Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 22

154

*
..

, ,
, 1.
IIII . . ., , , , ,
.
(, ) ,
(VSI, 481), XIX. 2, , . -

..


, IV . .. , .
( ), , , , , ,
,
, , ,
3 (VS I, 481). ,
.
,
4. , , ,
..; -,
,
; -,
(, ) , 5,

.

, , ,
(CassinB. Leffet sophistique.
P., 1995. P.459).
4
.: Brunt P.A. The Bubble of the Second Sophistic // Bulletin of the Institute
of Classical Studies. Vol.39. 1994. P.31.
5
Whitmarsh T. The Second Sophistic. Cambridge, 2005. .1; 4; 9f. ., , . . : De Oliveira
Silva M. A. A Segunda Sofstica: movimento, fenmeno ou exagero? //
Praesentia. Revista Venezolana de Estudios Clsicos. No. 8 2007. [
]
http://erevistas.saber.ula.ve/index.php/praesentia/article/
view/3735/3591 ( 12.10.2012).
3

* ,
113100218 ( , , , , , ).
1

.. : . / . . .. . ., 1985.
2
. : RohdeE. Die asianische Rhetorik und die
zweite Sophistik // Rheinisches Museum fr Philologie. Bd.41. 1886. S.170190
(= Idem. Kleine Schriften. Bd.2. Tbingen, 1901. S.7597).

155

..

. , 1969 .6,
, ,
, .

, ,
, , , ,

, 7. ,


.
. . ,
,
,
;

8. ,
,
,
, , ..
,
, 9, , , , , ,
10, ,
, , .
,
, .
, ,
. -

156

Bowersock G.W. Greek Sophists in the Roman Empire. Oxford, 1969. . an epoch-making book (Whitmarsh T. Op. cit.
.8).
7

: Approaches to the Second Sophistic
/ Ed. G. W. Bowersock. University Park, PA, 1974; Anderson G. The Second
Sophistic: a Cultural Phenomenon in the Roman Empire. L.N. Y., 1993;
Gleason M. W. Making men: sophists and self-presentation in ancient Rome.
Princeton, 1995; Swain S. Hellenism and Empire: Language, Classicism, and
Power in the Greek World: AD 50250. Oxford, 1996; Schmitz Th. Bildung
und Macht. Zur sozialen und politischen Funktion der zweiten Sophistik in
der griechischen Welt der Kaiserzeit. Mnchen, 1997; Korenjak M. Publikum
und Redner. Ihre Interaktion in der sophistischen Rhetorik der Kaiserzeit.
Mnchen, 2000. ,
. , 5, . ,
: Puech B. Orateurs et sophistes grecs
dans les inscriptions dpoque impriale. P., 2002. . : Anderson G.
Thepepaideumenos in Action: Sophists and their Outlook in the Early Empire
// Aufstieg und Niedergang der rmischen Welt. Tl. II, Bd. 33.1. B.N.Y., 1989.
P. 79208; Sirago V. A. La Seconda Sofistica come espresione culturale della
classe dirigente del II sec. // Aufstieg und Niedergang der rmischen Welt. Tl. II,
Bd.33.1. B.N.Y., 1989. P.3678.

:
Being Greek under Rome. Cultural Identity, the Second Sophistic and the
Development of Empire / Ed. S. Goldhill. Cambridge, 2001; Paideia: The
World of the Second Sophistic / Ed. B.E.Borg. B.N.Y., 2004; Perceptions of
the Second Sophistic and its times / Regards sur la Seconde Sophistique et son
poque / Ed. Th. Schmidt and P. Fleury. TorontoBuffaloLondon, 2011.


.:
Rothe S. Kommentar zu ausgewahlten Sophistenviten des Philostratos. Heidelberg,
1989; Filostrato. Vite dei sofisti: Introduzione, traduzione e note di M. Civiletti.
Milano, 2002.
..
6

157

Whitmarsh T. Op. cit. . 10.


