]-
[ ][ ]
[ ]
[?] [-
[?] [[? .]
[? .]
- ,
... -
- .
, 8.
...
,
-, . ,
, : [] /[ ]/[
]/[ ] .
9.
. -, ,
, ,
(!) - - . -, , ?
, -,
? , ,
.
, , , , , ..,
, 10.
, , .
, , ,
.
, .
,
,
(. 4). , ,
4 6 .
, 1989: 28; Vinogradov 1997: 498. . : 1996: 139; 2004: 130; 2013: 207.
9
1999: 124125.
10
., : Makarov 2006: 152 [] , , ; Vinogradov, Wrrle 1992: 160 , ,
, .. , .
8
. 3.
. -
133
134
911 . ,
, ,
,
, .. ... - ,
, ,
.
. 4. .
- ( ..)
,
,
. , , ,
,
,
,
. - (Plut. Luc. XII. 2).
... -
135
.. ..,
.11, , , ,
73 . .., ,
(Memn. 38; 40, 2)
.
,
(8986 .
..), , 12.
, 7473 . ..,
. ,
, : , , ,
, .
-, 101 . ..
. ,
.
, , ,
. ,
. , ,
. , , , 70-
..
, . , (LGPN IV. 45).
,
.
. 1
,
. , :
McGing 1986: 146 (note 49).
Olshausen 1974: 166 suiv.
11
12
136
1.
[ ] 2.
[]
3.
[ ]4.
[ ]
5.
[........................]
: ( ) ().
, -.
, , . II . .. I . .., .
,
I . .. (LGPN IV. 273), (LGPN II. 361),
(LGPN III.A. 353), , , (LGPN
V.A. 358), . , . ,
, , - .
, :
, , , . ,
, - , .
, , , ,
. ,
... -
137
, ,
, , . -
II . ..
(. 5): [][] [...], .. (). , - ,
, , ( IosPE I. 142
).
1 , - : ?[.../...]
<> [ ()] / () [] / [](?) (. 6)13.
,
, , [?], ..
14. ,
> .
. 6. .
. 5. .
138
, ,
. , ,
, - 15, . ,
- , ,
. , , - ,
,
.
, , 1986 . .
V . .., ,
, , (. 7; .
)16. ,
. , , , , , .
,
, . :
[...] [?...]
[...] [ ........]
: , ? (...) ().
[...] -,
[] = . [] [] , , , , ,
( , ). [] , , , .
kalos-name inscriptions,
, .
, .
1992: 73; 2005: 477.
..
.
15
... -
139
, , 17.
, , ( ), [] = . [] .
- ,
, .
.
I . .., (De adm. imp. 53. 239 ff.) (LGPN
IV. 83). , , I . ..
(IKalch. 65 = LGPN V.A. 114) ,
, . ,
, .
,
. , .
,
( ,
). , .
, , .
, . , ,
, , , () (),
.
, .
, , (IosPE I. 364)
16
17
140
, , , (IosPE I. 365),
, , ,
18.
, , , ,
,
, . IV . .. (Demosth. Adv. Lacr. 10, 20, 3234)
,
, .
, ,
. III . ..
, , , , /,
,
, .
, , , 19. (Syll. 584)
, (Syll. 604)
, . , II .
.. ,
, , . ,
. 175 . .., , (IG II. 903), . , ,
. , ,
1999: 217229; 2002: 7284; 2013: 119126; Saprykin 1999:
3141.
19
1939: 247, 12; Saprykin 2014: 355358.
... -
141
,
. , ,
,
(IosPE I. 332). , , , , ,
- ,
.
,
. , , ,
, , - .
VI IV . .. (ALG.
Archil. Fr. 79; Xen. Anab. VII. 5. 12; Strabo. VII. 6.1).
, , . III .
.. ,
.
, I (IGBulg I. 307).
.
-, - . , ,
(Herod.
IV. 103; Strabo. VII. 4. 2; Mela II. 11; Diod. III. 43. 5; Amm. Marc. XXII.
8. 33). 20. ,
, , ,
. ,
, ,
18
20
Rostowtzeff 1941: 676; 1949: 83; 1973: 129;
2004: 8388.
142
... -
143
,
,
(Steph. Byz. s.v.). -
,
.
, ,
( 73),
, ,
(. ).
,
. , (Bell.
Jud. II. 16. 4) 40 ,
I . ..
, ,
, . .
, , ,
, .
,
26.
:
. 193 . .. II
( 1237).
- .
,
-
, - . ,
, .
.
, , , ,
,
. ,
, (Strabo. VII. 4. 1),
.
, , 2002: 74.
26
144
-,
-
, . , , .
.
, -
? -
,
, 27.
,
, , . - , , , .
-
, . 112 . .. , .
, , , .
, ,
, . ,
.
,
. ,
,
. ,
,
,
, -
. , ,
2004: 177190; 2006: 98123.
27
... -
145
, , 28.
Summary
Greek Sailors in the North-West Crimea
by S.Yu. Saprykin (Moscow)
The article is devoted to the analysis of several Greek inscriptions
from the Hellenic settlements in the North-West Crimea. The settlement
of Tchaika gives a fragmentary graffito of the 3rd2nd c. BC which was a
dedication of naucleroi and sailors or to a God whose
name remained unknown as this part of the inscription is lost. The gift was
made for lucky sailing and return to native harbour. Two other dedicative
inscriptions were discovered on the settlement of Kara-Tobe near the
modern town of Saki. They are dated to not earlier than the late 3rd2nd c.
BC first half of the AD 1 and were installed by seamen, headed by
kybernetai and captains. The first inscription was a gift to an unknown deity
(the lower part of the stele is lost) by kybernetes Theotimos and seafarers
while the second one was gifted also to an unknown deity (the lower
part of this inscription is also dropped) by sailors , headed by
Parthenopaios and Aristonikos. The latter epigraphical monument had been
earlier wrongly studied and incorrectly estimated as evidence on installing
a military trophy after a victory over the Crimean Scythians, achieved by
the Pontic army of Diophantos and the Chersonesians. But in reality it has
nothing to do with it, being simply an ordinary dedication of seamen.
We have also some Greek graffiti from the sites of South Donuzlav,
Kara-Tobe and Dzhangul 1 on Tarkhankut a sanctuary of a local goddess
Targa =Tarka of the 2nd c. BC, and from Cercinitis. The graffito on amphora
from South-Donuzlav was left by a sailor Konon, the ceramic inscriptions
from Kara-Tobe and Dzhangul 1 mention Achilleus, patron of Pontus,
worshipped probably as Pontarchus and Soter, defender and rescuer of the
Greek sailors. The inscription with a picture from Cercinitis is a letter of
a kybernetes, written to his beloved woman Gykeia. All these inscriptions
were left by Hellenic sailors when they were passing by the western coast
of Taurica either through the seaway along the West and North-West
28
.: 2003: 53. C..
I . .. ( 2007: 158162),
.
- [...],
(, 2014) ( ).
146
coastline of the Black Sea or through the shortest ways from the mouth of
Danube or Tyras rivers directly to Western Crimea or from the South Black
Sea coast to Chersonesus and further on to the North-West Crimea. They
stopped in the vicinity of Tchaika and Kara-Tobe for making dedications
to their divine patrons, probably Achilleus, who, as they thought, helped
them to escape from pirates the Satarchi and Tauri, and to pass happily
all the rocks and shallows on their way to West Taurica Chersonesus
and Bosporus. These stelae were presumably dedicated to the sanctuary on
the Sakskaya Peresyp not far from Kara-Tobe. When this sanctuary was
seriously reconstructed on the turn of our era and at the same time the site
of Kara-Tobe was also greatly rebuilt, these limestone plates were carried
there to be used as secondary building material.
1948 .. // .
1948. 8. . 5678.
1973 .. // .
1973. 3. . 124133.
1989 ..
VII . .. ., 1989.
, 1989 .., ..
- // -
. , 1989. . 2729.
2004 ..
// - / .. (.). , 2004.
. 1219.
2007 .. .: ..
. , 2003 // . 2007. 2. . 158162.
1939 .. // . 1939.
3. . 231315.
1960 .. // . 1960. 1. . 261265.
1970 .. - // . ., 1970. 124. . 5153.
2004 ..
. , 2004.
2004 .. . ,
2004.
2013 .. . , 2013.
2003 ..
. , 2003.
... -
147
148
1999 ..
: // VI .. . ., 1999. . 124125.
Lang 1976 Lang M. Graffiti and Dipinti // The Athenian Agora. Princeton,
1976. XXI.
Makarov 2006 Makarov I.A. Lpitaphe dun commandant des archers de
Chersonse Taurique // ZPE. 2006. 155. P. 150160.
McGing 1986 McGing B. The Foreign Policy of Mithridates VI Eupator,
King of Pontus. Leiden, 1986.
Olshausen 1974 Olshausen E. Zum Hellenisierungsprozess am Pontischen
Knigshof // Ancient Society. 1974. 5. S. 153169.
Rostowtzeff 1941 Rostowtzeff M.I. Social and Economic History of the
Hellenistic World. Oxf., 1941. Vol. II.
Saprykin 1999 Saprykin S. Ju. Proxenic Decrees of Tauric Chersonesus and
Sea-Routes in Pontus Euxeinus // Orbis Terrarum. 1999. 5. . 3141.
Saprykin 2014 Saprykin S.Ju. The Pontic Proxenies and the Sea Routes of
the Ancient Greeks in the Euxine // The International Journal of Maritime History.
2014. 26 (2). P. 353363.
Talcott 1936 Talcott L. Vases and Kalos-Names from an Agora Well //
Hesperia. 1936. 5. P. 348352.
Vinogradov 1997 Vinogradov Ju.G. Pontische Studien. Mainz, 1997.
Vinogradov, Wrrle 1992 Vinogradov Ju.G., Wrrle M. Die Sldner von
Phanagoreia // Chiron. 1992. 22. S. 159170.
..
Scripta Antiqua
: 1,
,
. ,
.
, , , , . , : I. . II. . III. . IV. .
V. . , ,
, ;
, 2.
.
. ,
, 3.
2014: 655714.
2014: 667.
3
2013.
1
2
152
, ; , ; .
-, , , .
( ),
.
, , ,
, . , ,
. , ,
.
, .
,
(, ,
),
. ,
.
,
4.
: ,
.
.
4
: 2013: 1517.
... :
153
,
.
,
. ,
, 5.
, , 6,
( )
. .. 7.
, , , ,
,
, ,
, .
.
3 12 .
. , ( , ) :
8. , ,
19 4566,5 7 ,
7 33,5455,5 6
7,6 ; . , , 9
3 6 .
, ,
2013: 73. . 36; 86. . 48; 2014: 686. . 32; 696. . 41.
1963: 167, 169; 1988: 266; 1990: 199; 2014: 683, 686.
7
1961: 107.
8
2014: 689, 692, 695.
9
.
5
6
154
... :
155
, ,
.
, , ,
, .
, ,
10 .
, ,
;
11. ,
,
. ,
,
, , , .
.
, 12, ,
.
, , , .
1,
, (.1.1)13 , (.1.2).
2014: 711712.
1963: 7477; 89. . 34; 2013: 104.
12
2013: 65101; 2014: 683703.
13
,
10
11
. 1. , , , , . 1
156
... :
157
,
, . ,
, ,
14.
2,
, ,
; ,
(.2.1), (.2.2).
3,
,
(. 3.1). ,
, (.3.12; 4.1; 5.1),
(.5.2),
(.4.12) .
3, (. 3.12; 4.1; 5.12)
, .
,
(. 4.2).
, 3
: ,
(. : 2013: . 2834, 3666; 2014: . 2831, 3444).
; .
, .
.. ().
14
1963: 40, 54; 19881991 .
. 2. , , , , . 2
158
. 3. , , , , . 3, 12
... :
159
. 4. , , , , . 3, 34
160
... :
161
. ,
:
(. 6.2; .
), ;
.
4,
, , (. 7.13).
, .
, 3 ,
(.7.3). 4 : , , ; -,
, (.8.1).
5
: ,
.
(. 8.2).
.
, , ;
, .
. 5. , , , , . 3, 56
6,
, . 4 5 (
) (
) (.9.12).
162
... :
163
,
(.9.1).
(.9.2).
7
: .
, ;
(. 10).
(. 6.1; . ).
, 7, 8 9
.
8,
7
, , ,
, (.11.1). .
2 , ,
, , , (. 11.2).
.
9
, , (. 12.1).
. 7. , , , , . 4, 13
10
. ,
-, - (. 12.2).
.
164
. 8. , , , , . 1. 4, 4. 2. 5
... :
165
. 9. , , , , . 6
166
... :
167
, ,
.
, , , ,
.
, .
11,
,
. , , ,
(.13). ,
: .
12
, ,
,
. -,
(.14).
. 10. , , , , . 7
13
, (. 15). , ()
, ;
, , , .
-,
.
33 : 27
, , .
. ,
, ,
. -
168
. 11. , , , , . 8
... :
169
. 12. , , , , . 1. 9. 2. 10
170
. 13. , , , , . 11
... :
171
;
: , , ;
, , ; , , ; , , ; , , ; , , ; , ; , ;
; ; .
, , ,
, -
,
.
,
-: , (. 1.2;
2.12; 3.1; 4.2; 5.1; 7; 8.2; 9; 1112; 14) ,
(. 1.1; 3.2; 4.1; 5.2; 8.1; 10; 13; 15).
, . ,
:
, , .
, . ,
, , .
,
, ,
-
.
,
:
, , , , , .
, , ,
.
172
. 14. , , , , . 12
... :
173
. 15. , , , , . 13
174
... :
175
-
. ,
, .
, , : 15.
,
.
1 (. 16.1). , 11 ,
4. .
2
,
,
(. 16.2). 7,5 10 5
8,5.
3 :
,
, (.16.3). - , ,
.
7 10 4,5 7,5.
.
4. , ,
, (. 16.4).
4 6 3
5.
. 16. , , , , . 18
; .
15
176
. 17. , , , , . 916
... :
177
5 (. 16.5).
4 6,5 3,5
6.
6. . , ,
. , ,
(. 16.6).
: 8 10,5 ,
4 6,5.
: , .
, .
7. 15 (. 16.7). 88,5 67.
8.
:
(. 16.8). ,
.
8 10 6
8,5.
9 , : (. 17.1).
: 10,
7,5.
10 : -, - (. 17.2). 4 13
3,5 12.
11. , -
178
(. 17.3). 6
14, 5,5 13.
12, ,
, ,
. ,
,
, (. 17.4). ,
9 6. , ;
.
13. 11, :
(. 17.5).
:
5 13
4,5 12.
14 ,
(. 17.6), , .
: 7 12,
6,5 11, 5.
15 16 , , , (. 17.7), ,
(. 17.8).
,
.
,
(. 10.12).
,
,
-.
... :
179
..16 , VIII .
SUMMARY
The Fretted Ganch of Varakhsha: Ornamental Compositions
by T.G.Tsvetkova (Moscow)
This is a continuation of the article The Fretted Ganch of Varakhsha:
Classification and Common Compositional Techniques, published in the
third volume of Scripta Antiqua 2014, in which the author presented
his developed a classification of fretted ganch from the excavations on
Varakhsha near Bukhara (Uzbekistan). The author showed that the walls
of aivan Varakhsha Palace were decorated with the subjects of the kings
garden, and a variety of many ornamental compositions. Among them
were the so-called carpet ornaments, which are considered in detail in
this article.
The carpet of ornaments is called so because of the distance between them and the viewer, all their elements blend into a single background. Most likely, local masters used the data ornaments as internal
and external background that is, both inside the scenes with the image
of the kings garden plots (for example, as the background on which
unfolded scenes of hunting), and on the walls around the garden
paintings as a self-wall panels with one or another variant of geometric
and floral ornament. A large number of these ornamental compositions
show that on the walls of the aivan of the Varakhsha Palace they occupied
a large area.
The article presents thirteen variations of the carpet compositions and
sixteen options edges to them: technical, ornaments, their description, their
differences. The graphic reconstruction, made on the basis of the surviving
fragments fretted ganch, recreates ornaments of panels and edges in their
possible combinations.
1988 .. IXXV .: (- ). .,
1988.
1961: 76.
16
180
1990 ..
: ( ) // . 1990. . 37.
.199208.
1961 .. :
. , 1961.
2013 .. : . , 2013.
2014 .. : // Scripta Antiqua.
, , . 2014. . 3: . .655714.
1963 .. . ., 1963.
..
-
IVIX .
- ,
, IVIX .
, , , (
), , , ,
, , ,
1. ,
IX . 2. IV ., .. , IX .,
, ,
, , , , , , 3. , , .
, , ,
, ,
, ,
, , ( , , ),
VI . , ,
.
, , , , , ,
, , VII .,
1
Berger 1982; Magdalino 1985: 196199; 1991: 181; Decker 2008:
499500; 2009: 302.
2
2009: 302.
3
Berger 1982: 87, 93; Magdalino 1984: 234.
184
,
4. , , . , , (3,35 1 ),
5. ,
, - ..
, .
. , , 500 . , , , VI .6 ,
, , , .
, 7.
, , ,
, 8. , ,
9. , , . ,
. ,
, ,
,
, , , 10.
11. , .: Noret 1982: 151.
Frantz 1988: 119.
6
Koukoules 1951: 419 sq; Foss 2002: 7576, 8384, 8788; 2011: 268.
7
VI. 18, 22 (.: 1996: 261, 263264); Mango 1981: 338339.
8
Festugire 1970: 109 (Vol. 1), 113 (Vol. 2); 2002: 350352.
9
Mundell Mango 2006: 94.
10
, , 2009: 45; 2002: 144; 2009: 302.
11
Koukoules 1951: 425.
4
5
... - IVIX .
185
12, .
, , ,
, , . ,
,
, , ,
, ,
, , , , 13.
. 11 -
691/692 .
, 77
, , ,
, 14. ,
- (11) , , ,
,
, : , , ,
, 15. ,
,
., , ,
, 16. , .
I 866 . , ,
(nullo modo in quarta et sexta feria balneari
debeatis)17. ,
-,
.
,
, , ,
, , , , . , ,
2000: 219.
1992: XVII.
14
1996: 277278, 293.
15
.: , , 2009: 28.
16
2005: 95.
17
, 1954: 48.
12
13
186
IVV ., , , ,
. , ,
, 28
417 ., ,
, (VII. 11. 2)18.
. (. 396 .) ,
, 19,
.. , .
, IVV . ,
. ,
. , , , , ,
, ,
20.
.
,
. , ,
II
, , , , , 21.
,
, ,
, ,
, , , 22.
,
23. 5202 . , I
... - IVIX .
,
24.
I
, 25. . VI .,
, , , 26.
, 27. 588 ., ,
, ..,
,
(VI. 8)28. . , VI VII . - ( ), - 586 597 .
,
29. , ,
. ,
, , VIIVIII ., 30.
,
. , , , , , , .
, , II,
, ,
31. II .
2005: 162.
Dindorf 1831: 423; 2006: 505.
26
Charles 1916: XC; 2006: 565.
27
Charles 1916: XCII; 2006: 569.
28
2006: 396.
29
, , 1995: 114, 72173, 143; 1985: 84.
30
Bakirtzis 2003: 61. Fig. 18.
31
Dindorf 1831: 359.
24
25
2004: 284.
1838: 189.
20
Migne 1862: 581; , , 2009: 55.
21
Dindorf 1831: 363; 2006: 483.
22
Dindorf 1831: 399; 2006: 496.
23
Dindorf 1831: 409; 2006: 501.
18
19
187
188
III IV . , 700 . .,
1,05 ,
VIVII . , , , ,
, 32. , ,
VIII . . 161163 . , ,
, ,
2500 . , ,
, , ,
, XII , 33. - ,
() VIVII . .34
I,
, , 654 . , , 35.
IV, 680 . ,
, ..
, , - , -
36. , ,
.
()37,
()38. VII .
,
1964: 239. . 13.
1965: 18; 1968: 46.
34
McNally 1996: 255. Fig. 23.
35
.: 1991: 56.
36
, , 1995: 276, 279, .
37
de Boor 1904: 729.
38
.: 1920: 6, 234; 11, 225; 15, 464; 24, 504.
32
33
... - IVIX .
189
, . (. 805841 .)
, ,
39, .
(demosion loutron), ,
, VIII IX .40
,
, , . ,
, , , ,
, , , ,
.
, , , ,
, 713 . ,
IX . , ,
41.
, ,
, VIII ., ,
, 42. IX .
-,
. , ,
, , VIIIX .
, , . .
, ,
. , , ,
,
, ,
. , ( VI , (886895 .), ,
Holder-Egger 1878: 362.
van den Gheyn 1899: 213.
41
Mango 1959: 39; Mango 1981: 340
42
Mango 1981: 339; Mango 2004.
39
40
190
,
43).
, . . , VII ., ,
. ,
44. ,
V (741775 .)45.
, -,
III 46. 40- IX . , , , III47. -
VI
, , ,
48.
. , IX .49,
,
,
, VIIX ., ,
XIII .50
. ,
, 1015 .
, ,
Kurtz 1898: 3.
.: , , 2009: 107.
45
. 1884: 258.
46
Bekkerus 1838b: 199. 11 200. 5; Bekkerus 1838a: 660;
(IV. 37; .: 1992: 8586).
47
- 1859: 722.
48
Magdalino 1984: 225240; Magdalino 1987: 97118.
49
Mundell Mango 2006: 85.
50
2005: 196211. . 16.
43
44
... - IVIX .
191
,
VIIVIII . , , , 51.
, ( )
-, , .. 52. , ,
, , ( 16,0 6,75 22), ,
, .
III . , ,
VI IX . , , ,
53. III ,
, (6,8 4 ), , ,
, , ,
, IX .54
.. .,
, , ,
55.
, IX .
, . ,
, 2011: 366367.
.: 2009: 303.
53
2005: 197203. . 1.
54
2005: 205209. . 45.
55
2009: 304.
51
52
192
.
, ,
, . , . ,
, ,
, -, , 56. .
. ,
XXI . , 57.
, , , , ,
? , , , ,
, .
, , ,
.
2011: 269.
.: Falkenhausen 1967: 139.
56
57
... - IVIX .
193
Summary
The Bath-Laundry Business as a Market Service
in Byzantium in the IVIX Centuries
by S.B.Sorochan (Kharkov, Ucraine)
The article reviews the status of laundry and bath business in
Byzantium from late antiquity to the IX century, when the empire became
a typical medieval state with Christian society. The author comes to the
conclusion that in the early Byzantine period laundry business has ceased
its function as a market service industry. But bath business experienced
a complex evolution and had no significant decline after the VI century.
This is contrary to current views about the disappearance of Byzantine
baths and bath attendant profession, stoker baths in the dark ages. Bath
business restructuring took place in a different plane. Because of the
complex reasons the Byzantine capital baths lost their former luxury, large
sizes. In the provinces, they also became smaller. Alongside with enfilade
type baths, another baths were built with the absence of symmetry, where
the main and sometimes the only place caldarium occupied. However,
such facilities took place in the Byzantine city through the centuries.
They stopped being an entertainment centers and became an ordinary
establishments for washing to comply with the hygiene and Christian
piety.
194
, , 1995
. .2: VIIIX . / .., .., .. (.).
.,1995.
1920 ..
. .
, . . .,1920. .1: .
2002 .. . .,
2002.
2005 .. . ., 2005.
2000 ..
. ., 2000. .2.
1996 . / [. . ..]. ., 1996.
2006 . . 16 /
. ., . ., ., ., ... .,
2006.
, 1954 I 866 // ., .
: . , 1954.
.3852.
1991 .. . ., 1991.
1985 VIXII . /
.. (.). ., 1985.
1992 . / .. (.). ., 1992.
1965 . (IIVI .) // . , 1965. .7. .3. .324.
1968 . // . , 1968. .10. .1. C.3448.
. 1884 .
/
.., .. (.), .. (.).
., 1884.
1992 . ,
. ., 1992.
2004 . .1: 364491 . / .. (.,
., .). , 2004.
2005 .. (VIX .) //
, 2005. , 2005. .196211.
2011 .. : ,
. , 2011.
- 1859 // . . . , . .
..-. ., 1859. .742796.
2002 .. (IVVII .). ., 2002.
2005 .
... - IVIX .
195
. . / .. (.). , 2005.
Bakirtzis 2003 Bakirtzis Ch. The Urban Continuity and Size of Late Byzantine Thessalonike // DOP. 2003. N57. .5368.
Bekkerus 1838a Pseudo-Symeon (Symeonis magistri annales) // Theophanes
Continuatus. Ioannes Cameniata. Symeon magister. Georgius monachus / Im.Bekkerus (rec.). Bonnae, 1838. .638697.
Bekkerus 1838b Theophanes Continuatus // Theophanes continuatus.
Ioannes Cameniata. Symeon magister. Georgius monachus / Im.Bekkerus (rec).
Bonnae, 1838. .1238.
Berger 1982 Berger A. Das Bad in der byzantinischen Zeit. Mnchen,
1982.
Charles 1916 The Chronicle of John, Bishop of Nikioui / R.H.Charles (ed.).
L.; Oxf., 1916.
de Boor 1904 Georgii monachi chronicon / C.de Boor (ed.). Lipsiae,
1904.
Decker 2008 Decker M. Everyday Technologies // The Oxford Handbook
of Byzantine Studies / E.Jeffreys, J.Haldon, R.Cormack (ed.). Oxf., 2008.
.489503.
Dindorf 1831 Ioann Malalae Chronographia / L.Dindorf (ed.). Bonnae,
1831.
Falkenhausen 1967 Falkenhausen V. von. Untersuchungen ber die
byzantinische Herschaft in Sditalien von 9. bis 11. Jahrhundert. Wiesbaden,
1967.
Festugire 1970 Vie de Theodore de Sykeon / A.-J.Festugire (d.).
Bruxelles, 1970. Vol.12.
Foss 2002 Foss C. Life in City and Country // The Oxford History of
Byzantium / Mango. (ed.). Oxf., 2002. .6793.
Frantz 1988 Frantz A. The Athenian Agora 24. Late Antiquity, A.D. 267
700. Princeton, 1988.
Holder-Egger 1878 Agnelliqui et Andreas Liber Pontificalis Ecclesiae
Ravennatis / O.Holder-Egger (ed.) // Monumenta Germaniae Historica. Scriptores
rerum langobardicarum et italicarum saek VIXI. Hannoverae,1878.
Koukoules 1951 Koukoules Ph. Vie et civilisation byzantines. Byzantion
bios kai politismos. Athenes, 1951. T.4.
Kurtz 1898 KurtzE. Zwei griechische Texte ber die Hl.Theophano,
die Gemahlin Kaisers LeoVI // .
- . VIII. ., 1898. .3, .2.
S.143.
Magdalino 1984 Magdalino P. The Bath of Leo the Wise // Maistor:
Classical, Byzantine and Renaissance Studies for Robert Browning / A.Moffat
(ed.). Canberra, 1984. .229240.
Magdalino 1985 Magdalino P. Comptes-rendu: Berger A. Das Bad
in der byzantinischen Zeit. Mnchen, 1982 // BSl. 1985. An.46. Fasc.1.
P.196199.
Magdalino 1987 Magdalino P. The Bath of Leo the Wise and the
Macedonian Renaissance Revisted: Topography, Iconography, Ceremonial and
Ideology // DOP. 1987. N 42. .97118.
196
Mango 1959 Mango C. The Brazen House: A Study of the Vestibule of the
Imperial Palace of Constantinople. Copenhagen, 1959.
Mango 1981 Mango C. Daily Life in Byzantium // JB. 1981. Bd.31, Hf.1.
.332346.
Mango 2004 Mango C. Le developpement urbain de Constantinople. P.,
2004.
McNally 1996 McNally S. Split in the Byzantine Empire: The Archaeological Evidence // Acts of the XVIII International Congress of Byzantine Studies:
Selected Papers, main and Communications, Moscow, 1991. Shepherdstown,
1996. Vol.2. .253259.
Migne 1862 Ioannis Chrysostomi Opera omnia quae extunt... Opera et
studio B. de Montfaucon / Accurant et denuo rec. J.-P.Migne. 1862. T.1. (PG:
T.48).
Mundell Mango 2006 Mundell Mango M. Dynamic Archaeology of Early
Byzantium // Proceedings of the 21st International congress of Byzantine Studies,
London, 2126 August. L., 2006. Vol.1: Plenary Papers. P.8496.
Noret 1982 Vitae duae antiquae Sancti Athanasii Athanitae / J.Noret (ed.).
Turnhout, 1982.
van den Gheyn 1899 Acta Graeca SS. Davidi, Symeons et Georgii
Mytilensis / J.van den Gheyn (ed.) // Analecta Bollandiana. 1899. T.18.
.206218.
..
1934
19301950- ,
.
(.1). , , ,
,
,
(1963). ,
,
.
2008 .
..
1934 .1
, , 2008: 131142; . :
2001: 118120. .
, ,
..,
(, ;
, ).
1
200
... ...
201
. 2. 16 21
1934 .
. 1. . 1930- ,
.
,
2. : -
-3 ,
, ,
4 (.2).
- , , 5. -
- 6.
1947: 407.
. ,
.. -: -, -, -
; .. - ( 1940).
4
1963: 15.
5
1947: 8; 1963: 16.
6
1947: 8.
2
3
, .. ,
1934 . 1935 .
- (
,
)7.
, ,
1935-
..,
8.
,
:
, ,
, ,
, , -, , - . - ,
- , 9.
-
1963: 16.
2001: 118.
9
1954.
7
8
202
. .
, - -
, , ,
, VIVIII . .. ,
1956 ., . (-. ..) . , .. ( 1913
1915 . ..), ,
, . -,
, ( 1963 .! ..) ,
, , .
, , ,
.
, , ; ,
10 (
) .11. , , ,
19341935 .
, , : , , , -, , ..
.
1934 .
, . , ,
,
,
... :
, ..,
, .
11
1963: 16.
10
... ...
203
, 12.
13. , ,
-
, 1930- .
,
.., :
, ..,
. , , 1934 .14
12 28 1934 15
- ,
.
, - []
[. .2], (. ..).
.
- (,
, ,
),
1934; 1934; 19341935: 2762.
,
.
,
, .
14
, , 1934 ., (.: ,
, 2008: 130). 19351937 . ( , , 5, 41)
( 1963: 6) . .
15
, .. ...
12
13
204
: 12 ; 18 ; 6, 12 18 . , ..
- [ -]16
.
, [] ( -)
, . 31/2 2
. ,
, , , -, , .
( ) ,
.
, , , -.
, , [. . 3], -, -17
(- 1898 .), - ( -). 11/2
-
, , ( ) ,
, -. -
, ,
-.
, .
2
< , ,
; , , . ,
, , >.
1963: 16.
..,
,
- (. 4).
16
... ...
205
. 5. ,
1934. , . ...
- , ,
[. . 4].
< 6/X [19]34 . :
[] ,
18, .
17
18
.., , - (. 5).
206
, .
[ ] -,
,
. ,
.
(8060 []), .
, .
[-][] - ,
.. .
, ( 2
-), .
,
- , .
-, ,
, ,
[-][], 1 - -.
, . .
.
. , []
[], .
, , , ,
-[] , [. .4].
, ,
[-][], . [-][] ,
->.
.
< 18/X. , [] -.
, .
. , ,
.
, - -
[] -,
... ...
207
. 4. ,
1934. , . ...
[. . 3]. , ,
, , , , , [] -[] >.
21 , -
[ - ] . 21 < >
-, []-.
208
< , ,
: ( ) ,
; . , - , , [-][].
: 1) 1 ; 2) , , (?), ; 3) , -, , .
19 , -, [-]
[] - >.
22, 23 24 , .
<22/XI. - ,
, ( 6 ). , , .. ,
[-][]>.
, , 1 ( [1898 .]
). < ,
, [] [-][], . ,
>. .
[-]
,
, , ,
,
- []-.
,
.
1 - , 2 , 1 []- . , , ,
,
(-, -, - ) [. .2].
.. .
19
... ...
209
< [] [-][]
[].
, -, . []-[] -[]
,
, >.
11 ,
910 34 .
<, [-][] , [] - (), [-][] .
- , , . , [] -, , , ,
[-][].
- , , . ,
-.
- ([] ),
. .
, , : , , - ( ). :
. .
23/XI. . 3 , . , 7 .
[-][] . ->.
3
,
,
.
3 -
210
. , ,
, -. -
3 ,
1
, ,
, .
, .. , , ,
.
, [], , , .
[]-, -, , .. , , .
, - , 3
-, -
[] -, .. (. ..)20.
-- 180140 . - (
8060 ), .
[] 10 .
. .
, . -
, ,
. 26 15 .
20
..,
.., ( 1940).
.. , .. 19131915 .
1917 .
( 1940: 113; 1963: 1416).
... ...
211
4
.
, 30 10 (
).
, .
.
[] 6,5 ,
[] (. .. ..). , -
( - , ,
..).
