Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
The pneumatic diaphragm actuator must be able to close against a differential pressure
of 40 bar. Manual operation is an additional requirement. The function is direct (valve is
open on air failure-stem retracts). The intensity characteristic of cavitation and the limit of
the outlet velocity will be checked. If severe cavitating occurs a hardened or armored trim
should be chosen. Control valve accessories are required: I/P positioner and pressure
regulator. Furthermore, a material certificate in accordance with 3.1B is necessary. The
permissible sound pressure level is 85 dB(A).
18.1.1. Solution
18.1.1.1 Calculation of Cv-value, selection of valve characteristic and nominal
size.
The three different Cv-values are first computed. They are based on the following:
FL = 0.92; XFz = 0.28 at operating point qmax.
W
Cv =
27.3 ⋅ Fp ⋅ FY ⋅ FR ⋅ ∆ p ⋅ ρ
The factor FP becomes 1.0, since pipe size = valve size. This is also valid for the factor
FR, because the fluid is water with a viscosity ν of 0.33. The factor Fy first requires the
determination of FF:
pv 0.71
FF = 0.96 − 0.28 ⋅ = 0.96 − 0.28 ⋅ = 0.96 − 0.0159 ≅ 0.94
pc 221
p −F ⋅p 28 − 0.94 ⋅ 0.71
FY =
FL ⋅ 1 F v = 0.92 1.38 < 1.0
=
p1 − p2 28 − 16
The value of Fy must always be smaller than 1.0. If a higher value occurs, Fy must be set
to 1.0. This is also evidence that no flow limitation occurs and that the full value of the
differential pressure may be used. This gives a flow coefficient Cv as follows:
W 30000
=Cv = ≅ 10.2
27.3 ⋅ Fp ⋅ FY ⋅ FR ⋅ ∆ p ⋅ ρ 27.3 ⋅ 1⋅ 1⋅ 1⋅ 12 ⋅ 967
By application of the above mentioned equations. The following values result for minimum
and maximum flow:
Cvmin = 2.7 and Cvmax = 23.5
With the usual safety margin factor of at least 1.25 the required Cv-value results:
23.5 ∙ 1.25 = 29.4
The next higher rated Cv-value of the data sheet is 47, which corresponds to a nominal
size of DN 50. Therefore, a standard valve, DN 50 is chosen. Generally, the rangeability
Cvmax/Cvmin as well as the flow velocity should be checked. This gives the following values:
Cvmax / Cvmin ≈ 9
Rated Cv/Cvmin ≈ 17.4 ≈ 20.2% travel at Cvmin
In accordance with recommendations in Chapter 11.3.-2 a modified equal percentage
characteristic curve is chosen by selecting Series 3250. At minimum flow we get a valve
stroke of approx. 20.2 % and at maximum flow a travel of approx. 60%. These are quite
acceptable values. The flow velocity at qmax becomes:
Q 40000 ⋅ 4 π ⋅ d2
Q=
A ⋅ v, v == 5.9 m / s
= A=
A 962 ⋅ 3600 ⋅ 0.052 ⋅ π 4
18.1.1.2 Cavitation and reliability check and prediction of the noise level to be
expected
Not critical sound cavitation < 85 dB(A) up to damaging cavitation can occur if the pressure
ratio xF is considerably higher than the xFz value of the control valve. The highest pressure
ratio results from:
p1 − p2 35 − 16
= xFz = ≅ 0.55
p1 − pv 35 − 0.71
The normal valve trim would indeed be damaged - like in this example at qmin
∆p > ∆pcrit. = 15 bar - if the type specific Kc or xFmr value at minimal flow would be only 0.55
or less. At a valve load of Φ ≈ 6% however, the type specific Kc or xFmr value is approx.
0.7, i.e. no cavitation damage is expected even at the highest differential pressure (see
also picture Figure 8.7.-9 for the determination of the XFz value for a seat guided ported
plug). Generally it can be assumed that control valves < DN 100 do not create sound
pressure levels > 85 dB(A) if cavitation-free flow conditions exist. This assumption is also
true in this example with sound cavitation as shown in the calculation menu of SAMSON
sizing flowchart (Figure 18.1.1.6.-1).
The Kc value is a traditional flow measured value for onset of choked flow from
former times, which also used from some manufacturers as a approximation for
detecting material damage. Today a cooperation of SAMSON AG with the Darmstadt
University of Technology using established methods for detecting cavitation
damage at flow machines (pump impellers) which also practical for control valves.
(See Reprint SAMSON WA 174 EN, http://www.samson.de/material/deadv001.htm)
Also there were researches of cavitation damage from US institutes published in the
ISA recommended practice ISA RP 75.23-1995. Both methods using roughly comparable
factors. The incipient damage cavitation factor σid (ISA RP 75.23) in the reversed form
1/σid with the new xFid factor (Research of SAMSON AG and Technical University
Darmstadt, Germany) As a first approx. the former valve factor Kc can be used because
xFid measurements not completely available on short term.
The test is time consuming, because operating at the incipient damage level of cavitation
these new factors may produce objectionable noise and vibration in a control valve; minor
indications of pitting begin on softer materials like copper or aluminum.