.: Stanton G. R. Sophists and Philosophers: Problems of Classification //
The American Journal of Philology. Vol. 94, No. 4. 1973. P. 350364; Ct D.
Les deux sophistiques de Philostrate // Rhetorica: A Journal of the History
of Rhetoric. Vol. 24, No. 1. 2006. P. 135, .
. . : , ,
(Anderson G. Philostratus. Biography and Belles
Lettres in the Third Century A.D. L., 1986. .17).
10
Reardon B. P. The Second Sophistic // Renaissances Before Renaissance.
Cultural Revivals of Late Antiquity and the Middle Ages / Ed. W. Treadgold.
Stanford, 1984. P.24.
8

..

, .

- ,
, , 11?
12 (
, . , , II. .. , , 13,
).
. , ,
, ,
14. .
. , :
I III . .. , , (Greekness) , ,
15. .
, , ,

16. . 17.
, ,
, 18.
.
, ,
, ,
, ,
19. ,
, ( ), 20.
, 21.
,
, , , , . 22 (
) 23, -

158

, , , , , ,
(VS II, 25, 535).
12
Wilamowitz-Mllendorff U., von. Rez.: Boulanger A. Aelius Aristide. P.,1923
// Litteris. Vol. 2. 1925. S.126 (. : Bowersock G.W. Op. cit. .10, not. 6).
13
14
Brunt P.A. Op. cit. P.2552.
Bowersock G.W. Op. cit.
15
Bowie E.L. The Greeks and their Past in the Second Sophistic // Past & Present.
Vol. 46. 1970. P. 341 ( : Studies in Ancient Society / Ed. M.I.Finley. L., 1974. P.166209); Idem.
The Importance of Sophists // Yale Classical Studies. Vol. 27. 1982. P. 2959;
Swain S. Hellenism and Empire.
11

159

Schmitz Th. Op. cit.


Anderson G. The Second Sophistic: a Cultural Phenomenon in the Roman
Empire.
18
Anderson G. The pepaideumenos in Action; Gleason M. W. Op. cit.;
Korenjak M. Op. cit.; Connolly J. Reclaiming the Theatrical in the Second
Sophistic // Helios. Vol.28. 2001. P.7596; Eshleman K. Defining the Circle of
Sophists: Philostratus and the Construction of the Second Sophistic // Classical
Philology. Vol.103, No.4. 2008. P.395413.
19
Whitmarsh T. Op. cit. . 9; 22. . Whitmarsh T. Greek Literature and
the Roman Empire: The Politics of Imitation. Oxford, 2001.
20
Millar F. A Study of Cassius Dio. Oxford, 1964. P.174.
21
Swain S. The Reliability of Philostratuss Lives of the Sophists // Classical
Antiquity. Vol. 10, No. 1. 1991. .150.
22
(Syll. 3, 878;
879), (s.v. ).
23
, 16
17

..

, , .
.
(Eunap. Vitae philos. et soph. 454;
Synes. Dio. 1; . Philostr. Vita Apol. VI, 27) 165170 . ..
(I), ,
. , 180- .24; 25 , ,
. III.
.
26.
, ( )
27 (VS II, 20, 602; 23, 606; 24, 607), , ,
, , , .
28,
IIIII ., ,
, -

, .
, , ,
( ab epistulis
Graecis ), ,
,
29, , (Vita Apol. I,3).
. ,
(208 .)
(212 .), ,
, , 30. ,
.
, , . ,
( ) (Syll. 3, 879
= I. Eryphrai, I, 63). ( / ), III
(), , IV, 31.
.
,
,
. ( ), (
[Ep., 73] -

160

, : Solmsen F. Philostratos (10) // RE. Hlbd. 39. 1941.


Sp. 125174; Anderson G. Philostratus; Flinterman J.-J. Power, Paideia,
and Pythagoreanism: Greek Identity, Conceptions of the Relationship
between Philosophers and Monarchs and Political Ideas in Philostratus Life
of Apollonius. Amsterdam, 1995; Lannoy L., de. Le problme des Philostrate
(tat de la question) // Aufstieg und Niedergang der rmischen Welt. Tl. II, Bd.
34. 3. B., 1997. P. 23622449; Billault A. LUniverse de Philostrate. Bruxelles,
2000; Philostratus / Ed. E. Bowie and J. Elsner. Cambridge, 2009 (
: BowieE. Philostratus: the life of a sophist. P.1932); Muses de
mots: lhritage de Philostrate dans la littrature occidentale / Ed. S. BallestraPuech, B. Bonhomme and Ph. Marty. Genve, 2010.
24
Lannoy L., de. Op. cit. .2372 ff.
25

(Euseb. c. Heirocl. 2; Suda, s.v. ; Syll.3, 878).
26
Bowersock G.W. Op. cit. .56. , (. VS 479, 238., ,
244249. (Suda, s.v. ).
27
(VS II, 27, 617).
28
( VS I, 25, 530544; II, 1, 545566).