, , , ,
. , , -
, , . , .
.
[] , , -.
, , .
, -
, , []
-. -
.
, ,
.
.
, . . ,
.
,
-, , .. , , , -,
.
212
5
- ,
,
. -
-
.
4 - []- .
, -, : . -.
- . [] , 6 - []-.
27275,5 . , , .
. , , , . [ .:
.5. 12]: ,
<>,
: <> <>, .. 1127 ..
<>.
, .
,
.
.
1
( 2- [] 10- [] []
[]). , (-), 1 . ( 8 12 ) , . -
. -
. , ,
6
, ,
.
, , , -
... ...
213
. 3. 1. 5- ... . 2.
.
, []-[] .
,
. - .
25 []- [],
(
214
..) , .
- ,
, , . , , , ,
, .
, , []-.
,
: -. , , , -.
-21 , - , , .
-
.
.
. , (
60 [60 ] ), , ,
.
. ,
. .
7
, ,
. , , . .
, - , , -, ,
-, (. 21
- (. 2).
... ...
215
..), ,
, , .
, ,
, - . : [] -, , -
[] --. [] , [] [] -, ,
. [] 9
- 22
, -. 30 - ,
. 2 ., .
, -- -
, .
3 [], -. 5
.
, -,
[1898 ] [] -.
, .. . , .
...
[].
8
.
, - . ,
.
22
- (. 2).
216
30 . . . , , . , .
,
( ).
[] -,
.. , , .
, , . , , ,
, , , () -. ,
( ).
-
-- ,
.
. ([]
) , , 14086 , .
, ,
4,5. 432612 7 16;
1820.
, ,
, , , 34. , , . , - . ,
- , .
9
, - ,
.
, 100150 ,
... ...
217
-, . , , . , ,
, .
, ,
.
.
, , , ,
, -
.
, , (
). , .
,
. 2 ,
, ,
. 31/4
, .
- ( ) . , , ,
.
[] 2- 2
--, ,
120130 , 78 . .
, , .
. , ,
.
- , , ,
. ,
, , .
10
, , .
218
[] [] - - : ,
, - , ,
, .
, , , , , , . ,
.
.
, -, , .. , ,
, .
, ,
-, . , . ,
. . .
. 16,
15 .
- [] ,
,
, ,
.
-, - . , 5 .
, - , ..
, . . , . , .
, , .
, . ,
, 1
.
<3 , [] .
. [] - .
... ...
219
,
, ( 11 .),
, ,
1 []-[] . . 12 -
, .
. , ..
.
. >
11
, [] 4 .
<4 , 9 . 30 . .
, , 8
[] - .
,
, .. , ,
, , 8
. 11 11.
11 >.
,
, ,
, ,
, . -. .
, .
24
, .
,
, , .
- ,
9 ,
.
, ,
. , , , , .
200300 -, , , .
220
. - - .
, - .
[] . , , , 1924 (
-, ),
.
23 .
-
12
-- - , , .. ( ; [] [] [] []
[]. 20, . 2. [][], 1916, . 144146), -,
, .
23 ,
--,
( 23). - (
-) - -- ( ).
, [] [] ,
, .
-- , . , , . ,
, ..
( 23
, , ..
- ( 1963: 15, 16).
... ...
221
).
,
, ,
.
-- ,
,
. , , . . ,
23 .
-- , , , ..
-. . , 16 -.
-- ... , 12 ,
. .
, ,
.
, ,
, - .
, -, .
,
, , , ,
13
.
- , ( , .. ),
100 .
- , .
.., -- ,
,
, , - ..
,
, -, .
222
, ,
1 ,
, - , .
1 -- ,
, -
( 400500 ) .
.. . , -
- , , , .
, , , ,
50 , - ,
, , .
-- ( .. [1898 ]
-), 25 [] , ,
-, .
1 . (8070 ), . : , , ( []
3030) , ,
([] 5070). [,] - -- , .
14
, (-, ) , .
. - , . , , .
-
, ,
, ,
.
- , .
.
... ...
223
, , .., - - [], -, , .
, - , . , --, ,
, .
, ,
.
< , , .
. , ,
-, >.
, ,
-, - -
(
..), ,
, , ,
, ,
, ,
- .
, , .
15
,
, - , -
, .
-- --- :
. , .
.. [] ,
, , . ,
, , , (89 ).
.
224
, . ,
200 . - . , : , . , -- ( , ).
, , .
, 360
16
600 , 34 , ,
, -,
.
( )
. .
, , : ,
, .
, : 1) ,
, ( 1215 ); ;
2) ,
, ; 3) -
. , .
.
,
- .
.
.
. . ,
, .
... ...
225
, , -, 995 .
, , ,
-, ,
..
(26266).
,
, , -
..
( ,
17
) . ,
.
, , .
, , .
, . ,
. ,
.
, .
.
, , .
<27 1934 ., [] -.
. .
8.30, , . , ,
, , , ,
[1898 ] .
. -
, 50 []
(, , ..
)>.
, ,
226
, ,
.
, , .
- - , .
,
( ), 4
(.., ,
[], . 118119). , ..
30 .
- ( 200400), , .
. ,
[] 102710.
18
< , >.
, . , , , . ,
-,
. .
<: , ,
, , , - . - . : , , , .
, , , , ( [ ] >.
.
< - , , , ,
>.
-
... ...
227
,
.
< -
, , , [][] . , , , .
. , , ,
, , , , , [][] >.
..
1934 . .. 1937,
1938 1939 ., ,
1947, 19491954 .
,
24 .
Summary
Unpublished Archaeological Research in 1934 in the Bukhara Oasis
by T.G.Tsvetkova (Moscow)
We publish documents kept in the Fund of archaeological materials
in the Archive of the State Museum of Oriental Art in Moscow. This is
the report of the research expedition of the Uzbekistan Committee for
the protection and study of art and antiquities monuments in the Bukhara
oasis in autumn and winter of 1934, headed by a famous archaeologist
from Tashkent Vasiliy Afanasievich Shishkin.
In 2008 we published one of the archival documents the report by
V.A.Shishkin of the Archaeological expedition of the State Hermitage and
the Uzbekistan Committee for the protection of monuments in the eastern
part of the Bukhara oasis in spring and summer of 1934.
The objective of these two expeditions was mostly research of Kampyr24
. ( 1963: 127147);
..
(, ; , ).
228
Duval the wall surrounding irrigated oasis, and the study of towns and
villages built along the wall as additional fortifications.
These studies were very important for many problems of social and
economic history of ancient and mediaeval Sogd. For these reasons, as
well as taking into consideration the attention shown in the last decade
by the scientists from different countries Uzbekistan, Italy, Germany
to the monuments of Bukhara oasis, we believe that the V.A.Shishkins
unpublished archaeological materials in the Archive of the State Museum
of Oriental Art have great interest.
P ERSONALIA
..
..
(18701952) ,
. ,
XIX. ,
, , . ( 1880- )
( 1830- )
2. 18601870-
, , - .
..
(1888) - ,
. XIXXX ,
, 3.
( 14-18-00010).
LHritage germanique dans lapproche du dcor antique, CNRS lcole normale suprieure (, 23 2012 .);
.: 2014
2
2002: 2737, 4250, 6384, 9097, 230238, 383390, 607609;
2006: 438.
3
2006, 115436, 438441.
1
232
Personalia
c 1950-
c , , .. (. 1)
, 1918 .
,
4.
5 , ..
(18941918, 292 6), .
.. 7,
.. (19332008) (1997)
(2003).
: 19 . , , . , ,
. []
.
. Rossica non leguntur.
,
? , ,
. , , . :
.
. , 8.
-
, , ,
1914 .
4
., : H. M. L. 1953; Jones 1953; Welles 1956; Dow 1960;
Momigliano 1966: 92.
5
1997a; 1997a; 2008.
6
1997c: 201210; , 2003: 721722.
7
Wes 1988; 1990, XIIIXXXI, 118.
8
Heinen 2010: 265, 266.
... .. ...
233
. 1. ..
1890 . .. . - - . (18551919),
-
(1906)9. , .. 9
2004.
234
Personalia
10. ..
(18591944;
. 2) (18441925; . 3)11,
1890 .
- ,
( ) (Tadeusz Zieliski) ,
. , - () .
- , ..
- (1893) (1916)
, .
.. ,
12,
13.
.. .
..
, ( 1898) . ,
..,
. ..
, . , 1916 .
2 14.
.., ,
.. 15,
.
.. 34 1891; 1896.
- 1997: 46.
12
1997b: 8485.
13
2006: 312318; 2008: 260261; 2011: 667668.
14
2001: 22.
15
1924/2002: 211.
10
11
... .. ...
. 2. ..;
. . 977. . 1. . 36. . 1
235
. 3. ... ,
1924 .; . . 729.
. 1. . 92. . 17
.. - 16. ,
17
1924.
(Heinrich Nissen; 18391912) (Nissen 1877). 15
.. : 1877 . H.Nissen
Pompeianische Studien,
, . ,
, Schne Nissen,
. 1879 .
Pompeianische Beitrge.
. .
. , ,
, Pompeianische Studien.
,
,
. ,
, , . . : 1909b, 3233.
16
17
236
Personalia
. -
.. 18.
..
.., , ,
,
.
(. 4) ..
, .
19 - .
. 4. . 70- .. ( ); .. . , 1914 .;
@ . . 192. . 3. . 203
XIX XX. . ..
, , , - . 1997b: 54.
1924: 24/2002: 212.
18
19
... .. ...
237
20:
. ..,
, .
..
, . 5. Kondakof N., Tolstoy J.,
- .
Reinach S. Antiquits de la Russie
.. Mridionale. P., 1891.
(18891899)21 (
.. 22; . 5). .. ,
.
.. , . , ..,
,
23. .. , ,
, .
,
24.
1924: 25/2002: 213.
, 18891899.
22
Kondakof, Tolsto, Reinach 18911893.
23
2011: 657.
24
. 1917
1925 .: 2004: 650652, 682, 685, 693, 697698, 710, 724726.
20
21
238
Personalia
..
, . ,
.
, .. -
, . ,
.., . ,
, ,
, 25. ,
(18431921) (1869),
... ..
(1899) , .. ,
26.
..
, , -
, , , .
, .., , , :
.
, ,
,
,
-27.
. ..
, , ,
... .. ...
, , ,
. .., ..,
.., , 28, , .
,
..
.. (18871973).
.. , , ,
, ,
..
29.
..:
,
30.
.. , ,
. 1893 .
22- ..
.
, ,
.. .. ,
(Christian Hlsen, 18581935; . 6). .
, -, ..
, (August Mau,
18401909; . 7). . , Meyer 2009.
1997: 433.
30
Foletti 2008; Kondakov 2011; 2013.
28
239
29
240
Personalia
. 6. , 1905
. 7.
31 ,
.. (. 8).
genius loci , , [] , ,
, , , , , , , ,
,
, ... , ,
, ,
, ,
..32.
.
.
,
. ,
, ... , ,
... .. ...
. 8. .. ( ) .
( )
. 1893 .
, ,
33.
. .. Geschichte der
decorativen Wandmalerei in Pompeji34,
.
, ,
, ,
, ,
. ,
. .. , . ,
, ,
, ,
35.
1909a: 280.
Mau 1882.
35
1909a: 281.
33
. : Mau 1893.
1909b: 3031.
31
32
241
34
242
Personalia
... .. ...
243
. 36, ,
.., Hilfsarbaiter , , , , ,
37.
.
.. (. 9)
(1894),
(. 10)38.
. 10. .. ( ) . (
) . Forum Romanum. [18951898 .]
. 9. .. ( ) . (
) [18951898 .]
1895 1898 . .. .
Mau 1879; 1882; 1900.
1909b: 33, 34.
38
1894; 1896; 1910; 1917; Rostowzew 1904; 1911; Rostovtzeff
1919.
36
37
..
. , ,
1895 . , (Wilhelm Drpfeld,
18531940; . 11). .
.
XIX .
, .,
, ,
, (18931894).
..
...
..
,
. 11.
244
Personalia
, , II . .. , .
.. .
.
, .. . (Paul Wolters, 1858
1936) . 1895 .
, .., ..
15-
39.
1895 . .. , .
1895. ., 18941895 .
, . ..
, (Walter Oskar
Ernst Amelung; 18651927; . 12), (Eugen Adolf Hermann Petersen;
18361919) (. 1315). .. . ,
, ( 3 ), ..
.. 6
1895 .40
, -: ,
<> ,
, , , , , ,
( 22 1895 .)41.
1997b: 56; 1997c: 371374.
1997c: 375, 3.
41
1997c: 376, 4.
... .. ...
. 12.
245
. 13. .. . , , 1895 .
39
40
. 15. .. ( )
. [1895 .]
246
Personalia
... .. ...
247
, 42.
, .. -
, -.
, , .. . 1898 . .. -
. , 1899 . .. -
(. 17), 1903 . , , 1908 . .
. 14. .. .. . , , 1895 .
1895 1896 . ..
(Otto Benndorf; 18381907) , . (Eugen Ludwig Bormann; 18421917; . 16). .
: ,
. ,
, ,
. 16. E.
, ,
1901, 1903, 19051910 . . .
..
1907 . , , 1913.43
1997c: 380, 9.
1997b: 62, 78, . 32.
42
43
248
Personalia
... .. ...
249
. 19. .. ()
. , , 1906. (: )
. 18. -
1997b: 79, . 43.
44
250
Personalia
.. ,
( ) ,
48. - 49. .., .,
.., : ,
; ; , .
-
.. , .
.. 1908. - -
, 1914. - .
.. ,
1920- , .
..
1890- ..
. 1845.
..
, 50.
.. 51. 1894; 1896; 1917.
1910. : Rostowzew 1911.
50
1845.
51
1896.
... .. ...
251
.. 52.
XX. , - . ..,
,
.. . ,
53.
(18731946),
(18701928), .. XX.
.
, ,
, ..
19131914 .
..
(. 20),
..54.
.. ,
55.
IV . . . IVV. ..
..
, . 20. .[.]
. ., 1914. . 1.
1897.
1906.
54
19131914. . .: Rostovtzeff 2003.
55
Minns 1915.
48
52
49
53
252
Personalia
. , , (
)
.
, ,
. .. , ,
., .. .
..
, .
:
1. (, V
II . ..)56,
.
, ,
. , . ,
, ,
. .. , ,
(, . ) .
(
), , , 1908., .. 8 , 1867. ,
.
2. - (II I . .. I . ..)57, , ,
,
, .
1914: 10136.
1914: 137198.
... .. ...
253
.
..
: ; ,
,
.
, , , . . , ,
,
, , - .
, , .
.
- , .. 1832.
, , , 1853. - .
, 1852,
1867, 1877, 1878, 1891 .
3. :
1) ( )58 ,
, . ,
, . , ,
. ,
, . ,
. .
.. , , ,
, , .
2) 59
, 58
57
59
1914: 199259.
1914: 260282.
56
254
Personalia
, .
.. ,
1905 ., , ;
3) ( ) , 60.
, , , . ..,
.
,
. .. 1841. (
- 1845.61,
) .. (1872).
,
,
, , . ,
.., , : , , , .
-
, , .
4. . ( ) 62. :
, , ,
(, ), ,
,
.
. , , . ,
1873 1912.
1914: 283375.
1845.
62
1914: 401434.
60
61
... .. ...
255
.. , 63.
IVV . .., ,
- . 1894 ( ), 1903, 1904, 1905, 1907, 1909, 1912 . ..
, ,
. - ,
, , , , , .
..
.
, ,
, , , ,
. , A.
64.
, , ,
.., :
20 , XIX .,
. , -
, - - , -CCC XX., .
..
.
, , , ,
, XIX
XX ., . , .. ..
1914: 436507.
Rostovtzeff 2003.
63
64
256
Personalia
(, ) . 3D
, 65.
.., 1910- .
.
, . ,
,
. .. 1913 . Iranism
and Ionism in South Russia66, - , 67.
Scythians and Greeks68, .
.. ,
69. 70 ( ) .
.. -,
. , , 1918., , .
:
(1925) 65
, 2009; Logdacheva, Vinogradov, Shvemberger,
Borisov 2011; , , , 2012. . :
URL: http://www.bosporuscrypt.ru/; http://www.3DMultimediaLab.com.
66
1913.
67
1918; Rostovtzeff 1922.
68
Minns 1913.
69
1925.
70
Rostowzew 1993.
... .. ...
257
258
Personalia
***
.. . .., ,
,
, .
,
.. .. ,
..
, .., ,
, .
.., , ,
. ,
1914 .
Summary
M.I.Rostovtsev at the Junction of Russian and German
Classical Archaeology before the First World War
by I.V.Tunkina (St.-Petersburg)
There is a historiographic clich in West-European science stating that
main ideas and concepts, which helped M.I.Rostovtsev (18701952) to
become a classic of world study of antiquity, were formed only after his
emigration, as exactly in USA he got the most favourable conditions for
his studies. However examination of his works evidently disproves these
artificial inventions of historiographers. Thanks to his teacher N.P.Kondakov
(18441925) Rostovtsev adopted a scientific approach of processing
archaeological data and a width of historical and archaeological problems
statement, realization of necessity of studying not only Greek, but also a
nomadic substratum of South Russia in accordance with archaeological
materials. During his foreign trips M.I.Rostovtsev established close relations
with German colleagues, examined advanced methods of excavations and
main results of archaeological explorations in the Mediterranean. The phenomenon of M.I.Rostovtsevs personality and works is explained by his
... .. ...
259
260
Personalia
... .. ...
261
262
Personalia
..
, ,
, (. 1). . ,
.
.
, , .
.
. , .
.
: ,
. ,
. ,
, ; , . -
, . , , , . :
. ,
, .
, , . : , ,
. , .
.
, . . , . , , :
, . : , .
264
Personalia
. 1. . 90- .
,
. - , - . . . , .
, , :
, , , .
, . , , ,
. ,
...
265
,
, , . .
: ,
. ,
.
. :
, , ,
;
; (
, ); ;
, ,
- . .
.
, .
.
, , .
.
. , ,
.
. .
. ,
, . ,
. .
, , , . . ,
- .
.
.
,
. , , . ,
266
Personalia
- , . ! . - , .
, , . ,
- , , :
, !
, . .
, .
, - . ,
- , ,
. .
.
. , .
, - ,
. , , , , .
. ,
.
.
. , , ,
, , , - .
.
89, : ,
. ,
. ,
, .
.
,
. , .
.
. , .
. .
, ,
. , ,
.
, , ,
. , , -
...
267
: , ,
, ? ,
, . , . , :
!
. ,
. ,
. , , . , , ,
, . , . .
-,
. . , . ,
. , , , , , , .
, , .
. , ,
: , . ,
, . !
. , , , . ,
(. 2), , -.
, , , .
,
, , . ,
-, . ,
, ,
.
, , , , .
. , : . , - , .
, .
, . , .
(. 3).
- : , , -
268
Personalia
...
269
. 2. .., .. (1994 .)
. , , ,
. .
, , , , , . , ,
, , .
, .
.
-
. , ,
. , . , ,
.
, , , .
. - : ,
. ,
. , ,
- ,
270
Personalia
, , ,
. - ,
, .
, , , .
, , . .
, , , . .
. , ,
, . .
, , :
,
, ,
. , , , , .
, . ,
,
( ). .
- . ( ),
( , , , )
. ,
,
.
, ,
, - .
, ,
. - . ,
, .
. . , : ! ! ! , .
, , .
, - ,
...
271
.
.
.
. 80-
.
. , , .
. 91 .
, .
, . 93- ,
, ,
. ,
. ,
.
. , , -
:
.
, .
, ,
. .
.
. ,
70- 80- .
, ( ),
.
. .
.
: , , , -, ,
. ,
. .
,
. , -
272
Personalia
, .
. - ,
. , .
. ,
. , ( , - , ,
) . ! - (,
,
) ,
.
. . , , .
.
. ,
.
. .
,
, . ,
. ,
, , .
. , ,
, . , ,
(. 46;
. ).
(. 7). ,
, .
,
.
. ,
. , , ,
.
, . , , -
...
. 3. ...
273
274
Personalia
...
275
, .
. ,
. .
, ,
, .
. - ,
, - . , , , , . ,
, .
(. 8) ,
. ,
6070- .
, -
, . . . ,
, , ( ,
. 7. .. (1955 .)
, , .
.
! .
,
. , ,
, .
, .
.
. , -
. 8. .. .. ( ; 1970 .)
276
Personalia
. 9. .. (1990- )
).
.
. . , -
.
.
- . , , , .
, , .
-. , ,
,
. ,
. - , -
, , , . -
...
277
.
.
, ,
- .
. , , , .
,
, , ,
. ,
, . ,
, .
. , , ,
, .
.
, .
, .
:
. , . ,
, . ,
, , .
, , ,
.
. , .
, , -. ,
, , ,
.
, .
, .
. ,
, .
.
.
. . , , .
,
, ,
278
Personalia
, ,
. .
.
. ,
, ,
.
. , , , ,
. . ,
,
. .
.
. , . ,
, .
(. 9).
Summary
About My Father
by K.D.Nikolskaya (Moscow)
Personal memoirs about Russian Orientalist Dmitri Sergeevich Raevsky
are published in the article.
:
.
, , , (2011, 4). Scripta antiqua. ,
,
,
, , , , , , ,
.
, .
:
, ,
. , ,
, ,
. .
.
,
, ( ).
, ,
, , .
, -
282
283
*1
1961
//
. .. . , 1961. . 100107.
1964
// . 1964. 1. . 4455.
1965
19581963 . // . 1965. 2. . 169193 ( ..).
.: - .. // . 1965. 1.
. 172174 ( ..).
1966
I . .. //
. 1966 . ( ). ., 1966. . 2627.
, ,
.
, .
,
..-
.
..
1967
68/69 210 . ..
. . . . . . ., 1967.
1968
I II . .. //
. 1968. 2. . 133143.
II // . VII. ., 1968. .4367.
1970
III . .. // . 1970. 4. . 3340.
1971
// .
. II. . 1.., 1971, . 139.
*
..
284
285
1978
// 1977 . ., 1978.
. 138139 ( .. , .. ..).
, II . .. //
. ., 1978.
. 1418.
I (92123. ..) // . . 156.
., 1978. . 2226.
// . 1978. 2. .4961.
1975 . // . 39. 1978. . 173179 ( ..).
1979
// . 1979. 1.
. 139147.
The Coinage of the Kingdom of Bosporus A.D. 69328. Oxf., 1979 (BAR
International Series. 56).
1980
III (211226 . ..) // . 1980. XIII.
. 1337.
V (242276 . ..)
// . 1980. 1. . 5876.
19671972 . // . . I. , 1980. . 103122 ( ..).
19731977 . // . . I. , 1980. . 122135.
1981
III IV . .. //
. 19801981. ., 1981. . 2627.
1962 1975 . // . 1981. 1.
. 100113.
1982
- I III . .. // . , 1982.
. 5563.
V // . 1982. 1. . 9197 ( ..).
III IV . .. // . . , - . ., 1982. . 84.
1983
338 . . . (3945 . ..) //
286
287
S. 6669.
(266, 275278 . ..) // . 1991. 204.
. 103112.
// . ., 1991.
// . ., 1991.
// . ., 1991.
1992
(285308 . ..) // . 1992. XI. . 732.
VI . .. IV . ..
// . ., 1992. C. 187247.
( VIV . ..) //
. 1991 . 2528
1992 . . . 910.
1993
III . .. (1987) // . . , 1993. . 3.
Zur Chronologie der Herrschaft Asanders im Bosporos // Chiron. Mitteilungen
der Kommision fr alte Geschichte. Bd. 23. 1993. S. 6378 ( .. .).
1994
// . 68 1994 . .
., 1994. . 90.
- . I . ..
//
. . 11. ., 1994. . 81 ( ..).
. I . ..
//
. . 11. ., 1994. . 186187 (
.).
I . .. //
. . 11. ., 1994 ( ..).
1995
, 19841985 . () //
. . . ., 1995. . 8.
// .
1995. . 6. . 205212.
A Hoard of Bosporian Coins in the Period Third Century BC to AD 238 from
Ancient Gorgippia // NC. 1995. P. 2142 ( S.Ireland).
Essays on the Northern Black Sea Region Numismatics. Odessa, 1995.
288
1996
// . .
... , 1996. . 112.
// . . 2226 1996 . . ., 1996. . 1920.
VI V . .. // . 1996. 2.
. 3469.
III . 238 . .. (, 1987) // . 1996. 2. . 4472.
Towards a History of Bosporan Coinage (1st century B.C.) // ACSS. 3.2. 1996.
P. 151168.
1997
19791989 . // . 1997. IV.
. 143176.
Further to a Problem of Coinage of Lysimachus Type Staters in Tyra // Akten.
XII. Internationaler Numismatischer Kongress. Bd. I. B., 1997. S. 290299.
( I . .. IV . ..). . I.
49/48 . .. 210/211 . .. ., 1997.
( I . .. IV . ..). . II.
211 341/342 . .. ., 1997.
1998
//
VI . .. IV . .. . ., 1998. . 69.
I . .. // . . 13. ., 1998. . 1441.
IIIII . .. (, 1996 .) //
. . ., 1998. . 23.
I . ..,
(1984 1985) // . 1998. VI. . 5376.
: ? // . 1998. 1. . 140155 ( ..).
// . 1998. 1. . 247262.
// . IV- .
, 1214 1998 . , 1998. . 150151.
ber die Darstellungen von Schild und Schwert auf einem Mnztyp des
bosporanischen Knigs Leukon II. (zweite Hlfte des 3 Jhs. v. Chr.) // Stephanos
nomismatikos. Edith SchnertGeiss zum 65. Geburstag / Hrsg. von Ulrike Peter.
B., 1998. S. 251269.
1999
II (174 211
.) // -
289
. , 19 23 1999 . .,
1999. . 29.
(110/109
63 . ..) // VI . ... 100-
: 2122 1999 . ., 1999. . 120121.
VIIV . .. // . 1999. 3.
C. 3965 ( .. ..).
II (2- III . ..) // . 1999. VII. . 310325.
IVI . .. // .
1999. VII. . 326343 ( .. ..).
V IV . .. // . 1999. VIII. . 302313.
III . ..
-- // . 1999. VIII. . 314331 (
.. ..).
(110/109 63 . ..) // . 1999. 2. . 222265 ( S.Ireland).
// . 1999. 4.
. 3853.
I (93123 .) // . 1999. XVI. . 132196.
The Question of Continuity in the Late Classical Bosporus on the Basis of
Numismatic Data // ACSS. 1999. Vol. 5. P. 179205.
Two Hoards of Bosporan Coins of the 1st Century BC from the Ancient
Settlement of Poljanka (Kerch) // Hermathena. 1999. 166. P. 3144 ( S.Ireland).
2000
( VIII . ..) // . . ., 2000. . 12.
( ) //
. 2000. 3. . 340354.
II . .. // .
2000. IX ( .. ..).
I . .. II . .. (, 1978) // .
2000. 3. C. 110117 ( .. ..).
II . .. // . 2000. 4. . 6068 ( ..
..).
IIIII . .. //
. 2000. 4. . 6872 ( .. ..).
2001
( V IV . ..) // . , 1621
2001 . ., 2001. . 12.
( V IV . ..) //
. . 125. . ., 2001 ( .
XV). . 5870.
290
I . .. // . 2001. XI.
. 138144.
VI (12063 . ..) // . 2001. 4. . 442454.
(I IV . . .),
1995 . // . 2001. 3. . 5985 ( ..
..).
Two Hoards of Bosporan Coins // RN. 2001. 157. P. 287303 (
.. ..).
A Hoard of Bosporan Gold Staters of the 2nd century AD from the City-site
Krasnobatareinoye // ACSS. 2001. Vol. 7. 34. P. 169184 (
.. ..).
A Hoard of Bosporan Gold Staters of the 2nd and 3rd centuries AD from the
village of Kazanskaya // ACSS. 2001. Vol. 7. 34. P. 185191 (
.. ..).
A Hoard of Bosporan Copper Coins (1st mid. 4th Century AD) Found in
Kerch (1995) // ACSS. 2001. Vol. 7. No. 34. P. 194237.
.
. . I. . ., 2001 ( ..).
.
. II. . . ., 2001 ( ..).
2002
( ), .. (
- , , 1989 .) // . , 1520 2002 .
., 2002. . 23.
// .
. ., 2002. . 116119.
( V . ..) // . 2002.
3. . 7184.
IVI . . // . 2002. 3.
. 145152.
I . .. // . 2002. XI. . 138143.
IV . .. // . 2002. 5.
. 286303.
(
). ., 2002 ( .. .. ).
A Corpus of the Sindian Coins (First Half of the Vth Late Vth Century BC) //
ACSS. 2002. Vol. 8. 34.
The Coinage of the Bosporan Kingdom from the First Century BC to the
First Century AD. Oxf., 2002 (BAR International Series. 1102) (
R.Ireland).
2003
// . V-
. 1214
291
292
293
2011
VI . .. IV . .. // . . II. . 291350 ( . .).
..
// . 2011. 4. . 3276 ( . .).
- , // . 2011. 4. . 77103 ( .., .. ..).
// . 2011.
4. . 104118 ( .., ..
..).
(4553 . ..) // 2011 . .
, 2122 2011 . . ., 2011.
. 79.
On the Gold Coinage of Ancient Chersonese (46133 AD) // Proceedings of
the XIVth Internarional Numismatic Congress. Glasgow 2009. Vol. I.Glasgow,
2011. P. 178182.
2012
( ..) // . 2012. 1.
. 5580 ( ..).
( .. . ) () //
. 2012. 2. . 70101 ( ..).
//
. . XIX. ., 2012. . 1728 ( ..
..).
// .
. XIX. ., 2012. . 2942 ( ..).
( ..) // . 2012. 4. . 269317 (
..).
Silver Coins of Abdera and Maroneia of the 6th 4th Century BC in the
Collection of the State Historical Museum: an Updated View //
.
60-. , 2012.
. 7383 ( ..).
2013
VI
// -
294
. , , 2226 2013 .
. ., 2013. . 1922.
(70 60- . IV . ..) //
2013 . , 19 20 2013 . . ., 2013. . 911.
// . . X. , 2013. . 616626.
Catalogue of Coins of the Kings of the Spartocid Dynasty in the 2nd Century
BC (Hygiaenon, Spartocus and the Paerisades) // ACSS. 2013. Vol. 19. 2.
P. 217276.
The Coins of Ancient Epirus in Collections of the State Historical Museum
and the State Hermitage // Numismatic History and Economy in Epirus during
Antiquity. Proceedings of the 1st International Conference Numismatic History
and Economy in Epirus during Antiquity (University of Ioannina, October 3rd 7th
2007). , 2013. P. 617631 ( ..).
2014
VIIV . .. (, ) //
. . II. , 2014.
. 919 ( ..).
(438 . ..) // . . II. , 2014.
. 2941.
. . ., 2015 ( ..).
W.Stancomb
296
The Phygela hoard confirms that all minuscule bronze coinage started
at an average weight standard of 0.6g but Ephesos moved up to a 1.3g
weight c.405 followed slowly by some other mints in Northern Ionia3.
The minuscule coinage continued to expand widely during the period
c.410395 throughout western Asia Minor.
Karia and Rhodes
These coins weigh between 0.5 and 1.5 g with diameters 812 mm.
Using the plates in Ashtons article as a reference4 coins are from Kamiros (Pl. 1.1), Rhodes (Pl. 1.24), Idyma (Pl. 1.69), Kaunos (Pl. 1.10),
Keramos, with some using Carian legends (Pl. 1, 12 and Pl. 2, 14),
Halikarnassos (Pl. 2.1617), Iasos (Pl. 2.1920, 2.22 and 2.2425), Mylasa
(Pl. 2.26) and a number of other mints not yet identified (Pl. 3.2735). The
rare coins of Kamiros are important because they were probably issued
before the synoecism of the three cities Kamiros, Lindos and Ialysos to
form the new city of Rhodes in 408/9. The new foundation then went on
to issue minuscule coins immediately.
Lykia
Ashton5 suggests that it is possible that some small coins belong to this
province and period, including at least one with a Lykian legend for the
city Xanthos and another group using Aramaic for Persian officials.
Mysia
Here and below, we use the Ashmolean and Copenhagen Sylloges as
prime references (SNG Ash. and SNG Cop., parts 20 and 21; a full list of
abbreviations used will be found at the end of this article). Some of the
coins described are dated by the editors to the fifth century but the end of
that century is more likely. Coins known include Atarneus (HN p. 521?);
Kyzikos SNG Ash. 551; Gambrion (under dynast Gordion?) SNG Kayhan 51; Pergamon SNG Ash. 743745; SNG Kayhan 63; Pitane SNG
Kayhan 70; Priapos SNG Ash. 946? Finally, the small coins of Tissaphernes
(killed in 395) may be added, probably issued at Astyra and Adramytteion
with weights between 1.5 and 2.0 g6.