SAMSON AG recommend also an application dependent valve operating limit called
“manufacturer’s recommended limit” or xFmr factor1 lean on the ISA RP 75.23 practice
(1/σmr ≈ xFmr). Some valves may not have been tested due to test facility limitations. In
these circumstances, only a xFmr based on field experience, damage testing, or other
criteria agreeable to the user.
The manufacturer’s recommended limit for cavitation. xFmr, is the limit suggested for a
given valve. It may or may not coincide with other cavitation coefficients such as incipient
damage or constant cavitation. Published values of this limit are based on experience and
on the normal type of application for the valve. Published values may not be suitable for
all applications. The manufacturer also should publish the criteria for the selection of xFmr.
The manufacturer always should be contacted to verify the recommended limit for each
type of valve application.
18.1.1.3 Valve type and trim material selection for SAMSON globe valve.
If other valve cavitation factors are available:
* xFmr can also be substitute with ≈ Kc ≈ FL3 ≈ xFid ≈ 1/σmr ≈1/σid
Start
Yes
No remark xF < xFz
?
No
Note:
xFz, Kc, xFmr Yes
∆p > 15 bar
always from database!
?
No
No
xF > xFmr = 0.7 or Kc
?
Yes
Yes
∆p > 25 bar
?
No
Figure 18.1.1.3.-1: Valve type and trim material selection for SAMSON globe valves
Calculation results
Cv calculated 2.7 10.2 23.5
Cv required / type /size Cv100 = 47; Type 3251; NPS 2
Rel. travel %
27 61 81
f(characteristic e.q.%)
SPL (EN 60534 8-4) 74 78 64 dB(A)
Outlet velocity U2 1.46 4.39 5.86 m/s
xFz(p1) from valve data base 0.4 0.32 0.26
xF 0.55 0.44 0.21
xFmr 0.7
Incipient Incipient No cavitation
Reliability check:
or sound or sound U2 < 8 m/s
Follow the green and blue
cavitation cavitation OK
path in the flowchart Fig.
U2 < 5 m/s U2 < 5 m/s
18.2.-3
OK OK
Table 18.1.1.5.-4: Results of the Cv – and reliability check of three operating points.
Here Type 3251 DN 50 is selected because of the equal percentage characteristic high quality.
SAMSON AG Start
Valve selection flowchart All liquids with p2 > pv
1 Avoid or minimize cavitation.
Angle type globe valve with
Notes to flowchart Abrasive Yes hardened or ceramic trim and
see next Page fluid outlet liner (FTC) or Rotary
x ? Plug Valve hardened or
No ceramic disk and outlet liner.
(FTC = Flow To Close)
No
xF > xFz
?
Yes
Design with
Yes
xFz > xF
available
?
2
No
4 3
No No
SPL > x5
?
Standard Globe Valve (top guided)
Series V2001; (seat guided) Series
Yes
3240, and 3250.
Yes
∆p > ∆pcrit. = x2 Standard Rotary Plug Valve without
? measures.
Standard Butterfly Type 3331, and
No
Type 3237, Leusch, Pfeiffer or
Segment Ball Valve Type 3310 etc..
No
Hardened trim/disk and/ ∆p > ∆pcrit. = x3
or seat area for: ?
Standard Globe Valve Hardened trim/disk and/or seat area
(Top guided) Series Yes for: Heavy duty design: Series 3240,
V2001; (seat guided) and 3250. Seat- or top and bottom
Series 3240, and 3250. Hardened trim / disk and / or guided plug. Anti-Cavitation AC trim
Standard Rotary Plug seat area for: low noise measures: Baffles, etc..
Valve. Multi-stage Anti Cavitation AC-3 High performance rotary valves. In
Standard Butterfly - Type Trim, and AC-5 Trim. case of mechanical overstressing
3331, and Type 3237, Heavy duty design, Special limits reduce ∆p with multi-hole
Leusch, Pfeiffer. Segment rotary valves with multistage low downstream baffles or silencer.
Ball Valve Type 3310 etc.. noise devices. Proper downstream piping.
Figure 18.1.1.6.-1: SAMSON sizing selection flowchart for liquids (pv > p2)
Notes to flowchart:
1 Abrasive and corrosive fluids Risk of damage, keep U2* < 3 m/s
m p − pv m m
3 < 4.5 ⋅ 2 ⋅1 < 5
s 1bar s s
Recalculation with the chosen actuator 700 cm² spring range 0.2 to 0.6 bar and
Air supply 3 bar:
① ⑥
② ⑦
③ ⑧
④ ⑨
⑤ ⑩
Other values in SAMSON actuator sizing - here less important - are explained for better
understanding:
Required actuator thrust (Fm req.) ② Pressure balance
(see next example Chapter 18.2
Hysteresis
Hysteresis % = 10 ∙ 2 ∙ FR / A (pst100 – pst0)
Hysteresis % = 20 ∙ 100.48 / 700 ( 0.6 – 0.2) = 7.18 ⑨
At least only for „stem retract - air to close“
Figure 18.1.1.7.-3: Control valve Type 3251 with Positioner Type 3731-x
Valve data
Body type Globe valve Series 3250
Valve coefficient Cv 47 Type 3251
Nominal size DN ["] 2" Body material A216 WCC
Pressure ratings CLASS 300 Noise reduction without
Travel S [mm] 15 Charact. Equal perc.