161

.: Bowersock G. W. Op. cit. P. 101109; Levick B. Julia


Domna, Syrian Empress. L.N.Y., 2007. P.107ff.
30
. .479.
31
,
,
( ); (VS II, 30, 623).
()
, ,
.

29

..

, VIV. ,
32). ,
,
, - ().
, , , , 33. ,
() 34. , ,

- .
, ,
, ,

35.
, . , , , 36, ,
(. 346 . 414 .), ( ) , 37
38. ,

.
39, , ,
.
40.
De viris illustribus (, , 41)
, , ()
,
42. . ,
()43.
, - 44,
, 59 (IV . . .) .
Vitae sophistarum
,
.
, , I , , , ,
( IV . ..
, -

162

Penella R. J. Philostratus Letter to Julia Domna // Bd. 107, Hft. 2. Hermes.


1979. P.161168.
33
., : Korver J. Nron et Musonius: propos du dialogue du
pseudo-Lucien Nron ou Sur le percement de listhme de Corinthe //
Mnemosyne. Vol.3. 1950. P.319329.
34
. : Lannoy L., de. Op.
cit.; Elsner J. A Protean corpus // Philostratus / Ed. E. Bowie and J. Elsner.
Cambridge, 2009. P.518.
35
Eshleman K. Op. cit.
36
Cp. Bowersock G.W. Op. cit. P.15; Jones C.P. The Reliability of Philostratus //
Approaches to the Second Sophistic / Ed. G.W. Bowersock. University Park, PA,
1974. P.11; CtD. Op. cit.. P.1920.
37
(VS II, 11, 585) .
38
Eunap. Vitae philos. et soph., 454:
.
32

163

, (Suda, s.v. ).
. ,
(Jones C.P. Op. cit. P.11).
40
, , ,
(VS 480).
41
. ,
(Leo F. Die griechisch-rmische
Biographie nach ihrer literarischen Form. Leipzig, 1901. S.258).
42
Swain S. The Reliability of Philostratuss Lives of the Sophists. P. 151.
43
Rothe S. Op. cit. S.3536.
44
. . :
, , ,
(Jones C.P. Op. cit. P.16).
39

..

II . . .), -
, , 45.

. , ,
.
:
,
.. 350 ,
..,
IVIII . ..,
, , ( [Cic. Brut. 286]). , : , 46,
, , ,
, (VS I, 18, 511).
. 47.
48, ,
,
, 49, ( 50), . ,
, .
, , 33 , II ,
, -


51.
.52,
(magma flow53), , , ,
54.

,
, ,
,
. , , ,
, ,
. ,
. , , , .
, ,
,
, ,
, .
, - , ,
. ,

164

Kemezis A. Narrative of Cultural Geography in Philostratuss Lives of


Sophists // Perceptions of the Second Sophistic and its times / Regards sur la
Seconde Sophistique et son poque / Ed. Th. Schmidt and P. Fleury (Phoenix
supplementary volumes, 49). TorontoBuffaloLondon, 2011. P.11.
52
, . 49 , : Kemezis A. The Roman Past in the Age of
the Severans: Cassius Dio, Philostratus and Herodian. PhD Diss. University of
Michigan, 2006. P.141189, p.161 ff.
53
. (Filostrato. Vite dei sofisti. . 15).
54
. . :
Bowie E.L. The Greeks and their Past in the Second Sophistic // Past & Present.
Vol.46. 1970. P.17.
51

. , () (CassinB. Op. cit. P.452).