3
Kinns 2004. The northern Ionian raised weight level did not gain acceptance
elsewhere at this point (Kinns, pers. comm.). I am grateful to Dr Philip Kinns and
Mr Richard Ashton for a thorough discussion of this part of the paper.
4
Ashton 2006.
5
Ashton 2006: 1112.
6
Bodzek 2010.
297
Troad
Assos SNG Ash. 1051; Gargara SNG Kayhan 76; Gergis SNG Ash.
11421145, SNG Cop. 20 337; Kebren SNG Cop. 20 261262; Neandreia
SNG Kayhan 78; Sigeion, Lindgren 383; Skepsis Lindgren 378.
Tenedos
SNG Ash. 1238, 12391240, 1241.
Aeolis
Autokane SNG Ash. 1259, SNG Cop. 21 26; Kyme HN p. 553?; Elaia
SNG Ash. 1441, NG Cop. 21 167; Larisa SNG Kayhan 79; Temnos SNG
Ash. 1469, SNG Cop. 21 249; Teuthrania SNG Ash. 947 (dynasts Prokles
and Eurysthenes).
Lesbos
Mytilene SNG Ash. 15461549; SNG Cop. 21 370371, 372373, 374.
Island off Lesbos
Nesos SNG Ash. 1600.
Chios
SNG Kayhan 625.
We have concentrated above on the smallest coins of c. 0.6 g in weight
and the list is certainly not complete. In due course, and mostly after
c. 395, the weight of the chalkous was raised by different cities over a period of time, to between 1.3 and 2 g, a more practical solution for the user.
With the introduction of conventional bronze coinage c. 375, coins were
issued in different denominations. The slightly raised weight of the chalkous, now at c. 1.3 g, continued in use until the end of the Hellenistic period.
For Ionia, we have shown that the Samian coins are dated to c. 412404
and that Ephesos raises the weight after 405. Magnesia on the Maeander
moved to its new foundation in 399 and marked its new location on its first
coinage. For Rhodes, the coin of Kamiros is probably before 408 and the
issues of Rhodes fall directly after the synoecism.
The same Spartan general Thibron mentioned above shortly afterwards
conducted a campaign north of Ionia where he took amongst other cities,
Pergamon, Gambrion and Teuthrania (Xen. Hell. III. 1. 67), which then
issued minuscule coins7. His successor Dercylidas advanced still further,
taking towns in Aeolis, Troad and Mysia, including Larisa, Neandreia,
Kebren, Gergis and Skepsis (Xen. Hell. III. 1. 16ff), which again struck
minuscule coins. In 396 the Spartan king Agesilaus took over command
in Asia.
7
298
To sum up, the issue of minuscule coins in Asia appear to fall between
the years 412395. It was started in the last years of Athenian fading power
and spread under the Spartan generals in their struggle with the Persian
satraps Tissaphernes and Pharnabazos. This early bronze monetary system
was soon found to be impractical. Most mints ceased, but the major Ionian
trading cities retain the 1.3 g average weight for the chalkous and 0.6 g was
demoted to represent the hemichalkon, all being part of a multi-standard
bronze coinage which then lasted until the end of the Hellenistic period.
2. The Black Sea
In the last quarter of the fifth century, the cities on the Black Sea
coast had no struck bronze coinage, although, in an arc stretching from
Apollonia to Kerkinitis, many cities had previously used cast arrowheads,
dolphins and other tokens for internal trade. At some time in the third quarter of the fifth century, Istria, Nikonion, Olbia and Kerkinitis moved on to
produce cast coins. These were generally cast at different given weights
indicating separate denominations, but all types were probably valued by
their weight of metal8. On the south and north-east coasts, only silver was
used at this time.
We start with the early coinage of Tauric Chersonesos which has been
studied in detail by S.Kovalenko9. A colony of Herakleia Pontika, it was
founded c. 425 by Herakleots with some exiled Delians. Herakleia had no
tradition of bronze coins at this time and it is not unreasonable to suggest
that the new city looked to Asia Minor for a model10. For Kovalenkos
silver and bronze series 1, dated to c. 400390, the senior bronze denomination (1318) is Obv. Head of Parthenos wearing kekryphalos l. Rev.
; fish r.; club r., weighing 3.952.56 g. There is also one uncertain
chalkous (19) with the same types, weight 0.84 g. A second, larger, group
of hemichalkoi (2027) of the same series 1, has the same types, weight
ranges 0.720.58 g. A final group (2738) now shows fish and club to l.,
weights 0.690.26 g. The style of execution of these small denominations
shows an Ionian die engravers technique.
The coinage of Theodosia has also been covered by S.Kovalenko
together with A. Molchanov11. The early bronze coins all have Obv. Head
of bull half-facing r.
Price 1968. Later, Price (pers. comm.) suggested to me that by calculating the
value of the two metals in the heaviest Olbian bronze of c.120 g, in particular the
more valuable tin content, the large Olbian cast coin would be the equivalent of
a silver obol.
9
Kovalenko 2008.
10
Stancomb 2009.
11
Kovalenko, Molchanov 2005.
8
299
Rev. Six-, seven- or eight-rayed star. Some bear the abbreviated civic name, but most do not. We note that they all fall within the weight
and diameter limits shown in Ionia and elsewhere and they are here
dated by the authors to c. 390380. In spite of assistance from Herakleia in a war c. 380, Theodosia was captured by Leukon I of Bosporos
in c. 380.
The largest amount of comparable material is at Olbia, which struck a
group of minuscule coins again similar to those of Asia in both style and
weight. The small heads of Apollo or Demeter are not easily distinguished
and we present a number of variants from London, Berlin12, the State
History Museum Moscow, Copenhagen, Cracow and the authors own
Sylloge (see list of Abbreviations at the end of this article) together with a
few coins obtained subsequent to its publication (WMS coll.)13.
1. Obv. Head of Apollo laur. r. with long hair on neck. Rev. Corn
grain over dolphin l.; below
.
SNG BM 1420
iv 10.3 mm
SNG BM 1421
iv
10.7
0.91
Rev. as above.
ix
9.3
0.69
Rev. as above.
vii 9.3
0.69
Rev. as above.
ix
9.2
0.52
Rev. as above.
GIM 531
11.2
0.66
9.7
0.49
vii 8.5
2. Obv. Head of Demeter r with rolled hair. Rev. Corn grain over dolphin l.; below
.
xi
vii
8.1
0.61 g
SNG XI 356
8.8
0.35
SNG XI 357
9.2
0.42
Obv As above?
Obv. As above? Rev.
retrograde.
SNG XI 355
12
I am indebted to the Mnzkabinett der Staatlichen Museen zu Berlin for assistance during a recent study visit.
13
Neither SNG BM 1 nor SNG XI has separated Demeter from Apollo.
300
3. Obv. Head of Apollo laur. r. with short hair. Rev. Corn grain over
dolphin r.; below
.
SNG BM 1 415
SNG BM 1418
SNG BM 1 419
iii
x
xi
9.4 mm
1.35 g
9.5
1.21
SNG Cracow 60
9.2
0.42
WMS coll.
vi
7.8
0.42
Rev.
retrograde.
4. Obv. Head of Apollo laur. l. with short hair? Rev. Corn grain over
dolphin r.; below
10.7
1.23
As above.
9.1
0.66
Rev. As above.
9.5
1.00
GIM 577
12.0
2.27
Rev. As below.
GIM 579
10.9
1.18
Rev. As above.
GIM 582
11.0
1.04
Rev. As above.
GIM 583
10.6
1.04
Rev. As above.
GIM 584
9.7
1.04
Rev. As above.
GIM 593
9.4
0.90
Rev. As above.
SNG BM 1 417
GIM 597
10.2
0.81
Rev. As above.
8.0
0.86
Rev. As above.
12.4
1.06
8.0
0.75
9.6
0.62
GIM 526
9.2
0.76
9.9
0.60
GIM 605
Berlin, Lbbecke
1906
SNG BM 1 423
vi
ix
GIM 628
SNG BM 1 422
ix
GIM 613
SNG Cracow 61
iv
GIM 558
SNG Cracow 63
iv
8.7
0.55
Obv. As above.
SNG Cop. 79
xii
10.2
2.22
Berlin, Imhoof
1900
Berlin, 11130
ii
7.9
0.62
Rev. As above.
9.5
1.00
Rev. As above.
9.2
1.02
Rev. As above.
9.6
1.04
As above,
AMNG Pl. IX. 14.
xii
301
.
SNG BM 1 416
vi
9.7 mm
0.71 g
GIM 652
6.6
0.85
As above.
8.5
0.67
As above.
5. Obv. Head of Demeter r. with rolled hair. Rev. Corn grain over dolphin r.; below
xi
I
IX
0.64
6. Obv. Head of Apollo laur. r. with long hair on neck. Rev. Corn
grain over dolphin l.; to l., bow; below
10.5 mm
0.80 g
7. Obv. Head of Demeter r. with rolled hair. Rev. Corn grain over dolphin l.; to l., bow; below
.
GIM 527
9.2 mm
0.58 g
GIM 528
9.3
0.56
As above.
GIM 530
11.8
0.68
302
GIM 531
SNG BM 1 425
vi
10.7
0.66
Obv. As above.
8.3
0.48
Obv. As above.
8. Obv. Head of Apollo laur. l. with short hair? Rev. Dolphin l.; below
SNG BM 1 427
viii
10.8 mm
0.55 g
Same dies as
below.
SNG Cracow 56
viii
9.9
0.46
As above.
SNG XI 185
vii
10.2
0.70
As above.
GIM 653
10.2
0.53
GIM 654
9.1
0.54
GIM 656
8.4
0.49 g
9.6
0.77
SNG Cracow 57
viii
As above,
AMNG Pl. IX. 8
Obv. Different die.
Rev. As above.
Obv. Different die.
Rev. As above.
Different dies.
9. Obv. Head of Demeter l. with rolled hair? Rev. Dolphin l.; below
SNG BM 1 426
iv
7.9 mm
0.49 g
10. Obv. Head of Demeter r. with rolled hair. Rev. Corn ear r. over
dolphin l.; below
.
GIM 521
10.3 mm
0.84 g
11. Obv. Head of Demeter r. with rolled hair. Rev. Corn ear l. over
dolphin l.; below
.
GIM 515
8.6 mm
0.67 g
Dies as below.
GIM 517
9.5
0.53
As above.
303
ix
9.5 mm
0.59 g
WMS coll.
xii
9.9
0.66
It appears that these coins continue in use until early Hellenistic times,
but it seems stylistically that the earliest must have started at the turn of the
fifth/fourth century and continued for a long time14.
The numbers examined here are modest but it appears all varieties are
recorded and there is some logical order. The Apollo and Demeter types
generally follow each other in succession and the corn grain symbol would
indicate their small value, chalkous. We are not certain which of the groups
is the first but our type 1 is of better style and keeps closely to the minuscule weight limit. The deity and reverse of 2 is uncertain. 3 retains the
good style but the weight is less precise. With 4, the Obv. is careless in
execution and appears to be from a single set of dies. 5 may have a dotted
border but here we have only two examples, both with the ethnic retrograde. 6 is a rarity. Type 7 has two die combinations. 8 and 9 lose the corn
grain. 1011 incorporate an ear of corn.
We put forward the proposition that Olbian minuscule coins were
originally made by imported Ionian die engravers, after the cast bronze
coins were abandoned15. The portrait of a short-haired Apollo on these tiny
coins has some close parallels with those found at Kolophon (SNG Kayhan
357361) and Myous (SNG Kayhan 507511). The particular skills of
working with tiny blanks and dies would be beyond the ability of an Olbian
workman with no previous experience of striking coins. If this is indeed
the case, then a revolutionary change happened at Olbia which reflects the
renewed influence of Ionia on her Black Sea colonies. Our groups 1 to
3 could be close in date to c. 410395 but the remainder are clearly later.
It will be for a scholar who has access to a much larger body of material to
rationalise and date these minuscule coins.
We might add that parallel to these Olbian bronze pieces, we could
perhaps place two silver fractions described by P.O.Karyshkovski16. One
coin has the type Obv.
Bucranium. Rev. Thyrsus; ; below, uncertain symbols. Weight
I am particularly grateful for Dr Vladimir Stolba who has given me important advice.
15
There was, however, one later large issue of cast coins in the second quarter
of the fourth century, cf. GIM plates 2734, SNG BM 1 3903.
16
Karyshkovski 1960.
14
304
0.51 g diam. 6.8 mm, SNG BM 1 401. Another was seen by Karyshkovski
in a private collection and noted by him as the same but with the inscription expanded further to with, below, retrograde, weight 0.91 g,
diam. 8.0 mm. This coin is illustrated by a drawing and the current location
is unknown to us. Interestingly, the bucranium symbol also occurs on the
silver coins of Theodosia17.
Now let us turn briefly to a few other cities within the Black Sea.
The bronze coins of Apollonia Pontica have not been studied in detail,
but following the demise of the cast arrowheads there is a group of struck
bronze c. 1.84 g, 6.0 mm with Obv. Head of Apollo laur r. Rev. Anchor;
to l., A; to r., crayfish; above, i.e. two chalkoi, SNG XI 5152.
A smaller version, of similar style Obv. Head of Apollo laur r. Rev. Anchor;
to l., crayfish; to r., A, 1.09 g, 3.9 mm
SNG XI 50 is without any value mark, but presumably represents
the chalkous. These early coins are usually given to after 400. Apollonia
continues to mark its bronze with value marks for a considerable time
thereafter.
Istria is well known for its cast coins Obv. Wheel with four spokes. Rev.
, SNG BM 1 220224, which comes in different weights and sizes and
is given to c. 45040018. Less well known are a few later struck coins Obv.
Wheel with four spokes. Rev. , 0.95 g 8.7 mm and 1.40 g, 10 mm
(WMS coll.) which probably date to c. 40019.
The first bronze coins of Pantikapaion were placed by Shelov (1978) to
the period 400375. We have access to only a few examples:
Obv. Head of bearded Satyr r. Rev. Ram head r.; .
Hermitage
SNG XI 875
10.4
1.17
11.4
1.25
13.6 mm
1.95 g
SNG XI 534
11.9
1.39
SNG BM 1 876
xii
11.4
1.25
These bronze coins have similar reverses to, respectively, the silver
coins of Pantikapaion and the Sindi, which is a problem. The silver rams
head coins are dated c. 425 to 40020 and those of the Sindi to the second
half of the fifth century21. It is unlikely that Pantikapaion struck bronze
coins as early as the fifth century, so they must fall to c. 400.
With the demise of the Athenian empire and its control of the Black Sea
trade, direct contacts between the Euxine cities and Ionia were resumed.
As mentioned earlier, we propose that the bronze minuscule currency used
in Asia during the short period c.410395 was copied by some of the Black
Sea cities when they first started to strike bronze coins, which in the case
of Olbia at least, was at a similar date.
Bibliography
Ashton 2006 Ashton R.H.J. The Beginning of Bronze Coinage in Karia and
Lykia // NC. 2006. 166. P. 314.
Barron 1966 Barron J.P. The Silver Coins of Samos. L., 1966.
Bodzek 2010 Bodzek J. Kilka uwag temat monety Tissafernesa z kolekcji
Muzeum Narodowego w Krakowie in Hortus Historiae. Krakow, 2010.
Frolova 2004 Frolova N.A. Die frhe Mnzprgung vom Kimmerischen
Bosporos (Mitte 6., bis Anfang 4. Jh. v. Chr.). Die Mnzen der Stdte
Pantikapaion, Theodosia, Nymphaion und Phanagoria sowie der Sinder. B., 2004.
Frolova, Abramzon 2005 Frolova N.A., Abramzon M.G. Monety Olvii v
sobranii Gosudarstvennogo Istoricheskogo Muzeia: Katalog. Moscow, 2005.
Head 1911 Head B.V. Historia Numorum: a Manual of Greek Numismatics.
[2nd ed.]. Oxf., 1911.
Karyshkovski 1960 Karyshkovski P.O. Zametki o monetakh Olvii // SA.
1960. 2. P. 301309.
Kinns 2004 Kinns P. A Hoard Group of 3rd Century Hemichalka from
Magnesia // Opuscula Anatolica. 2004. III (i). P. 7183. (NC; 164).
Konuk (in press) Konuk K. War Tokens for Silver?: Quantifying the Early
Bronze Issues of Ionia // Quantifying Monetary Production in Greco-Roman
Times / F. de Callata (ed.). Rome.
Kovalenko 2008 Kovalenko S. Die sptklassische Mnzprgung von
Chersonesos Taurica. B., 2008.
Kovalenko, Molchanov 2005 Kovalenko, S.A., Molchanov, A.A. The Coinage
of Theodosia in the 5th4th centuries B.C. // NC. 2005. 165. P. 1522.
Lindgren, Kovacs 1985 Lindgren H.C., Kovacs F.L. Ancient Bronze Coins
of Asia Minor and the Levant from the Lindgren Collection. San Francisco, 1985.
Pick, Regling 18981910 Pick B., Regling K. Die Antiken Mnzen NordGriechenlands. 18981910 / B.Pick; 12: Die Antiken Mnzen von Dacien und
Moesien. 18981910.
17
18
305
20
21
306
Preda 1973 Preda C. Histria: monedele din epoca autonom // Preda C.,
Nubar H. Histria III: Descoperirile monetare 19141970. Bucharest, 1973.
P. 1747.
Price 1968 Price M.J. Early Greek Bronze Coinage // Essays Presented to
Stanley Robinson / C.M.Kraay, G.K.Jenkins (eds.). Oxf., 1968. P. 90104.
Shelov 1978 Shelov D.B. Coinage of the Bosporus VIIII Centuries B.C.
Oxf., 1978.
Stancomb 2009 Stancomb W. The Autonomous Bronze Coins of Heraclea
Pontica // NC. 2009. 169. P. 1528.
Sylloge Nummorum Graecorum: Denmark.
The Royal Collection of Coins and Medals of the Danish National Museum.
Part 6, Thrace 1, The Tauric ChersoneseThrace (Mesembria). 1942:
Part 20, Troas 1945; Part 21. AeolisLesbos. 1945.
Sylloge Nummorum Graecorum: Great Britain.
V. Ashmolean Museum Oxford. Part IX. BosporusAeolis. IX. The British
Museum. Part 1, The Black Sea. 2003;
XI. The William Stancomb Collection of coins of the Black Sea Region.
2000.
Sylloge Nummorum Graecorum: Poland.
III. The National Museum in Cracow. Part 4. SarmatiaBosporus. 2006.
Sylloge Nummorum Graecorum: Turkey.
1. The Muharrem Kayhan Collection. 2002.
E.Pavlovska
308
Fig. 1. Gold stater. Plilip II. Pella. ca. 323/2 and ca. 315 BC
seems that these royal Macedonian staters were not circulating very long
time; they were deposited into a hoard which might have contained even
more specimens. However, it should be kept in mind that, unfortunately,
the context and the precise location of its discovery are not known, except
the information that the hoard originates from the Nerezi Village. Hence,
one could possibly assume that it might have be a grave find.
Namely, on the north side of the foot of the Vodno Mountain, above the
Sredno Nerezi Village, the archeological site Gradishte is located, where
a fortified settlement existed during the early antiquity. Its necropolis was
located on the eastern slope, that is to say, covering a part of the modern
settlement of Zhdanec1. One of the graves excavated there in 19712 uncovered a gold stater of Philip Arrhidaeus3. Two decades later, there was
a chance find of a ritual burial in a tomb dating back to the end of the 5th
309
310
311
10
Fig. 6. Gold stater. Philip III. Babylon. ca. 323 and ca. 317 BC
312
15
313
314
..
(
)
(, , 1). ,
. , , 2 -
,
. (I. 94),
, ,
, ,
( . ..). , ,
. ; , ,
,
. , , ,
. (Fr. B4 DK = Poll. IX. 83), (Kraay 1976: 313). . : Seaford 2004: 125ff. (
, ).
2
. ,
, ,
VII . .. ,
, ( VII
VI . ..),
VI . .. (,
, , V . ..:
, 2010). .:
Wallace 1962; Kraay 1976; 1977; 1989; Radnoti-Alfldi1978: 72ff.; Kroll, Waggoner 1984; Jenkins 1990: 25f.; Rebuffat 1996: 3639; Kim 2001. ; , ,
exempli gratia.
1
316
.
.
,
( )
3.
. , ,
, .
. ! ,
.
, ,
, , . ,
, ,
, 4. , - , 5, .
,
(
), , , , ,
..6
, (, ,
) ? , , , , (, ) ,
. , -
, .
, , , ;
(
3
. : 2006:
205 ., 347 .
4
. : 1951: 23; Hill 1964: 26ff.
5
: Schaps 2004; Schaps 2008.
6
. : Servet 1984; Kraay 1989;
Reden 1997; Seaford 2004: 48ff.; 2007: 186 .
...
317
) 7.
, .
, . ,
, , ( Oikonomikos; 8). , ,
, , - .
, ( , ?).
, ; ,
, 9.
,
.
, , 10. ,
11, , , 7
, , (Amemiya 2007: 115ff.) ,
, .
8
,
(. : Schtrumpf 1995: 293ff.; Mansouri 2011: 39). ,
, .
.
9
: Patronis 2012: 13.
10
, , (. :
1984: 135 .).
11
. : 1994: 154 . ,
. ,
(
). , , ( TLG). ,
,
. , .
318
, , ,
. (
) ,
, , ,
.
- ( ) , ,
.
, ( )
, . , , ,
- , ,
, , ,
.
***
. , , ,
,
, , , .
, , .
,
.., , , . , ,
.
, , :
, (allage)
(katallattesthai) ,
, , ,
(nomismata)? ,
(nomisma) (phronesis),
(anti hou dei ta panta katallattesthai);
, , ,
(allattomena anti allelon),
...
319
,
, (Phaedo 69ab).
? , ,
, . , ,
. ,
-
, . , .
.
, , ( ). , , , - ,
, ,
.
: , (hou epeisagogimon me
deesetai), ,
, (komioun hon deitai)
, , ,
, ,
(eisaxonton kai exaxonton).
(emporoi) , ,
(polountes kai onoumenoi) (Resp. II.
370e 371b).
: (agora),
(nomisma) (symbolon tes allages) (Plat. Resp. II. 371b).
. 12.
,
.
, .
. : Tandy 1987.
(Reed 2003).
12
320
13.
. -
, ,
, (kapeloi) (Plat.
Resp. II. 371d).
( , 14):
, , (. ..). , (peri ten agoran) , (ant argyriou
allaxasthai) - , , - (anti au argyriou diallattein) , (priasthai) (Plat. Resp. II. 371cd).
(pros onen te kai prasin),
(en agorai) (Resp. II. 371d). ,
- .
, , 15,
, - .
, . : . , , ( ):
(argyrioi
e chrysioi)16, , ? , 17. 13
., : Thompson, Wycherley 1972;
Donati 2010; Mansouri 2011: 8598.
14
.
, :
Mansouri 2011: 17ss.
15
Rowe 2001. , (: Monoson
2000; Wallach 2001).
16
. (argyrion).
17
, , ( ) . , , ( ) .
...
321
. , ,
? . , (argyrion) , - ? ,
(argyrion),
, - (Resp. I. 333c334a).
( ). , , ,
. -,
. (
), .
,
.
, (, chrematismos)
. , ,
(chrematizesthai)18 19; ,
, ,
(Legg. V. 741).
,
:
18
, ( .
chrematismos, chrematizo) ;
- .
, , , ; , (..) ,
. .
19
, .
,
( ).
.
-
, , , -
, , , .
,
:
322
...
323
),
,
. , , ,
, , , .. (Plat. Legg. XI. 918cd).
.
, 23. , , ,
. ,
(exagogen, , , . ..) (nomismatos argyrou kai chrysou). ,
, , , , ,
(Plat.
Legg. IV. 705b). ,
.
, , . ,
.
, , :
(nomismati chrontai): ,
, , , . , , ,
, , (chrematon) .
- ,
, .
23
( )
, ( ),
, , .
( ) .
(
) : 1990.
, , , ,
- : - 2012.
324
(sideroi
stathmoi nomizousin), ; ,
, ,
.
, , , (ktemata),
, (chremata, ,
, . ..), , , ,
(chremata), , ?..
(nomisma) (chremata),
, ,
(toi argyrioi); ,
, , , , , ,
([Plat.] Eryx. 400a-e).
, ,
.
(chresimos) chrema, , , ,
, (chremata) ( ,
nomisma, ).
***
, , ,
24. ,
-
. 25
,
...
26,
, , ,
.
. , , ,
. ,
.
(metabletike)
, ,
(allagen) (metabletike) , (chrematistikes),
,
(autarkeias)27.
-
.
, (nomismatos),
.
(allagas) , , ,
, ,
, (sideros kai argyros) ;
,
, ,
(charakter), (tou
posou semeion) (Arist. Pol. I. 1257a1540).
, ,
( ?)
(. : 1984; 2011).
, , .
27
()
, .
.: 1919: 12 .
26
325
326
( ,
), ,
, , .
, (charakter, .. ) . , ( ) ,
( , ).
,
, . ,
, . , , -,
.
. , , (
) , - ( , , 500, 1000, 5000 , -,
, ,
, .
XIX . ,
..).
, ( ) , , , . , -
, , .
, ,
, : , (ek tes anankaias allages)
(nomismatos, , ,
. ..),
(chrematistikes), (kapelikon,
. ..). , ,
, , , ,
(chrematistike) (nomisma, . ..)
(nomismatos, -
...
327
328
, - ! ; ,
, , ,
29.
,
, . , ,
, : , (nomismatos, .. . ..) (ktesin), , ,
, :
(metaboles) (Pol. I. 1258b3 sqq.).
: , (allage),
- .
(nomisma) (meson),
, , , ,
, , (allage
oude koinonia). , - . , ,
- (kata
syntheken) (nomisma); ,
, (nomoi) (Arist. Eth. Nic.
V. 1133a1931).
30
, , , , ,
. ,
. , , ( ) - . IV . ..,
,
IV . .. ( 2008;
.: 2009).
29
., (. : Kroll 2008).
30
. : Seaford 2004: 142ff.
...
329
;
, . , , , ,
,
. , (
,
Arist. Pol. I. 1257b15 sqq.). , , .
, : .
, VI . .., : , - - , , , ,
, 31. , ; .
.
:
(nomisma) (allages)
, , , , , -.
, ,
. .
, , (allage), ,
. , (nomisma), (metron), , ,
- , , ; ,
, (nomismati).
, , ; ,
. ;
, , . ,
(nomisma) (allage) ,
,
(Eth. Nic. V. 1133b1127).
, (
) .
Seaford 2004: 143 (note 110).
31
330
(metron) ,
.
,
, , ,
. . ,
. ; ,
, , 32.
, , :
(koinon metron to nomisma), , (Eth. Nic. IX. 1164a sq.).
, -, ? , - . ,
. , , (, , ),
.
***
, ,
.. ,
(
). , , , , , , 33. ?
: Seaford 2004.
,
, , , .
33
, , , ,
,
. ., : Arist. Magn. Mor. I. 11994a19 sqq.:
, (antikatallatesthai) , (enomisan) (argyrion),
(nomisma), (oneta estin):
(axian), (allaxin) ;
.
...
331
, , .
.
, ,
, , , ,
.
, ,
.
, , ?
.
- . , IV . ..,
- 34 .
35,
(
). , - , . ( ),
.
, , , .
,
, , .
32
. . : Reden 1995;
Cohen 1997; Cohen 2008.
35
, .
(: 2005: 15 .).
34
332
Summary
Plato and Aristotle on the Coin
(To the Comparison of Ancient and Contemporary Scholarly Opinions
on the Emergence of Coinage in Greece)
by I.E.Surikov (Moscow)
Plato and Aristotle thought that the coin was invented to satisfy
commercials needs. The view is mistaken as demonstrated by works of
contemporary historians and numismatists. But why did the great Greek
thinkers make such a conclusion? The author argues that they looked at
the Archaic period and its realities through the prism of economic relations
characteristic of their own time (the 4th century B.C.). Their conclusions
about the emergence of coinage are, to be strict, ideas, not pieces of
evidence.
2008 .. . , 2008.
- 2012 - . : . ., 2012.
2011 ..
// . . ., 2011. . 348370.
1937 .. // . 1937.
1. . 114125.
1951 .. . .; ., 1951.
1994 .. : . ., 1994.
1984 .. // . : 4 . ., 1984. . 4. . 537.
, 2010 .., ..
// . 2010. 3. . 3159; 4. . 2350.
2003 .. : // . 2003. 4. . 5167.
1919 ..
. ., 1919.
1990 .. . ., 1990.
1990 .. . ., 1990.
2005 .. :
. . ., 2005.
2006 .. . ., 2006.
2007 .. : . ., 2007.
2009 .. -
...
333
// .
. ., 2009. . 79.
2009 .. ? // Studia Historica. 2009. 9. . 185201.
2001 .. //
. 2001. 32. . 528.
1984 .. : . ., 1984.
Amemiya 2007 Amemiya T. Economy and Economics of Ancient Greece.
L.; N.Y., 2007.
Cohen 1997 Cohen E.E. Athenian Economy and Society: A Banking
Perspective. Princeton, 2007.
Cohen 2008 Cohen E.E. The Elasticity of the Money-Supply at Athens //
The Monetary Systems of the Greeks and Romans. Oxf., 2008. P. 6683.
Donati 2010 Donati J.C. Towards an Agora: The Spatial and Architectural
Development of Greek Commercial and Civic Space in the Peloponnese: Diss.
N.Y., 2010.
Hill 1964 Hill G.F. Ancient Greek and Roman Coins: A Handbook. Chicago,
1964.
Jenkins 1990 Jenkins G.K. Ancient Greek Coins. 2nd ed. L., 1990.
Kim 2001 Kim H.S. Archaic Coinages as Evidence for the Use of Money //
Money and its Uses in the Ancient Greek World. Oxf., 2001. P. 721.
Kraay 1976 Kraay C.M. Archaic and Classical Greek Coins. Berkeley, 1976.
Kraay 1977 Kraay C.M. The Asyut Hoard: Some Comments on Chronology // NC. 1977. 17. P. 189198.
Kraay 1989 Kraay C.M. Schatzfunde, Kleingeld und der Ursprung der
Mnzen // Methoden der antiken Numismatik. Darmstadt, 1989. S. 180210.
Kroll 2008 Kroll J.H. The Monetary Use of Weighed Bullion in Archaic
Greece // The Monetary Systems of the Greeks and Romans. Oxf., 2008. P. 1237.
Kroll, Waggoner 1984 Kroll J.H., Waggoner N.M. Dating the Earliest Coins
of Athens, Corinth and Aegina // AJA. 1984. 88. 3. P. 325340.
Mansouri 2011 Mansouri S. Athnes vue par ses mtques (Ve IVe sicle
av. J.-C.). P., 2011.
Monoson 2000 Monoson S.S. Platos Democratic Entanglements: Athenian
Politics and the Practice of Philosophy. Princeton, 2000.
Patronis 2012 Patronis V. Economic Ideas of Ancient Greek Philosophers:
Assessing their Impact on the Formation of the World Economic Thought //
Hellenic Dimension: Materials of the Riga 3rd International Conference on
Hellenic Studies. Riga, 2012. P. 1221.
Radnoti-Alfldi 1978 Radnoti-AlfldiM. Antike Numismatik. Mainz, 1978.
Teil 1.
Rebuffat 1996 Rebuffat F. La monnaie dans lantiquit. P., 1996.
Reden 1995 Reden S. von, Exchange in Ancient Greece. L., 1985.
Reden 1997 Reden S. von, Money, Law and Exchange: Coinage in the Greek
Polis // JHS. 1997. 117. P. 154176.
Reed 2003 Reed C.M. Maritime Traders in the Ancient Greek World.
Cambr., 2003.
334
Rowe 2001 Rowe C.J. Killing Socrates: Platos Later Thoughts on Democracy // JHS. 2001. 121. P. 6376.
Schaps 2004 Schaps D.M. The Invention of Coinage and the Monetization
of Ancient Greece. Ann Arbor, 2004.
Schaps 2008 Schaps D.M. What was Money in Ancient Greece? // The Monetary Systems of the Greeks and Romans. Oxf., 2008. P. 3848.
Schtrumpf 1995 Schtrumpf E. Politische Reformmodelle im vierten
Jahrhundert: Grundstzliche Annahmen politischer Theorie und Versuche
konkreter Lsungen // Die athenische Demokratie im 4. Jahrhundert v. Chr.: Vollendung oder Verfall einer Verfassungsform? Stuttgart, 1995. S. 271300.
Seaford 2004 Seaford R. Money and the Early Greek Mind: Homer,
Philosophy, Tragedy. Cambr., 2004.
Servet 1984 Servet J.-M. Nomismata: tat et origines de la monnaie. Lyon,
1984.
Tandy 1987 Tandy D.W. Warriors into Traders: The Power of the Market in
Early Greece. Berkeley, 1987.