Seat bore SB [mm] 48 Flow direction FTO
Stem diameter Sd [mm] 10 Balanced without (0,0)
Internal parts material 4571 / 316Ti Leakage rate IV
Packing PTFE (3,2) Bonnet standard
Sealing metal (2,0)
Pipe data Type of pipe Steel pipe Pipe insulation none D1 [mm] 50 D2 [mm] 50
cR [m/s] 5100 rho [kg/m³] 7800 di [mm] 54.5 s [mm] 2.9
Actuator data
Type 3277 Fail-safe act. retracts
Diaphr. area A [cm²] 700 Bench range ps0 [bar] 0,2 ... 0,6
Supply psu [bar] 3
(Defaults: p1max [bar(a)] 40 p2min [bar(a)] 1 t1max [°C] 90)
Actuator results
req. act. force Fo req. [kN] 7.46 req. diff. psu-ps100 d ps [bar] 1.17
max. act. force Fmax [kN] 24.97 Actuator force Fa [kN] 16.80
max. dp on plug d. pmax [bar] 90.61 Close safety factor Fa/Fo (SF) 2.25
req. start bench range ps0req. [bar] 0.02 Open safety factor Ff/Fw 13.64
Figure 18.1.1.8.-1: Calculation menu of SAMSON SIZING for liquids (Example 18.1)
SAMSON SIZING confirms the previous results. The actual sound pressure levels are
74, 78 and 64 dB(A). i.e. well below the permissible value of 85 dB(A). Partial sound
cavitation occurs, but without risk for material damage or stem vibration if a top and seat
guided contoured plug of series 3240 and 3250 are selected.
The valve load at maximum flow is only 81 %, i.e. we have safety reserves for a possible
flow increase at a later date. The results of SAMSON SIZING for the actuator calculation
procedure follow from Figure 18.1.1.8.-1 and Figure 18.1.1.8.-2. Also these results of the
manual calculation are confirmed by SAMSON SIZING. The effective signal range is 0.2
to 0.6 bar, caused by the different nominal travels of the control valve (15 mm) and the
selected actuator (30 mm).
Following the IEC standard 60534-2-4 SAMSON AG is calculating the real measured
inherent valve characteristic and Cv100 value to avoid any maladjustment of an additional
travel stop device if specific Cv – values have to be warranted e.g. in case of an interaction
with a safety valve.
Figure 18.1.1.8.-2: Calculation menu of SAMSON SIZING for liquids with the true stroke of 27 %, 61 %,
and 81 % at min, norm., and max. load and the true Cv100 value 45
Today all modern globe valve sizes with a competitive largest Cv100 value cannot fulfill
the tolerance limits for the true equal percentage characteristic, because of the global
competition in lower weight, travel and material cost pressure.
It is more important to have a smooth characteristic form. If relatively seldom there is a
real demand for a true e.q. characteristic valves with reduced seats or higher performance
Series 3250 may fulfill this demand.
The completely filled-in ISA Form S20.50, Rev.1 specification sheet (TAG-No. PIC - 4711)
is shown with Figure 18.1.1.8.-3.
SAMSON sizing software works together with SAMSON Project tools to generate Project
list, dimension drawings and ISA or IEC specification sheets.
Specification Form for Control Valves
According to ISA Form S20.50, Rev. 1
41 80 * Set Pressure
42 81 Filter Gauges
82
43 NEC Class Group Div.
SPECIALS / ACCESSORIES
44 83 * Hydrostatic Pressure
TESTS
The pneumatic diaphragm actuator must be able to close against 35 bar. The function is
REVERSE (valve closed on air failure). Air supply 4.5 bar. Control valve accessories are
I/P positioner, solenoid valve and pressure regulator. The maximum permissible sound
pressure level - considering thermal insulation of the pipeline (80 mm thick) - is 85 dB(A).
By means of an “Override”- function, which should be implemented through a three-way
solenoid valve, the valve should be able to achieve 75 % of the maximum flow coefficient
in less than one second. Furthermore, a material certificate is necessary in accordance
with 3.1B. The pipeline flanges are designed for a pressure rating of PN 40. Suitability of
the standard carbon steel material is to be checked. Otherwise a high temperature steel
body material must be used.
18.2.1. Solution
18.2.1.1 Calculation of the flow coefficient (Cv-value). selection of the valve
characteristic and nominal size.
First the three different Cv-values are calculated. They are calculated type specific in the
operating points min., norm., max: xT = 0.8; 0.77; 0.74. The respective inlet density can be
read off from corresponding steam tables. At inlet pressures of p1 = 30. 22 and 16 bar, the
corresponding inlet densities become 13.03, 9.31, and 6.64 kg/m3. The value of Fp can
simply be read off from Figure 5.4.3.-3. With a relationship of DN/D = 150/200 = 0.75 and
a ratio of Cv∙100/DN2 ≈ 68∙100/1502 = 0.3 for standard valves, a Fp value of approximately
0.99 results. For the calculation of Y first the value of Fy be must be determined.