46
. , .
.Filostrato. Vite dei sofisti. P.428.
47
Flavii Philostrati Opera / Ed. C.L. Kayser. Vol.II. Lipsiae, 1871. P.IX.
48
Anderson G. Philostratus. P.12.
49
Schubert P. Philostrate et les sophistes dAlexandrie // Mnemosyne. Vol. 48,
Fasc. 2. 1995. P.178188.
50
Swain S. The Reliability of Philostratuss Lives of the Sophists. P. 162, not.74.
45

165

..

, , , , , ,
, . ,
, , , ,
, .
, , , .
, , , , . ,
, 55.
56.
, .

(), , , ,
(), 57.
,

58. Vitae sophistarum, II III., , ,
. ,
, , , ,

(VS I, 22, 524; 525).


,
(VS II,
9, 583; 23, 605606). , , -,
150- ., , 80 . (VS II, 27, 618619). , ,
, - -
(VS II, 9, 585; 10, 586).

. , , , (VS I, 8, 490; 25, 543; II, 1, 562563).
, , , , , ,
, , (),
, , ,
(), 60 ,
(VS II, 9, 585). , ,
, , , , ,
,
.
, , .
. , (VS II, 1, 557), , . ,
, (VS II, 9, 581),
. ,
(VS II, 1, 545; cp. I, 25, 536).
. ,
, ,
,
, , , ,
,
59.

166

Cp. Swain S. Hellenism and Empire. P.380.



, (VS I, 16).
57
Anderson G. Philostratus. P.14.
58
. Swain S. The Reliability of Philostratuss Lives of
the Sophists.
55

56

167

Swain S. The Reliability of Philostratuss Lives of the Sophists. .159 ff.; 163.

59

168

, ,
, ,

,
, ,
. ,
.. ,
11 ( ), ,

. ,
, , ,
, ,
,
.


..

169


(I, 118)60
..

[479]


61.
60

. .: . () / . . //
/ . . . .-; . .. .,
1961. . 503509; II. () / .
.. // - / . . ... ., 1964. . 168177.

: Flavii Philostrati Vitae
sophistarum / Rec. C. L. Kayser. Heidelbergae: Sumptibus J. C. B. Mohr,
Bibliopolae Academici, 1838 ( 18421846 1853 ., :
Flavii Philostrati Opera. Vol. II. Lipsiae: Teubner, 1871, . ) Philostratus and Eunapius. The Lives of the
Sophists / With an English translation by Wilmer Cave Wright. London:
William Heinemann; New York: G. P. Putnams Sons, 1921 (The Loeb Classical
Library). (Gottfried Olearius) (Lipsiae, 1709), . : Philostratorum et Callistrati
Opera / Rec. Antonius Westermann; Eunapii Vitae sophistarum / Iterum ed.
Jo.Fr.Boissonade; Himerii Sophistae. Declamationes / Emendavit Fr. Dbner.
Paris: Didot, 1849, .
61
. (Avotins I. The Date and the Recipient of
the Vitae Sophistarum of Philostratus // Hermes. Bd. 106, Hft. 1. 1978.
P. 242247), (. 160238 .) 60

170

..

, , , , ,
, , , ,
62, , - [480]
, - [] 63.
, , , ,
. , 64 ,
,
, 65. , ,
c , - ,
,
237238 . . . I
( 238 . ..)
. . . II, I (Barnes T. D. Philostratus and Gordian // Latomus.
Vol. 27. 1968. P. 581597). , I
III (225244 . . ., 238244 . . .) , , 242/243. .. .: Jones P. Philostratus and
the Gordiani //Mediterraneo Antico: economie, societ, culture. 2002. Anno5.
P. 759767; Bowie E. Philostratus: the life of a sophist // Philostratus / Ed.
E. Bowie and J. Elsner. Cambridge, 2009. P. 29.
- .
62
.
(101177), , 143 . . .,
. . VS II,1 (545568); Suda, s.v. ).
,
. ,
. , (IG IIIII2, 3979). . Barnes T.D. Op. cit. P.587.
63
.: Iulian. Misopogon.
346; Vita Apol. I,16.
64
, (460403), , , ,
, , . 404403 . . .,
. . : . ,
, // . 2003. 4. . 6789 (=
. . ., 2004.
.227259).
65
, , .