Thompson, Wycherley 1972 Thompson H.A., Wycherley R.E. The Agora of
Athens: The History, Shape and Uses of an Ancient City Center. Princeton, 1972.
(The Athenian Agora; Vol. 14).
Wallace 1962 Wallace W.P. Early Coinages of Athens and Euboia // NC.
1962. 2. P. 2342.
Wallach 2001 Wallach J.R. The Platonic Political Art: The Study of Critical
Reason and Democracy. University Park, 2001.
..
IV III . ..
,
.
,
,
.
. .
-, ,
, ,
. -,
.
1 ,
, . 19231926 . , .2,
1
, ,
. . (Prokesch-Osten 1848; Beul 1858).
. (BMC Attica;
Head 1911).
2
Svoronos. : Svoronos
1975. ,
, ,
. . ,
, . ,
.
. 30- ., -
336
, . 60- XX .
3, , ,
.
1993 . XXVI (Agora XXVI), 16 557 ,
19311990 . IV . .. III . ..
. . : I (
IV III . ..), II (229 183 . ..),
III ( 160- 87/6 . ..), IV (8610-
..), V ( 120- 175 . ..); VI (
264267 . . .). .
. IIIVA (22942 . ..), , : AE 1 ( II , IVA ; 20
22 , 810 ), AE 2 ( ; 1620 ,
(Shear 1936: 285332), , 40- , .; , .
(Thompson 1941: 199236),
(Thompson 1942: 213229).
3
Robinson 1960: 115 (
() V . ..); Price 1964: 2736 (
I . ..); Robinson, Price 1967: 16 ( ,
360- . .. ); Kroll 1973:
312333 (
); Kleiner 1975: 302330 (
II . ..); Kleiner1976: 140 (
200 8786 . ..);
Chambers 1978: 921927 ( );
Thompson 1982: 163171 ( ).
, .
IV . .. (Price 1968: 90104; .
IV .
..) ., IV III . .. (Kroll 1979: 139154).
.: 2004: 1014.
337
57 ), AE 3 ( ; 1315 , 24 ),
AE 4 ( , 1013 , 12 ), AE 5 (
; 710 , 1 ). I . .. ( IVB E, 42/110- ..)
. . , I ,
3 4.
, I .
The Athenian Agora, XXVI.
***
Agora XXVI 23 (
3860). IV .
.., ., , ..
4, ,
.. , 5, ELEUSI.
( 38;
350-
330- ..)6.
( 330- ..) .., .. 7, , ()
. ,
. ,
, ,
(Apollod. I. 5. 12; .: Paus. I. 14. 23; Hyg. Fab. 147). .:
1887: 3943; 2000: 139146.
5
, , ,
, ; Agora
XXVI mystic staff (.:
Agora XXVI: 28 (note 23)).
6
. :
, , ,
, , , , , ,
, ;
, , (Agora XXVI: 30 (note 34); . : p. 40, 38as).
, ,
., 15 . .: 2004: 1617.
7
, 4
338
AQE ( 39), ..
AQE ( 40).
330- 322/317 . ..; ( 110). ..
,
, , . .. 8, .
..:
) ( 41); ) ( 42); ) 9 ( 43)10.
. .
41 , (Q$)11. 42
Q$, QE EQ12.
. ,
, ,
(.: 2000: 95, 155156,
193198; Agora XXVI: 28 (note 24)). .
8
.. IV . .. ( )
V . .. ,
; ,
;
.
. , - :
( 2003: 550).
9
, (: 1887: 116117, 128; 2000: 8586). .
,
, Eleusis ring (Agora XXVI: 28).
10
16 , 73
, 169 ; 721 -
(Agora XXVI: 4142).
11
(Svoronos. Pl. 22, 43; SNG Cop. 82. Pl. 2;
Agora XXVI: 4141c).
12
(Agora XXVI: 4142a, ce. Pl. 4; SNG
Mnchen. 133. Taf. 4), (Agora XXVI: 4142b), (Svoronos. Pl. 22, 45;
SNG Mnchen. 132. Taf. 4).
339
43 EQ, QE, Q$
QH ( )13.
1 ..
, , ..
41. .. ,
, :
, , , .
, (Q$), .
.. ( );
- IV . ..14
2
.., 42. , , .., : Q$.
, ,
, .
( 38) , .. ( 43). 3 ..
, : QE, . 4 ..
, .. ,
,
QE, Q$, QH. 5 . ..
, : EQ.
, 6 7, :
EQ. , 7 , (BMC Attica: 21, 225; Svoronos: Pl. 22,
3537; Agora XXVI: 41, 43ac; SNG Mnchen. 135. Taf. 4; II, 5),
(BMC Attica: 21, 221223; Svoronos. Pl. 22, 38; Agora XXVI: 4243g, k;),
(BMC Attica: 21, 224; SNG Cop. 8. Pl. 2; II 67), (Agora XXVI:
4243l, m). , ,
, .
14
.: Bingen 1973: 759. 283
20 ; , ; -.
13
340
6 , , . , ..
(
6). 8 .. ,
.
, 9 10, .., ,
( 41 43)
( 42). 9
.., .. ,
, . ,
QE, Q$, QH.
.. 10 , , (
),
EQ. (
43). 10:
15, ,
90.
( 110) , . ..
. , , . ..16 ,
15
. (Pl. 22, 37).
16
,
(
); .
.: (Svoronos: Pl. 21, 53;
), (Svoronos: Pl. 21, 59, 61, 62;
),
(Svoronos: Pl. 21, 5458, 60;
, ).
, ,
; (BMC Attica: 17, 174176) (BMC Attica: 17,
177179).
( ) ( ); -
341
,
17. ,
, , . .. (
IV . ..).18
( 322/317307 . ..), ., ; ( 1120).
.. ,
.
(SNG Mnchen. 110112. Taf. 3).
( ), : (Agora XXVI: 20b.
Pl. 3; . 21 20b ).
17
.,
,
, (Thompson 1961: 525526; , ,
II I . ..). ,
, . ,
, .
.
18
, (
).
:
,
, ;
, , ;
(Lang, Crosby, 1964: 52, DM 44. Pl. 18.14). .
(Lang,
Crosby 1964: 5354, DM 46, DM 59, DM 63. Pl. 18) (Lang, Crosby 1964:
5354, DM 45, DM 48, DM 51, DM 61. Pl. 18, 14, 34).
:
(Lang, Crosby 1964: 63, LM 25, LM 26, LM 27. Pl. 18) (Lang,
Crosby 1964: 63, LM 21, LM 22, LM 23, LM 24. Pl. 18).
(Ath. pol. 51, 2),
. , ( , )
.
342
.. , , .
..: ) , AQE
( 44); ) ,
AQ ( 45); ) (AQ QA) (A Q) ( 46); ) AQH (
47)19.
11 12 ..
, 44. 11
, AQE. 12
..,
, .
13 ;
- ,
, ;
( 45).
, AQ
.
46. 14, 15, 17, 18, , : AQ. 16 , , . 19
; , QA,
,
A | Q (A Q). 20 ,
(AQ, QA, A | Q).
( 322/317307 . ..) , 38 . .. : ) , , (),
, ; )
, ,
(), ,
19
49 ,
34 , 274 (), 2 ; 368 (Agora XXVI: 4243).
343
, . .. , ;
( 38). ELEU .. (
48) ( 49)20. (307 300 .
..) .
.. .. , .. ELEUSI
( 51). ( ELEUSI
) 284270- .. ( 55).
21 .. ,
.
21 , ..
,
. .. ,
, .
,
, . , , (ELEU ELEUSI),
49, 5522. 22
, . ..
; ,
. .. , , , ; :
20
28 (
.. 13 , 11 ) 17 ( .. 2 , 11 )
(Agora XXVI: 4344).
21
1517
3,73 ; 1114 2,26 .
39 51 59 55. . , 55
25 , 36 . ,
61 , 59 ; , -
(Agora XXVI: 4446).
22
21
51.
344
,
ELEU ELEUSI. 22 48, 49 5523. 36, ,
; ..
, .. . , , . ( ) , , 5124,
ELEUSI.
307 300 . .. 51
. ..
,
. .. , ;
: A, HQ,
( 50)25.
13
( 2335). , , ,
( 32 ..,
34 ..). , 31 . .. : .. 32 , .. ; .. 30 , ..
.
. .. 33 . 23 .., , .. . .. 35 . ,
;
25, 26, 28.
24, 27, 29, 34. .. , ,
, .. , .
23
, 356
/ , - (Agora XXVI: 46).
24
13,514,5 , 4,36 ; . . 22.
25
, , 251 (Agora XXVI: 44).
345
, , .
. .
.. , .. ( 52): , , ,
. 26:
. 287
284 . .. ( 53): , AQ QA.
( 54): , ; AQ QA.
53 54 284270- ..27
(
37), 52.
. .. ,
, , .
, .
28,
. .. ,
. .
53 AQ ( 3855). ,
, .. ,
.. ,
Agora XXVI , . .
, . (Svoronos. Pl. 22.80); .: Agora XXVI: 34. :
( 36170, .: II, 24) ( 10821, ).
27
37 52, 201 53, 38 54 (Agora XXVI: 4445).
28
. . 26.
26
346
347
ra XXVI36. , ,
5254. -, 57
60 .. : , , .
613, 656637, 6838, , ,
5760. 64
. 67 69. 67
, .. ,
. , 59 71 (
5760 ).
..
43 55. 67
5254. 69 , , .. .
,
52
54. 70 71; , :
AQ. , 53 54.
270 . .. 56, 46, . .. ( 46 ). ..
, ,
( , 46).
(A Q),
, , 39.
5760 ( 270261 . ..). .. . .. , , ,
; : ( Agora XXVI 580
(p. 47).
37
66
, , , .
38
68 - , ,
, , , 52.
39
.
36
348
349
57 60.
. (261229 . ..)
. 62 .. , ..
, AE. .. 63 , ;
.. ,
ELEUSI. III . .. 61. ..
, .. , , ELEUSI43.
. 88 ,
; IV .
..44 .. : )
, , , ; ) , ,
; ) ,
, . , 1- 2- , , 3-
. .. : ) (, ),
; SA LA; )
, SALA.45 , 1- ..
1- .., 2- .. 1-
2- .., 3- .. 1- ..
Agora XXVI :
640 / , SALA;
641 / ,
SALA; 642 /
, SALA46. , : .
.: 2004: 2526.
. : Taylor 1975: 188195 (
).
45
, ,
, triskeles (Agora XXVI: 215). ,
, ,
,
.
46
42 640,
43
44
350
1519 2,99 ,
: 1113 1,52 . .. 88
, ,
. , , ,
,
(, ,
).
( 8990) , , ..
, .. ( 89 .. ,
90). . .. . , .
386276/261 . ..47 : . .., .. . .. , MURI ( 455)48;
.. ,
49. , 50.
641 642; 55
(Agora XXVI: 214215).
47
. ,
, , 394 .
.. ( 267262 . ..) .
. .: 2004: 2627.
48
(SNG
Cop. Thrace. 990. Pl. 19), , ..
, (SNG Cop. Thrace. 989.
Pl. 19). Agora XXVI , .. (p. 179, 455f).
49
, .. ,
(SNG Cop. Thrace. 975. Pl. 19; 1,38 ). , ..
, , ..
(SNG Cop.
Thrace. 974. Pl. 19). 89 (1,60)
. 90 -
, .
50
41
455 28 ,
( 455; Agora XXVI: 179).
351
***
.
( . ).
( 143 ) : I 88 51 (61,5%), II
13 (9,1%), III 25 (17,5%), IV 17 (11,9%)52.
53. (
118 ): I 37 (31,4%), II 14 (11,9%), III 45 (38,1%), IV
22 (18,6%). (
153 54): I 51 (33,3%), II
14 (9,2%), III 55 (35,9%), IV
33 (21,7%). ,
I
.
52
,
(V VI )
.
53
(
)
.
, . ( )
,
. (.:
1984: 104). ,
, , .
(
),
. (,
, ) , ,
, ( ,
).
54
;
(
).
51
352
III (3638%), I
(3133%), IV (1922%),
II (912%)55. III ,
, IV II ;
I .
I , ,
(61,5% 33%). , ,
-
.
( ) . 56.
55
, ( 11451 ): I 3796 (33,1%), II 1489 (13,0%), III 2038 (17,8%), IV 4128 (36,1%). ,
, IV , , I .
(
) ,
.
56
, , . .
I ; 50, 5254, 5759.
, 4143 4446
. , , ,
.
(229
183 . ..) , , I . ,
270261 . .. ( I
5760) 229 . .. ( II ).
4050
. , (
) XIX XX . - (
,
, ). ,
,
(
). , , (-
353
I ( IV III . ..)
330- 322/317 . ..
1. .. .
.. ,
, :
[$]?
-2,22 -12,5-14,5 /-12 . 15951
: ,
: Svoronos. Pl. 22, 43 (297255 . ..); SNG Cop. 82.
Pl. 2 (. 393 . .. III . ..); Kroll 1979. Variety Ab. Pl. 16
(. 350330 . ..); Agora XXVI: 4141ac. Pl. 4.
2. .. .
.. ,
,
, : A
Q$
-2,14 -14-16 /-4 . 15952
: ,
: Svoronos. C.: Pl. 22.4446 (297255 . ..); Kroll
1979. Variety Aa. Pl. 16 (. 350 330 . ..); Agora XXVI: 4142a,
ce. Pl. 4; SNG Mnchen. 133. Taf. 4 (. 340 320 . ..).
; |
3. .. .
.. ,
, , : A
Q
)
. (
). ,
.
20- 30-
. , .
354
355
356
357
358
359
28. , : A
[HQ]
-3,79 -14-15 /-6 . 15975
: ,
29. , : [A]
[HQ]
-3,85 -15,5-16 /-7 . 15976
: , , ,
30. , : A
HQ
-3,91 -14,5-15 /-12 . 15977
: ,
31. , : A
HQ
-4,03 -13,5-15 /-7 . 15978
: ,
32. , : A
HQ
360
361
284270- ..
; AQ
38. .. .
.. , , :
A [Q]
-1,77 -11,5-13 /-12 . 15984
: , ,
A
: BMC Attica: 22, 229234. Pl. VI.8 (393322 . ..);
Svoronos. Pl. 22.6770 (297255 . ..); SNG Cop. 98. Pl. 2 (III .
..); CBC. .: 370 (1 III . ..); Kroll 1979. Variety G.
Pl. 16 (286280 . .. ); Agora XXVI: 45, 53ag. Pl. 5;
SNG Mnchen. 149150. Taf. 4 (. 286262 . ..); MM II. 2527
(= . 23642365).
39. , : AQ
-1,81 -13,5-14 /-12 . 15985
: , , Q
40. , : AQ
-1,93 -13 /-7 . 15986
: ,
41. , : A[Q]
-2,00 -11-13,5 /-11 . 15987
: , , ,
42. , : AQ
-2,03 -11,5-12,5 /-4 . 15988
: , ,
43. , : AQ
-2,22 -13-14 /-11 . 15989
: , ,
44. , : A[Q]
-2,23 -12,5-13 /-12 . 15990
: , , ,
.. , ..
45. , : AQ
-2,24 -11,5-13 /-12 . 15991
: , , Q
46. , : A[Q]
-2,27 -12-12,5 /-11 . 18921
: , , ,
47. , : AQ
-2,29 -13-14 /-11 . 15992
362
: , , Q
48. , : A[Q]
-2,46 -12,5-13 /-12 . 15993
: , ,
49. , : AQ
-2,62 -13 /-12 . 15994
: , ,
50. , : A[Q]
-2,64 -12,5-14 /-11 . 15995
: , , ,
51. , : A[Q]
-2,65 -12 /-12 . 15996
: ,
52. , : A[Q]
-2,68 -13-14 /-11 . 17573
: , , ,
53. , : [A]Q
-2,69 -12-14 /-12 . 17574
: , , , A, Q
54. , : A[Q]
-2,89 -14 /-5 . 17575
: , ,
55. , : AQ
-2,97 -12,5-13 /-12 . 17576
: ,
; QA
56. .. .
.. , , :
QA
-3,08 -14-15 /-? . 17577
: , , , .. -
, Q
: Svoronos. Pl. 22.64 (297255 . ..); CBC. .: 370
(1 III . ..); Kroll 1979. Variety G. Pl. 16 (286280 .
.. ); Agora XXVI: 45, 53h. Pl. 5.
; AQ
57. .. .
.. , , : AQ
363
364
365
270261 . ..
72. .. .
.. , , . : [A]
Q[E]
-1,90 -14 /-12 . 18779
: , , , ,
: BMC Attica: 22, 236238. Pl. VI. 9 (393322 . ..);
Svoronos. Pl. 22.7677 (297255 . ..); SNG Cop. 96. Pl. 2 (III .
..); Kroll 1979. Variety Ja. Pl. 16 ( 256/255 240- . ..);
Agora XXVI: 46, 57ag. Pl. 6; SNG Mnchen. 152. Taf. 4 (. 286262 .
..); MM II. 30.
73. , : [A]
Q[E]
-2,51 -13-14 /-11 . 18780
: , , ,
74. , : A
Q[E]
-2,75 -14-14,5 /-12 . 18781
: , , ,
75. .. .
.. , , , : A
QE
-1,98 -13,5-14,5 /-6 . 18782
: , ,
: Svoronos. Pl. 22.7879 (297255 . ..); Kroll 1979.
Variety Jd ( 256/255 240- . ..); Agora XXVI: 46, 58ae.
Pl. 6; MM II. 31.
76. , : [A]
[QE]
-2,66 -13,5-15 /-12 . 18783
: , , , ,
77. , : A
Q[E]
-2,90 -14-14,5 /-7 . 18784
: , ,
366
78. , : A
QE
-2,99 -13-14,5 /-1 . 18785
: , ,
79. .. .
.. , , . : [A]
QE
-1,64 -13 /-5 . 18786
: , ,
: BMC Attica: 22, 239. Pl. VI.10 (393322 . ..);
Svoronos. Pl. 22.7374 (297255 . ..); SNG Cop. 97. Pl. 2 (III .
..); Kroll 1979. Variety Jb. Pl. 16 ( 256/255 240- . ..);
Agora XXVI: 47, 59ae. Pl. 6.
80. .. .
.. , , , : [A]
[QE]
-1,61 -12,5-14 /-12 . 18787
: , , ,
: BMC Attica. .: . 22, 236239. Pl. VI.910 (393322 .
..); Svoronos. .: Pl. 22.7379 (297255 . ..); SNG Cop.
C.: 9697. Pl. 2 (III . ..); Kroll 1979. Varieties Jad. Pl. 16 (
256/255 240- ..); Agora XXVI: 4647, 57ag, 58ae,
59ae, 60. Pl. 6; SNG Mnchen. C. 152. Taf. 4 (. 286262 .
..); MM II. .: 3031.
81. , : [A]
Q[E]
-2,04 -13,5-14 /-12 . 18788
: , , , ,
Q
82. , : [A]
Q[E]
-2,40 -13,5-15 /-12 . 18789
: , , ,
83. , : [A]
[QE]
367
IV . ..
88. .. ,
.
.. , , : [S]ALA
-2,49 -14,5-15,5 /-7 . 18874
: , , ,
: BMC Attica: 116.11 (, . 350318 . ..);
SNG Cop. .: 457. Pl. 11 (, . 339318 . ..); CBC.
.: 531 (, IV . ..); Agora XXVI. .: . 214215,
640af. Pl. 26; SNG Mnchen. 467468. Taf. 17 (, IV . ..);
MM II. .: 113116 (= . 24302432).
(. )
386-276/261 . ..
89. .. .
.. , , : MURI
368
, : ( )
-1,60 -11-11,5 /-3 . 18872
: BMC Thrace. .: . 213.5; p. 214.2 ( ); SNG Cop. Thrace. .: 973, 975, 988990. Pl. 19
(. 300 . ..); Agora XXVI. .: . 179, 455ah, 455Aad. Pl. 23;
MM II. .: 119 (= . 26).
: , ,
90. , : MURI
-2,23 -13-14 /-9 . 18873
: , ,
Summary
Athenian Bronze Coins of the mid. IV mid. III Century B.C. in the
Collection of Numismatic Department of the State Historical Museum
by A.V.Strelkov (Moscow)
The author publishes Athenian Bronze Coins of the I Period (after
periodization of J.Kroll; mid. IV mid. III cent. B.C.) from the collection
of Numismatic department of the State Historical Museum.
1984 .. // / . ... .,
1984. . 101137.
2000 . : . ., 2000.
1887 .. . .,
1887.
2003 .. // . / . . .. ... ., 2003. . 545564.
2004 .. IVI .
.. // : . . . ... ., 2004. . 2. . 1055.
Beul 1858 Beul E. Les monnaies dAthnes. P., 1858.
Bingen 1973 Bingen J. Le trsor montaire Thorikos 1969 // Thorikos. 1973.
VI. P. 759.
Chambers 1978 Chambers J.T. Athenian Imperial Bronze. Its Historical
Significance and Chronology // The Numismatist. 1978. 91, 5. P. 921927.
Head 1911 Head B.V. Historia Numorum. 2nd ed. Oxf., 1911.
Kleiner 1975 Kleiner F.S. The Earliest Athenian New Style Bronze Coins:
Some Evidence from the Athenian Agora // Hesperia. 1975. XLIV, 3. P. 302330.
369
Kleiner 1976 Kleiner F.S. The Agora Excavations and Athenian Bronze
Coinage, 20086 B.C. // Hesperia. 1976. XLV, 1. P. 140.
Kroll 1973 Kroll J.H. The Eleusis Hoard of Athenian Imperial Coins and
Some Deposits from the Athenian Agora // Hesperia. 1973. XLII, 3.
P. 312333.
Kroll 1979 Kroll J.H. A Chronology of Early Athenian Bronze Coinage,
ca. 350250 B.C. // Greek Numismatics and Archeology: Essays in Honor of
Margaret Thompson / O.Mrkholm, N.M.Waggoner (ed.). Wetteren, 1979.
P. 139154.
Lang, Crosby 1964 Lang M., Crosby M. Weights, Measures and Tokens.
Princeton, 1964. (The Athenian Agora; Vol. X).
Price 1964 Price M.J. The New-Style Coinage of Athens: Some Evidence
from the Bronze Issues // NC. Ser. 7. 1964. 4. P. 2736.
Price 1968 Price M.J. Early Greek Bronze Coinage // Essays in Greek
Coinage Presented to Stanley Robinson / C.M.Kraay, G.K.Jenkins (ed.). Oxf.,
1968 P. 90104.
Prokesch-Osten 1848 Prokesch-Osten [A]. von. ber die Mnzen Athens.
B., 1848.
Robinson 1960 Robinson E.S.G. Some Problems in the Later Fifth Century
Coinage of Athens // ANSMN. 1960. IX. P. 115.
Robinson, Price 1967 Robinson E.S.G, Price M.J. An Emergency Coinage
of Timotheos // NC. Ser. 7. 1967. 7. P. 16.
Shear 1936 Shear J.P. Athenian Imperial Coinage // Hesperia. 1936. V. 3.
P. 285332.
Svoronos 1975 Svoronos J.N. Corpus of the Ancient Coins of Athens.
Chicago, 1975.
Taylor 1975 Taylor M.C. Salamis and the Salaminoi: The History of an
Unofficial Athenian Demos. Amsterdam, 1975.
Thompson 1941 Thompson M. Some Athenian Cleruchy Money //
Hesperia. 1941. X, 3. P. 199236.
Thompson 1942 Thompson M. Coins for the Eleusinia // Hesperia. 1942.
XI, 3. P. 213229.
Thompson 1961 Thompson M. The New Style Silver Coinage of Athens.
New York, 1961.
Thompson 1982 Thompson M. Reflections on the Athenian Imperial
Coinage // Hesperia. Suppl. 20: Studies in Athenian Architecture, Sculpture and
Topography: Presented to Homer A.Thompson. Princeton, 1982. P. 163171.
..
,
, . , , ,
. , . , , , .
,
. , , -. , ,
, ,
, ,
. . , .
. , ,
. , - ,
. , , . ,
, . .
.
.
.
.. 1. ,
SNG BM. 714.
...
371
,
IV . ..,
.
.. , , 2. ,
, de visu, .
, ..3.
,
. .. .
..4.
.
, , , , , .
,
, . .
, 5, ,
..,
, ,
. , .
( ) . , , . , ..,
, .
, ,
,
,
.
, .
, Kovalenko 2008. Taf. 18.332.
1977: 144147.
4
2010.
5
1977.
2
372
,
. , , ,
6.
. ,
, , . , , ,
. , 7. ..
. ..
(. 1.1) ,
. , .. 7 ,
, 8. ,
.. .
?
, .. . - .
-
. , ..,
, .
(), , (. 1.3).
.
..,
, , .., (. 1.2). ,
.., ,
.
.. ,
, , 9. 2010: 199.
1997.
8
1977. . I.2.
9
2010: 198.
6
7
...
373
. 1.
,
... .
.
374
.. contra . -, ,
.
-,
. . , .
. . .
, .. (
), 10. . ,
.
, .
, ..-
, 11.
.., , ,
3,88 12. .. -13. .. , 14. , , ,
.
,
,
, .
,
.
4,89 , , 15. ..- 1977. . I.1.
- 1906: 233242.
12
1951: 146147.
13
1988: 146.
14
1977: 3435.
15
SNG BM. 1566.
...
16. , 4,64,8
.
, , ,
,
. .., ,
. . 7,1
( 6,78 ), , , .
.., ,
. ,
.
. .
,
,
2011 . .. : 17.
III . .. ..18.
19.
, .
10,38 . (
, , (. 2.3) ;
, ,
10,3 ). : (
, ), , ;
( , (. 2.1), (. 2,2);
(. 2,3) (. 2,4)).
, ,
5,1 .
10
11
375
- 1906: 233242.
1977. . VI.9193.
18
1989: 5570.
19
, 2006: 550563.
16
17
376
...
. 2.
377
378
, ;
, ,
, . :
(. 2.5), (. 2.6) (. 2.7).
,
. , .
.
. ,
, , .
, ( ), .
, , , .
.
IV . ..
. ,
.
. , IV . ..
. , , , , ,
IV . ..
Summary
Some Controversial Problems of the Numismatics of Chersonesos
by E.Ya.Turovsky (Sebastopolis)
Two series of silver coins of Chersonese are reconsidered in the article.
The first series is the earliest, it starts the coinage in the city. Uniqueness
of the majority of coins of the senior face values of a series makes the
attribution of their weight system rather disputable. Coins of the fourth
silver series have been stroke after the Persian weight system. These
are very rare coins which were apparently completely withdrawn from
circulation. The quantity of magistrates names in this series considerably
grew due to the new finds. The names on silver coins of the fourth series
and on the synchronous copper coins coincide only in one case. This allows
us to assume that the issues of the coins from different metals have been
controlled by different people.
...
379
1977 .. (V . ..
XII . ..). , 1977.
2010 .. , . , 2010.
1977 ..
// .
., 1977. . 144151.
- 1906 - ..
// . 1906. VI. . 215275.
1951 .. . .; ., 1951. (; 16).
1988 .. . - .
, 1988.
Kovalenko 2008 Kovalenko S. Die sptklassische Mnzprgung von
Chersonesos Taurica. B., 2008.
, 2006 .., .. // . 2006. XII, 2. . 550564.
1989 .. -
// . 1989.
4. . 5571.
1977 .. . , 1977.
... -...
381
..
20072010 . -
. 1. XIX .
, ,
(), 2009 . . ,
( 2010)
, . 2009 .
, 5. , , ,
(. 2 ).
, 2010 ., -, .
, 178 . (. ) (. 3). ..
1933 . (. 4 )6.
( 30 ) . , , ,
2010: 140. . 87.
2010: 21. . 48.
5
6
382
... -...
383
. 2. , . 86 ().
,
;
. 2. ;
. 2. 86 ( ) (: Saprykin 1994)
. 3. 1:100000.
(178 ),
-
. -
.
, , , , ,
- ,
. 4. . . ..
( . . 2. . 1. . 130 (1933). . 81. . 2, 7.)
384
... -...
385
. 4. Google Earth
, , ,
. : -,
15, , -, ( ), , -, , , , -.
,
- .
, -.
-
, ,
(. 5).
,
, .. 1778 .7; - ,
,
. - , 2013.
. 6. - . ,
1790 .
, , , 1959 . ,
(. 9). ,
. - ( 1 -
)
386
... -...
387
. 8. 1817 .
, .
1790 . (. 6),
XIX . (. 7).
..,
1929 . . : , ,
, , , -
, -8.
, , , ,
, , ,
, : , 9.
, - (. 6). 1817 . (. 8) , . ,
, ,
(. 9). , XIX .
- , XIX . ,
. -
XIX . ; , , (. 7).
,
, , , .
. . , , ,
. , . XVIII XIX .
, .
, . - .
2008: 17.
,
, (. ).
- XIX . , 1817 .
(. . 8) , .
. 7. .
. . ,
. -
8
9
388
. 9. 1959 . -
... -...
389
( , , ),
, . ,
335 335 . -
12 ( ),
- ,
(. 9). , ,
(. 9). ,
.. 10.
. 1959 .
, . , , 1979 . ..
1959 . ,
. ,
420 250255 11.
. - , , , .
120- , , ,
2010 . ,
(. 10).
, (. 10). .
, ,
, .
, , , , (. 11).
, , ,
, 1980- . ,
1978: 99. . 54.1.
eglov 1980. Fig. 14.
10
11
390
, . :
, , , (. 11). ,
IV III . .. III . ..
, ,
. ,
Google Earth
(. 10). , (
, , ),
.
.
, , . - 910 . - (. 12).
, - . -
,
, , ,
.
, , . 5 5 .
-
( 60-)
(1020 ) .
. (. 12).
. ,
. , , , 100,
. ,
, , ( 30 ).
(. 12).
... -...
391
. 11. . . 1, 2 ; 3 ;
4 ; 5 ;
6 ; 7
(?) ; 8 ; 9 ;
1012 ;
1318
, , , .
.
, ,
(. 2, 5)12.
,
13. ,
.
, , 2010: 169. . 13.
, , 2010: 167. . 11.
12
13
392
... -...
393
- , , . .
2009 . .. . , . -,
, , , ,
.
Summary
New Greek Settlement Chokrak-Verkhniy on the Cap Tarkhankut
by T.N.Smekalova (St.-Petersburg)
, -
.
80 5060 ,
,
, , , , . 14. . -
IV III . .. III . ..,
, IV . ..
,
. -, ,
.
. -, ,
. , 10
, .
.
, 2005: 135. . 1; , 2004.
14
For a long time the opinion that the Greeks have only civilized
a narrow coastal 2 km wide strip has been maintained. This view must
now be reconsidered. A new Greek estate (Kunan near Krasnoselskoe
of Chernomorskiy rayon) in the middle part of the Tarkhankut cape
was discovered in 2008. Now seven Chersonessos estates in the remote
regions of Tarkhankut cape and six on the northern (furthest from the
sea) coast of the Sasyk-Sivash lake are known, which were discovered
by the reconnaissance and excavations in 20082014. The present article
describe the results of the studies of new Greek estate Chokrak-Verkhniy
with remote geophysical methods.
394
Th.Kourempanas
the second half of the second century to the middle of the first century
B.C. During that period overstriking was a very common practice for the
Macedonian cities of Thessaloniki, Pella and Amphipolis. Thanks to the
known overstrikes we can have the sequence of different coin issues. The
two rare overstrikes presented here were not known to I.Touratsoglou2 and
they help us to prove the sequence of two issues of Thessaloniki dated to
middle of the first century B.C. The first coin belongs to the collection of
the Archeological Museum of Veria and the second to the collection of
the Archeological Museum of Blagoevgrad. On both coins over the type
Dionysus/goat is struck the type Janus/centaurs.
The type Dionysos/goat was used for the very first issues of
Thessaloniki, as well as for the previous coinage in the name of the Roman
quaestors of Macedonia3. The cult of Dionysus was apparently very
important in Thessaloniki and is also attested in the city by literary sources
and excavation finds such as inscriptions (IG. X. 2. 1, 28). The different
coin issues of this type are distinguished by the use of different monograms
during the second century B.C.
During the first century B.C. the type Dionysus/goat was used for
a latter issue without monograms. To that particular issue belong the two
coins we are examining in the present paper. The style of this issue is
clearly distinguished from the style of the previous issues of the same type
dated to the second century B.C. The inscription on the reverse is written
in two columns right and left of the reverse type, unlike the inscription
on the earlier issues found above and below the reverse type. The coins
belonging to the issue of the first century B.C. weigh usually less than the
1
I would like to thank I.Prokopov and I.Graikos for showing me the coins of
Thessaloniki from the museums of Blagoevgrad and Veria.
2
Touratsoglou 1993: 75.
3
Kourempanas 2010. Pl. 1.3, 7.