γ 1.29
Fy
= = = 0.92
1.4 1.4
As already mentioned, for a calculation of the term Y, the value of the pressure ratio x
must be limited to the valve specific figure xT, even if the actual pressure ratio x is higher:
x < xT → 0.73 < 0.77.
x 0.73
Y=
1− 1−
= 1 − 0.367 =
= 0.643 ≥ 0.667
3 ⋅ Fy ⋅ x T 3 ⋅ 0.92 ⋅ 0.72
Since Y must be in any case between 0.667 and 1.0, the calculated value of Y must be
set to 0.667. This means that a critical pressure ratio and sonic velocity occur inside the
control valve. In this way, the flow coefficient Cv can be computed:
W
=Cv ≅ 68
27.3 ⋅ Fp ⋅ Y ⋅ 0.73 ⋅ 22 ⋅ 9.34
If the calculation procedure is repeated for the minimum and maximum flows, the results
are as follows: Cv ≈ 25 for Wmin and Cv ≈ 129 for Wmax.. Considering the usual safety margin
of 25 % on top of the maximum calculated Cv-value, the required Cv-value becomes:
Cv required = 129 ∙ 1.25 ≥ 161
So we select a rated Cv-value of 190. This corresponds to a nominal size of DN 150
with flow divider Type ST I or baffle type (downstream multi-hole orifice plates) which is
required to keep the sound pressure level within given limits. The relationship between
the maximum and minimum flow coefficients is as follows:
Cvmax/Cvmin @ 5.2
Rated Cv/Cvmin @ 7.6
This corresponds to a travel at Cvmin of approx. 8 % (linear characteristic) or approx. 41%
for an equal-percentage characteristic. Since normally a critical pressure ratio applies
and the required rangeability is comparably low, a satisfactory regulation can be achieved
with both basic valve characteristics.
The flow velocity in the valve outlet and the pipeline behind the valve can be roughly
computed if we assume a steam density of 2.45 kg/m³ at 6 bar and a fluid temperature of
275°C. This corresponds to a maximum flow volume of approx. 8042 m3/h at maximum
flow. The fluid velocities are as follows:
lg (1 − 0.73 )
= = 1.59
lg (1 − 0.555 )
The inner sound power can be computed with the acoustic efficiency factor and the given
operating data:
γ p1 lg (1 − x )
L= 134.4 + 10 ⋅ lg W + 10 ⋅ lg + 10 ⋅ lg + 10 ⋅ lg + 10 ⋅ lgηG
lg (1 − x cr )
wi
γ +1 ρ1
1.29 22 lg (1 − 0.73 )
L = 134.4 + 10 ⋅ lg15000 + 10 ⋅ lg + 10 ⋅ lg + 10 ⋅ lg + 10 ⋅ lg0.00003282
wi 1.29 + 1 9.34 lg (1 − 0.555 )
From the determined sound power Lwi, the “standardized sound power spectrum” can be
computed for the relevant frequencies:
f
L wi ( f ) = L wi + 10 ⋅ lg − 14.9
500
If the relevant frequencies 500; 1.000; 2.000; 4.000; and 8.000 Hz are inserted into the
equation above, the following rounded off internal sound power levels and transmission
losses will be achieved:
cR 5100
=fr = ≅ 8120 Hz
π ⋅ di π ⋅ 0.2
With the parameters now available, the pipe transmission loss RR can be computed:
c R ⋅ ρR ⋅ s fr 3 5 ⋅ f
RR (f ) = 10 + 10 ⋅ lg + 10 ⋅ lg + f
c F ⋅ ρF ⋅ di 5 ⋅ f r
If one inserts for f, the relevant frequencies, the transmission loss is shown in the table
above.
The external sound power Lwa results from the following equation:
4 ⋅l
L wa (f=
) L wi (f ) − RR (f ) + 10 ⋅ lg
di
With the considered pipe length (l) of l = 2.0 m the frequency-dependent values of Lwa are
shown in the table below. Therefore, one must not simply subtract the pipe transmission
loss of the inner sound power, but must still consider the term
4 ⋅l
10 ⋅ lg⋅
di
The external A-weighted sound power level is calculated from the individual non-weighted
sound levels when one adds the following adjustment values.
The aggregate level, which must be naturally higher than the largest single level, must
now be computed from the individual weighted sound power levels. The specific addition
occurs by taking the logarithmic sum with the basis 10 and an exponent of 0.1 ∙Lwa as
shown in the following equation:
The external A-weighted sound pressure level measured at a distance of 1.0 m downstream
of the outlet flange and 1.0 m of the pipe surface, results in the case of a cylindrical
radiation, approximately from the following equation:
π ⋅ l di
Lpa ≅ L wa − 10 ⋅ lg ⋅ + 2
l0 d0
π ⋅ 2 0.2
Lpa ≅ L wa − 10 ⋅ lg ⋅ + 2 ≅ L wa − 11
1 1
When subtracting the „measuring area“ value of approx. 11 dB(A) from the evaluated
sound power level. Lwa(A), one finally gets the sound pressure level
Lpa(A): 106.7 dB(A) - 11 dB(A) = 95.7 dB(A)
18.2.1.3 Summary:
The manual calculation in the table compares with the graphic from the software
CONVAL and SAMSON sizing.