171

, , , , . () , , , 66.
, !

[481]


(... ).
, , ,
, , ,
. , ,
. ,
67. [] ,
, ,
; []
. (2) , :
68,

69

,

Hom. Od., IV, 220; cp. VA VII, 22; Iulian.


Or. VIII, 240c. V. .. , () (Elog. Hel., 14).
67
.: Meno 70; Symp., 208c;
Thaetet. 180a.
68
Hdt. I, 47 (. .. ); Vita Apol. VI,11.
69
.. , .
66

172

, 70,

, -.
(3) , , , 71, , ,
, , [] .
, ( ), 72,
,
, [] , . [] 73,
, 74, ,
, ;
,
.
(4) , , - [482]
, 75,
Suet. Nero 39; Vita Apol. IV, 38.
.
71
Plato. Sophist. 217c.
72
. : Ct D.
Les deux sophistiques de Philostrate // Rhetorica: A Journal of the History of
Rhetoric. Vol. 24, No. 1. 2006. P. 135.
73
Plato. Menin. 70 b. () (485380),
, ( ). 427 . . . , . . , I, 9.
74
(389 . 314), ,
, ,
.
75
(. 495429), , ; 461 . . .
; 443. .. 15 , , ,
. .

.
70

..

173

[] ;
, ,
, ,
76, ; , ,
, 77,
. ,
, , , ,
[ ],
, - .
, , : ! , , ,
, .
. (5) 78 ,

, , -;
, , ,
79.
[483] ,
, 80 81, , . (6) ,

.
.: Demosth. De cor. 136; cp.: Vita Apol. VII, 37.
.
77
, 377353 . .., ; , .
78
. , .
79
, , , . . : Xen. Memorab. II,1,22.
80
.: Plato. Protagor. 315a, .
81
,
, ; .
76

174

, .
. , 82, -
, , ,
. ,
, [ :]
, ?83. , , : ; - , , , 84.
(7) , , ,
,
. 85 ,
, , ; [ ]. , 86, ,
; , -, [484]
87 [ ],
, .
, , ,
[ ] . ,

- .
; . Eupolis. Kolakes, fr. 165 Kock; Schol. ad Vesp. 1408 ad Nub.
496; Ath. IV, 164. .
83
(IX,74b); ,
-,
. .
84

, , , , ,
, ,
;
Vita Apol. VIII,3.
85
., : Aeschin. Contra Timarch. 170; Demosth. De cor. 276.
86
Aeschin. Contra Timarch. 170.
87
.
82

..

175

,
.
1. 88,
,
; , , , , ,
, , 89.
2. 90 [485]
, , , ,
. , 91
, :
- , , [ ] ? :

, : , ,
, ,
92. : ,
. (2) , .
,
, . ,
, : , ? , ?
, , [ ], ,
,
. , -

(. 390 . 340), ,
, .
89
( ) (VI,5).
90
, ,
II
339 . . . ,
.
91
92
II (382336).
. Vita Apol. VII, 42.
88

176

, 93.
3. 94 95
, . , ,
, , - [486]
, ,
, .
4. 96,
, ,
.
5. , 97, ,
,
, ,
. -
:
, ,
, 98.
FHG, II, 329. (IV,37)
, . (XII, 74 f) , , .
94
(Adv. Col. 32, 1126 d) -,
, .
95
. (Vita
Apol. VI, 12).
96
(214129) , ()
, , , , . 155 . . ., ,
.
97
. ., , (Plut. Ant. 80, 2: , ,
; . ..).
98
(215),
, ,
. : Ath. VII, 102 ab; Iulian. Misopogon.
349d. , ,
, ,

(Anthol. Pal. VII, 645).
93

..

177

6. 99, ,
.
7. 100, , , ;
[487] , , , 101,
[ ] [],
. , , [ ]
,
. . , , ,
,
, ; , , , , ,
[ ]. (2)
, , , , , , . ,
, 102 (
, ).
(Plut. Cato Min. 57).
, -, , (Brut. 24).
100
() (. 40
112), - .
, , ,
, . , . , , ,
. , .
78 , ,
-, ,
.
101
.. (cornucopia), , ,
, .
102
. ,
.