396
issues of the second century B.C. Unlike most of the previous coin issues
of Thessaloniki, this issue is not found among the excavation coins of the
Hellenistic city of Pella, destroyed and abandoned at the beginning of the
first century B.C. during the period of the Mithridatic wars4.
The type Janus/centaurs is strongly influenced by bronze coins of the
roman republic. Their low weight and the low artistic quality of their dies
shows that these coins were produced in a hurry most probably during
the Roman civil wars, as Macedonia was often the center of the military
operations. A great number of these coins were found during the excavations
of the ancient cities of Amphipolis and Thasos5.
We find both of these types in the hoard of Prosotsani B/ 1984 from
the actual region of Drama (CH. 8. 401), together with bronze coins of
Amphipolis dated to the beginning of the Roman imperial period. Some
coins of the type Janus/centaurs are also found in the hoard Platania 1959
from the same region (IGCH. 663), together with silver and bronze coins
of the Roman Republic. According to the evidence of these two hoards
the type Janus/centaurs would most probably precede the type Dionysus/
goat, as in the hoard of Platania we dont find Greek coins of the Roman
imperial period. However the two overstrikes already presented here prove
the opposite.
Bibliography
. 2010.
//
, , 1619 2006. ,
2010. P. 513520.
Kourempanas 2010 Kourempanas Th. Les monnayages de bronze en
Macdoine aprs la fin de la monarchie // The Coin Circulation in the Ancient
Greek World. International Conference. Athens, 1417 April. Athens (in print).
., 2007 ., .
. // Arch Ephem.
2007. 146. P. 221242.
Touratsoglou 1993 Touratsoglou I. The Coin Circulation in Ancient
Macedonia (ca. 200 B.C. 268286 A.D.). The Hoard Evidence Athens, 1993.
(Bibliotheca of the Hellenic Numismatic Society; 1).
4
5
, 2007: 221242.
2010: 513520.
III . ..
,
,
. ,
.
. , ,
.
1.
,
. .
, .
,
. ,
, 2.
, ,
Will 19791982: 59407; 1980: 147159; Hommonod, Walbank
1988; Walbank 1981a: 4757.
2
Walbank 1981b: 1427; Crawford 1985: 117132, 219239;
2000: 52156.
1
398
.. ...
399
3. ,
,
, , . . ,
,
4.
III II . ..
II . .., . ,
, .
,
, , .
.
, -,
, .
.
.
,
, , 5.
,
,
. , .
196, 168 150 . ..
. -
.. 6 7.
, III . ..
, , . , , .
.
. 8.
, , , . .
. , ,
/ ,
, . , ,
.
,
. . ,
, . .
3
Mommsen 1970: 3439; Holleaux 1970: 4047; Baddin 1970a: 4856;
1970b: 9194; Rostovzeff 1970: 8590; Kallet-Marx 1996.
4
Prokopov 2000: 375386.
5
Prokopov 2006: 232237.
I
. ..
(. I AC)
, .
, / ( ,
VI ).
, 6
7
400
.. ...
401
, , .
. , 280 160 .
.., 9,
,
:
III ( )
4421
( )
1057
II ( )
300
II
112
III
80
80
III
71
IIII
60
-
52
17
IIII
13
11
4
2
I
2
2
1
1
1
1
: 6288 .
.
. , III, . ,
.
. . 70% .
, -
IA (15). I:
II
9
IGCH. 452454, 459460, 466, 468, 851857, 859860, 865, 869875,
877, 886889; CH I. 92; CH II. 50, 53; CH III. 26, 29, 35, 39, 74; CH V.
29, 68; CCCHBulg. IV. KIPh1; AOP1; PH1; ImPhIII1 ( ).
402
IB (111). I:
,
I
.. ...
403
404
. II
22% .
. , 4,4%.
, .
II
. ..
(. II)
, , , ,
.,
10, .
,
11,
:
( )
17642
,
8020
7907
3233
1300
1150
( )
750
.
701
III ( )
506
II
405
Callata 1997; Karayotov 1994; Marinescu 2011.
IGCH. 481, 484522, 525, 527528, 548, 559, 561, 576, 623, 630, 637,
675, 676677, 681, 889, 891933, 941952, 955, 957972, 974, 1432; CH I.
87, 100; CH II. 100101; CH III. 68, 74; CH V. 40, 44; CH V. 48,
50; CH VII. 113, 117, 131, 141; CH VIII. 362, 493, 533; CH IX. 249;
Prokopov 2011: 3, 712, 14, 1721, 27, 29, 3132, 3537, 4142, 4549, 56,
5859, 65, 7778, 81, 86, 88, 91, 95, 9899, 102103, 106, 110, 113114, 121
122; Prokopov 2006: 5, 8, 2022, 26, 3233, 36, 3957, 5963, 67, 6972,
7477, 81, 8384, 8788, 9192, 94, 9698, 102104, 106, 110111, 116, 119,
121, 123124, 126, 130134, 136137, 139, 141, 145, 147, 152, 155, 159163,
169, 174175, 178180, 184185, 187, 192193, 195, 202204, 209211, 213,
217, 219220, 223224, 226, 229235, 237, 240, 242, 247253, 256259, 261,
264, 266, 270272, 275276, 282, 284, 287, 290, 292293, 295296, 298,
302303, 305306, 308, 310312, 317, 320325, 330, 332, 334.
10
11
.. ...
405
( )
401
-
364
-
280
( )
218
182
211
II
103
94
61
22
18
II
16
( )
16
14
IIIV
14
( )
10
V
6
III
5
VI
4
4
4
3
3
( )
3
( )
2
2
VI
2
I
1
II
1
1
: 43 679 .
. . ,
, , . ,
.
c . , 90% . , ,
, 8%.
. , ,
406
.. ...
407
133129 . .. 12. , ,
13.
. . , ,
. . ,
.. 700%.
,
.
III
,
(. IIIAB)
14:
4845
( )
1012
748
,
54
52
,
46
-
28
39
14
2
( )
2
2
III
1
,
1
2
: 6848 .
2011.
Bauslaugh 2000; Fisher 1985: 88; Callata 1996: 113151;
1985: 311.
14
IGCH. 647, 649, 652, 654, 659, 662, 664, 682, 683, 975980; CH VI.
45, 48; CH VIII. 533; Prokopov 2006: 6, 12, 24, 34, 54, 56, 60, 62, 98,
116, 131, 133134, 137, 147, 152, 174175, 178, 202, 240, 253, 272, 290, 306,
308, 325; Prokopov 2011: 64, 78, 89; Paunov 2010: 74105.
12
13
II (110). II:
-
408
.. ...
409
I . .. , 71%.
, .. , , , (
) 28%.
, , , , 1% ( 0,7%.).
, ,
, ,
.
I . ..15
, II I . ..
,
Crawford 1985: 220239; Paunov 2010.
15
410
42 . .. 31 . .., ,
, ,
16.
,
.
8070- I . .. I . ..
.
IV
(. IVAB)
. ,
. , ,
. 17.
.
. 22 00023 000 , .
20 00025 000 .
,
Paunov, Prokopov 2010.
Crawford 1985: 326333; Lockyear 2007; Paunov, Prokopov 2002: 12,
47, 1012, 14, 1625, 2632, 3437, 39, 4143, 4647, 4952, 5561, 6365,
6970, 7273; Paunov 2010: 173, 106109.
16
17
.. ...
411
.
, .
/
,
. ,
V, . ,
-
-, . .
.
- .
,
, . VI . , ,
. ,
. , ,
. ?
/ , . ,
.
,
.
.
.. . ,
,
. , . .
.
.. , . .
. Roma
,
412
.. ...
413
414
.. ...
415
, . .
7050 . I . ..
, ,
, .
, ,
,
. I . ..,
.
. .
IVB (18). IV:
,
-.
, ,
.
,
, ,
, ,
.
, , , , . ,
.
.
, , , .
, , . 42 . .. 31 . ..,
.
,
, , , . -
Summary
Transition from Late Hellenistic to Roman Monetary System in Thrace,
2nd1st Centuries BC
by I.Prokopov (Sofia)
The author discusses the fall of Alexander IIIs monetary system
which was functioning till Late Hellensitic times. The work is grounded
on the analysis of the coin hoards of precious metals found in the territory
of Thrace and in its adjacent contact zones. The approximate number of
registered gold and silver coins from hoards is about 100000.
The process of disintegrating of the old and the establishment of the
new monetary system is herein followed in four stages. First stage: only
late tetradrachms of Alexanders type are attested, mostly longly used, as
well as issues of other Macedonian kings and Hellenistic rulers. Second
stage: the majority of the coins are of the new styles: coins with the name
of the island of Thasos and of the Macedonian districts; coins of Maroneia,
Athenian pieces of the New Style and small amount of foreign rulers
coins. Alexanders type coins are much less often found. A varied mixture
of new style coins and their imitations is characteristic of the third stage.
Coins bearing both Greek and Latin inscriptions appeared in some hoards,
as well as Roman Republican denarii. Fourth stage: Roman Republican
denarii completely dominated the monetary system, sometimes mixed with
imitations, mostly of Thasian tetradrachms.
In historical terms, the establishment of the new monetary system was
realized after the battle at Phillipi in 42 BC and that at Actium in 31 BC.
416
.. ...
417
.. ...
419
, ,
3.
,
..
,
[]4 (. 23) []5.
( )
Price 960,
. (. 6472, 16,70 , (##)),
(. 1)1.
. 1. ,
, Price 960 (, . 6472) A
, ,
2.
., . .. , ,
1
- . (.: Karayotov 2007: 171. Fig. 46a).
2
, Price 947960 (tentative . Price: 179).
. 2. ,
, Price 1173 (, . 6089) A
Price 1173
(. 23). (. 2) . 6089, 16,41 , (##), (. 3; . ) .
6108, 16,59 .
(?) Price 1173a (Pl. 48), ,
,
, , . ,
, ,
. 2. ..
, []. Price 11731174
. 6,
, . 2. ,
Price: 179.
Price 11721173.
5
Price 1174.
6
.: Price 1174a. Pl. 48.
3
4
420
( A),
( A). , (?) ( A), ,
, .
,
7 , ,
. ,
,
, , []
[].
, , Odessus 200 . ., .8, , [], []
[]9.
.
. .. , ,
7
.,
(.: Price: 179).
, []
[].
8
Price: 191192.
9
Price 11751176.
, / ,
, ,
() ()
[] .: SNG BM 289; 1975: 36. . 27.
, . , (Price: 191).
.. ...
421
- ,
10,
( !) [...]11.
. .., .. ,
, 200190/188 . ..12 ,
, ,
terminus ante quem , .
. ..
. .., , (
)
, Bosphorus
Workshop13. .
.. ,
, ,
, 260 . ..14
, ( ) (. AAA),
,
.
,
. , (there are stater emissions...
which are derivate of those from Byzantium and Chalcedon...)15,
Olcay, Seyrig 1965. 193, 105191, 227234.
Olcay, Seyrig 1965. 7.
12
Olcay, Seyrig 1965: 2930; Price: 62.
13
Marinescu 2003: 131.
14
Marinescu 2000: 333334, 336; Marinescu 2003: 127129.
15
Marinescu 2003: 130.
10
11
422
.. ,
240 . .. (are much like those on the staters of
Byzantium and Chalcedon minted ca. 240 BC)16. ,
, (workshop) ,
.
,
, , , , t 17 . ..18
Summary
Silver Tetradrachms of Odessos of the Alexander Type with Signature
a Prototype of the Silver Issues of Dionysopolis
with Signature
by B.Ruseva (Sofia)
The article presents a tetradrachm of Dionysopolis, struck with types
and name of Alexander the Great, from the Numismatic Collection from
the Numismatic Collection of the National Institute of Archaeology at the
Academy of Sciences of Bulgaria in Sofia (Price 960), and signed with the
name of city magistrate Leontiskos.
This coin belongs to the issues, by which the Dionyspolis ends its
imitative issues of the Alexander type. It was struck, supposedly at
Dionyspolis at the beginning of the II cent. B.C., when other Black Sea
poleis also truck their own coins of Alexander type, signed either with full
of with abridged names of their coin magistrates.
1975 . . , 1975.
Marinescu 2003: 130.
2004: 1931.
18
. : 2008: 123.
16
17
.. ...
423
2004 .
// , . 2004. 1. . 1931.
2008 . // , . 2008. 4. . 123.
Karayotov 2007 Karayotov I. Le monnayage de Messambria et les
Monnayages dApollonia, Odessos et Dionysopolis // Ancient Greek Colonies in
the Black Sea 2. Oxf., 2007. Vol. 1. P. 127174. (BAR Intern. Series; 1675 (I)).
Marinescu 2000 Marinescu C. The Posthumous Lysimachi Coinage and the
Dual Monetary System at Byzantium and Chalcedon in the Third Century BC. //
XII Internationaler Numismatischer Kongress, Berlin, 2000. Akten = Proceedings
= Actes. B., 2000. 1. S. 333336.
Marinescu 2003 Marinescu C. From Byzantium to the Black Sea. Dies,
Engravers and the Production of Posthumous Lyssimachi Coinages During
the 32 c. BC. // Acta Musei Varnaensis. 2003. II. P. 127139.
Olcay, Seyrig 1965 Olcay N., Seyrig H. Le trsor de Mektepini en Phrygie.
P., 1965.
100
.
. , , ,
.
, .
, . , : , 1, 2, , () .
,
. , , , ,
(. )3 4. , , , ,
, . , , , . .
,
, - .
..
,
,
. .
,
.
, 5. ,
, .
, ,
,
,
, .
,
, 1950 ., .6.
,
,
7.
. : .
.. (. 300280 . ..8); . ..9; .
..10; . ..11
,
. .., .. 218 . 217 . 168/7 . ..
. Canarache 1950: 213257.
Canarache 1950: 213257.
7
1995.
8
Canarache 1950: 218.
9
Regling 1906: 259265; Knechtel 1919: 2534.
10
1953: 5358; 1995: 140, 147.
11
Youroukova 1977: 105121; 1992: 160.
5
6
1956: 2230.
1956: 2230.
3
Mihailov 1970: 41.
4
1985: 4750; Mihailov 1997: 5003.
1
2
425
426
.12.
.
, ,
. 253252 .
..13,
, , , , .
. ,
()
. 350339 . ..
-
.
, 14. . , , 218 . .. .
, . .
15.
, .
, , , ., ., ., ., .,
.,
, , . ..
,
.
, , .
, .
, Regling 1906: 259265; Knechtel 1919: 2534.
1999: 36.
14
2003.
15
Manov 2007.
12
13
..
427
, , , .
, ,
. , . ,
.
, .. . (. ?).
, . 5060 . ,
, , , , .
, -,
, , , ,
- . (. ) .
(. ).
. . , ,
- - . , (
), . , .
.
,
, , .
, ,
. , , . .
, , . 19
,
428
(. I.1), , ,
. V 29 16.
.., 17. . , , , , ,
18.
,
, 19. , ,
20, , (. I.2).
, , , , , , 21. ..,
, tanu
(- ) saka (- ).
,
( ). .. ,
22. , , , -
, , . ,
2006: 83.
, , () kanas , .
.
18
.: 1988: 85.
19
1956: 29.
20
2006: 8193.
21
, , .: 1956: 56.
22
1956: 25.
16
..
429
,
, , , ,
. ,
, .
, / (. I.3) /
23 (. I.4). , .
(-) ,
/ ,
1953 . . ,
24. , ,
.
, 25 (. I.5),
: , , ,
..
26. ..,
, (), , ,
27. ,
, ugra
saka (, ), agra saka
, , , , ,
,
28. .
17
2002.
. , . .
, ().
25
: 1956: 26.
26
Manov 2002; 2006.
27
1956: 26.
28
1956: 26.
23
24
430
, 29.
,
30, , .
.. ..
, , ,
, () (),
,
(. I.6).
, , ,
. ,
, ,
V.
31, ,
, (. I.7).
, ( xar aspa ),
32.
()
.
, , 33. , ,
, 34. ,
, .
.. , ,
airya ariya , , Manov 2002: 46.
2009: 73. 89.
31
Manov 2002: 46.
32
1956: 23.
33
2003: 11; 2005: 2527.
34
2009: 7273, 47.
..
35. ,
. , r l Ailis, ,
( ), ,
( ) 36. ,
,
- ,
,
(. I.8). , - (), , - .
, ..,
, , , .
()
, ,
, 37.
,
.
, 168/167 . .., .
. , , 38. .39
, , ,
, .
. ,
29
30
431
1956: 28.
1956: 28 .
37
1956: 28 .
38
1953: 5358.
39
1995: 142.
35
36
432
, , , .
, 40,
.
.,
, , ,
. ..
,
,
, . ,
. ,
(. I.9), - 41.
, ,
,
V ,
179 . ..42 ,
- ,
43, . , V (221179 . ..)
, , , ,
V
179 . ..44 ,
V , :
,
Manov 2001; 2004.
.: 2002: 140.
42
Manov 2009; 2009.
43
.: 2002: 140.
44
Manov 2009; 2009.
40
41
..
433
I. 1. /
. 2. (). 3. () /
. 4. () /
. 5.
() / .
6. / , .
7. / ,
. 8. , /
. 9. .
434
V, , , 45. , 46.
( )
(sara ), .. , ,
, , 47, , ,
.
, ,
. . . ..
,
, . 218 . ..,
. ,
.
,
.
. 168/167 . .., .
, ,
.
Summary
Scythian Kings in Dobroudzha
by M.Manov (Sofia)
For more than 100 years different bronze coins of chance finds in the
area of Dobrudzha with the names of six rulers and the title of king caused
many debates among historians and numismatists.
These six rulers are with typical Scythian names: Kanitas, Tanusas or
Tanusakes, Acrosas or Akrosakes, Charaspes, Ailis and Sariakes. None of
these kings is mentioned in the works of ancient authors, which significantly
impedes study of their political activity. Only two of them Kanitas and
Sariakes, are mentioned in inscriptions respectively from Odesos and from
cape Kaliakra.
Manov 2009: 224. Fig. 4; 2009: 240. . 6.
1985: 4750; Mihailov 1997: 5003.
47
1956: 24.
45
46
..
435
1995 . V .
.. , 1995.
1953 . , , ,
// . 1953. IX.
. 5358.
2009 . // , . 2009. 5. C. 7176.
2002 . // .
2002. 4: Studia in Honorem Ivani Karaiotov. . 130147.
2003 . . , 2003. (- :
).
1985 . // . 1985. 3. . 4750.
1999 .
281218 . .. , 1999. (: ; 4).
2002 . // Numismatica Bulgarica. 2002. I, 1. C. 1518.
2003 M. - ,
// . 2003. 1.
C. 181195.
2004 .
// , . 2004.
1. C. 3339.
2005 M. //
, . 2005. 2. C. 2527.
2006 M. // , . 2006. 3, 1: Studia in
436
., .
Via Diagonalis
( . , o, . )
2006 . . -
2 .
.
( . ),
(. ),
10- - . 3.
(Via militaris / Via diagonalis)4.
500 1 - , -
( , 70 50 : GPS: 41.9144; 26.1423) , . , 130 5 Castra Rubra. Castra Rubra,
., 6
, 5,5 - . , . 1
- .
() - . (-, ) ,
. - .,
.
2
, 2005: 7274.
3
, . (
, ), .
4
via militaris / via diagonalis . . (Jireek 1877: 4647; :
Todorov 1937: 20ff. Fig. 9; Gren 1941: 3133). .
: URL:http://www.seecorridors.eu/?w_
p=23&w_l=2&w_c=3
5
, 1888: 35.
438
., .. ...
439
6, , .
7.
,
, - .
-,
. 2471.
:
..: ,
. , MGN ( MGN /MA ),
.
..: (prora) , .
[I]MP, [PIVS].
, ac, 27,7/29,2 , 19,62 , 12 ,
7 . (. 1).
, 8. 42 38 . ..9
.,
( III, 2, 10) (. 2), 39 / 38 36 . ..11
, , (. Lilybaeum(?) 2 12),
13 , 4045%14.
,
(. 67 . ..), 15.
(48 . ..) ,
. 13
, 2009: 471474; 2011: 718.
, 1888: 3536.
8
Bahrfeldt 1909: 6770. Taf. I.37; Grant 1946: 2224; Crawford 1974:
479/1; RPC I. 671.
9
Sear 1998: 202203. 336; Woytek 2003: 499501. 281.
10
Martini 1995: 151162. 632633.
11
Martini 1995: 50 (n. 249).
12
Martini 1995: 2021.
13
RPC I: 146; Sear 1998: 203204.
14
Bahrfeldt 1909: 7677; Martini 1995: 243247.
15
.: Miltner 1952: Cols. 22132250; Powell, Welch 2002.
6
7
. 1.
.
(15 45 . ..). . ,
(. ). , 43 . ..
praefectus classis et
440
orae maritimae, ex Senato consulto (App. Bell. Civ. IV. 84; Dio. Cass.
LV. 10. 616). , ,
(Dio. Cass. LV. 17. 2)
lex Pedia. 42 . ..
.
.
( ), 3836 . ..
17, 3
36 . .. Naulochus
18.
(Dio. Cass. XLIX. 11. 1; App. Bell. Civ. V. 14. 133144),
, ,
19. , 35 .
.. ,
(Dio. Cass. XLIX. 1718).
c , ,
. ,
, (Morgantina
25 , 20), , 21,
22 23,
24. , / 25.
, ( IRRCHBg.).
Sear 1998: 200.
Sear 1998: 200.
18
Miltner 1952: Cols. 22332241; Sear 1998: 152; Stone 2002: 135165.
19
Sear 1998: 201204. 332336; Martini 1995: 20, 55.
20
Buttrey, Erim, Groves, Holloway 1989: 126. 691692. Pl. 48.
21
Bori-Breskovi, Popovi 2006. 14691470.
22
Martini 1995: 139. 502; 143. 587, 612 Vindonissa;
Kraay: 1962: 54. 1415; 70. 179.
23
Martini 1995: XXV.
24
Voegtli 1993. 636 .
25
(:
Crawford 1974. 511/14; Sear 1998. 333335ab). ,
, 21 .
10 000 ( .).
16
17
., .. ...
441
- :
1. , . .
. , . 211206 . 187175 . ..26, 32 ,
41,80 (?), . -, . -94827.
2. , . .
. , . 169158 . ..28, 26 24 ,
15,92 , . -, . 2461, 1988 .29
3. , . .
. , . 169158 . ..30, 28 ,
13,41 , . -, . 2542,
1989 .31
4. Heraclea Syntica, . , . .
. , . 169158 . ..32, max 31 ,
34,30 . -, . 11, 2006 . (
., . ).
5. e , . .
. , . 179170 . ..33, 28 30 , 20,13 ,
. -, . 19 ( ., . ).
6. e , . ( .., ).
7.
Augustae . ,
. , ( )
, 34.
, .
( ),
, via diagonalis, : Crawford 1974: 56/2 182.
.: 1981: 221223. 7. . .
28
: Crawford 1974. 182.
29
.: Filipova, Paunov, Prokopov 2009: 197.
30
: Crawford 1974: 198b.
31
.: Filipova, Paunov, Prokopov 2009: 198.
32
: Crawford 1974: 182/1.
33
: Crawford 1974: 169/3.
34
-, 19972000 .,
.: Paunov 2013.
26
27
442
,
I . .. . 1311 . ..,
4 . .. .35, 36.
, 37. 38, - (68 .).
, .
( )
3040 I . ..
, 39.
Summary
As of Sextus Pompeius from Via Diagonalis in Thrace
by E.Paunov, M.Slavova (Sofia / Haskovo, Bulgaria)
This paper discusses a stray coin of the Late Roman Republic from
South Thrace. It was discovered by chance in the locality Bostanite near the
village of Oryahovo, Lyubimets area, region of Haskovo, South-Eastern
Bulgaria. The site lies on the main Roman military road in Thrace via
diagonalis, near mutatio Castra Rubra, not far from Hadrianople.
The coin itself is a bronze as of Sextus Pompeius (27.7 29.2 mm,
19.62 g, axis 12 h, Haskovo museum, inv. no. 2471. Fig. 1). It is struck in
Sicily between 42 and 38 B.C.40, belonging to issue III, group 2, series B
after the typology of Rodolfo Martini41.
Syme 1999: 203205; . 2012: 459460.
, 61 .,
, , T. Iulius Justus (. CIL III, 6123 = 14207; IGBulg. V. 5691;
AE (1912). 193; AE (1999). 1397).
37
, , .
38
.
- , . Carnuntum
(Vondrovec 2007).
39
. Prokopov 2000: 378386; Paunov, Prokopov 2012; Paunov 2013.
40
Crawford 1974: 479/1 = RPC 671.
41
Martini 1995: 151162. 632633.
35
36
., .. ...
443
., 2009 ., .
, ,
. , // 2008 . , 2009. . 471474.
2011 . // Castra Rubra 1. = (
, 12). , 2011. . 750.
2012 .
, . 100 . . . 98/117 . . . // HPAKEOY
THPO AIN. Studia in Honorem Iliae Prokopov Sexagenario ab Amicis
et Discipulis Dedicata. , 2012. P. 443488.
, 2005 ., . 2004 . // 2004 . , 2005. . 7274.
, 1888 ., .
// . , 1888. , : .
1981 . // .
, 1981. . I. . 218261.
Bahrfeldt 1909 Bahrfeldt M. Die letzten Kupferprgungen unter der rmischen Republik // Numizmatische Zeitschrift. 1909. 42, (Neue Folge 2). S. 6777.
Bori-Breskovi, Popovi 2006 Bori-Breskovi B., Popovi P. Coins of the
Roman Republic. Collections of the National Museum in Belgrade and Belgrade
University. Belgrade, 2006.
Buttrey, Erim, Groves, Holloway 1989 Buttrey T.V., Erim K., Groves T.D.,
Holloway R.R. Morgantina Studies II: The Coins. Princeton, 1989.
Crawford 1974 Crawford M.H. Roman Republican Coinage. Cambr., 1974.
Vols. III.
Filipova, Paunov, Prokopov 2009 Filipova S., Paunov E., Prokopov I.
The Numismatic Collection of the Regional Historical Museum at Kyustendil
(Ancient Ulpia Pautalia). Pt. I: Greek, Thracian Macedonian, Roman Republican
and Roman Provincial Coins. Sofia, 2009 (Coin Collections and Coin Hoards
from Bulgaria. II).
Prokopov 2000: 378365; Paunov, Prokopov (in print).
42
444
I . ..
.
(. 1).
,
1. . ()
:
..: , ,
.
..: . .
. 1. . (: 1946: 63. 1)
.
..2 ,
, .
, (. 23) ,
1946: 6263.
1912: 97129.
1
2
446
. 3.
/ , ,
, ,
. .3. ,
,
( ) ,
, / TOM, ,
, 4.
,
5. , , , ,
,
, ,
. ,
, 1912: 97. 1713. . III,9; .: . 2.
1912: 98. 1731.
5
1995: 105106.
3
.. I . .. ...
447
, 6.
, , , / , , .
,
.. - .
. 3 , , . :
.: ,
, . . 9,0 , ,
, ,
.
.: , ( ),
( ). . -
.
: . 7,75 , : 21
21,5 , 4,5 .
, , , ,
. (?) , ///(?).
I, . . , ,
.
, ,
, A ( ), -,
1995: 105106.
448
.
,
. ,
, I, , ,
.
.
, / ,
II I . .. , , VI , , , ,
. , , .
VI
, , ,
. , .
VI ,
, ,
.
VI, , ,
,
. ,
,
. , ,
/ .
.. I . .. ...
449
, I, , , 7.
,
, ,
, 8.
, , . ,
, ,
, .
,
, .
Summary
Towards the Attribution of the Round Overstrike Wheel with Spoke and
Teeth Used in the Western Pontic Coast in the First century B.C.
by S.Topalov (Sofia)
T.Gerasimov, who was the first to study the overstrikes on the Thracian
coins, has published a poorly conserved coin of the city Tomi, represented
as head of Zeus TOMI, bell-like cap between two stars with the
overstrike wheel with spoke and teeth. This overstrike was attributed as
belonging to Mesambria.
Two monographs, devoted to the overstrikes on the Western Pontic
Cities, hae shown that Mesambria never had such an overstrike. Basing on
the coins from the Bulgarian collections with this overstrike as well as on
the good piece from the personal collection of the author this Tomi-coin
could be better attributed as head of Zeus TOMI, protomes of two of two
horses to the right, two stars (symbols of Dioskures) over them.
The author would like to represent the extended description of the
.: 2002: 131185;
: 2009: 121181, . 161165.
8
1995: 96106,
(. 100),
(. 104).
7
450
overstrike as wheel with four spokes, from which radial rays go, between
the spokes letter I, in the rest of the sectors traces from the letters I, T
and R, i.e. possibly of an abbreviated designation of the city-name .
The overstrike has been attributed as belonging to Istria as well as the
earliest coins of the type wheel with four spokes IT; its usage can
be dated to the time after the victory of Rome over Mithridates VI. The
reasons of its appearance are also considered in the article.
1995 .. VI I .
.. , 1995.
1946 .
// . 1946. XV. . 5181.
1912 . . , 1912.
1995 . .
VI . . .. , 1996.
1997 .
, IIII . . ..
, 1997.
2002 . IIII . . . .
, 2002.
2009 .
II . . .. I . .. , 2009.
.., ..
I III . .. (2009 .)
2009 . ,
127 I III . .. ,
; .
:
1) I (93123) 4 . ( 14),
2) II (123132) 3 . ( 57),
3) (131154) 3 . ( 810),
4) II (174210) 24 . ( 1134),
5) III (211226) 48 . ( 3582),
6) III (227233) 3 . ( 8385),
7) III (229231) 8 . ( 8693),
8) IV (233234) 2 . ( 9495),
9) (234238) 31 . ( 96126).
, ( 127).
, 1, ,
I . .. 238 . 1989 . ..2 14 , I
III . .. 233238 .,
239241 ., .. 239 242 . ..3
, 20072008: 5154.
1989: 196.
3
1989: 200.
1
2
452
. 28 ,
I .
10.
,
III
220
1
, I . 238 . ..
(19101912)
11.
( 1949)
III 14
12.
(1972)
II 10,
III 4
13.
-
( 1935)
II,
III
14.
( 1914)
II 3,
III 67
15.
(1868)
,
II,
III
16.
(1845)
III
17.
(1850)
-
(2004)
, ,
II
III
III
19.
(1849)
20.
,
(1852)
I,
II,
,
,
II,
III,
III
I
II,
,
,
II,
III,
III
1.
(1978)
2,
5,
2,
I 3,
II 4,
I 16,
II 2
129130
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
(1846)
(131154)
(1960)
I 3,
II 6,
11,
69
170
--
( 1917)
1,
3
(154170)
(1949)
1,
II 8
204
( 1884)
II,
II
(1834)
(174210)
,
II
7,
155216
II 21,
III 7
(1958)
(1941)
I 2,
III 4
(174210)
220
,
2000: 110117; 2002:
252259; Abramzon, Frolova, Gorlov 2001: 296
303; , ,
20072008: 298302
1880: 8; , , 20072008:
303
, ,
2000; 2002: 260
269; Abramzon, Frolova,
Gorlov 2001b; ,
20072008:
304309
1941: 240. . 1;
2000: 92; , 20072008:
602. 53
1950: 79.;
1974: 7374;
, 2007
2008: 311312
1884: 19;
, 2007
2008: 600. 40
1880: 3536;
, 2007
2008: 597. 2
1993;
2000: 8890; ,
20072008:
315319
1950: 80; 1974: 74; ,
20072008:
319320
18.
453
1935: 188.
20; ,
20072008: 601. 50
222
Thompson 1949: 379381;
, 2007
2008: 603. 69
225
, , 2000; Abramzon, Frolova, Gorlov 2001: 185192;
, , 2002: 270273; , 20072008:
325327
225
1935: 188. 23;
, 2007
2008: 608. 58
225
Bruder Egger 1914: XLVI.
Taf. IXXI. 508577;
, 2007
2008: 322324
(211226)? 1868 (1870):
XVIIIXIX; 1880:
4748; 2000:
8788; , 20072008: 314315
(211226) , 1846:
121; 1974: 74
(. 64); ,
20072008: 597.
5
(211226) 1880: 47; 2000: 87; ,
20072008: 313
228
2005: 34;
, 2007
2008: 332
(227233) 1880: 2728.
3; ,
20072008: 328
(227233)
1880: 29.
4; ,
20072008: 331
454
21.
(1867)
(227233)
1880: 10,
6; 1978: 36.
3; ,
20072008: 331
28.
(2009)
(1913)
(227233)
, 1914:
344; 1915: 137;
1957: VII.
1729; 1978: 37.
10; , 20072008: 602. 51
2000: 94; , 20072008:
611. 130
2000: 94; , 20072008:
610. 121
I 4,
II 3,
3,
II 24,
III 48,
III 3,
III 8,
IV 2,
32
234238
22.