The difference between the red and green bars is the damping function of the downstream
pipe versus the octave frequency band.
140.0 133.9
131
130.0 125 128
119 122
120.0
105.3 Lwi
110.0 99.3
100.2 101.3
100.0 93.9 91.7
Lwa (A)
88.8 89.9 87.9
90.0
77.1 80.3 Lpa (A)
80.0
70.0 65.6
60.0
50.0
40.0
30.0
20.0
10.0
0.0
Total 500 Hz 1 kHz 2 kHz 4 kHz 8 kHz
Figure 18.2.1.3.-1: Summary of the manual Sound calculation to VDMA 24422 Edition 89
Since the pipeline is provided with a thermal insulation of 80 mm thickness and the outlet
velocity of the fluid is very moderate, the correction of the computed sound pressure level
can be carried out in accordance with the equations (8-96) and (8-98). This gives the
following correction value for of the fluid velocity:
Lpa ' ≅ Lpa − ( 5.5 + lnMa ) ≅ 95.7 − ( 5.5 + ln0.18 ) ≅ 3.78 dB(A)
In this way, the total adjustment value becomes 3.78 + 8 dB(A) @ 11.7 dB(A), which can
be subtracted from the previously calculated sound pressure level. This gives a sound
pressure level at a distance of 1.0 m from the pipe surface at normal flow condition:
The tolerance band resulting from uncertainties of the calculation and from special
influences, is about 5 dB(A). In this way, the request for a maximum allowable sound
pressure level of 85 dB(A) at normal flow is guaranteed.
The result of the manual SPL calculation for the operating point Wnorm = 15000 kg/h
→ 88.5 dB(A) fits very good to the result of SAMSON Sizing 88 dB(A) if the standard
reduction of a thermal isolation is used.
Propsl./order no.: Customer
Project: Date: 04.03.2010 Data entered by:
Valve data
Body type Globe valve Series 3240
Valve coefficient Cv 190 Type 3241
Nominal size DN [mm] 150 Body material WN 1.7357
Pressure ratings PN 40 Noise reduction Flow div. I
Travel S [mm] 30 Charact. Equal perc.
Seat bore SB [mm] 100 Flow direction FTO
Stem diameter Sd [mm] 16 Balanced Graphite (10)
Internal parts material 4571 / 316Ti Leakage rate IV
Packing PTFE (1.6) Bonnet insulating s
Sealing metal (2,0)
Pipe data Type of pipe Steel pipe Pipe insulation TemperatureD1 [mm] 200 D2 [mm] 200
cR [m/s] 5100 rho [kg/m³] 7800 di [mm] 206,5 s [mm] 6,3
Actuator data
Type 3271 Fail-safe act. extends
Diaphr. area A [cm²] 700 Bench range ps0 [bar] 0,8 ... 2,4
Supply psu [bar] 3
(Defaults: p1max [bar(a)] 35 p2min [bar(a)] 1 t1max [°C] 275)
Actuator results
req. act. force Fm req. [kN] 4.55 req. diff. psu-ps100 d ps [bar] 0.51
max. act. force Fmax [kN] 49.89 Actuator force Fa [kN] 5.60
max. dp on plug d. pmax [bar] 86.14 Close safety factor Fa/Fo (SF) 1.23
req. start bench range ps0req. [bar] 0.72
*The calculated sound pressure level can not be guaranteed because of the pipe insulation.
Figure 18.2.1.4.-1: Valve calculation / selection of SAMSON SIZING for superheated steam
As can be seen from Figure 18.2.1.4.-2 a very good agreement is achieved with the manual
method of calculating values. SAMSON SIZING provides in addition more information
with respect to the noise spectrum Figure 18.2.1.4.-2.
Frequency division
In. sound power level LWi (octave bands)
500 Hz [dB] 116 119 120
1000 Hz [dB] 119 122 123
2000 Hz [dB] 122 125 126
4000 Hz [dB] 125 128 129
8000 Hz [dB] 128 131 132
Ext.sound power level LWa (Octave bands)
500 Hz [dB] 72 75 76
1000 Hz [dB] 85 88 89
2000 Hz [dB] 91 94 95
4000 Hz [dB] 92 96 96
8000 Hz [dB] 89 92 93
Figure 18.2.1.4.-2: Detailed noise calculation with display of important noise criteria
-10
31.5 63 125 250 500 1000 2000 4000 8000 16000
Octave Hz
-10
-20
-30
-40
Pipe normal size in mm
-50
50 100 200 300 400
-60
31.5 63 125 250 500 1000 2000 4000 8000 16000
Octave Hz
Before doing this a suitable actuator type from the manufacturer’s product range is
selected with a diaphragm area of 700 cm2.