99

178

103, , , ,
,
.
(3) ,
104; , [488]
, 105.
, , ,
, ,
106,
107, , , . , , ,

, ,
. (4)
108, , , 109,
. .
. .: / . .. - //
/ . . . ., 1961. . 6386.
104
(. I. .. . [9698]), , , ;
.
8- ,
( ) ,
,
, , .
( ), , ,
, ;
119. .., . , (Ep. I,10).
105
.: Vita Apol. V, 33; 37. , .
106
107
.. .
. Vita Apol. VII, 4.
108

(Or. XII, 1720).
109
.: Suet. Dom. 23.
103

..

179

, ,
,
:
110.

, , ,
, , ,
. ,
, , -. ,
, ,

, , : , , , 111.
, ,
,
,
.
8. ,
[489] .
, 112, 113.
, , 114, :
;
Hom. Od. XXII, 1.
. .: Fein S. Die Beziehungen der Kaiser Trajan und Hadrian zu den
literati. Stuttgart, 1994. S.2022; Schmitz Th. Trajan und Dion von Prusa. Zu
Philostrat, Vit. Soph. 1, 7 (488) // Rheinisches Museum fr Philologie. Neue
Folge. Bd.139, Hft.3/4. 1996. S.315319. . (Bowie E.L. The
importance of sophists // Yale Classical Studies. Vol.27. Later Greek Literature.
Cambridge, 1982. P. 44, not. 49), ,
(v. 1169). -,
(LXVIII,3, 4) ,
; . : Dio Cass. LXVIII,7, 4 Plin. Pan. 47,1.
112
. . . Gell. NA. II,22.
113
Cobet; Kayser .
114
. Lucian. Demon. 12, 13; Eunuch. 7. , , testiculi
(Polemon. Physiogn. I, 163 F./H.). , , . ( ).
110
111

180

, , .
, - 115. - ,
116, . -
, , : , ; , , , . (2)
, , ,
, . ,
117, , , . ,
,
.
(3) , , , , -, , [490]
, 118, . , ,
, . , , , ,
. ,
, 119. , , 120.
. Dio Chrys. Or. XXXVII, 33 sq. (3235) .
116
Cp. SHA. Hadr. 15; Dio Cass. LXIX, 3, 44.1. .
Swain S. Favorinus and Hadrian // Zeitschrift fr Papyrologie und Epigraphik.
Bd.79. 1989. P.150158. 1920- .
(P. Marm.) ( ),
, , (. Norsa M.,
VitelliG. Il papiro Vaticano greco 11 // Studi e Testi. Vol.53. 1931. P.IXX).
117
Hom. Il. I, 80. , .
118
.
119
(De cor. 205) , ,
(Crito 50).
120
.
(LXIX,3,56).
115

..

[491]

181

, ,
, ,
[] 121. , , , ,
,
. ,
, , ,
, : , , ,

, .
(4) , :
[] 122? , ,
, ,
, 123. , , ,
, ,
.
(5) 124 , ,
, , , , ,
,
. , , , , ,
125, , , ,

(Dig. 27,1,6,8; 50,4,18,30).
122
(fr. 231 Kock), (Or. LII, 17).
123
, , ,
. ,
-. . Lucian. Lexiphan. 2,9; ,
.
(III,11) .
124
(. 88144) ,
, .
, . ,
. . : VS I,25, 530545; Suda, s.v. .
125
. Thuc. II,44.
121

182

, , . , , ,
, , , 126.
(6) ,
, . , . 127,
, ,
, - ,
, 128;
,
,
,
, 129, , , .
(7) ,
, , -, , , , [492]
. ,
130, ,
. , ,
, , .
, , , . , ,
.
9. , , , , , . ,
, ,
, , ,
127
Hesiod. Op. 25.
.
. VS II, 9, 583.
129
. Cp. Gell. NA.
XI,5,5; Diog. Laert. IX, 87. (. 360270), .
130
. . 513.
(Or. XXXII, 68) , ,
, ; .: Cic. Orat. 18.
126
128

..