II,
,
,
II,
III,
III
II,
III,
III
23.
24.
(1998)
,
(
1990-)
25.
(1863)
26.
(1984)
27.
(1987)
II,
III,
III
II,
III,
III,
III,
IV
II,
III,
IV,
II 2,
I 5,
II 2,
7,
II 8,
III 32,
III 13,
III 7,
IV 2,
28
, III .
.. 7,
II 1,
II 1,
I 29,
II 2,
3,
II 76,
III 160,
III 34,
III 38,
IV 13,
128,
2,
1,
. 22
(227233)
(233234)
(234238)
1880: 910.
5; ,
20072008: 333334
238
1989: 203204;
, 2007
2008: 334352
238
455
1
II
III . .., . 28
II, II ( 57), III ( 817), III ( 1823), ( 2528).
. , , 420 . .. =
123/124 . .. ( 33) , II
, . , , -, II TEIMAI BACIEC
KOTYOC TOY ACOYPOY4.
II, - ,
174186 .
5. II . .. , ,
..6, II
III . .., , 193 . ..,
II ,
( 1237).
III (211226). ,
.
, , 220 . .. ..
1997: I. 135, 141.
1997: I. . LXXXIII.14.
6
2007: 235.
4
5
456
, 2005 .,
: ! , , , ,
, , , , ,
, ,
, , , 517 ,
7. 220 . ..
, -
8.
IIIII . .. , ,
II III . ..
, , ( 12411243, 12461248)9.
.. , 220 236 . .., 220 .10
..11 .
220 . ..
III . .. 239 . ..
12. ,
13, ,
230- 14.
..15 ,
221 . .. ( 54. . 56).
III , . ,
, 220 ..., ,
2007: 227238.
2007: 235.
9
2007: 235.
10
1968: 5152.
11
2007: 235.
12
1997: 75.
13
1998: 136.
14
2007: 235.
15
2007: 235236.
7
8
457
, 2005 .
III, 220 221 .
( 1008) III ; , II .
III ,
.
III 218219 . . ..16 , : 1)
218219 . .. ,
17; 2) 222226 . (?) , 18; 3) 222
226 . ,
; 19. ,
, , III
. -,
, ,
. , -,
, .
III . :
1987 . 20 , , 21. , , 217218 218219 .
III . III .
.. ,
: , 215 . .. III,
3020%;
1997: II. 1214.
1997: II. . XIII.12.
18
1997: II. . XXI.18.
19
1997: II. . XXI.18.
20
, 20072008: 740. . 105. 121.
21
, 20072008: 740. . 105. 120.
16
17
458
22.
()
III ? , 217218 218219 .,
,
216 . ..23 III 218219 . . ,
1941 . III 220 . ..24
222 . ,
25. 225 . ..
..26, 27 1972 . 28. 222226 .
III ( ) , ;
29.
III,
, ,
, . , , 1, ( 2528), , .. 234238 .:
1. 1863 ., 30.
2. 1984 ., 31.
3. 1987 ., 32.
4. 2009 ., , .
459
22
23
1954: 1825.
1997: II. 29.
35
1997: II. 29. . XXVIII.1119.
36
1880: 16. 11.
37
1989: 196. 8.
38
Frolova 1979; 1989: 200.
39
, , 1972: 89.; 1978: 1040;
, , 2002: 319336; , 20072008:
358355.
40
1989: 203204.
41
Frolova, Ireland 1995: 2142; 1996: 4472.
33
34
460
2
III
(1984, 1987) (2009)
(1984)
(1987)
(2009)
III
(211226)
32
160
48
(234238)
28
128
33
106
517
127
2009 .
I (93123) 13, , ..42, 97/98103/104 . ..
I
( 4) , -, 108115 .43
II (123132),
: 1) , ( 56); 2) ( 7).
, , , 125 . ..44
(131154)
( 810).
II (174210)
186196 .
( 11) 23 ( 12
34). , 186 . .. II
:
( * ), ( *) (144
= 3 = = ).
(48)
q (96)45, .
.
III (211226) 48 ( 3582).
. , .. 211226 ., ..
1997: I. 245246. . XLII.112.
1997: I. 255. . XLV.1619.
44
1997: I. 270. . XLIII.15.
45
1938: 287306; Zograf 1938: 99f.; 1977: 150180; 1997: I. 149156.
461
46. , : 31 ( 3565) 17 ( 66
82). 51 BACIEC PHCKOYOPIC, , , ,
218 .47
III (227233)
8385. ,
II (174210)
III (211226)48.
III (229231) III49,
8 ( 8693).
IV (233234)
( 9495). .
(234238) 96126. , , :
, , * ( 96)
(?) , 50. , ,
.
(, II, III,
III), .. , 234235 .
,
;
: *, , *. ..,
, .
,
. , ( *, *)
51.
1997: I. 147156.
1997: II, . 12.
48
1997: II. 25.
49
1997: II. 26.
50
1997: II. 229. . XXXII.1718; XXXIII.13.
51
1997: II. 3739.
42
46
43
47
462
2009 . 130 .
1984 1987 .: 170 , 500 ( III .
.. 150 ). 238 . .., . 1997 . ..
,
52. : ..
1988 .53 .
.. 239 .
V 239241 . , , 239 241 .54 , 238 . ..
.
251 .,
, 238 251 . ..
, .
, 2009 . III . .. ,
, , 238 . ..,
, , .. 234 238 .,
, . III (238244) .
239241 .55
56.
463
I (93123)
II. 97/98103/104 .
.. TI IOYIOY BACIEC CAYPOMATOY
, , . .
.. ; MH. .
.: BMC Pont. 1889: Pl. XIV.3; 1884: . XXVIII.165;
Frolova 1979: l. VIII.2124; 1997: I. 246. . XLII.112.
1. ; .
2. .
3. .
C IV. 108115 .
.. [BACIEC CAYPOMATOY]
II . .
.. ; , ;
MH. .
.: 1997: I. 255. . XLV.1619.
4. ; .
II (123132)
123124 .
.. BACIEC KOTYO
II . .
.. ; MH. .
.: 1986: . 20.481; 1997: I. 271. . LII.23.
5. ; .. 28373.
.: 1997: I. 271. . LII.23.
6. .
.: 1997: I. 271. . LII.21, 24; LIII.3.
125 . ..
.. BACIEC KOTYO
II ; . .
464
.. ; ,
; MH. .
.: 1884: . XXIX.173; Frolova 1979: l. XVI.2428;
1986: . 20.488; 1997: I. 270. . LIII.15.
7. .
(131154)
132 .
.. BACIEC POIMHTAKOY
. .
.. ; MH. .
.: 1986: . 22.519; 1997: I. 283284.
. LX.1718.
8. ; .
133134 .
.. BACIEC POIMHTAKOY
; . .
.. ; MH. .
.: 1884: . XXIX.188; 1951: . XLVII.18;
Frolova 1979: Pl. XXIII.1; 1986: . 22.522; 1997: I.
283284. . LXII.121.
9. ; .
.. .
.. .
10. ; .
II (174210)
186196 .
.. BACIEC CAYPOMATOY
II . .
.. ;
465
, ; *. .
.: 1997: I. 329. . XC.7.
11. ; .. 28653; , .. .
.: 1997: I. 323. . .7.
.. BACIEC CAYPOMATOY
II . .
.. ;
; . .
.: 1884: . XXXI.246248; 1951:
. XLVIII.14; Frolova 1979: Pl. L.68; 1986: . 29.618
618; 1997: I. 323325. . XC.1419; XCI.118; XCII.118;
XCIII.17.
12. ; .
13. ; .
14. ; .
15. .
16. ; .
17. .
18. ; .
19. ; .
20. .
21. ; .
22. ; .
23. ; .. .
24. .
25. ; ; ..
.
26. .
27. ; .
28. .
29. ; .. .
30. .
31. .
32. .
33. .
34. .
466
III (211226)
211213 .
.. BACIEC PHCKOYOPIC
III . .
.. ; ;
*. .
.: 1884: . XXXI.271273; BMC. 13 1889:
Pl. XVII.3; Frolova 1979: Pl. L.2123; 1951: . XLIX.1112;
1986: . 31.645; 1997: II. 208. . XIV.710.
35. .
36. .
214215 .
14.
.. .
.. .
.: Frolova 1979: Pl. L.2526; 1997: II. 208. . XIV.11
37. ; BACIEC PHCKOYOPIC.
38. ; BACIEC PHCKOYOPIC.
216217 .
.. .
.. .
.: 1884: . XXXI.272; 1997: II. 208209.
. XIV.1520; XV.112.
39. ; BACIEC PHCKOYOPIC.
40. ; BACIEC PHCKOYOPIC.
41. ; BACIEC PHCKOYOPIC.
42. ; BACIEC PHCKOYOPIC.
43. ; BACIEC PHCKOYOPIC.
44. ; BACIEC PHCKOYOPIC.
45. ; BACIEC PHCKOYOPIC.
46. ; BACIEC PHCKOYOPIC.
47. ; BACIEC PHCKOYOPIC.
467
218 .
.. .
.. .
.: 1997: II. 209. . XV.1316; XVI.117.
48. ; BACIEC PHCKOYOPIC.
49. ; .. 48.
.. .
.. .
.: 1997: II. 209. . XVI.8.
50. ; BACIEC PHCKOYOPIC .
219 . ..
.. .
.. .
.: 1997: II. 210. . XVI.16.
51. ; BACIEC PHCKOYOPIC.
52. ; BACIEC PHCKOYOPIC.
53. ; BACIEC PHCKOYOPIC.
.. .
.. .
.: 1997: II. 210. . XVI.20.
54. ; BACIEC PHCKOYOPIC.
220222 . ..
.. .
.. .
.: 1997: II. 210. . XVII.17.
55. ; BACIEC PHCKOYOPIC.
56. ; BACIEC PHCKOYOPIC.
57. ; BACIEC PHCKOYOPIC.
468
222224 . ..
.. .
.. .
.: 1997: II. 210. . XVII.8.
58. ; BACIEC PHCKOYOPIC. .. 4754.
.. .
.. .
.: 1997: II. 210. . XVII.821.
59. ; BACIEC PHCKOYOPIC.
60. .
61. ; .. (?).
62. ; .
63. ; .
64. ; .
65. ; .
218219 .
.. BACIEC PHCKOYOPIC
III . .
.. ; ;
*. .
.: 1884: . XXXII.281; 1951: . XLIX.10;
Frolova 1979: Pl. LII.2728; 1986: . 31.648; 1997:
II. 212. . XVIII.1419; XIX.13.
66. ; * ?
67. .
68. .
69. .
70. .
71. .
72. .
73. .
469
222225 .
.. BACIEC PHCKOYOPIC
III . .
.. ; ;
*. .
.: 1884: . XXXII.278; 1986: . 31.649;
1997: II. 212. . XX.922; XXI.19.
74. .
75. .
76. .
77. .
78. .
.. .
.. ; ; *. .
79. .
80. ; .. 79.
.. .
.. ; ;
*. .
.: 1997: II. 212. . XX.20.
81. .
.. .
.. .
82. ; .
III (227233)
.. BACIEC KOTYOC
III ; . .
.. ; ;
*. .
.: 1884: . XXXII.295; 1951: .
470
XLIX.14; Frolova 1979: Pl. LVII.8, 10, 13, 19, 26; LVIII.2; 1986:
. 32.664; 1997: II. 220221. . XXVI.418; XXVII.112.
83. .
84. .
85. BACIEC [KOTYOC].
III (229231)
.. BACIEC AYPOMATOY
. .
.. ; ;
*. .
.: 1997: II. 224. . XXVIII.2122; XXIX.45.
86. .
87. .
88. .
89. .
90. .
91. .
92. .
93. . BA[CIEC AYP]OMATOY.
IV (233234)
.. BACIEC PHCKOYOPIC
; . .
.. ; ;
*. .
.: 1884: . XXXII.309; Frolova 1979: Pl. LI.21;
1986: . 33.673; 1997: II. 225. . XX.24.
94. .
95. .
(234238)
234235 .
.. Y
; . .
471
.. ; ; *. .
.: 13 1889: 74. 4. Pl. XVII.12; Frolova 1979: Pl. L.30
38; LI.34; 1986: . 33.678; 1997: II. 228229.
. XXII.116.
96. .
236238 .
.. Y
; . .
.. ;
; *, * *. .
.: Frolova 1979: Pl. LI.10; 1951: . XLIX.18; 1986: . 34. 683; 1997: II. 229230. . XXIII.420;
XXXIV.118; XXXV.12.
97. ; *.
98. ; *.
99. ; *.
100. ; *.
101. ; *.
102. ; * .
103. ; *.
104. ; *.
105. ; *.
106. ; *.
107. ; *.
108. ; *.
109. ; *.
110. ; *. Frolova 1979: Pl. LI.11.
111. ; *.
.. Y
; . .
.. ; ;
* . .
.: Frolova 1979: Pl. LIII.19; 1997: II. 230231.
. XXV.39.
472
112. ; .
..
; . .
.. ; ; * *.
.
.: Frolova 1979: Pl. LII.1617; 1986: . 33.681;
1997: II. 232. . XXVII.415.
113. ; .
114. .
115. ; .
116. ; .
117. ; .
118. ; .
119. ; .
120. ; .
121. ; .
122. ; .
123. ; .
124. ; .
125. ; .
.. Y
. .
.. ; ;
*. .
.: Frolova 1979: Pl. LIII.19; 1986: . 34.686; 1997: II. . XXVII.415.
126. .
.. .
.. .
127. ; .. .
473
474
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
II
17
21
III
18
22
19
23
20
24
475
476
25
29
IV
26
30
27
31
28
32
33
37
34
38
35
30
36
40
477
478
41
45
VI
42
46
43
47
44
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
VII
479
480
57
61
VIII
58
62
59
63
60
64
65
69
IX
66
70
67
71
68
72
481
482
73
77
74
78
75
79
76
80
81
85
XI
82
86
83
87
84
88
483
484
89
93
90
94
91
92
95
96
97
101
XII
XIII
98
102
99
103
100
104
485
486
97
101
XIV
98
102
99
100
103
104
113
117
XV
114
118
115
119
116
120
487
488
489
Summary
A Hoard of Bronze Bosporan Coins
of the late 1st3rd Century AD from Panticapaeum (2009)
by M.G.Abramzon (Magnitogorsk), N.F.Fedoseev (Kerch)
121
122
123
124
125
XVI
126
127
, 20072008 .., ..
. ; , 20072008. . 1:
18342005 . ( ; Supplementum 2).
, , 2000 .., .., .. I . .. II . .. (, 1978 .) //
. 2000. 3. . 110117.
, , 2000 .., .., .. II . ..
// . 2000. 4. . 6068.
, , 2000 .., .., .. IIIII . .. . //
. 2000. 4. . 6872.
, , 2002 .., .., .. : ( ). ., 2002.
, , , , 2006 ..,
.., .., .., ..
: -
. / , 2006. . 1.
, , , 2007 .., .., .., .. 234253 .
.. (1988) // . 2007. 2. . 60109.
1997 .. . ., 1997.
1986 .. . , 1986.
2005 .. III
// : . , 2005. . 34.
2000 ..
// . 2000. 2. . 8697.
490
491
1996 .. III .
.. 238 . .. (, 1987) // . 1996. 2.
. 4472.
1997 .. ( I .
.. IV . .. ., 1997. . III.
1993 .. // . 1993. 3. . 4354.
Abramzon, Frolova, Gorlov 2001 Abramzon M.G., Frolova N.A., Gorlov Yu.V. Two Hoards of Bosporan Coins // RN. 2001. 157. . 287303.
Abramzon, Frolova, Gorlov 2001b Abramzon M.G., Frolova N.A., Gorlov Yu.V. A Hoard of Bosporan Gold Staters of the 2nd Century AD from the City
Site Krasnobatareinoye // ACSS. 2001. Vol. 7, Nos. 34. P. 169184.
Abramzon, Frolova, Gorlov 2001c Abramzon M.G., Frolova N.A., Gorlov Yu.V. A Hoard of Bosporan Gold Staters of the 2nd and 3rd Centuries AD from
the Village of Kazanskaya // ACSS. 2001. Vol. 7, N 34. P. 185193.
Brder Egger 1914 Brder Egger. Auktions-Katalog. XLVI. Wien, 1914.
Frolova 1979 Frolova N.A. The Coinage of the Kingdom of Bosporus A.D.
69238. Oxf., 1979. (BAR International Series; 56).
Frolova, Ireland 1995 Frolova N.A., Ireland S. A Hoard of Bosporan Coins
in the Period Third Century BC to AD 238 from Ancient Gorgippia // NC. 1995.
155. P. 2142.
Thompson 1949 Thompson M. A Hoard of Bosporus Electrum // Hesperia.
1949. Supplement VIII: Commemorative Studies in Honor of Theodore Leslie
Shear / The American School of Classical Studies at Athens. P. 378489.
Zograf 1938 Zograf A.N. Sauromates II s Reform of the Currency // NC.
1938. 18. P. 99115.
... ...
493
..
-
. 1. . . . 275245 . ..
-
13
.
..1, ..2 ..3. , .
V . .. -
. , , - ,
. , , ,
, . 2- IV . ..
.
- ,
, 4. (. 1). ,
N.
1977: 150180; 1980: 1337; 1986: 6681; 1992: 731; 1997;
, 2005.
2
1986; 1989.
3
1951
4
1986: 58, 66.
275245 . ..,
. , .
, N.
6,64 ,
2 - .
(. 2) II .
.. , ,
NTI. . ,
,
, . , , ,
- ,
.
, , 5.
. 2. . . . II . ..
5
1977: 156.
494
. 34. . 37 . ..
, . IIV .
.. . , .
(. 3), , ..6.
, , .
.
, ( (. 4) ).
IB, .. 12 .
37 . .. .
, ,
,
. , ,
7.
(. 5) II, -
. 5. II. 123132 .
6
7
... ...
495
123132 .
.
.
, .
, , , .. 48 .
II, 68
92 . .. ,
.
, .
, ,
8, , , II 123124 .
(. 67).
;
.
. 6. . . 132 .
. 7. . . 134 .
1986: 72.
496
II. .
, , . ,
.. 132136 .,
, , .., , ,
9.
, . ..
132 . 134 .
II, ,
(. 89).
.
. :
, , , -
... ...
, . , , . 174186 ., .. .
186 .
, ,
10. ,
, : , 8 ; , 4 , , 3
. 96 ,
, , , 11.
. ,
.
II . 186196 .
. .
.
, 144 , .. , .
III . ,
III
. (. 10) 211224 .
, .
8. II. 174186 .
9. II. 186196 .
10
1986: 112.
497
11
498
.
. .
, 6- .
.
V,
(. 11). ,
. 11. V. 263 . ..
, . .
560 . 263 . ..
.
.., , 12. ..
. 13.
, , , 14. (. 1213)
,
, (. 14)
, 594 599 . , ..
297 302 . ..
. -
... ...
, , , , , -
15.
VI
(. 15).
, , , I
, 616 . 319 . .
, , ,
, 16.
-
(. 16). I . .., .
OBIO OEI,
, , (. 17);
17. ..18,
1997: II. 162.
1997: II. 159, 163.
17
, 2005: 219220.
18
1989: 72, 113114.
15
1986: 123.
13
1997: II. 159160.
14
1997: II. 154.
12
499
16
500
... ...
501
The only coin of the city-state of Olbia from the museum collection
was minted in the 2nd half of the 1st century AD when Olbia coinage had
been recommenced after a long interruption. According to V.A.Anokhins
catalogue, this coin was struck in 7576, and between 98 and 161 it received the caduceus countermark, put over the image on the obvers.
. 16. . .
I . ..
. 17.
7576 ., ,
( 98 161 .) , .
-
.
Summary
The Coins of Bosporus and Olbia in the Collection of Yaroslavl Museum
by A.V.Maksimov (Yaroslavl)
During the work with numismatic material from the numberless fund
of the Yaroslavl museum a small group of ancient coins of Northern Black
Sea Coast 13 Bosporus coins and one Olbia coin was revealed and
attributed. The purpose of this publication is to acquaint with results of
coins attribution and to observe what events found their reflection in coins.
Two pieces of Pantikapeum issues are the most ancient Bosporus coins
in the museum collection. One of them was minted in Bosporus in the
period of the long money crisis and can be dated to 275245 BC; the other
coin is dated to the end of the 2nd century BC.
Other Bosporus coins belong not to the city issues but to the imperial ones. They were minted on behalf of eight Bosporus kings in the
1st4th centuries AD. At that time Bosporus was in Romes sphere of
influence. In the Roman period of the Bosporus history there was a gradual
disappearance of junior coin denominations of the Bosporus monetary
system and degradation of the senior denomination a gold stater which
had become a bronze coin by the end of the Bosporus kingdom. These
processes have been imprinted in general outline in Bosporus coins from
the museum collection. Aspurgus reign has been presented by an ass, the
period from Kotys II to the money reform of Sauromates II by sesterces,
the reform of Sauromates II by a drachm, the reign of Rheskuporis III
by a denarius, and the reigns of Rheskuporis V, Thothorses and Rheskuporis VI by token and bronze staters.
1986 .. . , 1986.
1989 .. -
. , 1989.
1977 ..
// . .. 1977.
. 156160.
1951 .. . .; ., 1951. (:
. 16).
1969 .. .
., 1969.
1977 .. II (174210 . ..) // .
177. 49. . V. . 1. . 150232.
1980 .. III
(211226 . ..) // . 1980. XIII. . 1337.
1986 .. II (123132 . ..) // . 1986. . 6681. ( / . . 61).
(; I).
1992 .. (285308 . ..) //
, , . 1992. . 731. ( / . . 88.
(; XI).
1997 .. ( I .
.. IV . ..). ., 1997. . 12.
, 2005 .., ..
. ., 2005.
503
., .. ...
., .
. ,
( )
(-1) (. 1; . Ia):
..: , .
..: ,
. . --.
max 19 , 8,37 2 . 1945.
, .
,
. 1951 . .., . , . ,
(. ()), (), (), ).
, , , , , ,
(. 1ab).
(. 2ab), (?3) ..4.
: ,
: , , 1998
, , 1998: 19 8,45 .
3
.. .
4
1896: 8. . XIX.44.
1
. 1. . , . , . 1945. 8,37
, 5.
6.
: ,
, - , , , ,
7. ,
, .8, .
. 2. ... 8,45
(: 1896: . XIX44)
504
505
., .. ...
..
IV . ..9 ,
(. 3ab). , , ,
()
. 382 (. 4ab . Ib), .. 10.
. 4. , . 382.
8,37 (: 2010: 239, 357, . VII.6)
, , ,
..11. , ., , - (die wir (Dressel12
und ich) immer den Russen nannten, weil das Gesicht des Satyrn etwas
vom russischen Volkstypus hat13),
.
, ,
( XIX .),
14. , ..15.
. , .. .. , 20-
XIX . .16, ,
(. , ), . 17. , .. ,
(. 5), , , , ?
, . ,
, ( , ), ( : .. ; .. - )18.
, ., ( ..) , .19. ., -
14
1899: 189196; ., .:
1884: 3132; 1907: 6163; - 1896: 4042;
1963; 1967: 50.; 2007: 8789.
15
1910: 70.
16
Sestini 1826: 12. Tab. IV.1.
17
Kinns 1984: 34, 1314.
18
Kinns 1984: 5, 1314. 3ah, 3A. Pl. I.3, IV.41.
19
Svoronos 1922: 102. . 25. Pl. A25.
. 3. ...
8,34 (: 1887: 52, 384. . II.384)
506
., .. ...
507
.., .. . ,
, ,
.
. 5. , (:
Sestini 1826: 12. Tab. IV.1)
,
20,
. , , (
) XIX .21,
- ,
, .
, , 22,
XIX .,
23.
..24, .. (= . 382)
( VII)25. ,
IV . .., (310/09304/03 .), III . ..26
Kinns 1984: 14 (note 60).
Kinns 1984: 5.
22
, . . ,
, ,
.
23
., .: Kinns 1984: 19; Wartenberg 1998: 369370;
2014: 46 .
24
1964.
25
2010: 239, 357. . VII.34
26
.: 1951: 173; 1956: 138139; 1964: 137,
139; 1986: 141; 2010: 233234.
20
21
..-27 ,
28, (IV29)
9,09,20 (VI VII30) . 8,5 31.
(VI VII), , , ,
9 , ..32 , 33. ,
IV . .., .
34. ,
35 .
-
. ,
.. ,
- 1911; 1913.
1951: 174; 1956: 136137 .
29
: 2010: 235239.
30
: 2010: 239.
31
: 2010.
32
1951: 174175.
33
,
( IV, 410330 . .. Fritze 1912: 14. 191, Taf .VI.3; . :
1970: 82. . IV. 62)
,
, . ..
,
- ( 1956:
137138).
34
.: 1956: 135136; 1969: 140;
1986: 3637.
35
1956: 135; 1969: 140 (. 24).
27
28
508
, 36,
. ,
(7 1),
37. ..
. 6,4 , , , ,
2,15 , 38.
39, , ,
.
, . ,
.40 ,
, 41
: 42
. (), , , 43.
, 44 45
46. ,
,
1951: 175.
Chryssanthaki-Nagle 2007: 8992.
38
Chryssanthaki-Nagle 2007: 92, 155159. Pl. 17.5, 7.
39
.. ( 2010: 490491).
40
1942.
41
1942: 74. . 48; .: Laloux 1971: 36, Carte 1; 50, Carte 2;
58, Carte 3.
42
.: 2003.
43
: Bravo, Chankowski 1999: 310311.
44
1848: 1719.
45
Regling 1931.
46
1951: 174.
36
37
., .. ...
509
. ,
, 47,
48.
.. ,
49. ,
,
. , , IV . ..
( ;
8,53 50) ( (?)51). III .
.. 52.
III . .. 53. ,
.
. ,
II- ,
(. Ic). , -
,
, (),
54,
.: 1956: 132 = IGCH 1508 (Saida, Levant).
,
,
, IVIII .
. . (Kroll 1993: 173, 430432).
48
.: 1971: 78.
49
1956: 137.
50
1992: 11; 2007: 367, . 1.
51
1992: 11. . 2 (3); 1995: 63. . 6.
52
1992: 31. . 13, 14; Karayotov 1994: 114. Pl. IV gold
staters; Petac 2011: 714.
53
2000: 117.
54
1956: 140; 2009: 211; 212. . 1, 10; 214. . 3.2930;
215. . 4.41.
47
510
55.
(. II.1356), ,
.
, .
, (, (?)
) , , . ,
/ , , N ,
. , . 623 (CCCHBulg. III. P. 4041, 94)57.
( ,
, .)
(. 6ab)
..,
, , ,
, 58,
, , , ,
59.
..
,
, 1956; Mielczarek 1986: 101104; , 2007; 2009: 215. . 4.40; 216, . 5.43.
56
, , - ,
(:. Tzamalis 19971999 (1997): 13; (1998): 1718.
5358. Tabl. II.5457 Uncertain; Terzopoulou 2003: 14, 21, 26. Pl. II.15 =
Psoma, Karadima, Terzopoulou 2008: 10. PM 23ab, PM 25. Pl. II. PM 23ab,
PM25 Dikaia; Liampi 2005: 192. 130. Pl. 15,130 Argilos; 272273, 292.
Pl. 19, 56, Exc 68 Akanthos).
57
. ,
- . () .
58
1986: 43.
59
Chryssanthaki-Nagle 2007: 159.
55
511
., .. ...
. 6. , , III . .. , . ,
. 623. 2,50 (: CCCHBulg. III. 4041. 94)
60. , , ,
IV . .. .., -
- .
, (, , )
,
(. ). ,
, :
(IVV) (.: . 78).
61, , ,
. 62, .. III (. 9ab). , ., ,
, ,
III- 63 (. 9).
III :
2009: 227.
.: 2010: 239, 357. . VII.34, 67.
62
Regling 1931: Taf. IV.167171, 174, 178.
63
Regling 1931: 33 (note 2).
60
61
512
513
., .. ...
..:
,
, . III ,
(. 9), , (. 78).
. 9. . 9,149,20
(: Regling 1931: 31. Taf. IV.168)
. 7. .. . 9,08
(: 1896: . XIX.43)
. 8. , . ... 8,55 (:
1892: . IV.22)
..:
(IIII) , (.:
. 24 . 9).
, N (. 78).
. (. 24),
(. 78).
IIII
(. 24, 9), 8 (. . 78).
:
(. 78), I II 64, III
(.: . 24 . 9).
,
65,
.
, , 66, (. 1) 67 , ,
,
. (IIII),
P-A-N ,
(. 9).
.: 2010: 351352. . I.119, . II.116.
1951: 172. , .. ,
, I II , ..
( 1951: 176).
66
2010: 239, 357. . VII.34, 67; Kinns 1984: 14. 3af.
Pl. I.3.
67
Kinns 1984: 14. 3g.
64
65
514
(. . 24).
,
(. III . ..),
,
68, ,
II . ..69
.
.. , ,
, ,
70, . . (IIII),
IV V.
,
(. ) III. - ,
9 . , . ,
71,
..72 ..73.
.. .
,
330 . ..74. . ., III III (3- )75. ,
1956: 139.
.: 1986: 66; 2007: 106113.
70
1964: 136.
71
Regling 1931: 36.
72
1956: 139.
73
1964: 137.
74
2009: 226.
75
2009: 225.
., .. ...
515
, , . , ,
, , III IV,
. , , I II, ..,
.. III
IV .
, (. 382)
.
.
, , , 76. .
, , , ..
, 18221824 ., , 1914 ., . ..
1887 . 1845 ., , , , .
.
., (. ),
, . ,
, ., ..
,
, (Weber coll. P. 182, 2689. Pl. 103, 2689)
., .
68
69
, , . 382 ,
.
(990),
(.: 2010: 9394, 380383), ( 2010: 9495), II III
( 2010: 1418).
76
516
, , , ( ) ,
, , . 1830 ., , , .
., .. ...
517
II
,
( 4:1)
518
, ,
, ,
,
., , III
.
Summary
The Coins of Panticapaeum from the Collections of the Archaeological
Museum of Plovdiv (Republic of Bulgaria)
(Towards the Question of the Panticapaeum Gold Issues)
by V.Peshekhonov (Moscow), D.Davidova (Plovdiv)
The history of the Panticapaeum coinage as based on the data from the
Archaeological Museum in Plovdiv (Bulgaria) is discussed in the article.
2010 .. VI .
.. III . .. // . 2010. 1.
. 477521.
1986 .. . , 1986.
1848 .
, , , . II. , 1848. . 2.
1967 .. // .
1967. . IX. . 5054.
- 1896 - .. // . 1896. . 19. . 2768.
- 1911 - ..
IV . . . //
. ., 1911. . I. . 1100.
- 1913 - ..
// . ., 1913. . II. . 148.
1970 .. // .
1970. 2. . 7386.
1884 .. ,
, , . , 1884. . I.
1942 .
// . 1942. IV. . 7289.
1892 .. . ., 1891.
1896 .. ,
1892 1893 . ., 1896.
., .. ...
519
1971 .. . ., 1971.
1951 .. . .; ., 1951. (; 16).
1963 .. // .
1963. IV. . 130135.
1969 .. .
., 1969.
1992 . . ,
1992.
2003 . // NB. 2003. II, 1. . 913.
1964 .. // . 1964. 1. . 134139 (11:
III . ..).
, , 1998 ., ., . . , 1998.
2000 .. // .
2000. 1. . 107120.
1910 .. ..
.. // . 1910. 44. . 6489.
2014 .. ( ).
2009 .. // : . . .
(19491999). , 2009. . 211228.
, 2007 .., . // . 2007. IV.
. 719.
1995 . .
VI . . .. , 1995.
2007 . .
VII . . .. , 2007.
1887 .. / . .. ., 1887 ( , . . VI).
1899 .. // X (1896). . I.
., 1899. . 189196.
1996 .. VIV .
.. // . 1996. 2. . 3469.
2002 .. IV .
.. // . 2002. .5. . 286302.
2007 .. II . .. (, , ) // . 2007. 4.
. 70113.
2010 ..
IV . .. // .. -
520
( ).
., 2010.
1956 .. VIII . .. .,
1956.
1907 .. .
1: .,
// . 1907. 40. . 6163.
Bravo, Chankowski 1999 Bravo B., Chankowski A.S. Cits et emporia dans
le commerce avec les barbares la lumire du document dit tort inscription de
Pistiros // Dossier Pistiros. BCH. 1999. 123, 1: P. 275317.
Chryssanthaki-Nagle 2007 Chryssanthaki-Nagle K. LHistoire monetaire
dAbdere en Thrace (VIe s. av. J.-C. IIe s. ap. J.-C.). Athenes, 2007 (Meletemata. 51).
Fritze 1912 Fritze H. von. Die Elektronpragung von Kizikos // Nomisma.