Fmreq. ⋅ 1.25
=A = 711.09 cm2
10 ⋅ pst0
at H = 0, pst = 0
4551⋅ 1.25
=A = 711.09 cm2
10 ⋅ 0.8
Recalculation with the chosen actuator 700 cm2 spring range 0.8 to 2.4 air supply 3 bar:
⑥ Max. ∆pmax on plug = (Fa - FSF - FR – FRB - c) /10∙(π/4) Sd2
Max. ∆pmax on plug = 5600 - 3848.4 / 20.1 = 87.14 bar
Small deviation to SAMSON SIZING
Total friction force FR + FRB + c
c = actuator stem sealing force and other forces.
⑤ ⑦
⑧
⑥ ⑨
Figure 18.2.1.5.-2: SAMSON sizing shows hysteresis information 57.54 % only here and
SAMSON SVSS software recommends a larger actuator size:
A (pst100 – pst0) = (Actuator area ∙ spring range)
In case of pressure balance valves not only the shut down requirement should be the basic
for actuator selection. Because of the high hysteresis of a pressure balanced trim system
the actuator diaphragm area should be min. 700 cm2 to take a reasonable controllability
into account. Please check this always with SAMSON Sizing SPECIALIST Software.
Page 3/4
Quote/order no.: Customer:
Project: Date: 04.03.2010 Data entered by:
Expert
Category Noise
Evaluation Increased
Recommendation flow divider III
Category Cavitation
Evaluation -
Recommendation -
Category Flashing
Evaluation -
Recommendation -
Category Rangeability
Evaluation o.k.
Recommendation -
Figure 18.2.1.6.-1: SAMSON SPECIALIST SVSS Software checks the total valve performance with
actuator 700 cm² including the influence of the hysteresis to the controllability.
Figure 18.2.1.6.-2: Selection of actuator 700 cm² (spring range 1.2 to 3.6 bar), to improve controllability
with reduced hysteresis from 57.5 to 38.3 %.
⑩ Hysteresis
10 ⋅ 2 ⋅ (FR + FRB ) 20 ⋅ 3220.4
=
Hyst. % = = 38.3 %
A ⋅ ( pst100 − pst0 ) 700 (1.2 − 3.6 )
Page 1/1
Quote/order no.: Customer:
Project: Date: 03.03.2010 Data entered by:
Diagram overview
p1 p1
p2 p2
LpAe Ma2
Kv W
x Fd
FL
xT
Figure 18.2.1.7.-1: Plant system and installed valve characteristics SAMSON sizing software works
together with SAMSON Project tools to generate Project list, dimension drawings and
ISA or IEC specification sheets.
*This example is also published in DIN IEC 60534 2-1 with other valve factors and
differences in operating data first based for the flow QS = 0.46 m3n/h and viscosity
ν = 13.38 10-6 m2/s at standard conditions 1.013 bar and temperature of 60 °F (15 °C)
The major result difference comes from using ν = 13.38 10-6 m²/s in the calculation. The
viscosity ν as a function of (T1; p1) has a high influence to the calculation of the Reynolds
number.
SAMSON as well as CONVAL sizing software are using high professional and very
accurate property calculating methods for a huge volume of fluids. The result for Argon at
2.8 bar and 320 K (45 °C) of ν = 5.75 10-6 m2/s is the right value to use in the calculation.
See Table 18.3.-1.
A new draft of EN 60534 2-1 Edition 2008 announced to use the actual volume flow
QA to calculate the Reynolds number at operating conditions f(p1;T1). QA in case of a
compressible fluid therefore can be substitute with QA = W/ρ1 as well as Qs∙ρs/ρ1;
Index s = standard conditions at 0 °C or 60 °F, 1.013 bara. The manual calculation here
with Qs = 0.46 m3n/h based on US standard conditions 60 K; 1.013 bar.
Figure 18.3.-3: Property calculation of Argon with SAMSON sizing (above) and using
the CONVAL independent tool (below) to calculate ν versus p1 and T1
18.3.1. Solution
The first step requires a verification of the valve Reynolds number Rev:
Equation (5-26)
0.076 ⋅ Fd ⋅ Q
Re v =
ν ⋅ FL ⋅ Ci
0.076 ⋅ Fd ⋅ W
Rev = ⋅c Equation (5 − 26) modified
ν ⋅ ρ1 ⋅ FL ⋅ Ci
c ≈1
If case of the common use of the kinematic viscosity ν under operating conditions the
volume flow QA is replaced with the mass flow QA =W/ρ1.
The appropriate factor Ci is, according to equation (5-25a) 1.3 times the flow coefficient
Cv. This however represents the ultimate value and is, at first, unknown. Therefore, the
flow coefficient Cv is first computed under the assumption that the flow is turbulent and
second not critical: x < Fy ∙ xT.
x 0.536
Y=
1− 1−
= 1 − 0.19 =
= 0.8 ≥ 0.667
3 ⋅ Fy ⋅ x T 3 ⋅ 1.193 ⋅ 0.75
If Rev < 10000 SAMSON AG modified Y for higher accuracy to their micro flow
measurements:
1
Y= 1− ⋅x = 1 − 0.5 ⋅ 0.54 = 0.854
2
Ci ⋅ FL 0.0182 ⋅ 0.95
Fd =⋅
2.3 2.3
=⋅ ≅ 0.101
D0 3
Rev is far below a value of approx. 10.000 at which a fully turbulent flow is guaranteed.