[493]

183

, , ,
, , .
, , , ,
;
131. (2), ,
132; , , , ,
, , ,
, 133,
, ,
134. ,
135, 136, .
, [137], .
,
[], , , , -

., :
Porter J. I. The Seductions of Gorgias // Classical Antiquity. Vol. 12, No. 2.
1993. P.267299; Nol M.-P. Gorgias et linvention des Gorgiveia schvmata //
Revue des tudes Grecques. Vol.112. 1999. P.193211.
132
. : I, praef., 482.
133
(. 450 . 404), , , .
134
: , (. 495429) .
(460396) 33 .
135
(. 447 . 405) ,
, , 411. .. .
136
.: Aristophan. Thesmophor. 49. (Symp. 195 sqq.) .
137
,
.
131

184

138. (3) ,
,
,
.
, , , , ,
, , , [494]
, , , , , ,
.
, , ,
, .
10. 139, ,
140, 141. , ; 142,
. , , ,
. ,

Cp. Isocr. Paneg. 42.


.
(.480410), , . 444 . . .
, .
, , , , (DK, 80 [74] B1; . .. ), .
140
(. 460371), -, ( ),
, . , , , , ,
(Diog. Laert. IX, 42).
141
. (IX, 34) , .
142
. Val. Max. VIII,7.
138

139

..

185

, , 143, , , ,
,
, , ,
. (2)
, ,
, ,
. , , 144, , ,
.

, , , ,
, , . , , , , [495] ,
145,
146.
11. 147 , , ,
, .
, , , , .
,
, [] ,
.
, : [ ] , , , . (2)
, - ,
, ,
, .
, .
144
, 60, . Plut. Pericl. 11.
145
. Plato. Protag. 319a; Gorg. 520 c.
146
.
147
(. . 410 . . .)
, , . ,
.
143

186

, ,
148 , . ,
, 149.
- [496]
.
, ,
.
12. 150 , 151, 152, , .
, , 153. 154,
, .. . ,
[ 155],
156. ,
,
?
13. 157 [ [497]
] , , ,
. , 158,
. . .
(282) ,
20 ;
, ,
.
150
, .
151
(. 430 355), ,
.
152
,
412. .., ; . Thuc., VIII,60.
153
, , Plat. Protag. 316.
154
155
Plat. Sophist. 231d.
I, praef., p. 482483.
156
. Xen. Memorab. II, 1, 21.
157
, (Plato. Gorg. 448c).
158
( ),
, ( ). , 148
149

..

187

, , ,

. -
, , : , ,
159.
14. , 160 , , ,
161, :

, , .
15. 162 [498]
, .
. , ,
; .
, .
, , .
, ,
, , ,
,
(. ).
159
Plato. Gorg. 467b. , , . . Plato. Symp. 185.
160
. 430400 . .. , .
, .
161
Plat. Resp. 341 c.
162
. .. : 1) // Studia
historica. . 6. ., 2006. . 4068; 2) Antiphontea II: -
- - ? // . . 7. .,
2007. . 2843; 3) Antiphontea III: ( ) // . . 8. ., 2008. . 6795; 4) Antiphontea IV:
( ) // . . 9. ., 2009. . 127; 5) Antiphontea V: // . . 10. ., 2010. . 2565;
Antiphontea VI:
(GagarinM. Antiphon the Athenian: Oratory, Law, and Justice in
the Age of the Sophists. Austin, University of Texas Press, 2002. XI, 222 p.) //
. . XI. M., 2011. . 258276.

188


163.
(2) , ,
, , ,
; , , , .
, [ ], , , 164, . ,
[ ],
, 165, ,
,
166. [499]

, , ,
. ,
. (3) , , , , , ;

, , ,
;
, , . ,
:
, ,
, 411.
. .,
,
. . , , (VIII,68).
164
.
165
;
( ; . .. )
Hom. Od. IV,221.
166
(vv. 13):

..

189

[ ] .
, , ,
, , ,
,
. (4)
167, , .
168, , . ,
[500] , , ,
: , ,
169.
, , 170. , ,
, ; - , , . (5) ,
,
, , : ,
, ,
, , , ,
. , , , -

163

,
, , ,
,

?
(.
. )

(. 430367), 405 . .., .