Untersuchungen auf dem Gebiet der antiken Mnzkunde. 1912. VII. S. 138.
Karayotov 1994 Karayotov I. The Coinage of Mesambria. Vol. I Silver and
Gold Coins of Mesambria. Sozopol, 1994.
Kinns 1984 Kinns Ph. The Caprara Forgeries. London; Basle, 1984. (RNS
SP; Vol. 16).
Kroll 1993 Kroll J.H. The Greek Coins. Princeton, 1993. (The Athenian
Agora; Vol. XXVI).
Laloux 1971 Laloux M. La circulation des monnaies dlectrum de
Cyzique // RBNS. 1971. CXVII. P. 3169.
Liampi 2005 Liampi K. Argilos: A Historical and Numismatic Study.
Athens, 2005.
Mielczarek 1986 Mielczarek M. Gold Panticapaean Coins Set in Rings
found in the Great Ryzhanovka Barrow (Ukraine) // Archeologia. 1986. XXXVII.
P. 99105.
Petac 2011 Petac E. From the Types of Alexander to Lysimachus
The Chronology of Some Mesembrian and Other West Pontic Staters // AJA.
2011. P. 714.
Psoma, Karadima, Terzopoulou 2008 Psoma S., Karadima C., Terzopoulou D. The Coins from Maroneia and the Classical City at Molyvoti: (A Contribution to the History of Aegean Thrace). Athens, 2008 (Meletemata. 62).
Regling 1931 Regling K. Der griechische Goldschatz von Prinkipo // ZfN.
1931. XLI. S. 146.
Sestini 1826 Sestini D. Sopra i moderni falsificatori di medaglie greche
antiche nei tre metalli, e descrizione di tutte quelle prodotte dai medesimi nello
spazio di pochi anni. Firenze, 1826.
Svoronos 1922 Svoronos J.N. C. Christodoulos et les faussaires dAthnes //
JIAN. 1922. 20. P. 97107.
Terzopoulou 2003 Terzopoulou D. Small Silver Fractions from Ancient
Stryme // NK. 2003. 22. P. 2330.
Tzamalis 19971999 Tzamalis A. Uncertain Thraco-Macedonian Coins //
NK. 1997. Nos. 16. P. 1320; 1998. Nos. 17. P. 1522; 1999. Nos. 18. P. 1116.
Wartenberg 1998 Wartenberg U. Calymna Calumniated a NineteenthCentury Misattribution? // Studies in Greek Numismatics in Memory of Martin
Jessop Price / Ed. Ashton R., Hurter S. L., 1998. P. 363371.
S.Filipova
research works I started in 2000 on the coin circulation within the period
of 294498. A particularity of the research is that it observes not only coin
hoards but also coins from archeological excavations, including ancient
emporions found in the todays towns of Radomir and Kocherinovo. There
are analyzed 6188 coins from 20 hoards and 22 archeological sites situated
in the regions of todays Pernik district; Kyustendil valley with its center in
the ancient town of Pautalia (today the town of Kyustendil); the geographic
areas of Kraishte, Piyanets and Kamenitsa; Razmetanitsa; Gorno Pole
(with its center in the town of Sapareva Banya, the ancient Germanea)
and Dolno Pole (with the towns of Kocherinovo and Blagoevgrad). The
research accents on the coin circulation within Pautalia, which is the main
city in the examined territory, situated in a wide crossroad influenced by
both the Empires Western and Eastern tendencies of development.
Geographical features of the research
The region of the Upper Struma River is situated in the central part of
the Balkan Peninsula and covers the Upper Struma River Valley (the ancient
Strymon), as well as the passages and the smaller river valleys connecting
it with the areas of the rivers Dzherman, Gorna Mesta (ancient Nestus),
Vardar (ancient Axios) and Morava (ancient Brongus). Regarding its
politic-geographical location the Upper Struma River region was situated
at the most western part of the Thracia Province up to the second half of
the 3rd c., and after the administrative reforms during the times of the Late
Empire it was a part of the Dacia Interior Province (Map 1) including the
city areas of Serdica (Sofia), Pautalia (Kyustendil), Germanea (Sapareva
Banya), Naissus (today Nish in Republic of Serbia) and Remesiana (Bela
Palanka, Republic of Serbia). The Struma River, along with its basin and
the adjoining valleys, is given a central place among the physical and
geographical features of the examined district.
522
S.Filipova. Coin Circulation Along the Upper Struma Rivers Region During...
523
set the beginning of the late Roman coin system and the reform by
Emperor Anastasius I (491518) in 498, with which the Byzantine
minting began.
Map 1. Inner Dacia (VIIV cent. B.C.; from: Fontes Latini Historiae
Bulgaricae. , 1958. I.)
Along the Upper Struma Rivers region there was well developed and
organized network of main and minor roads that benefited the contacts
between the town areas and the rest of the settlements and settlement
structures. It was crossed by main roads with inter-provincial significance
that made a grate importance to the development of the road network in
the examined area the road of Serdica Pautalia Stoby; the road along
the Struma River Valley towards Amphipolis; the road connecting Pautalia
with Philipopolis through Germanea1; as well as several minor roads that
enabled the connection between remote settlements and the main urban
center the ancient Pautalia.
Chronology of the research
Chronologically, the research covers the period between the coin
reform undertaken by Emperor Diocletian (284305) in 294, which
1989: 177193; 2004: 85115; 2005: 212.
524
S.Filipova. Coin Circulation Along the Upper Struma Rivers Region During...
525
7. Drumohar
8. Mazarachevo
9. Marvodol
10. Goranovtsi
11. Lilyash
10
8
11
4
5
5
14
526
S.Filipova. Coin Circulation Along the Upper Struma Rivers Region During...
527
1
2
2
7
1
10
13
12
3
5
14
11
lage of Bosnek, Pernik district includes 511 copper coins and a solidus of
Emperor Theodosius II weighing 4,40 g22. There is a golden coin triens
(tremis) of Emperor Zeno (474491) weighing 1,50 g found in the village
of Zidartsi, Pernik district23.
The golden coins weight is within the normal divergence from the
standard of 4,50 g introduced by Constantine the Great and has been
registered in other soliduses and their subdivisions, as well as in the weight
standards for controlling the coin weights24.
The silver coin from the Upper Struma River region, about which there
is available information, is a siliqua of Emperor Jovian (363364). It was
found in the basilica at the Strumsko quarter in the town of Blagoevgrad25.
Carson, Kent, Burnet 1994: 253. 202.
Carson, Kent, Burnet 1994: 308. 926.
24
- 1985: 2231; - 2005:
7479; Vladimirova-Aladjova 1997: 1924.
25
2001: 41.
22
23
Small nominal value prevails in the bronze coins half follises and coins
conditionally named 3 and 4. The heavy follises minted before the first
reduction in 30726 are 16 in number and are found in Pautalia (3 coins);
at the sanctuary at the Daskalovo quarter in the town of Pernik (2 coins);
at the Arbanas quarter in the town of Radomir (9 coins); at the fortress
on the Krakra Hill in the town of Pernik (1 coin during the archeological
excavations in 20022003) and at the basilica at the Strumsko quarter in
the town of Blagoevgrad (1 coin). In 2001 a coin hoard was found closely
to an ancient mound necropolis in the village of Krivonos, the Breznik
district. It consists of 32 late ancient copper and silvered coins follises
and half follises, 8 of them were minted before the follis reduction in 30727.
There are much more follises minted in the period of 307313. They are
42 in number 17 from the archeological sites in the town of Kyustendil
Bastien 1980: 59, 89.
The information is by E.Paunov, whom I am grateful to.
26
27
528
S.Filipova. Coin Circulation Along the Upper Struma Rivers Region During...
the coins are of 3 and 4 nominal value with prevailing small one. At
the coin hoards from the village of Nedelkova Grashtitsa and the Dolno
Tserovo fortress the situation is a little bit different. The first one was
placed as a grave inventory and is with terminus post quem of 335. Similar
is the situation with the coin hoard from the necropolis in the village
of Zabel, the Tran district, which includes 16 copper and silvered billon
coins follises and their fractions from the period of 31332432. The find
from Dolno Tserovo is more compact covering the period 341/346 378
and is with terminus post quem of 378. Coins of low nominal value from
the 4th century end are deficient in both hoards.
Comments and conclusions
By the decline of the Roman coin system in the 3rd c. and after the unsuccessful attempt to be introduced a coin reform in the time of Aurelian
(270274), it became quite necessary to be undertaken urgent measures for
the coin systems stabilization. The coin reform of the Emperor Diocletian
(284305) undertaken in 29433 and developed by the Emperor Constantine
I (306337)34 established the basic principles of the late ancient minting.
By the moving of the Roman Empires center to the East, especially after
the building of the new capital of Constantinople, the circulation of coins
minted in the Balkan Peninsulas and Asia Minors mints along the Upper Struma River region prevailed. The presence of coins from the remote
Western European mints was typical for the beginning of the given period,
especially during the time of Constantine I (306337). The coins of Siscia
situated in the central Empires territory were traditionally well presented,
especially in the period of 364378, when the mint was quite active and
there were four officinae. The significant presence of Cyzicus coins is connected with its well developed mint activity, especially after 378.
There are coins of all Roman emperors from the period of 294491
(see table). The number of the coins increased intensively in the periods of
330341, 354361, 383395 and 425450, and the coins themselves were
of small nominal value showing the increasing inflation and the need of
much money with low value at market. The continuous weight and size
losing of the copper coin par, especially after the beginning of the 5th century, are a testimony for the presence of inflation and devaluation. There
are preserved mints indications on 1358 coins, as 274 of them were minted
at the Western and Central Empires ateliers and 1084 at the Balkan and
Eastern ones. According to the mints they were minted they are divided as
follows:
28
29
529
- 2003: 217218.
Sutherland: 1960: . 9497.
34
Bruun 1966: 24; 2005: 190.
32
33
530
S.Filipova. Coin Circulation Along the Upper Struma Rivers Region During...
531
center along the Upper Struma River the town of Pautalia was the same,
which testimonies that the reasons for treasuring the hoards were the developments in the 440s40. Again, the latest coins from the market place at
the town of Kocherinovo are dated in the period of 425450. The market
places territory hasnt been archeologically examined yet, except of
the sounding research works undertaken at the place of Chepreshlako,
which doesnt allow me to make precise conclusions.
Just one of the presented coin hoards has terminus post quem of
the Emperor Marcianus coins (450457). Its treasuring can be connected
with the developments from the beginning of Marcianus rule 451,
when was the last invasion of the Attilas Huns in the Empires Balkan
Provinces41.
The latest coin finds of the coin complexes at the Krakra Hill, Arbanas
quarter in the town of Radomir and of the coin hoard from the village of
Bosnek, Pernik district, belonged to the time of Emperor Leos I (457
474). Having in mind the hoard of golden coins from the village of Goz,
Breznik district, the region of todays town of Pernik was damaged by the
developments that had happened during the time of Leo I42.
The research on the coin circulation in the Late Antiquity along the
Upper Struma Rivers region unambiguously testimonies to the increasing
inflation, especially the one in the end of the 4th c., which can be explained
with the common economic crisis affected the Roman Empire. In the 5th c.
the Upper Struma Rivers region became a field of military conflicts and
Empires interior contradictions that inevitably affected the coin circulation
too. During the second half of the 5th c. it gradually slowed down as the
hiatus continued for some 4050 years (up to the beginning of the 6th c.).
Reasons for this can be found in the economic collapse after the numbers of
barbarian invasions. Besides, we shouldnt ignore the fact that worn out and
effaced coins continued to be in circulation too. Strengthening the bronze
coins par was the main objective of the Emperor Anastasius reform in
498, after then the late Roman bronze coin signs were replaced by the early
Byzantine follises and its subdivisions.
35
36
40
1958: 41 .; 1979: 409; 1958:
310; 1954: 9091.
41
1958: 42, 235.
42
1958: 410; 1960: 232.
532
TR
LG
TIC ARL
AQ
533
S.Filipova. Coin Circulation Along the Upper Struma Rivers Region During...
MINTS
SIS SIRM SERD TES
total
H CON
ANT
ALE
u.m.*
29
12
1
1
46
1
2
15
17
41
3
1
3
2
2
1
3
9
5
7
1
9
2
1
1
3
26
6
1
1
3
1
3
2
1
1
3
4
1
2
4
1
10
1
3
1
1
1
3
1
1
3
1
1
7
1
1
1
1
4
4
6
1
1
3
1
2
23
2
7
10
1
1
1
2
534
LG
TIC ARL
1
2
AQ
535
S.Filipova. Coin Circulation Along the Upper Struma Rivers Region During...
MINTS
SIS SIRM SERD TES
total
H CON
ANT
ALE
u.m.*
1
23
18
1
32
30
10
1
11
7
8
2
1
3
4
4
5
14
1
4
2
1
1
6
8
1
4
1
1
5
8
1
1
28
29
23
31
2
9
45
5
1
1
1
42
47
37
61
3
12
49
5
1
1
1
2
1
1
1
2
1
2
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
2
2
3
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
3
7
2
2
1
1
8
14
6
6
1
536
TR
LG
TIC ARL
AQ
MINTS
SIS SIRM SERD TES
537
S.Filipova. Coin Circulation Along the Upper Struma Rivers Region During...
total
H CON
2
2
5
15
1
7
N
1
ANT
ALE
1
3
19
26
14
5
1
1
2
1
3
1
1
1
u.m.*
1
1
1
2
3
4
2
8
7
3
2
2
2
1
2
1
1
1
7
1
2
1
1
4
5
27
49
15
10
2
2
3
1
1
31
8
24
10
38
38
20
17
11
2
2
31
4
8
5
25
28
14
16
7
2
25
14
14
1
645
1
2
723
257
274
40
51
10
538
LG
TIC ARL
AQ
539
S.Filipova. Coin Circulation Along the Upper Struma Rivers Region During...
MINTS
SIS SIRM SERD TES
1
1
1
1
total
H CON
1
1
4
1
2
2
ANT
ALE
1
1
u.m.*
48
3
11
1
6
1
1
8
4
3
1
1
1
2
19
29
2
1
1
19
9
4
21
26
2
10
1
5
6
9
11
2
2
2
2
1
2
1
1
70
62
6
4
98
124
2
1
1
3
2
10
42
1
1
1
3
1
2
1
2
1
6
6
16
2
6
24
6
4
1
1
1
1
2
5
1
1
13
2
1
49
8
17
1
6
9
1
8
7
1
104
108
6
10
143
164
2
6
17
58
1
1
7
21
7
15
24
12
4
1
1
1
1
23
2
3
540
LG
TIC ARL
AQ
MINTS
SIS SIRM SERD TES
1
1
4
1
541
S.Filipova. Coin Circulation Along the Upper Struma Rivers Region During...
4
3
12
2
2
1
total
H CON
ANT
ALE
u.m.*
1
2
3
2
1
1
1
1
11
1
2
18
59
24
2
5
1
35
1
1
1
1
17
1
7
5
10
1
2
106
4
27
1
17
5
21
3
1
5
148
4
21
3
3
1
14
15
2
2
6
7
12
8
3
91
24
2
10
2
62
2
1
1
1
1
10
1
39
32
1
39
46
542
LG
TIC ARL
AQ
MINTS
SIS SIRM SERD TES
total
H CON
ANT
ALE
1
1
1
543
S.Filipova. Coin Circulation Along the Upper Struma Rivers Region During...
2
2
2
14
6
22
1
1
2
4
1
1
3
3
7
2
2
1
4
3
1
1
1
1
33
1
1
1
1
2
11
4
6
5
2
14
207
1
2
24
9
16
153
16
6
6
1
12
8
1
u.m.*
10
3
2
11
15
2
1
37
1
14
3
1
20
1
12
12
1
2
14
19
6
2
56
2
33
1
16
3
1
1
1
27
1
4
544
LG
TIC ARL
AQ
545
S.Filipova. Coin Circulation Along the Upper Struma Rivers Region During...
MINTS
SIS SIRM SERD TES
total
H CON
2
2
2
2
5
ANT
ALE
1
12
u.m.*
8
104
12
1
1
17
1
1
6
1
5
1
73
2
6
7
7
1
1
***
***
1
15
2
10
123
1
4
1
1
***
***
***
***
***
*** ***
1
3
4
***
5
1
1
1
5
1
102
4
7
13
1
***
***
***
***
***
7
1
1
1
1
2
***
8
1
1
1
1
2
2
8
43
159
7
107
2
8
43
166
7
111
546
TR
LG
TIC ARL
AQ
S.Filipova. Coin Circulation Along the Upper Struma Rivers Region During...
MINTS
SIS SIRM SERD TES
H CON
K
3
ANT
1
ALE
4
3
4
7
1
1
total
u.m.*
99 103
5
5
2
2
1
18
18
16
4
261
336
1
4
1
17
16
4
269
346
1
4
1
18
42
1
47
1
3
3
4
16
2
1
33
1
422
1
35
17
12
3
54
100
12
1
69
6188
3
3
4
16
2
1
33
1
1
405
1
1
1
1
52
22
188
1
12
1 426 129
*
u.m. = Unsertain mint.
189
66
2
203
37
21
547
33
16
12
3
46
98
12
1
66
4830
548
549
Bibliography
2005 . .
. , 2005.
, 1988 ., . // . , 1988.
1978 . 1978. .
, // 1977. 1978. . 8687.
1980 . //
. , 1980. . 1447. . 2: .
1985 .
: ( ) // . 1985. 3.
. 2637.
2003 .
(
. ) // .
, 2003. . 2. . 183201.
1958 11. //
. , 1958. . 1. . 116191 (XI).
1989 .
(V .) // . 1989. 1. . 177193.
1995 . . , 1995. . 1.
1925 . 1924 . //
. 1925. 3. . 254255.
19261927 .
192526 . // . 19271927. 4. . 323.
2005 . . ., 2005.
1985 . . , . , 1985. ( ; 14).
1954 / . // . , 1954. . 1. . 86129 (IX).
- 1963 - .
. , // . 1963. 4.
. 1927.
2004 . ( .):
: . , 2004. . 2.
1960 //
. , 1960. . 3. . 226289 (XXII).
2001 ..
// . 2001. 8. . 5160.
2001 .. // . 2001. 2. . 4152.
2010 .. () // : . . . - . . , 2010.
. 104118. 1.
1985 .
1982 . // . 1985. 2. . 5864.
Bastien 1980 Bastien . Le Monnayage de latelier de Lyon de la reform
1949 .
. .
1980 .
(. ) // . 1980. 4. . 1215.
1992 .
// . 1992. 4. . 245253.
1992 . .
, // . 1992. 4. . 253261.
, 1985 ., . . , // 1984. ,
1985. . 149.
1958 . .
, 1958.
- 1985 - .
// . 1985. 1. . 2231.
- 2005 - . (V .) // , . 2005. 2. . 4552.
- 2003 - . . , : (
1999-2000 ) // . 2003. 9. . 215225.
1934 . 1933
1934 // . 1934. 8. . 467473.
1950 . // . 1950.
17. . 321322.
1950 . // .
1950. 17. . 316326.
1962 . , 1958 59 . // . 1962. 25. . 222239.
2009 . H ( )
378612 .: //
. , 2009. . 346365.
1952 . //
. 1952. 18. . 353358.
-, 1978 - .,
. .
, 1978.
- 1987 - . . , 1987.
1957 .
// . 1957. 21. . 211232.
1979 . , 1979. . .
1911 . // .
1911. 2. . 185189.
1914 . ,
// . 1914. V. . 80112.
S.Filipova. Coin Circulation Along the Upper Struma Rivers Region During...
550
D.Vladimirova-Aladzhova
The letters on the obverse are rendered rather carelessly, their shape is
clear but there is a problem with the details outlining. It is obvious that for
the etcher the inscription of the signs was a mechanical process of copying
and not a conscious action of literate. The image of the ruler is also depicted
1
delson 1958: 126; Reece 1963: 241242; Grierson, Mays 1992: 1721;
Carson, Kent, Burnett 1994: 1317; Bendall 2003: 457461.
2
-: 188189.
552
sketchy. The features of the face are sharp, instead of an eye there is just
a point, the tiara is depicted by two lines of small points, and the garments
are rendered linearly and quite economically regarding the details. The naivety of the drawing implies inexperience and lacking sense of plasticity.
On the reverse the wreath is depicted carelessly, but the letters are
written correctly. The general impression is that the image on the reverse does not differ drastically from the emissions of siliquas of the emperor Leo I, which type probably imitates the examined specimen.
The sketchy make of the obverse as well as the weight of the specimen
are a reason to be defined as an imitation of a half siliqua3 of the emperor
Leo I. The half siliqua as a nominal belongs entirely to the West. In the
beginning it was minted rarely in connection with certain ceremonies,
but after 447 during the time of the Ostrogoths it became a regular coin
for exchange4.
East there are few coins of Leo I with weight about half of the siliqua
and with its types for the obverse and reverse. They have the stamp of
the mint of Constantinople but their style is strange and unusual. These are
the reasons the place and origin of these coins to be considered uncertain5.
The well-known coins of the world collections with a description close to
that of Sofia are several. Hahn reports for a specimen of a half siliqua but
without any details6. Carson, Kent and Burnet include the coin in RIC X,
as an imitation of a half siliqua7. Grierson and Mays mention information about silver coins of Leo I just of the nominal heavy miliarenses,
which were minted in Constantinople. Information about a half siliqua
from the time of Leo I is lacking but there is some about the emperors
Zeno, Basilisk, and Julius Nepos, and the coins were minted in the West
Empire in Ravena and Milan. Their weight varies between 1.23 g and
0.68 g8.
The historic events during the rule of the emperor Leo I are a kind of
a landmark, regarding minting the coins of a half siliqua of that ruler. It
could be connected with giving out extra money to the firefighters, after
the extinguishing the big fire in Constantinople in 464 or 465 according the
writings of Zonaras. Another possibility is that manufacture was connected
with payments to the Ostrogoths, who were a permanent threat to the
Eastern Empire. In 459 they devastated the district of Illirycum and forced
the emperor Leo I to conclude a peace treaty with them, paying them a big
Its weight is considerably reduced.
Grierson, Mays 1992: 35; Carson, Kent, Burnett 1994: 17.
5
Carson, Kent, Burnett 1994: 16.
6
Hahn 1989: 68.
7
Carson, Kent, Burnett 1994: 290, 650.
8
Grierson, Mays 1992: 38.
3
4
553
annual tax. In 472 the Goths invaded the district of Illyricum again and the
emperor was forced to give them lands to settle on.
The half siliqua is a nominal, widespread in the Western Empire, which
means that it was familiar to the Ostrogoths. The Ostrogoth Kingdom
was the only one amongst all the German states, sprung up in the Late
Antiquity on a Roman land, which had a developed monetary system based
on three metals gold, silver and copper9. It is possible that having been in
a difficult situation Leo I to have been forced to mint the small coins in order
to pay off the Ostrogoths. The careless etching could be connected with
the production of a temporary military mint, forced to manufacture coins
urgently on behalf of the mint in the capital Constantinople. According
to the mentioned circumstances the dating of the National Archeological
Museum in Sofia could go back to the 70s or 80s of the 5th century.
The described silver coin is a modest example to the studying of the
5th century mint on the boundary of Rome and Byzantium.
Bibliography
- 2006 - . 2006. // . 2006. 14. . 187190.
Adelson 1958 Adelson H.L. Silver Currency and Values in the Early
Byzantine Empire // Centennial Publication of the American Numismatic Society /
Ed. by H.Ingholt. New York, 1958. P. 126.
Bendall 2003 Bendall S. Anonymous Western Half-Siliquae of the Late
Fourth Century // RN. 2003. 159. 6. P. 457461.
Carson, Kent, Burnet 1994 Carson R.A.G., Kent J.P.C., Burnett A.M.
The Roman Imperial Coinage. L., 1994. Vol. .
Grierson, Mays 1992 Grierson Ph., Mays M. Cataloque of Late Roman
Coins in the Dumbarton Oaks and in the Whittemore Collection. Washington, 1992.
Hahn 1989 Hahn W. Die Ostprgung des Rmischen Reiches im 5. Jahrhundert (408491). Wien, 1989.
Kraus 1928 Kraus F.F. Die Mnzen Odovacars und des Ostgotenreiches in
Italien. Halle, 1928.
Metlich 2004 Metlich M.A. The Coinage of Ostgothic Italy. L., 2004.
Reece 1963 Reece R. Some Analyses of Late Roman Silver Coins // NC.
7th Series. 1963. Vol. 3. P. 241242.
Wroth 1911 Wroth W. Catalogue of the Coins of the Vandals, Ostrogoths and
Lombards and of the Empires of Thessalonica, Nicaea and Trebizond in
the British Museum. L., 1911.
..-
:
..
(18061884)
. , (18071884), 1853 .
25
.
,
1. .. ,
-
. , .
, 10/I 1845.2,
.
,
(
)3. ,
.
.
, ,
, ,
.
. ,
, .
,
..-. : ..
.
, , . ( )4, .. , , . .,
, ,
. ,
,
, ,
, .
. .
-
,
5. 20 . ,
( , ) -.
, ,
, . . ,
,
, 6.
, (
, )
. ,
,
.
.. , (18151894).
. , - 7. ,
. , ,
1879.
1879: . 3.4.
6
1910: 6489.
7
1884.
4
2008: 270.
1869.
3
1880.
1
2
555
556
..-. : ..
-8. .
, , . , 9, - .., ,
, , . , , , ,
, ,
, ,
10.
:
.
, ,
.
!
,
.
;
,
,
,
,
.
,
, ,
,
.
, , :
,
,
:
, ,
- 1907.
1910: 6489.
10
1910: 65.
( ), , ,
,
.
, ,
,
.
,
, ,
.
,
,
.
,
, ,
11.
, ,
. , .. 19 1876. ( 1907 . 40 .)12.
: -
,
, , ,
1868
8
9
557
1910: 6970.
1907: 6173.
11
12
558
1869 . 13. ,
: ,
: , ,
14.
, , . ,
. .. , , , . . , , ,
, , , . I,
, 15.
, , . . 24
, 1870. 16. ,
1878. . -
, .
..
17 ,
. , 216
, 217 I, 232233
, 235 18.
, .
, - .
1907: 6162.
1907: 62.
15
1907: 62.
16
1902: 1418.
17
1884.
18
1884.
13
14
..-. : ..
559
, , , , .
Summary
The Forgotten Pages of Classical Numismatics: E.E.Lyutsenko
by T.A.Izbash-Gotskan (Odessa)
The personality of E.E.Lyutsenko, a fancier of archeology and
numismatics of the Northern Black Sea coast is discussed in the article. His
name is insufficiently known even among the specialists in this field as he
scarcely ever published his scientific works. A number of archaeological
documents, E.E.Lyutsenkos copies, containing the description of ancient
coins and buried coins treasures from Novorossia are mentioned in
the article, and an outstanding role of E.E.Lyutsenko in grading of coins
with APOL inscription as a temple mintage is stressed. Special attention
is placed on literary works of E.E.Lyutsenko and particularly on
Archeological ode in which the author describes a lot of archaeologists
of 19th century and presents a part of numismatic collection of P.O.Burachkov in ironic manner.
- 1907 - ..
... ., 1907.
1884 .. ,
,
, . ,
.. , 1884. . 1.
,
.
2008 .. .. // .
. . : - .
, 2008. . 270271.
1869 .. , 10/I-1845. // . . 28. . 2.
1879 .. ,
, . ( ) //
. .28. .19.
1880 .. ,
560
( ) // . . 28. . 22.
1902 .. : (
...) // . 1902. 24. . 1418.
1910 .. ..
.. // . 1910. 44. . 6489.
1907 .. .
1: .,
. 2: // . 1907. 40. . 6371.
F. de Callata
The many studies of Nina Frolova have shaped our knowledge of royal
Bosporan coinages. With her several reference catalogues, she stands as the
prominent figure of the last decades in the field and I am glad to contribute
to the Festschrift she well deserves.
To be sure, she came after a long list of scholars who paved the way.
Most of these names have vanished now, since their studies were of no use
any more. Russian current literature rarely ventured before Zograf1 who
himself devoted illuminating pages on the history of numismatics. Well
aware of ancient international literature from the Renaissance up to his
time, he argued that Russian numismatics started late and did not reach an
acceptable scientific level before the second half of the 19th c.2 Then, dealing with the Northern Black Sea littoral, he referred to Khler and Khne
as the pioneers for these areas.
This is possibly true from the restricted point of view of Russian
scholarship but ignores the vast amount of publications made well before.
In any case, the claim that no systematic work about Bosporan coinages
was made before the mid-19th c. is untrue. Quite the contrary, Bosporan
coinages were highly discussed in the 18th c. At the very end of the 17th c.,
Jean-Foy Vaillant had already gathered an impressive material, published
in 1725, a quarter of century after his death, in a book with more than
1
See: Frolova, Ireland 2002: 1; Frolova 1979: 5 is an exception although the
short list of quoted 18th and 19th c. literature, except Cary 1752, appears as unfortunate, lacking the true specific references on the topic. Most of what is important
is missing: Jean Foy-Vaillant, for example, is quoted, p. 12, but not for the right
book (and actually for a book without any reference to the topic).
2
Zograf 1977: 26: unfortunately one must acknowledge that although this
study started at a comparatively late date, only at the beginning of the XIXth
century after the formation of a cabinet of coins and medals within the Hermitage,
it did not in mid-century escape being permeated with a dense flow of courtier
dilettantism which set a stamp upon it.
562
563
Publishing in 1665 a choice of coins of his collection (Selecta numismata antiqua ex museu Petri Seguini), the Parisian Pierre Seguin (1599
1672) is likely to have been the first to give a set of printed images of royal
Bosporan coins (p. 3239). As an example of the kind of inaccuracies of
the time, lets take his interpretation of the letters QKF, on a gold stater of
Cotys (actually Cotys III), which he read as the initials of Th[eos] K[aisar]
Ph[ilos] (Fig. 3) and not as the year 529 of the Bosporan era8.
Other numismatists, among the most reputed of the time, dealt with
Bosporan coinages during the last third of the 17th c. The list includes
Ezerchiel Spanheim (1666), Charles Patin (1672 and 1675), Jean-Foy
Vaillant (1674), Andr Morell (1683), Charles-Csar Baudelot de Dairval
(1686), Jean Hardouin (1697) and Lorenz Beger (1696 and 1702)9. All
these authors bravely tried to identify what they could, not without misunderstandings however. Charles Patin durably mislead research with a
8
9
564
565
15
566
567
568
569
570
571
around the Mediterranean Sea and beyond24. He is likely to have been the
first teacher in numismatics of Jean-Jacques Barthlemy who in turn is
likely to have edited his scientific researches25. His interest for Cimmerian
Bosporus was not new26 when he published in 1752 his Histoire des rois
de Thrace et de ceux du Bosphore cimmrien claircie par les mdailles
(Fig. 10).
Except for Rhoemetalces which is still classified with Thracian kings,
Cary made a clear distinction between what is Bosporan (to make it short:
coins with dates) and what is Thracian (without dates)27. With this distinction in mind and an enlarged collection of coins personally inspected,28 he
24
Son of a distinguished bookseller, member of the Acadmie de Marseille
(whom he was president in 1733) and of those of Cortone, elected corresponding
member at the Acadmie des Inscriptions & Belles-Lettres in 1752, Flix Cary
was a man of many interests. Among his unpublished studies, we find a Vocabulaire provenal avec les etymologies de chaque mot and a Dissertation sur les
langues qui ont t en usage Marseille, et en particulier sur le provenal. See
his biography in Recueil de lAcadmie de Marseille, 1755 (non vidi). As Pellerin,
he must have had a large network of relations in remote places. About the unique
coin of Terianes, one out of two coming from his collection, he writes: Cette
mdaille de Teirans, que je crois unique, mest venue des lieux mmes o ce
prince a rgn (Cary 1752: 78).
25
Jean-Jacques Barthlemy negotiated post mortem with his brother the
acquisition of his collection for the king (acquired for 18,000 pounds): see Barthlemy 1821: LII, 31. Describing Cary, Barthlemy wrote: Des connaissances en
tout genre, diriges par un esprit excellent, et embellies par des murs douces,
rendaient son commerce aussi agrable quinstructif. Je laimais beaucoup (ibid.,
p. 7). About Barthlemy, Cary wrote: Je dois cette observation M. lAbb
Barthelemi de lAcadmie des Inscriptions & Belles-Lettres, qui, avec lagrment
de M. de Boze, ma communiqu toutes les mdailles du cabinet du Roi dont
jai eu besoin ; il ma de plus fourni bien des remarques qui prouveraient ses
connaissances dans ce genre de littrature, si je pouvais entrer ici dans des dtails,
que lamiti & la reconnaissance semblent exiger de moi (Cary 1752 : 67).
26
See: Cary 1744. The author recognized later on that many errors were
printed there; to have given credit to a medal for Lesbonax is one of them.