Therefore, the conventional calculation method according to Table 5.5.1.-1 is no longer
valid. Rather the equation (5-30) must be applied and the flow coefficient must be
calculated. At first however, a repeat calculation of FR according to equation (5-30) is
required. This in turn firstly presupposes the knowledge of the radical index n equation
(5-31) for reduced trim and a transitional flow:
Rev: 10 < 1867.3∙ < 1000 transitional flow Ci/DN2 < 0.016
0.0183 /152 < 0.016 reduced trim (micro flow)
Now Equation (5-31) is valid to calculate the radical index n:
2/3 2/3
C 0.0183
n=
1 + 127 ⋅ 2i =
152 1.24
=
d
Maximum = 1
Therefore, now calculated is a value for FR = 0.778 which is inserted in the following
equation (5-44) with a factor 1590 for STD condition 15 °C for a non turbulent flow :
Finally, an examination must be carried out as to whether the following condition is valid:
C 0.014
<C
=i = 0.018 < 0.0182
FR 0.778
If Cv/FR > Ci the task must be repeated where the value for Ci is raised again by around
30%. The new value of Ci = 0.0182∙1.3 = 0.0237 now must used for the calculation of Fd
and the same iteration process continue until Cvn/FRn < Cn. This however is not the case
in this example.
Therefore selected is a control valve SAMSON AG Type 3510 DN 15 with a Cv100 value of
0.030 and a linear characteristic*. It should be mentioned that the correctly computed flow
coefficient with non-turbulent flow conditions from (5-44) Cv = 0.017 is about 22% higher
than the calculated Cv for turbulent flow 0.0141.
*In general linear valve characteristic should be preferred in case of high viscosity fluids
or/and low Reynold numbers which result to non turbulent flow conditions.
Specially in case of liquids the linear Cv characteristic will tend to an equal percentage
flow characteristic, even in case of constant pressure differential. See Figure 18.3.1.1.-1.
Figure 18.3.1.1.-1: Characteristic calculation shows the impact of non turbulent flow to the installed flow
characteristic (even in case of gases PVC 6711)
Valve data
Body type Globe valve Series 3510
Valve coefficient Cv 0.03 Type 3510
Nominal size DN [mm] 15 Body material WN 1.0619
Pressure ratings PN 16 Noise reduction without
Travel S [mm] 7.5 Charact. Linear
Seat bore SB [mm] 3 Flow direction FTO
Stem diameter Sd [mm] 4 Balanced without (0,0)
Internal parts material 4571 / 316Ti Leakage rate IV
Packing PTFE (1.6) Bonnet standard
Sealing metal (2,0)
Pipe data Type of pipe Steel pipe Pipe insulation none D1 [mm] 15 D2 [mm] 15
cR [m/s] 5100 rho [kg/m³] 7800 di [mm] 17.3 s [mm] 2
Actuator data
Type 3277 Fail-safe act. extends
Diaphr. area A [cm²] 120 Bench range ps0 [bar] 0,4 ... 0,8
Supply psu [bar] 1.00
(Defaults: p1max [bar(a)] 5 p2min [bar(a)] 1 t1max [ K] 350)
Actuator results
req. act. force Fo req. [kN] 0.05 req. diff. psu-ps100 d ps [bar] 0.02
max. act. force Fmax [kN] 12.72 Actuator force Fa [kN] 0.48
max. dp on plug d. pmax [bar] 345.98 Close safety factor Fa/Fo (SF) 9.55
req. start bench range ps0req. [bar] 0.05
Page 3/3
Quote/order no.: Customer:
Project: Date: 04.03.2010 Data entered by:
Diagram overview
p1 p1
p2 p2
LpAe Ma2
Kv W
x Fd
FL
xT
Figure 18.3.1.1.-3: Sizing with SAMSON Specialist SSVS Kv = 0.014 = Cv = 0.0167 and graphics of
different installed characteristic curves
Differential pressure ratio of incipient cavitation noise corrected for inlet pressure calculated
with equations 8-74a and 8-74c.
Example 1 Example 2 Example 3
xFz(p1) = 0.2386 xFz(p1) = 0.2386 xFz(p1) + 0.1 = 0.3324
Table 18.4.-1: Final results for xFz(p1) of example 1 to 3
Pipe
Inlet nominal pipe size: DN 100
Outlet nominal pipe size: DN 100
Internal pipe diameter: Di = 107.1 mm = 0.1071 m
Pipe wall thickness: tp = 3.6 mm = 0.0036 m
Speed of sound in pipe: Cp = 5000 m/s
Density of pipe material: ρp = 7800 kg/m3
Other
Speed of sound in air: C0 = 343 m/s
Density of air: ρ0 = 1.293 kg/m3
Valve inlet
p1 = 10 bar = 1.0 ∙ 106 Pa p1 = 10 bar = 1.0 ∙106 Pa p1 = 10 bar = 1.0 ∙ 106 Pa
absolute pressure
Valve outlet
p2 = 8 bar = 8.0 ∙ 105 Pa p2 = 6.5 bar = 6.5 ∙ 105 Pa p2 = 6.5 bar = 6.5 ∙ 105 Pa
absolute pressure
Vapor pressure of
pv = 2.32 ∙ 103 Pa pv = 2.32 ∙ 103 Pa pv = 2.32 ∙ 103 Pa
liquid
Speed of sound in
cL = 1400 m/s cL = 1400 m/s cL = 1400 m/s
liquid
Table 18.4.-2: Example 1 to 3
Final results
Example 1 Example 2 Example 3
LpAe,1m = 62.7 dBA LpAe,1m = 81.0 dBA LpAe,1m = 66.9 dBA
Table 18.4.-3: Final results for LpAe of example 1 to 3
Figure 18.4.-4: Example 3 shows the influence of the xFz value on prediction accuracy.