168
367 . . . , , ,
,
.
169
, 514. .. .
,
. V. .. , .
170

(Mor. 68 ab).
167

190

,
, . ,
[] .
(6) , [ ] ,
,
[] , [] , , [
] .
16. , - [501]
,
, , , , ,
, 171,
172, ,
,
, , , ; [173]; ,
,
, , .
(2) ,
, , , 174 , .
. . Thuc. III, 58.
. , 461. .. . 404. ..,
, . , ,
. .
173
. . 4.
174
. Plato. Crit. 53, ,
: .
171

172

..

[502]

191

,
,
, , . ,
, ,

,

. (3)
, ,
[ ];
,
- .
, ,
,
, , , ,
, .
(4) 175, 176, , , ,
177. , , . , ,
;

(. 388), , , , . 411. ..
. , ,
404. .. . ,

. .
176
Bentley Cobet; Kayser
; :
.
177
.. .
, (Archid.45: ), . VS II, 10, 590 Gymn. 34.
175

192

, ,
, , 178.
(5) ,
, , , , , [503]
. ,
, , ,
[ ]; 179 ,
, .
180,
, ,
, ,
.
17. , 181, , ,
, ;
, 182, ,
183, , ,
(Contra Ctes. 623); cp.: 1 . 13:1 (... ).
179
. (Lexiph. 24) , .
180
, (
, ), .
181
(436338), , , , , ;
390 . . . , . 21 (). : . .
. / . .., .., .., .., . . , . . , . . , . . ,
.., .., .. //. 1965. 31969. 2.
182
, , ().
183
(. ) , 178

..

193

; - . 184, [504] ,
. , . (2) :
, ,
; ,
, , , 185. : , ,
, ,
186.
(3)
, - , - [505]
187,
, - 188.
189
, , , , ;
, , . (4) , ,
, ,
. ,
( , . .) , .
184
(. 420 . 350), ,
. 11
.
185
Demosth. XVIII, 97 ( ; . .. ).
; .: Lucian. Encom. Demosth. 5; Hermog.
Peri ideon. 222 Walz.
186
Paneg. 179. . . .
187
. : , , ,
(Phil. 82; . ..).
188
. Thuc. III, 38 ( , ).
189
II, .

194

190. [] 191
, ,
, 192, .
,
.
(5) , 193; 194 , . , [506]
, 195, , , ,
,
,
, , - . ,
,
196,
.
, , ,
.
191
371. .. , .
192
.
193
(390322), , , , ,
. 10
. 52
, . : . / . .. // . 1962. 1.
194
,
. (377 320), ,
12, 410394 . .., 58 , II .
.
,
340. ..
195
. fr. 712 Kock, ; .
Ps.-Plut. Isocr. 836e.
196
338. .. II
190

..

195

18. , 197, 198, [507] .


:
[] , . ,
,
, , ,
;
,
,
,
, .

, , , , , - , ,
.
. (2) , , ,
199. , , [508] , ,
, , , ,
- .
, 200, 201
, - , -

. .
197
.
198
.: Ct D. La
figure dEschine dans les Vies des sophistes de Philostrate // Cahiers des tudes
anciennes. Vol.42. 2005. P.389420.
199
. Demosth. De corona 262. (), .. .
200

(.34).
201
, .

196

202,
. , , . (3)
203,
, 204
205. 206
,
, 207. - [509]
, , ,
, ,
, . ,
- . ,
, , 208
,
, ; , , ,
.
354 . .. , ,
. . Aeschin. De legat. 169.
203
(. 142) ,
346. .. . ,
.
204
.
205

.
206
. . , , - (- ,
,
).
. 346. .. . Demosth. De corona 149.
207
. Demosth. De corona. 143.
, .
208
,
330. .. 323. .. .
202

..

[510]

197

(4) , ,
,
[].
,
, , , 209.
210 , .
, , , ,
.
(5) 211 , , ,
, ,
.
, 212, [ ], , ,
,
,
,
. (6) ,
, : ,
. 213,
, . . -
,
, , , :
, , . , .
, (De subl. 13,2).
.
211
3 . : . / .
. . , . . , .. // . 1962. 34;
. / . .; / . . , . // . ., 1985.
.127210.
212
(. 119 .),
, 340. ..
213
.
209
210