27
Cary 1752: 6869 (Thrace): Il y en a plusieurs que Seguin, Patin, Spanheim
& dautres auteurs, ont attribus des rois de Thrace, & qui appartiennent des
rois du Bosphore: on les trouvera toutes leur place, dans lhistoire de ces rois
auxquels jai cru devoir les restituer. Pour navoir pas distingu les mdailles
des royaumes de Thrace & du Bosphore, on a t oblig dimaginer plusieurs
systmes qui se dtruisent mutuellement. Cest ce qui est arriv au savant
Spanheim.
28
Cary 1752: iv (Bosporus): Vaillant nous aurait donn sans doute une suite
des rois du Bosphore fort diffrente de celle quil nous a laisse, sil avait vu les
mdailles qui ont t dcouvertes dans ces derniers temps ; et je naurais pas fait
des efforts inutiles lorsque jcrivis la premire fois sur ces rois, si ces mdailles
taient alors venues ma connaissance.
572
573
30
574
575
576
577
Frlich 1752: Foy-Vaillant (4: 133, 135, 136, 153), Hardouin (2: 133, 136),
Haym (2: 133, 137), Souciet (2: 133, 136).
Cary 1752: Foy-Vaillant (32: Thrace: 75/ Bosporus: i, iv, 1, 2, 17, 18, 19, 32,
33, 34, 35, 39, 40, 42, 44, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 66, 74, 75, 76, 77, 84,
86), Seguin (10: Thrace: 66, 67, 68, 69/ Bosporus: i, 42, 54, 66, 73, 74), Patin
(8: Thrace: 66, 67, 68, 75 Bosporus: 33, 40, 74, 75), Spanheim (8: Thrace: 68, 69 /
Bosporus: i, 2, 59, 71, 73, 74), Morell (6: Bosporus: 32, 42, 53, 59, 60, 66), Souciet (5: Bosporus: I, 4, 40, 75, 77 [footnote o]), Hardouin (4: Bosporus: 2, 47,
66, 71), Haym (4: Bosporus: 3, 12, 49, 59), Tiepolo (4: Thrace: 75 [footnote u] /
Bosporus: 71, 72, 87), Havercamp (3: Thrace: 67 [footnote r]/ Bosporus: 49, 53),
Frlich (2: Bosporus: 67, 68), Baudelot de Dairval (1: Bosporus: 45), Maffei
(1: Bosporus: 48), du Choul (1: Bosporus: 53), Beger (1: Bosporus: 76), Cary
(1: Bosporus: 78).
Frlich 1754: Cary (10: 84, 85, 86, 87, 88, 89 [footnote n], 90 [footnote o], 91,
96, 97), Foy-Vaillant (4: 86, 87, 93 [footnote q], 94 [footnote s]), Frlich (1: 93
[footnote r]).
Belley 1756: Foy-Vaillant (5: 74/5, 79, 81, 84, 85), Souciet (4: 76, 77, 82, 83),
Frlich (2: 75 [footnote d], 84), Cary (1: 75 [footnote d]), Noris (1: 81), Spanheim
(1: 85).
Frlich 1758: Cary (2: 202, 206), Xavier (1: 205), Haym (1: 205).
Eckhel 1794: Cary (11: 368, 373, 374, 375, 376, 377, 378, 379, 380, 381, 382),
Foy-Vaillant (8: 367 [footnote h], 368, 371, 372, 373, 374, 375, 376), Frlich
(7: 368, 369 [footnote z], 371, 372, 373, 381, 382), Sestini (7: 368, 374, 375, 377,
378, 379, 380), Pellerin (6: 368, 372, 377, 379, 380, 381), Belley (5: 369, 370, 371,
372, 373), Patin (3: 367 [footnote i], 369, 372), Souciet (3: 371, 372, 373), Gros de
Boze (1: 367 [footnote k]), Caylus (1: 369 [with a wrong reference: Rec. dAntiq.
Tom. II. p. 170]), Seguin (1: 371), Hardouin (1: 375), Haym (1: 377).
Annex II
Provenances of coins36
Spanheim 1706:
King of France (4: Polemo, 489; Sauromates 489, 491; Cotys, 502),
Great duke of Toscana (Rhoemetalces, 499),
Paris, Ste Genevive (489),
Schwarzburg (Pharnaces II, 486),
Pierre Seguin, 15991672, acquired by the king of France in 1669 (Sauromates, 489),
Hans Sloane, 16601753 (Rhescuporis, 500).
Hardouin 1709:
King of France (8: Pythodoris, 139; Sauromates, 140 [3]; Eupator, 140;
Rhoemetalces AV year 501, 140 [vidi cum D. de Boze]; Cotys, 141 [vidi cum
D. de Boze]; Sauromates, 141 [vidi cum D. de Boze]),
Nicolas-Joseph Foucault, 16431721 (2: Rhoemetalces, 139; Eupator, 140),
Thesaurus Brandenburgicus (Rhescuporis, 140),
36
Cary 1752 is a clear example of real provenances. Others (e.g. Frlich 1752)
may be less clear about who really owned and who published the quoted coins.
578
579
580
581
582
583
584
585
586
587
Annex III
Number of pages and illustrations of the main references
to Bosporan royal coinages (17th18th c.)
References
Pages
Engraved coins
1665 Seguin
1706 Spanheim
21
1709 Hardouin
107
18 + 9
46
105
42
1754 Frlich
25
1756 Belley
22
1758 Frlich
10
10
1789 Sestini
14
1728 Foy-Vaillant
1752 Frlich
1752 Cary
1794 Eckhel
Total
23
384
94 + 9
Bibliography
Ancient literature specific to royal Bosporan coinages (before 1800 classified in chronological order)38
Seguin 1665 Seguin P. Selecta numismata antiqua ex museu Petri Seguini.
P., 1665 (see p. 329: p. 33 [Rhoemetalces AE (p. 41 in 2nd ed.)], 35 [Cotys AV
year 529 (p. 43 in 2nd ed.)], 35 [Rhescuporis Ferreus year AAF sic! (p. 43
in 2nd ed.)], 38 [Pythodoris AR] and 39 [Ininthymevus AR year 531 (p. 47 in
2nd ed.)]. See also Foy-Vaillant J. Ad selecta P. Seguini numismata notae et observations. P., 1684 (see p. 3937).
Spanheim 1706 Spanheim E. Dissertationes de praestantia et usu numismatum antiquorum. n. ed.L., 1706. T. I. (see: p. 47998: De Ponti & Bospori regibus
in nummis 5 engraved coins: p. 487 [Pharnaces II AV year 247], 488 [Asander AV], 490 [Sauromates AR and Eupator year 459], 492 [Sauromates year 408]
and 498504: De Thraciae regum nummis p. 500 [Cotys AV year 529 and AF?]
and 501 [Rhescuporis AR year 521, AE year 531, ? year 542 and AE letters KC]).
Hardouin 1709 Hardouin J. Opera selecta. Nummi antiqui populorum et urbium illustrati. Amsterdam, 1709 (see p. 13941: De nummis Ponti regum).
Foy-Vaillant 1725 Foy-Vaillant J. Achaemenidarum imperium sive regum
Gros de Boze 1729:549564 is not relevant here since it is entirely devoted
to Pairisades (one plate inserted after p. 552 with 1 coin of Pairisades and 2 of
Lysimachus).
38
588
589
Grec par feu Mr. le Baron de Spanheim, avec des remarques & des preuves, enrichies du plus de 300 mdailles, & autres anciens monuments. Amsterdam, 1666
(see p. 419 [Sauromates], 421 [Eupator], 459, 493).
Patin 1672 Patin Ch. Thesaurus numismatum, e musaeo Caroli Patini. P.,
1672 (see p. 50 [Cotys III AR year 530]).
Foy-Vaillant 1674 Foy-Vaillant J. Numismata imperatorum romanorum
praestantiora a Julio Caesare ad Posthumum et tyrannos. Paris, 1674. 2 vol. (see:
p. 12930 [Sauromates AE year 408], 157 [Sauromates AV year 418], 2434
[Sauromates AV year 494]). Book often republished (Rome, 1743, etc.).
Patin 1675 Patin Ch. Suetonius. Opera quae exstant. Carolus Patinus
notis and numismatibus illustravit suisque sumptibus edidit. Basel, 1675 (see:
p. 25 [Pharnaces II with a wrong reading of the letters OSSA], 172 [Cotys V and
Rhescuporis IV, AE year 531], 298 [Polemo II]).
Morell 1683 Morell A. Specimen universae rei nummariae antiquae, quod
literatorum Reipublicae. P., 1683 (see p. 2324 and pl. VII [Pharnaces II AV year
247], 345 and pl. VIII [Sauromates I], pl. VII [Sauromates II], 397 and pl. VII
[Eupator] and Sauromates III).
Baudelot de Dairval 1686 Baudelot de Dairval Ch.-C. De lutilit des voyages et de lavantage que la recherche des antiquits procure aux scavans. P., 1686.
T. II (p. 588 [list of 3 kings], 6056, nr. 10 [Sauromates]).
Hardouin 1697 Hardouin J. Chronologia veteris testamenti ad vulgatam
versionem exacta, et nummis antiquis illustrata. Chronologiae ex nummis antiquis
restitutae. P., 1697 (see: V, p. 581, 613 [Pharnaces II AV year 247]).
Beger 16961702 Beger L. Thesaurus Brandeburgicus selectus sive gemmarum et numismatum graecorum in cimelarchio electorali Brandenburgico.
Colonia Marchica (= Berlin), I (1696, see: p. 271 [a bronze coin of the Pontic
city of Pharnakeia wrongly attributed to Pharnaces II]) and III (1702, see: p. 5
[Rhescuporis, classified as a rex Thraciae], 123 [Roemetalces, no ill.]).
Spanheim 1717 Spanheim E. Dissertationes de praestantia et usu numismatum antiquorum. N. Ed. Amsterdam, 1717. T. II. (see: p. 5767 [engraved coin of
Sauromates III]).
Haym 17191720 Haym N. Del Tesoro Britannico, overo il Museo
Nummario. Ove si contengono le Medaglie Greche e Latine in ogni metallo e
forma, non prima pubblicate. L., 17191720. 2 vol. (see: II, p. 516: De i re
Sauromati [2 engraved coins in the name of Sauromates belonging to the Duke of
Devonshire and a list p. 56 of all the Bosporan royal coins illustrated so far]). See
also the Latin translation: Thesauri Britannici, seu Museum Numarium, quo continentur numi Graeci et Latini, omnis metalli et formae, necdum editi, ab autore
ipso caelati. Vienna, 1763 and 1765. 2 vol.
Liebe 1730 Liebe S. Gotha numaria sistens thesauri Fridericiani numismata
antique aurea, agentea, aerea, ea ratione descripta, ut generali eorum notitiae exempla singularia subiungantur. Amsterdam, 1730 (see: p. 1011 [stater of Pharnaces II).
Tiepolo 1736 Tiepolo G.D. Musei Theupoli antiqua numismata olim collecta a Joanne Dominico Theupolo. Aucta & edira a Laurentio Equite et D. Marci
Procuratore et Federico Senatore fratribus Theupolis. Venice, 1736. 2 vol. (see:
p. 211, 249, 988, 1199, 1240).
Panel 1737 Panel X.A. Lettre touchant le mdaillier de feu M. Le Bret//
Journal de Trvoux. 1737. 11. Oct. P. 17871827 ([Polemo]).
590
591
Other References
Anokhin 1986 Anokhin V.A. Monetnoe delo Bospora. Kiev, 1986.
Babelon 1901 Babelon J. Trait des monnaies grecques et romaines.
P., 1901. I, 1.
Bayle 1706 Bayle P. Nouvelles de la Rpublique des Lettres, June 1705.
Barthlemy 1821 Barthlemy J.-J. Mmoires sur la vie et quelques uns
des ouvrages de J.J. Barthlemy crits par lui-mme en 1792 et 1793. P., 1821.
(uvres de J.-J. Barthlemy; T. IV).
de Callata (in press) de Callata F. Vaillant, Frlich and the Others
(Spanheim, Beger, Haym, Liebe, Pellerin, Eckhel, Duane, etc.): the Remarkable
Interest for Seleucid Coinages in the 18th c. // Numismatics and Monetary History
in the Age of Enlightenment: (Proceedings of an international conference hold in
Dresden, May 4th9th, 2009) / C.E.Dekesel (ed.). Wolffenbttel (in press)
Cary 1744 Cary F. Dissertations sur la fondation de la ville de Marseille;
sur lhistoire des rois du Bosphore Cimmrien et sur Lesbonax, philosophe de
Mytilne. P., 1744.
Dekesel 1995 Dekesel C.E. Jean Foy-Vaillant (16321706): the Antiquary of
the King // Numismatische Literatur, 15001864: die Entwicklung der Methoden
einer Wissenschaft / P. Berghaus (ed.). Wiesbaden, 1995. P. 4755.
Foy-Vaillant 1681 Foy-Vaillant J. Seleucidarum imperium, sive historia
regum Syriae. P., 1681.
Foy-Vaillant 1701 Historia Ptolemoerum Egypti regum, ad fidem numismatum accommodate. Amsterdam, 1701.
Frolova 1979 Frolova N. The Coinage of the Kingdom of Bosporus, A.D.
69238. Oxf., 1979 (BAR Suppl. Ser. 56).
Frolova 1983 Frolova N. The Coinage of the Kingdom of Bosporus, A.D.
242341/342. Oxf., 1983. (BAR Suppl. Ser. 166).
Frolova, Ireland 2002 Frolova N., Ireland S. The coinage of the Bosporan
Kingdom: from the first century BC to the middle of the first century A.D.
Oxf., 2002.
Gros de Boze 1729 Gros de Boze Cl. Des rois du Bosphore cimmrien //
Mmoires de Littrature tirez des registres de lAcadmie royale des Inscriptions
et Belles Lettres. Depuis lanne M.DCCXVIII. jusques & compris lanne. 1729.
VI. P.549564.
von Khler 1850 Khler H.K.E. von. XVIII. Mdailles de Pharnace II, roi
du Bosphore cimmrien // H.K.E. Khlers gesammelte Schriften in Auftrge der
kaiserlichen Akademie der Wissenschaften / L. Stefani (ed.). St. Petersburg, 1850.
T. II. S. 219225.
Lazius 1558 Lazius W. Commentariorum vetustorum numismatum maximi
scilicet operis et quatuor sectionibus multarum rerum publicarum per Asiam,
Aphricam et Europam antiquitatis historiam nodosque Gordianis difficiliores
comprehendendis. Speicmen exile ceu ex tecto tegula quaedam C. Julii dictatoris,
Augusti et Tyberii Caesarum monetam, si quae ex argento in forulis S. R. R. M.
extat, explicans, tabulam videlicet sectionis tertiae parties secundae primam.
Vienna, 1558.
Momigliano 1950 Momigliano A. Ancient History and the Antiquarian //
Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes. 1950. 13. P. 285315.
592
..
(18561919), ,
,
. ,
. , ,
, ,
.. -. , ,
,
.. - 1.
1912 .
19131915 .
2. , , ,
. , : ,
, ( ) , ( ).
, , . , , , ,
, 3. ,
2006 . . .. , 150- .., .
, (.., .. , .. .) .
2
1990: 2531, 3739, 4445 .
3
1990: 299.
1
594
, . .
4. 1898 .
.. : ...
() : , 54,
6- . , , , , , , ,
II, III. ?..5.
, ,
.
, .
(193211) (208212), ,
..6 1880 . .
. , , . . ADVENTUS
AUG..., , , SC (Senatus Consulto)7.
.. ( )
,
2002: 222.
2002: 222..
6
(18551933)
, ,
. 1875 .
.
.. (1887 .) (1891 .). -
..- .
( 1887 .) ,
(. . . 136, . 74, . 7).
7
1968: 94; 2005: 215.
4
5
... ...
595
,
... , :
1) . 196 . ..
.. , . L SEPT SEV PERT
AVG IMP VIII.
.. , . .
ADVENTVI AVG FELICISSIMO. SC.
.: Mattingly, Sydenham 1936: 189. 719.
2) . 196 . ..
.. , . L SEPT SEV PERT
AVG IMP VIII.
.. , . .
ADVENTV AVG FELICISSIMO (sic!). SC.
.: Mattingly, Sydenham 1936: 190. 731.
. ,
, ,
. , .
.
. 210212 . ..
.. , . P SEPTIMIVS
GETA PIVS AVG BRIT.
.. , . , vexillum. ADVENTVS
AVGVSTI. SC.
.: Mattingly, Sydenham 1936: 342. 1828.
... . , 1898., ,
12 .
, .
-
, .. .
.. (18331902)
: ... :
. .: , 2003: 1466 .
596
: .
23 . 9,
,
. , , , ,
... ,
. ...
...10.
1899. 100 , , .
, 4500 1300 .
.. ,
11.
.. : ...
,
, , - .
, ,
,
,
, ...12.
.., , , ,
: ..
...
; ,
, .
...
-
... [] :
...13.
9
. (. ). - .
10
2002: 222.
11
2002: 248.
12
1995. I: 141.
13
1995. I: 250.
... ...
597
. : ..
, .
. 4
. 6
, 14.
, ,
.. , . .
. .., ..
. , ,
:
. 1906. .
1917. ,
.., .
1939. ..:
.. : . 1968. -
, 2005. - ..15.
. ..
, . ..16,
.., ..17, ..18,
2002: 240.
1968: 92117; 2005: 211225.
16
(18581920) , ( 1889 .), ,
( 1900 .), - (1907). (1910) . ( . 2004: 106109).
17
(18371908)
,
, .
18
(18491925)
( 1900 .), ( 1894 .),
( . 2004:
121123).
14
15
598
.
19.
.
.
..,
.
. .
-, , .. .
, ... ...
[] , ...
, , ... , , , ,
, ...20.
,
,
1768. .21.
. , ( ,
),
... ... , , ...,
( ,
. ..). , .. ,
2002: 302; 2005: 211.
1994: 230.
21
(17171768) ,
. (1764). 1768 . ,
.
19
20
... ...
599
... , ,
...22.
, .
23,
III24, 25
, .
, ( ,
. ..)
( ,
XVIIIXIX. ..). : ... -
5 . ... 15 .).
.
, , ,
.. ,
150 , .. . : ...
, ,
,
, ...26.
, :
?
, !
?
, -, - .
1994: 232.
(18261894) , .
24
III (18691947)
19001946 . 120 .
. ,
, ,
( 2005: 103110).
25
(18661933)
I, -.
.
26
1994: 235.
22
23
600
? , !..
, . , , : ,
!
, .., , , ,
.27 IV
5000 ., ... ,
.
.. .
. , , ,
.
. ,
, ,
, !,
.
100 ,
.
.28,
, ... , ...
.. .
, ...
, ,
, , , ... ...
. , ... ,
... ,
, ,
(-) (18721934)
, .
.
28
(17721830) -,
. ( 1993: 210 .).
27
... ...
601
. :
?
... ..29
, , , ,
.
- ,
1917.
1924 . .
1478 30.
1939. ..31 3470 ..,
12, 822, 2629, 7.
, . ,
.. . 1943.
, ,
, 1944.32
1947.
, , , , , 33. , ..
, . . .., ,
.
.., . ,
, 34.
..29
(18951975) .., ( 2008: 824825).
30
2006: 28.
31
(19001956) .., - ( 2008: 820)
32
2006: 23.
33
2006: 23.
34
. : 2006: 2223.
602
, ,
.
1500 , ,
, ,
,
35. , ,
,
36. , ,
37.
Summary
Numismatic Addictions of Russian philosopher Vasiliy Rozanov
and his Archaeology of Ancient Miniatures
by V.V.Khukharev (Tver)
Not so thoroughly renowned is the part of the heritage of Russian philosopher Vasily Rozanov presented by series of essays related to numismatics. So far from being associated with philosophical studies on a first
glance, numismatics is given to a closer consideration in Rozanovs philosophical and publicistic works.
In Solitaria (1912) and Fallen Leaves (19131915) there was a remark often mentioned: beyond numismatics. Rozanov turned into a research technique adjacent with a particular state of mental activity. Contact
with authentic evidences of times past so long ago fostered his interest in
ancient history. The opportunity to see and even to touch with his hands
those artifacts of previous generations gave a powerful emotional message,
and sometimes the basis for a number of publications. In spring of 1899
Rozanov quit his work in State Control for a new assignment in The New
Time, what allowed him to devote himself completely to the passion of
collecting. Within a few years he managed to amass a collection of 4,500
Greek and 1,300 Roman coins.
We know from his memoirs how much he loved to show this collection
to visitors of his jours-fixes. Coins or rather work on them took a special
place in Rozanovs life. Thirty one remarks beyond numismatics mentioned in small essays of the philosopher. In addition to it, he prepared two
2004: 5458.
2002: 626.
37
.. (),
.. (, ) .. ().
35
36
... ...
603
604
2006 .. .. -:
// -, 18561919: ( 150- ): . ., 2006.
. 526.
. 2004 , 1852
1917.: . / .., .., ..
(.-.). ., 2004.
2006 .. .. . .. //
-, 18561919: ( 150-
): . ., 2006. . 2740.
2002 ..
.. // : . .
. ., 2002. . 301303.
2005 .. .. //
. ., 2005. . 211225.
2008 / .. (.,
.). ., 2008.
2005 .. XVII
XX.: . . ., 2005.
1993 .. . . . ., 1993.
1994 .. : ( .. ..) // : .
. ., 1994. . 8183.
1995 ..: pro et contra: 2 . / .. (.,
., .). ., 1995.
1968 .. :
// .. ..
. 2- . -, 1968. . 92117.
1990 .. . ., 1990.
1990 .. . ., 1990.
1994 .. // .. . ., 1994. . 229238.
2005 .. III
// . . : 85-
..: . . . ., 2005. . 103110.
2002 .. :
. .; , 2002.
, 2003 .., ..
: . ., 2003. . III: .
2004 .. : //
. ...
: . 2004. 9(54). . 5458.
Mattingly, Sydenham 1936 Mattingly H., Sydenham E.A. The Roman
Imperial Coinage. L., 1936. Vol. IV, pt. 1.
. .
, .
. .
, , . .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. --.
. .
. .
. .
. .
. . .
. .
. .
, .
. .
.
.
. .-., 1965.
. .
. .
, .
.
,
. .
. .-.
. .
. .
.., .. . ., 1968.
606
. .
. .
..
. (I) , 1964, (II) , 1973.
, ., .
.. ,
. ., 1891.
. .
, , .
.
. .
. .
-
. .
. .
. .
. .
,
, .
. A.
ACSS Ancient Civilizations from Scythia to Siberia. An International
Journal of Comparative Studies in History and Archaeology,
Leiden, Boston, Kln.
AE LAnne pigraphique. P.
Agora XXVI The Athenian Agora. Vol. XXVI. The Greek Coins. By J.H.Kroll
with contributions by A.S.Walker. PrincetonNew Jersey, 1993.
AIIN Annali, Istituto Italiano di Numismatica. Roma.
AION Annali Istituto Orientali di Napoli. Napoli.
AJA American Journal of Archaeology. Durham-Boston-Milwaukee.
ALG Anthologia lyrica Graeca. Fasc. IIII / Ed. E.Diehl. Lpz.,
19491954.
AMNG Pick B., Regling K. Die antiken Mnzen von Dacien und Moe
sien. Die antiken Mnzen Nord-Griechenlands. Vol. I.B., 1898.
ANSMN American Numismatic Society Museum Notes. N.Y.
BAR British Archaeological Reports. Oxf.
BCH Bulletin de correspondance hellnique. P.
BEFAR Bibliothque des coles Franaises dAthnes et de Rome. P.
BMC Attica Head B.V. Catalogue of the Greek Coins in the British Museum.
Attica Megaris Aegina. L., 1888.
BMC Pont. Wroth W. A Catalogue of the Greek coins in the British
607
Museum. Catalogue of Greek Coins. Pontus, Paphlagonia,
Bithynia, and the Kingdom of Bosporus. L., 1889.
BMC Thrace Poole R.S. Catalogue of the Greek Coins in the British Museum.
The Tauric Chersonese, Sarmatia, Dacia, Moesia, Thrace. L.,
1877.
BSl Byzantinoslavica. Prague.
CAH The Cambridge Ancient History. Cambr.
CBC Walker A. Ancient Greek Coins. The Credit Bank Collection.
Athens, 1978.
CCCHBulg. Coin Collections and Coin Hoards from Bulgaria Volume IV
in series: The Numismatic collection of the Regional Museum
at Vratsa Part I; Lost, dispersed and unpublished coin hoards
Part II. Sofia, 2011.
CCCHBulg. III Coin Collection & Coin Hoards from Bulgaria. Vol. III. The
Numismatic Collection of the Regional Historical Museum at
Smolyan (Central Rhodopes) / Prokopov I., Filipova S.,
Paunov E. (eds.). Sofia, 2011
CH Coin Hoards. L.
CIL III Corpus Inscriptionum Latinarum. B., 1902.
CRAI Acadmie des Inscriptions et Belles-Lettres. Comptes-Rendus. P.
DAFA Dlgation archologique franaise en Afghanistan
DOP Dumbarton Oaks Papers. Washington.
EI Encyclopedia Iranica. Leiden.
FHG Fragmenta Historicorum Graecorum. P.
GIM .., ..
. . ., 2005.
HN Head B.V. Historia Numorum. A Manual of Greek Numismatics.
Oxf., 1911.
IG Inscriptiones graecae. B., 1860
IG II Inscriptiones Graecae II et III: Inscriptiones Atticae Euclidis
anno posteriores, 2nd edn. Parts IIII / Ed. J.Kirchner. B.,
19131940.
IG VII Inscriptiones Graecae, Inscriptiones Megaridis et Boeotiae /
W.Dittenberger (Hrsg.). B., 1892.
IGBulg I Inscriptiones graecae in Bulgaria repertae / Ed. G.Mihailov.
Vol. 1. 2nd ed.Inscriptiones orae Ponti Euxini. Sofia, 1970.
IGBulg. Inscriptiones graecae in Bulgaria repertae / Ed. G.Michailov.
Sofia, 19581970, 1997.
IGBulg. V Mihailov G., Banev K., Medarov K. Inscriptiones Graecae in
Bulgaria Repertae. Vol. 5. Serdicae, 1997.
IGCH An Inventory of Greek Coin Hoards / Ed. M.Thompson,
O.Mrkholm, C.M.Kraay. New York, 1973.
IKalch. Die Inschriften von Kalchedon / Ed. RMerkelbach. Bonn,
1980.
608
IosPE Inscriptiones antiquae orae septentrionalis Ponti Euxini graecae
et latinae, ed. V.Latyschev. Petropoli.
IosPE I Inscriptiones antiquae orae septentrionalis Ponti Euxini graecae
et latinae / Ed. Basilius [Vasilii] Latyshev. 3 vols. St. Petersburg
18851901. Vol. 1. 2nd ed.Inscriptiones Tyriae, Olbiae,
Chersonesi Tauricae. St. Petersburg, 1916.
IRRCHBulg Paunov E., Prokopov I. An Inventory of the Roman Republican
Coin Hoards and Coins in Bulgaria. Milano, 2002 (Glaux. 15.).
ISM Inscriptiones Scythiae Minoris graecae et latinae. I. Inscriptiones
Histriae et viciniae / Ed. D. Pippidi. Bucuresti, 1983.
JAOS Journal of American Oriental Society. New Haven.
JHS Journal of Hellenic Studies. L.
JHS The Journal of Hellenic Studies. Cambr.
JIAN Journal international darchologie numismatique. Athne.
JNES Journal of Near Eastern Studies. Chicago.
JB Jahrbuch der sterreichischen Byzantinistik. Wien.
JRS The Journal of Roman Studies. L.
LGPN A Lexicon of Greek Personal Names. Oxf.
LIMC Lexicon iconographicum mythologiae classicae. Vol. VI. 12.
ZrichMnchen, 1992.
Lindgren Lindgren H.C., Kovacs F.L. Ancient Bronze Coins of Asia
Minor and the Levant. San Mateo, 1985.
MDAI AA Mitteilungen des Deutschen Archaologischen Instituts.
Athenische Abteilung. B.
MDAI RA Mitteilungen des Deutschen Archologichen Instituts. Rmische
Abteilung. Rom.
MM II .. IVI . ..
// (
). II. ., 2004. . 1055.
NB Numismatica Bulgarica. Sofia.
NC Numismatic Chronicle. L.
NX . .
PG Patrologiae cursus completus. Series graeca, accurente
J.P.Migne. Patrologiae graeca. P.
Price Price M.J. The Coinage in the Name of Alexander the Great and
Philip Arrhidaeus. ZrichLondon, 1991.
RBNS Revue Belge de Numismatique et de Sigillographie. Bruxelles.
RE Paulys Realencyclopdie der classischen Altertumswissenschaft.
Stuttgart.
RN Revue numismatique. P.
RNS SP Royal Numismatic Society Special Publications. L.
RPC Burnett A., Amandry M., Ripolles P.P. The Roman Provincial
Coinage. Vol. I: From the Death of Caesar to the Death of
Vitellius (44 BC 69 AD). LondonParis, 1992.
609
SA . .
SEG Supplementum Epigraphicum Graecum. Leiden, 19232003.
SNG Sylloge Nummorum Graecorum.
SNG BM Sylloge Nummorum Graecorum. Vol. IX. The British Museum.
Part 1. The Black Sea / Ed. Price M.J. L., 1993.
SNG Cop. Sylloge Nummorum Graecorum. The Royal Collection of Coins
and Medals, Danish National Museum. Vol. 3. Greece: Thessaly
to Aegean Islands (Attica Aegina). New Jersey, 1982 (Reprint
of the first edition, Copenhagen, 1944).
SNG Cop. Thrace Sylloge Nummorum Graecorum. The Royal Collection of
Coins and Medals, Danish National Museum. Vol. 2. Thrace and
Macedonia (Thrace). New Jersey, 1982 (Reprint of the first
edition, Copenhagen, 1942).
SNG Mnchen Sylloge Nummorum Graecorum. Deutschland. Staatliche
Mnzsammlung. Mnchen. 14. Heft. Attika, Megaris, gina.
Mnchen, 2002.
Svoronos Svoronos J.N. Les monnaies dAthnes. Tables composes par
B.Pick. Mnich, 19231926.
Syll. Sylloge inscriptionum graecarum / Ed. W. Dittenberger. Lipsiae,
19151924.
Weber coll. Forrer L. The Weber collection. Vol. II. Greek coins: Macedon
Thrace Thessaly North Western, Central and Southern
Greece. L., 1924.
ZfN Zeitschrift fr Numismatik. B.
ZPE Zeitschrift fr Papyrologie und Epigraphik. Kln.
611
- -
(, )
, ,
()
, ,
() ,
,
- (, ) ,
,
, -
() ,
(, )
.
(, )
;
(),
, -
(, ) ,
(-)
, Parabellum novum
() ,
. ..
(, )
(, )
( )
(, )
()
(, ) -
- .
- (, )
,
....
(, ) ,
(, ) (Dr. hab.),
Directeur de Recherche (DR-2), CNRS UMR 8167 Orient et
Mditerrane
() ,
,
. ..
() ,
- ,
(, )
,
(, )
(, )
, ()
() -
(-)
,
-
(, ) ,
612
,
. ..
(, ) ,
() ,
. ..
() ,
()
(-)
, -
()
,
() ,
-
(, )
()
- -
( ),
() ,
Scripta antiqua. , ,
,
. . ,
.
, , , .
- 20. . , - ,
.
, 8, 300 dpi.
Unicode, Times New Roman Titus.
.
(, Hellenica, Greek ..),
Unicode. ,
, , .. .
, .
.
: ,
; ,
.
.
, ;
614
: . (. NN; . : ).
(), .
:
: : .
:
.. . , .
, .
.. // . . . . . . , ,
Bd Hbd .
.. // /
.. (.). , . . .
. .
. .
.
, (, ..)
. , :
.. . ,
( . NN ). . .
, : ( ). Fig (Pl./Tav. ..). . Abb.
.
.
.
,
: (. ???). ; .
.
,
:
,
, : Fig. 4.6.
615
(, , , ,
, ) , , -.
, , , ,
-, Berlin, Cambridge, Leipzig, New York, Oxford, Paris,
.
pdf.
, .
.
45
Scripta antiqua. , ,
: / [. . . . ] ;
. - . . : , 2011 .
ISSN 2221-9560 . ISBN978-5-9606-0113-9.
. 4. 2015. 616c. ISBN978-5-9606-0135-1.
Scripta antiqua. ,
, .
, , , ,
,
.. ..,
,
...
,
.
: , . . 325320 . ..
121471, , ., . 45
77-44032 22 2011 .
: 117519, , . , 15
.: (495) 389-68-66, 389-68-88
121471, , ., . 45
. +7 (495) 389 68 88 http://www.lubimayarossia.ru
00.00.2015 .
6090/16. . . . 38,50. .-. . 00,00
300 . oooo
121099, , ., 6