Example 3 is identical with example 2, but the xFz value was shifted with 0.1.
This leads a significant prediction error of 66.9- 81 = -14.1 dB.
Valve data
Body type Globe valve Series 3240
Valve coefficient Cv 195 Type 3241
Nominal size DN [mm] 100 Body material WN 1.4404
Pressure ratings PN 40 Noise reduction without
Travel S [mm] 30 Charact. Equal perc.
Seat bore SB [mm] 100 Flow direction FTO
Stem diameter Sd [mm] 16 Balanced without (0.0)
Internal parts material 4404 / 316L Leakage rate IV
Packing PTFE (1.6) Bonnet standard
Sealing metal (2.0)
Pipe data Type of pipe Steel pipe Pipe insulation none D1 [mm] 100 D2 [mm] 100
cR [m/s] 5000 rho [kg/m³] 7800 di [mm] 107.1 s [mm] 3.6
Actuator data
Type 3277 Fail-safe act. extends
Diaphr. area A [cm²] 700 Bench range ps0 [bar] 1,2 ... 3,6
Supply psu [bar] 3.80
(Defaults: p1max [bar(a)] 10 p2min [bar(a)] 1.01 t1max [°C] 20)
Actuator results
req. act. force Fo req. [kN] 7.79 req. diff. psu-ps100 d ps [bar] 0.02
max. act. force Fmax [kN] 66.29 Actuator force Fa [kN] 8.40
max. dp on plug d. pmax [bar] 9.77 Close safety factor Fa/Fo (SF) 1.08
req. start bench range ps0req. [bar] 1.22
Frequency division
Internal sound pressure level Lpi (octave bands)
31.5 Hz [dB] 134 138 138
63 Hz [dB] 137 141 141
125 Hz [dB] 140 145 145
250 Hz [dB] 143 148 148
500 Hz [dB] 145 151 151
1000 Hz [dB] 143 152 152
2000 Hz [dB] 135 151 151
4000 Hz [dB] 126 147 147
8000 Hz [dB] 117 143 143
16000 Hz [dB] 108 138 138
Sound pressure level (1m distance) Lpa (octave bands)
31.5 Hz [dB] 24 28 28
63 Hz [dB] 33 37 37
125 Hz [dB] 42 46 46
250 Hz [dB] 51 55 55
500 Hz [dB] 59 64 64
1000 Hz [dB] 62 72 72
2000 Hz [dB] 60 76 76
4000 Hz [dB] 57 78 78
8000 Hz [dB] 53 78 78
16000 Hz [dB] 45 75 75
In comparison to the original standard IEC 60534 8-4 Second Edition 2005-08 small
deviations occurs by the approximation of Cv = 90, which here are calculated correctly
with small differences to Cv = 90.
The mass flow can be determined using the DIN IEC 534 calculation equations for sizing
flow capacity.
pNV − pST
Venting air x acc = p1acc = pNV
pNV
pST − patm
Exhausting air x acc = p1acc = pST
pST
x acc
Expansion factor Yexp = 1 − xacc ≤ xxcrit.
3 ⋅ x acc
Table 18.5.-1: The mass flow can be determined using the DIN IEC 60534 calculation equations for
sizing flow capacity. Factors used in the equation above
Two differential equations are obtained from these equations which can be solved for
Cvacc = const. and p1 as well as p2 = const. during signal pressure change. If this is not
the case (e.g. due to the pump characteristic), only incremental calculation in small time
increments is possible. The first variant is implemented in the valve sizing program to
estimate opening and closing times.
The true representation (of the positioner, for example) is not possible in this way, i.e.
the times determined are usually smaller because in reality the positioner air capacity is
reduced as the regulator deviation reduces.
Specifying the mathematical equation of the closed solution would go too far at this point.
The following times are the result:
tO1 and tO2 for valve opening
tC1 and tC2 for valve closing
π 2⋅ ∆p Dpipe5
Cvpipe ⋅ 0.862 =⋅ ⋅
4 ρ0 λ ⋅ Lpipe
Equation from Nikuradse1
1
λ= 2
Dpipe
2 ⋅ lg + 174
2⋅k
1
C=
vtotal Cvacc ⋅ 2
C
1 + vacc
Cvpipe
Dead volumes
Actuation surface Dead volume Actuator rated travel
A cm2 V0 nom cm3 Hnom acc mm
80 130 15
240 425 15
350 690 15
700 2665 30
1400 6195 60